No. TC/G-148/ e, 6 20/ C) (071) 9310133 OFFICE OF THE [email protected] EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PUBLIC HEALTH ENGINEERING DIVISION SUKKUR Sukkur dated: 03 /0).2017
NOTICE INVITING TENDERS
The sealed tender on B-I / II forms are invited from the bidders meeting the eligibility criteria of Sindh Public procurement Rules 2010.
S. Name of Work Estimated Earnest Tender Completion No. Cost in Money in Fee in Period Million Million Millions
44 LIST ATTACHED
1. The Blank tender forms can be had from the office if the undersigned, during office hours on any working day up to 24-02-2017 on payment of the tender fee, specified against each work.
2. The tenders will be received back on 21-02-2017 up to 1.00 PM opened on the same day at 2.00 PM, if the undersigned is out of headquarter, the tenders will be opened on the next day. In case the tenders are non-responded the next date of issue & opening will be 03-03-2017 and 06-03-2017.
3. The bidders who will provide following documents / information are eligible to participate as per SPPRA Rules 2010. i. Registration with Pakistan Engineering Council in the relevant field of specialization of work to the extent of tender amount under the code of CE-09 Pakistan Engineering Council (PEC Certificate 2016) is required. ii. Full name, permanent address, Telephone & Fax numbers, E-mail & the organization & structure. Bio Data of technical staff employed and to be made available for working on the Project. iv. Details of work executed during the last five years including copy of certificate for satisfactory completion of works by client. v. Documentary proof and ownership of available Machinery and T & P. vi. List, Scope & Approximate cost of works in hand. vii. Finance stability certificate issued by a scheduled bank. viii. Affidavit in which the bidder undertakes that it is not involved in any litigation. ix. Affidavit in which it should be undertaken that the information provided is true and correct. x. Affidavit that the bidders has not been black listed by any Government / Semi Government ' Autonomous body. xi. Registration (NTN certificate) from Income Tax Department including CNIC. 4. The earnest money specified would be pledged in the name of Executive Engineer P111.. Division Sukkur in the shape of Call Deposit from any scheduled bank and must be attached with bid documents, otherwise it will be not entertained. 5. If Firm / Partner involved in partnership deed, then complete details / instructions and power of attorney will be submitted on affidavit by the Proprietor. 6. Conditional & telegraphic tenders will not be entertained. 7. The Procuring Agency may reject all or any bid subject to the relevant of PPRA Rules. 8. Works will be carried out as per PWD Specification. lc large. 9. The Condition at serial No. 3(i) is not applicable re CogtItk 4.00 Mill: Adverts en rttwet rachi 111: Go 10, All the contractors / firms shall be registered with Sindh Revenue Board (SRB) in term of Rule-46-I(ii) of SPPRA rule (Amended 2014) 11. The work orders shall be issued to the lowest bidder after receipt of funds from gov eminent Ad ess: , Near District Council Hall, Local Board Sukkur
(Ahsan Ali Chohan) Executive Engineer Public Health Engi Division Sukk CC to the:
1. The Director Information, Block No: 96 Sindh Secretariat Karachi for information and publkanoli u. at least three languages leading Newspapers. 2. Secretary to Government of Sindh, Information Technology Department I st Floor. Sindh Secretariat no. 6, Karachi for display on the website of Sindh Government. 3. Manager (Assessment-III), Sindh Public Procurement Regulatory Authority (SPPRA), Government of Sindh, Barrack No. 8 Secretariat No. 4A, Court Road, Karachi for publishing on web. 4. The Deputy Commissioner, Sukkur for favour of kin d information. 5. Superintending Engineer, Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur for favour of kind information. 6. Notice Board. LIST OF WORKS
Estimated Earnest Tender Completion Cost in Million Money in Fee in Period S.N.o: Name of Scheme Million Millions (5%)
DISTRICT ADP 2016-17 Construction of CC Blocks & CC Drainage at 4.00 0.200 3000.00 15 Months Village Rooshanabad Rehabilitation of Water Supply of Village 2.00 0.100 2000.00 15 Months Bhandho CC Paver Block & Water Tank at Village 2.50 0.125 2000.00 15 Months Fida Hussain Buledi i/c Water Supply Construction of CC Paver Village Lal Bux 4.00 0.200 3000.00 15 Months Chajan, Muhammad Yaqoob Buriro & Village Shahbaz Dino Abro, Village Nazir Unar Construction of CC Paver Block & Water 2.00 0.100 2000.00 15 Months Tank at Village Hamid Khan Shambhani i/c Water Tank Water Supply & Water Tank at Village 2.50 0.125 2000.00 15 Months Allah Rakhio Kahinjo Construction of New Water Supply at 8.00 0.400 3000.00 15 Months Village Khair Muhammad Jatoi & Village Jamani Repair of Surface Drains at New Pind 2.00 0.100 2000.00 15 Months Phatak to Engine Shade Colony, Shaikh Mohalla and Adjacent UC-14 Old Sukkur Construction of Paver Block Flooring & 2.00 0.100 2000.00 15 Months Drain at Mirani Mohalla No. 1 Hosa Lane road UC-15 Old Sukkur Construction of Paver Block flooring & 2.00 0.100 2000.00 15 Months Drain at Dayo Mohalla Burma Shell, Abdul Jabbar and Punhal Shaikh Street UC-15 Old Sukkur ConStruction of Paver Block Flooring & 3.00 0.150 3000.00 15 Months Drains at Abdul Qadir Jamali Mohalla Bypass road UC-26 Dargah Bedal Faqir Sukkur Construction of Paver Block Flooring 3.00 0.150 3000.00 15 Months and Drains at Village Gul Chohan UC-26 Bedalpur Sukkur Construction of Paver Block flooring & 5.00 0.250 3000.00 15 Months Drains at Burira Colony UC-20 Site Area Sukkur Widening of drains at Lateef Park, Kiri 2.00 0.100 2000.00 15 Months Quarter, Ghora Gali and Mangi Mohalla and Narishala School UC-14 Old Sukkur 15 Construction of Drainage Scheme and 17.00 0.850 3000.00 15 Months .Surface Drains village Miandad Khoso and Village Alan Khan khoso UC-21 Sukkur
16' Construction of Paver Block flooring & 4.00 0.200 3000.00 15 Months Drain at Bhosa lane Gole Takri Mohalla, Mahar Mohalla, Shaikh Mohalla and Abbasi Mohalla and adjacent street of ward No. 4 UC-17 new pind Sukkur 17 Construction of Paver Block Flooring 5.00 0.250 3000.00 15 Months and Surface Drains at Awan Mohalla Al- Madina Colony Sukkur 18 Construction of Paver Block Flooring 3.00 0.150 3000.00 15 Months and Surface Drain at Jamali Mohalla Barrage Colony Sukkur
19 Construction of Paver Block Flooring 3.00 0.150 3000.00 15 Months and Surface Drain at Oad Mohalla Barrage Colony Sukkur 20 Construction of Paver Block Flooring 5.00 0.250 3000.00 15 Months and Surface Drain at various streets of Barrage Colony Sukkur
21 Construction of Paver Block Flooring 5.00 0.250 3000.00 15 Months and Surface Drain at Jamali Mohalla and various streets of Adam Shah Colony Sukkur
22 Construction of CC Paver Block Flooring 3.00 0.150 3000.00 15 Months & Drains at Police Line, Mughal Colony No. 1 & 2 Adjacent Street of Ward No. 3 UC-17 New Pind Sukkur 23 Construction of Paver Block Flooring 10.00 0.500 3000.00 15 Months and Drains at various streets of UC-23 Sukkur 24 Construction of Drainage @ Alas Khoso 2.00 0.100 2000.00 15 Months
25 Construction of Drainage at Village 2.00 0.100 2000.00 15 Months Pisand Khan Khoso
26 Construction of Drainage / Disposal at 3.00 0.150 3000.00 15 Months Allahabad Colony UC-20 Sukkur
27 Construction of Paver Surface Drains at 1.50 0.075 1000.00 15 Months Dildar Shah Colony UC-20 Sukkur
28 Construction of Water Supply for 2.20 0.110 1500.00 15 Months Bilawal Colony UC-20 Sukkur 29 Construction of CC Block & Drainage 2.00 0.100 2000.00 15 Months system at Daya Goth Rohri 30 Construction of CC Block & Drainage 2.00 0.100 2000.00 15 Months system Ward-3 Rohri 31 Construction of CC Block & Drainage 2.00 0.100 2000.00 15 Months system @ various streets of Ward-5 Rohri 32 Coristruction of Water Supply / 3.00 0.150 3000.00 15 Months Drainage Scheme for Village Bagirji Town 33- Construction of Drainage @ Basherabad 2.00 0.100 2000.00 15 Months UC-17 Society 34 Construction of Drainage at Shah Khalid 2.00 0.100 2000.00 15 Months Colony UC-17 Society 35 Construction of Paver and Drains at 2.00 0.100 2000.00 15 Months Hamdard Co-operative Society Sukkur (Jahangir Mahar House Street No. 09) 36 Construction of Paver & Drainage at 2.50 0.125 2000.00 15 Months Village 60 Chowk 80 chowk UC-22 Rohri 37 Construction of Paver & Drainage @ 56 2.00 0.100 2000.00 15 Months Mohalla Locoshed Rohri 38 Construction of Paver & Drainage @ Pir 2.50 0.125 2000.00 15 Months Murad Shah Gulshan-e-lqbal Goth Qureshi Sukkur 39 Construction of Paver & Drainage @ 2.50 0.125 2000.00 15 Months Main Road Mandhro Shaikh House to Street Allah Dino Jatoi 40 Construction of Paver Block @ Malik 2.20 0.110 2000.00 15 Months Mohalla New Yard Rohri 41 Construction of CC Block at Village New 2.00 0.100 2000.00 15 Months Police Chowki Qureshi Goth UC Gulshan-e-lqbal Sukkur 42 Construction of CC Block & Drainage 2.20 0.110 2000.00 15 Months system & Water Supply wall at Dhareja Mohalla UC-15 Sukkur 43 Construction to Paver & Drainage at 1.80 0.090 2000.00 15 Months Chachar House Misri Khan Chachar 44 Construction of Paver Block & Drainage 1.50 0.075 1000.00 15 Months at Wan Daudpota House New Yard Rohri 45 Construction of CC Blocks & Drainage at 2.00 0.100 2000.00 15 Months Allah Abad Colony Ward-9 Rohri 46 Construction of CC Blocks at Village 2.00 0.100 2000.00 15 Months Hussainabad Ward-1 Rohri 47 Construction of Paver Block Village Haji 2.00 0.100 2000.00 15 Months Khan UC Hingoro Taluka Pano Akil 48 Construction of Paver Block Village Sain 2.00 0.100 2000.00 15 Months Dad Jatoi UC Hingoro Taluka Pano Akil
49 Construction of Paver Block Village Kato 2.00 0.100 2000.00 15 Months UC Hingoro Taluka Pano Akil 50 Construction of Paver Block Village 2.00 0.100 2000.00 15 Months Dater Dino Kalhoro UC Hingoro Taluka Pano Akil 51 Construction of Paver Block & Drainage 3.00 0.150 3000.00 15 Months @ Village Meranpur UC Sangi Taluka Pano Akil 52 Construction of Paver Block & Drainage 2.00 0.100 2000.00 15 Months at Village Waloo Jatoi UC Sangi Taluka Pano Akil 53 Construction of CC Block & Drain Police 1.00 0.050 1000.00 15 Months Mincro Chonki to Imran Shah House Sukkur
Community Development Programme 54 CC Drainage and CC Paver for Village Adam 13.000 0.650 3000.00 15 Months Gopang Taluka Pano Akil District Sukkur.
55 Construction of Sewerage line & Drain @ 40.000 2.000 3000.00 15 Months Micro / Tower New Pind Sukkur District Sukkur.
56 Construction of CC Pavers, CC Drainage 20.000 1.000 3000.00 15 Months disposal and Water Supply at Village Wah Burira Taluka Sukkur Rohri District Sukkur.
(Ahsan Ali Choh n) Executive Engineer Public health Engi Grigg Division Sukku
.000.00.008.0,,co (00031403.• 141111fr .4111 2000 0.110 2.20 '2 03-02.21112•4, TC.0-1411i101400 17 , ,F1 sat-1149.0, • 4 . il_ is • .1111 3000 0.000 1.00 /°S 2P r' '3 .) i laililli 4.110111a 4011114111 Zk,* 4 L-0.3...74144.4..Z. 4cilk,f;2010144".1%.4 ...Ai 411 1100 0.015 1.04 opoo.,Atrikt...1.11140.1 J.k.,144 -, I ,s6S.444/ 461,•664,114.0(414‘ .1 0 24011 11160 2.00 jit4rAys1 t., ,f cj a.s3404‘ sOsa ... 4, 'Issi • .111 2000 100 200 ..(3,411.44V.4.(53,41141,Lor 12010.1 /1.1.1:114/01 s 2000 0000 2 00 a; ,0.111 7 .11 3000 0 200 4 00 4tds.44414.14../41.1.4 .1 sf1.431; 4 416 2000 0.100 2.00 114 YO,.;31,1.1.• -2 3000 0100 2.00 JP* joise! . .fisos, 4116 ION 0.120 2.0.0 3.4‘.01.0.1k.4.1.4.4144), 4 1,401s.iet 416 3006 6160 2.00 Jusiaystv-i*4.4' .4 411 3000 0.200 4.00 L.A.4,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 4 , .41S 2000 0100 3.04 ataih .44? 5,14. ..r.ii.V.... .411 2000 0.100 2.00 ..".44.,..cis...... 4,,jd 4 I 416 3000 0 150 3.00 4, 0,,,,,,.(144.1..111 4/I? 1 4,14),),J6.1= ".41s me. • los 2.04 1.srAs,ros-fit ,4• .1I 3040 • 0110 2.00 2 .10110•11 0.404 444 4434/2,.rik.k.-11.2444., 4
416 00* 4 060 •• 3 411.4. 411 06441 0.160 3 00 talc k41/14441,,,a41.4.? 4 1.0,10diZsi7eJich14 rause.** s 3 ...aos, 4112000 0 100 2.00 ..14 3S41.0410..46J144° 4 411 3000 0 0.50 13 Ook-l(frApi-ussistbtAvv 4 Aitha-s; A11/401,1514644441" I 411 2000 0.100 3.00 ...4.,./101,1144.1.143.444.31 10 , 410 3000 3_000 4400 i.1/416.5(4414,44011t. 6 .41$ 3000 0.100 3.00 ..400{(6.4..bri..3.4 iv? 11 416 3400 1 000 xe ooss144....).0t) Ar4 "litokf.akuss.,, /1411: 4 i3:413-1-114.4. 44116 31140 0.160 3.00 J4,(11250/ 41.1.03.441414$ 13 4 L • AL Ad).12442-29170,44A, I 4J•341.116i$, -..jt‘J'1,‘Soycd.Jits•!sks-Lrl.44.#-. 446 14400 case ossis IS4.10r•o33-1.o..411-414.‘ 13 sfi•••44‘61,41,s-4,40v4:4417 4 I "36.1( 411. 2001 6.100 240 .../41,14.4.410.114;444,41 14 h4141,011.444.-14,..,0 1 1446.3k40411444.42.1. .1111: 0843•2017.44343•20174441P-s46/..44 411 3000 0150 17.00 44.4.1.1).4.14.44(64.1., 16 41(••4.414,1/421 14 :5,1, 410 3004 0.300 4.00 1.1(64.•Eress(,„ J 0.0,4)...i.idzsr•-424...,:(si.:20101C/SPPRA • 1 1A44.444.11^-140/..kI, 2.joNA44••••sytrnxia-lii AAA All
CE-431/l64.4164,C11:0046,1,44%iSI.4 (I )411 3040 0.25.0 5.00 ellylksi.1...444LAJ11. 12 1 J 314.4 ;42014.kk/PECkA)4,4-•AriiVreria 114 34441 6.114 3.00 412(0404.4..2.46.2 16 J ,,,,,e,...4, 42 , .103066 ..104 1.00 .SSIres 4.s.4a•A.4401 IN -1,ZARci),1-irtc•z-SN (w 1 ,444 0-1,4A.2.,t, 1 410 3000 0.350 3.00 41114,024,31//'-uJ1,4j 20 ao4A,C, .410 3000 0.250 5.00 4ssrasci,1/44,..4,./6yss21 ...4.44z4.44.44ptsj444,1%,is.s dkra44(.61-1, .....11,4441..&,Aruergr; ' Air 3000 0.1041 3.00 Args21,1,.C•14111414/414133 (vm I 41140•.)10.2.11•? J. f.(0 (4L , •ftst.)V1 416 30410 6.000 10.004,234014;44..C41.104$4. 33 Asosikwefreissx/44:si,...A.)Ji.r,cs.s. 4.4kr 415 2000 0.100 200 "CSA.134, J2 4116 2060 0.100 2 00 ,416.441114.1,25 -LIVAtivvai..04G,--a2P- (xi .416 3000 0.1$0 3 60 ...IX oLs, rsk *Art 1 t,,440 24 .a.sisti-sVV.i(.rsai.s./„C‘14..4"stO•14/rM 4 "10 414 4416 1000 0.075 1.60 j.05414.1. rrs, 344/..f; . -1. i7 -,Zie.)‘-•Lbssi•St.34,-)Li /304 -sa-diiViisisAa:Juil41.,' 4 415 1500 0.110 3.20 I421/T(.111.)42-1.444,.11..3 ...pc04-.44.414-skis.sci,lispitAJA.A.,4• 411 2000 0.100 2.00 oaloroseth-fiNstsro• .144.00,/ ,:tmL.s.scAV k4 r 4 ...Is 2000 0.100 2.00 0.116)-10'.104,12:30 410 3006 0.004 -4,053(sWeoAsol4444-4S4JAV 2.00 si.2•4‘.414sil-1.1.•161141 31 (Y)..)...L(2010ssphi,/ SPPILta)1o•utFrO 10 .16 3400 0.1541 3 04 atist.A.pl-tyetts. 104". 32 _Zooiss.d.. 144,,oi-al."‘444 .115 2000 0.100 2.00 .11.17441:41fict.t, 53 i 410 2000 0.100 2 00 SI.,1741.01.1.6..04t.14) 34 416 2000 o 1 so 2 00 i1s•-1,11./.(14.1./.4) 30 (3.4)41"1311/443. .416 31100 0.125 3 1011.4.41611.464.4.(114t./...ef 30 4.3Str1r:1,11,) IP, 0../3.J4 A(sP MI 2000 0.100 2.00 JI4451.0434(11:414...... IT 411 2000 0.126 2.50 •24../.13•toprOtt../.42/30 At 6*.4 60ws4441cas 416 2000 0.126 2 50 r,r4e,•••14,1rIkt414d 3 461/ 11.11151Wri77.1.4 1•.044/. • ATTENDANCE SHEET ' Ref: - NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017.
Date of Open: 06-03-2017
S# Name of Contractor Signature
U4, .P-
'3t 9 c) 0 v, %Nu-Um
MIs kV•sk•ftktxvo Coai
,41, team A ..6„., 4Qiihfn AIL.. cu.,,A uv02-,- G7 ------to LAA--4 A-AA RA,,,y4,, .
(Abdul G ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Choh Section Officer (Tech:) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer PHE & RDD Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Government of Sindh Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) ATTENDANCE SHEET
* 'Ref. NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017.
