AaBbCc 123456

MUNICI PAL COUNCI L L O RS 2 0 19 Òepee HeÀeTb[sMeve ner He#eefvejHes#e keÀece keÀjCeejer mJe³ebmesJeer mebmLee Deens. osMee®³ee Founded in 1998, the PRAJA Foundation is a non-partisan jep³ekeÀejYeejele menYeeieer nesC³eemeeþer veeieefjkeÀebveer me#ece JneJes ne J³eeHekeÀ GÎsMe voluntary organisation which empowers the citizen to participate in governance by providing knowledge and enlisting people’s meceesj þsTve 1998 ceO³es Òepee®eer meg©Jeele Peeueer. veeieefjkeÀebveer celeoeveeHegjlee®e participation. PRAJA aims to provide ways in which the citizen efJe®eej ve keÀjlee jepekeÀer³e¢<ìîee DeefOekeÀ me¬eÀer³e JneJes, jep³ekeÀejYeej DeefOekeÀ can get politically active and involved beyond the ballot box, HeejoMe&keÀ Je pevelesuee GÊejoe³eer DemeeJee ³ee ¢<ìerves ceeefnleer Je %eevee®ee mlej thus promoting transparency and accountability. Gb®eeJeC³eemeeþer Òepee mebmLesves efJeefJeOe GHe¬eÀce neleer Iesleues Deensle. Concerned about the lack of awareness and apathy of the mLeeefvekeÀ mJejep³e mebmLeeb®³ee keÀecee®eer ueeskeÀebvee ceeefnleer vemeles DeeefCe cnCetve l³eebvee local government among citizens, and hence the disinterest ³eeefJeIndia. PRAJA is committed to creating a HeejoMe&keÀ, GÊejoe³eer DeeefCe keÀe³e&#ece meceepe efvecee&Ce JneJee ³eemeeþer transparent, accountable and efficient society through ueeskeÀmenYeeieeves keÀece keÀjC³eemeeþer mebmLee Je®eveye× Deens. people’s participation.

MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 1 he´cegKe efJeMues

DeO³ee³e He=<þ ¬eÀceebkeÀ Chapter Pg. No.

Òepee®eer ìerce 4 The Team 5

ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeR®es ÒeieefleHegmlekeÀ keÀe Heeefnpes DeeefCe keÀmes Heeefnpes? 6 Why was a Report Card needed and what does it contain? 7

ÒemleeJevee 8 Foreword 10

$eÝCeefveos&Me 12 Acknowledgements 13

veiejmesJekeÀeb®³ee keÀeceefiejer®es Jemlegefve<þ cetu³eceeHeve 14 Assessing the performance of Municipal Councillors objectively 15

¬eÀceJeejer iegCe leeefuekeÀe 16 Ranking Score Sheet 16

cegK³e efJeMues

keÀe³e&He×leer The Methodology (1) ceeHeob[-cetu³eceeHeve ceespeHeÆer 153 (1) Matrix – Scale of Ranking 164

(2) De@HeÀer[sJnerì Üejs peenerj kesÀuesueer ceeieerue (YetlekeÀeueerve) ceeefnleer 156 (2) Parameters for Past Records as per Affidavit 167

(3) ceneveiejHeeefuekeÀe DeeefCe meefceleer yewþkeÀeleerue keÀeceieerjer mebyebOeer cetu³eceeHeve IeìkeÀ 156 (3) Parameters for Present Performance in the Corporation and Committee Meetings 168

159 (4) pevecele ®ee®eCeervegmeej ueeskeÀeb®eer celes/¢<ìerkeÀesve (4) Parameters for People’s Perception as per Opinion Poll 172

163 (5) vekeÀejelcekeÀ iegCeebkeÀvee®es IeìkeÀ (5) Parameters for Negative Marking 176

2 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 3 ìerce THE TEAM

efJeMJemle ceb[U ceekexÀì efjme®e& Spevmeer Board of Trustees Market Research Agency Hansa Research nbmee efjme®e& Nitai Mehta efveleeF& cesnlee DeMeeskeÀ oeme Managing Trustee, Praja Foundation; Ashok Das keÀe³e&keÀejer efJeéemle, he´pee HeÀeGb[sMeve, GÐeespekeÀ Entrepreneur J³eJemLeeHekeÀer³e meb®eeuekeÀ, nbmee efjme®e& Managing Director, Hansa Research megcebieueer iee[e Sumangali Gada Anjan Ghosh mebmLeeHekeÀ efJeéemle, he´pee HeÀeGb[sMeve; GÐeespekeÀ Debpeve IeesMaharashtra vesne keÀesjer, veeruece efcejeMeer, efveuesMe keÀoce, HeuueJeer Nilesh Kadam, Pallavi Kakaji, Pooja Verma, GÐeespekeÀ Dhruv Mundra Pragati Watve, Prasna Padmanabhan, keÀekeÀepeer, Hetpee Jecee&, he´ieleer JeeìJes, He´mevee HeodceveeYeve, Entrepreneur Radhika Uppal, Rakesh Pote, Rajesh, kesÀ. Sce. Sme. (ìerìg) DenuegJeeefue³ee jeefOekeÀe GHHeue, jekesÀMe heesìs, jepesMe, ªhesMe kegÀceej, Rupesh Kumar, Sangeeta Patwa, Sarika mebieerlee HeìJee, meeefjkeÀe vee³ej, meeF&efkeÀjCe kewÀjcekeÀeW[e, K. M. S. (Titoo) Ahluwalia veeruemeve DeesDeejpeer-ceeie&®es ceepeer DeO³e#e DeeefCe meerF&Dees Former Chairman & CEO Nair, Saikiran Kairamkonda, Shraddha Þe×e iegjJe, MegYece efmebn, mìsHeÀer PesefJe³ej, mJeefhveue A.C. Nielsen ORG- MARG Gurav, Shubham Singh, Steffi Xavier, cegmleHeÀe [e@keÌìj þeketÀj, efJeyesMe keÀekeÌkeÀeHeesFue, efJeÐee leebyeesUer DeeefCe Swapneel Thakur, Vibesh Kakkapoil, Vidya keÀe³eos efJe®eejkeÀ (mee@efueefmeìj) Mustafa Doctor Tamboli and Vipul Gharat. efJehegue Iejle. Advocate jepeve cesnje Rajan Mehra GÐeespekeÀ Entrepreneur efJeve³e meebIeer Vinay Sanghi GÐeespekeÀ Entrepreneur

4 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 5 Why was a Report Card needed and ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeR®es ÒeieleerHegmlekeÀ keÀe Heeefnpes DeeefCe keÀmes Heeefnpes? what does it contain?

DeeHeu³ee osMeeves mJeeleb$³eeHe½eele ÒeeefleefveefOekeÀ ueeskeÀMeener®eer keÀe³e&He×leer mJeerkeÀejueer. cnCetve Heb®ee³eleerHeemetve The People of India have had Elected Representatives representing them in mebmeosHe³e¥le meJe& mlejebJej ueeskeÀebveer efveJe[tve efouesues ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeer l³eeb®es ÒeefleefveefOelJe keÀjleele. various bodies from the parliament to the panchayat for the last 66 years. These representatives have deliberated, debated, questioned, proposed Yeejleer³e mebefJeOeeveeves DeeKetve efouesu³ee ®eewkeÀìerle keÀece keÀjCes, ®e®ee& Je efJe®eejefJeefvece³e keÀjCes, veJes keÀe³eos new laws, passed new laws and governed the nation at all levels using the cebpetj keÀjCes DeeefCe osMee®ee keÀejYeej ®eeueJeCes ner ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeR®eer peyeeyeoejer Deens. Hejbleg iesu³ee leerve mechanisms given to them by the Constitution of India. The 1950 constitution which we gave to ourselves laid out the way in which the country should be oMekeÀebHeemetve DeeHeu³ee jep³ekeÀejYeeje®ee opee& KeeueeJele ®eeueuee Deens. ³ee®eer DeveskeÀefJeOe keÀejCes Deensle. governed. In the last three decades we have seen a steady decline in the l³eeHewkeÀer cenÊJee®eer oesve keÀejCes cnCepes jepekeÀejCee®es Jee{les J³eeHeejerkeÀjCe DeeefCe iegvnsieejerkeÀjCe. quality of governance due to various reasons, prime amongst them being commercialisation of politics and criminalisation of politics, which has created jepekeÀejCee®es yeouele peeCeejs mJeªHe Deece pevelee cegkeÀeìHeCes Heenele Deens. DeeHeues mejkeÀej DeeefCe a huge governance deficit in our country. ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeer ³eeb®³eeJej®ee l³eeb®ee efJeéeeme G[le ®eeueuee Deens. The Electorate has remained a silent witness for most part of this and are feeling oj Hee®e Je

6 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 7 ÒemleeJevee

efveJe[CetkeÀ he´ef¬eÀ³esceO³es celeoejeb®es jepekeÀer³e ¢äerkeÀesve, l³eeb®es jepekeÀer³e efJe®eej, l³eebvee Demeuesueer ceeefnleer ³ee Je DeMee 2609 nesleer, peer 2019 ceO³es keÀceer nesTve 2571 Peeueer. lemes®e, veiejmesJekeÀeb®³ee GheeqmLeleerceO³esner Ieì Peeuesueer IeìkeÀeb®ee l³eeb®³ee celeoevee®³ee efveCe&³eeJej he´YeeJe he[le Demelees. ³ee®e nsletves, celeoejebvee DeefOekeÀ mepeie keÀjC³ee®³ee Demetve 2018 ceO³es 80.7… Demeuesues ns he´ceeCe 2019 ceO³es 77.6… Peeuesues Deens. GÎsMeeves, he´pee®³ee Jeleerves Deeheu³ee ueeskeÀhe´efleefveOeeR®es he´ieleer hegmlekeÀ le³eej kesÀues peeles, p³eeletve l³eeb®³ee keÀeceefiejer®es jepekeÀer³e he#eefvene³e mejemejer iegCe heg{eruehe´ceeCes Deensle: 2019 ceO³es keÀeBie´sme®³ee veiejmesJekeÀeb®eer keÀeceefiejer meJee&le ®eebieueer meJe¥keÀ

8 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 9 Foreword

In the electoral process a voter's decision to vote is determined by various by councillors in the various deliberative bodies of the MCGM marginally fell aspects like their perceptions, political affiliations, the level of information from 2609 questions in 2018 to 2571 in 2019. Similarly, there was a fall in they have and so on. Towards this, Praja's report cards provide a nuanced attendance of the councillors from 80.7% in 2018 to 77.6% in 2019. layer of information on the comprehensive functioning of our elected Party wise, the average scores of Congress (INC) councillors were the representatives. best in 2019 (61.96%) followed by Shiv Sena (61.61%) and BJP (59.54%). This report card is the seventh in the series of Praja's Councillor Report Card Compared to the second year of the previous term, performance of BJP for Mumbai, where we have analysed their working in the deliberative forums councillors has fallen (65.26% in 2014), while that of Shiv Sena (60.56% in and the perceptions of their work by their constituency members. 2014) and Congress (58.60% in 2014) has improved in the current year. For the last term of 2012-2017 we had come up with four report cards and If we analyse the kind of issues that councillors have raised, it shows that for the current term (2017-22) we released one report last year and this is the questions have not been congruent to the type of complaints registered the second report. in their area. A comparison of the questions asked by councillors to the total Before we analyse the information and compare it with the past report cards, complaints in the ward related to civic issues, shows that 206 councillors let me first congratulate the top three rankers of the current year: Sujata received marks below 50%. This means that 93% councillors’ deliberation Patekar (Rank 1 - Score 82.30%), Kishori Pednekar (Rank 2 - Score 81.25%) on civic issues was poor as compared to the complaints made by citizens. and Sejal Desai (Rank 3 - Score 77.33%). Female councillors have performed well in these terms, 11 out of the 15 councillors who had an average score above 50% in terms of asking All the top three rankers are women councillors! When the 50% reservations questions related to complaints in their ward were female councillors. were brought in many states for the local self-governing institutions there were some speculations on the impact that it might have on the quality of Why is asking questions so important? deliberations in the house. However, we can now see with strong data emerging As per our citizen survey of 22,845 households for 2019 conducted by Hansa from our 7 councillor report cards spread across 3 terms that the women Research for us, 93% of the respondents in the constituencies of the top five councillors are now outperforming their male counterparts consistently. councillors who received the highest overall score (average of 78.77%) said The average scores of female and male councillors over the years bear a that there was an improvement in their quality of life; whereas only 66% of testimony towards it: 2011, the female councillors scored 60.06% while male the respondents from the bottom five councillors constituencies, responded councillors scored 58.77%; 2013, the female councillors scored 57.62% that there was an improvement in their quality of life. while male councillors scored 59.66%; 2014, the female councillors scored Let me end this foreword on a positive note of the women councillors 59.41% while male councillors scored 59.40%; 2015, the female councillors performance: An overall gender wise analysis of this year's (2019) report scored 58% while male councillors scored 58.19%; 2016, the female card shows that the performance of female councillors have improved in the councillors scored 62.80% while male councillors scored 61.11%; 2018, the current term as compared to the last term. As compared to the last year, the female councillors scored 59.02% while male councillors scored 60.44%; quality of questions asked by female councillors have improved from 40% and this year 2019, the female councillors scored 60.28% while the male to 42%. Of the Top 10 performers in 2019, 7 were female councillors, while councillors scored 59.98%. We hope now that our political leaders take an there were 5 female councillors in Top 10 in 2014 and 4 in 2018. Whereas inspiration from the data and work towards ways to increase the number of the overall scores of the councillors have improved from 59.4% in 2014 to women law makers. 60.2% in 2019. Let us now analyse the data further: We sincerely hope that our women leaders will now show the light to their Although, the second year of the new municipal councillors elected in 2017, male counterparts in terms of initiative and raising quality questions and help to shows a marginal improvement in overall scores compared to their first make our city well governed thereby improve the delivery of its public services. year, from 59.6% in 2018 & 60.2% in 2019, it seems that the deliberative forums are slightly getting sidelined. The total number of questions asked Nitai Mehta, Managing Trustee, Praja Foundation

10 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 11 $eÝCeefveoxMe Acknowledgements

efJe®eejer DeeefCe DeeHeu³ee O³es³eeMeer ÒeeceeefCekeÀ DemeCeeN³ee veeieefjkeÀeb®ee uenevemee mecetn peie yeouet Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens MekesÀue keÀe, DeMeer MebkeÀener ceveele DeeCet vekeÀe; keÀejCe DeepeJej kesÀJeU ³eecegUs®e yeoue Ie[uee Deens. can change the world; indeed, it’s the only thing that ever has. – Margaret Mead – ceeiee&jsì ceer[

yeoue lesJne®e Ie[sue pesJne ueeskeÀ peeie=le nesleerue, ceeieCeer keÀjleerue DeeefCe leer HetCe& nesC³eemeeþer meJe&leesHejer Òe³elve The change comes when people stand up and demand for it, and then strive keÀje³euee meppe nesleerue. Deepe DeeHeCe SkeÀe DeMee SsefleneefmekeÀ ìHH³eeJej GYes Deenesle, pesJne keÀeUe®eer DeeHeu³eekeÀ[tve to get it. Today we are at that juncture of history where time demands that we ner®e ceeieCeer Deens ö yeoue Ie[JeC³eemeeþer Gþe, meppe Jne DeeefCe lees keÀªve oeKeJee. stand up and demand that change and go and get it. Deepe®ee keÀeU DeeHeu³eekeÀ[tve keÀener þesme ke=Àleer®eer DeHes#ee keÀjCeeje keÀeU Deens. DeMee JesUer Meeble jentve nesCeeN³ee Ieìveeb®es Individuals involved in developing this report card strongly believe that they cannot just wait and remain mute spectators when time is demanding action cetkeÀ mee#eeroej nesCes yejesyej veener. ³ee efJe®eejeves SkeÀ$e ³esTve Deecner keÀener ueeskeÀebveer ³ee Òeieleer HegmlekeÀe®³ee keÀeceeuee meg©Jeele from them. All of them have come together to develop this report card with a kesÀueer. Deece®ee Yeejlee®³ee jep³eIeìvesJej efJeéeeme Deens. v³ee³e, mJeeleb$³e, mecelee DeeefCe yebOeglJe ³ee Ieìvesves Ieeuetve efouesu³ee over-arching belief in the Constitution of India and the opportunity it creates lelJeebvee meeO³e keÀjC³ee®eer meeOeves DeeHeu³ee IeìveelcekeÀ ®eewkeÀìerle®e GHeueyOe Deensle DeeefCe DeeHeu³eeuee DeeHeuee jep³ekeÀejYeej for improved and efficient governance – the mean towards achieving the high DeefOekeÀ ®eebieuee Je keÀe³e&#ece keÀjC³ee®eer mebOeerner jep³eIeìvesletve GHeueyOe Deens, ³eeJej Deece®eer DeHeej Þe×e Deens. ideals of the constitution – Justice, Liberty, Equality and Fraternity. ns HegmlekeÀ le³eej keÀjC³eeceO³es Òepee ìerce®³ee ceveëHetJe&keÀ kesÀuesu³ee keÀe³ee&®ee ceesþe Jeeìe Deens. keÀener J³ekeÌleeR®³ee ceeie&oMe&vee®ee This book is a compilation of sincere, concerned efforts of the Core Praja Team. We ³eeefþkeÀeCeer efJeMes

he´pee HeÀeGb[sMeveÜejs ³ee He´keÀeMevee®eer ceeefnleer He´keÀeefMele kesÀueer iesueer Deens. ns He´keÀeMeve ³egjesefHe³eve ³egefve³eve DeeefCe The contents of this publication are published by Praja Foundation and in no way can be taken to reflect the views of the European Union and other donors Flej oel³eeb®³ee Je He´e³eespekeÀeb®³ee celeebvee He´efleefyebefyele keÀjle veenerle. and sponsors.

12 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 13 AssesSing the performance of veiejmesJekeÀeb®³ee keÀeceefiejer®es Jemlegefve<þ cetu³eceeHeve municipal councillors objectively

Yeejleele meO³ee jepekeÀer³e Heg{eN³eeb®³ee efJejesOeer pevecele le³eej Peeues Deens. HeCe Keje ÒeMve DeeHeCe ³ee The air in India is thick with criticism of politicians. The question that arises is: how can the performance of our elected representatives be assessed jepekeÀejCeer ueeskeÀeb®³ee keÀeceefiejer®es Jemlegefve<þ cetu³eceeHeve keÀmes keÀjCeej ne Deens. ³eemeeþer l³eebvee l³eeb®³ee objectively? Surely the right way cannot be by asking them for their opinion keÀeceeyeÎue keÀe³e Jeeìles ns efJe®eejCes Hegjsmes veener. efkebÀJee keÀener jepekeÀer³e le%e ceb[UeRvee cetu³eceeHeve keÀje³euee of themselves. Nor is it adequate to get a few political pundits (who may have meebieCesner ³eesi³e þjCeej veener (l³eeb®ee mJeleë®eener keÀener SkeÀ keÀue Demet MekeÀlees). their own angles) to evaluate them. HeejoMe&keÀ DeeefCe He×leMeerj mJeªHee®³ee DeY³eemeeletve ueeskeÀÒeefveOeeR®es meceleesue, HetJe&ûenefJejefnle DeeefCe The only way such an assessment can be done in a manner that is, and is efJeéeemeen& cetu³eceeHeve keÀjCes Meke̳e Deens. DeeefCe Demes cetu³eceeHeve keÀjCes ne Òepee Òeieleer HegmlekeÀe®³ee keÀecee®ee seen to be, unbiased and credible, is through a systematic and transparent nsleg Deens. study undertaken independently by respected professionals. That is precisely what The Praja Report Card seeks to accomplish. veiejmesJekeÀeb®es cetu³eceeHeve Heg{erue iees<ìeRJej DeeOeeefjle Deens. The ratings of the Municipal Councillors’s are based on: (De) ceneievejHeeefuekesÀ®³ee efJeefJeOe meefceleer yewþkeÀebvee GHeefmLeleer, efJe®eejuesu³ee ÒeMveeb®eer mebK³ee Je ÒekeÀej (a) Data accessed through RTI on attendance of different Committee Meetings veiejmesJekeÀ efveOeer®ee efJeefve³eesie Fl³eeoer ceeefnleer DeefOekeÀejeKeeueer efceUJeuesueer ceeefnleer. of the Municipal Corporation, number and type of questions raised, use of discretionary funds, etc. (bye) cegbyeF&leerue 22,845 veeieefjkeÀeb®³ee Jew³eefkeÌlekeÀ cegueeKeleer ö ³ee cegueeKeleer SkeÀe ceev³eJej (b) Personal interviews with 22,845 citizens of Mumbai conducted by a mebMeesOeve mebmLesves Iesleu³ee Demetve veeieefjkeÀeb®eer ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeRefJe

14 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 15 Note: (1) Ranking of Vishavanath Pandurang Mahadeshwar (SS) for Constituency no. 87 is not available as he is Mayor from March 2017

MUNICIPAL PARTY DETAILS COUNCILLOR Vishavanath P. Mahadeshwar, Mayor, Mumbai

Birth date: 15-Apr-1960 MUMBAI’S Edu.: Graduate Ward: H/E Area: Hanuman Tekdi, Golibar, T.P.S. 3, SS Sen Nagar. V.N.Desai Hospital 227 COUNCILLORs Ward No.: 87

