Fieldwork Under Difficult Circumstances
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Vol. 31, No. 2, Spring 2009 PRACTICING ANTHROPOLOGY 1 FIELDWORK UNDER DIFFICULT CIRCUMSTANCES 2 Regime Change at Practicing Anthropology Ronald Loewe and Jayne Howell 4 Living and Working in a War Zone: An Applied Anthropologist in Afghanistan Patricia A. Omidian 12 Are You With the F.B.I.?: Fieldwork Challenges In A Post 9/11 Muslim-American Community Tony Gaskew 18 Who Burned Down Our House This Time?: Ethnography & Conflict in Timor Leste Patricia L. Delaney 24 Unstable Relocations: Meeting the Other in Kurdolato Bruno Anili 29 Turbulence Within the Cuban Diaspora in South Florida Indira Rampersad 35 We Find Ourselves in the Middle: Navajo Relocation and Relocatee-Host Conflicts Orit Tamir 2 PRACTICING ANTHROPOLOGY Vol. 31, No. 2, Spring 2009 REGIME CHANGE AT PRACTICING ANTHROPOLOGY By Ron Loewe the Journal of American Folklore, the be evaluated individually. Finally, we American Anthropologist, and Culture, strongly encourage submissions from and Jayne Howell Medicine and Psychiatry. His mother, practicing anthropologists as well as recently deceased, says all the articles are professors and students. or obvious reasons, I did not really good, but that he should learn the We are also contemplating some Fwant our first issue of Practicing difference between a colon and a semi- changes, but don’t look for these in Anthropology to go to press on the colon. Hopefully, now that he is an editor, the first issue. One of the things we are Ides of March, but the people who set he will. He is completing a book on na- considering is introducing a broader production schedules are, undoubtedly, tionalism and identity in Yucatan entitled variety of submission categories: brief less superstitious than cultural anthro- Making Mayas into Mestizos: National- comments on articles that were pub- pologists, at least this one. Anyway, it ism, Modernity and its Discontents. lished in earlier issues; book, museum is with a sense of optimism and a touch We should also mention that Krystal exhibit and film reviews; anthropologi- of trepidation that Jayne Howell and Kittle, a graduate student of ours who cal humor, editorials/op-eds, or possibly I release our first issue of Practicing is studying aging in the gay community a forum in which contemporary issues Anthropology. We hope it is considered will be working with us. Krystal is a can be debated. These, hopefully, will a good one, but please let us know what talented artist and musician as well as stimulate an ongoing dialogue between you think by writing to our new address a good anthropologist, and will help us readers of Practicing Anthropology. at [email protected]. copyedit the journal. In any case, we do not plan to shy As our first order of business, we away from controversy. In light of would like to thank the previous editors Plans for Practicing Anthropology the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and of Practicing Anthropology, Jeanne the Human Terrain System, there is a Simonelli and Bill Roberts for their Some things about Practicing An- renewed interest in ethics in anthropol- stewardship of the journal, for giving thropology will stay the same for the ogy. As we begin our turn as editors, us a quick tutorial in editing, and for foreseeable future. Practicing Anthro- Terry Turner, professor emeritus at the lending Kristen Gentke from Wake pology will remain an editor-reviewed, University of Chicago, has proposed Forest University to us for the time be- as opposed to a peer-reviewed, journal reinstating the language in the 1971 ing. Jeanne and Bill, in our estimation, and will continue to publish relatively AAA statement of ethics that prohibited produced many interesting issues of PA, short articles (3,500 words) on topics anthropologists from engaging in covert and we hope we can adequately fill their of general concern to anthropologists research or withholding research find- shoes. In any event, it seems as though inside and outside the academy. We ings from the population from they were editors are generally appreciated about are interested in receiving case studies obtained. The Network of Concerned as much as IRS agents or bill collectors, in medical anthropology, education, Anthropologists (NCA) supports the so we need to stick together. international development, tourism, resolution. Most members of the Na- As our second order of business, we business, etc., which address important tional Association of Practicing Anthro- would like to provide brief introductions, substantive, ethical or policy concerns pologists (NAPA) oppose it. Wouldn’t so our readers know who we are. Jayne in the practice of anthropology. We this be an interesting issue to debate in Howell joined the faculty at California also invite submissions relating to the pages of Practicing Anthropology? State University (Long Beach) in 1994. anthropologically-oriented program She is currently on sabbatical in Oaxaca, evaluation, social impact assessment, Mexico, completing her book Rural Fieldwork in Difficult Settings and cultural resource management as Girls, Urban Women on urban migration, well as innovations in the teaching of While fieldwork has been fraught schooling, and employment in this south- anthropology. While articles do not with difficulty since the beginning of eastern state. In addition to her research require extensive citations, manuscripts modern anthropology, the present issue on education, she has written about indig- should discuss the methodology or highlights new difficulties which have enous identity, US migration, domestic methodologies employed and should emerged in the wake of the wars in Iraq service and prostitution in Oaxaca, and be well-grounded. We will continue the and Afghanistan, the Patriot Act and domestic violence in the United States. practice of publishing issues focusing the rise of anti-Muslim and anti-Arab Ron Loewe joined the CSULB faculty on a particular theme (when we receive prejudice in the United States. In the in 2006. He has published a number good proposals), but, as is the case first article, for example, Patricia Omid- of articles in small, effete journals like with other journals, each article will ian, a medical anthropologist who has Vol. 31, No. 2, Spring 2009 PRACTICING ANTHROPOLOGY 3 lived and worked in Afghanistan for not insurmountable if one is open and hosts and newcomers. In this case, seven years, discusses the need as well honest about his background. Kurdish immigrants not only found an as the difficulty of maintaining a clear The article by Patricia Delaney, a economic niche in a community where boundary between her work and that former Peace Corp worker who devel- native Italians were leaving in large of the military. Omidian’s article also oped health education programs in East numbers, but are seen as an important reminds us of the old adage that “truth Timor, provides another example of social asset that can help the local com- is the first casualty of war,” especially the personal side of fieldwork during a munity maintain its vigor and evolve. when the truth about negative maternal time of war. While most Americans are In a discussion of ethnic tension closer health outcomes implicates the U.S. familiar with the atrocities carried out to home, Indira Rampersad discusses con- military. Anyone who has followed the by Pol Pot in Cambodia, few Americans tinuity and change in the attitudes of Cu- debate within anthropology about the are aware of the violence and famine ban-Americans toward the U.S. embargo Human Terrain System (e.g., the use of that claimed the lives of an estimated as well as the Island nation itself. Through anthropologists in military brigades) or 200,000 East Timorese, nor the role of an analysis of interviews with Cubans the emerging discussion of the Minerva Indonesia and its US ally in this matter. living in the United States and Cuba, she Research Initiative, a DOD grant pro- Delaney’s poignant recollection of the notes the emotional toll that travel restric- gram to promote social science research fear she felt for her former co-workers tions have had on many families as well in strategic hotspots like the Mideast, and fictive kin after she returned to the as the growing political diversity within will find this paper of interest. US, serves as a reminder that our ethical the Cuban-American community. The paper by Tony Gaskew, a crimi- ties to the people we work with do not Finally, we close this issue on a nologist working in a Muslim commu- end once we leave the field. happier note by including Orit Tamir’s nity in south Florida, shows that you do Bruno Anili’s study of the peaceful paper of the Navajo-Hopi land dispute, not have to leave the U.S. to run into coexistence between Italian hosts and a dispute which finally appears to have some of the same problems: suspicion, Kurdish migrants who settled in the run its course after more than one hun- mistrust and expulsion. However, as coastal community of Baldolato demon- dred years. Gaskew’s piece demonstrates, even strates that immigration can sometimes difficult obstacles to field research are have very positive outcomes for both Ron Loewe and Jayne Howell n CLASSI C S OF PRA C TI C ING ANTHRO P OLOGY : 1978 – 1998 An exciting new collection of some of the best articles from the first 20 years of Practicing Anthropology. Many selec- tions come from the early volumes of the journal printed on newsprint and no longer easily accessible. All the articles were chosen for their enduring contribution to the history and prac- tice of anthropology. Useful as a teaching aid or as a reference work, Classics of PA provides a snapshot of the variegated scene of anthropologists at work in the final decades of the 20th century.