Date of Open: 06-03-2017
S# Name of Contractor Signature
M() At Mwitz+t-
A310,1 MuNt.-/-), C
INA i j 4-4_..(4-.4.4. Vex 4 cAr4 `4-11('
I $ dr 4 A 1,0.. 4144.4.....- 7c.V('
" ' Tc"-{"f°v‘i
MI i A-r.,....-e-1.1e0,4 iNfi:.. #t" mis F F t A. c ccviti co$ r-r.
(Abdul G i Abro) (Ahsan (Muhammad Bux arwar) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Section Officer ( ch:) Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division PHE & RDD Government of Sindh Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) ATTENDANCE SHEET
4111. NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017.
Date of Open: 06-03-2017
S# Name of Contractor ' ature
INA 1) D Ic 4_ CA) il-- V------i'
2-- ME 1 .Coy -zt C-,,itio . , . r; all K11 C lk) cliv.V rci ...wb I,
k; Ck LALA---. titwitre... nikfrA;k_ (7 . twkl Sal,a,,, tA, (A
PIN,)k,,A u.).-t,) 1\1\4.4
n ui,c161/4__ Mito ,. C1L4 -
mu,
---m
Mk A-WI M3 c,Aip'
(Muhammad Bux rwar) (Abdu G i Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan Section Officer (Tech:) Executh; Engineer Executive Engineer PHE & RDD Highway Division Public Health Engineering Division Government of Sindh Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) ATTENDANCE SHEET
Ref: • NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017.
Date of Open: 06-03-2017
S# Name of Contractor Signature
tVANi.-i IN-L tA01,,,0
kt— Me4ivt. 60 . 444.1i-
':t . . _,wv Uco 00,1
v oa- ILI pi-cA -.1A) :I tv.i A.,..u.,,:l ( ksmi)
1\1\1 s A„,,ei,v c.,4
mil A ii---f-L-3 (,,C„,___
Mito,r
I (Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdu G • Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan Section Officer (Tech:) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer PHE & RDD Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Government of Sindh Sukkur '(Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) • ATTENDANCE SHEET Ref: • NIT No. TC/G- 148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017.
Date of Open: 06-03-2017
S# Name of Contractor Signature
C_ otv—etv) K-kraz kw) .. ).-.
\bt t s IG,,...) co ,f e.,•••• 1
I-. b. ml Prtill) CA‘,147(‘ a ee r AL . A_„„„4,„ 4, nfAIA•
\.),,,„.,,t 11,0.dictio ti
CA`11-e-,-- (c.., C it.,) , r•-",.#4."'' -7
10 . WI s.va,-- t R,..-.44L0. ViCr;fr MAl,v,1 4-tAkid1.-=/4 AittA.,...
(Abdu Abro) (Ahsan Section Officer (Tech:) Executive ngineer Executive Engineer PHE & RDD Highway Division Public Health Engineering Division Government of Sindh Sukkur ember) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) • ATTENDANCE SHEET • Ref: . NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017.
Datp of Open: 06-03-2017
S# Name of Contractor Signature R. A • co..011.
"
Lekki 44-k;i kfookt CII"
MIS A-- R . Avsix.,„-- C?)
M ' & %-eo I Al; R,...114 4/A0' IIN kipp , . A caA-,44,,A
e_.,1,10_p,40.,5t tro.ib 4v,AA'
(Muhammad Bu Jarwar) (Ab Abro) (Ahsan i s a ) Section Officer (Tech:) Executive Engineer Executive Engineer PHE & RDD Highway Division Public Health Engineering Division Government of Sindh Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) • ATTENDANCE SHEET • • Ref: • NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017.
Date of Open: 06-03-2017
S# Name of Contractor Signature
kAi LA-r-,,/ k ildti
6--,J1, Ck ' S C—tsw) ti21744/74:1 '
tsell s Creo4oNAA.vD bvt--S gr11 s
IA PA/4c M • 41194..),_
AS e•-- A-ti TL...JL,
Pr- es-)A,,s4 604 A
mwM.;--y A-CA q.4,._,LA ,
(Muhammad Bux Narwar) (Ab• ul i Abro) (Ahsan Ali Cho ) Section Officer (Tech:) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer PHE & RDD Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Government of Sindh Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) ATTENDANCE SHEET • Ref: NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017.
Date of Open: 06-03-2017
S# Name of Contractor till Signature
Mid&ka,,- t‘NatiAr. A...1 40 \ 4 ...-
,44,342Ap 11-c; 06 ' s 411
1 A I ? mi-a-a--4 6ves-4 el
A-L_TJ1....-,:___ u+
To...Le 4 4-u.nt,... Tjut\AV A44 6-k-: Icpl,v -- A-wcs, 46 A-be,A4 I ,/ NNr i
I\le .( AtjetA
0/I , (Muhammad Bux J rwar) (Abe ul 1 'ani Abro) (Ahsan o an) Section Officer (Tech:) Executi e Engineer Executive Engineer PHE & RDD High y Division Public Health Engineering Division Government of Sindh Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) ATTENDANCE SHEET
II • Ref: - NIT No. TC/G- 148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017.
Date of Open: 06-03-2017
S# Name of Contractor Signature
A.I %A "Wf_A •
Vvrre.-ry `1.) h
IV\ v•L...... ,c1 e61-^4 v.) d't-A/ -Jcitui !
1\11k t ---ectoAtiki. .J.Ast9s•C‘vai N•,,,,A),_Q 1\m, p,„,r,.... t1/1,4 ,,. A.
(Muhammad x Jarwar) (A dul ani Abro) (Ahsan r-- Section Officer (Tech:) Execut ye Engineer Executive Engineer PHE & RDD High ay Division Public Health Engineering Division Government of Sindh Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
No. TC/G-148/ WI /2017 (071)9310133 OFFICE OF THE [email protected] EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PUBLIC HEALTH ENGINEERING DIVISION SUKKUR Sukkur dated: O 6 /03 /2017
Subject: PROCUREMENT COMMITTEE MEETING HELD ON 06-03-2017.
A meeting of the procurement committee was held in the office of Executive Engineer, Public Health Engineering Division Sukkur under the Chairmanship of Executive Engineer. 2. The below mentioned members of the committee attended the meeting to discuss the bids invited for the procurement of works vide Executive Engineer, Public Health Engineering Division Sukkur letter No. TC/G-148/1066 dated 03/02/2017 and subsequently hoisted on the website of Sindh Public Procurement regularity Authority and Newspapers. Following attended the meeting.
1. Abdul Ghani Abro Executive Engineer, Member Highway Division, Sukkur
2. Muhammad Bux Jarwar Section Officer (Tech), Member Public Health Engineering & Rural Development Department Karachi
3. During the course of meeting following discussion were made by the committee.
i. The tenders received on dated 06-03-2017 at 2.00 PM were opened before the procurement committee in presence of representatives of participants. ii. The methods for bidding documents observed as single envelop. iii. The tenders were opdned on 06-03-2017 before the tender opening committee. 4. The committee was informed that 168 Nos. bidders have purchased the bidding documents upto dated 03-03-2017 and 168 Nos. have respond the bids and received today upto 2.00 PM in the office of Executive Engineer, Public Health Engineering Division Sukkur. 5. During the openingof the tenders received, following status was found. S# Name of Firms Ranking in Remarks Terms of Cost 1 M/S Bhambhro Construction 1st Lowest Accepted Mr. Insaf Ali Buriro 2nd Highest Rejected Mr. Agha Gul Hassan 3rd Highest Rejected 2 M/S Al-Asim & Co. 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Hassan Enterprises 2nd Highest Rejected . M/S Adeel Ahmed Construction 3rd Highest Rejected 3 M/S Bhambhro Construction & Co. 1St Lowest Accepted M/S Hassan Enterprises 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Veeru Mal Enterprises 3rd Highest Rejected 4 M/S Kamal & Co. 1st Lowest Accepted M/S DKC Enterprises 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Al-Hassan Electric & Civil Work 3rd Highest Rejected 5 Mr. Hamadullah Abbasi 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Adeel Ahmed Construction 2nd Highest Rejected Mr. Shafqat Ali Chohan 3rd Highest Rejected 6 M/S Bhambhro Construction & Co. 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Hassan Enterprises 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Agha Gul Hassan 3rd Highest Rejected 7 M/S Veeru Mal Enterprises 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Bhambhro Construction 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Saqib Rasheed & Co. 3rd Highest Rejected 8 M/S Hamad Global Enterprises 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Niaz Ali 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Veeru Mal Enterprises 3rd Highest Rejected 9 M/S Agha Gul Hassan Khan 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Ali Enterprises 2nd Highest Rejected M/S G.S Sons Enterprises 3rd Highest Rejected 10 M/S Shahzado Mahar ' Lowest Accepted M/S Ali Builder 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Saqib Rasheed & Co. 3rd Highest Rejected 11 M/S R.A Construction 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Shamim & Brothers 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Mehran machinery Store 3rd Highest Rejected 12 M/S R.A Construction Company 1St Lowest Accepted M/S Hassan Enterprises 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Ansari & Co. 3rd Highest Rejected 13 M/S Al-Hassan Electric & Civil Work 1St Lowest Accepted M/S Adeel Ahmed Construction 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Saqib Rasheed & Co. 3rd Highest Rejected 14 M/S Ali Baba Mahar Enterprises 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Soomra Brothers 2nd Highest Rejected M/S DKC Enterprises 3rd Highest Rejected 15 M/S New Royal Enterprises 1St Lowest Accepted M/S DKC Enterprises 2nd Highest Rejected M/S AM & Mj Builders 3rd Highest Rejected 16 M/S Muhammad Usman & Builders 1st Lowest Accepted M/S AMD Construction 2nd Highest Rejected M/S DKC Enterprises 3rd Highest Rejected 17 M/S Saqib Rasheed & Co. 1st Lowest Accepted M/S DKC Enterprises 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Muhammad Usman & Builders 3rd Highest Rejected 18 Mr. Ashique Ali Abbasi 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Awais & Brothers 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Ameer Ali 3rd Highest Rejected 19 M/S Z.A Qureshi 1st Lowest Accepted Mr. Ghulam Rasool Narejo 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Hassan Enterprises 3rd Highest Rejected 20 M/S Niaz Ali 1St Lowest Accepted M/S Hassan Enterprises 2nd Highest Rejected M/S DKC Enterprises 3rd Highest Rejected 21 M/S Rashidi Enterprises 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Muhammad Shoaib & Brothers 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Hassan Enterprises 3rd Highest Rejected 22 Mr. Nazir Ahmed Kalwar 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Veeru Mal Enterprises 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Nippon Builders 3rd Highest Rejected 23 M/S Adeel Ahmed Construction & 1st Lowest Accepted Co. M/S DKC Enterprises 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Hassan Enterprises 3rd Highest Rejected 24 Mr. Mazhar Hussain Memon 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Zulficiar & Co. 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Adeel Ahmed Construction 3rd Highest Rejected 25 Mr. Bagh Ali Buriro 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Ali Enterprises 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Saqib Rasheed & Co. 3rd Highest Rejected 26 M/S Agha Gul Hassan Khan. 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Hassan Enterprises 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Relient Trade Link 3rd Highest Rejected 27 M/S Abdul Rasool Construction 1st Lowest Accepted Company M/S Rohri Enterprises 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Saqib Rasheed & Co. 3rd Highest Rejected 28 M/S Ajlal Mustafa 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Adeel Ahmed Construction 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Zulfiqar & Co. 3rd Highest Rejected 29 M /S A.Hafeez Pathan 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Qalandar Sr Brothers 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Hassan Enterprises 3rd Highest Rejected 30 M/S F.F Enterprises 1st Lowest Accepted Mr. Bahadur Ali Thaheem . 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Qalandar & Brothers 3rd Highest Rejected 31 M/S Nippon Builders 1St Lowest Accepted M/S Hassan Enterprises 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Zulfiqar & Co. 3rd Highest Rejected 32 Mr. Bashir Ahmed Mahar 1st Lowest Accepted M/S AMD Construction 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Al-Hassan electric & Civil Work 3rd Highest Rejected 33 M/S N.S Jaffar & Co. 1st Lowest Accepted M/S DKC Enterprises 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Sastech Construction Works 3rd Highest Rejected ' 34 M/S Al-Mustafa Enterprises 1st Lowest Accepted Mr. Nazir Ahmed Kalwar 2nd Highest Rejected Mr. Jawaid Hussain Jatoi 3rd Highest Rejected 35 M/S Atif Ali Khoso & Company 1st Lowest Accepted Mr. Ashique Ali Abbasi 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Nasir Abbas Construction 3rd Highest Rejected 36 M/S A1-Tehreem Enterprises 1st Lowest Accepted Mr. Tahir Hussain 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Muhammad Shoaib & Brothers 3rd Highest Rejected 37 M/S Zaheer & Brothers 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Abbas Ali 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Zulfiqar & Co. 3rd Highest Rejected 38 M/S A.R Awan & Co 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Shehzoor Enterprises 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Shoaib & Brothers 3rd Highest Rejected 39 M/S Ansari & Co. 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Hassan Enterprises 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Zulfiqar & Co. 3rd Highest Rejected 40 M/S Paragon Enterprises 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Ayan-e-Noor Engineers 2nd Highest Rejected M/S F.F Electrical & Construction 3rd Highest Rejected 41 M/S Sultan Muhammad 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Al-Noor Builders 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Marhaba Traders 3rd Highest Rejected 42 Mr. Basher Ahmed Mahar 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Akhtar Ali & Co. ' 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Anwar Ali & Co. 3rd Highest Rejected 43 M/S Waqar Traders 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Ghulam Mustafa Malik 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Shehzoor Enterprises 3" Highest Rejected 44 Mr. Abdul Wahid Mahar 1st Lowest Accepted Mr. Ashique Ali Mangi 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Hassan Enterprises 3rd Highest Rejected 45 Mr. Asad Ali Thaheem 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Malik Muhammad Ishaque & 2nd Highest Rejected Co. M/S Awais & Brothers 3rd Highest Rejected 46 Mr. Muhammad Anwar Jamali 1st Lowest Accepted M/S AMD Construction 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Zulfiqar & Co. 3rd Highest Rejected 47 M/S Shaheen Enterprises 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Saqib Rasheed & Co. 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Akbar & Ali Associates 3rd Highest Rejected 48 Mr. Shafqat Ali Chohan 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Sastech Construction Work 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Ceccon Engineering Works 3rd Highest Rejected 49 M/S Asad Ali Buriro 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Ashique Ali Mangi 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Hassan Enterprises 3rd Highest Rejected 50 M/S Aijaz Ali 1st Lowest Accepted Mr. Ashique Ali Abbasi 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Awais & Brothers 3rd Highest Rejected 51 M/S Abdul Rasool Construction 1st Lowest Accepted Company Mr. Mushtaque Ali Shah 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Ali Enterprises 3rd Highest Rejected 52 M/S Ghulam Mustafa Malik 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Bilal & Brothers 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Ali Builders 3rd Highest Rejected 53 M/S Zain Shah & Brothers 1st Lowest Accepted Mr. Irshad Ali Abbasi 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Aazmeer Enterprises 3rd Highest Rejected 54 M/S Al-Ameer Enterprises 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Adeel Ahmed Construction 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Saqib Rasheed Construction 3rd Highest Rejected 55 M/S Bedal Becus 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Saqib Rasheed & Co. 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Adeel Ahmed Construction 3rd Highest Rejected 56 M/S Green Land & Company 1st Lowest Accepted M/S Muhammad Usman & Builder 2nd Highest Rejected M/S Saqib Rasheed & Co. 3rd Highest Rejected
6. The committee thoroughly scrutinized each case / tender documents by comparing arithmetically and financially with sanctioned estimates / bill of quantities and criteria for eligibility and minimum qualification as per bidding documents.
7. Recommendation After due deliberation / scrutiny of each tender document by the committee, it was recommended that lowest evaluated responsive bidder may be awarded the respective tender.
8. Decision In view of Para No. 7 of this report it is decided that tenders are being awarded to above mentioned lowest responsive bidders accordingly.
(Muhammad Bu (Abdu*;a4.6i Abro) (Ahsan Ali Choh. n) Section Officer (Tech) Executive E gineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highway D ision Public Health Engg: Division Rural Development Dept: Sukkur Sukkur Karachi Member Chairman Member BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 01
1.Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer, PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of CC Blocks & CC Drains at Village Roshanabad Taluka Rohri District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10.Bids Rejected: NIL 11.Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12.Bid Evaluation Report Sii Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection
1 M/S Bhambhro Construction 18.77% Above I' Lowest 1.99% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 Mr. Insaf Ali Buriro 20.35% Above 2' Lowest 0.69% Rejected Being high Saving
3 Mr. Agha Gul Hassan 20 80°0 Abo v e 3rd Lowest 0.32% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (Abdul G ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highw Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS OUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of CC Blocks & CC Drains at Village Roshanabad Taluka Rohri District Sukkur. Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name
S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S Bhamhhro Mr. Insaf Ali Mr. Agha Construction Buriro Gul Hassan
1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Oualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the author Yes Yes Yes 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by ti Yes Yes Yes 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad r‘ar) (AbdulG ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer ech) Executive Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of CC Blocks & CC Drains at Village Roshanabad Taluka Rohri District Sukkur.
References. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Bhambhro Construction Mr. Insaf Ali Buriro Mr. Agha Gul Hassan GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 18.77% above the Schedule "B" @ 20.35% above the Schedule "B" @ 20.80% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 3140242 00 3140242 3140242 3140242
Non-Schedule Items Rs - -
Cartage Rs 589581 00 589423 639039 653170
Ceiling Rs 75643 00
Total: Rs. 3805466.00 3729665 3779281 3793412 Rs. 3805500.00 E/COST 3805500 3805500 3805500 -75835 -26219 -12088 1.99% Below the E/Cost 0.69% Below the E/Cost 0.32% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Bhambhro Construction Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 37,29.665/- (Rupees. Thirty Seven Lac Twenty Nine Thousand Six Hundred Sixty Five) Only at 18_77% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.99% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of aleck / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhammad Bux Jal war) ( %Mu! Gh i %Iwo) (Ahsan Ali ('hohan) Section Officer (Tech) 1.xecuti‘ e .ngineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural I lighway Division Public Health Engineextifig Division Development Department Sukkur (. ember) Sukkur (Chair90 Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT • 1..' Sr # 02
I. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer, PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work /Item: Water Supply at Village Bandho Taluka Rohri
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: ahlgl; 10.Bids Rejected: NIL 11.Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12.Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Bidder Ranking Compa Reasons for acceptance Remarks Terms of rison / Rejection Cost with Estimat I M/S Al-Asim & Co. 17.85% Above 1" Lowest 0.89% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Hassan Enterprises 20.38% Above 2nd Lowest 0.67% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Adeel Ahmed Construction 20.80% Above 3`d Lowest 0.43% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul G ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Choha ) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highway Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1 066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work Water Supply at Village Bandho Taluka Rohri
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S Adeel S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S Al-Asim & M/S Hassan Ahmed Co. Enterprises Construction I Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 MIN Certificate Yes Yes Yes
3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes
4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes
5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board • Yes Yes Yes
Qualification Criteria
6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant field Yes Yes Yes
7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes
8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes
9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the authorized persor Yes Yes Yes
10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by the procurir Yes Yes Yes
11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux4J near) (Abdul ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Cho an) Section Officer (Tech) Executi Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highw y Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) •
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work. Water Supply at Village Bandho Taluka Rohri Date of opening: 06-03-2017
References TC/G-14811066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DBi dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Al-Asim & Co. M/S Hassan Enterprises M/S Adeel Ahmed Construction GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 17.85% above the Schedule "B" @ 20.38% above the Schedule "B" @ 20.80% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 577984 00 577984 577984 577984
Non-Schedule Items Rs. 279000.00 279000 279000 279000
Cartage Rs 16651 00 103170 117793 120221
Ceiling Rs. 107775 00
Total: Rs. 981410.00 960154 974777 977205 Rs. 981400.00 E/COST 981400 981400 981400 -21246 -6623 -4195 2.16% Below the E/Cost 0.67% Below the E/Cost 0.43% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Al-Asim & Co Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 9,60,154/- (Rupees. Nine Lac Sixty Thousand One Hundred Fifty Four) Only at 17.85% above the schedule "B" items and being 2.16% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion.
y (Muhammad Bux arwar) (Abdul (dia i 'Ono (Ahmin Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Exccuti‘e ngineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural ivision l'uhl calth Engin ring Dix ision Development Department Sukkur ember) Sukkur (Ch n) Karachi (Member)
BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 03
1.Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: CC Paver Block & Water Tank at Village Fida Hussain Buledi i/c Water Supply Taluka Saleh Pat District Sukkur
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10.Bids Rejected: NIL 11.Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report SH Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for acceptance Remarks Bidder Terms of with / Rejection Cost Estimated Cost 1 M/S Bhamhhro Construction & 18.10% Above 1" Lowest 1.41% Saving Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Co. award of work
2 M/S Hassan Enterprises 18.80% Above 2nd Lowest 0.91% Saving Rejected Being High
3 M/S Veeru Mal Enterprises 19.50% Above 3"I Lowest 0.40% Saving Rejected Being Highest
( (Muhammad Bux arwar) (Abdul Gh ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executive ngineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT • NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work CC Paver Block & Water Tank at Village Fida Hussain Buledi lie Water Supply Taluka Saleh Pat District Sukkur
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement:
Bidder's Name M/S Veeru S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S Bhambhro M/S Hassan Mal Construction & Co. Enterprises Enterprises 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) , N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes
3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes
4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes
5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes
Qualification Criteria
6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant fi Yes Yes Yes
7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes
8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes
9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the authori Yes Yes Yes
10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by a Yes Yes Yes
11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
. •
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 CC Paver Block & Water Tank at Village Fida Hussain Buledi i/c Water Supply Taluka Saleh Pat District Sukkur
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by. Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Bhambhro Construction & Co. M/S Hassan Enterprises M/S Veeru Mal Enterprises GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 18.10% above the Schedule "B" @ 18.80% above the Schedule "B" @ 19.50% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1428193 00 1428193 1428193 1428193
Non-Schedule Items Rs 266000 00 266000 266000 266000
Cartage Rs 88261 00 258503 268500 278498
Ceiling Rs 198207 00
Total: Rs. 1980661.00 1952696 1962693 1972691 Rs. 1980700.00 E/COST 1980700 1980700 1980700 -28004 -18007 -8009 1.41% Below the E/Cost 0.91% Below the E/Cost 0.40% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Bhambhro Construction & Co Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 19,52,696/- (Rupees. Nineteen Lac Fifty Two Thousand Six Hundred Ninety Six) Only at 18.10% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.41% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of heck / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (.‘hdul ni 1bro) ( 111san 111 (hohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executise ngineer Executive Eng'neer Public Health Engg: & Rural Di% ision Public ealth Enginee Division Development Department Sukkur 'ember) Sukkur (Chai Karachi (Member)
• BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 04
I. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer, P1-1E Division Sukkur _ 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of CC paver block village Lal Bux Chaim', Muhammad Yakoob Buriro & Village Shahbaz Dino Abro, Village Nazir Unnar Taluka
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10.Bids Rejected: NIL 11.Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection 1-...... 1 M/S Kamal & Co 18.10% Above 1 st Lowest 1.97% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S DKC Enterprises 19.90% Above 2' Lowest 0.48% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Al-Hassan Electric & Civil 20.15% Above 3'd Lowest 0.27% Rejected Being Highest Works Saving
(Muhammad ux atwar) (Abdul G ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer ech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highw Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) • TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of CC paver block village Lal Bux Chajan, Muhammad Yakoob Buriro & Village Shahbaz Dino Abro, Village Nazir Unnar Taluka Rohri Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S Al- S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S DKC M/S Kamal & Co Hassan Enterprises Electric & 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes s Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the author Yes Yes Yes 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by tl Yes Yes Yes 1 I Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux J ar) (Abdul Gh i Abro) (Ahsan 1 o an) Section Officer (Tech) Executive ngineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highway Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) •
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Construction of CC paver block village Lal Bux Chajan, Muhammad Yakoob Buriro & Village Date of opening 06-03-2017 Shahbaz Dino Abro, Village Nazir Unnar Taluka Rohri
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Kamal & Co M/S DKC Enterprises M/S Al-Hassan Electric & Civil Works GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 18.10% above the Schedule "B" f 19.90% above the Schedule "B" @ 20.15% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 3184599 00 3184599 3184599 3184599
Non-Schedule Items Rs - - -
Cartage Rs 602499 00 576412 633735 641697
Ceiling Rs 49578 00
Total: Rs. 3836676.00 3761011 3818334 3826296 Rs. 3836700.00 E/COST 3836700 3836700 3836700 -75689 -18366 -10404 1.97% Below the E/Cost 0.48% Below the E/Cost 0.27% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Kamal & Co. Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 37,61,011/- (Rupees. Thirty Seven Lac Sixty One Thousand eleven) Only at 18.10% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.97% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue th- work order to the lowest contractor,
I (Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul Gha i .Abro) (Ahsan Ali ( hohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executise ngineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural hvision Publ. Health Enginee ' g Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (('hair Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 03
1. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: CC Paver Block & Water Tank at Village Hamid Khan Shambhani i/c water Supply Taluka Saleh Pat District Sukkur
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL I 1 . Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for acceptance Remarks Bidder Terms of with / Rejection Cost Estimated Cost I NI r I lamadullab Abbasi 18.95% A ho \ L: Is' Lowest 0.64% Saving Accepted being Lowest Recommended for award of work
2 M/S Adeel Ahmed Construction 19.10% Above 2nd Lowest 0.53% Saving Rejected Being High
3 Mr. Shafqat Ali Chohan 19.77% Above 3rd Lowest 0.07% Saving Rejected Being Highest
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executi e Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highw y Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS OUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: CC Paver Block & Water Tank at Village Hamid Khan Sham bhani i/c water Supply Taluka Saleh Pat District Sukkur
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement:
Bidder's Name M/S Adeel S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria Mr. Hamadullah Mr. Shafqat Ahmed Abbasi Ali Chohan Construction 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes
3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes
4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes
5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board l'es Yes Yes
Qualification Criteria
6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant fi Yes Yes Yes
7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes
8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes
9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the authori Yes Yes Yes
10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by tl' Yes Yes Yes
11 Qualified/ disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad ‘Bux Ja ar) (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executi Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highw y Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukk (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 CC Paver Block & Water Tank at Village Hamid Khan Shambhani i/c water Supply Taluka Saleh Pat District Sukkur
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost Mr. Hamadullah Abbasi M/S Adeel Ahmed Construction Mr. Shafqat Ali Chohan GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 18.95% above the Schedule "B" @ 19.10% above the Schedule "B" @ 19.77% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1114587 00 1114587 1114587 1114587
Non-Schedule Items Rs 266000 00 266000 266000 266000
Cartage Rs 85999 00 211214 212886 220354
Ceiling Rs 135482 00
Total: Rs. 1602068.00 1591801 1593473 1600941 Rs. 1602000.00 E/COST 1602000 1602000 1602000 -10199 -8527 -1059 0.64% Below the E/Cost 0.53% Below the E/Cost 0.07% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by Mr. Hamadullah Abbasi Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 15,91,801/- (Rupees. Fifteen Lac Ninety One Thousand Eight Hundred Cne) Only at 18.95% above the schedule "B" items and being 0.64% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhammad Bux iarwar) ( kb I (; niEbro) ( ‘hsan CTilfo an) Section Officer (Tech) Executi% e ngincer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Ilighn a Di% ision Pohl calth Enginee Division Development Department Sukkur Member) ukkur (Chaff. Karachi (Member)
BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 06
1.Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-I48/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Water Supply & Water Tank at Village Allah Rakhio Kahiniho Taluka Saleh Pat District Sukkur
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10.Bids Rejected: NIL 11.Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report SO Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for acceptance Remarks Bidder Terms of with / Rejection Cost Estimated Cost I \I'S Bhambhro Construction & 18.05% Above 1 m Lowest 1.44% Saving Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Co. award of work
2 M/S Hassan Enterprises I8.93% Above 2nd Lowest 0.81% Saving Rejected Being High
3 M/S Agha Gul Hassan 19.67% Above 3rd Lowest 0.28% Saving Rejected Being Highest
(Muhammad Bux a ar) (Ab ul r ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Choh n) Section Officer (Tech) Executi e Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & High y Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukk r (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Water Supply & Water Tank at Village Allah Rakhio Kahinjho Taluka Saleh Pat District Sukkur
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name
S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S Bhambhro M/S Hassan M/S Agha Cul Construction & Co. Enterprises Hassan
1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes
3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes
4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes
5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes
Qualification Criteria
6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant ti Yes Yes Yes
7 Turnover of at least last three years , Yes Yes Yes
8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes
9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the authori Yes Yes Yes
10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by tl- Yes Yes Yes
1 I Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Choh ) Section Officer (Tech) Executi e Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highw y Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
. •
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue: 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening: 06-03-2017 Water Supply & Water Tank at Village Allah Rakhio Kahinjho Taluka Saleh Pat District Sukkur
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by: Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Bhambhro Construction & Co. M/S Hassan Enterprises M/S Agha Gul Hassan GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 18.05% above the Schedule "B" @ 18.93% above the Schedule "B" @ 19.67% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1416618 00 1416618 1416618 1416618
Non-Schedule Items Rs 266000 00 266000 266000 266000
Cartage Rs 88169 00 255700 268166 278649
Ceiling Rs 195892 00
Total: Rs. 1966679.00 1938318 1950784 1961267 Rs. 1966700.00 E/COST 1966700 1966700 1966700 -28382 -15916 -5433 1.44% Below the E/Cost 0.81% Below the E/Cost 0.28% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Bhambhro Construction & Co.Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 19,38.318/- (Rupees. Nineteen Lac Thirty Eight Thousand Three Hundred Eighteen) Only at 18.05% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.44% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of heck / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abd ul ani Alm)) (Ahsan Ali ('hohan) Section Officer (Tech) FACCUti% Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Ilighssa Division Pubitc eealth Engine ing Division ,-- Development Department Sukkur Member) Sukkur (('ha"' Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT a Sr # 07 "I. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer, PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Water Supply Scheme Village Khair Muhammad Jatoi & Village Jamani UC Trimonh Taluka Rohri District Sukkur
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Resort S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for acceptance Remarks Bidder Terms of with / Rejection Cost Estimated Cost I M/S Veeru Mal Enterprises 24.80% Atiovc 1st Lowest 0.45% Saving Accepted being Lowest Recommended for award of work
2 M/S Bhambhro Construction 25.00% Above 2nd Lowest 0.29% Saving Rejected Being High
3 M/S Saqib Rasheed & Co. 25.17% Above 3rd Lowest 0.16% Saving Rejected Being Highest
(Muhammad Bux J rwar) (Abdul Gh ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executive ngineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highw Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
ST No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work Water Supply Scheme Village Khair Muhammad Jatoi & Village Jamani UC Trimonh Taluka Rohri District Sukkur
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement:
Bidder's Name M/S Saqib S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S Veeru Mal M/S Bhambhro Rasheed & Enterprises Construction Co. 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) Yes Yes Yes
2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes
3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes
4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes
5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes
Qualification Criteria
6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant field Yes Yes Yes
7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes
8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes
9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the authorized Yes Yes Yes
10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by the p Yes Yes Yes
11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executi e Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural High y Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
•
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Water Supply Scheme Village Khair Muhammad Jatoi 8. Village Jamani UC Trirnonh Taluka Rohri District Sukkur
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by Chief Engineer Public Health Engineering dept Govt of Sindh Sukkur vide No. DB/DWE/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Veeru Mal Enterprises M/S Bhambhro Construction M/S Sagib Rasheed & Co. GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 24.80% above the Schedule "B" @ 25.00% above the Schedule "B" @ 25.17% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 5319871 00 5319871 5319871 5319871
Non-Schedule Items Rs 335600 00 335600 335600 335600
Cartage . Rs 535842 00 1319328 1329968 • 1339012
Ceiling Rs 814234 00
Total: Rs. 7005547.00 6974799 6985439 6994483 Rs. 7006000 00 E/COST 7006000 7006000 7006000 -31201 -20561 -11517 0.45% Below the E/Cost 0.29% Below the E/Cost 0.16% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Veeru Mal Enterprises Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 69.74,799/- (Rupees. Sixty Nine Lac Seventy Four Thousand Seven Hundred Ninety Nine) Only at 24.80% above the schedule "B" items and being 0.45% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) tbdul 6 ani %Iwo) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Exccutis Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Ilighw y Division Public Icalth EngineerkDivis. Development Department Sukk (Member) Sukkur (Chairmit0- Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr#08
I. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Repair of Surface Drains at New find Pliatak to Engine Shade Colony Shaikh Mohalla and Adacent II I UC-14 Old Sukkur
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope 5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10.Bids Rejected: NIL 11.Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection r-.....6 I MIS Hamad Global Enterprises 17.80% Above 1$` Lowest 2.01% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Niaz Ali 19.22% Above 2nd Lowest 0.82% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Veeru Mal Enterprises 19.79% Above 3rd Lowest 0.35% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux a ar) (Abdul Gh Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan Section Officer (Tech) Executive ngineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highway ivision Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur ( ember) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Repair of Surface Drains at New Pind Phatak to Engine Shade Colony Shaikh Mohalla and Adacent UC-14 Old Sukkur
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S Hamad M/S Veeru S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria Global M/S Niaz Ali Mal Enterprises Enterprises 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant I Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the author Yes Yes Yes 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by tl Yes Yes Yes 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
kv (Muhamma anvar) (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highw Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Repair of Surface Drains at New Pind Phatak to Engine Shade Colony Shaikh Mohalla and Adacent UC-14 Old Sukkur
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Hamad Global Enterprises M/S Niaz Ali M/S Veeru Mal Enterprises GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 17.80% above the Schedule "B" @ 19.22% above the Schedule "B" @ 19.79% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1592038 00 1592038 1592038 1592038
Non-Schedule Items Rs -
Cartage Rs 281190 00 283383 305990 315064
Ceiling Rs 40539 00
Total: Rs. 1913767.00 1875421 1898028 1907102 Rs. 1913800.00 E/COST 1913800 1913800 1913800 -38379 -15772 -6698 2.01% Below the E/Cost 0.82% Below the E/Cost 0.35% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Hamad Global Enterprises Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 18.75,421/- (Rupees. Eighteen Lac Seventy Five Thousand Four Hundred Twenty One) Only at 17.80% above the schedule "B" items and being 2.01% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion Hence duly recommended f r favour of check / sanctioned F. issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (Abdul ;ha i Abro) (Ahsan Ali C ohan Section Officer (Tech) Exectitk e ngineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Dighvt 3% )is ision Publf. ilealth Enginetring Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chan-4W- Karachi (Member) • BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 09
1. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer, PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Paver Block Flooring & Drain at Mirani Mohallal No. 1 Bhosa Lane road UC-15 Old Sukkur District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 3 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection 1-.,... 1 M/S Agha Gul Hassan Khan 18.05% Above Ia Lowest 1.03% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Ali Enterprises 18.70% Abu ‘ e 2nd Lowest 0.49% Rejected Being high Saving
3 M/S G.S Sons Enterprises 19.00% Above 3"I Lowest 0.23% Rejected Being Highest Saving
I\NNNV (Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul Gh ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Paver Block Flooring & Drain at Mirani Mohallal No. 1 Bhosa Lane road UC-15 Old Sukkur District Sukkur. Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S G.S S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S Agha Gul M/S Ali Sons Hassan Khan Enterprises Enterprises 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the author Yes Yes Yes 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by t] Yes Yes Yes 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul Gh ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
S
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of Paver Block Flooring & Drain at Mirani Mohallal No. 1 Bhosa Lane road UC- 15 Old Sukkur District Sukkur.
References. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Agha Gul Hassan Khan M/S Ali Enterprises M/S G.S Sons Enterprises GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR @ 18.05% above the Schedule "8" e 18.70% above the Schedule "B" e 19.00% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1626940 00 1626940 1626940 1626940
Non-Schedule Items Rs.
Cartage Rs 286387 00 293663 304238 309119
Ceiling Rs 27281 00
Total: Rs. 1940608.00 1920603 1931178 1936059 Rs. 1940600.00 E/COST 1940600 1940600 1940600 -19997 -9422 -4541 1.03% Below the E/Cost 0.49% Below the E/Cost 0.23% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Agha Gul Hassan Khan Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 19,20.603/- (Rupees. Nineteen Lac Twenty Thousand Six Hundred Three) Only at 18.05% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.03% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of c eck / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhamma ux Jarwar) I ‘11)(Itil (;11; i Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) ExceutiNe ,ngineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Ilighssas )isision Public Health Engineilipg Division Development Department Sukkur lember) h( Sukkur(('hair/slot) Karachi (Member) • • BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 10
1. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer, PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-I48/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Paver Block Flooring & Drain at Davo Mohalla Burma shell. Abdul Jabbar and Punhal Shaikh Street UC-15 Old Sukkur District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection r....,.., I M/S Shahzado Mahar 20.10% Above ist Lowest 0.95% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Ali Builder 20.45% Above rd Lowest 0.66% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Saqib Rasheed & Co 20.95% Above3"I Lowest 0.25% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (Ab s G i Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) •• TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Paver Block Flooring & Drain at Dayo Mohalla Burma shell, Abdul Jabbar and Punhal Shaikh Street UC-15 Old Sukkur District Sukkur. Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S Saqib S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S Shahzado M/S Ali Builder Rasheed & Mahar Co 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes
5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria
6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant t Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the author Yes Yes Yes 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by tl Yes Yes Yes
11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad rw ar) (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highwa, Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of Paver Block Flooring & Drain at Dayo Mohalla Burma shell, Abdul Jabbar and Punhal Shaikh Street UC-15 Old Sukkur District Sukkur.
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 Estimate Sanctioned by Supenntending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Shahzado Mahar M/S Ali Builder M/S Sagib Rasheed & Co GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR @ 20.10%, above the Schedule "B" e 20.45% above the Schedule "B" @ 20.95% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1569905 00 1569905 1569905 1569905
Non-Schedule Items Rs -
Cartage Rs 291095 00 31555' 321046 328895
Ceiling Rs 42454 00
Total: Rs. 1903454.00 1885456 1890951 1898800 Rs. 1903500.00 E/COST 1903500 1903500 1903500 -18044 -12549 -4700 0.95% Below the E/Cost 0.66% Below the E/Cost 0.25% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Shahzado Mahar Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 18.85,456/- (Rupees. Eighteen Lac Eighty Five Thousand Four Hundred Fifty Six) Only at 20.10% above the schedule "B" items and being 0.95% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sancti ned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul(, 111 %Iwo ) (Absan Ali ('hohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executive Engineer E ecutive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highs a Dis ision ealth Enginttring Division Development Department Sukkur(\ II:tither) Sukkur (('hairrnan) Karachi (Member)
• BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 11
1. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer, PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Paver Block Flooring & Drains Abdul Oadir Jamali Mohala by Pass Road UC-26 Dargah Bedal Fakir Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New 0..11.1.....