AND THEIR (2) The ranking of Councillors for Constituency no. 28, 32, 76, 81 & 91 is not available as these councillors have been either suspended/deceased or elected in between the current RANKINGS financial year. And hence, these councillors have not been considered for ranking. (3) While reading the ratings of the councillors in the next pages kindly note the following: (A) The parameter indicating Quality of Questions is summation of scores for ‘Importance of questions asked by issues raised in the question’ (max. marks - 18) and ‘Issues raised compared to Citizen’s Complaints (max. marks - 10), while certain individual parameters (Discretionary Funds, Education Qualification, Income Tax, Awareness & Accessibility, Corruption Index and Broad Measures) are not shown separately. A (B) The grades are given based on actual percentage of marks earned for the particular parameter and are given as below: (a) Grade ‘A’ – Between 100% to 80% (b) Grade ‘B’ – Less than 80% but more than or equal to 70% (c) Grade ‘C’ – Less than 70% but more than or equal to 60% B (d) Grade ‘D’ – Less than 60% but more than or equal to 50% (e) Grade ‘E’ – Less than 50% but more than or equal to 35% (f) Grade ‘F’ – Less than 35%. (4) Number of Questions have a weightage of 10 marks since 2015. Hence, while showing average score on Number of Questions for 2014, the weighted average is shown considering the score of 15 marks. E C F D

16 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 17 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

58.21 12.21 2.90 5.92 5 26.19 2019 D 134 A F F A A

SS B 71.49 29 A 12.76 A 8.64 D 15.40 A 5 C 19.66 2018 Member: Ward Committee R/Central and R/North, Tejasvee Abhishek Birth Date: 27-Dec-1987, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of BMC General Body Meeting, Women and Child Welfare Area: Ganpat Patil Nagar, Ward: R/N, Constituency No.: 1 questions Ghosalkar Committee, Public Health Committee

64.49 13.49 5.81 10.66 5 23.53 2019 C 83 A D E A B

BJP C 64.79 75 A 13.79 E 4.29 E 10.47 A 5 B 23.33 2018

Jagdish Birth Date: 30-Apr-1967, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee R/Central and R/North, Karunashankar Oza Area: Anand Nagar, Ward: R/N, Constituency No.: 2 BMC General Body Meeting, Improvement Committee

61.87 12.63 5.13 16.45 -2 23.66 2019 C 106 A D D F B

SS D 57.02 139 A 12.40 C 6.33 E 12.95 F -7 B 22.01 2018

Balkrishna Birth Date: 11-Aug-1963, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee R/Central and R/North, Shift: Quality of questions; Perceived Jaysingh Brid Area: Ketkipada, Ward: R/N, Constituency No.: 3 BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (Suburbs) Performance

82.30 14.34 9.50 18.58 5 25.27 2019 A 1 A A C A A

SS B 76.02 10 A 13.50 A 8.64 C 18.01 A 5 C 20.85 2018 Member: Ward Committee R/Central and R/North, Sujata Udesh Birth Date: 2-Oct-1973, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, BMC General Body Meeting, Standing Committee, Area: Ekta Nagar, Ward: R/N, Constituency No.: 4 Patekar Public Health Committee

18 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 19 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

72.87 11.81 8.63 18.43 3 22.36 2019 B 15 B A C C B

SS B 70.08 36 A 12.77 A 8.19 C 17.25 F -2 B 23.34 2018

Sanjay Shankar Birth Date: 22-Apr-1969, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee R/Central and R/North, Ghadi Area: Ganesh Nagar, Ward: R/N, Constituency No.: 5 BMC General Body Meeting, Standing Committee

62.93 11.42 4.59 15.03 0 25.89 2019 C 99 B E D F A

SS D 52.94 167 A 13.05 F 1.58 E 10.77 F 0 C 20.55 2018 Member: Ward Committee R/Central and R/North, Harshad Prakash Birth Date: 6-Nov-1993, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of BMC General Body Meeting, Law, Revenue and General Area: Maratha Colony, Ward: R/N, Constituency No.: 6 questions; Perceived Performance Karkar Purposes Committee

69.16 11.29 9.31 16.35 -2 23.54 2019 C 41 B A D F B

SS C 63.68 85 A 13.66 A 9.63 D 14.88 F -7 B 21.89 2018 Member: Ward Committee R/Central and R/North, Sheetal Mukesh Birth Date: 23-Aug-1974, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Housewife, Shift: Quality of questions; BMC General Body Meeting, Education Committee, Law, Area: Kandar Pada, Ward: R/N, Constituency No.: 7 Perceived Performance Mhatre Revenue and General Purposes Committee

76.09 13.14 9.00 19.54 5 20.80 2019 B 5 A A C A C

BJP C 68.94 44 A 12.95 C 6.60 E 13.63 A 5 C 19.42 2018 Member: Ward Committee R/Central and R/North, Harish Ravji Birth Date: 17-Nov-1957, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of BMC General Body Meeting, Improvement Committee, Area: Mandpeshwar Colony, Ward: R/N, Constituency No.: 8 questions Chheda Markets and Gardens Committee

20 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 21 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

69.85 10.80 8.63 18.99 5 20.44 2019 C 34 B A C A C

INC B 79.22 2 A 13.18 A 8.86 B 21.22 A 5 B 22.23 2018 Member: Ward Committee R/Central and R/North, Sweta Sharad Birth Date: 25-Apr-1992, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Shift: Attendance; Quality of questions; BMC General Body Meeting, Women and Child Welfare Area: M.H.B. Colony, Ward: R/C, Constituency No.: 9 Perceived Performance Korgaonkar Committee, Works Committee (Suburbs)

59.15 14.23 0.27 5.71 5 28.94 2019 D 123 A F F A A

C 64.27 78 A 13.93 F 3.16 E 10.41 A 5 B 23.87

BJP 2018

Jitendra Ambalal Birth Date: 15-Jun-1967, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee R/Central and R/North, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Patel Area: Govind Nagar, Ward: R/C, Constituency No.: 10 BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (Suburbs) questions

68.53 13.38 5.81 12.22 5 22.51 2019 C 46 A D E A B

SS B 72.41 22 B 11.71 A 8.19 C 17.39 A 5 B 21.39 2018 Member: Ward Committee R/Central and R/North, Riddhi Bhaskar Birth Date: 7-Aug-1983, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Business, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of BMC General Body Meeting, Law, Revenue and General Area: Daulat Nagar, Ward: R/C, Constituency No.: 11 questions Khursange Purposes Committee, Tree Committee

70.57 12.83 6.68 17.28 5 18.35 2019 B 28 A C C A C

SS C 67.39 54 A 12.82 D 5.97 E 13.52 A 5 B 21.35 2018 Member: Ward Committee R/Central and R/North, Geeta Sanjay Birth Date: 6-May-1972, Edu.: Post Graduate, Profession: Business, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of BMC General Body Meeting, Markets and Gardens Area: National Park, Ward: R/C, Constituency No.: 12 questions Singhan Committee, Women and Child Welfare Committee

22 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 23 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

49.35 11.41 3.40 14.01 -5 20.53 2019 E 188 B F D F C

BJP D 57.35 134 A 13.23 C 6.60 D 15.33 F -5 C 20.16 2018

Vidyarthi Balister Birth Date: 5-Oct-1951, Edu.: Upto Fifth, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee R/Central and R/North, Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Singh Area: Dattapada, Ward: R/C, Constituency No.: 13 BMC General Body Meeting, Standing Committee Quality of questions

70.10 11.75 7.63 18.15 5 18.92 2019 B 32 B B C A C

BJP B 74.87 15 A 12.10 A 8.77 B 20.01 A 5 C 20.96 2018 Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Asawari Birth Date: 6-Jul-1958, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee R/Central and R/North, BMC Quality of questions; Perceived Area: Khatao Estate, Ward: R/C, Constituency No.: 14 General Body Meeting, Markets and Gardens Committee Anil Patil Performance

40.44 5.68 0.68 4.52 5 19.57 2019 E 218 E F F A C

BJP D 50.94 177 D 8.14 F 1.08 F 9.63 A 5 B 22.10 2018 Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Pravin Birth Date: 7-Dec-1955, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee R/Central and R/North, Quality of questions; Perceived Area: Saibaba Nagar, Ward: R/C, Constituency No.: 15 BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (Suburbs) Rikhavchand Shah Performance

68.99 11.11 5.81 15.55 5 23.86 2019 C 42 B D D A B

BJP D 52.88 168 A 12.43 F 1.58 F 9.61 A 5 D 17.23 2018

Anjali Arun Birth Date: 24-Mar-1955, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee R/Central and R/North, BMC Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Khedkar Area: Gorai-1, Ward: R/C, Constituency No.: 16 General Body Meeting, Women and Child Welfare Committee questions; Perceived Performance

24 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 25 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

60.81 9.64 3.40 12.97 5 21.19 2019 C 115 C F E A B

BJP D 59.36 113 C 9.33 F 3.16 E 10.45 A 5 B 21.21 2018

Bina Paresh Birth Date: 17-Jan-1962, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee R/Central and R/North, Doshi Area: Satya Nagar, Ward: R/C, Constituency No.: 17 BMC General Body Meeting, Public Health Committee

65.64 12.65 6.95 17.77 3 20.26 2019 C 70 A C C C C

SS D 59.37 112 A 13.83 E 4.29 D 14.62 F -2 C 19.18 2018

Sandhya Vipul Birth Date: 15-Oct-1975, Edu.: Post Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee R/Central and R/North, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Doshi Area: Charkop Sector 4, 5 & 9, Ward: R/C, Constituency No.: 18 BMC General Body Meeting, Education Committee questions

43.64 8.09 1.27 8.18 0 21.11 2019 E 210 D F F F B

SS D 54.35 158 C 10.11 C 6.60 E 11.06 F -5 B 21.02 2018

Shubhada Subhash Birth Date: 4-Apr-1950, Edu.: SSC, Profession: No Occupation, Member: Ward Committee R/South, Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Gudhekar Area: Charkop Gaon, Ward: R/S, Constituency No.: 19 BMC General Body Meeting, Education Committee Quality of questions

61.55 13.09 4.09 14.57 5 18.80 2019 C 108 A E D A C

BJP B 72.07 24 A 13.15 B 7.69 C 18.56 A 5 C 19.77 2018

Deepak Parshuram Birth Date: 7-Jul-1973, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee R/South, BMC General Body Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Tawde Area: Sahyadri Nagar, Ward: R/S, Constituency No.: 20 Meeting, Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee questions

26 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 27 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

65.40 13.04 3.40 13.79 5 21.53 2019 C 74 A F E A B BJP

Pratibha Yogesh Birth Date: 27-Dec-1978, Edu.: Post Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee R/South, Girkar Area: Parekh Nagar, Ward: R/S, Constituency No.: 21 BMC General Body Meeting

64.66 13.86 6.18 13.76 5 20.85 2019 C 82 A C E A C

BJP B 72.46 20 A 13.43 A 9.36 D 14.48 A 5 B 21.30 2018

Priyanka Prafull Birth Date: 1-Jun-1963, Edu.: HSC, Profession: No Occupation, Member: Ward Committee R/South, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of More Area: Parekh Nagar, Ward: R/S, Constituency No.: 22 BMC General Body Meeting, Public Health Committee questions

56.54 12.18 1.95 9.87 5 22.55 2019 D 148 A F E A B

BJP D 57.05 138 A 12.62 F 1.08 F 9.33 A 5 B 21.12 2018 Member: Ward Committee R/South, Shivkumar Birth Date: 18-Jan-1967, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: Business, BMC General Body Meeting, Improvement Committee, Area: Poisar (East), Ward: R/S, Constituency No.: 23 Basukinath Jha Markets and Gardens Committee

71.67 13.49 6.95 17.57 5 22.65 2019 B 23 A C C A B

BJP B 73.20 19 A 13.54 B 7.33 D 16.62 A 5 C 20.68 2018 Member: Ward Committee R/South, Sunita Ramnagina Birth Date: 1-Sep-1971, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Business, BMC General Body Meeting, Education Committee, Area: Defence Colony, Ward: R/S, Constituency No.: 24 Yadav Women and Child Welfare Committee

28 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 29 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

62.23 11.40 5.13 15.82 5 18.87 2019 C 103 B D D A C

SS C 62.52 93 B 11.76 E 4.79 D 15.42 A 5 D 17.64 2018

Madhuri Yogesh Birth Date: 19-Oct-1987, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee R/South, BMC General Body Bhoir Area: Thakur Village, Ward: R/S, Constituency No.: 25 Meeting, Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee

49.15 8.67 0.68 10.04 5 19.77 2019 E 190 D F E A C

BJP E 37.24 216 E 6.12 F 0.58 F 3.43 A 5 D 17.11 2018

Preetam Gautam Birth Date: 30-Jul-1970, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee R/South, BMC General Body Shift: Attendance; Quality of questions; Pandagle Area: Gautam Nagar, Ward: R/S, Constituency No.: 26 Meeting, Women and Child Welfare Committee Perceived Performance

57.92 8.89 6.68 9.41 5 19.33 2019 D 140 D C F A C

BJP D 59.48 110 B 11.34 E 4.79 E 11.46 A 5 C 19.99 2018

Surekha Birth Date: 30-Jun-1975, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Service, Member: Ward Committee R/South, BMC General Body Shift: Attendance; Quality of questions Manojkumar Patil Area: Lokhandwala Township, Ward: R/S, Constituency No.: 27 Meeting, Women and Child Welfare Committee

37.99 2.64 0.68 3.52 5 21.16 2019 E 219 F F F A B

BJP E 43.78 209 E 7 F 1.58 F 4.04 A 5 C 20.16 2018

Member: Ward Committee R/South, Sagar Ramesh Birth Date: 9-Dec-1989, Edu.: Post Graduate, Profession: Business, BMC General Body Meeting, Improvement Committee, Area: Akurli Nagar, Ward: R/S, Constituency No.: 29 Singh Works Committee (Suburbs)

30 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 31 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

63.75 12.40 6.68 14.75 5 18.91 2019 C 96 A C D A C

BJP C 65.04 72 A 13.77 D 5.52 E 10.72 A 5 C 21 2018

Leena Rajesh Birth Date: 19-Dec-1960, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Professional, Member: Ward Committee R/South, BMC General Body Deherkar Area: Iraniwadi, Ward: R/S, Constituency No.: 30 Meeting, Women and Child Welfare Committee

69.61 14.00 9.27 20.65 -2 21.68 2019 C 36 A A B F B

BJP C 64.96 73 B 10.86 A 9.04 D 14.22 F -2 B 22.81 2018

Kamlesh Birth Date: 18-Feb-1967, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee R/South, Shift: Attendance; Quality of questions Shobhnath Yadav Area: Nilkanth Nagar, Ward: R/S, Constituency No.: 31 BMC General Body Meeting, Standing Committee

73.08 11.61 9.36 19.59 5 18.86 2019 B 13 B A C A C

INC B 76.10 9 A 13.19 A 9.32 C 19.02 A 5 C 20.53 2018

Virendra Tukaram Birth Date: 4-Jul-1967, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee P/North, Choudhary Area: Valnai Gaon, Ward: P/N, Constituency No.: 33 BMC General Body Meeting, Public Health Committee

76.91 10.01 8.13 16.86 5 26.68 2019 B 4 C A C A A

INC B 74.13 18 A 12.02 A 9.18 C 17.52 A 5 C 20.67 2018 Qumarjahan Birth Date: 4-Sep-1966, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Service, Member: Ward Committee P/North, BMC General Body Mohammed Shift: Perceived Performance Area: BMC Colony, Ward: P/N, Constituency No.: 34 Meeting, Standing Committee, Improvement Committee Moin Siddiqi

32 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 33 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

77.33 12.16 8.50 20.30 5 21.77 2019 B 3 A A B A B

BJP B 71.71 26 B 10.95 A 8.05 C 19.56 A 5 C 19.12 2018

Sejal Prashant Birth Date: 22-Nov-1974, Edu.: Under Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee P/North, BMC General Body Shift: Attendance; Quality of questions; Desai Area: Domnic Colony, Ward: P/N, Constituency No.: 35 Meeting, Markets and Gardens Committee Perceived Performance

72.94 12.35 8.50 16.94 5 21.50 2019 B 14 A A C A B

BJP B 74.74 16 A 13.59 A 8.05 C 17.92 A 5 B 21.15 2018

Daksha Jagdish Birth Date: 6-Aug-1966, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee P/North, BMC General Body Patel Area: Pushpa Park, Ward: P/N, Constituency No.: 36 Meeting, Women and Child Welfare Committee

55.29 12.55 1.95 9.54 5 20.25 2019 D 155 A F F A C

BJP C 62.90 88 A 13.24 E 4.29 E 11.56 A 5 C 19.91 2018

Pratibha Hemant Birth Date: 1-Sep-1975, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee P/North, Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Shinde Area: Kurar Village, Ward: P/N, Constituency No.: 37 BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (Suburbs) Quality of questions

56.26 13.95 2.90 11.96 5 16.45 2019 D 149 A F E A D

SS B 70.87 33 A 12.90 B 7.33 C 18.08 A 5 B 21.56 2018

Atmaram Laxman Birth Date: 1-Jul-1960, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Service, Member: Ward Committee P/North, BMC General Body Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Chache Area: Maharani Saibai Vidyamandir, Ward: P/N, Constituency No.: 38 Meeting, Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee questions; Perceived Performance

34 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 35 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

55.07 14.41 0.68 7.86 5 22.12 2019 D 158 A F F A B

SS D 54.14 160 A 13.85 F 1.08 F 8.62 A 5 C 20.59 2018

Vinaya Vishnu Birth Date: 7-Sep-1972, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee P/North, Sawant Area: Gokul Nagar, Ward: P/N, Constituency No.: 39 BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (Suburbs)

66.09 14.32 5.13 18.37 5 17.28 2019 C 61 A D C A D

SS C 65.32 70 A 14.20 B 7.87 D 14.16 A 5 D 16.20 2018

Suhas Chandrakant Birth Date: 21-Dec-1974, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Professional, Member: Ward Committee P/North, BMC General Body Wadkar Area: Sankalp Colony, Ward: P/N, Constituency No.: 40 Meeting, Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee

64.12 14.02 4.09 14.23 5 18.17 2019 C 89 A E D A C SS D 58.96 116 A 14.20 B 7.33 E 12.20 A 5 E 13.33 2018

Tulsiram Dhondiba Birth Date: 15-Dec-1968, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee P/North, Shift: Quality of questions; Shinde Area: Santosh Nagar, Ward: P/N, Constituency No.: 41 BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (Suburbs) Perceived Performance

45.24 7.87 1.27 7.15 5 17.94 2019 E 202 D F F A D

NCP E 43.92 208 C 9.93 F 0.58 F 3.49 A 5 C 18.92 2018 Member: Ward Committee P/North, BMC General Body Dhanashree Birth Date: 14-Jul-1990, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Housewife, Meeting, Improvement Committee, Law, Revenue and General Area: Ambapada, Ward: P/N, Constituency No.: 42 Vaibhav Bharadkar Purposes Committee, Works Committee (Suburbs)

36 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 37 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

59.06 8.80 7.36 14.74 -2 20.55 2019 D 124 D B D F C

BJP C 65.35 68 B 11.08 A 9.18 C 17.50 F -2 B 21.69 2018 Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Vinod Udaynarayan Birth Date: 1-Oct-1973, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee P/North, BMC General Body Quality of questions; Perceived Area: Pathan Wadi, Ward: P/N, Constituency No.: 43 Meeting, Improvement Committee, Works Committee (Suburbs) Mishra Performance

63.20 11.59 5.13 11.13 5 24.35 2019 C 98 B D E A A

BJP C 66.31 62 A 12.41 D 5.52 D 14.88 A 5 C 20.61 2018

Sangeeta Birth Date: 10-Jun-1974, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee P/North, BMC General Body Shift: Attendance; Quality of questions Gyanmurti Sharma Area: MHB Colony, Ward: P/N, Constituency No.: 44 Meeting, Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee

58.26 8.37 4.59 12.37 5 20.28 2019 D 133 D E E A C

BJP C 61.82 100 B 11.19 E 4.29 E 11.33 A 5 C 20.98 2018

Ramnarayan Birth Date: 2-Mar-1945, Edu.: L.C.E.H. (Mumbai), Profession: Professional, Member: Ward Committee P/North, Shift: Attendance Amtharam Barot Area: Lower Govind Nagar, Ward: P/N, Constituency No.: 45 BMC General Body Meeting, Education Committee

59.21 10.08 5.59 13.73 5 19.82 2019 D 122 C D E A C

BJP C 65.73 64 A 12.71 B 7.87 D 15.02 A 5 C 18.23 2018 Member: Ward Committee P/North, BMC General Body Yogita Birth Date: 21-Jun-1975, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Professional, Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Meeting, Women and Child Welfare Committee, Area: Mamaletdar Wadi, Ward: P/N, Constituency No.: 46 Quality of questions Sunil Koli Public Health Committee

38 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 39 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

64.18 11.26 7.63 11.46 5 21.18 2019 C 88 B B E A B

BJP B 72.38 23 A 12.22 B 7.69 C 19.48 A 5 C 18.97 2018

Jaya Satnam Birth Date: 1-Jan-1959, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee P/North, BMC General Body Shift: Attendance; Quality of questions Singh Tiwana Area: Evershine Nagar, Ward: P/N, Constituency No.: 47 Meeting, Works Committee (Suburbs)

