Warsaw, Poland, 6 to 17 July 2015)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Annex 6 Report of the Working Group on Ecosystem Monitoring and Management (Warsaw, Poland, 6 to 17 July 2015) Content Page Opening of the meeting ...................................................................... 219 Adoption of the agenda and organisation of the meeting ............................... 219 The krill-centric ecosystem and issues related to management of the krill fishery ............................................................................. 220 Issues for the present ....................................................................... 220 Fishing activities ........................................................................ 220 Krill Fishery Report ................................................................. 220 Redevelopment of the CCAMLR database ........................................ 221 Green weight estimation ............................................................ 222 Fishery notifications ................................................................. 222 Fishing gear library .................................................................. 224 Scientific observation ................................................................... 224 Krill biology, ecology and management .............................................. 227 Role of fish in the ecosystem ........................................................... 232 Feedback management (FBM) ......................................................... 234 Submitted approaches ............................................................... 237 FBM in Subarea 48.1 ............................................................. 237 Development of FBM in Subarea 48.2 ......................................... 239 A general approach to FBM at the SSMU scale ............................... 241 General ............................................................................ 243 General considerations for management of the krill fishery ..................... 244 State of the krill-based food web at present .................................... 244 Precautionary requirements for predators at SSMU-scales ................... 248 Using existing data and monitoring ............................................. 249 Further development of at-sea monitoring and CEMP sites .................. 250 Structured fishing to further FBM .............................................. 253 Implementation of FBM ......................................................... 253 Future work plan to progress stage 2 ............................................... 253 Current state of the krill-based ecosystem and the fishery .................... 254 Stage 2 subdivision of catch and/or update of trigger level ................... 256 Precautionary requirements for predators at SSMU scales ................... 256 Krill surveys and CEMP in stage 2 ............................................. 256 General ............................................................................ 258 CEMP and WG-EMM-STAPP ........................................................ 259 CEMP data submission .............................................................. 259 New methods and tools for CEMP .............................................. 259 CEMP monitoring in Area 48 ................................................... 262 Spatial correlation of CEMP parameters ....................................... 264 Standardisation ................................................................... 264 WG-EMM-STAPP .................................................................. 266 Integrated assessment model ........................................................... 266 Collection of fishing vessel acoustic data ............................................. 267 Scientific surveys undertaken from fishing vessels ............................... 269 217 Proposals for future krill surveys ................................................... 270 Multinational coordination ............................................................. 271 Spatial management .......................................................................... 273 Marine protected areas (MPAs) ........................................................... 273 MPA Planning Domain 1 (Western Antarctic Peninsula and southern Scotia Sea) .............................................................. 273 MPA Planning Domains 3 and 4 (Weddell Sea) ...................................... 276 Approaches to MPA planning in the boundary region between Domains 1 and 3 ..................................................... 279 Archiving of background information and data layers used in MPA planning processes ..................................................... 280 Vulnerable marine ecosystems ............................................................ 282 Advice to the Scientific Committee and its working groups............................ 283 Future work ................................................................................... 284 Streamlining the work of the Scientific Committee and its working groups .......... 284 Joint workshops ............................................................................. 285 Workshop reports ........................................................................... 286 Climate change ............................................................................. 286 Understanding CCAMLR’s approach to management .................................. 287 FBM ......................................................................................... 287 Three-year work plan ................................................................... 287 Other business ................................................................................ 287 The CCAMLR Scientific Scholarship Scheme .......................................... 287 CEMP Special Fund ........................................................................ 288 The Antarctic Wildlife Research Fund ................................................... 289 CCAMLR Science ........................................................................... 290 WG-EMM Convener ....................................................................... 290 Author affiliation of working group papers .............................................. 290 GEF proposal ............................................................................... 291 CCAMLR website .......................................................................... 291 Adoption of the report and close of the meeting ......................................... 291 References ..................................................................................... 292 Tables ........................................................................................... 295 Appendix A: List of Participants ...................................................... 300 Appendix B: Agenda .................................................................. 305 Appendix C: List of Documents....................................................... 306 218 Report of the Working Group on Ecosystem Monitoring and Management (Warsaw, Poland, 6 to 17 July 2015) Opening of the meeting 1.1 The 2015 meeting of WG-EMM was held at the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development, Warsaw, Poland, from 6 to 17 July 2015. The meeting was convened by Dr S. Kawaguchi (Australia). The meeting was opened by Dr M. Kaniewska-Krolak (Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development) and Prof. P. Jonczyk (Institute of Biochemistry and Biophysics, PAS) who welcomed the Working Group to Warsaw. 1.2 Dr Kawaguchi welcomed participants (Appendix A) and reviewed the current work of WG-EMM. He also outlined the meeting’s agenda that focused on the krill-centric ecosystem and issues related to the development of the feedback management (FBM) of the krill fishery. Adoption of the agenda and organisation of the meeting 1.3 The Working Group discussed the provisional agenda. While there was no specific agenda item dealing with climate change, WG-EMM reiterated the importance of climate change in its work. The Working Group agreed to note the discussion points that were relevant to climate change for further consideration by the Scientific Committee. The agenda was adopted (Appendix B). Subgroups were formed to address detailed aspects of the agenda. 1.4 Documents submitted to the meeting are listed in Appendix C. While the report has few references to the contributions of individuals and co-authors, the Working Group thanked all authors of papers for their valuable contributions to the work presented to the meeting. 1.5 In this report, paragraphs that provide advice to the Scientific Committee and its other working groups have been highlighted; these paragraphs are listed in Item 4. 1.6 The report was prepared by T. Brey (Germany), A. Constable (Australia), R. Currey (New Zealand), C. Darby (UK), O.R. Godø (Norway), S. Grant and S. Hill (UK), B. Krafft (Norway), J. Melbourne-Thomas (Australia), D. Ramm, K. Reid and L. Robinson (Secretariat), C. Reiss (USA), M. Santos (Argentina), C. Southwell (Australia), P. Trathan and J. Watkins (UK) and G. Watters (USA). 219 The krill-centric ecosystem and issues related to management of the krill fishery Issues for the present Fishing activities Krill Fishery Report 2.1 The Working Group reviewed the draft krill fishery report (WG-EMM-15/30) noting that: (i) in 2013/14: (a) 12 vessels fished in Subareas 48.1, 48.2 and 48.3 (b) Subarea 48.1 was closed on 17 May 2014 when the catch of krill in that