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 . 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection 1-..... 1 M/S R.A Construction Company 19.27% Above 1 st Lowest 1.13% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Shamim & Brothers 19.88% Above 2"4 Lowest 0.62% Rejected Being High Saving
M/S Mehran Machinery Store 20.30% Above 3"I Lowest 0.27% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Ab s ul ' lani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highw = Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) • • TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Paver Block Flooring & Drains Abdul Qadir Jamali Mohala by Pass Road UC-26 Dargah Bedal Fakir Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur. Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S R.A M/S Mehran S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S Shamim & Construction Machinery Brothers Company Store 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax ' Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Si mill Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant i Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the author Yes Yes Yes 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by tl Yes Yes Yes 1 I Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux J'arwar) (Ab ul ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executi Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highw. Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department S (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of Paver Block Flooring & Drains Abdul Oadir Jamali Mohala by Pass Road UC- 26 Dargah Bedal Fakir Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
References. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S R.A Construction Company M/S Shamim & Brothers M/S Mehran Machinery Store GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 19.27% above the Schedule "B" @ 19.88% above the Schedule "B" @ 20.30% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 2441231 00 2441231 2441231 2441231
Non-Schedule Items Rs - - -
Cartage Rs 450528 00 470425 485317 495570
Ceiling Rs 53081 00
Total: Rs. 2944840.00 2911656 2926548 2936801 Rs. 2944800.00 E/COST 2944800 2944800 2944800 -33144 -18252 -7999 1.13% Below the E/Cost 0.62% Below the E/Cost 0.27% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S R.A Construction Company Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 29,11,656/- (Rupees. Twenty Nine Lac Eleven Thousand Six Hundred Fifty Six) Only at 19.27% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.13% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of r heck / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhammad Bux rwar) (Abdul Gil' ni %Iwo) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executive .ngincer Executive En weer Public Health Engg: & Rural I lighn ay Dis ision rub)c " ealth,E Engine ing Di‘ision Development Department Sukkur ( !ember) Sukkur (( hairkan) , Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 12
I. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Paver Block Flooring and Drains at Village Gul Chohan UC-26 Bedalpur Sukkur
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 0 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection
1 M/S RA Construction Company 19.75% Above 1$1 Lowest 1.03% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Hassan Enterprises 20.10% Above 2nd Lowest 0.74% Rejected Being High Saving
M/S Ansari & Co. 20.80% Above 3rd Lowest 0.16% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul Gh i Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan Section Officer (Tech) Executive ngineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) • TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION 121,: l'O IZT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Paver Block Flooring and Drains at Village Gu I Chohan UC-26 Bedalpur Sukkur Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S RA S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S Hassan M/S Ansari Construction Enterprises & Co. Company 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached ' Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the author Yes Yes Yes 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by ti Yes Yes Yes 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Jarvvar) (Abdul Gh i Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan Section Officer (Tech) Executive ngineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highway ivision Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur ( ember) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of Paver Block Flooring and Drains at Village Gul Chohan UC-26 Bedalpur Sukkur
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost MIS RA Construction Company M/S Hassan Enterprises M/S Ansari & Co. GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 19.75% above the Schedule "B" @ 20.10% above the Schedule "B" @ 20.80% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 2390090 00 2390090 2390090 2390090
Non-Schedule Items Rs - -
Cartage Rs 455759 00 472043 480408 497139
Ceiling Rs 45926 00
Total: Rs. 2891775.00 2862133 2870498 2887229 Rs. 2891800.00 E/COST 2891800 2891800 2891800 -29667 -21302 -4571 1.03% Below the E/Cost 0.74% Below the E/Cost 0.16% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S R.A Construction Company Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 28,62,133/- (Rupees. Twenty Eight Lac Sixty Two Thousand One Hundred Thirty three) Only at 19.75% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.03% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
\\g\( (Muhammad Bux arwar) (Abdul (ilia i Alm)) (Ahsan Section Officer (Tech) Exccuti‘c .ngincer Executise Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural )isision Publ. Ilealth Engineeting Divisi n Development Department Sukkur I lember) Sukkur (('hair R' Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 13
1. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Paver Blocks floorine & Drains at Burira Colony UC-20 Site Area Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection r.,.. 1 M/S Al-Hassan Electric & Civil work 22.00% Above I' Lowest 1.21% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Adeel Ahmed Construction 22.88% Above 2nd Lowest 0.50% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Saqib Rasheed & Co. 23.20% Above 3rd Lowest 0.24% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (Abdul G ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Choha Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highw y Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Paver Blocks flooring & Drains at Burira Colony UC-20 Site Area Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S Al-Hassan M/S Adeel M/S Saqib S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria Electric & Civil Ahmed Rasheed & work Construction Co. 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) Yes Yes Yes 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant fielc Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the authorize( Yes Yes Yes 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by the r Yes Yes Yes 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (Ab s ul ani Abro) (Ahsan Section Officer (Tech) Executi e Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural High ay Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of Paver Blocks flooring & Drains at Burira Colony UC-20 Site Area Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost MIS Al-Hassan Electric & Civil work M/S Adeel Ahmed Construction M/S Saqib Rasheed & Co. GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 22.00% above the Schedule "B" @ 22.88% above the Schedule "B" @ 23.20% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 3911323 00 3911323 3911323 3911323
Non-Schedule Items Rs -
Cartage Rs 785165 00 860491 894911 907427
Ceiling Rs 133868 00
Total: Rs. 4830356.00 4771814 4806234 4818750 Rs. 4830400.00 E/COST 4830400 4830400 4830400 -58586 -24166 -11650 1.21% Below the E/Cost 0.50% Below the E/Cost 0.24% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Al-Hassan Electric & Civil Work Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 47,71,814/- (Rupees. Forty Seven Lac Seventy One Thousand Eight Hundred Fourteen) Only at 22.00% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.21% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended or favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
L
(Muhammad Bux .larwar) (Abdul G ani Alm)) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executi c Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highly v Div ision Public Ilcaith Engineeri ii; Division Development Department Sukk ( \knitter) Sukkur (Chairtn Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 14
I. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer, PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Widening of drains at Lateef Park, Kiri Ouarter, Gora Gali and Mangi Mohalla and Narishala School UC-14 Old Sukkur District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: alitm 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 3 Nos. 10.Bids Rejected: NIL 11.Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection d-.,... I M/S Ali Baba Mahar Enterprises 18.85% Above I g Lowest 0.95% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Soomra Brothers 19.30% Above 2nd Lowest 0.57% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S DKC Enterprises 19.88% Above 3rd Lowest 0.09% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux rwar) (Abdul G ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Suldcu (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS OUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Widening of drains at Lateef Park, Kiri Quarter, Gora Caliand Mangi Mohalla and Nariihala School UC-14 Old Sukkur District Sukkur. Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S Ali Baba S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S Soomra M/S DKC Mahar Brothers Enterprises Enterprises 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the author Yes Yes Yes 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by tl Yes Yes Yes 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux J ar) (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highw Division Public I lealth Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
•
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Widening of drains at Lateef Park, Kiri Quarter, Gora Gali and Mangi Mohalla and Narishala School UC-14 Old Sukkur District Sukkur.
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by: Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Ali Baba Mahar Enterprises M/S Soomra Brothers M/S DKC Enterprises GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 18.85% above the Schedule "B" @ 19.30% above the Schedule "B" @ 19.88% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1606867 00 1606867 1606867 1606867
Non-Schedule Items Rs -
Cartage Rs 284598 00 302894 310125 319445
Ceiling Rs 36510 00
Total: Rs. 1927975.00 1909761 1916992 1926312 Rs. 1928000.00 E/COST 1928000 1928000 1928000 -18239 -11008 -1688 0.95% Below the E/Cost 0.57% Below the E/Cost 0.09% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Ali Baba Mahar Enterprises Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 19,09,761/- (Rupees. Nineteen Lac Nine Thousand Seven Hundred Sixty One) Only at 18.85% above the schedule "B" items and being 0.95% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor ill (Muhammad Bux rwar) (Abdul Gh• ni ‘bro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer ( ech) Executive ngincer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Ilighwa Division Publi• jlealth Engineek0 Division Development Department Sukkur (N)ember) Sukkur ((hairm3u) Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 15
1.Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of CC Drainage Scheme and Surface Drains Village Miandad Khoso and Village Alan Khoso Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10.Bids Rejected: NIL 11.Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection r".,.. 1 M/S New Royal Enterprises 19.45% Above 1st Lowest 1.40% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S DKC Enterprises 20.90% Above fd Lowest 0.41% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Am & MJ Builder 21.34% Above 3rd Lowest 0.11% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul G ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) ExecutivTf Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highway Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of CC Drainage Scheme and Surface Drains Village Miandad Khoso and Village Alan Khoso Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name
S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S New Royal M/S DKC M/S Am & Enterprises Enterprises MJ Builder
1 Registration with PEC (if Application) Yes Yes Yes 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant I Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the author Yes Yes Yes 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by tl Yes Yes Yes II Qualified / disqualified , Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad 1u la var) (Abdul t ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Execut e Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highway Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 24-02-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 27-02-2017 Construction of CC Drainage Scheme and Surface Drains Village Miandad Khoso and Village Alan Khoso Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur
References: TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 Estimate Sanctioned by Chief Engineer Public Health Engineering Department. Government of Sindh, Sukkur vide No. DB/DWE/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S New Royal Enterprises M/S DKC Enterprises M/S Am & MJ Builder GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTC R GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 19.45% above the Schedule "B" @ 20.90% above the Schedule "B" @ 21.34% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 9794436 00 9794436 9794436 9794436
Non-Schedule Items Rs 2418000 00 2418000 2418000 2418000
Cartage Rs 993043 00 1905018 2047037 2090133
Ceiling Rs 1112044 00
Total: Rs. 14317566.00 14117454 14259473 14302569 Rs. 14318000.00 E/COST 14318000 14318000 14318000 -200546 -58527 -15431 1.40% Below the E/Cost 0.41% Below the E/Co':t 0.11% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S New Royal Enterprises Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 1,41,17,454/- (Rupees. One Crore Forty One Lac Seventeen Thousand Four Hundred Fifty Four) Only at 19.45% above the schedule "B" items and being 1 40% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion Hence duly reco mended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest rnntrartnr
(Muhammad Siux Jan,yar) (Abdul ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali ( 'holian) Section Officer (Tech) Executhe ingineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highs. ision Pub! ealth Engineerity Disision Development Department Sukkur Member) Sukkur (('hairm) Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 16
1. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer, PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Paver Block Flooring & Drain at Bhosa Lane Gole Takri Mohalla, Mahar Mohalla, Shakh Mohalla and Abbasi Mohalla and adjacent ...I AT.. A TT!, 1 ,1 %T.....
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 3 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection r--,. 1 M/S Muhammad Usman & 18.90% Above I" Lowest 1.02% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Builders Saving award of work
2 M/S AMD Construction 19.27% Above 2nd Lowest 0.71% Rejected Being High Saving
' M/S DKC Enterprises 19.90% Above 3rd Lowest 0.18% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bu Jarwar) (Abdul Gh tni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Paver Block Flooring & Drain at Bhosa Lane Gole Takri Mohalla, Mahar Mohalla, Shakh Mohalla and Abbasi Mohalla and adjacent street of Ward No. 4 UC-17 New Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name
S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S Muhammad M/S AMID M/S DKC Usman & Builders Construction Enterprises
1 Registration with PEC (if Application) , N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant I Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the author Yes Yes Yes 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by tl Yes Yes Yes 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
ja ar) (Muhammad Bux (Abdfil G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
•
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Construction of Paver Block Flooring & Drain at Bhosa Lane Gole Takri Mohalla, Mahar Date of opening 06-03-2017 Mohalla, Shakh Mohalla and Abbasi Mohalla and adjacent street of Ward No. 4 UC-17 New Pind District Sukkur.
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Muhammad Usman & Builders M/S AMD Construction M/S DKC Enterprises GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR @ 18.90% above the Schedule "B" @ 19.27% above the Schedule "B" e 19.90% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 3073613 00 3073613 3073613 3073613
Non-Schedule Items Rs - -
Cartage Rs 558025 00 580913 592285 611649
Ceiling Rs 60436 00
Total: Rs. 3692074.00 3654526 3665898 3685262 Rs. 3692000.00 E/COST 3692000 3692000 3692000 -37474 -26102 -6738 1.02% Below the E/Cost 0.71% Below the E/Cost 0.18% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Muhammad Usman & Builders Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 36,54,526/- (Rupees. Thirty Six Lac Fifty Four Thousand Five Hundred Twenty Six) Only at 18.90% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.02% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the woric order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhamma arwar) (Abdul (.li; ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer ( ech) Exceuti% Ingincer Executive En ineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Ilighway )ivision Pith I •%)• lealth Engince Division Development Department Sukkur I ember) Stikkur (Chai j Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 17
I. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1 066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Paver Block Flooring and Surface Drains at Awan Mohalla Al-Madina Colony Sukkur
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report SS/ Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder ' Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection e,.... . I M/S Saqib Rasheed & Co. 19.40% Above i Lowest 1.06% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S DKC Enterprises 19.80% Above 2"d Lowest 0.73% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Muhammad Usman & 20.40% Above yd Lowest 0.23% Rejected Being Highest Builder Saving
(Muhammad Bux Ja ) (Abdul G ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv t Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highly Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) •
TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Paver Block Flooring and Surface Drains at Awan Mohalla Al-Madina Colony Sukkur
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S M/S Sagib S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S DKC Muhammad Rasheed & Co. Enterprises Usman & 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) Yes Yes Yes 2 NTN Certificate ' Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the author Yes Yes Yes 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by tl Yes Yes Yes 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (Abdul ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executi e Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural High y Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
•
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work, Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of Paver Block Flooring and Surface Drains at Awan Mohalla Al-Madina Colony Sukkur
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Sagib Rasheed & Co. M/S DKC Enterprises M/S Muhammad Usman & Builder GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR @ 19.40% above the Schedule "B" © 19.80% above the Schedule "B" e 20.40% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 3993934 00 3993934 3993934 3993934
Non-Schedule Items Rs -
Cartage Rs 754162 00 774823 790799 814763
Ceiling Rs 71745 00
Total: Rs. 4819841.00 4768757 4784733 4808697 Rs. 4820000.00 E/COST 4820000 4820000 4820000 -51243 -35267 -11303 1.06% Below the E/Cost 0.73% Below the E/Cost 0.23% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Saqib Rasheed & Co. Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 47,68.757/- (Rupees. Forty Seven Lac Sixty Eight Thousand Seven Hundred Fifty Seven) Only at 19.40% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.06% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhammad B Jarwar) th ul ani Abro) (Ahsan li ( hohan) Section Officer (Tech) ENccuti% Engineer FAecutise Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highs% y Dis ision PuhFcW 1calth Enginccrin Division Development Department Sukk r (Member) Sukkur (Chairm Karachi (Member)
131D EVALUATION REPORT ' Sr # 18
1.Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-l48/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Paver Block Flooring and Surface Drains at Jamali Mohalla Barrage Colony Sukkur
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: N os. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10.Bids Rejected: NIL 11.Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection f-..... I Mr. Ashique Ali Abbasi 16.70% Above lg Lowest 2.08% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 MIS Awais & Brothers 17.65% Above 2nd Lowest 1.28% Rejected Being High Saving
3 MIS .\meer Enterprises 18.16% Above 3gl Lowest 0.85% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux rwar) (Abdul rani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Choh n) Section Officer (Tech) Executi e Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & High ay Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) • TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Paver Block Flooring and Surface Drains at Jamali Mohalla Barrage Colony Sukkur Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name
S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria Mr. Ashique Ali M/S Awais & M/S Ameer Abbasi Brothers Enterprises
1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant I Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the author Yes Yes Yes 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by tl Yes Yes Yes 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bd1x Jai'war) (Ab • ul G ani Abro) (Ahsan A n) Section Officer (Tech) Executi Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highw y Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of Paver Block Flooring and Surface Drains at Jamali Mohalla Barrage Colony Sukkur
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost Mr. Ashique Ali Abbasi M/S Awais & Brothers M/S Ameer Enterprises GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR @ 16.70% above the Schedule "B" @ 17.65% above the Schedule "B" __e 18.16% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 2414864 00 2414864 2414864 2414864
Non-Schedule Items Rs - - -
Cartage Rs 422551 00 403282 426223 438539
Ceiling Rs 40628 00
Total: Rs. 2878043.00 2818146 2841087 2853403 Rs. 2878000.00 E/COST 2878000 2878000 2878000 -59854 -36913 -24597 2.08% Below the E/Cost 1.28% Below the E/Cost 0.85% Below the ElCost
The precentage rate quoted by Mr. Ashique Ali Abbasi Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 28.18,146/- (Rupees. Twenty Eight Lac Eighteen Thousand One Hundred Forty Six) Only at 16.70% above the schedule "B" items and being 2 08% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
\t AI
(Muhammad Bux arwar) (Abdul G ni Abro) (Ahsan hohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executive Engineer Executise Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Dighss a Division Pubrealth Engineerbignivision Development Department Sukkur Member) Sukkur (Chairm* Karachi (Member)
BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 19
1. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer, PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Paver Block Flooring and Surface Drains at Oad Moltalla Barrage Colony Sukkur
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection r".. I M/S Z.A Qureshi 16.00% Above Is' Lowest 2.31% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 Mr. Ghulam Rasool Narejo 18.20% Above 2" Lowest 0.45% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Hassan Enterprises 18.65% Above 3rd Lowest 0.07% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Buz mar) (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer ( ch) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highw y Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member)
TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Paver Block Flooring and Surface Drains at Oad Mohalla Barrage Colony Sukkur Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name
S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria Mr. Ghulam M/S Hassan M/S Z.A Qureshi Rasool Narejo Enterprises
1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant I Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the author Yes Yes Yes 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by tl Yes Yes Yes 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux J ar) (Abdul Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executive gineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highway ivision Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
to
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of Paver Block Flooring and Surface Drains at Oad Mohalla Barrage Colony Sukkur
References. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost MIS Z.A Qureshi Mr. Ghulam Rasool Narejo M/S Hassan Enterprises GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 16.00% above the Schedule "B" @ 18.20% above the Schedule "B" @ 18.65% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 2415408 00 2415408 2415408 2415408
Non-Schedule Items Rs - - - -
Cartage Rs 419192 00 386465 439604 450474
Ceiling Rs 32925 00
Total: Rs. 2867525.00 2801873 2855012 2865882 Rs. 2868000.00 E/COST 2868000 2868000 2868000 -66127 -12988 -2118 2.31% Below the E/Cost 0.45% Below the E/Cost 0.07% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Z.A Qureshi Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 28,01.873/- (Rupees. Twenty Eight Lac One Thousand Eight Hundred Seventy Three) Only at 16.00% above the schedule "B" items and being 2.31% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhammad Bux J rwar) Gha i Abro) (Ahsan Section Officer (Tech) F:vccuti.c ngineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural I ligh‘. hvision c lealth Enginee Division Development Department Sukkur ( !ember) Sukkur (Chair --' Karachi (Members BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 20
1. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer, PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Paver Block Flooring and Surface Drains at various streets of Barrage Colony Sukkur
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 9_32•1os. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 0 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection 1"....i. I M/S Niaz Ali 16.85% Above 1 u Lowest 1.81% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Hassan Enterprises 18.30% Above rd Lowest 0.59% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S DKC Enterprises 18.98% Above 3rd Lowest 0.02% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux Ja (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highw Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) • TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Paver Block Flooring and Surface Drains at various streets of Barrage Colony Sukkur
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name
S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S Hassan M/S DKC M/S Niaz Ali Enterprises Enterprises
1 Registration with PEC (if Application) Yes Yes Yes 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board' Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant 1 Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the author Yes Yes Yes 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by tl Yes Yes Yes 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul G ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
• COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue: 03-03-2017 Name of Work: Date of opening: 06-03-2017 Construction of Paver Block Flooring and Surface Drains at various streets of Barrage Colony Sukkur
References: TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by: Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No. DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Niaz Ali M/S Hassan Enterprises M/S DKC Enterprises GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR @ 16.85% above the Schedule "B" @ 18.30% above the Schedule "B" @ 18.98% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs. 4016479.00 4016479 4016479 4016479
Non-Schedule Items Rs. - - - -
Cartage Rs. 700436.00 676777 735016 762328 Ceiling Rs. 62878.00
Total: Rs. 4779793.00 4693256 4751495 4778807 Rs. 4779800.00 E/COST 4779800 4779800 4779800 -86544 -28305 -993 1.81% Below the E/Cost 0.59% Below the EJCost 0.02% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Niaz Ali Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 46,93,256/- (Rupees. Forty Six Lac Ninety Three Thousand Two Hundred Fifty Six) Only at 16.85% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.81% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul Gha i Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executive F gineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highway ivision Publi V.I 'ealth Engineehng Division Development Department Sukkur(? ember) Sukkur (Chair Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr# 21
I. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work Item: Construction of Paver Block Flooring & Surface Drains at Jamali Mohalla and various streets of Adam Shah Colony Sukkur District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 9.3 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report SW Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder , Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection a-..... I M/S Rashidi Enterprises 15.65% Above Ig Lowest 2.80% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Muhammad Shoaib & 18.39% Above 2"d Lowest 0.49% Rejected Being High Brothers Saving
3 MIS Hassan Enterprises I 8.89% Above 3'd Lowest 0.07% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux rwar) (Abdul Chan' bro) (Ahsan Ali Choh n Section Officer (Tech) Executive Engipeer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highway Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member)
TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Paver Block Flooring & Surface Drains at Jamali Mohalla and various streets of Adam Shah Colony Sukkur District Sukkur. Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure - Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S M/S Rashidi M/S Hassan S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria Muhammad Enterprises Enterprises Shoaib & 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) Yes Yes Yes 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the author Yes Yes Yes 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by tl Yes Yes Yes 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux lar)i (AbdulGhani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executive Engi4eer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highway Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
•
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue: 03-03-2017 Name of Work: Date of opening: 06-03-2017 Construction of Paver Block Flooring & Surface Drains at Jamali Mohalla and various streets of Adam Shah Colony Sukkur District Sukkur.