61.15 10.45 4.09 15.78 5 20.83 2019 C 110 C E D A C

INC D 52.83 169 A 12.04 F 2.26 F 9.51 A 5 C 19.02 2018

Salma Salim Birth Date: 13-Oct-1956, Edu.: Upto Fifth, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee P/North, BMC General Body Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Almelkar Area: Samana Nagar, Ward: P/N, Constituency No.: 48 Meeting, Works Committee (Suburbs) questions; Perceived Performance

58.16 13.84 1.95 9.22 5 22.15 2019 D 136 A F F A B

SS E 47.42 197 A 12.03 F 1.58 F 4.04 A 5 C 18.77 2018

Sangeeta Sanjay Birth Date: 16-Aug-1972, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee P/North, BMC General Body Shift: Attendance; Quality of questions; Sutar Area: Darivali Village, Ward: P/N, Constituency No.: 49 Meeting, Markets and Gardens Committee Perceived Performance

44.86 10.43 0.27 3.33 5 20.83 2019 E 205 C F F A C

BJP C 63.05 87 A 13.04 F 3.16 E 13.91 A 5 C 20.94 2018

Deepak Birth Date: 27-Aug-1980, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee P/South, BMC General Body Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Jaiprakash Thakur Area: Bangur Nagar, Ward: P/S, Constituency No.: 50 Meeting, Works Committee (Suburbs) Quality of questions

40 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 41 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

64.99 12.96 4.09 13.57 5 19.76 2019 C 79 A E E A C

SS D 55.94 148 A 13.82 F 3.16 F 8.17 A 5 D 16.07 2018

Swapnil Mohan Birth Date: 4-Aug-1972, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee P/South, BMC General Body Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Tembwalkar Area: Jayprakash Nagar, Ward: P/S, Constituency No.: 51 Meeting, Improvement Committee, Works Committee (Suburbs) questions; Perceived Performance

68.82 11.83 8.63 18.86 5 18.50 2019 C 44 B A C A C

BJP B 79.12 3 A 13.23 A 9.41 B 19.82 A 5 C 20.94 2018 Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Priti Birth Date: 5-Jul-1984, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee P/South, BMC General Body Quality of questions; Perceived Area: Mali Nagar, Ward: P/S, Constituency No.: 52 Meeting, Women and Child Welfare Committee Manoj Satam Performance

49.92 9.23 0.68 9.06 5 20.95 2019 E 185 C F F A C

SS E 43.60 211 A 12.22 F 0 F 0 A 5 B 21.37 2018

Rekha Dadasaheb Birth Date: 31-May-1964, Edu.: Upto Fifth, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee P/South, BMC General Body Shift: No. of questions; Ramvanshi Area: Aarey Colony, Ward: P/S, Constituency No.: 53 Meeting, Markets and Gardens Committee Quality of questions

67.18 10.74 7.63 13.60 5 21.60 2019 C 53 B B E A B SS C 66.64 60 A 13.19 D 5.97 E 13.14 A 5 C 19.32 2018 Member: Ward Committee P/South, BMC General Body Sadhana Birth Date: 13-Sep-1949, Edu.: Post Graduate, Profession: Housewife, Meeting, Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Area: Pandurang Wadi, Ward: P/S, Constituency No.: 54 Sadashiv Mane Works Committee (Suburbs)

42 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 43 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

43.20 5.77 1.27 8.54 5 17.62 2019 E 211 E F F A D

BJP D 56.15 147 C 9.65 F 2.26 E 13.82 A 5 C 19.42 2018 Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Harsh Birth Date: 1-Jul-1984, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee P/South, Quality of questions; Perceived Area: Jawahar Nagar, Ward: P/S, Constituency No.: 55 BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (Suburbs) Bhargav Patel Performance

49.31 13.26 0.68 3.69 5 19.68 2019 E 189 A F F A C

BJP C 69.85 39 A 14.41 B 7.33 D 16.51 A 5 B 21.61 2018 Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Rajul Birth Date: 26-Dec-1967, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee P/South, Quality of questions; Perceived Area: Motilal Nagar 2 & 3, Ward: P/S, Constituency No.: 56 BMC General Body Meeting, Public Health Committee Sameer Desai Performance

48.10 11.57 1.95 5.67 5 17.91 2019 E 196 B F F A D

BJP C 69.96 37 A 13.07 B 7.14 C 17.91 A 5 C 19.83 2018 Member: Ward Committee P/South, Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Srikala Birth Date: 29-Sep-1974, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Service, BMC General Body Meeting, Education Committee, Quality of questions; Perceived Area: Bhagatsingh Nagar, Ward: P/S, Constituency No.: 57 Ramchandran Pillai Women and Child Welfare Committee Performance

66.79 14.01 4.09 10.81 5 26.89 2019 C 57 A E E A A

BJP B 71.29 31 A 13.28 C 6.33 D 15.86 A 5 C 20.10 2018

Sandeep Birth Date: 6-Feb-1981, Edu.: Diploma in Production Technology, Member: Ward Committee P/South, BMC General Body Shift: No. of questions; Dilip Patel Profession: Business, Area: Motilal Nagar, Ward: P/S, Constituency No.: 58 Meeting, Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee Quality of questions

44 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 45 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

65.73 12.08 4.59 15.40 5 19.05 2019 C 67 A E D A C

SS C 64.37 77 A 13.39 D 5.97 D 14.75 A 5 C 18.26 2018

Pratima Shailesh Birth Date: 10-Sep-1979, Edu.: D.Ed, Profession: Professional, Member: Ward Committee K/West, BMC General Body Khopade Area: Versova, Ward: K/W, Constituency No.: 59 Meeting, Markets and Gardens Committee

55.63 10.72 2.90 8.10 5 19.69 2019 D 153 B F F A C

BJP C 61.05 104 B 11.46 F 3.16 E 11.22 A 5 C 20.19 2018

Yogiraj Narayanrao Birth Date: 13-Feb-1981, Edu.: Post Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee K/West, BMC General Body Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Dabhadkar Area: Lokhandwala Complex, Ward: K/W, Constituency No.: 60 Meeting, Improvement Committee Quality of questions

58.44 12.50 9.54 17.89 -10 19.29 2019 D 130 A A C F C

SS B 71.23 32 A 13.01 A 9.77 B 21.55 F 0 D 16.28 2018

Member: Ward Committee K/West, Rajul Birth Date: 11-Mar-1962, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Shift: Attendance; Quality of questions; BMC General Body Meeting, Standing Committee, Area: MHADA Colony, Ward: K/W, Constituency No.: 61 New FIR registered Suresh Patel Women and Child Welfare Committee

59.47 13.26 7.36 14.25 -5 20.38 2019 D 121 A B D F C SS

Raju Shripad Birth Date: 5-Mar-1965, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee K/West, Pednekar Area: Oshivara, Ward: K/W, Constituency No.: 62 BMC General Body Meeting, Improvement Committee

46 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 47 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

57.19 9.67 1.95 11.20 5 20.76 2019 D 143 C F E A C

BJP D 57.66 129 B 11.92 F 3.16 E 11.95 A 5 D 17.72 2018

Ranjana Birth Date: 10-Apr-1962, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee K/West, BMC General Body Ujwal Patil Area: Veera Desai Industrial Estate, Ward: K/W, Constituency No.: 63 Meeting, Women and Child Welfare Committee

56.75 10.87 1.27 9.72 5 24.89 2019 D 147 B F F A A

SS D 54.64 154 A 12.92 F 2.26 F 7.91 A 5 B 21.55 2018 Member: Ward Committee K/West, Shaheda Haroon Birth Date: 12-Nov-1964, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: Business, BMC General Body Meeting, Markets and Gardens Area: Shivalik Nagar, Ward: K/W, Constituency No.: 64 Rashid Khan Committee, Women and Child Welfare Committee

63.85 5.66 8.63 16.40 5 18.93 2019 C 94 E A D A C

INC C 64.12 80 E 7.42 A 8.77 C 18.29 A 5 C 18.64 2018

Alpa Birth Date: 30-Aug-1980, Edu.: Post Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee K/West, Ashok Jadhav Area: Amboli, Ward: K/W, Constituency No.: 65 BMC General Body Meeting, Public Health Committee

74.07 12.42 7.95 18.87 5 20.08 2019 B 8 A B C A C

INC C 69.08 42 B 11.68 A 8.86 D 16.44 A 5 D 16.49 2018 Member: Ward Committee K/West, BMC General Body Meher Birth Date: 1-Mar-1970, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Business, Shift: Attendance; Quality of questions; Meeting, Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Area: Dhangar Wadi, Ward: K/W, Constituency No.: 66 Perceived Performance Mohsin Haider Works Committee (Suburbs)

48 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 49 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

60.37 11.16 5.13 14.29 5 18.78 2019 C 118 B D D A C

BJP C 60.59 108 B 11.65 E 4.29 D 14.48 A 5 C 19.17 2018

Sudha Birth Date: 16-Feb-1964, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee K/West, BMC General Body Shambhunath Singh Area: Gulmohor Colony, Ward: K/W, Constituency No.: 67 Meeting, Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee

44.64 10.22 1.27 10.68 -2 18.48 2019 E 206 C F E F C

BJP D 57.38 133 B 10.73 C 6.60 C 17.17 F -2 C 18.89 2018

Rohan Shashindra Birth Date: 21-Aug-1985, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Service, Member: Ward Committee K/West, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Rathod Area: Seven Banglow, Ward: K/W, Constituency No.: 68 BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (Suburbs) questions

55.74 9.43 2.90 12.13 5 20.28 2019 D 150 C F E A C

BJP D 59.44 111 C 9.76 F 3.16 D 14.32 A 5 C 20.20 2018

Renu Kishorilal Birth Date: 31-Dec-1970, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee K/West, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Bhasin Area: Juhu Tara, Ward: K/W, Constituency No.: 69 BMC General Body Meeting, Markets and Gardens Committee questions

65.89 11.24 6.95 16.32 5 21.37 2019 C 65 B C D A B

BJP C 68.79 46 A 12.64 B 7.33 D 16.80 A 5 C 20.13 2018

Sunita Rajesh Birth Date: 1-May-1972, Edu.: Post Graduate,Profession: Professional, Member: Ward Committee K/West, Mehta Area: Prem Nagar, Ward: K/W, Constituency No.: 70 BMC General Body Meeting, Public Health Committee

50 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 51 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

53.85 11.19 4.59 13.29 -2 20.78 2019 D 167 B E E F C

BJP D 57.41 132 A 13.26 C 6.33 E 13.28 F 0 D 16.64 2018 Member: Ward Committee K/West, Aneesh Naval Birth Date: 22-Nov-1977, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Professional, BMC General Body Meeting, Education Committee, Shift: Attendance; No. of questions Area: Juhu Airport, Ward: K/W, Constituency No.: 71 Makwaaney Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee

50.50 12.80 1.27 7.10 5 18.33 2019 D 182 A F F A C

BJP D 56.45 143 A 12.90 F 3.16 F 6.99 A 5 C 20.51 2018

Pankaj Shobhnath Birth Date: 29-Aug-1967, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee K/East, Shift: No. of questions; Perceived Yadav Area: Natwar Nagar, Ward: K/E, Constituency No.: 72 BMC General Body Meeting, Markets and Gardens Committee Performance

54.08 12.62 1.95 4.32 5 25.18 2019 D 166 A F F A A

SS D 56.30 144 A 13.58 F 1.58 F 6.72 A 5 B 22.52 2018

Pravin Gajanan Birth Date: 15-May-1958, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee K/East, Shinde Area: Janata Colony, Ward: K/E, Constituency No.: 73 BMC General Body Meeting, Best Committee

48.77 4.46 1.95 10.39 5 20.97 2019 E 192 F F E A C

BJP E 46.33 203 D 8.86 F 0.58 F 5.72 A 5 B 21.17 2018

Ujwala Birth Date: 27-Aug-1966, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee K/East, Shrikrushna Modak Area: Durga Nagar, Ward: K/E, Constituency No.: 74 BMC General Body Meeting, Education Committee

52 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 53 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

67.01 12.72 6.95 14.69 5 18.05 2019 C 55 A C D A C

SS C 67.77 51 A 12.63 D 5.97 D 15.96 A 5 C 19.19 2018 Member: Ward Committee K/East, BMC General Body Priyanka Pramod Birth Date: 11-Feb-1977, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Meeting, Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Area: Marol, Ward: K/E, Constituency No.: 75 Sawant Public Health Committee

72.28 14.28 9.90 18.33 -2 21.23 2019 B 20 A A C F B

SS C 68.17 50 A 13.11 A 9.63 C 17.46 F -2 C 19.35 2018

Anant Birth Date: 10-May-1965, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee K/East, Bhiku Nar Area: Income Tax Colony, Ward: K/E, Constituency No.: 77 BMC General Body Meeting, Improvement Committee

55.74 12.13 2.90 10.16 5 20.54 2019 D 151 A F E A C

NCP E 40.58 213 A 12.29 F 0 F 0 A 5 C 18.29 2018 Member: Ward Committee K/East, BMC General Body Naziya Birth Date: 1-Nov-1987, Edu.: Upto Fifth, Profession: Housewife, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Meeting, Women and Child Welfare Committee, Area: Shivaji Nagar, Ward: K/E, Constituency No.: 78 questions; Perceived Performance Jabbar Sofi Public Health Committee

72.53 11.35 8.13 17.84 5 19.67 2019 B 17 B A C A C

SS D 57.97 128 A 12.43 C 6.60 D 14.52 F -2 C 18.52 2018 Shift: No. of questions; Criminal case Sadanand Birth Date: 4-May-1966, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee K/East, withdrawn; Quality of questions; Area: Shankar Wadi, Ward: K/E, Constituency No.: 79 BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (Suburbs) Waman Parab Perceived Performance

54 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 55 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

43.00 11.67 1.95 4.47 -2 17.30 2019 E 213 B F F F D

BJP D 50.72 178 B 11.48 E 4.79 F 7.40 F -2 C 20.32 2018

Sunil Lalanprasad Birth Date: 17-Oct-1970, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee K/East, BMC General Body Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Yadav Area: Bima Nagar, Ward: K/E, Constituency No.: 80 Meeting, Improvement Committee, Public Health Committee questions; Perceived Performance

66.94 12.62 7.63 14.46 5 19.58 2019 C 56 A B D A C

INC C 64.41 76 B 11.74 E 4.79 E 13.07 A 5 B 21.08 2018

Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Jagdish Birth Date: 2-May-1967, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee K/East, BMC General Body Quality of questions; Area: J.B. Nagar, Ward: K/E, Constituency No.: 82 Meeting, Markets and Gardens Committee, Tree Committee Kutti Amin Perceived Performance

47.67 10.32 0.27 6.16 5 19.92 2019 E 197 C F F A C

INC E 39.47 214 C 9.58 F 0 F 0 A 5 C 18.88 2018

Winnifred Birth Date: 29-Oct-1959, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee K/East, Baptist D'souza Area: Ambedkar Nagar, Ward: K/E, Constituency No.: 83 BMC General Body Meeting, Education Committee

58.61 10.23 1.95 11.88 5 19.13 2019 D 128 C F E A C

BJP C 65.36 67 A 12.80 E 4.79 E 13.46 A 5 C 18.86 2018 Member: Ward Committee K/East, BMC General Body Abhijit Birth Date: 19-Mar-1966, Edu.: Post Graduate, Profession: Business, Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Meeting, Standing Committee, Law, Revenue and General Area: Koldongari, Ward: K/E, Constituency No.: 84 Quality of questions Ganpat Samant Purposes Committee, Tree Committee

56 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 57 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

65.91 9.88 8.13 18.94 5 18.96 2019 C 64 C A C A C

BJP D 58.23 126 A 12.57 B 7.69 E 13.76 F -5 C 19.87 2018 Member: Ward Committee K/East, BMC General Body Jyoti Birth Date: 10-Nov-1973, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Meeting, Improvement Committee, Law, Revenue and General Area: Shastri Nagar, Ward: K/E, Constituency No.: 85 questions; Criminal case withdrawn Parag Alavani Purposes Committee

59.74 9.61 5.81 14.40 5 18.92 2019 D 120 C D D A C

INC E 45.42 205 D 8.61 F 2.26 F 6.60 A 5 D 15.96 2018 Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Sushma Birth Date: 15-Jul-1976, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee K/East, BMC General Body Quality of questions; Perceived Area: Sahar Village, Ward: K/E, Constituency No.: 86 Meeting, Markets and Gardens Committee, Tree Committee Kamlesh Rai Performance

49.42 14.07 5.59 9.34 -5 19.43 2019 E 187 A D F F C

SS D 53.51 162 A 14.46 E 4.79 E 12.71 F -5 C 19.55 2018 Member: Ward Committee H/East and H/West, Sadanand Birth Date: 4-Jun-1960, Edu.: SSC, Profession: No Occupation, BMC General Body Meeting, Standing Committee, Area: Aagripada, Ward: H/E, Constituency No.: 88 Gajanan Parab Public Health Committee

45.23 13.05 0 0 5 17.57 2019 E 203 A F F A D

SS D 53.02 166 A 13.59 F 1.08 F 5.70 A 5 C 18.62 2018 Dinesh Birth Date: 22-Mar-1970, Edu.: SSC, Profession: No Occupation, Member: Ward Committee H/East and H/West, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Kashiram Kubal Area: Lalbahadur Shastri Nagar, Ward: H/E, Constituency No.: 89 BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (Suburbs) questions; Perceived Performance

58 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 59 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

68.50 11.34 6.18 16.43 5 19.01 2019 C 47 B C D A C

INC B 72.41 21 B 11.05 A 8.05 B 19.63 A 5 C 18.35 2018 Member: Ward Committee H/East and H/West, Tulip Brian Birth Date: 18-Nov-1978, Edu.: BA. LLB, Profession: Housewife, Shift: No. of questions; BMC General Body Meeting, Law, Revenue and General Area: Kalina, Ward: H/E, Constituency No.: 90 Quality of questions Miranda Purposes Committee, Works Committee (Suburbs)

30.60 4.35 0 0 5 15.25

2019 F F F A D AIMIM F 221

F 33.56 220 F 4.68 F 0 F 0 A 5 D 17.88 2018

Gulnaz Birth Date: 30-Apr-1983, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Professional, Member: Ward Committee H/East and H/West, Md. Salim Qureshi Area: BKC, Ward: H/E, Constituency No.: 92 BMC General Body Meeting

68.10 14.19 6.18 10.92 5 23.15 2019 C 50 A C E A B

SS B 75.36 14 A 14.57 A 9.04 E 13.74 A 5 B 22.98 2018

Rohini Yogesh Birth Date: 8-Apr-1982, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: , Member: Ward Committee H/East and H/West, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Kamble Area: Gandhi Nagar, Ward: H/E, Constituency No.: 93 BMC General Body Meeting, Public Health Committee questions

66.38 15.00 8.13 9.87 5 18.15 2019 C 60 A A E A C

SS C 68.64 47 A 14.79 A 9.72 E 12.92 A 5 C 18.31 2018

Pradnya Deepak Birth Date: 16-Sep-1965, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee H/East and H/West, Bhutkar Area: Golibar, Ward: H/E, Constituency No.: 94 BMC General Body Meeting, Education Committee

60 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 61 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

65.95 14.01 2.90 14.16 5 21.22 2019 C 63 A F D A B

SS D 54.30 159 A 12.95 F 3.16 F 7.69 A 5 C 19.49 2018 Chandrashekhar Member: Ward Committee H/East and H/West, Birth Date: 19-Dec-1969, Edu.: D.Pharm, Profession: Business, Shift: Attendance; Quality of questions; Vasudeo BMC General Body Meeting, Law, Area: Kherwadi, Ward: H/E, Constituency No.: 95 Perceived Performance Waingankar Revenue and General Purposes Committee

60.83 10.51 7.63 12.00 5 17.04 2019 C 114 B B E A D

SS D 51.36 175 D 8.29 F 2.26 E 10.78 A 5 C 18.03 2018 Mohammed Halim Member: Ward Committee H/East and H/West, Birth Date: 6-Jul-1981, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Business, Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Mohammed BMC General Body Meeting, Markets and Gardens Area: Bandra Terminus, Ward: H/E, Constituency No.: 96 Quality of questions Shamim Khan Committee, Tree Committee

60.40 10.70 4.59 11.93 5 20.52 2019 C 117 B E E A C

BJP D 58.91 117 B 10.97 E 4.02 F 8.16 A 5 B 21.73 2018 Member: Ward Committee H/East and H/West, Birth Date: 27-Apr-1977, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: Business, Hetal Vimal Gala BMC General Body Meeting, Law, Revenue and Area: Khira Nagar, Ward: H/W, Constituency No.: 97 General Purposes Committee

64.01 11.96 6.18 11.40 5 23.46 2019 C 92 B C E A B

BJP C 69.91 38 A 12.28 A 8.19 C 18.08 A 5 C 18.36 2018 Alka Subhash Birth Date: 11-Jun-1952, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee H/East and H/West, BMC General Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Kerkar Area: Dr. Ambedkar Nagar, Ward: H/W, Constituency No.: 98 Body Meeting, Standing Committee, Tree Committee Quality of questions

62 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 63 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

