BABY BOLLINGER (1915–1915) of “Defective” Babies in American Medicine and Motion American Victim of Infanticide Pictures Since 1915
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
B-Albrecht-4690.qxd 4/28/2005 7:37 PM Page 155 B ᨘ Pernick, Martin S. 1996. The Black Stork: Eugenics and the Death BABY BOLLINGER (1915–1915) of “Defective” Babies in American Medicine and Motion American victim of infanticide Pictures since 1915. New York: Oxford University Press. “Baby Bollinger” (first name: Allen) was born to ᨘ Anna and Allen Bollinger at the German-American BANK-MIKKELSEN, Hospital in Chicago, Illinois. The seven-pound Baby NEILS ERIK (1919–1990) Bollinger was diagnosed with multiple physical Danish reformer anomalies and became the first victim in a string of public infanticides of disabled babies committed by Neils Erik Bank-Mikkelsen, an early champion of the head of staff at the hospital, Dr. Harry Haiselden. normalization, was born in Denmark in 1919 and The doctor declared Baby Bollinger a “monster,” a received a degree in law in 1944 from the University “pitiful bundle of semi-life.” Anna Bollinger was of Copenhagen. During World War II, he joined the encouraged to allow her baby to die by withholding Danish resistance movement, was captured, and life-saving surgery. “I want my baby. But the doctor interned in a Nazi concentration camp. He developed has told me...I want him to live—but I couldn’t bear the concept of normalization in response to his per- to think of how he would suffer...how he would ception that institutionalized people with disabilities so often curse the day he was born. So I agreed with were treated only slightly better than concentration the doctor.” On the day of Baby Bollinger’s death, a camp inmates. Following the war, he entered the Chicago newspaper printed the following description Danish Ministry of Social Affairs. In 1950, he moved of him: “A pink bit of humanity lay upon the white to the Danish Service for the Mentally Retarded, cloth. Its blue eyes were wide open. Its hair was becoming departmental head in 1959. brown and silky, it dug at its face with little fists. It He introduced the concept of normalization in a cried lustily as it drew up chubby legs and kicked out. piece of Danish legislation called the 1959 Mental It seemed quite vigorously informed with life.” Retardation Act. He described normalization as a means to ensure people with this diagnosis the right —Sharon Lamp to the same community-based existence as their peers See also Eugenics; Infanticide. without disabilities, including clothing, housing, educa- tion, work, and leisure. Normalization was seen as a Further Readings way to ensure that this population received the same Chicago Daily News, November 17, 1915. legal and human rights given to other citizens. In 1968, Chicago Tribune, November 17, 1915. Bank-Mikkelsen received the Kennedy Foundation 155 B-Albrecht-4690.qxd 4/28/2005 7:37 PM Page 156 156———Barbellion, W. N. P. (1889–1919) Award in recognition of his work. In 1971, he became Further Readings the Director of the Department of Care and Rehabili- Barbellion, W. N. P. 1984. Pp. 282–283 in The Journal of a tation of the Handicapped, Danish National Board Disappointed Man, & A Last Diary. London: Hogarth. of Social Welfare, and was instrumental to the 1980 formation of Denmark’s Central Committee on the Handicapped. ᨘ BARKER, ROGER GARLOCK —Pamela Block (1903–1990) American scholar and author See also Bengt Nirje; Normalization. Further Readings Just after World War II, Roger Barker, while on the faculty in psychology at Stanford University, Flynn, R. and K. Nitsch, eds. 1980. Normalization, Social was asked by the Social Science Research Council Integration and Community Services. Baltimore: University Park Press. to conduct a comprehensive review of the psycho- logical literature on physical disability to help meet the needs of returning war veterans with injuries. ᨘ BARBELLION, W. N. P. Not content with an annotated bibliography of the literature, Barker, in collaboration with Beatrice A. (1889–1919) Wright, Lee Meyerson, and Mollie Gonick, pub- English naturalist and author lished an extensive theoretical and research mono- graph dealing with the social psychology of physique, The fledgling scientist and writer W. N. P. Barbellion, disability, and illness. The monograph was revised born Bruce Frederick Cummings, kept a journal from in 1953. the age of 13 almost to his death. Earlier parts show In this work, Barker applied Kurt Lewin’s field the lad’s abilities as a naturalist, a largely self-taught theoretical concepts of new and overlapping psycho- thinker, and voracious reader. When he learned in 1915 logical situations to problems of physique, physical that the ailments long plaguing him arose from “dis- disability, and illness. He coined the term somato- seminated sclerosis” (multiple sclerosis), the journal psychological relation to refer to the question of how recorded a race against time to achieve some large variations