References: TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 Estimate Sanctioned by: Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No. DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Rashidi Enterprises M/S Muhammad Shoaib & Brothers M/S Hassan Enterprises GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR @ 15.65% above the Schedule "B" @ 18.39% above the Schedule "B" @ 18.89% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs. 4043899.00 4043899 4043899 4043899
Non-Schedule Items Rs. - - - -
Cartage Rs. 704475.00 632870 743673 763893
Ceiling Rs. 62878.00
Total: Rs. 4811252.00 4676769 4787572 4807792 Rs. 4811300.00 E/COST 4811300 4811300 4811300 -134531 -23728 -3508 2.80% Below the E/Cost 0.49% Below the E/Cost 0.07% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Rashidi Enterprises Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 46,76,769/- (Rupees. Forty Six Lac Seventy Six Thousand Seven Hundred Sixty Nine) Only at 15.65% above the schedule "B" items and being 2.80% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work o.-der to the lowest contractor.
\\\ (Muhammad Bu\arwar) (Abdul (Mani A (Ahsan Ali Choh ) Section Officer (Tech) Executive Engine r Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highway Divisio Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 22
I. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of CC Paver Block Flooring & Drains at Police Line, Muehul Colony No. 1 & 2 Adjacent Street of Ward No. 3 UC-17 New Pind Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: nhal 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: Dihism 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection l',...i. I Mr. Nazir Ahmed kalwar 18.00% Above Is` Lowest 1.60% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Veeru Mal Enterprises 19.25% Above fd Lowest 0.56% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Nippon Builders 19.88% Above 3rd Lowest 0.03% Rejected Being Highest Saving
\•\ t (Muhammad Bux J rwar) (Abdul G ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highw Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of CC Paver Block Flooring & Drains at Police Line, Mughul Colony No. 1 & 2 Adjacent Street of Ward No. 3 UC-17 New Pind Sukkur. Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name
S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria Mr. Nazir Ahmed M/S Veeru Mal M/S Nippon kalwar Enterprises Builders
1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the author Yes Yes Yes 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by tl Yes Yes Yes 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad ux Jarwar) (Abdul G • ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv; Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highw., Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
•
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of CC Paver Block Flooring & Drains at Police Line, Mughul Colony No. 1 & 2 Adjacent Street of Ward No. 3 UC-17 New Pind Sukkur.
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost Mr. Nazir Ahmed kalwar M/S Veeru Mal Enterprises M/S Nippon Builders GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 18.00% above the Schedule "B" @ 19.25% above the Schedule "B" @ 19.88% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 2408928 00 2408928 2408928 2408928
Non-Schedule Items Rs
Cartage Rs 425287 00 433607 463719 478895
Ceiling Rs 54452 00
Total: Rs. 2888667.00 2842535 2872647 2887823 Rs. 2888700.00 E/COST 2888700 2888700 2888700 -46165 -16053 -877 1.60% Below the E/Cost 0.56% Below the E/Cost 0.03% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by Mr. Nazir Ahmed Kalwar Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 28,42,535/- (Rupees. Twenty Eight Lac Forty Two Thousand Five Hundred Thirty Five) Only at 18.00% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.60% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour o check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul ( ani .‘bro) (Ahsan Ali C ohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executi c Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural iv Division l'u1)1i ealth Enginee g Division Development Department Sukk r (Member) Sukkur (Chai Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr#23
I. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-I48/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Paver Block Flooring and Drains at various streets of UC-23 Sukkur
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection 1-.... I M/S Adeel Ahmed Construction I 8.00% Above 1" Lowest 1.05% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for & Co. Saving award of work
2 M/S DKC Enterprises 18.60% Above 2nd Lowest 0.55% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Hassan Enterprises 19.20% Above 3n1Lowest 0.05% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux Ja var) (Abdul G ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Paver Block Flooring and Drains at various streets of UC-23 Sukkur
_ Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S Adeel Ahmed S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S DKC M/S Hassan Construction & Enterprises Enterprises Co. 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) Yes Yes Yes 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes
3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant I Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes
8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the author Yes Yes Yes 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by tl Yes Yes Yes 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
tit (Muhammad Bux\41v/ar) (Ab ul G ani Abro) (Ahsan A i Cho an) Section Officer (T h) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highw. Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 24-02-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 27-02-2017 Construction of Paver Block Flooring and Drains at various streets of UC-23 Sukkur
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No. DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Adeel Ahmed Construction & Co. M/S DKC Enterprises M/S Hassan Enterprises GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 18.00% above the Schedule "B" @ 18.60% above the Sch,adule "B" @ 19.20% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 8085871 00 8085871 8085871 8085871
Non-Schedule Items Rs -
Cartage Rs 1454664 00 1455457 1503972 1552487
Ceiling Rs 102111 00
Total: Rs. 9642646.00 9541328 9589843 9638358 Rs. 9643000.00 E/COST 9643000 9643000 9643000 -101672 -53157 -4642 1.05% Below the E/Cost 0.55% Below the E/Cost 0.05% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Adeel Ahmed Construction & Co. Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 95,41,328/- (Rupees. Ninety Five Lac Forty One Thousand Three Hundred Twenty Eight) Only at 18.00% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.05% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended f. favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul (.h ni %brio (Ahsan Ali Choha ) Section Officer (Tech) Executi% c ngineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Division Pub*ckl Health Engine ing Division Development Department Sukkur /ember) Sukkur (Cha an) Karachi (Member) 131D EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 24
1. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Drainage a Village Alas Khoso Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection 1^...* I Mr. Mazhar Hussain Memon 16.75% Above 15t Lowest .3.07% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Zulfigar & Co. 19.34% Above 2nd Lowest 0.92% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Adeel Ahmed Construction 19.84% Above 3"I Lowest 0.50% Rejected Being Highest Saving
( (Muhammad Bu rwar) (Abdul Gh ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Choha ) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv = Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
. Name of Work: Construction of Drainage (d Village Alas Khoso Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S Adeel S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria Mr. Mazhar M/S Zulfiqar & Ahmed Hussain Memon Co. Construction 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration , Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes
Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant I Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Choha ) Section Officer (Tech) Executi e Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural 1-lighw. y Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of Drainage @ Village Alas Khoso Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost Mr. Mazhar Hussain Memon M/S Zulfiqar & Co. M/S Adeel Ahmed Construction GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR @ 16.75% above the Schedule "B" e 19.34% above the Schedule "B" e 19.84% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1623344.00 1623344 1623344 1623344
Non-Schedule Items Rs
Cartage Rs 284202 00 271910 313955 322071
Ceiling Rs 47658.00
Total: Rs. 1955204.00 1895254 1937299 1945415 Rs. 1955200.00 E/COST 1955200 1955200 1955200 -59946 -17901 -9785 3.07% Below the E/Cost 0.92% Below the E/Cost 0.50% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by Mr. Mazhar Hussain Memon Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 18,95,254/- (Rupees. Eighteen Lac Ninety Five Thousand Two Hundred Fifty Four) Only at 16.75% above the schedule "B" items and being 3.07% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor
(Muhammad rwar) toklidul (:ha i Abro) (Ahsan .k i tolian Section Officer ( ech) Executive I nginecr Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural )isision Public lealth Engin ig Di% ision Development Department Sukkur ( !ember) Sukkur (Chili and Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 25
1. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer, PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Drainage at Village Pisand Khan Khoso Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL I 1. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection
1 Mr. Bagh Ali Buriro 21.85% Above Is` Lowest 1.47% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Ali Enterprises 22.70% Above 2nd Lowest 0.79% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Saqib Rasheed & Co. 23.00% Above 3rd Lowest 0.54% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux Janv r) (Abdul Gh ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executive Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Drainage at Village Pisand Khan Khoso Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name Saqib S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria Mr. Bagh Ali M/S Ali RashM/S eed & Buriro Enterprises Co. 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant I Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul G 44ni Abro) (AhsanA o an) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv= Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highwa, Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
•
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of Drainage at Village P sand Khan Khoso Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
References. TC/G.148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 Estimate Sanctioned by: Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Bagh Ali Buriro M/S Ali Enterprises M/S Saqib Rasheed & Co. GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 21.85% above the Schedule "B" @ 22.70% above the Schedule "B" @ 23.00% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1561607 00 1561607 1561607 1561607
Non-Schedule Items Rs - -- -
Cartage Rs 311657 00 341211 354485 359170
Ceiling Rs 58039 00
Total: Rs. 1931303.00 1902818 1916092 1920777 Rs. 1931300.00 E/COST 1931300 1931300 1931300 -28482 -15208 -10523 1.47% Below the E/Cost 0.79% Below the E/Cost 0.54% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Bagh Ali Buriro Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 19,02,818/- (Rupees. Nineteen Lac Two Thousand Eight Hundred Eighteen) Only at 21.85% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.47% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctio ed & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhammad u rvvar) (Abdul (ili• ni Abro) (Alison Ali thohan) Section Officer Tech) Executi% e Ingineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural High a Di% ision Publ.k • Health Engineering Di% ision Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur Whairiiiiint Karachi (Member) •
BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 26
I. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer, PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Drainage / Disposal at Allah Abad Colony UC-20 Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 27/02/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Re ort S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection r"... 1 M/S Agha Gul 1-lassan Khan 24.10% Above 10 Lowest 0.98% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Hassan Enterprises 24.30% Above 2n4 Lowest 0.82% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Relient Trade Link 24.86°/0 Above 3rd Lowest 0.37% Rejected Being llighest Saving
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Cho an) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) • TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Drainage / Disposal at Allah Abad Colony UC- 20 Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name
S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S Agha Gul M/S Hassan M/S Relient Hassan Khan Enterprises Trade Link
1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executi Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highw Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work. Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of Drainage / Disposal at Allah Abad Colony UC-20 Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No. DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Agha GuI Hassan Khan M/S Hassan Enterprises M/S Relient Trade Link GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR @ 24.10% above the Schedule "B" @ 24.30% above the Schedule "B" . _ .2 24.86% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 2338094 00 2338094 2338094 2338094
Non-Schedule Items Rs -
Cartage Rs 497913 00 563481 568157 581250
Ceiling Rs 94334 00
Total: Rs. 2930341.00 2901575 2906251 2919344 Rs. 2930300.00 E/COST 2930300 2930300 2930300 -28725 -24049 -10956 0.98% Below the E/Cost 0.82% Below the E/Cost 0.37% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Agha Gul Hassan Khan Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 29.15.575/- (Rupees. Twenty Nine Lac One Thousand Five Hundred Seventy Five) Only at 24.10% above the Schedule "B" items and being 0.98% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (Abdul (;ha i %Imo (Ahsan Ali Chohan Section Officer (Tech) Executi‘c nginccr ExecutiN e Engkncer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highn ision Publ'r calth Engineering 11)i% ision Development Department Sukkur em her) Sukkur ((hairnoin) Karachi (Member) o
HID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 27
1. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Paver Surface Drains at Dildas Shah Colony Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report SO Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection r,.... 1 M/S Abdul Rasool Construction 17.50% Above lst Lowest 1.05% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Co. Saving award of work
2 M/S Rohri Enterprises 19.10% Above rd Lowest 0.47% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Saqib Rasheed & Co. 19.46% Above 3rd Lo‘% est 0.16% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux J ar) (Abdul Gh ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Choha Section Officer (Tech) Executive ngineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) • TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Paver Surface Drains at Dildas Shah Colony Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S Saqib S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S Abdul Rasool M/S Rohri Rasheed & Construction Co. Enterprises Co. 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) . N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes
3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes
4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria
6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant t Yes Yes Yes
7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes
8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Buxvar) (Abdul Gh ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
•
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work. Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of Paver Surface Drains at Dildas Shah Colony Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Abdul Rasool Construction Co. M/S Rohri Enterprises M/S Sagib Rasheed & Co. GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR @ 17.50% above the Schedule "B" e 19.10% above the Schedu'e "8" @ 19.46% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1235203 00 1235203 1235203 1235203
Non-Schedule Items Rs - - -
Cartage Rs 215450 00 216161 235924 240371
Ceiling Rs 27332 00
Total: Rs. 1477985.00 1451364 1471127 1475574 Rs. 1478000.00 E/COST 1478000 1478000 1478000 -26636 -6873 -2426 t80% Below the E/Cost 0.47% Below the E/Cost 0.16% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Abdul Rasool Construction Co Government Contractor amounting to Rs, 14,51.364/- (Rupees. Fourteen Lac Fifty One Thousand Three Hundred Sixty Four) Only at 17,50% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.80% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of eck / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) ni kbro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan Section Officer (Tech) Executhe Engineer Esecutis c Enkneer Public Health Engg: & Rural I ligh‘s a Dis ision Publiilealth Engineer-lug, Dis ision Development Department Sukkur Nlember) Sukkur It Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 28
1.Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer, PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Water Supply for Bilawal Colony UC-20 Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / . Cost Estimated Rejection C.,.4 I Mr. Ajlal Mustafa 18.00% Above 1st Lowest 1.85% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 MIS Adeel Ahmed Construction 19.60% Above 2nd Lowest 0.63% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Zulfigar & Co. 20.00% Above 3"I Lowest 0.01% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux Jarw (Abdul Gha i Abro) (Ahsan A >< C oh ) Section Officer (Tech) Executive. ngineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highway ivision Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur ember) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Water Supply for Bilawal Colony UC-20 Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S Adeel S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S Zulfigar Mr. Ajlal Mustafa Ahmed & Co. Construction 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) , N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant I Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executi e Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highway Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
•
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of Water Supply for Bilawal Colony UC-20 Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost Mr. Ajlal Mustafa M/S Adeel Ahmed Construction M/S Zulfigar & Co. GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 18.00% above the Schedule "B" @ 19.60% above the Schedule "B" @ 20.00% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1771153 00 1771153 1771153 1771153
Non-Schedule Items Rs - - -
Cartage Rs 3801 00 318808 347146 354231
Ceiling Rs 354460 00
Total: Rs. 2129414.00 2089961 2118299 2125384 Rs. 2129400.00 E/COST 2129400 2129400 2129400 -39439 -11101 -4016 1.85% Below the E/Cost 0.52% Below the E/Cost 0.19% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by Mr Ajlal Mustafa Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 20.89.961/- (Rupees. Twenty Lac Eighty Nine Thousand Nine Hundred Sixty One) Only at 18.00% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.85% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctio d & issue the work order to the lowest contractor
(Muhammad Bux Jalte ) (Abdul (:h i Abro) (Ahsan kli ('hohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executive .ngineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural )ivision Publlealth Engine4. g Division Development Department Sukkur( 'ember) Sukkur (Chai Karachi (Member) •
BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 29
I. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of CC Blocks & Drainage at Daya Goth Rohri District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by Ahe Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection 1"..... I M/S A. Hafeez Pathan 18.07% Above 151 Lowest 2.01% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Qalandar & Brothers 19.87% Above 2nd Lowest 0.52% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Hassan Enterprises 20.40% Above 3"1 Lowest 0.08% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux‘\\ Ja nar) (Abdul Ch ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv ► Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member)
TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of CC Blocks & Drainage at Daya Goth Rohri District Sukkur. Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name
S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S A. Hafeez M/S Qalandar M/S Hassan Pathan & Brothers Enterprises
1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Oualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Buz 3a r) (Abdul hani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Execut e Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural High ay Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) •
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of CC Blocks & Drainage at Daya Goth Rohri District Sukkur.
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S A. Hafeez Pathan M/S Qalandar & Brothers M/S Hassan Enterprises GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 18.07% above the Schedule "B" @ 19.87% above the Schedule "B" @ 20.40% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1579373 00 1579373 1579373 1579373
Non-Schedule Items Rs -
Cartage Rs 296441 00 285393 313821 322192
Ceiling Rs 27453 00
Total: Rs. 1903267.00 1864766 1893194 1901565 Rs. 1903000.00 E/COST 1903000 1903000 1903000 -38234 -9806 -1435 2.01% Below the E/Cost 0.52% Below the E/Cost 0.08% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S A. Hafeez Pathan Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 18,64,766/- (Rupees. Eighteen Lac Sixty Four Thousand Seven Hundred Sixty Six) Only at 18.07% above the schedule "B" items and being 2.01% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion Hence duly recommended for favour of eck / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhammai4 111 rwar) (Abdul (a). ni Aim)) (Ahsan tohan Section Officer (Tech) Executive Inginecr Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural I I ighss a Division rubl )ealth Engineetting Disision Development Department Sukkur Member) Sukkur ((haim:Pin) Karachi (Memberl BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 30
I. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of CC Blocks & Draina2e system Ward- 3 Rohri District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: ' Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection re.,.. I M/S FT Enterprises 19.24% Above 1s` Lowest 1.05% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 Mr. Bahadur Ali Thaheem I 9 ()(,''0 Above rd Lowest 0.70% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Qalandar & Brothers 20.00% Above 3ui Lowest 0.42% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bu (Abdul Gh ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executive ngineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of CC Blocks & Drainage system Ward-3 Rohri District Sukkur.
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name MIS S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S F.F Mr. Bahadur Qalandar & Enterprises Ali Thaheem Brothers 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes
5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria
6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad B x (Abdul Gh ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executive Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) •
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of CC Blocks & Drainage system Ward-3 Rohri District Sukkur.