41.67 7.59 0.68 9.91 -2 21.49 2019 E 215 D F E F B

SS E 49.72 180 C 10.21 E 4.02 E 11.31 F -2 C 20.19 2018

Sanjay Gulabrao Birth Date: 4-Jul-1976, Edu.: ITI Diploma (Technical), Profession: Professional, Member: Ward Committee H/East and H/West, Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Agaldare Area: Khar Danda, Koliwada, Ward: H/W, Constituency No.: 99 BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (Suburbs) Quality of questions

70.25 12.07 5.59 18.58 5 18.46 2019 B 30 A D C A C

BJP B 71.61 27 A 14.28 B 7.87 C 18.21 A 5 D 17.22 2018

Swapna Virendra Birth Date: 24-Mar-1979, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Service, Member: Ward Committee H/East and H/West, Mhatre Area: Pali Hill, Ward: H/W, Constituency No.: 100 BMC General Body Meeting, Markets and Gardens Committee

65.22 13.79 4.59 12.87 5 20.32 2019 C 76 A E E A C

INC B 71.60 28 A 14.24 A 8.55 C 18.25 A 5 D 16.35 2018

Asif Ahmed Birth Date: 3-Jan-1971, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee H/East and H/West, Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Zakaria Area: Bandra Talao, Ward: H/W, Constituency No.: 101 BMC General Body Meeting, Standing Committee Quality of questions

48.26 11.59 1.27 4.06 5 18.69

2019 B F F A C Independent E 195

E 49.44 184 A 12.33 F 0.58 F 3.63 A 5 C 20.00 2018

Mumtaz Birth Date: 4-Jul-1974, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee H/East and H/West, Rahebar Khan Area: Santosh Nagar, Ward: H/W, Constituency No.: 102 BMC General Body Meeting, Public Health Committee

64 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 65 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

63.80 9.60 8.86 13.96 -2 22.49 2019 C 95 C A E F B

BJP C 66.88 57 B 11.58 A 8.86 D 16.36 F -2 B 21.10 2018

Manoj Kishorbhai Birth Date: 25-Dec-1972, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee S and T, BMC General Body Shift: Attendance; Quality of questions Kotak Area: Bhandup Complex, Ward: T, Constituency No.: 103 Meeting, Standing Committee, Tree Committee

52.94 12.00 1.27 5.06 5 21.96 2019 D 174 A F F A B

BJP B 74.26 17 A 12.90 D 5.52 C 17.93 A 5 B 23.45 2018

Prakash Kashinath Birth Date: 29-Aug-1953, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee S and T, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Gangadhare Area: Indira Nagar, Ward: T, Constituency No.: 104 BMC General Body Meeting, Improvement Committee questions; Perceived Performance

68.00 13.80 7.36 13.06 5 21.17 2019 C 51 A B E A B

BJP C 67.73 52 A 14.42 D 5.52 D 15.29 A 5 C 19.47 2018

Rajani Birth Date: 9-Jul-1973, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee S and T, BMC General Body Naresh Keni Area: Gavhanpada, Ward: T, Constituency No.: 105 Meeting, Markets and Gardens Committee

69.45 10.84 7.95 17.16 3 19.95 2019 C 38 B B C C C

BJP C 65.19 71 A 12.95 A 8.46 C 16.91 F -2 C 18.09 2018

Prabhakar Birth Date: 18-Feb-1958, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee S and T, Shift: Quality of questions; Perceived Tukaram Shinde Area: Navghar, Ward: T, Constituency No.: 106 BMC General Body Meeting, Standing Committee Performance

66 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 67 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

58.09 11.50 5.13 11.32 5 20.14 2019 D 138 B D E A C

BJP C 61.32 103 A 13.61 E 4.02 E 11.81 A 5 C 18.15 2018

Samita Vinod Birth Date: 22-Dec-1967, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Service, Member: Ward Committee S and T, BMC General Body Shift: Attendance Kamble Area: Mulund BEST Bus Dept., Ward: T, Constituency No.: 107 Meeting, Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee

55.07 15.00 3.40 6.02 5 19.65 2019 D 157 A F F A C

BJP C 63.94 82 A 14.28 D 5.97 D 14.54 A 5 C 19.16 2018

Neil Kirit Birth Date: 10-Nov-1990, Edu.: Post Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee S and T, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Somaiya Area: Moti Nagar, Ward: T, Constituency No.: 108 BMC General Body Meeting, Public Health Committee questions

58.19 13.55 3.40 9.92 5 21.31 2019 D 135 A F E A B

SS D 57.47 131 A 13.92 F 1.58 F 8.90 A 5 B 22.08 2018

Deepali Deepak Birth Date: 7-Mar-1973, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee S and T, BMC General Body Gosavi Area: Tulshetpada, Ward: S, Constituency No.: 109 Meeting, Women and Child Welfare Committee

59.03 12.98 4.09 7.22 5 23.09 2019 D 126 A E F A B

INC D 56.29 145 B 11.82 E 4.79 E 12.13 A 5 D 17.55 2018 Member: Ward Committee S and T, BMC General Body Asha Suresh Birth Date: 15-Jan-1966, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: Professional, Meeting, Women and Child Welfare Committee, Area: M.M.R.D.A.Colony, Ward: S, Constituency No.: 110 Koparkar Works Committee (Suburbs)

68 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 69 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

68.40 13.75 6.68 9.76 5 23.61 2019 C 48 A C F A B

BJP D 58.42 123 A 13.42 F 3.16 F 8.96 A 5 D 17.86 2018

Sarika Mangesh Birth Date: 15-May-1977, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee S and T, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Pawar Area: Tata Nagar, Ward: S, Constituency No.: 111 BMC General Body Meeting, Public Health Committee questions; Perceived Performance

75.58 13.80 8.13 14.57 5 24.48 2019 B 6 A A D A A

BJP C 65.55 66 A 14.45 D 5.52 E 14.00 A 5 C 19.58 2018

Sakshi Deepak Birth Date: 8-Jul-1978, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Service, Member: Ward Committee S and T, BMC General Body Shift: No. of questions; Perceived Dalvi Area: Dina Bama Estate, Ward: S, Constituency No.: 112 Meeting, Markets and Gardens Committee Performance

62.07 12.23 4.09 15.79 5 19.96 2019 C 104 A E D A C

SS C 69.27 41 A 13.03 C 6.60 D 16.18 A 5 C 19.44 2018 Member: Ward Committee S and T, BMC General Body Deepmala Baban Birth Date: 1-Jun-1968, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: Business, Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Meeting, Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Area: St. Anthony Church, Ward: S, Constituency No.: 113 Quality of questions Badhe Works Committee (Suburbs)

55.69 10.80 1.95 11.33 5 18.95 2019 D 152 B F E A C

SS B 70.45 35 B 10.59 A 8.37 C 18.27 A 5 C 19.01 2018

Ramesh Gajanan Birth Date: 13-Apr-1960, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee S and T, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Korgaonkar Area: Mata Ramabai Ambedkar Nagar, Ward: S, Constituency No.: 114 BMC General Body Meeting, Standing Committee questions

70 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 71 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

45.75 9.43 3.40 8.93 0 17.99 2019 E 199 C F F F D

SS E 48.30 190 A 12.10 D 5.52 F 8.69 F -5 D 17.96 2018 Member: Ward Committee S and T, BMC General Body Umesh Subhash Birth Date: 28-Mar-1974, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Meeting, Markets and Gardens Committee, Area: Samarth Nagar, Ward: S, Constituency No.: 115 Mane Public Health Committee

58.53 12.89 1.95 6.45 5 23.59 2019 D 129 A F F A B BJP

Birth Date: 22-Feb-1990, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee S and T, Jagruti Pratik Patil Area: Hanuman Tekadi, Ward: S, Constituency No.: 116 BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (Suburbs)

53.28 11.17 1.95 7.75 5 20.19 2019 D 173 B F F A C

SS C 63.14 86 A 12.61 E 4.79 D 15.48 A 5 C 19.26 2018 Member: Ward Committee S and T, Suvarna Sahadev Birth Date: 8-May-1957, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: , Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; BMC General Body Meeting, Law, Area: Kanjur Village, Ward: S, Constituency No.: 117 Quality of questions Karanje Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Tree Committee

45.51 12.93 0 0 5 19.92 2019 E 200 A F F A C

SS C 61.96 99 A 13.21 D 5.97 E 12.05 A 5 C 20.73 2018 Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Upendra Dattaram Birth Date: 13-Nov-1967, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee S and T, Quality of questions; Perceived Area: Kannamwar Nagar 1 & 2, Ward: S, Constituency No.: 118 BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (Suburbs) Sawant Performance

72 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 73 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

45.12 12.14 0 0 5 21.97 2019 E 204 A F F A B

NCP E 48.49 189 A 14.11 F 0 F 0 A 5 B 22.38 2018 Manisha Member: Ward Committee S and T, BMC General Body Birth Date: 7-Dec-1972, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Professional, Harishchandra Meeting, Markets and Gardens Committee, Area: Kalaghoda Ramwadi, Ward: S, Constituency No.: 119 Rahate Women and Child Welfare Committee

58.10 13.65 3.40 9.89 5 21.16 2019 D 137 A F E A B

SS E 49.38 185 A 14.40 F 1.58 F 4.12 A 5 D 15.25 2018 Member: Ward Committee S and T, BMC General Body Rajrajeshwari Birth Date: 24-Nov-1963, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Housewife, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Meeting, Women and Child Welfare Committee, Area: Godrej Hill site Colony, Ward: S, Constituency No.: 120 questions; Perceived Performance Anil Redkar Public Health Committee

54.80 14.84 1.27 11.37 5 16.32 2019 D 161 A F E A D

SS E 49.70 181 A 13.86 F 1.08 F 6.77 A 5 D 15.99 2018 Member: Ward Committee S and T, Chandravati Birth Date: 9-Oct-1978, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Service, BMC General Body Meeting, Education Committee, Area: Powai Lake, Ward: S, Constituency No.: 121 Shivaji More Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee

64.39 13.77 9.13 8.82 5 19.02 2019 C 85 A A F A C

BJP D 53.02 165 A 13.78 F 1.08 F 7.21 A 5 C 18.96 2018

Vaishali Shrikant Birth Date: 21-Oct-1976, Edu.: Post Graduate, Profession: Service, Member: Ward Committee S and T, BMC General Body Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Patil Area: Hiranandani Garden, Ward: S, Constituency No.: 122 Meeting, Markets and Gardens Committee questions; Perceived Performance

74 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 75 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

52.91 13.50 0.68 7.78 5 19.96 2019 D 175 A F F A C SS D 51.70 173 A 13.37 F 2.26 F 4.41 A 5 C 19.67 2018

Snehal Birth Date: 13-Jan-1977, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee N, BMC General Body Meeting, Sunil More Area: Vikhroli Parksite, Ward: N, Constituency No.: 123 Improvement Committee, Women and Child Welfare Committee

70.92 12.33 6.95 18.35 5 22.28 2019 B 26 A C C A B

NCP C 60.69 107 A 13.63 F 2.26 F 9.55 A 5 A 24.26 2018

Jyoti Birth Date: 14-Nov-1961, Edu.: Technical Diploma, Profession: Housewife, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Member: Ward Committee N, BMC General Body Meeting Harun Khan Area: R. City Mall, Ward: N, Constituency No.: 124 questions

65.19 10.88 6.95 16.33 5 21.04 2019 C 77 B C D A B

SS D 55.09 153 B 10.80 D 5.52 E 10.69 A 5 C 18.08 2018

Rupali Suresh Birth Date: 17-Jul-1986, Edu.: Upto Fifth, Profession: Professional, Member: Ward Committee N, BMC General Body Meeting, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Awale Area: Godrej Colony, Ward: N, Constituency No.: 125 Markets and Gardens Committee questions; Perceived Performance

62.55 13.41 5.13 10.95 5 19.44 2019 C 102 A D E A C

SS E 45.03 206 E 5.46 F 2.26 F 9.36 A 5 D 16.95 2018 Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Archana Sanjay Birth Date: 31-Jan-1980, Edu.: Bachelor of Dental Surgery, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee N, BMC General Body Meeting, Quality of questions; Perceived Area: Nabard Colony, Ward: N, Constituency No.: 126 Public Health Committee Bhalerao Performance

76 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 77 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

56.90 10.81 3.40 10.29 3 20.74 2019 D 146 B F E C C

SS D 51.83 172 A 14.28 C 6.33 F 7.19 F -2 C 19.04 2018

Tukaram Krishna Birth Date: 29-Nov-1968, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee N, BMC General Body Meeting, Patil Area: Ram Nagar, Ward: N, Constituency No.: 127 Markets and Gardens Committee

53.56 13.45 2.90 4.72 5 21.49 2019 D 170 A F F A B

SS D 54.46 156 A 13.58 F 2.26 F 6.37 A 5 C 20.25 2018

Ashwini Deepak Birth Date: 5-Apr-1979, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee N, BMC General Body Meeting, Hande Area: Barve Nagar, Ward: N, Constituency No.: 128 Women and Child Welfare Committee, Public Health Committee

61.06 14.20 2.90 12.10 5 20.86 2019 C 111 A F E A C

BJP D 58.21 127 A 13.80 F 3.16 F 8.96 A 5 C 19.40 2018

Suryakant Jayhari Birth Date: 25-Oct-1973, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee N, BMC General Body Meeting, Gawali Area: Maneklal Estate, Ward: N, Constituency No.: 129 Markets and Gardens Committee

65.28 11.22 3.40 14.78 5 22.22 2019 C 75 B F D A B

BJP D 53.49 163 A 12.81 F 1.58 E 10.50 A 5 D 16.70 2018

Bindu Chetan Birth Date: 15-Nov-1970, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Professional, Member: Ward Committee N, BMC General Body Meeting, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Trivedi Area: T.P.S. Colony, Ward: N, Constituency No.: 130 Education Committee, Public Health Committee questions; Perceived Performance

78 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 79 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

68.88 12.99 6.95 14.57 5 19.39 2019 C 43 A C D A C

NCP C 66.75 59 A 13.18 D 5.52 D 15.80 A 5 D 17.30 2018

Rakhi Harishchandra Birth Date: 15-Oct-1975, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Professional, Member: Ward Committee N, Jadhav Area: Naidu Colony, Ward: N, Constituency No.: 131 BMC General Body Meeting, Standing Committee

41.01 4.88 0.68 3.52 5 20.93 2019 E 217 F F F A C

E 49.89 179 E 6.52 F 1.08 E 12.02 A 5 C 19.28

BJP 2018

Parag Birth Date: 16-Aug-1969, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee N, Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Kishor Shah Area: Rajawadi Hospital, Ward: N, Constituency No.: 132 BMC General Body Meeting, Standing Committee Quality of questions

43.06 10.38 0.68 10.39 -5 20.61 2019 E 212 C F E F C

SS F 34.78 219 E 5.97 F 0.58 F 6.25 F -5 C 19.98 2018

Parmeshwar Birth Date: 14-Mar-1973, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee N, Tukaram Kadam Area: Ramabai Ambedkar Nagar, Ward: N, Constituency No.: 133 BMC General Body Meeting, Standing Committee

57.01 10.83 1.95 12.04 5 18.54 2019 D 144 B F E A C

SP D 57.25 135 A 12.68 F 3.16 E 12.71 A 5 D 15.81 2018

Shaera Shafahad Birth Date: 8-May-1987, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee M/East, BMC General Body Khan Area: Kamala Nagar, Ward: M/E, Constituency No.: 134 Meeting, Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee

80 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 81 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

64.40 14.35 3.40 12.84 5 20.16 2019 C 84 A F E A C

SS C 64.24 79 A 12.88 F 3.16 D 14.14 A 5 C 19.04 2018

Samiksha Deepak Birth Date: 15-May-1967, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee M/East, Sakre Area: Mohite Patil Nagar, Ward: M/E, Constituency No.: 135 BMC General Body Meeting, Standing Committee

57.96 11.71 6.18 12.36 5 16.71 2019 D 139 B C E A D

SP C 64.11 81 A 12.10 E 4.79 D 15.08 A 5 D 16.40 2018 Member: Ward Committee M/East, BMC General Body Rukhsana Nazim Birth Date: 25-Apr-1972, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Housewife, Meeting, Markets and Gardens Committee, Women and Child Shift: Attendance; Quality of questions Area: Adasa Nagar Phase-II, Ward: M/E, Constituency No.: 136 Siddiqui Welfare Committee, Improvement Committee

41.39 5.71 1.27 8.20 5 15.21 2019 E 216 E F F A D

SP D 54.43 157 D 8.32 E 4.79 E 10.14 A 5 C 18.28 2018 Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Ayesha Rafique Birth Date: 30-Sep-1995, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee M/East, BMC General Body Quality of questions; Perceived Area: Shivaji Nagar, Ward: M/E, Constituency No.: 137 Meeting, Public Health Committee, Works Committee (Suburbs) Shaikh Performance

35.29 4.60 0 0 5 19.69 2019 E 220 F F F A C

SP E 49.70 182 C 10.21 F 1.58 F 7.63 A 5 C 20.28 2018 Member: Ward Committee M/East, Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Ayesha Bano Ain Birth Date: 12-Nov-1993, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Housewife, BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (Suburbs), Quality of questions; Area: Raman Mama Nagar Phase – I, Ward: M/E, Constituency No.: 138 Mohammed Khan Markets and Gardens Committee Perceived Performance

82 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 83 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

53.44 12.54 1.27 10.61 5 16.37 2019 D 172 A F E A D

SP D 58.56 121 B 11.26 E 4.29 D 15.97 A 5 E 14.01 2018 Member: Ward Committee M/East, BMC General Body Akhter Abdul Birth Date: 6-Aug-1967, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: Business, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Meeting, Improvement Committee, Law, Revenue and General Area: Shivaji Nagar Junction, Ward: M/E, Constituency No.: 139 questions Rajjak Qureshi Purposes Committee, Public Health Committee

52.67 9.69 1.95 10.63 5 19.41 2019 D 176 C F E A C

NCP E 48.18 193 C 9.46 F 1.08 F 8.17 A 5 C 18.47 2018 Member: Ward Committee M/East, BMC General Body Nadiya Mohsin Birth Date: 18-Aug-1991, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Meeting, Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Area: Tata Nagar, Ward: M/E, Constituency No.: 140 Shaikh Markets and Gardens Committee, Works Committee (Suburbs)

64.23 13.43 6.95 15.29 5 17.55 2019 C 86 A C D A D

INC C 61.96 98 A 12.32 B 7.33 D 15.73 A 5 D 15.58 2018

Vitthal Govind Birth Date: 1-Jul-1965, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee M/East, Lokare Area: Municipal Colony Sector 1, 2 and H-3 Block, Ward: M/E, Constituency No.: 141 BMC General Body Meeting, Improvement Committee

71.47 13.50 8.13 18.17 5 18.01 2019 B 24 A A C A C

SS C 63.79 83 A 14.18 E 4.79 E 11.34 A 5 C 20.46 2018 Member: Ward Committee M/East, BMC General Body Vaishali Navin Birth Date: 3-Jun-1974, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Housewife, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Meeting, Women and Child Welfare Committee, Area: Lallubhai Compound, Ward: M/E, Constituency No.: 142 questions Shewale Works Committee (Suburbs)

84 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 85 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

50.26 14.26 0.27 6.37 5 18.36 2019 D 184 A F F A C

SS E 43.65 210 A 14.59 F 0 F 0 A 5 C 20.16 2018

Rutuja Birth Date: 22-Dec-1978, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee M/East, BMC General Body Rhadayanath Tari Area: Maharashtra Nagar, Ward: M/E, Constituency No.: 143 Meeting, Markets and Gardens Committee

44.20 12.18 0.27 3.33 5 18.42 2019 E 207 A F F A C

BJP E 38.00 215 B 11.50 F 0 F 0 A 5 D 15.50 2018

Anita Dinesh Birth Date: 31-Oct-1980, Edu.: Upto Fifth, Profession: Housewife Member: Ward Committee M/East, Panchal Area: M.B.P.T. Colony, Ward: M/E, Constituency No.: 144 BMC General Body Meeting, Public Health Committee

53.53 7.52 7.63 17.92 -7 21.46

2019 D B C F B AIMIM D 171

F 27.80 222 E 6.87 F 0.58 F 5.83 F -7 E 14.62 2018 Shahnawaz Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Birth Date: 23-May-1983, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee M/East, Sarfaraz Hussain Quality of questions; Perceived Area: Cheeta Camp Sector C, D, E, G, H, J, Ward: M/E, Constituency No.: 145 BMC General Body Meeting Shaikh Performance

62.87 12.29 6.18 9.17 5 20.61 2019 C 101 A C F A C

SS C 62.57 92 A 12.45 A 8.55 E 11.94 A 5 D 16.73 2018

Samriddhi Birth Date: 18-Oct-1989, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee M/East, Ganesh Kate Area: Anushakti Nagar, Ward: M/E, Constituency No.: 146 BMC General Body Meeting, Improvement Committee

86 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 87 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

63.34 11.88 7.63 11.65 5 18.53 2019 C 97 B B E A C

SS C 62.52 94 B 10.93 B 7.87 E 10.87 A 5 C 18.81 2018 Member: Ward Committee M/East, BMC General Body Anjali Birth Date: 16-Aug-1972, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Housewife, Meeting, Education Committee, Law, Revenue and General Area: R.C.F. Colony, Ward: M/E, Constituency No.: 147 Sanjay Naik Purposes Committee

