ANNEX A

Year Minister Cost Provider Reason 2014/15 Minister for £1,200.00 Pink Elephant Introductory Youth & Communications Media Women’s Training Employment – Minister for £1,200.00 Pink Elephant Introductory Environment, Communications Media Climate Training Change & Land Reform – Aileen McLeod Cabinet £1,440.00 Pink Elephant Introductory Secretary for Communications Media Justice – Training Michael Matheson Minister for £1,200.00 Pink Elephant Refresher Public Health Communications Media – Maureen Training Watt Cabinet £1,200.00 Pink Elephant Refresher Secretary for Communications Media Education & Training Lifelong Learning – 2016/17 Minister for Nil Scottish Introductory Childcare & Government Media Early Years – Communications, Training Mark Ministerial McDonald support and Facilities Directorate Minister for Nil Scottish Introductory Higher Government Media Education, Communications, Training Further Ministerial Education & support and Science – Facilities Shirley-Anne Directorate Somerville Minister for Nil Scottish Introductory Social Government Media Security – Communications, Training Jeane Ministerial Freeman support and Scottish Ministers, special advisers and the Permanent Secretary are covered by the terms of the Lobbying () Act 2016. See www.lobbying.scot

Facilities Directorate Minister for Nil Scottish Introductory Local Government Media Government & Communications, Training Housing – Ministerial Kevin Stewart support and Facilities Directorate 2017/18 Minister for Nil Scottish Introductory Children and Government Media Young People Communications, Training - Ministerial support and Facilities Directorate 2018/19 Cabinet £972.12 voicebusiness Refresher Secretary for public Finance, speaking Economy and Fair Work - Minister for Nil Scottish Refresher Children and Government Media training Young People Communications, Maree Todd Ministerial support and Facilities Directorate Cabinet Nil Scottish Refresher Secretary for Government Media Social Communications, Training Security and Ministerial Older People - support and Shirley-Anne Facilities Somerville Directorate Minister for Nil Scottish Introductory Rural Affairs Government Media and the Communications, Training Natural Ministerial Environment - support and Facilities Directorate Minister for Nil Scottish Introductory Trade, Government Media Investment Communications, Training and Innovation Ministerial - Ivan McKee support and Facilities Directorate Minister for Nil Scottish Introductory Community Government Media Communications, Training Scottish Ministers, special advisers and the Permanent Secretary are covered by the terms of the Lobbying (Scotland) Act 2016. See www.lobbying.scot

Safety - Ash Ministerial Denholm support and Facilities Directorate Minister for Nil Scottish Introductory Mental Health Government Media - Clare Communications, Training Haughey Ministerial support and Facilities Directorate Minister for Nil Scottish Introductory Public Finance Government Media and Digital Communications, Training Economy - Ministerial support and Facilities Directorate Minister for Nil Scottish Introductory Europe, Government Media Migration and Communications, Training International Ministerial Development - support and Ben Facilities Macpherson Directorate Minister for Nil Scottish Refresher Public Health, Government Media Sport and Communications, Training Wellbeing - Ministerial Joe FitzPatrick support and Facilities Directorate Minister for Nil Scottish Introductory Parliamentary Government Media Business and Communications, Training Veterans - Ministerial support and Facilities Directorate Minister for Nil Scottish Introductory Older People Government Media and Equalities Communications, Training - Christina Ministerial McKelvie support and Facilities Directorate

Scottish Ministers, special advisers and the Permanent Secretary are covered by the terms of the Lobbying (Scotland) Act 2016. See www.lobbying.scot