A History of the Church of England in the Diocese of Brisbane, 1950 - 1970
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE PAST IS A FOREIGN COUNTRY: A History of the Church of England in the Diocese of Brisbane, 1950 - 1970. A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy, at the University of Queensland in December 2006 JONATHAN CHARLES HOLLAND School of History, Philosophy, Religion and Classics University of Queensland Statement of Originality I declare that this thesis is my own work and has not been submitted in any form for another degree or diploma at any university or other institute of tertiary education. Information derived from published or unpublished work of others has been acknowledged in the text and a list of references are given. I also declare that I am familiar with the rules of the School and the University relating to the submission of this thesis. Jonathan Holland date ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I am very grateful to all who have assisted me in this thesis. Many people – including those I have interviewed and those who have seen some of the fruits of my research over the last few years – have shown a graciousness to me and an interest in my work that has been very encouraging. I have much appreciated the insights, encouragement and time of my supervisors, Associate Professors Clive Moore and Marion Diamond. Their direction has been invaluable and they have persisted with me over several years to see this thesis to its completion. I have also received much support from the Anglican Diocese of Brisbane, in particular a free hand to access material in the Diocesan archives. The archivists, Ms Glenda Morrell and more recently, Ms Desley Soden, have both been tremendously supportive and helpful. They allowed me space to read archival material and attempted to answer my many questions and meet my many requests. Ms Elsie Manley gave me access to the diaries of Bishop Philip Strong, which are in her possession. I stayed with Elsie for a week reading the diaries and making notes. It was both generous and gracious of her. Reading the diaries and handling some of the mementoes of Strong’s life – his prayer book with a bullet hole through its middle – were moving experiences and have left me a feeling of privilege and gratitude. Finally, my wife Kerry and children have watched this thesis unfold and have made sacrifices in family life to accommodate it. I am as usual grateful and privileged to have such an understanding and patient family. iii ABSTRACT THE PAST IS A FOREIGN COUNTRY: A History of the Church of England in the Diocese of Brisbane, 1950 - 1970. This thesis charts the history of the Church of England in the Diocese of Brisbane from 1950 to 1970. The history of the Diocese from its beginnings in the mid-nineteenth century could be read as the attempt to address the challenge of three abiding issues: a lack of ordained clergy, of financial resources and of active members. But suddenly, for about a decade from the early 1950s, these shortfalls were transcended. Churches recorded growing participation and parents sent their children to Sunday Schools in record numbers. More young men than ever before attended the theological college – St Francis’ College at Milton – and a money raising scheme, called the Wells Way, allowed parishes to tap post-World War II prosperity. Perhaps for the first time in Diocesan history, parishes could plan for the future with some confidence that the financial and human resources were in place for those plans to come to fruition. The first part of this thesis attempts to explain why this decade of growth occurred. Several answers are given. The Diocese established parishes in the emerging suburbs, which provided social activities for families, and especially for that new class of young people called ‘teenagers’. The churches were also seen as upholders of moral standards and one of the bulwarks against atheistic communism. Finally, the Diocese of Brisbane was seen to carry something of the ethos of the Church of England in England at a time of pride in the British heritage, which burst out when the newly crowned Queen Elizabeth II toured Australia in 1954 to tumultuous acclaim. The second part of this thesis charts the numerical decline which set in from the early 1960s. Coincidentally, this decline began when a new archbishop – Philip Strong – was installed in March 1963 as Archbishop of Brisbane. Strong came to Brisbane with a powerful reputation as a iv longstanding, missionary bishop in Papua New Guinea, whose steadfastness in World War II, during the Japanese invasion, evoked much respect and pride. After examining a number of theories for why numerical decline should suddenly set in, this thesis argues that rapid change – social, cultural, economic and technological – is the principal reason for the decline. Sundays were no longer sacrosanct to the churches alone. A more liberal spirit to moral issues challenged the traditional Christian moral code. Immigration patterns changed. New media, especially television, had a profound effect on the churches, more so than has perhaps been realised. Attitudes to authority figures and authoritative institutions changed in the wake of the Vietnam War, and the inchoate feminist movement challenged traditional church teachings on the role of women in religious institutions. The speed and scale of change wrong-footed the Diocese (and other churches), and it was unable to read or satisfactorily address social changes. What changes should the church accommodate? What ones should the church resist? The answer to these questions introduced a new divide in the Diocese (as elsewhere) between conservatives and liberals. The capacity of the Diocese to respond to social change was further inhibited by other factors. There was a loss of confidence in traditional teachings, especially after the publication of John Robinson’s book, Honest to God, in 1963. As well, Diocesan leadership tensions meant that time and energy was directed internally. The Diocese had a powerful registrar, Roland St John and he and other outspoken leaders did not always see eye to eye with the archbishop. Strong, who had spent the previous 26 years in Papua New Guinea, exercising unchallenged authority, found it hard to adjust to these more robust and challenging voices, some of whom were much more liberal than his own conservatism allowed. Finally, Anglo-Catholicism – the Diocesan theological engine room, which had created the passion and direction for Diocesan ministry over so many years – was seriously wounded by social and cultural change and gradually lost its force to inspire and motivate. v The thesis finishes by drawing some conclusions from this history and outlining the legacy of these years. A Note on Terminology The terms ‘Roman Catholic; and ‘Catholic’ are used throughout the thesis to refer to that Christian Church which is under the jurisdiction of the Bishop of Rome. The term ‘Anglo-Catholic’ refers throughout this thesis to a branch within the Church of England. vi TABLE OF CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS............................................................................... iii ABSTRACT..................................................................................................... iv Introduction..................................................................................................... 1 Chapter One The Fifties...................................................................... 25 1.1 Australia in the Fifties....................................................................... 27 1.2 Queensland: Brisbane ..................................................................... 37 1.3 Queensland: Rural Areas................................................................. 44 1.4 The Church of England in the Diocese of Brisbane ......................... 50 1.5 Optimism and Growth ...................................................................... 61 Chapter Two: 1954................................................................................ 65 2.1 A Mood of Pride ............................................................................... 68 2.2 A Mood of Fear ................................................................................ 83 2.3 A Mood of Expectancy ..................................................................... 95 2.4 The Building Boom......................................................................... 106 2.5 Conclusion ..................................................................................... 113 Chapter Three 1956.............................................................................. 115 3.1 Protector of Youth .......................................................................... 117 3.2 Protector of Family Life .................................................................. 128 3.3 Parishes: filling a social void .......................................................... 137 3.4 Bush Ministry: hostels and camps ................................................. 146 3.5 Conclusion ..................................................................................... 153 Chapter Four 1959.............................................................................. 154 4.1 Anglicans in Society....................................................................... 159 4.2 Ministry to All.................................................................................. 163 4.3 Sectarianism and Mass Rallies...................................................... 172 4.4 Social Influence.............................................................................. 181 Chapter Five 1962.............................................................................