63.97 13.76 2.90 12.56 5 21.09 2019 C 93 A F E A B

SS C 65.35 69 A 14.53 F 3.16 E 11.58 A 5 B 22.19 2018

Nidhi Pramod Birth Date: 16-Sep-1977, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee M/East, Shinde Area: H. P. Nagar, Ward: M/E, Constituency No.: 148 BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (Suburbs)

69.29 13.88 6.68 16.17 5 18.91 2019 C 40 A C D A C

BJP C 65.69 65 A 13.66 C 6.60 E 13.84 A 5 C 19.60 2018

Susham Gopal Birth Date: 21-Dec-1974, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee M/West, BMC General Body Shift: Quality of questions Sawant Area: Tilak Nagar, Ward: M/W, Constituency No.: 149 Meeting, Markets and Gardens Committee

67.71 11.59 5.13 17.30 5 22.68 2019 C 52 B D C A B

INC C 68.80 45 B 11.47 B 7.69 C 17.26 A 5 C 20.38 2018 Sangeeta Birth Date: 1-Jun-1965, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee M/West, Chandrakant Area: BMC Colony, Ward: M/W, Constituency No.: 150 BMC General Body Meeting, Education Committee Handore

88 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 89 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

59.04 13.58 5.81 14.83 -2 21.82 2019 D 125 A D D F B

BJP E 47.20 199 A 13.28 E 4.29 F 7.58 F -2 D 17.15 2018

Rajesh Omprakash Birth Date: 17-Nov-1979, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee M/West, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Fulwaria Area: Thakkarbappa Colony, Ward: M/W, Constituency No.: 151 BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (Suburbs) questions; Perceived Performance

69.83 13.09 8.13 17.84 5 18.11 2019 C 35 A A C A C

BJP C 66.45 61 A 13.78 C 6.33 D 14.18 A 5 C 19.26 2018

Asha Subhash Birth Date: 3-Feb-1969, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee M/West, Shift: No. of questions; Marathe Area: Chembur Gaonthan, Ward: M/W, Constituency No.: 152 BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (Suburbs) Quality of questions

70.46 14.05 8.13 16.19 5 16.55 2019 B 29 A A D A D

SS B 76.84 7 A 12.63 A 9.50 B 20.00 A 5 C 18.98 2018

Anil Ramchandra Birth Date: 21-Jul-1964, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee M/West, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Patankar Area: Vasant Nagar, Ward: M/W, Constituency No.: 153 BMC General Body Meeting, Best Committee questions; Perceived Performance

62.88 11.08 4.59 15.65 5 20.56 2019 C 100 B E D A C

BJP C 67.35 55 A 13.85 D 5.97 D 15.64 A 5 C 18.99 2018

Mahadev Shankar Birth Date: 1-Jun-1962, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Professional, Member: Ward Committee M/West, BMC General Body Shift: Attendance; No. of questions Shivgan Area: Chembur Colony, Ward: M/W, Constituency No.: 154 Meeting, Improvement Committee, Works Committee (Suburbs)

90 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 91 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

67.16 12.74 7.36 14.28 5 22.78 2019 C 54 A B D A B

SS C 67.66 53 A 12.00 B 7.01 D 15.94 A 5 C 20.71 2018

Shrikant Govind Birth Date: 20-Feb-1965, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee M/West, Shetye Area: Suman Nagar, Ward: M/W, Constituency No.: 155 BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (Suburbs)

66.59 12.35 9.13 16.70 5 18.42 2019 C 58 A A D A C

SS D 55.85 149 C 9.20 E 4.79 D 15.86 A 5 D 16.00 2018 Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Ashwini Ashok Birth Date: 23-Mar-1972, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee L, BMC General Body Meeting, Quality of questions; Perceived Area: Savarkar Nagar, Ward: L, Constituency No.: 156 Education Committee Matekar Performance

51.12 8.22 1.95 9.94 5 20.01 2019 D 179 D F E A C

SS D 54.52 155 C 9.12 F 2.26 E 10.99 A 5 B 21.15 2018

Aakansha Sanjay Birth Date: 15-Jan-1994, Edu.: Post Graduate, Profession: No Occupation, Member: Ward Committee L, BMC General Body Meeting, Shetye Area: Raheja Vihar, Ward: L, Constituency No.: 157 Public Health Committee

54.21 12.09 5.13 8.49 5 18.50 2019 D 164 A D F A C

SS E 49.47 183 A 13.23 F 0.58 F 5.92 A 5 C 18.73 2018

Chitra Somnath Birth Date: 29-Jun-1960, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee L, BMC General Body Meeting, Sangle Area: MHADA Colony, Ward: L, Constituency No.: 158 Improvement Committee

92 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 93 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

64.10 12.70 5.59 13.68 5 22.13 2019 C 90 A D E A B

BJP C 62.40 96 A 14.68 F 2.26 E 10.69 A 5 B 22.87 2018

Prakash Devji Birth Date: 4-Mar-1966, Edu.: Upto Fifth, Profession: , Member: Ward Committee L, BMC General Body Meeting, More Area: Mohili Village, Ward: L, Constituency No.: 159 Public Health Committee

65.68 12.68 5.59 15.09 5 18.67 2019 C 69 A D D A C

SS D 56.97 140 B 11.90 E 4.79 E 13.87 F 0 C 18.50 2018

Kiran Jyotiram Birth Date: 27-Aug-1989, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee L, BMC General Body Meeting, Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Landge Area: Milind Nagar, Ward: L, Constituency No.: 160 Improvement Committee Quality of questions

65.47 12.63 6.18 15.20 3 18.85 2019 C 72 A C D C C

SS E 48.27 192 A 13.40 D 5.52 E 10.91 F -2 E 14.45 2018

Vijayendra Onkar Birth Date: 14-Feb-1978, Edu.: ITI Diploma, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee L, BMC General Body Meeting, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Shinde Area: Lokmanya Tilak Nagar, Ward: L, Constituency No.: 161 Markets and Gardens Committee questions; Perceived Performance

66.46 9.04 6.18 18.02 3 21.62 2019 C 59 C C C C B

INC D 51.54 174 C 10.34 E 4.02 E 11.45 F -2 C 20.83 2018

Wajid Wahid Birth Date: 13-Jun-1982, Edu.: Upto Fifth, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee L, BMC General Body Meeting, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Qureshi Area: Sathi D’souza Nagar, Ward: L, Constituency No.: 162 Markets and Gardens Committee questions; Perceived Performance

94 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 95 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

61.23 10.60 9.36 17.34 -2 16.18 2019 C 109 B A C F D

SS C 61.54 101 D 8.57 A 8.64 D 15.84 F -2 C 20.04 2018 Member: Ward Committee L, BMC General Body Meeting, Dilip Bhausaheb Birth Date: 2-Jun-1961, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Standing Committee, Law, Revenue and General Purposes Area: Sakinaka, Ward: L, Constituency No.: 163 Lande Committee, Improvement Committee

58.44 11.66 3.40 13.05 5 19.32 2019 D 131 B F E A C

BJP D 57.17 137 A 12.36 F 3.16 E 10.11 A 5 C 20.54 2018

Harish Krishna Birth Date: 14-Jul-1980, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee L, BMC General Body Meeting, Bhandirge Area: Kamani, Ward: L, Constituency No.: 164 Tree Committee

72.40 12.00 9.00 18.61 3 18.93 2019 B 19 B A C C C

INC C 64.91 74 B 11.95 A 9.14 C 18.28 F -2 D 16.68 2018 Mohammed Ashraf Birth Date: 16-Feb-1965, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee L, BMC General Body Meeting, Mohammed Aslam Shift: Perceived Performance Area: Cristian Gaon, Ward: L, Constituency No.: 165 Improvement Committee Azmi

46.52 5.01 6.18 11.69 0 17.63 2019 E 198 F C E F D

MNS D 57.23 136 C 9.24 B 7.33 E 12.72 A 5 D 15.94 2018

Sanjay Birth Date: 18-Aug-1966, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee L, BMC General Body Meeting, Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Ramchandra Turde Area: Bailbazar, Ward: L, Constituency No.: 166 Markets and Gardens Committee, Works Committee (Suburbs) Quality of questions

96 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 97 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

54.95 7.41 4.59 13.92 5 19.03 2019 D 160 E E E A C

INC E 49.09 186 D 7.95 F 2.26 E 10.37 A 5 C 18.50 2018 Dilshad Banu Member: Ward Committee L, BMC General Body Meeting, Birth Date: 3-Jul-1962, Edu.: Upto Fifth, Profession: Business, Mohammed Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Area: Vinoba Bhave Nagar, Ward: L, Constituency No.: 167 Ashraf Azmi Public Health Committee

68.78 10.80 10.00 13.48 5 18.68 2019 C 45 B A E A C

NCP B 70.81 34 B 10.88 A 10.00 D 15.50 A 5 C 18.66 2018 Saeeda Birth Date: 14-Jun-1969, Edu.: M.D., DNB, D.A., MBBS, Profession: Professional, Member: Ward Committee L, BMC General Body Meeting, Arif Khan Area: Maharashtra Nagar, Ward: L, Constituency No.: 168 Education Committee, Public Health Committee

65.70 13.47 7.95 13.56 5 19.71 2019 C 68 A B E A C

SS C 68.47 49 A 13.59 B 7.14 D 15.09 A 5 C 19.75 2018 Pravina Manish Birth Date: 6-Jan-1970, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Service, Member: Ward Committee L, BMC General Body Meeting, Morajkar Area: Nehru Nagar, Ward: L, Constituency No.: 169 Public Health Committee

61.82 11.88 5.81 15.53 -2 20.17 2019 C 107 B D D F C

NCP C 62.04 97 A 13.17 B 7.01 D 16.22 F -2 D 17.03 2018 Abdul Rashid (Kaptan) Birth Date: 1-Jan-1961, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee L, Mohammad Area: Evahrad Nagar, Ward: L, Constituency No.: 170 BMC General Body Meeting, Tree Committee Islam Malik

98 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 99 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

73.78 13.57 8.50 21.28 5 19.43 2019 B 9 A A B A C

SS B 71.30 30 A 13.38 A 9.50 C 17.16 A 5 D 16.54 2018 Member: Ward Committee L, BMC General Body Meeting, Sanvee Birth Date: 19-May-1979, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Service, Shift: Quality of questions; Perceived Markets and Gardens Committee, Tree Committee, Area: Chunabhatti, Ward: L, Constituency No.: 171 Performance Vijay Tandel Works Committee (Suburbs)

55.49 10.52 2.90 10.71 3 19.71 2019 D 154 B F E C C

BJP D 52.68 170 B 11.53 E 4.02 E 10.13 F -2 B 22.01 2018

Rajeshree Rajesh Birth Date: 4-Feb-1978, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Professional, Member: Ward Committee F/South and F/North, BMC General Shirwadkar Area: Sion Talao, Ward: F/N, Constituency No.: 172 Body Meeting, Standing Committee, Works Committee (City)

69.31 13.46 5.13 15.67 5 21.39 2019 C 39 A D D A B SS

Ramdas Devidas Birth Date: 20-Jun-1989, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee F/South and F/North, Kamble Area: Pratiksha Nagar, Ward: F/N, Constituency No.: 173 BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (City)

60.59 12.57 4.09 14.38 5 18.55 2019 C 116 A E D A C

BJP D 58.66 120 A 12.67 F 1.58 E 11.58 A 5 C 19.93 2018

Krishnaveni Vinod Birth Date: 10-Aug-1968, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee F/South and F/North, Reddy Area: Wadala R.T.O., Ward: F/N, Constituency No.: 174 BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (City)

100 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 101 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

70.20 12.16 9.54 12.75 5 20.01 2019 B 31 A A E A C

SS B 78.62 4 A 13.35 A 9.27 B 19.78 A 5 C 20.50 2018 Member: Ward Committee F/South and F/North, Mangesh Shridhar Birth Date: 8-Sep-1966, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, BMC General Body Meeting, Standing Committee, Shift: Quality of questions Area: Motilal Nehru Nagar, Ward: F/N, Constituency No.: 175 Satamkar Education Committee

73.72 11.86 9.86 18.79 5 17.20 2019 B 11 B A C A D

INC B 75.53 13 B 11.62 A 9.90 B 20.06 A 5 D 17.95 2018

Ravi Birth Date: 20-May-1960, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee F/South and F/North, BMC General Kondu Raja Area: Sardar Nagar, Ward: F/N, Constituency No.: 176 Body Meeting, Standing Committee, Best Committee

72.49 13.28 8.86 17.18 5 19.51 2019 B 18 A A C A C

BJP C 68.54 48 A 14.57 D 5.52 D 16.62 A 5 C 18.84 2018 Member: Ward Committee F/South and F/North, Nehal Birth Date: 23-Mar-1973, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of BMC General Body Meeting, Education Committee, Area: Hindu Colony, Ward: F/N, Constituency No.: 177 questions; Amar Shah Works Committee (City)

55.25 10.91 4.09 7.10 5 18.48 2019 D 156 B E F A C

SS E 48.95 187 B 11.32 B 7.01 E 10.44 F -2 D 15.19 2018 Member: Ward Committee F/South and F/North, Amey Birth Date: 10-Jun-1986, Edu.: Post Graduate, Profession: Business, Shift: Criminal case withdrawn; BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (City), Area: Kohinoor Mills, Ward: F/N, Constituency No.: 178 Perceived Performance Arun Ghole Public Health Committee

102 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 103 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

64.21 10.50 6.18 13.66 5 18.19 2019 C 87 C C E A C

INC D 57.52 130 B 11.40 E 4.29 F 7.44 A 5 C 18.53 2018 Member: Ward Committee F/South and F/North, Sufiyan Niyaz Birth Date: 10-Sep-1983, Edu.: Post Graduate, Profession: Business, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of BMC General Body Meeting, Law, Revenue and Area: B.P.T. Colony, Ward: F/N, Constituency No.: 179 questions Ahmed Vanu General Purposes Committee, Works Committee (City)

64.80 13.87 6.68 11.08 5 17.55 2019 C 81 A C E A D

SS D 51 176 A 14.36 F 1.58 F 6.87 A 5 D 17.18 2018 Member: Ward Committee F/South and F/North, Smita Sharad Birth Date: 7-Aug-1968, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Housewife, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of BMC General Body Meeting, Tree Committee, Area: Sangam Nagar, Ward: F/N, Constituency No.: 180 questions Gaonkar Women and Child Welfare Committee

57.57 12.29 1.95 11.51 5 21.82 2019 D 141 A F E A B

INC D 59.13 115 A 13.45 F 3.16 E 13.42 A 5 D 17.20 2018 Member: Ward Committee F/South and F/North, BMC General Pushpa Krishna Birth Date: 1-Sep-1962, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: Business, Body Meeting, Markets and Gardens Committee, Women and Area: Korba Mithaghar, Ward: F/N, Constituency No.: 181 Koli Child Welfare Committee

51.41 12.89 1.95 4.25 5 17.71 2019 D 178 A F F A D

SS D 58.37 125 A 12.82 F 2.26 E 10.06 A 5 C 20.33 2018

Milind Dattaram Birth Date: 20-Oct-1964, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee G/North, BMC General Body Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Vaidya Area: Mahim Koliwada, Ward: G/N, Constituency No.: 182 Meeting, Standing Committee, Works Committee (City) questions; Perceived Performance

104 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 105 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

56.91 10.98 2.90 12.86 5 20.16 2019 D 145 B F E A C

INC D 52.23 171 A 12.22 F 1.58 F 7.19 A 5 C 18.20 2018

Ganga Birth Date: 28-Aug-1980, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee G/North, Kunal Mane Area: Dharavi Depot, Ward: G/N, Constituency No.: 183 BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (City)

50.41 11.38 4.59 10.28 -2 21.17 2019 D 183 B E E F B

INC D 55.09 152 A 13.12 F 2.26 F 8.32 A 5 C 19.50 2018

Babu Birth Date: 5-Jul-1971, Edu.: Upto Fifth, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee G/North, Shift: Attendance; FIR registered Safajalli Khan Area: Laxmi Baug, Ward: G/N, Constituency No.: 184 BMC General Body Meeting, Public Health Committee

48.84 11.45 1.27 7.32 5 18.81 2019 E 191 B F F A C

SS E 36.83 217 C 9.34 F 0 F 0 A 5 D 16.49 2018

Jagdish Makkunny Birth Date: 19-May-1959, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee G/North, BMC General Body Thaivalapill Area: Rajiv Gandhi Nagar, Ward: G/N, Constituency No.: 185 Meeting, Markets and Gardens Committee

49.90 13.62 0.68 3.52 5 20.07 2019 E 186 A F F A C

SS E 48.77 188 A 14.15 F 0.58 F 3.64 A 5 D 17.50 2018

Vasant Shivram Birth Date: 5-Apr-1973, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee G/North, Nakashe Area: Mukund Nagar (East), Ward: G/N, Constituency No.: 186 BMC General Body Meeting, Public Health Committee

106 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 107 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

50.75 11.34 0.68 6.63 5 22.09 2019 D 180 B F F A B

SS E 46.47 201 B 11.77 F 0.58 F 3.43 A 5 C 20.69 2018 Mariammal Member: Ward Committee G/North, Birth Date: 14-May-1974, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: Housewife, Muthuramlingam BMC General Body Meeting, Women and Area: Shahu Nagar, Ward: G/N, Constituency No.: 187 Thevar Child Welfare Committee, Works Committee (City)

53.66 10.75 1.27 9.01 5 20.62 2019 D 168 B F F A C

NCP E 40.74 212 B 11.99 F 0 F 0 A 5 D 16.76 2018 Reshmabano Member: Ward Committee G/North, Birth Date: 7-Sep-1984, Edu.: Post Graduate, Profession: Housewife, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Mohammadhasim BMC General Body Meeting, Markets and Gardens Area: Seth Wadi, Ward: G/N, Constituency No.: 188 questions; Perceived Performance Khan Committee, Works Committee (City)

60.90 13.93 1.95 11.06 5 22.95 2019 C 113 A F E A B

SS E 47.48 196 C 9.61 F 0.58 F 5.41 A 5 D 17.85 2018 Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Harshala Ashish Birth Date: 15-Aug-1974, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee G/North, BMC General Body Quality of questions; Perceived Area: Labour Camp, Ward: G/N, Constituency No.: 189 Meeting, Women and Child Welfare Committee More Performance

68.25 11.63 8.63 13.89 5 18.89 2019 C 49 B A E A C

BJP E 47.79 194 C 9.59 F 2.26 F 4.62 A 5 C 19.42 2018 Member: Ward Committee G/North, BMC General Body Sheetal Suresh Birth Date: 2-Nov-1981, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Meeting, Women and Child Welfare Committee, Works Area: Navjivan Colony, Ward: G/N, Constituency No.: 190 Quality of questions Gambhir Committee (City)

108 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 109 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

65.18 10.53 9.72 16.68 -2 19.32 2019 C 78 B A D F C

SS D 56.89 141 B 11.10 C 6.33 E 13.99 F -2 C 19.44 2018

Vishakha Birth Date: 13-Oct-1962, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee G/North, BMC General Body Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Sharad Raut Area: Shivaji Park, Ward: G/N, Constituency No.: 191 Meeting, Standing Committee, Works Committee (City) questions

52.08 12.90 1.27 6.11 5 21.79 2019 D 177 A F F A B

SS E 44.86 207 A 14.33 F 0 F 0 A 5 C 19.54 2018

Priti Prakash Birth Date: 25-Aug-1971, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee G/North, BMC General Body Patankar Area: Babasaheb Ambedkar Nagar, Ward: G/N, Constituency No.: 192 Meeting, Tree Committee, Works Committee (City)

64.06 8.92 9.00 15.47 5 19.67 2019 C 91 D A D A C

SS C 60.98 105 D 7.79 A 8.46 C 17.23 A 5 D 17.50 2018

Hemangi Birth Date: 26-Feb-1972, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee G/South, Hareshwar Worlikar Area: Worli Village, Ward: G/S, Constituency No.: 193 BMC General Body Meeting

74.87 13.93 9.95 19.18 5 20.80 2019 B 7 A A C A C

SS B 78.13 5 A 14.40 A 9.59 B 20.06 A 5 C 20.06 2018 Samadhan Birth Date: 4-Sep-1985, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee G/South, Sadanand Area: Century Mill, Ward: G/S, Constituency No.: 194 BMC General Body Meeting, Public Health Committee Sarvankar

110 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 111 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

58.72 11.99 3.40 12.74 5 19.59 2019 D 127 B F E A C

SS C 69.57 40 A 13.46 B 7.14 C 17.82 A 5 C 18.26 2018 Member: Ward Committee G/South, BMC General Body Santosh Namdeo Birth Date: 18-Aug-1981, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Professional, Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Meeting, Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Area: Lower Parel (W), Ward: G/S, Constituency No.: 195 Quality of questions Kharat Works Committee (City)

73.16 12.29 7.36 18.20 5 21.66 2019 B 12 A B C A B

SS C 66.24 63 A 14.04 E 4.79 E 12.30 A 5 C 19.91 2018

Ashish Ramnath Birth Date: 7-Sep-1963, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee G/South, BMC General Body Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Chemburkar Area: Worli Dairy, Ward: G/S, Constituency No.: 196 Meeting, Best Committee, Works Committee (City) questions; Perceived Performance