in physique affect the psychological situa- ambitions before his body collapsed. He was by then tion of a person by influencing the effectiveness of married, had had scientific papers published, and held the person’s body as a tool for actions or by serving a minor post at the British Museum of Natural History. as a stimulus to the person or others. This pioneering Barbellion (1984) continued “tinkering about in the monograph helped to establish the psychology of Museum,” though he found it “excoriating to be thus physical disability and rehabilitation as a research wasting the last few precious days of my life in such and professional discipline and to the launching of the mummery merely to get bread to eat” (pp. 282–283), division on Rehabilitation Psychology of the American against a background of the Great War across Europe. Psychological Association. A bowdlerized edition of his journal, published in 1919, impressed most of the critics with its freshness —Phil Schoggen and lively acumen. Barbellion died knowing that he had See also Kurt Lewin; Psychology. made his mark in the world of human self-knowledge. Ironically, despite republication in the late twentieth Further Readings century, his work remains practically unknown and unused by the disability movement. Barker, Roger G., Beatrice A. Wright, Lee Meyerson, and Mollie R. Gonick, 1953. Adjustment to Physical Handicap —Kumur B. Selim and Illness: A Survey of the Social Psychology of Physique and Disability. New York: Social Science Research [QU: about in the Museum” “tinkering THE QUOTES THE SOURCE FOR IS AND “excoriating to be thus wast- ing . .” IT, 282-283?] AS I HAVE (1984) PP. CORRECT BARBELLION See also Autobiography; Multiple Sclerosis. Council. B-Albrecht-4690.qxd 4/28/2005 7:45 PM Page 157 Beers, Clifford Whittingham (1876–1943)———157 ᨘ BASHSHAR IBN BURD effect. He was also influential in the growth of anesthe- siology as an independent medical specialty. Born in (714/715–783/784) Kansas in 1904, Beecher earned his medical degree Arab poet and critic from Harvard Medical School in 1932. After early The renowned blind poet Bashshar ibn Burd spent surgical training, Beecher was appointed Chief of much of his life at Baghdad. He was probably born Anesthesia at the Massachusetts General Hospital, blind, though some writers argue that he lost his sight despite having no formal education in anesthesia. later. Efforts have been made to elucidate the ques- In 1941, Beecher was named the Dorr Professor of tion from his verses. Of the poetry of Al-A’sha and Research in Anaesthesia at Harvard University, the first Bashshar, the celebrated critic Al-Jahiz wrote that endowed chair of anesthesia in the world. Beecher’s these two blind men succeeded in catching truths that career was interrupted by service in World War II, when sighted people failed to discern, and Bashshar in par- he observed pain responses of battle-wounded soldiers ticular excelled in doing so. Bashshar’s self-reflexive to be quantitatively different from those of surgical wit gave rise to anecdotes, as when he broke wind in patients. Later, Beecher compared morphine and company and dismissed it as “merely a noise. Don’t placebo to investigate psychological context in the phys- believe anything unless you see it!” Sometimes the iology of pain control. This work has led to Beecher’s joke turned against Bashshar. He publicly teased appellation, “father of the prospective, double-blind, another savant, Said the Philologer, for academic placebo-controlled clinical trial.” fraud, by asking him the meaning of the word jaranful Beecher will be remembered most for his stance among the Bedouin. Said, who had himself invented on human experimentation. He argued for informed con- this bogus word, was briefly silent, then came back, sent by research subjects, and he condemned research “The jaranful is one who has commerce with blind that did not demonstrate potential benefit to patients men’s wives,” causing hilarity among those present. as ethically unjustifiable. His landmark 1966 article in the New England Journal of Medicine chronicled —Kumur B. Selim 22 published studies with ethical infractions and conse- quently stimulated U.S. researchers to obtain informed See also Abu 'l-`Ala al-Ma`arri; Abu 'l Aswad ad-Duwali; `Ata ibn consent prior to experiments. Abi Rabah; Jahiz, Al- (Abu Othman Amr bin Bahr); Khalil, Al-; Middle East and the Rise of Islam. In 1970, Beecher retired and received the Distin- guished Service Award from the American Society of Further Readings Anesthesiologists. Beecher died in 1976. Blachère, R. 1960. “Bashshar b. Burd.” Encyclopaedia of Islam,new —Hugh M. Smith edition, Vol. 1, pp. 1080–1082. Leiden, the Netherlands: Brill. See also Consent to Treatment; Ethics; Pain. Ibn Khallikan’s Biographical Dictionary. 1842–1871. Translated by Mac Guckin de Slane, Vol. 1, pp. 254–257, 633. Paris. Further Readings Roman, A. 1970–1971. “A propos des vers des yeux et du regard dans l’oeuvre du poète aveugle Bashshar b.