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dat€ d amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S F.F Enterprises Mr. Bahadur Ali Thaheem M/S Qalandar & Brothers GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 19.24% above the Schedule "B" @ 19.66% above the Schedule "B" @ 20.00% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1581894 00 1581894 1581894 1581894
Non-Schedule Items Rs -
Cartage Rs 296890 00 304356 311000 316379
Ceiling Rs 27453 00
Total: Rs. 1906237.00 1886250 1892894 1898273 Rs. 1906200.00 E/COST 1906200 1906200 1906200 -19950 -13306 -7927 1.05% Below the E/Cost 0.70% Below the E/Cost 0.42% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S F.F Enterprises Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 18.86.250/- (Rupees. Eighteen Lac Eighty Six Thousand Two Hundred Fifty) Only at 19.24% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.05% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhammad Buic Ja ar) (Ah I Gh ni Abro) (Ahsan A o an Section Officer (Tech) Executi‘e Ingineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural II igh‘s a Division Pub'li Ilealth Enginee Dix ision Development Department Sukkur Member) Sukkur (Chair 1 Karachi (Member) I
BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 31
I . Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of CC Blocks & Drainaee system rd various streets of ward-5 Rohri Rohri District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered it the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection r„c. I M/S Nippon Builders 13.52% Above la Lowest 2. 10% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Hassan Enterprises 21).17% Above 2nd Lowest 0.74% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Zulficiar & Co. 2 I.00% Above rd Lowest 0.05% Rejected Bcing Highest Saving
(Muhammad Buz J ar) (Abdul Gh ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali C ohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highw Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of CC Blocks & Drainage system @ various streets of ward-5 Rohri Rohri District Sukkur.
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name
S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S Nippon M/S Hassan M/S Zulfiyar Builders Enterprises & Co.
I Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant 1 Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 1 1 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (Ab ul ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan Section Officer (Tech) Executi e Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highw y Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
S
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of CC Blocks & Drainage system @ various streets of ward-5 Rohri Rohri District Sukkur.
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Nippon Builders M/S Hassan Enterprises M/S Zulfiqar & Co. GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 18.52% above the Schedule "B" @ 20.17% above the Schedule "B" @ 21.00% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1574511 00 1574511 1574511 1574511
Non-Schedule Items Rs - -
Cartage Rs 295782 00 291599 317579 330647
Ceiling Rs 27581 00
Total: Rs. 1897874.00 1866110 1892090 1905158 Rs. 1906200.00 E/COST 1906200 1906200 1906200 -40090 -14110 -1042 2.10% Below the E/Cost 0.74% Below the E/Cost 0.05% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Nippon Builder Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 18,66.110/- (Rupees. Eighteen Lac Sixty Six Thousand One Hundred Ten) Only at 18.52% above the schedule "B" items and being 2.10% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
\\\ (Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul (;ha i Abro) (Ahsan . ( a Section Officer (Tech) Executive nginccr Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highway )ivision Publ. lealth Engineer g Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (('hair Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr#32
1.Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer, PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-20 17 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Drianaee System for Baeirii Town Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10.Bids Rejected: NIL 11.Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection r•-,—+ I Mr. Bashir Ahmed Mahar 18.02% Above I' Lowest 0.48% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S AMD Construction 21.45% Above rd Lowest 0.37% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Al-Hassan electric & Civil 21.90% Above 3`d Lowest 0.26% Rejected Being Highest Work Saving
(Muhammad B (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer ech) Executiv ,Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highw y Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
• Name of Work: Construction of Drianage System for Bagirji Town Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S Al- Mr. Bashir M/S AMD S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria Hassan Ahmed Mahar Construction electric & 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executi e Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highway Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukku (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) i
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of Drianage System for Bagirji Town Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by Chief Engineer Public Health Engineering Deptt Government of Sindh. Sukkur vide No DBI dated amounting
Estimate of Cost Mr. Bashir Ahmed Mahar M/S AMD Construction M/S Al-Hassan electric & Civil Work GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 18.02% above the Schedule "B" @ 21.45% above the Schedule "B" @ 21.90% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs. 533499 00 533499 533499 533499
Non-Schedule Items Rs 1506000 00 1506000 1506000 1506000
Cartage Rs 13146 00 96137 114436 116836
Ceiling Rs 109334 00
Total: Rs. 2161978.00 2135636 2153935 2156335 Rs. 2162000.00 E/COST 2162000 2162000 2162000 -26364 -8065 -5665 1.22% Below the E/Cost 0.37% Below the E/Cost 0.26% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by Mr. Bashir Ahmed Mahar Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 21,35.636/- (Rupees. Twenty One Lac Thirty Five Thousand Six Hundred Thirty Six) Only at 18.02% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.22% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhammad Bux Jiirwar) (Abdul ( ni %Iwo) (Ahsan Ali (Inian) Section Officer (Tech) Executi% Engineer Executi% e Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Diem a Ms keen Publ lealth Enginee Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chair Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr#33
1. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Drainage Bashir Abad UC-17 Society Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Resort S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance I Cost Estimated Rejection e..... 1 M/S N.S Jaffar & Co. I - 35% Above 1st Lowest 1.08% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S DKC Enterprises 19.00% Above 2nd Lowest 0.53% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Sastech Construction Works 19.60% Above 3rd Lowest 0.03% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux a (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highw Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Drainage Bashir Abad UC-17 Society Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S Sastech S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria • M/S N.S Jaffar & M/S DKC Construction Co. Enterprises Works 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul (;h ni Abro) (Ahsan Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Ilighwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
S
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of Drainage @ Bashir Abad UC-17 Society Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 Estimate Sanctioned by. Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No. DBI dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S N.S Jaffar & Co. M/S DKC Enterprises M/S Sastech Construction Works GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 17.35% above the Schedule "B" @ 19.00% above the Schedule "B" @ 19.60% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1644142 00 1644142 1644142 1644142
Non-Schedule Items Rs - -
Cartage Rs 284100 00 285259 312387 322252
Ceiling Rs 38723 00
Total: Rs. 1966965.00 1929401 1956529 1966394 Rs. 1967000.00 E/COST 1967000 1967000 1967000 -37599 -10471 -606 1.91% Below the E/Cost 0.53% Below the E/Cost 0.03% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S N.S Jaffar & Co. Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 19,29,401/- (Rupees. Nineteen Lac Twenty Nine Thousand Four Hundred One) Only at 18.35% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.08% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowet;t contractor.
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (Abdul Ch• ni Ahro) (Ahsan Ali ( hohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executive ,ngineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Ilighwa Division 1'04khl%tf o Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur Member) Sukkur (('hairrnao) Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 34
1. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-I48/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Drainaee Shah Khalid Colony UC-17 Society Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder ( ost Offered h‘ the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection 4-,... I M/S Al-Mustafa Enterprises 16.90% Above 1" Lowest 2.35% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 Mr. Nazir Ahmed Kalwar 19.05% Above 21'd Lowest 0.55% Rejected Being High Saving
3 Mr. Jawaid Hussain Jatoi 19.66% Above 3w" Lowest 0.04% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux Ja a ) (Abdul Gha i Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executive ngineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highway Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Drainage Shah Khalid Colony UC-17 Society Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name Mr. Jawaid S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S Al-Mustafa Mr. Nazir Hussain Enterprises Ahmed Kalwar Jatoi 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) . N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Jarv il (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Choh n) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highw Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur ?Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of Drainage Shah Khalid Colony UC-17 Society Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by. Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No. DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Al-Mustafa Enterprises Mr. Nazir Ahmed Kalwar Mr. Jawaid Hussain Jatoi GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 16.90% above the Schedule "B" @ 19.05% above the Schedule "B" @ 19.66% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1657854 00 1657854 1657854 1657854
Non-Schedule Items Rs - - -
Cartage Rs 288843 00 280177 315821 325934
Ceiling Rs 37860 00
Total: Rs. 1984557.00 1938031 1973675 1983788 Rs. 1984600.00 E/COST 1984600 1984600 1984600 -46569 -10925 -812 2.35% Below the E/Cost 0.55% Below the E/Cost 0.04% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Al-Mustafa Enterprises Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 19,38,031/- (Rupees. Nineteen Lac Thirty Eight Thousand Thirty One) Only at 16.90% above the schedule "B" items and being 2.35% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhamma Lwar) (Abdul t; .%bro) (Ahsan Ali Cho an) Section Officer (Tech) Evecutive .ngincer F ecutive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Ilighls ay Division Publ. calth Engince g Division Development Department Sukkur leonine-) Sukkur (Chair Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 35
I . Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer, PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Paver and Drains at Hamdard Cooperative Society Sukkur (Jahaneir Mahar House Street No. 9).
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 NOS. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10.Bids Rejected: NIL 11.Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered ti the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection I',...• I M/S Atif Ali Khoso & Company 19.45% Above Is' Lowest 1.07% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 Mr. Ashique Ali Abbasi 20.00% Above 2nd Lowest 0.61% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Nasir Abbas Construction 21).53% Above 3"I Lowest 0.17% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux a ar) (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ah Cool an) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highw y Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Paver and Drains at Hamdard Cooperative Society Sukkur (Jahangir Mahar House Street No. 9).
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S Atif Ali M/S Nasir S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria Mr. Ashique Ali Khoso & Abbas Abbasi Company Construction 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration , Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
I
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul G' ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv- Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highw. y Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukku (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work. Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of Paver and Drains at Hamdard Cooperative Society Sukkur (Jahangir Mahar House Street No. 9).
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No. DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Atif Ali Khoso & Company Mr. Ashique Ali Abbasi M/S Nasir Abbas Construction GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 19.45% above the Schedule "B" @ 20.00% above the Schedule "B" @ 20.53% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1643135 00 1643135 1643135 1643135
Non-Schedule Items Rs - -
Cartage Rs 300659 00 319590 328627 337336
Ceiling Rs 40065 00
Total: Rs. 1983859.00 1962725 1971762 1980471 Rs. 1983900.00 E/COST 1983900 1983900 1983900 -21175 -12138 -3429 1.07% Below the E/Cost 0.61% Below the E/Cost 0.17% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Atif Ali Khoso & Company Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 19.62,725/- (Rupees. Nineteen Lac Sixty Two Thousand Seven Hundred Twenty Five) Only at 19.45% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.07% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour • check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul (. ani Abro) (Ahsa t i ( ohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executis Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural I I ighss Division Public lealth Enginee 'rig Division Development Department Sukku Member) Sukkur (Chair Karachi (Member)
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of Paver and Drains at Hamdard Cooperative Society Sukkur (Jahangir Mahar House Street No. 9).
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 Estimate Sanctioned by: Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Atif Ali Khoso & Company Mr. Ashique Ali Abbasi M/S Nasir Abbas Construction GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 19.45% above the Schedule "B" @ 20.00% above the Schedule "B" @ 20.53% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1643135 00 1643135 1643135 1643135
Non-Schedule Items Rs -- -
Cartage Rs 300659 00 319590 328627 337336
Ceiling Rs 40065 00
Total: Rs. 1983859.00 1962725 1971762 1980471 Rs. 1983900.00 E/COST 1983900 1983900 1983900 -21175 -12138 -3429 1.07% Below the E/Cost 0.61% Below the E/Cost 0.17% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Atif Ali Khoso & Company Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 19.62,725/- (Rupees. Nineteen Lac Sixty Two Thousand Seven Hundred Twenty Five) Only at 19.45% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.07% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest •ntractor.
(Muhammad Bux !larwar) ( 1bdul Gha i .1bro) (Ahsan Ali ('hohan) Section Officer (Tech) Esecutise .ngineer .lecutive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Ilit;hssas Division P lealth Enginee Division Development Department stikkur Member) Sukkur (('hairM ) Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 36
1.Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer, PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Paver & Drainage at Village 60 Chowk 80 Chowk UC-22 Rohri District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 10.Bids Rejected: NIL 11.Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection 1--.... 1 M/S Al-Tehreem Enterprises 18.07% Above 1st Lowest 0.93% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 Mr. Tahir Hussain I 9 I) 0% Above ed Lowest 0.15% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Muhammad Shoaib & 19.159 0 Above 3rd Lowest 0.03% Rejected Being Highest Brothers Saving
(Muhammad Bu Ja ar) (AbdulGh ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executive ngineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS OUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Paver & Drainage at Village 60 Chowk 80 Chowk UC-22 Rohri District Sukkur. Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S Al-Tehreem Mr. Tahir Nliihammad Enterprises Hussain slioaib & 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Oualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified/disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highw. Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukku (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
•
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of Paver & Drainage at Village 60 Chowk 80 Chowk UC-22 Rohri District Sukkur.
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S AI-Tehreem Enterprises Mr. Tahir Hussain M/S Muhammad Shoaib & Brothers GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR @ 18.07% above the Schedule "B" @ 19.00% above the Schedule "B" A 19.15% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1985383 00 1985383 1985383 1985383
Non-Schedule Items Rs -
Cartage Rs 350915 00 358759 377223 380201
Ceiling Rs 29894 00
Total: Rs. 2366192.00 2344142 2362606 2365584 Rs. 2366200.00 E/COST 2366200 2366200 2366200 -22058 -3594 -616 0.93% Below the E/Cost 0.15% Below the E/Cost 0.03% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Al-Tehreem Enterprises Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 23,44,142/- (Rupees. Twenty Three Lac Forty Four Thousand One Hundred Forty Two) Only at 18.07% above the schedule "B" items and being 0.93% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor. \.\ (Muhammad Bux Ja ar) alli Atm)) (Ahsan Ali ('hohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executis Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural v Division Health Enginee Divi 'on Development Department Sukku (Member) Sukkur (Chair Karachi (Member) Publy BID EVALUATION REPORT • Sr#37
I. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Paver & Drainage 56 Mohalla Locoshed Rohri District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10.Bids Rejected: ' NIL 11.Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Resort S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection 1"...... I M/S Zaheer & Brothers 19.20% Above lit Lowest 1.08% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Abbas Ali 19.77% Above 2nd Lowest 0.61% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Zulfigar & Co. 20.40% Above 3`d Lowest0.08% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux Janvar) (Abdul G ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Paver & Drainage @ 56 Mohalla Locoshed Rohri District Sukkur.
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name
S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S Zaheer & M/S Zulfigar M/S Abbas Ali Brothers & Co.
1 Registration with PEC (if Application) , N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with, 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Ja war) (Abdul G ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Choha ) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of Paver & Drainage @ 56 Mohalla Locoshed Rohri District Sukkur.
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No. DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Zaheer & Brothers M/S Abbas Ali M/S Zulficiar & Co. GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR @ 19.20% above the Schedule "B" e 19.77% above the Schedule "B" @ 20.40% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1582715 00 1582715 1582715 1582715
Non-Schedule Items Rs - - -
Cartage Rs 297028 00 303881 312903 322874
Ceiling Rs 27453 00
Total: Rs. 1907196.00 1886596 1895618 1905589 Rs. 1907200.00 E/COST 1907200 1907200 1907200 -20604 -11582 -1611 1.08% Below the E/Cost 0.61% Below the E/Cost 0.08% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Zaheer & Brothers Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 18,86.596/- (Rupees. Eighteen Lac Eighty Six Thousand Five Hundred Ninety Six) Only at 19.20% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.08% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor_
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul (i n Oro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executis Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Ilighssa Division PublIV. I ealth Engineerin Division Development Department Sukkur Nlember) Sukkur (Chairm Karachi (Member) •
BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 38
1.Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Paver & Drainage at Pir Murad Shah Gulshan-e-Iabal Oureshi Uc-18 Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 0 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered b) the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection i-e..... 1 M/S A.R Awan & Co 20.67% Above I' Lowest 1.87% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Shehzoor Enterprises 22.27% Above fd Lowest 0.57% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Shoaib & Brothers 22.89% Above ri Lowest 0.07% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highw Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Paver & Drainage at Pir Murad Shah Gulshan-e- Iqbal Qureshi Uc-18 Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur. . Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name
S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S A.R Awan & M/S Shehzoor M/S Shoaib Co Enterprises & Brothers
1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux 1/ar) (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highw. Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukku (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of Paver & Drainage at Pir Murad Shah Gulshan-e-lqbal Qureshi Uc-18 Sukkur Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S A.R Awan & Co M/S Shehzoor Enterprises M/S Shoaib & Brothers GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 20.67% above the Schedule "B" @ 22.27% above the Schedule "B" @ 22.89% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1976889 00 1976889 1976889 1976889
Non-Schedule Items Rs
Cartage Rs 407514 00 408623 440253 452510
Ceiling Rs 46647 00
Total: Rs. 2431050.00 2385512 2417142 2429399 Rs. 2431000.00 E/COST 2431000 2431000 2431000 -45488 -13858 -1601 1.87% Below the E/Cost 0.57% Below the E/Cost 0.07% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S A.R Awan & Co. Government Contractor amounting to Rs 23,85,512/- (Rupees. Twenty Three Lac Eighty Five Thousand Five Hundred Twelve) Only at 20.67% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.87% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor
\Ad (Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul Gh ni kbro) (Ahsan Ali ( 'hohan) Section Officer (Tech) Esccutise .ngincer Executive En ineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Disision PubicV lealth Engine ng Div' Development Department Sukkur Member) Sukkur (Cha Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr#39
I. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer, PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1 066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Paver & Drainage Main road Mandhro Shaikh House to Street Allah Dino Jatoi Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos• 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10.Bids Rejected: NIL 11.Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection re... I M/S Ansari & Co. 18.29% Above 1g Lowest 1.00% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Hassan Enterprises 18.99% Above 2nd Lowest 0.42% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Zulfiqar & Co. 19.40% Above 3rd 1,0‘,c,t 0.07% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Ab hani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Execu ve Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Hig ay Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Paver & Drainage @ Main road Mandhro Shaikh House to Street Allah Dino Jatoi Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur. Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name • S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S Hassan M/S Zulfiqar M/S Ansari & Co. Enterprises & Co.
1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant I Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executt e'Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural High ay Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 40
I . Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer, PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Paver Block Q, Malik Mohalla New Yard Rohri District Sukkur
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection 1".....« 1 M/S Paragon Enterprises 18.10% Above la Lowest 1.07% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Ayan-e-Noor Engineers 19.70% Above 2nd Lowest 0.57% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S F.F Electrical & 20.05% Above 3rd Lowest 0.28% Rejected Being Highest Construction Co. Saving
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdu Ghan Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executive En ineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highway Div ion Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) • TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Paver Block Malik Mohalla New Yard Rohri District Sukkur
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S F.F M/S Paragon M/S Ayan-e- S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria Electrical & Enterprises Noor Engineers Construction 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified \'/ (Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul Chan' bro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executive Eng eer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highway Divi on Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
•
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of Paver Block @ Malik Mohalla New Yard Rohri District Sukkur
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No. DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Paragon Enterprises M/S Ayan-e-Noor Engineers M/S F.F Electrical & Construction Co. GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 18.10% above the Schedule "B" @ 19.70% above the Schedule "B" @ 20.05% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1743659 00 1743659 1743659 1743659
Non-Schedule Items Rs
Cartage Rs 323966 00 315602 343501 349604
Ceiling Rs 31463 00
Total: Rs. 2099088.00 2059261 2087160 2093263 Rs. 2099100.00 E/COST 2099100 2099100 2099100 -39839 -11940 -5837 1.90% Below the E/Cost 0.57% Below the E/Cost 0.28% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Paragon Enterprises Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 20,59,261/- (Rupees. Twenty Lac Fifty Nine Thousand Two Hundred Sixty One) Only at 18.10% above the schedule "B" items and being 1 90% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
L
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdu (.hani o) (Ahsan Ali hohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executive Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highssa Disision Public Health Engineering Dis ision Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 41
1.Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of CC Blocks at Village New Village New Police Chowki Oureshi Goth UC Gulshan-e- Iabal Sukkur District Sukkur.