72.24 13.30 9.68 17.73 5 21.53 2019 B 21 A A C A B

SS B 75.71 11 B 11.84 A 9.86 B 21.17 A 5 B 21.86 2018

Dattaram Shivaram Birth Date: 8-Nov-1966, Edu.: Upto Fifth, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee G/South, BMC General Body Narvankar Area: Haji Ali, Ward: G/S, Constituency No.: 197 Meeting, Best Committee, Works Committee (City)

65.86 13.90 5.81 13.61 5 18.88 2019 C 66 A D E A C

SS C 69.00 43 A 13.54 A 8.37 C 18.70 A 5 D 15.48 2018

Snehal Suryakant Birth Date: 31-Jul-1972, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee G/South, Ambekar Area: Gandhi Nagar, Ward: G/S, Constituency No.: 198 BMC General Body Meeting, Education Committee

112 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 113 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

81.25 13.67 9.45 18.29 5 24.16 2019 A 2 A A C A A

SS A 81.59 1 A 13.82 A 9.77 B 21.62 A 5 C 20.61 2018

Kishori Kishor Birth Date: 25-Jun-1962, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee G/South, BMC General Body Pednekar Area: Adharsh Nagar, Ward: G/S, Constituency No.: 199 Meeting, Improvement Committee, Works Committee (City)

55.04 12.52 4.09 7.29 5 17.48 2019 D 159 A E F A D

SS E 48.28 191 B 11.93 F 2.26 F 6.48 A 5 D 15.62 2018 Member: Ward Committee F/South and F/North, BMC General Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Urmila Ulhas Birth Date: 5-Jul-1977, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Housewife, Body Meeting, Women and Child Welfare Committee, Public Quality of questions; Perceived Area: Naigaon B.D.D. Chawls, Ward: F/S, Constituency No.: 200 Panchal Health Committee Performance

43.91 13.58 0 0 5 19.33 2019 E 209 A F F A C

INC E 45.68 204 A 13.95 F 0 F 0 A 5 C 20.73 2018

Supriya Birth Date: 3-May-1966, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Service, Member: Ward Committee F/South and F/North, BMC General Sunil More Area: Spring Mill Compound, Ward: F/S, Constituency No.: 201 Body Meeting, Works Committee (City)

70.06 11.24 8.86 18.43 -2 23.09 2019 B 33 B A C F B

SS C 67.08 56 A 12.50 A 8.86 C 17.78 F -2 C 20.73 2018 Member: Ward Committee F/South and F/North, Shraddha Shridhar Birth Date: 28-Feb-1964, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Business, Shift: Quality of questions; BMC General Body Meeting, Improvement Committee, Area: Parmanand Wadi, Ward: F/S, Constituency No.: 202 Perceived Performance Jadhav Works Committee (City)

114 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 115 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

61.91 13.96 5.81 6.83 5 21.65 2019 C 105 A D F A B

SS C 62.77 89 A 14.41 B 7.33 E 10.39 A 5 C 20.60 2018 Sindhu Member: Ward Committee F/South and F/North, Birth Date: 20-Feb-1954, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Housewife, Ravindranath BMC General Body Meeting, Women and Child Welfare Area: Vighnharta Sukhkarta Soc., Ward: F/S, Constituency No.: 203 Masurkar Committee, Works Committee (City)

72.54 13.77 9.77 16.88 3 19.51 2019 B 16 A A C C C

SS D 59.96 109 A 12.98 E 4.79 E 13.38 F -2 B 21.28 2018

Anil Birth Date: 29-May-1964, Edu.: NCTVT (Mech. Engg.), Profession: No Occupation, Member: Ward Committee F/South and F/North, BMC General Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Sadashiv Kokil Area: Megh Wadi, Ward: F/S, Constituency No.: 204 Body Meeting, Best Committee, Works Committee (City) Quality of questions

65.63 14.92 6.18 16.73 0 21.80 2019 C 71 A C D F B

SS C 62.46 95 A 14.79 F 2.26 E 10.25 A 5 C 20.96 2018

Dattaram Rambhau Birth Date: 1-Jun-1962, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee F/South and F/North, Pongade Area: Kalachowky, Ward: F/S, Constituency No.: 205 BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (City)

73.75 14.05 9.63 15.04 5 19.22 2019 B 10 A A D A C

B 76.42 8 A 13.51 A 8.19 C 18.17 A 5 B 21.22

SS 2018

Sachin Devdas Birth Date: 2-Jan-1978, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee F/South and F/North, BMC General Padwal Area: Brick Bundar, Ward: F/S, Constituency No.: 206 Body Meeting, Education Committee, Works Committee (City)

116 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 117 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

57.47 11.29 3.40 9.17 5 20.95 2019 D 142 B F F A C

BJP D 54.11 161 A 12.56 F 1.58 F 7.60 A 5 C 18.34 2018

Surekha Rohidas Birth Date: 18-Dec-1975, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee A, B and E, Lokhande Area: Kasturba Hospital, Ward: E, Constituency No.: 207 BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (City)

64.80 14.05 4.59 11.59 5 23.58 2019 C 80 A E E A B

SS C 63.75 84 A 12.75 C 6.60 D 15.22 F 0 C 20.15 2018

Ramakant Birth Date: 25-Apr-1956, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee A, B and E, Sakharam Rahate Area: Ghodapdev, Ward: E, Constituency No.: 208 BMC General Body Meeting, Improvement Committee

66.08 9.60 9.13 12.78 5 18.68 2019 C 62 C A E A C

SS B 78.10 6 C 10.40 A 9.95 B 19.62 A 5 B 21.23 2018 Member: Ward Committee A, B and E, Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Yashwant Birth Date: 28-Aug-1963, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Professional, BMC General Body Meeting, Best Committee, Perceived Performance; Area: Wadi Bunder, Ward: E, Constituency No.: 209 Kamlakar Jadhav Standing Committee, Tree Committee Quality of questions

45.43 13.23 0.27 2.31 5 18.62 2019 E 201 A F F A C

INC D 58.67 119 A 13.80 F 3.16 F 9.22 A 5 C 19.59 2018 Member: Ward Committee A, B and E, BMC General Body Sonam Manoj Birth Date: 29-Dec-1969, Edu.: SSC. Profession: Housewife, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Meeting, Markets and Gardens Committee, Law, Revenue and Area: Tadwadi, Ward: E, Constituency No.: 210 questions; Perceived Performance Jamsutkar General Purposes Committee

118 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 119 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

71.40 12.38 9.81 15.27 5 18.01 2019 B 25 A A D A C

SP B 75.69 12 A 12.97 A 9.45 D 14.98 A 5 B 22.36 2018

Rais Birth Date: 1-Jun-1974, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee A, B and E, BMC General Body Kasam Shaikh Area: Madan Pura, Ward: E, Constituency No.: 211 Meeting, Standing Committee, Works Committee (City)

50.50 7.47 1.95 10.57 5 19.51

2019 E F E A C ABS D 181

E 47.29 198 D 7.52 F 2.26 F 4.63 A 5 B 21.88 2018

Geeta Birth Date: 20-Jul-1983, Edu.: SSC, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee A, B and E, BMC General Body Ajay Gavli Area: R.T.O. Colony Byculla (West), Ward: E, Constituency No.: 212 Meeting, Standing Committee, Public Health Committee

69.48 13.49 7.36 14.96 5 19.07 2019 C 37 A B D A C

INC C 66.87 58 A 13.42 C 6.60 E 13.69 A 5 D 17.39 2018

Javed Ibrahim Birth Date: 19-Oct-1977, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee A, B and E, Juneja Area: Kazipura, Ward: E, Constituency No.: 213 BMC General Body Meeting, Improvement Committee

43.97 8.51 0.27 2.31 5 22.88 2019 E 208 D F F A B

BJP C 62.71 91 B 11.80 F 3.16 E 12.31 A 5 B 22.44 2018 Member: Ward Committee C and D, BMC General Body Sarita Birth Date: 11-Aug-1976, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Professional, Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Meeting, Best Committee, Markets and Gardens Committee, Area: Gowalia Tank, Ward: D, Constituency No.: 214 Quality of questions Ajay Patil Works Committee (City)

120 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 121 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

54.77 13.96 1.27 9.55 5 20.00 2019 D 162 A F F A C

SS C 60.75 106 A 14.55 F 3.16 D 14.02 A 5 D 17.12 2018 Member: Ward Committee C and D, BMC General Body Arundhati Arvind Birth Date: 28-Sep-1965, Edu.: Upto Ninth, Profession: Housewife, Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Meeting, Women and Child Welfare Committee, Works Area: Bane Compound, Ward: D, Constituency No.: 215 Quality of questions Dudhwadkar Committee (City)

70.72 12.90 7.95 17.78 5 21.09 2019 B 27 A B C A B

INC B 71.94 25 A 14.20 D 5.97 D 16.68 A 5 C 20.06 2018 Rajendra Member: Ward Committee C and D, BMC General Body Birth Date: 26-Jun-1955, Edu.: B.E (Mech.), Profession: Business, Dattatraya Meeting, Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee, Area: B.I.T. Chawls, Ward: D, Constituency No.: 216 Narwankar Works Committee (City)

54.14 11.26 3.40 9.56 5 18.92 2019 D 165 B F F A C

BJP E 46.46 202 B 11.28 F 0.58 F 3.43 A 5 C 20.18 2018

Minal Birth Date: 2-Jun-1983, Edu.: Post Graduate, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee C and D, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Ruchit Patel Area: Papanas Wadi, Ward: D, Constituency No.: 217 BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (City) questions

58.44 9.92 1.95 9.21 5 22.13 2019 D 132 C F F A B

BJP D 58.83 118 A 13.54 F 1.08 F 9.50 A 5 C 19.68 2018 Member: Ward Committee C and D, BMC General Body Anuradha Vijay Birth Date: 13-Mar-1967, Edu.: PHD, Profession: Service, Meeting, Education Committee, Law, Revenue and General Area: Opera House, Ward: D, Constituency No.: 218 Potdar Purposes Committee, Works Committee (City)

122 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 123 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

59.75 11.34 3.40 11.14 5 22.87 2019 D 119 B F E A B

BJP D 59.33 114 A 13.57 E 4.02 E 10.83 A 5 C 18.01 2018

Jyotsna Devesh Birth Date: 29-Jul-1961, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee C and D, BMC General Body Mehta Area: Simla Nagar, Ward: D, Constituency No.: 219 Meeting, Law, Revenue and General Purposes Committee

53.64 10.87 4.59 7.17 5 21.01 2019 D 169 B E F A B

BJP D 55.37 150 D 8.41 F 2.26 F 8.73 A 5 C 20.94 2018 Member: Ward Committee C and D, BMC General Body Atul Hasmukhlal Birth Date: 13-Dec-1956, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Meeting, Best Committee, Law, Revenue and General Area: Gulal Wadi, Ward: C, Constituency No.: 220 Shah Purposes Committee, Works Committee (City)

54.66 11.32 1.95 6.26 5 21.47 2019 D 163 B F F A B

BJP D 53.07 164 A 12.04 F 2.26 E 10.11 A 5 C 20.67 2018

Akash Birth Date: 2-Nov-1982, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee C and D, BMC General Body Raj Purohit Area: Bhuleshwar, Ward: C, Constituency No.: 221 Meeting, Tree Committee, Works Committee (City)

71.68 12.79 6.95 17.46 5 21.05 2019 B 22 A C C A B

BJP C 61.38 102 A 13.81 E 4.29 E 11.86 A 5 C 18.69 2018 Member: Ward Committee C and D, BMC General Body Rita Bharat Birth Date: 3-Jul-1964, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Housewife, Shift: No. of questions; Quality of Meeting, Women and Child Welfare Committee, Works Area: Dhobi Talav, Ward: C, Constituency No.: 222 questions; Perceived Performance Makwana Committee (City)

124 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 125 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

42.14 8.13 0.27 2.31 5 20.43 2019 E 214 D F F A C

INC E 46.67 200 C 9.88 F 1.08 F 3.79 A 5 C 20.93 2018

Nikita Dnyanraj Birth Date: 5-Mar-1990, Edu.: Post Graduate, Profession: No Occupation, Member: Ward Committee A, B and E, BMC General Body Nikam Area: Dana Bundar, Ward: B, Constituency No.: 223 Meeting, Works Committee (City), Public Health Committee

48.71 9.71 0.27 5.69 5 22.04 2019 E 193 C F F A B

INC D 55.12 151 C 10.35 F 1.58 F 9.53 A 5 B 22.66 2018

Afreen Javed Birth Date: 28-Apr-1980, Edu.: HSC, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee A, B and E, BMC General Body Shift: Attendance; No. of questions; Shaikh Area: Paydhuni, Ward: B, Constituency No.: 224 Meeting, Women and Child Welfare Committee Quality of questions

65.47 13.55 4.09 13.63 5 19.58 2019 C 73 A E E A C SS C 62.72 90 A 14.23 E 4.79 E 12.08 A 5 C 20.63 2018

Sujata Digvijay Birth Date: 17-Jul-1983, Edu.: Graduate, Profession: Housewife, Member: Ward Committee A, B and E, Sanap Area: Fort, Ward: A, Constituency No.: 225 BMC General Body Meeting, Standing Committee

48.62 6.93 0.68 8.87 5 21.14 2019 E 194 E F F A B

BJP E 47.49 195 B 11.26 F 1.08 F 3.79 A 5 C 20.37 2018

Harshita Ashwin Birth Date: 23-Jan-1979, Edu.: Post Graduate, Profession: Business, Member: Ward Committee A, B and E, Narwekar Area: Nariman Point, Ward: A, Constituency No.: 226 BMC General Body Meeting, Works Committee (City)

126 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 127 NO. OF QUALITY OF LEAST CRIMINAL PERCEIVED TOTAL ATTENDANCE MUNICIPAL QUESTIONS QUESTIONS RECORD PERFORMANCE PARTY GRADE SCORE RANK COUNCILLOR Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual % Grade Grade Grade Grade Grade out of 15 out of 10 out of 28 out of 5 out of 30

61.04 8.04 4.59 15.87 5 20.53 2019 C 112 D E D A C

BJP D 58.42 124 C 9.18 E 4.29 E 10.65 A 5 B 21.39 2018

Member: Ward Committee A, B and E, BMC General Body Makarand Suresh Birth Date: 20-Sep-1978, Edu.: B.Com, L.L.B., Profession: Professional, Meeting, Standing Committee, Law, Revenue and General Area: Geeta Nagar, Ward: A, Constituency No.: 227 Narwekar Purposes Committee, Works Committee (City)

128 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 129 cegK³e efJeMues

Note for all graphs and tables: Number of Councillors who were ranked in 2014 are 225, in 2018 are 222 & in 2019 are 221. The data covered for 2014 Report Card is from April 2013 to March 2014, for 2018 is from March 2017 to March 2018 and similarly for 2019 is from April 2018 to March 2019.

Overall Grade Question Asked Overall Grade Queson Asked

A - 100% to 80% marks

B - Less than 80% to 70% marks ) 116 (52%) C - Less than 70% to 60% marks 120 113 (51%) (45%

85 (38%) ) 85 (38%) D - Less than 60% to 50% marks

90 ) E - Less than 50% to 35% marks ) )

F - Less than 35% marks 102 (32% (32% ) ) 72 (29% (30% 75 Avg. Score 59.4% in 2014, 70 100 Total Quesons asked' 66 66 59.6% in 2018 & (37% In 2014 : 2841; in 2018 : 2609 & (36% 2014 60.2% in 2019 ) 2571 in 2019 81 80 (30% 60 ) 80 2018 ) 67 ) ) (18% ) ) 2019 (16% 40 (16%

45 (15% (14% 36

(14% 60 35 34 32 31 No. of Councillors of No. Councillors of No. 30 40 4% ) (6%) (6%) (6%) 2% ) 15 8( (5%) 1% ) (4%) 0.45% ) 0.45% ) 4% ) 4% ) 14 4( 4% ) 13 20 13 2( 3% ) 3% ) 3% ) 11 1( 1( 10 9( 9( 2% )

0 8( 6( 6( 6( 0 4( 2014 2018 2019 0 012 to 10 11 to 30 31 to 50 Above 50 A B C D E F Number of Quesons

Attendance Proportion of Questions asked by Aendance Councillors compared to Citizen's Complaints Proporon of Quesons asked by Councillors compared to Cizen's Complaints

A - 100% to 80% aendance B - Less than 80% to 70% aendance 160 C - Less than 70% to 60% aendance Avg. Score 75.4% in 2014, 141 (64%) D - Less than 60% to 50% aendance 80.7% in 2018 & E - Less than 50% to 35% aendance 153 (69%) 140 77.6% in 2019 F - Less than 35% aendance 160 146 (66%) 139 (62%) 113 (51%) A - 100% to 80% marks 120 B - Less than 80% to 70% marks Avg. Score 26.9% in 2014, 102 (45%) C - Less than 70% to 60% marks 26.2% in 2018 & 120 D - Less than 60% to 50% marks 26.4% in 2019 100 E - Less than 50% to 35% marks

) F - Less than 35% marks ) ) ) )

80 (27% ) (25%

60 80 (22% (24% (23% ) ) 55 No. of Councillors of No. Councillors of No. (18% 50 60 53 52 ) ) 41 (13% (12% (10% (10%

40 (9%) 30 (9%) 28 ) 40 23 (5%) 22 (6%) 19 20 (5%) 4% ) 4% ) (4%) 2% ) 3% ) 1% ) 3% ) 3% ) 10 13 (1%)

20 8 10 9( 9( 5( 7( 3 (0.45% 2( 6( 6( 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 2014 2018 2019 2014 2018 2019

A B C D E F A B C D E F

130 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 131 Least Criminal Record Awareness & Accesibility Awareness & Accesibility

FIRs as per Affidavit February 2017 34 New FIRs Registered as on 31st DecemberLeast 2018 Criminal6 Record 120 (53%) A - 100% to 80% marks Charge Sheeted as on 31st December 2018 20 B - Less than 80% to 70% marks Avg. Score 62.5% in 2014, 120 C - Less than 70% to 60% marks D - Less than 60% to 50% marks 74.6% in 2018 & E - Less than 50% to 35% marks

185 (83%) 185 (84%) ) Avg. Score 35.3% in 2014, 200 79.9% in 2019 F - Less than 35% marks 175 (78%) 55.5% in 2018 & 100 58.7% in 2019 (36%

A - 100% to 80% marks 81 160 B - Less than 80% to 70% marks

C - Less than 70% to 60% marks 80 ) D - Less than 60% to 50% marks ) ) (24%) ) )

E - Less than 50% to 35% marks ) 120 (23% (22%

F - Less than 35% marks 54 ) 51

60 (19% 48 (18% ) ) (18% (18% ) ) ) ) 43 41 41 (21% 80 40 No. of Councillors of No. (13% (17% (13% 47 (12% (11%

(12% 40 29 37 (9%) 28 26 25 (8%) 27 No. of Councillors of No. 21 40 4% ) 1% ) 17 9( 0 3( 0 0 000 0000 20 1% ) 0.44% ) 2( 0 0 1( 2014 2018 2019 0 2014 2018 2019 A B C DEF A B C D E F

PerceivedPerceived PerformancePerformance Gender-wiseGender-wise Anal Analysisysis ) 60 A - 100% to 80% marks Avg. Marks of Female Avg. Marks of Male (40% 140 127 (57%) ) B - Less than 80% to 70% marks 126 (56%) 59.4% in 2014, 59.4 in 2014, C - Less than 70% to 60% marks 122 (55%) 52 59% in 2018 & ) 60.4% in 2018 &

(39% D - Less than 60% to 50% marks

60.3% in 2019 60% in 2019 ) E - Less than 50% to 35% marks 50 47

A - 100% to 80% marks (33% 120 ) F - Less than 35% marks (32% ) ) Avg. Score 58.6% in 2014, B - Less than 80% to 70% marks 43 ) 41 (36% ) ) 64.5% in 2018 & C - Less than 70% to 60% marks ) (28% 38

67.8% in 2019 D - Less than 60% to 50% marks ) (37% 40 (37% ) 36 (31% (36% 100 (28%

E - Less than 50% to 35% marks ) 34 84 33 33 33 (23% F - Less than 35% marks ) (32% 30 29 (30% (27%

) 30 ) 80 ) ) ) 25 66 ) ) ) ) ) ) (15% (16% ) (22% (19% (18% 19 19 18 (15% 18 (14% (19% ) 17 (18% 60 17 48 20 16 16 (15% (12% 15 (12% ) 42 13 (11% No. of Councillors of No. No. of Councillors of No. 10 (10% 40 10 5% ) 3% ) 5( 2% ) 2% ) 22 (2%) 1% ) 1% ) 3( (5%) (5%) 2( 2( 2 1( 0 0 0 1( 0 0 2% ) 2% ) 11 20 11 0.45) 0 4( 4( 0 0 1( 0 0 0 Female (120)Male (105) Female (130) Male (92) Female (130) Male (91) 0 2014 2018 2019 2014 2018 2019 A B C D E F

A B C D E F

132 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 133 Top 10 Councillors in Overall

2019 2018 Quality of Quesons Score Score Quality of Questions Constituency Political (out of (out of Ward No. Party Councillor Name 100) Rank 100) Rank 70 (32%) 70 (32%) 68 (31%) 70 65 (29%) R/N 4 SS Sujata Udesh Patekar 82.30 1 76.02 10 ) ) ) )

60 (24% G/S 199 SS Kishori Kishor Pednekar 81.25 2 81.59 1 ) (22% (22% (22% 53 ) 50 50 50 (20% )

(19% P/N 35 BJP Sejal Prashant Desai 77.33 3 71.71 26

50 45 43 (17% ) Avg. Score 48.8% in 2014, 38 P/N 34 INC Qumarjahan Mohammed Moin Siddiqi 76.91 4 74.13 18 40 42.2% in 2018 &

43.1% in 2019 (13%

29 R/N 8 BJP Harish Ravji Chheda 76.09 5 68.94 44 30 (9%) S 112 BJP Sakshi Deepak Dalvi 75.58 6 20 A - 100% to 80% marks 65.55 66 B - Less than 80% to 70% marks No. of Councillors of No. 20 (5%) C - Less than 70% to 60% marks

12 D - Less than 60% to 50% marks G/S 194 SS Samadhan Sadanand Sarvankar 74.87 7 78.13 5 E - Less than 50% to 35% marks F - Less than 35% marks 10 1% ) 1% )

3( K/W 66 INC Meher Mohsin Haider 74.07 8 69.08 42 2( 0 0 0 L 171 SS Sanvee Vijay Tandel 73.78 9 71.30 30 Aver2014age Score for Different2018 Parameters 2019 A B C D E F F/S 206 SS Sachin Devdas Padwal 73.75 10 76.42 8 Average Score for Different Parameters

100.0 Bottom 10 Councillors in Overall 80. 7 79. 9 2019 2018 77. 6 74. 6 75. 4

80.0 72. 5 Score Score

67. 8 Constituency Political (out of 64. 5 (out of 62. 5

58. 6 Ward No. Party Councillor Name 100) Rank 100) Rank 60.0 48. 8 47. 9 47. 8 H/E 92 AIMIM Gulnaz Mo. Salim Qureshi 30.60 221 33.56 220 43. 1 42. 2 M/E 138 SP Ayesha Bano Ain Mohammed Khan 35.29 220 49.70 182 40.0 R/S 29 BJP Sagar Ramesh Singh 37.99 219 43.78 209

20.0 R/C 15 BJP Pravin Rikhavchand Shah 40.44 218 50.94 177

N 132 BJP Parag Kishor Shah 41.01 217 49.89 179 0.0 No. of Quality of Least Criminal Perceived M/E 137 SP Ayesha Rafique Shaikh 41.39 216 54.43 157 Aendance Quesons Quesons Record Performer (out of 15) (out of 10) (out of 28) (out of 5) (out of 30) H/W 99 SS Sanjay Gulabrao Agaldare 41.67 215 49.72 180 2014 11.31 7.25 13.67 3.12 17.58 2018 12.11 4.78 11.81 3.73 19.35 B 223 INC Nikita Dnyanraj Nikam 42.14 214 46.67 200 2019 11.63 4.79 12.07 4.00 20.33 K/E 80 BJP Sunil Lalanprasad Yadav 43.00 213 50.72 178 2014 2018 2019 N 133 SS Parmeshwar Tukaram Kadam 43.06 212 34.78 219 Note: Number of Questions have a weightage of 10 marks since 2015. Hence, while showing average score on Number of Questions for 2014, the weighted average is shown considering the score of 15 marks.

134 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 135 Top 10 Councillors in Attendance Top 11 Councillors in Questions Asked

Constituency Political Score (out of 15) Overall Rank 2019 2018 Ward No. Party Councillor Name 2019 2018 2019 2018 No. of No. of Constituency Political question Overall question Overall H/E 94 SS Pradnya Deepak Bhutkar 15.00 14.79 60 47 Ward No. Party Councillor Name asked Rank asked Rank L 168 NCP Saeeda Arif Khan 96 45 T 108 BJP Neil Kirit Somaiya 15.00 14.28 157 82 128 34 G/S 194 SS Samadhan Sadanand Sarvankar 68 7 42 5 F/S 205 SS Dattaram Rambhau Pongade 14.92 14.79 71 95 K/E 77 SS Anant Bhiku Nar 59 20 45 50 S 121 SS Chandravati Shivaji More 14.84 13.86 161 181 F/N 176 INC Ravi Kondu Raja 52 11 57 13 E 211 SP Rais Kasam Shaikh 48 25 35 12 P/N 39 SS Vinaya Vishnu Sawant 14.41 13.85 158 160 F/S 204 SS Anil Sadashiv Kokil 44 16 8 109 M/E 135 SS Samiksha Deepak Sakre 14.35 12.88 84 79 G/N 191 SS Vishakha Sharad Raut 43 78 11 141 G/S 197 SS Dattaram Shivaram Narvankar 42 21 R/N 4 SS Sujata Udesh Patekar 14.34 13.50 1 10 53 11 F/S 206 SS Sachin Devdas Padwal 41 10 19 8 P/N 40 SS Suhas Chandrakant Wadkar 14.32 14.20 61 70 K/W 61 SS Rajul Suresh Patel 39 130 51 32 K/E 77 SS Anant Bhiku Nar 14.28 13.11 20 50 F/N 175 SS Mangesh Shridhar Satamkar 39 31 29 4

M/E 143 SS Rutuja Rhadayanath Tari 14.26 14.59 184 210 Bottom 15 Councillors in Questions Asked

2019 2018 Bottom 10 Councillors in Attendance No. of No. of Constituency Political question question Ward No. Party Councillor Name asked Rank Constituency Political Score (out of 15) Overall Rank asked Rank Ward No. Party Councillor Name 2019 2018 2019 2018 H/E 89 SS Dinesh Kashiram Kubal 0 203 2 166 R/S 29 BJP Sagar Ramesh Singh 2.64 7.00 219 209 H/E 92 AIMIM Gulnaz Mo. Salim Qureshi 0 221 0 220 S 118 SS Upendra Dattaram Sawant 0 200 10 99 H/E 92 AIMIM Gulnaz Mo. Salim Qureshi 4.35 4.68 221 220 S 119 NCP Manisha Harishchandra Rahate 0 204 0 189 K/E 74 BJP Ujwala Shrikrushna Modak 4.46 8.86 192 203 M/E 138 SP Ayesha Bano Ain Mohammed Khan 0 220 3 182 F/S 201 INC Supriya Sunil More 0 209 0 204 M/E 138 SP Ayesha Bano Ain Mohammed Khan 4.60 10.21 220 182 R/C 10 BJP Jitendra Ambalal Patel 1 123 5 78 N 132 BJP Parag Kishor Shah 4.88 217 6.52 179 P/S 50 BJP Deepak Jaiprakash Thakur 1 205 5 87

L 166 MNS Sanjay Ramchandra Turde 5.01 9.24 198 136 K/E 83 INC Winnifred Baptist D'souza 1 197 0 214 M/E 143 SS Rutuja Rhadayanath Tari 1 184 0 210 K/W 65 INC Alpa Ashok Jadhav 5.66 7.42 94 80 M/E 144 BJP Anita Dinesh Panchal 1 207 0 215 R/C 15 BJP Pravin Rikhavchand Shah 5.68 8.14 218 177 E 210 INC Sonam Manoj Jamsutkar 1 201 5 119 D 214 BJP Sarita Ajay Patil 1 208 5 91 M/E 137 SP Ayesha Rafique Shaikh 5.71 8.32 216 157 B 223 INC Nikita Dnyanraj Nikam 1 214 2 200 P/S 55 BJP Harsh Bhargav Patel 5.77 211 9.65 147 B 224 INC Afreen Javed Shaikh 1 193 3 151

136 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 137 Top 10 Councillors in Quality Questions Asked Top 10 Councillors in Perceived Performance

Constituency Political Score (out of 28) Overall Rank Constituency Political Score (out of 30) Overall Rank Ward No. Party Councillor Name 2019 2018 2019 2018 Ward No. Party Councillor Name 2019 2018 2019 2018 L 171 SS Sanvee Vijay Tandel 21.28 17.16 9 30 R/C 10 BJP Jitendra Ambalal Patel 28.94 23.87 123 78

R/S 31 BJP Kamlesh Shobhnath Yadav 20.65 14.22 36 73 P/S 58 BJP Sandeep Dilip Patel 26.89 20.10 57 31

P/N 35 BJP Sejal Prashant Desai 20.30 19.56 3 26 P/N 34 INC Qumarjahan Mohammed Moin Siddiqi 26.68 20.67 4 18

P/N 33 INC Virendra Tukaram Choudhary 19.59 19.02 13 9 R/N 1 SS Tejasvee Abhishek Ghosalkar 26.19 19.66 134 29

R/N 8 BJP Harish Ravji Chheda 19.54 13.63 5 44 R/N 6 SS Harshad Prakash Karkar 25.89 20.55 99 167

G/S 194 SS Samadhan Sadanand Sarvankar 19.18 20.06 7 5 R/N 4 SS Sujata Udesh Patekar 25.27 20.85 1 10

R/C 9 INC Sweta Sharad Korgaonkar 18.99 21.22 34 2 K/E 73 SS Pravin Gajanan Shinde 25.18 22.52 166 144

K/E 85 BJP Jyoti Parag Alavani 18.94 13.76 64 126 K/W 64 SS Shaheda Haroon Rashid Khan 24.89 21.55 147 154

K/W 66 INC Meher Mohsin Haider 18.87 16.44 8 42 S 112 BJP Sakshi Deepak Dalvi 24.48 19.58 6 66

P/S 52 BJP Priti Manoj Satam 18.86 19.82 44 3 P/N 44 BJP Sangeeta Gyanmurti Sharma 24.35 20.61 98 62

Bottom 11 Councillors in Quality Questions Asked Bottom 10 Councillors in Perceived Performance

Constituency Political Score (out of 28) Overall Rank Constituency Political Score (out of 30) Overall Rank Ward No. Party Councillor Name 2019 2018 2019 2018 Ward No. Party Councillor Name 2019 2018 2019 2018 H/E 89 SS Dinesh Kashiram Kubal 0.00 5.70 203 166 M/E 137 SP Ayesha Rafique Shaikh 15.21 18.28 216 157

H/E 92 AIMIM Gulnaz Mo. Salim Qureshi 0.00 0.00 221 220 H/E 92 AIMIM Gulnaz Mo. Salim Qureshi 15.25 17.88 221 220

S 118 SS Upendra Dattaram Sawant 0.00 12.05 200 99 L 163 SS Dilip Bhausaheb Lande 16.18 20.04 109 101

S 119 NCP Manisha Harishchandra Rahate 0.00 0.00 204 189 S 121 SS Chandravati Shivaji More 16.32 15.99 161 181

M/E 138 SP Ayesha Bano Ain Mohammed Khan 0.00 7.63 220 182 M/E 139 SP Akhter Abdul Rajjak Qureshi 16.37 14.01 172 121 F/S 201 INC Supriya Sunil More 0.00 209 0.00 204 P/N 38 SS Atmaram Laxman Chache 16.45 21.56 149 33 E 210 INC Sonam Manoj Jamsutkar 2.31 9.22 201 119 M/W 153 SS Anil Ramchandra Patankar 16.55 18.98 29 7 D 214 BJP Sarita Ajay Patil 2.31 12.31 208 91 M/E 136 SP Rukhsana Nazim Siddiqui 16.71 16.40 139 81 B 223 INC Nikita Dnyanraj Nikam 2.31 3.79 214 200 SS Mohammed Halim Mohammed Shamim 17.04 18.03 114 175 H/E 96 P/S 50 BJP Deepak Jaiprakash Thakur 3.33 13.91 205 87 Khan

M/E 144 BJP Anita Dinesh Panchal 3.33 0.00 207 215 F/N 176 INC Ravi Kondu Raja 17.20 17.95 11 13

138 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 139 Top 10 Councillors in Awareness & Accessibility Top 11 Councillors in Discussion

Constituency Political Score (out of 5) Overall Rank Constituency Political Score (out of 5) Overall Rank Ward No. Party Councillor Name 2019 2018 2019 2018 Ward No. Party Councillor Name 2019 2018 2019 2018 R/C 10 BJP Jitendra Ambalal Patel 4.96 4.39 123 78 F/N 176 INC Ravi Kondu Raja 5.00 5.00 11 13

H/E 93 SS Rohini Yogesh Kamble 4.96 4.78 50 14 N 131 NCP Rakhi Harishchandra Jadhav 4.98 4.95 43 59

T 103 BJP Manoj Kishorbhai Kotak 4.85 3.89 95 57 G/N 191 SS Vishakha Sharad Raut 4.93 3.03 78 141

L 159 BJP Prakash Devji More 4.83 4.78 90 96 E 211 SP Rais Kasam Shaikh 4.93 4.93 25 12

R/S 31 BJP Kamlesh Shobhnath Yadav 4.70 4.35 36 73 T 103 BJP Manoj Kishorbhai Kotak 4.89 4.98 95 57

R/C 11 SS Riddhi Bhaskar Khursange 4.65 4.34 46 22 E 209 SS Yashwant Kamlakar Jadhav 4.89 4.91 62 6

P/N 36 BJP Daksha Jagdish Patel 4.62 4.67 14 16 INC Mohammed Ashraf Mohammed 4.86 4.86 19 74 L 165 Aslam Azmi G/S 197 SS Dattaram Shivaram Narvankar 4.60 4.05 21 11 L 168 NCP Saeeda Arif Khan 4.82 4.77 45 34 P/N 39 SS Vinaya Vishnu Sawant 4.56 4.02 158 160 F/S 206 SS Sachin Devdas Padwal 4.82 4.34 10 8 H/E 88 SS Sadanand Gajanan Parab 4.56 3.85 187 162 K/W 66 INC Meher Mohsin Haider 4.75 4.62 8 42

L 163 SS Dilip Bhausaheb Lande 4.75 4.46 109 101 Bottom 10 Councillors in Awareness & Accessibility F/N 175 SS Mangesh Shridhar Satamkar 4.75 4.73 31 4 Constituency Political Score (out of 5) Overall Rank Ward No. Party Councillor Name 2019 2018 2019 2018 G/N 188 NCP Reshmabano Mohammadhasim Khan 0.75 1.46 168 212

D 219 BJP Jyotsna Devesh Mehta 0.88 1.45 119 114

M/E 136 SP Rukhsana Nazim Siddiqui 1.00 0.96 139 81

P/N 41 SS Tulsiram Dhondiba Shinde 1.25 1.13 89 116

M/E 139 SP Akhter Abdul Rajjak Qureshi 1.27 0.88 172 121

L 161 SS Vijayendra Onkar Shinde 1.29 1.01 72 192

F/S 200 SS Urmila Ulhas Panchal 1.29 1.08 159 191

M/E 137 SP Ayesha Rafique Shaikh 1.34 1.54 216 157

L 156 SS Ashwini Ashok Matekar 1.41 1.16 58 149

F/N 180 SS Smita Sharad Gaonkar 1.41 1.38 81 176

140 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 141 RANK OF PARTY HEAD/COMMITTEE CHAIRPERSON 2019-2020 PARTY WISE SCORE

Constituency Party Head/ Score 2014 2018 2019 Ward No. Councillors Committee Chairperson (out of 100) Rank Political Party Score Rank Score Rank Score Rank R/C 18 Sandhya Vipul Doshi R/C & R/N Ward Committee 65.64 70 AIMIM – – 30.68 221 42.06 196

R/S 26 Preetam Gautam Pandagle R/S Ward Committee 49.15 190 Akhil Bharatiya Sena 51.36 176 47.29 198 50.50 181

P/N 43 Vinod Udaynarayan Mishra P/N Ward Committee 59.06 124 Bharatiya Janata Party 65.26 76 60.31 106 59.54 116

P/S 57 Srikala Ramchandran Pillai P/S Ward Committee 48.10 196 Bhartiya Republican Party Bahujan Mahasangha 51.40 179 – – – –

K/W 71 Aneesh Naval Makwaaney K/W Ward Committee 53.85 167 Bhartiya Shetkari Kamgar – – – – – – Independent 52.83 146 54.27 153 48.26 195 K/E 80 Sunil Lalanprasad Yadav K/E Ward Committee 43.00 213 Indian National Congress 58.60 119 60.69 106 61.96 97 H/E 95 Chandrashekhar Vasudeo Waingankar H/E & H/W Ward Committee 65.95 63 Maharashtra Navnirman Sena 56.50 127 57.23 136 46.52 198 T 106 Prabhakar Tukaram Shinde S & T Ward Committee 69.45 38 Nationalist Congress Party 58.13 120 53.58 146 58.09 125 N 133 Parmeshwar Tukaram Kadam N Ward Committee 43.06 212 Republican Party Of India RPI(A) 43.54 208 – – – – M/E 142 Vaishali Navin Shewale M/E Ward Committee 71.47 24 Samajwadi Party 59.95 103 59.96 115 52.75 153 M/W 152 Asha Subhash Marathe M/W Ward Committee 69.83 35 Shiv Sena 60.56 109 60.25 109 61.61 102 L 156 Ashwini Ashok Matekar L Ward Committee 66.59 58

G/N 186 Vasant Shivram Nakashe G/N Ward Committee 49.90 186 G/S 194 Samadhan Sadanand Sarvankar G/S Ward Committee 74.87 7 PARTY WISE NUMBER OF MEMBERS F/S 205 Dattaram Rambhau Pongade F/N & F/S Ward Committee 65.63 71

C 221 Akash Raj Purohit C & D Ward Committee 54.66 163 2014 2018 2019

A 227 Makarand Suresh Narwekar A, B & E Ward Committee 61.04 112 Political Party R T R T R T

M/W 153 Anil Ramchandra Patankar BEST Committee 70.46 29 AIMIM – – 2 2 2 2 Akhil Bharatiya Sena 2 2 1 1 1 1 M/E 147 Anjali Sanjay Naik Education Committee 63.34 97 Bharatiya Janata Party 31 31 81 84 81 81 H/E 88 Sadanand Gajanan Parab Improvements Committee 49.42 187 Bhartiya Republican Party Bahujan Mahasangha 1 1 – – – – R/N 7 Sheetal Mukesh Mhatre Law, Revenue and General Purposes 69.16 41 Committee Bhartiya Shetkari Kamgar 1 – – – –

S 115 Umesh Subhash Mane Markets & Gardens Committee 45.75 199 Independent 14 14 4 5 1 1

F/N 178 Amey Arun Ghole Public Health Committee 55.25 156 Indian National Congress 52 52 30 31 28 29

E 209 Yashwant Kamlakar Jadhav Standing Committee 66.08 62 Maharashtra Navnirman Sena 28 28 1 1 1 1 Nationalist Congress Party 13 13 9 9 9 9 G/N 189 Harshala Ashish More Women & Child Welfare Committee 60.90 113 Republican Party Of India RPI(A) 1 1 – – – – G/N 192 Priti Prakash Patankar Works Committee (City) 52.08 177 Samajwadi Party 9 9 6 6 6 6 S 118 Upendra Dattaram Sawant Works Committee (Suburbs) 45.51 200 Shiv Sena 74 75 88 92 92 94 T 103 Manoj Kishorbhai Kotak BJP Party Head 63.80 95 Total 225 227 222 231 221 224 N 131 Rakhi Harishchandra Jadhav NCP Party Head 68.88 43

F/N 176 Ravi Kondu Raja INC Party Head 73.72 11 Note: • Column "R" indicates members who were accounted for computing the report card; while "T" indicates G/N 191 Vishakha Sharad Raut SS Party Head 65.18 78 total no of members in that year (including suspended or members who had demised during the year) • The data covered for 2014 Report Card is from April 2013 to March 2014, for 2018 is from March 2017 E 211 Rais Kasam Shaikh SP Party Head 71.40 25 to March 2018 and similarly for 2019 is from April 2018 to March 2019.