_ 4. Method of Procurement: • Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10.Bids Rejected: NIL 11.Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S,4 Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection
I M/S Sultan Muhamamd 20.15% Above 111 Lowest 1.00% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Al-Noor Builders 20.79% Above f'd Lowest 0.47% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Marhaba Traders 21.20% Above 3rd Lowest 0.13% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (Abdul 1ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highw Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member)
• TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of CC Blocks at Village New Village New Police Chowki Qureshi Goth UC Gulshan-e-Iqbal Sukkur District Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name MIS S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S Sultan M/S Al-Noor Marhaba Muhamamd Builders Traders 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Oualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (Abdul ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executi e Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highway Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of CC Blocks at Village New Village New Police Chowki Qureshi Goth UC Gulshan-e-lqbal Sukkur District Sukkur.
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost MIS Sultan Muhamamd M/S Al-Noor Builders M/S Marhaba Traders GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR @ 20.15% above the Schedule "B" e 20.79% above the Schedule "B" @ 21.20% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1599357 00 1599357 1599357 1599357
Non-Schedule Items Rs -
Cartage Rs 299766 00 322270 332506 339064
Ceiling Rs 42363 00
Total: Rs. 1941486.00 1921627 1931863 1938421 Rs. 1941000.00 E/COST 1941000 1941000 1941000 -19373 -9137 -2579 1.00% Below the E/Cost 0.47% Below the E/Cost 0.13% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Sultan Muhamamd GovernmEnt Contractor amounting to Rs. 19,21,627/- (Rupees. Nineteen Lac Twenty One Thousand Six Hundred Twenty Seven) Only at 20.15% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.00% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
- \\\ (Muhammad Bux Ja ar) ni .‘bro) (Ahsan .Ali ('hohan) Section Officer (Tech) Lngincer Executive Lngincer Public Health Engg: & Rural Div 'vino Publiy I alth Lngineersing Division Development Department Sukkur ( Mein Iwo Sukkur tchairo,g) Karachi (Member) •
BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 42
1.Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of CC Block & Drainage System & water supply wall at Dhareio Mohalla UC-15 Sukkur
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL II. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection r,.... I Mr. Bashir Ahmed Mahar I 8 90% Above Ist Lowest 2.12% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Akhtar Ali & Co. 20.80% Above 2nd Lowest 0.56% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Anwar Ali & Co. 21.38% Above rl Lowest 0.08% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (Abdul ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Choh • n) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highw y Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of CC Block & Drainage System & water supply wall at Dharejo Mohalla UC-15 Sukkur
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name
S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria Mr. Bashir M/S Akhtar Ali M/S Anwar Ahmed Mahar & Co. Ali & Co.
1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Jarw\\c\ r (Abdul G 'ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executi e Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highway Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work. Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of CC Block & Drainage System & water supply wall at Dharejo Mohalla UC-15 Sukkur
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost Mr. Bashir Ahmed Mahar M/S Akhtar Ali & Co. M/S Anwar Ali & Co. GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 18.90% above the Schedule "B" @ 20.80% above the Schedule "B" @ 21.38% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1739371 00 1739371 1739371 1739371
Non-Schedule Items Rs - - -
Cartage Rs 238701 00 328741 361789 371878
Ceiling Rs 135017 00
Total: Rs. 2113089.00 2068112 2101160 2111249 Rs. 2113000.00 E/COST 2113000 2113000 2113000 -44888 -11840 -1751 2.12% Below the E/Cost 0.56% Below the E/Cost 0.08% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Bashir Ahmed Mahar Government Contractor amounting to Rs 20,68,112/- (Rupees. Twenty Lac Sixty Eight Thousand One Hundred Twelve) Only at 18.90% above the schedule "B" items and being 2.12% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
l\!\/ (Muhammad Bux rwar) (Abdul (:h ni two) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executi‘c .ngineer xecutive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Illighm a Di% iNion Pub ealth Engineer Division Development Department Stikkur ( Member) Sukkur (Chairm Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr#43
1. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer, PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Paver & Drainage at Chachar House Misri Khan Chachar Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 93. Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection 1"...i. I M/S Wagar Traders 23.00% Above ls' Lowest 1.98% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Ghulam Mustafa Malik 24.81% Above2"d Lowest 0.54% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Shehzoor Enterprises 25.39% Above P Lowest 0.08% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (Abdul G i ni Abro) Section Officer (Tech) Executive ngineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Paver & Drainage at Chachar House Misri Khan Chachar Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S Waqar M/S Ghulam Shehzoor Traders Mustafa Malik Enterprises 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant I Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified ----.. '
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Cho i n) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highw Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sal( (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
•
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of Paver & Drainage at Chachar House Misri Khan Chachar Taluka Sukkur New District Sukkur.
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 Estimate Sanctioned by: Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Wagar Traders M/S Ghulam Mustafa Malik M/S Shehzoor Enterprises GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 23.00% above the Schedule "B" @ 24.81% above the Schedule "B" @ 25.39% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1400132 00 1400132 1400132 1400132
Non-Schedule Items Rs - -
Cartage Rs 314769 00 322030 347373 355494
Ceiling Rs 42169 00
Total: Rs. 1757070.00 1722162 1747505 1755626 Rs. 1757000.00 E/COST 1757000 1757000 1757000 -34838 -9495 -1374 1.98% Below the E/Cost 0.54% Below the E/Cost 0.08% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S waqar Traders Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 17,22,162/- (Rupees. Seventeen Lac Twenty Two Thousand One Hundred Sixty Two) Only at 23.00% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.98% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhammad Bux J rwar) I %lulu! Gha i ‘brot (Ahsan k t Section Officer (Tebh) Esecutise .ngineer Executise Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Ilighssas tisision PubllealthW Engineehog DiNi%jo ll Development Department tiukkur !ember) Sukkur (Chairni:at Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 44
1.Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Paver Block & Drainage at Irfan Daudpota House New Yard Rohri District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: fatjsm 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection 1-..... 1 Mr. Abdul Wahid Mahar 17.20% Above l st Lowest 3.01% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 Mr. Ashique Ali Mangi 19.99% Above 21'd Lowest 0.70% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Hassan Enterprises 20.64% Above 3rd Lowest 0.16% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (Abdul ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Choha ) Section Officer (Tech) Executi e Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highw y Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
- Name of Work: Construction of Paver Block & Drainage at Irfan Daudpota House New Yard Rohri District Sukkur.
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name
S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria Mr. Abdul Wahid Mr. Ashique Ali M/S Hassan Mahar Mangi Enterprises
1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board . Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Jarwa ) (Abdul ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Execu ye Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural High ay Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member)
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of Paver Block & Drainage at Irfan Daudpota House New Yard Rohri District Sukkur.
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost Mr. Abdul Wahid Mahar Mr. Ashique Ali Mangi M/S Hassan Enterprises GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 17.20% above the Schedule "B" @ 19.99% above the Schedule "B" @ 20.64% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1170316 00 1170316 1170316 1170316
Non-Schedule Items Rs -
Cartage Rs 220392 00 201294 233946 241553
Ceiling Rs 23499 00
Total: Rs. 1414207.00 1371610 1404262 1411869 Rs. 1414200.00 E/COST 1414200 1414200 1414200 -42590 -9938 -2331 3.01% Below the E/Cost 0.70% Below the E/Cost 0.16% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by Mr. Abdul Wahid Mahar Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 13,71.610/- (Rupees. Thirteen Lac Seventy One Thousand Six Hundred Ten) Only at 17.20% above the schedule "B" items and being 3.01% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctionea & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhamma,d Bux Ja ar) (Abdul idian .‘bro) (Ahsan A I o ian Section Officer (Tech) E‘ecutise I. gineer Executise Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Ilighvias I vision Public( 1ealth E nginee 'ng Division Development Department Sukkur ember) Sukkur (Chair Karachi (Members •
BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 45
1. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of CC Blocks & Drainage at Allaha bad Colony War-9 Rohri District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Resort S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection r..... I Mr. Asad Ali Thaheem 18.55% Above Is' Lowest 1.61% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Malik Muhammad !shame 19.89% Above 2nd Lowest 0.50% Rejected Being high & Co. Saving
3 Awais & Brothers 20.48% AboN c .3' Lowest 0.01% Rejected Being highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (Abdul Gh ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highway Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) •
TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of CC Blocks & Drainage at Allahabad Colony War-9 Rohri District Sukkur.
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S Malik S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria Mr. Asad Ali Awais & Muhammad Thaheem Brothers Ishaque & Co. 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes
3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes
4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes
5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria
6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant 1 Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Ja 'ar) (Abdul Gh ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executive Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work: Date of opening: 06-03-2017 Construction of CC Blocks & Drainage at Altahabad Colony War-9 Rohri District Sukkur.
References: TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 Estimate Sanctioned by: Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No. DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost Mr. Asad Ali Thaheem M/S Malik Muhammad Ishaque & Co. Awais & Brothers GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR @ 18.55% above the Schedule "B" @ 19.89% above the Schedule "B" @ 20.48% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs. 1576851.00 1576851 1576851 1576851
Non-Schedule Items Rs. - - - -
Cartage Rs. 295991.00 292506 313636 322939
Ceiling Rs 27453.00
Total: Rs. 1900295.00 1869357 1890487 1899790 Rs. 1900000.00 E/COST 1900000 1900000 1900000 -30643 -9513 -210 1.61% Below the E/Cost 0.50% Below the E/Cost 0.01% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by Mr. Asad Ali Thaheem Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 18,69,357/- (Rupees. Eighteen Lac Sixty Nine Thousand Three Hundred Fifty Seven) Only at 18.55% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.61% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of c eck / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhammad B x Jarwar) (Abdul Gila i Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan Section Officer (Tech) Executive N gineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highway ivision Publ. lealth Engin ring Division Development Department Sukkur (. lember) Sukkur (Cha. 0) Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 46
I. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of CC Blocks at Hussainabad Ward-1 Rohri District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10.Bids Rejected: NIL 11.Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance i Cost Estimated Rejection ...... 1 Muhammad Anwar Jamali 18.30% Above 1' Lowest 2.29% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S AMD Construction 20.50% Above rd Lowest 0.47% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Zulfigar & Co. 21.00% Above 3rd Lowest 0.06% Rejected Being Highest Saving
41111111\
11 (Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (Abdu hanibro) (Ahs 1 o a ) Section Officer (Tech) Executive Engi eer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highway Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member)
TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of CC Blocks at Hussainabad Ward-1 Rohri District Sukkur. Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name
S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria Muhammad M/S AMD M/S Zulfiqar Anwar Jamali Construction & Co.
1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (AbdM Ghani bro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executive Eng eer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highway Divi ion Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of CC Blocks & Drainage at Allahabad Colony War-9 Rohri District Sukkur.
References. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No. DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost Muhammad Anwar Jamali MIS AMD Construction M/S Zulfiqar & Co. GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 18.30% above the Schedule "B" @ 20.50% above the Schedule "B" @ 21.00% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1582715 00 1582715 1582715 1582715
Non-Schedule Items Rs - - - -
Cartage Rs 305682 00 289637 324457 332370
Ceiling Rs 27826 00
Total: Rs. 1916223.00 1872352 1907172 1915085 Rs. 1916200.00 E/COST 1916200 1916200 1916200 -43848 -9028 -1115 2.29% Below the E/Cost 0.47% Below the E/Cost 0.06% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Muhammad Anwar Jamali Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 18,72,352/- (Rupees. Eighteen Lac Seventy Two Thousand Three Hundred Fifty Two) Only at 18.30% above the schedule "B" items and being 2.29% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (Abdul Otani ro) (Ahsan Ali ( holm Section Officer (Tech) Executive Engi eer Executise Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highway His is n Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) a
BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 47
1. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Paver. Block Village Haii Khan UC Hineoro Taluka Pano Akil District Sukkur.
_ 4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website - 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection r.„.4. I M/S Shaheen Enterprises 21.10% Above Is' Lowest 1.21% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Saqib Rasheed & Co. 21.57% Above fd Lowest 0.82% Rejected Being High Saving
1 M/S Akbar & Ali Associates 22.10% Above 3"I Lowest 0.39% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdu`l G ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highw Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member)
•
TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Paver Block Village Haji Khan UC Hingoro Taluka Pano Akil District Sukkur. Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S Akbar S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S Shaheen MIS Saqib & Ali Enterprises Rasheed & Co. . Associates I Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the . Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executi e Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highw a y Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) •
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue: 03-03-2017 Name of Work: Date of opening: 06-03-2017 Construction of CC Blocks & Drainage at Allahabad Colony War-9 Rohri District Sukkur.
References: TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 Estimate Sanctioned by: Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No. DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Shaheen Enterprises M/S Saqib Rasheed & Co. M/S Akbar & Ali Associates GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR @ 21.10% above the Schedule "B" @ 21.57% above the Schedule "B" @ 22.10% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs. 1547434.00 1547434 1547434 1547434
Non-Schedule Items Rs. -- - -
Cartage Rs. 314540.00 326509 333782 341983
Ceiling Rs. 34810.00
Total: Rs. 1896784.00 1873943 1881216 1889417 Rs. 1896800.00 E/COST 1896800 1896800 1896800 -22857 -15584 -7383 1.21% Below the E/Cost 0.82% Below the E/Cost 0.39% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Shaheen Enterprises Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 18,73,943/- (Rupees. Eighteen Lac Seventy Three Thousand Nine Hundred Forty Three) Only at 21.10% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.21% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhammad Bux J ar) (Abdul Gh ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali ('hohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv ngincer .xecutive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural llighwa Division rubrc calth Enginec .4,1 11Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (('hair I Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 48
1.Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Paver Block at Village Sain Dad Jatoi UC Hingoro Taluka Pano Akil District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10.Bids Rejected: NIL 11.Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report SN Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection
1 Mr. Shafqat Ali Chohan 19.22% Above 1" Lowest 2.78% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Sastech Construction Work 21.99% Above2nd Lowest 0.52% Rejected Being High Saving
; M/S Ceccon Engineering Works 22.53% Above 3rd Lowest 0.08% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux Jarw r) (AbdulGh ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Choha Section Officer (Tech) Executive Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highwa Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) •
TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Paver Block at Village Sain Dad Jatoi UC Hingoro Taluka Pano Akil District Sukkur.
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S Sastech M/S Ceccon S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria Mr. Shafqat Ali Construction Engineering Chohan Work Works 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (Abdul Gh ni Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executive Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highway Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur ( ember) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) •
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue: 03-03-2017 Name of Work: Date of opening: 06-03-2017 Construction of CC Blocks & Drainage at Allahabad Colony War-9 Rohri District Sukkur.
References: TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Estimate Sanctioned by: Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No. DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost Mr. Shafqat Ali Chohan M/S Sastech Construction Work M/S Ceccon Engineering Works GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR @ 19.22% above the Schedule "B" @ 21.99% above the Schedule "B" @ 22.53% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs. 1541214.00 1541214 1541214 1541214
Non-Schedule Items Rs. - - - -
Cartage Rs. 319035.00 296221 338913 347236 Ceiling Rs. 29883.00
Total: Rs. 1890132.00 1837435 1880127 1888450 Rs. 1890000.00 E/COST 1890000 1890000 1890000 -52565 -9873 -1550 2.78% Below the E/Cost 0.52% Below the E/Cost 0.08% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by Mr. Shafqat Ali Chohan Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 18,37,435/- (Rupees. Eighteen Lac Thirty Seven Thousand Four Hundred Thirty Five) Only at 21.40% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.00% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour o check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhammad Bux Jerwar) (Abdul C ani Abro) (Ahsan All Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executi e Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highw y Division Publi Health Engine ng Division Development Department Sukk (Member) Sukkur (Cha Karachi (Member) dk •
BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 49
1. Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer, PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Paver Block at Village Kato UC Hingoro Taluka Pano Akil District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10. Bids Rejected: NIL 11. Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection .--4 1 M/S Asad Ali Buriro 21.32% Above l't Lowest 1.07% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Construction Co. Saving award of work
2 M/S Ashique Ali Mangi 22.00% Above 2nd Lowest 0.51% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Hassan Enterprises 22.46% Above 3"I Lowest 0.14% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highw Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukku r (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: Construction of Paver Block at Village Kato UC Hingoro Taluka Pano Akil District Sukkur.
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S Asad Ali S# Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S Ashique M/S Hassan Buriro Ali Mangi Enterprises Construction Co. 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) N/A N/A N/A 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes 5 Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant I Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bux Ja ar) (Ab ul ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executiv Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highw. Division Public I lealth Engineering Division Development Department Sukku (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) •
COMPARATIVE STATEMENT Date of issue 03-03-2017 Name of Work Date of opening 06-03-2017 Construction of CC Blocks & Drainage at Allahabad Colony War-9 Rohri District Sukkur.
References TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 Estimate Sanctioned by Superintending Engineer Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur vide No DB/ dated amounting
Estimate of Cost M/S Asad Ali Buriro Construction Co. M/S Ashique Ali Mangi M/S Hassan Enterprises GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR GOVERNMENT CONTRACTOR
@ 21.32% above the Schedule "B" @ 22.00% above the Schedule "B" @ 22.46% above the Schedule "B" Schedule "B" Items Rs 1545913 00 1545913 1545913 1545913
Non-Schedule Items Rs - - _
Cartage Rs 319701 00 329589 340101 347212
Ceiling Rs 30050 00
Total: Rs. 1895664.00 1875502 1886014 1893125 Rs. 1895700.00 E/COST 1895700 1895700 1895700 -20198 -9686 -2575 1.07% Below the E/Cost 0.51% Below the E/Cost 0.14% Below the E/Cost
The precentage rate quoted by M/S Asad Ali Buriro Construction Co. Government Contractor amounting to Rs. 18,75,502/- (Rupees. Eighteen Lac Seventy Five Thousand Five Hundred Two) Only at 21.32% above the schedule "B" items and being 1.07% Below the estimate cost having lowest in the competion. Hence duly recommended for favour of check / sanctioned & issue the work order to the lowest contractor.
(Muhammad Buxlev Ja ar) (Abdul (.ilu ni k two) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executive .ngineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highs% av )iv ision Publk. fealth Engintering Division Development Department Sukkur !ember) Sukkur Whait,,a.n1 Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr# 50
1.Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer, PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: Construction of Paver Block at Village Dater Dino Kalhoro UC Hingoro Taluka Pano Akil District Sukkur.
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10.Bids Rejected: NIL 11.Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Report S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection r....,.. I M/S Aijaz Ali 19.13% Above In Lowest 2.29% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
' Mr. Ashique Ali abbasi 21.40% Above 2nd Lowest 0.43% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Awais & Brothers 21.89% Above 3rd Lowest 0.03% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bux Jarwar) (Abdul Gha bro) (Ahsan Section Officer (Tech) Executive E gineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highways P ivision Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) BID EVALUATION REPORT Sr # 55
1.Name of Procuring Agency: Executive Engineer. PHE Division Sukkur 2. Tender Reference No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017 3. Tender Description / Name of Work / Item: CONSTRUCTION OF SEWERAGE LINE & DRAINS na MICRO / TOWER NEW PIND SUKKUR DISTRICT SUKKUR
4. Method of Procurement: Single Stage Single Envelope
5. Tender Published: NIT Published in Newspapers & SPPRA Website 6. Total Bid Documents Sold: 03 Nos. 7. Total Bids Received: 03 Nos. 8. Technical Bid Opening Date: 6/3/2017 9. No. of Bid Technically Qualified: 03 Nos. 10.Bids Rejected: NIL 11.Financial Bid Opening Date: Not Applicable 12. Bid Evaluation Resort S# Name of Bidder Cost Offered by the Ranking Comparison Reasons for Remarks Bidder Terms of with acceptance / Cost Estimated Rejection 1"...... d. 1 M/S Bedal Becus 22.12% Above 13' Lowest 1.04% Accepted being Lowest Recommended for Saving award of work
2 M/S Saqib Rasheed & Co. 23.16% Above 2nd Lowest 0.34% Rejected Being High Saving
3 M/S Adeel Ahmed Construction 23.45% Above 3`d Lowest 0.14% Rejected Being Highest Saving
(Muhammad Bu ar) (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executi e Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Highw y Division Public Health Engineering Division Rural Development Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Department Karachi (Member) TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT / BIDDERS QUALIFICATION REPORT
NIT No. TC/G-148/1066 Dated 03-02-2017
Name of Work: CONSTRUCTION OF SEWERAGE LINE & DRAINS @ MICRO / TOWER NEW PIND SUKKUR DISTRICT SUKKUR
Method of Single Stage - One envelope procedure Procurement: Bidder's Name M/S Adeel Eligibility / Qualification Criteria M/S Saqib S# M/S Bedal Becus Ahmed Rasheed & Co. Construction 1 Registration with PEC (if Application) Yes Yes Yes 2 NTN Certificate Yes Yes Yes 3 Sales Tax Registration Yes Yes Yes 4 Professional Tax Yes Yes Yes Registration with Sindh Revenue Board Yes Yes Yes Qualification Criteria 6 Minimum 03 Years experience of relevant f Yes Yes Yes 7 Turnover of at least last three years Yes Yes Yes 8 Required Bid Security is attached Yes Yes Yes 9 Bid is signed name and stamp by the Yes Yes Yes authorized person of the firm along with 10 Any other factor deemed to be relevant by Yes Yes Yes the procuring agency subject to provision of Rule -44 11 Qualified / disqualified Qualified Qualified Qualified
(Muhammad Bu a r) (Abdul G ani Abro) (Ahsan Ali Chohan) Section Officer (Tech) Executi Engineer Executive Engineer Public Health Engg: & Rural Highw y Division Public Health Engineering Division Development Department Sukkur (Member) Sukkur (Chairman) Karachi (Member) OFFICE° MetnIV a V.14 PlitaL1 ENGateeRtma 3UKKUR
Thu rktvit5taril (A55..asNmetil), rk 1k rEibl ai 14y Authk, zi-11-2rAt,
tml)ieo: t-iltetQa-Ote•-14:8_ /113H.QAT.EDS5-__02.-1011.15r,NQ,..411S221..
I(CtfiNV/ICC. le114 - NI4, A I A:q.,1T)SPI'VtA36-1. I0590 tlai,ed I 5 -I12-71-in
l t7 LotEtpll.ince with. your gock.1, (Alice tetti.-r circd alxivi!, it I., 10 Li r= 1"
jai WiSc CoMplialICC of the subjected ina4er Ls as under_
1. The .03 Nos. leading newspapers of Sindhi, do Urdu Languages :err herewith, 2. The nec'cssary corrigendum of PEC cntetories, is issued. Crhe cop.,' corr4N. attached) 3 The condition at Sr. no, 8 of NIT defines that the works an site will be carrilzd trsit per PWD specifications, it does not in contrAry with SPPRA ru 21110 2017), The corrigendum regarding- use the work SPPRA Lnsuzad of PPRA is t,
(copy enclosed).
(AHRAN Au CH mAri) Executive Engineer Public Health Engineering Division Sukkur OPTIC* IA Lurk EXEOUTWE PtkaLiC HEALTH SHOW OUFAUFt Sukkur rtta'
CORRIGENDUM
In continu4ion of thil office NIT ti3uet.1 vide No, 11.41.143
Rated 03412,2(111, the., condition in Sr. 'No-. 7 i) correk.-lcisi
7, Thy under,$igned anal at-hev minpetent auLhotils' 11-ic re,'Kci int ix bid sa 'xi provision of SPI)16% Rules 2010 (Amended 2u13),
An oitlir terino condiflons. will rc&uain 113c f-trlia.
(AKSAN Au CkbHAM Executivv. Engineisr Engineering DiVi.5011 Sukkur CC to the;
1. Manner (Aastssmcm-111), Sindh Public Procurernerit Regulatory A utiltrity (SITRA), Government of Sindh, Barrack No, 8 Secretariat 4A, Court Road, Karachi for publishing on web. 2. Deputy Commissioner Sukkur for favour of his kind information. 3, Superintending Engineer, Public Health Engineering Circle Sukkur fug favour of kind inforrna Lion 4. Notice Board. ORRIGENDlj
h) c,ontintkrition of t1tri ollicc NIT 'ilf4Utt,li irk N mend 0 3.02-2017,1i-to C1,1016111 pt Sr_ N. 1(i) ccticpric
RegiAtr,itIon with PokistAn Engincrini.;Council, in catr...gory C-5 1ti requ the work © Sr. No:55 & C-6 is required for all icalaining 'oiLorts, duly F.:not:v.1 fur Ow Yc-iir 2017 with ficld of Npc 6111 i
All other tcrins-ck conditions will MInain the
(Art rA2.4 Au CH 11)cccutive Engineer Public Health Engineerin Sukkur ath :
1. Manage (Assessment-ill), Stridh Public Procurement Regulatory Authority (SPPRA), Government of Sindh, Barrtuk No. 8 Secretariat No 4A, Curt Road, Karachi for publishing on web. 2. Deputy Commissioner Sukkur for favour of his kind information. Circle • Sukkur OT 3. Superintending Engineer, Public Health Engineering favour of kind information, 4. Notice Beard.
annintiMMI k • ,c '.A:. 6 1. • J. alt 1: 4 - TI f 0411611 116 CI . 'TENDERS N foru-r.* a. Isar tarryametitais t wra-91 tor 0 • Um' aStIOGITMai th• C• at • 6146/ ' 11 Mr. tV • 44-4rats-1.41./. 10.1 • .1-87 ttor-1/ 0 11 M.. 9. 9 V 1061ime *410 C180110,110•1.011 L".. ur.. 8 t • ""4../.dkVI.0 41 'amt • \ LW %same •r"...... ria V6•116,11 1.4 • .0N6,• •.. - - .--,,,.,,,, VII 411 or i hip! 6 66, I pm.. Ip. ...arr... a. Mo.. 10- .7.•••••44. -I 4. 11010 .r 1..6 *107074V.4 4 M.o. 11110; L.:di '47'.. ; ..IMAJII 1 II III $ 400.804•44404.• a X • I 0.• /GI lbw - r if , ,I alli-iild Z$ 14' 4" 4 * '4- , , Clam mamma ad at., 4.. Imlay Loa lal ain a .r..1 rbm.1 s• i,t tr45r381AIkahrta rC474=rC a 6,1R Lai,* il...... raw....., twati Ira. 4 9Maart 'Ir.. a a ed 4 In, 'en 14 4.000 • I, 01.41.14.088. Naar aa VS" 1404 41 t 4' *.iiir • at. manor 1 o axtr.. 4=.1 la& •11)Imat Iltict Era Ors 1 la tat as tlarweris. J014•••181. f-yr. 110,4 i'441. 44 t L. "Vie 184 V1„4. AjZ. Ill 941 .$401 40 Twam I araltatIstarlowt Its+ past 17;r7a-r-
s Yin 'saw WIII; 91.4tpa r:1-11;71* -110 141tal rellf T.* 41601.1 Vat att ia • bora Orr • air 11•4 Maw M itttatta tat 0 taw /ma IWO ;40' . sa Sir ✓ II Is LAM I. Myr 16.1 tarp, Fa.11.4sm.l. ____.titaistitta./4umtiOrk te.1' Li_, in- I', ' • I ti issoarsol 41400 INalt * tea-witi Gtf f: I rat par.-4 casarta.trry s' how ;wry► Pral*lansaa t tretest 14•41, nw. • i atvaat serf. ta. t Her Ur rw.1 LC, f, trawl. ' III et1:111410ra1 sitsra lirs•-• 11.0.111' 4" I "II ;•12". e v.4 a_tras.. il IOW %14.* 1.4 e.r; hen 14-4 • I Ltatatatat pato lib.% C.44.1* 0.46. 1.1 11111 Mar iriftwii_ ▪romit.g.4. ir-** 1664:44441 1041••• 10- 1.2.=r..4.011 M. II 0-11081 . gi.4.4 10 4 1044 1004 r. 4 , # am 1...#. 1,,,,...4 ....r"0,8 Ma 11.88 ilusa.. 4 •n".• riwor ham. 8 III *I Kra (10001 *-4.4.** 11 *be frac tar.1 04II 0,60L 4111 he& A* so I I r IltiVreakrths._ 44. • a ars ;rm.* ..1 Jot SIM )0Jtill ilillittbm•••••311e1 Cesar .• West IC.11 'Orr GC /sr 01.4 G..1.40. it 44. Nava arsairapl re Ira Na 00 10 Cttaat tat4 44.04 urr 20/ Marc rot* sr *Sot voi0 *of" Sark .144 4.1it4 ata4 ttatts 161 ✓r- I U. NUN I- rem a.6,4 maw r.. rm. is 144 Ms tott abto • few 0110.0n$1011 11.00.0. 00* 1•14 C'4 G+1 ir4 mop irso.kstr Ors Is ia 0. 4 9C.14 cart Ira.' • 1•1 cap wilt sts Sr as aa ;4 4S XI,' at Palm* 44 go 111.41•I at's, If.* /ta I re 'Plow Maw 4•• Nabs CID" 1J iXtaltal it 400a0 attt redb arm, at L. Nast tat 44t1 Mwal. .1. r04 MO* 14.1110.410i141•41111.04.; /4410.000 41. 14 IIP1110100,P0 Iff 1.1N -11 IM Pik /*a memputl rus gda•rd.r •41 sa rr, 0. 1.41 -1"1..ur aixar .4 *fa. 1181411.0.44 011=4011.-111 1110/ k001414 •C 4.44,- Iararbtakos Sew Jed tal•••,. `. PAL tisfiii'llarils 1..1 Mar L Ihs Wan %Ir. ad mom moure bokowo#,. #.1hows..... • evils 44.6.drad611m4 A ..•1 1:C. t: war • pre W 11.4 1/100 41•••• 1/49IItt" • 11.p.... arm Paro...17••••1 L".••••1 • st •■ 14 •••.i. Hasty sat 14 ••• booi 44 .4•4•4 awe+ of ••.• •• La err .frotir arra /mum a Atas it4tffit A/-114rIst 101•1140 aro do m.644:I • • Iiime•A Imapsamsa Cara INICCataStar.acu to rawrol • f AI arr. ipromom risr Tora...• r ha Imum.. t ***I • Ito • Isomer 14 *. J tam Irk &rag II Maid Wart 111.00... Cab Nora. aosous • pod at liniv084.4.1 0.4 8,18. or& II401.6446,441 /4.1•If Iva 18 Bow oil N.. 111■04 1.001041 la "WWI 44/II0+0 (100.0i Ice 414 MIIIII10111•01.44,•• &err I. floss, II 884. ,trawl 4404 011, two 148 0.•• 0+80.8 .4.8 .0 40441. 40 Or ...... -4.01111•010 11•4141,10. MAID r151 111.1 00601,06 454 II • 11•••••••=01.1 goi I • a Imastaz Oro at ‘104.0.0 WWI at sr", 4.0 I #.1.4 ..smillems oat al ani,••• 1#01 Corry %Was .00 surokini marl •••••••40 owe arwrarast raws era I . .### 116.1.,•• /...4.1.44•14•orwrokromm• * .65 q..1.0. n get r464 ow. Drip r }tart Mark arli swats. 1110.0• • Alltaral arti alr.4111s dal stairs lam 'II arrow rs 10.8.Ist m arm . . 11.0, • MPS •4101014 Catiwitalloa cc poi s OWNS 110•I 118 10.1.1moims• 00111110114101061 40101 UP, 44-wr 4.0.0•TV1100/ I l•.* 4.0.. Mils& a NIA Slw.01.04 Obinrr Or 1 • 0,40.9011 1 .1144,..nomm0 .91lltaart assa .1 111.11.1 :1C-.7 Par +4 114.46.6.8111:111.44/44/0•84 bow EMI* Pal 1.14/1.14. I+ ...Sr 141. ,I) powwow. of ..rorw 111.E fu**. amt Job 4 Or 104.11•0 44411.1 bit pest Ire AM@ pf Grandma iapato AIL* CA *VW /M,E1.5.A100' 0~ battier to 4.41atte Deafer row sktioal lova mat maw 1.11140140 cniug_s•ir."0 . allar••• 1 mill• tar mraimmot .14 Lourrirrier or I 144y loom II #41.11•46esoleys UM/ /,.Las 4.0•611al pwra *MAW. 4101.01.6.6 taindor. wo.nral Era 371 I • .5.,,or .4f****4.4o. 1.arIgw tltawrr.f • col I aavt a Whip Mani' Orr itato I Craltaarat /1 argaspar radar pm Is trairtanal st Daisy t Copra! Me -1110 11 I I* It a-rati 14010 44 NNW itto HI 14141 sa .1441114.141/1111 41114 Won Car- l.larr & '001100 salt Is Hata cot at pm". ri Ioatihroet.‘ or low Owns III LS I nstasistatrr 4444 ila-10 • 10. off•take ttat Lxta 4... 1 4 IA fib Mrt. pa ata tilt #. rimora 16.11 lurid 11.111 N Wei Corievomit y. 111.11 1140114•4,110 &OSA tat I.6.0-d r/ I "-No II Twirl.' amins aal. hurt la tat ar0144Lram Ryer t-14rvoiirorrioart. c...opoor,of IA:L$*4•/*4-1,‘ irar IAN* War 00110 I 1.3. . .1 E.xccutire Engiate.cr 114.11 ‘444-A44 JO Wed Iii1444 v14.4 a Pplo Public Eicaltit Engiaeraing Divition 00001hal a CC I trims" 4.,-•?r,..11.4q3 StekkUT v vvr. 1 • if .c.,..,.. of 01:01.0 UR" 1 Dahl. 01111 car . ;Icze 'seri Agrierfatiratf0t4‘. kr Vtie,-.31= ..rt... * Dealer. 0 Wombat 1,,NCl b fog rot utertirmoor ot sorx.wriGe. /4444 4...1.0 3 9 ki it Curarpo rt am.. a II...k Col ,.w 40•4411, SMS Lmr yourt 1.cESSAZE maw txr•., forirt Ji k .• e UT{ 1 DIC ter -'Snr41't.'",r1411:700 t'el 1,4te'y.trisvilr,r7,-,?„, f t P:;714,7i ([ ;.1.'111-ritpbrVO711S"."til t ' oft if pc iiVoahirtipTcrit,"1). -pre ifytt •;111pa et (0"3114 ,0/Y.u44c 117'4?-?)57, nr.)711(3)
r/t;kAiA,77- L. vy,,rni.sdp7,71rolifi N.v."6/0- 41I't 1111 ill
ii1/0 IAbt IY fic-lite,411.4,4•31PerPY'IrfOrt * (19 rr-neter?n,l'o'N'rr
1-1711.3,>111 4f- oco .1-1-40A0 ImeiviryerpiPreP • *,*-IerPri.pl .qt` (PO iref*P"r,firtf"1.1 iyt?Irelortelnli 0,A) all? "4'1'!" U VI* IntrAP) 0.,1-ply,„4.,,,p.fry.A..4. tAY 41-‘4011,4,1}",44.) 4A--431,4reeiroe" (64) r5, cf I) htfr4A4'7,4KIVX01-77,74f— (1) frO•44"pitirtir":11:4A"''"O's. t.ttinyern'i.e•+- 14:1111,t0OC 7tiWeVe.rir'72-r:lea3 cveap-rinoppc M AMIP"1/4q1)N1Vrirrivv. .""rirt IP.rJ ,f71-77r1144*%0•41e7p t.
J rf• -reVITP/4,3.7-cp*c•ct-coricOz-ctia 17-14.47?-7A. ?p7- •• 6.77,-, rpV Pr-47. ,r1 it
'tom- Wet, Ilt,1 t7fr— , ririttrl I
nr t to r isr •
7...-11;10
•na WI •
LIS rilli"' .... ••••••• .... '14'' ' 114" NA, tsr, if 0-----,:::...... ui, II 4 i ll" 0T-....-4 - -I • =11•3:44 1
. trIv 14- 4 NI 1 fli, '--...1- 7- ,---r ":'117.-4L2:7,- laPr'• ., •.4...... -..*-,,..L.z... :.. wa MI TIC -41:=7;3-7,t1
• Imes 41. M.N. Pi.ir71.!.•.; er•••:. - I .7•••04• 44 .••• e•Allai 1447.1.", .0*•.••J‘4C4C, 0,11 t 0.04japt•
••••., e t•-• I Low-, z•••••• ...••••• 0••••••• ekor ..•-w...... M1 _u__ I o.:.....1:0. I '••••,/, ; •4 . I . ,li 411.4.' .1,64 ..<•L t! ;LP -I4,..4 v....4w. •4'4, -. • • • 4.0)... 31... ;,....i .f.. s .4. j,...... 1,‘,I stsw.! ,...t.L21 IL,: .... ,..e.i.A.A:‘ i.4.,..46,0.-00,---.#4.004.14oi, .,,-- . '1/ 2, .0 earl? e•••• WI s i .....$ .0A, ,-6:.-.),...... y....„.L.J,Ljui 7, 0: -,...... 0..L.A..-:„,1.-..,.....,va Mn....4.•1.,... eol 669' .J...Y ...Ow.j3441./ .61.44. Ore :"..,....."-....4 I .....1.• .e...0•4 do•'• de MAO Iji 4 .)—.A...-A4.4.o.4 r•••••••411;10.• 0..JI•infi44.00 -"'"-^'e - KC ;•41.... 4.44.64 *ma; . 40" J•a•M 141 ..w 1-•••17"-j '' • ••,- vA.-"•;."..'•-••••61.0._s..-,.., ,,r::.•••• • T ••••••••.1,4 it* j•••• 4.•)be sa• ••••.:•••1•• •••• -•••••••%•• • A.:: a • 1•1 pot./ •••••••• •••••••-•••••••.4 - I .4' ••••••••• zort.ortsor eos-1,I „•••• asa-An." ....400.1g mgr. ,e,a, toe o •••!....;p1A .1••••••••1.0.Xi. 4.••••1 dive "t• omit AV' VS 4 01 u liesti ,oho-e I.2-4 , ...4•4••• Jos JO • 41 "11.; +40 va vaa•al. --o41140 rio 1J 11 root, 1.1.-Ai•iluar 4.400 •,!/"." 3.4 ilk • . k *Pa 0,!...41.44„,fig...1.4.4.....CNIC 31 &Vs O., S..a....1.-.--...... ---d—cm4;•42.0euIr144,. 464,4 • so .4,4i.podLe‘1.•
.,--4 1..p....-..04-,-,,,t,"Jale;s•-•1-1 40•94-4
.6.a -l e"' 4r- 1,11'.11(a0 04.41 ...04.4..J/ 041 %--••• 14.) too 0•44.
41 .4. 4,4.6.11 ,Cas J-1•• • v41 •tti
1-;="1Apt-64J 4.010ft dr•-.4k)# 44;4 Z-Lee1 '64 '=1.1 :41.