142 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 143 overall rank and score overall rank and score

A (100% to 80%) B (<80% to 70%) C (<70% to 60%) D (<60% to 50%) E (<50% to 35%) F (<35%) Political 2019 Ward CN* Councillor name Area Party (*) CN – Constituency No. Grade Score Rank Defence Colony, Akurli Industrial Estate, Political 2019 R/S 24 BJP Sunita Yadav B 71.67 23 Ward CN* Councillor name Area Kandivali Railway Yard, Thakur Complex Party Grade Score Rank R/S 25 SS Madhuri Bhoir Thakur College, Janupada, Thakur Village C 62.23 103 Ganpat Patil Nagar, Borivali RTO, Singh Estate, Laxmi Nagar, Gautam Nagar, R/N 1 SS Tejasvee Ghosalkar D 58.21 134 R/S 26 BJP Preetam Pandagle E 49.15 190 Dahisar River & I.C. Colony Damu Nagar Avadhut Nagar, Anand Nagar, Mahindra & Mahindra Company, Narsi Pada, R/N 2 BJP Jagdish Oza C 64.49 83 R/S 27 BJP Surekha Patil D 57.92 140 N. L. Complex & Sudhindra Nagar Lokhandwala Township, MHADA Colony Ketkipada, Dharkhadi, Dimond Industrial Estate, Ashok Nagar, Akurli Nagar, Times of India, R/N 3 SS Balkrishna Brid C 61.87 106 R/S 29 BJP Sagar Singh E 37.99 219 Vaishali Nagar and Dahisar Check Naka Sports Authority of India Ghartan Pada, Kokani Pada, R/N 4 SS Sujata Patekar A 82.30 1 R/S 30 BJP Leena Deherkar Bhadran Nagar, Shankarwadi, Iraniwadi C 63.75 96 Ekta Nagar & Rawal Pada R/S 31 BJP Kamlesh Yadav Ekta Nagar, Nilkanth Nagar C 69.61 36 Ashokvan, Chogle Nagar, Ganesh Nagar, R/N 5 SS Sanjay Ghadi B 72.87 15 Chintamani Nagar & S.T. Depot P/N 33 INC Virendra Choudhary Rathodi, Aazad Nagar, Valnai Gaon, Aazmi Nagar B 73.08 13 Ratan Nagar, Ambewadi, Ovari Pada, BMC Colony, Old Collector Compound, R/N 6 SS Harshad Karkar C 62.93 99 P/N 34 INC Qumarjahan Siddiqi B 76.91 4 Maratha Colony and Manav Kalyan Kendra Malvani Police Station Aadarsh Dugdhalay, Domnic Colony, R/N 7 SS Sheetal Mhatre Dahisar River, Nava Gaon & Kandar Pada C 69.16 41 P/N 35 BJP Sejal Desai B 77.33 3 Meeth Chowky, Goraswadi Marry Emaculate School, St. Fransis School, R/N 8 BJP Harish Chheda B 76.09 5 Pushpa Park Gautam Nagar, C.O.D., Bhagvati Hospital, LIC Colony & Mandpeshwar Colony P/N 36 BJP Daksha Patel B 72.94 14 Shantaram pada, Raheja Complex M.H.B. Colony, Gorai 2, R/C 9 INC Sweta Korgaonkar C 69.85 34 Gorai Gaon, Pagoda, Gokhale College P/N 37 BJP Pratibha Shinde Tanaji Nagar, Kurar Village, St. Joseph High School D 55.29 155 Govind Nagar, Yogi Nagar C.K.P. Colony, Tanaji Nagar, Maharani Saibai Vidyamandir, R/C 10 BJP Jitendra Patel D 59.15 123 P/N 38 SS Atmaram Chache D 56.26 149 Pai Nagar, Eksar Nutan Vidyamandir Daulat Nagar, Shrikrishna Nagar, P/N 39 SS Vinaya Sawant Gokul Nagar, Durga Nagar D 55.07 158 R/C 11 SS Riddhi Khursange C 68.53 46 Abhinav Nagar, Kaju Pada Sankalp Colony, Nagari Niwara Mira Nagar, P/N 40 SS Suhas Wadkar C 66.09 61 National Park, Kulup Wadi, Tata Power House, Banjarapada, Dindoshi Court R/C 12 SS Geeta Singhan B 70.57 28 Magathane Bus Depot Nagari Niwara, Santosh Nagar, P/N 41 SS Tulsiram Shinde C 64.12 89 Borivali Station, Asra Colony, Omkareshwar Mandir, Indira Gandhi Development Institute R/C 13 BJP Vidyarthi Singh E 49.35 188 Sukurwadi, Dattapada Pimparipada, Ambapada, Maharshi Shankar Buva P/N 42 NCP Dhanashree Bharadkar E 45.24 202 Rajendra Nagar, F.C.I, Khatao Estate, Salvi Ground, Shivsrushti Seva Soc. R/C 14 BJP Asawari Patil B 70.10 32 Sanskruti Complex Pathan Wadi, Shantaram Talav, P/N 43 BJP Vinod Mishra D 59.06 124 Saibaba Nagar, Kora Kendra, Veer Savarkar Garden, Triveni Nagar, Kokani Pada R/C 15 BJP Pravin Shah E 40.44 218 Prabhodankar Thakre Theatre P/N 44 BJP Sangeeta Sharma Raheja Township, Dindoshi Bus Depot, MHB Colony C 63.20 98 Vazira Naka, Don Bosco High School, Lower Govind Nagar, Ram Leela Maidan, Dhobi Ghat, R/C 16 BJP Anjali Khedkar C 68.99 42 P/N 45 BJP Ramnarayan Barot D 58.26 133 Ganesh Mandir, Gorai-1 Nav Jeevan High School, M. W. Desai Hospital Poisar Bus Depot, Satya Nagar, Chikuwadi, R/C 17 BJP Bina Doshi C 60.81 115 P/N 46 BJP Yogita Koli Mamaletdar Wadi, Navy Nagar, Somwar Bazar D 59.21 122 Puneet Nagar Kanchpada, Evershine Nagar, Goregaon Sports Club, P/N 47 BJP Jaya Tiwana C 64.18 88 R/C 18 SS Sandhya Doshi Charkop Sector 4, 5 & 9 and Theam Park Garden C 65.64 70 Bhujavale Talao Charkop Gaon, Charkop Industry, New Collector Compound, Samana Nagar, R/S 19 SS Shubhada Gudhekar E 43.64 210 P/N 48 INC Salma Almelkar C 61.15 110 Charkop Sector No.1, Bundar Pakhadi Gaikwad Nagar, Malvani Bus Depot R/S 20 BJP Deepak Tawde Sahyadri Nagar, Ganesh Nagar, Bundar Pakhadi C 61.55 108 P/N 49 SS Sangeeta Sutar Madh Island, Darivali Village, Ambojwadi D 58.16 136 R/S 21 BJP Pratibha Girkar Mahavir Nagar, Dhanukarwadi, Shravan Nagar C 65.40 74 Bangur Nagar, Sunder Nagar, Mahesh Nagar, P/S 50 BJP Deepak Thakur E 44.86 205 Parekh Nagar, Sunderpada, Kandivali Gaonthan, Udyog Nagar, Ram Nagar R/S 22 BJP Priyanka More C 64.66 82 Poisar Gymkhana Jayprakash Nagar, Hanuman Tekdi, Pahadi School, P/S 51 SS Swapnil Tembwalkar C 64.99 79 Ryan International School, St.Lawrence High Virwani Industrial Estate R/S 23 BJP Shivkumar Jha D 56.54 148 School, Gaondevi, Janata Nagar-Poisar (East)

144 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 145 overall rank and score overall rank and score

Political 2019 Political 2019 Ward CN* Councillor name Area Ward CN* Councillor name Area Party Party Grade Score Rank Grade Score Rank Yashodham Vidyalaya, Gokul Dham, K/E 78 NCP Naziya Sofi Bandra Plot, Jhula Maidan, Shivaji Nagar D 55.74 151 P/S 52 BJP Priti Satam C 68.82 44 Mali Nagar, Ram Nagar K/E 79 SS Sadanand Waman Parab Shankar Wadi, Holly Spirit Hospital, Tolani College B 72.53 17 Aarey Colony, Film City, Royal Palm, Unit No. 22, P/S 53 SS Rekha Ramvanshi E 49.92 185 Aarey Dairy, Mahanand Dairy, S.R.P.F. K/E 80 BJP Sunil Yadav M.V. College, Parsi Colony, Azad Nagar, Bima Nagar E 43.00 213 Pandurang Wadi, Sonawala Industry, Kama Industry, J.B. Nagar, Ashok Nagar, Ramlila Maidan, P/S 54 SS Sadhana Mane C 67.18 53 K/E 82 INC Jagdish Amin C 66.94 56 Churi Wadi, Goregaon Railway Station Sai Nagar, A.A.I. Colony Jawahar Nagar, Mitha Nagar, Unnat Nagar, Piramal Ambedkar Nagar, Bamanwada, P/S 55 BJP Harsh Patel E 43.20 211 K/E 83 INC Winnifred D'souza E 47.67 197 Nagar, Shree Nagar, Tilak Nagar, Siddharth Nagar P.& T. Colony, A.A.I Colony Motilal Nagar 2 & 3, Jijamata Nagar, Koldongari, Tejpal Scheme, Paranjape Scheme, P/S 56 BJP Rajul Desai E 49.31 189 K/E 84 BJP Abhijit Samant D 58.61 128 Nutan Vidya Mandir Netaji Subhash Nagar Dahanukar College, Shastri Nagar, P/S 57 BJP Srikala Pillai Bhagatsingh Nagar, Laxmi Nagar E 48.10 196 K/E 85 BJP Jyoti Alavani C 65.91 64 Ville Parle Police Station Oshiwara Bus Depot, Goregaon Bus Depot, P/S 58 BJP Sandeep Patel C 66.79 57 Chhatrapati Shivaji International Airport, BEST Nagar, Motilal Nagar, Siddharth Nagar K/E 86 INC Sushma Rai D 59.74 120 Sahar Village, Chimatpada K/W 59 SS Pratima Khopade Versova, Sai Nagar, Versova Jetty C 65.73 67 Aagripada, Vakola, Davari Nagar, H/E 88 SS Sadanand Gajanan Parab E 49.42 187 Lokhandwala Complex, Metro Depot, RTO, Pratiksha Nagar, Shivaji Nagar K/W 60 BJP Yogiraj Dabhadkar D 55.63 153 Laxmi Industrial Estate H/E 89 SS Dinesh Kubal Lalbahadur Shastri Nagar, Gala College, Dhobi Ghat E 45.23 203 MHADA Colony, Anand Nagar, Kalina, P.& T. Colony, Korve Nagar, K/W 61 SS Rajul Patel D 58.44 130 H/E 90 INC Tulip Miranda C 68.50 47 Raigad Military School I.A. Staff Quarters Momin Nagar, Behram Baug, Oshivara, M.M.R.D.A Ground, BKC, Dhyaneshwar Nagar, K/W 62 SS Raju Pednekar D 59.47 121 H/E 92 AIMIM Gulnaz Qureshi F 30.60 221 Shukla Estate Bharat Nagar Veera Desai Industrial Estate, Jeevan Nagar, Government Colony, M.I.G. Colony, K/W 63 BJP Ranjana Patil D 57.19 143 H/E 93 SS Rohini Kamble C 68.10 50 MHADA Colony, Sahakar Nagar Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar Udyan, Gandhi Nagar K/W 64 SS Shaheda Khan Patel Estate, Shivalik Nagar, Patil Wadi, Khan Estate D 56.75 147 H/E 94 SS Pradnya Bhutkar Golibar, Raje Sambhaji Vidyalaya, Jawahar Nagar C 66.38 60 Amboli, Ram Baug, Dhakoji Seth Pada, Kherwadi, Shivaji Garden, Government Technical K/W 65 INC Alpa Jadhav C 63.85 94 H/E 95 SS Chandrashekhar Waingankar C 65.95 63 Dattaguru Nagar, Gilbert Hill College, Nirmal Nagar Dhangar Wadi, Fidai Baug, Lohana Colony, Bandra Terminus, Behrampada, K/W 66 INC Meher Haider B 74.07 8 H/E 96 SS Mohammed Khan C 60.83 114 Gaondevi Dongari Garib Nagar, Bandra Court Gulmohor Colony, Mhada Colony, Four Banglow, Khira Nagar, Muktanand Park, Navyug Colony, K/W 67 BJP Sudha Singh C 60.37 118 H/W 97 BJP Hetal Gala C 60.40 117 Bhawans College MSEB Colony, Santacruz Bus Depot Wellington Gymkhana, Dr. Ambedkar Nagar, K/W 68 BJP Rohan Rathod Moragaon, Bharat Nagar , Seven Banglow E 44.64 206 H/W 98 BJP Alka Kerkar C 64.01 92 Khar Gymkhana, Rotary Park K/W 69 BJP Renu Bhasin Juhu Tara, Vitthal Nagar, Vallabh Nagar, Neharu Nagar D 55.74 150 H/W 99 SS Sanjay Agaldare Khar Danda, Danda Village, Govind Nagar, Koliwada E 41.67 215 K/W 70 BJP Sunita Mehta Irla, Azad Nagar, Prem Nagar, Mithibai College C 65.89 65 H/W 100 BJP Swapna Mhatre Pali Village, Patwardhan Park, Union Park, Pali Hill B 70.25 30 Juhu Airport, Daulat Nagar, Juhu Koliwada, K/W 71 BJP Aneesh Makwaaney D 53.85 167 Bandra Talao, National Liabrary, Chimbai Village, Indira Nagar H/W 101 INC Asif Zakaria C 65.22 76 Dr. Bhaba Hospital Ismail Yusuf College, Natwar Nagar, K/E 72 BJP Pankaj Yadav D 50.50 182 Santosh Nagar, Bandra Reclaimation, Bandrekar wadi, Laxmi Nagar H/W 102 IND Mumtaz Khan E 48.26 195 Bandra Bus Depot, ONGC Colony Shyam Nagar, Majas Bus Depot, Jogeshwari Caves, K/E 73 SS Pravin Shinde D 54.08 166 Bhandup Complex, Vihar Lake, Janata Colony T 103 BJP Manoj Kotak C 63.80 95 Veena Nagar, Ghatipada Durga Nagar, Rup Nagar, Ganesh Nagar, K/E 74 BJP Ujwala Modak E 48.77 192 Kamaal Amrohi Studio T 104 BJP Prakash Gangadhare Tambe Nagar, Indira Nagar, Siddharth Nagar D 52.94 174 Seven Hills Hospital, Marol Bus Depot, Kadam wadi, Gavhanpada, Nilam Nagar, Sajjanwadi, Patil Nagar, K/E 75 SS Priyanka Sawant C 67.01 55 T 105 BJP Rajani Keni C 68.00 51 Marol, Vijay Nagar Dr. Ambedkar Nagar Income Tax Colony, Meghwadi, Indira Nagar, Hariom Nagar, MHADA Colony, Dumping Salt Lake, K/E 77 SS Anant Nar B 72.28 20 T 106 BJP Prabhakar Shinde C 69.45 38 Kokan Nagar Tata Colony, Navghar

146 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 147 overall rank and score overall rank and score

Political 2019 Political 2019 Ward CN* Councillor name Area Ward CN* Councillor name Area Party Party Grade Score Rank Grade Score Rank T 107 BJP Samita Kamble Mulund BEST, Bus Dept., St. Pious Colony D 58.09 138 Ram Nagar, Bhim Nagar, Siddharth Nagar, N 127 SS Tukaram Patil D 56.90 146 Kajrolkar Society Rahul Nagar, Moti Nagar, Hanumanpada, T 108 BJP Neil Somaiya D 55.07 157 Asha Nagar N 128 SS Ashwini Hande Barve Nagar, Kajupada, Gandhi Nagar, Pawar Chawl D 53.56 170 Tulshetpada, Tanajiwadi, Tembipada, N 129 BJP Suryakant Gawali Chirag Nagar, Azadnagar, Maneklal Estate C 61.06 111 S 109 SS Deepali Gosavi D 58.19 135 Bhandup, Tansa Pipeline N 130 BJP Bindu Trivedi Kirol Village, T.P.S.Colony, Naval Stores, Kapolwadi C 65.28 75 Rajiv Gandhi Nagar, M.M.R.D.A.Colony, Naidu Colony, MHADA Colony, Saibaba Nagar, S 110 INC Asha Koparkar D 59.03 126 N 131 NCP Rakhi Jadhav C 68.88 43 Subhash Nagar, Bhandup Sonapur Savitribai Phule Nagar Kirti Nagar, Bhavani Nagar, Tata Nagar, Shyam Somaiya College, O.N.G.C. Colony, Garodiya Nagar, S 111 BJP Sarika Pawar C 68.40 48 N 132 BJP Parag Shah E 41.01 217 Nagar, Datar Colony, Sai Nagar, Rukhmini Nagar Rajawadi Hospital Nirmal Nagar, Jaydeosing Nagar, Panjabi Colony, N 133 SS Parmeshwar Kadam Kamraj Nagar, Ramabai Ambedkar Nagar E 43.06 212 S 112 BJP Sakshi Dalvi Ram Nagar, Dina Bama Estate, Ambedkar Nagar, B 75.58 6 Rafiq Nagar, Indira Nagar, Kamala Nagar, M.M.R.D.A. Colony M/E 134 SP Shaera Khan D 57.01 144 Adarsh Nagar, Shivaji Nagar Bus Dept. Milind Nagar, Gaondevi (Bhandup west ward), Ramabai Nagar, Mohite Patil Nagar, Chikuwadi, M/E 135 SS Samiksha Sakre C 64.40 84 S 113 SS Deepmala Badhe Sarvoday Nagar, St. Anthony Church, C 62.07 104 Ekta Nagar, Mandala Sharad Industrial Estate M/E 136 SP Rukhsana Siddiqui Adasa Nagar Phase-II, Shivaji Nagar Terminus D 57.96 139 Kranti Nagar, Anand Nagar, Mata Ramabai S 114 SS Ramesh Korgaonkar Ambedkar Nagar, Sarveshwar Hospital, D 55.69 152 M/E 137 SP Ayesha Shaikh Shivaji Nagar, Noor-E-Elahi Masjid E 41.39 216 S.V.B. College of Pharmacy Raman Mama Nagar Phase – I, Metro Hospital, M/E 138 SP Ayesha Khan E 35.29 220 Kokan Nagar, Samarth Nagar, Jamil Nagar, Shivaji Nagar Hospital, Municipal Urdu School S 115 SS Umesh Mane E 45.75 199 Pathan Colony, Utkarsh Nagar, Maharashtra Nagar Natvar Parekh Compound, Indian Oil Nagar, Lotus M/E 139 SP Akhter Qureshi D 53.44 172 Colony, MHADA Colony, Shivaji Nagar Junction Hanuman Tekadi, New Colony, Mahatma Jyotiba S 116 BJP Jagruti Patil D 58.53 129 Phule Nagar, Holy Trinity Church Gautam Nagar, New Gautam Nagar, Nimoni Nagar, M/E 140 NCP Nadiya Shaikh D 52.67 176 Tata Nagar, Deonar Slaughter House Kanjur Village, N.C.H.Colony, Mirashi Nagar, S 117 SS Suvarna Karanje D 53.28 173 Municipal Colony Sector 1, 2 and H-3 Block, Indira Nagar M/E 141 INC Vitthal Lokare C 64.23 86 Annabhau Sathe Nagar, Zakir Husain Nagar Kannamwar Nagar 1&2, Togare Nagar, Hanuman Lallubhai Compound, Jyotirling Nagar, P.M.G.Colony, S 118 SS Upendra Sawant Nagar, Dr. B. R. Ambedkar Bhavan, Asmita College E 45.51 200 M/E 142 SS Vaishali Shewale B 71.47 24 of Arts & Comm. Lale Amirchand Complex Maharashtra Nagar, Cheeta Camp Sector A, B, Bharat Nagar, Rajiv Gandhi Nagar, Vikhroli M/E 143 SS Rutuja Tari D 50.26 184 S 119 NCP Manisha Rahate Vidyalaya, Ashok Nagar, Jay Bhavani Chawl, E 45.12 204 F. and I, Cheeta Camp. Kalaghoda Ramwadi Deonar Village, Shivneri Nagar, Telecom Factory M/E 144 BJP Anita Panchal Colony, Amar Nagar, M.B.P.T.Colony, New Mandala, E 44.20 207 Surya Nagar, Chandan Nagar, Godrej Hill site S 120 SS Rajrajeshwari Redkar D 58.10 137 Mankhurdgaon, B.S.N.L. Telecom Factory Colony, Lokmanya Nagar, Cipla Co. Cheeta Camp Sector C,D, E, G, H, J and K Upper I.I.T.Powai, Passpoli, Mayur Nagar, Powai Lake, S 121 SS Chandravati More D 54.80 161 M/E 145 AIMIM Shahnawaz Shaikh Trombay, Trombay Koliwada, Dhobighat, D 53.53 171 Morarji Nagar Datta Nagar, Shahaji Nagar, Paylipada Hiranandani Garden, Sainath Nagar, Punchkutir Anushakti Colony, Wadvaligoan, Sahyadri Nagar, M/E 146 SS Samriddhi Kate C 62.87 101 S 122 BJP Vaishali Patil Ganesh Nagar, MHADA Colony, Jalvayu Vihar, C 64.39 85 Anushakti Nagar, B.A.R.C Ramabai Ambedkar Nagar Tata Colony, R.C.F.Colony, B.P.C.L. Colony M/E 147 SS Anjali Naik C 63.34 97 N 123 SS Snehal More Hanuman Nagar, Vikhroli Parksite D 52.91 175 M.M.R.D.A.Colony, Ayodhya Nagar Varsha Nagar, Parksite Colony, H.P.Nagar, Bharat Nagar, Vishnu Nagar, N 124 NCP Jyoti Khan B 70.92 26 M/E 148 SS Nidhi Shinde C 63.97 93 Phirozshah Godrej Co., R.City Mall Bharat Petroleum Refinary, Kala Chowki Ramabai Colony, Godrej Company, Sambhaji Park, Tilak Nagar, Indira Nagar Zopadpatti, Cheddanagar, N 125 SS Rupali Awale C 65.19 77 M/W 149 BJP Susham Sawant C 69.29 40 Godrej Colony, Vikhroli Village Pestamsagar Colony Rahul Nagar, BMC Colony, Jyoti Nagar, Jagdusha Nagar, Indira Nagar, Sainath Nagar, M/W 150 INC Sangeeta Handore C 67.71 52 New GaribJanta Nagar N 126 SS Archana Bhalerao Nityanand Nagar, Damodar Park, NABARD Colony, C 62.55 102 Adony Compound Sahakar Nagar, Thakkarbappa Colony, M/W 151 BJP Rajesh Fulwaria D 59.04 125 Vatsalabai Naik Nagar, Saibaba Nagar

148 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 149 overall rank and score overall rank and score

Political 2019 Political 2019 Ward CN* Councillor name Area Ward CN* Councillor name Area Party Party Grade Score Rank Grade Score Rank Postal Colony, Chembur Gaonthan, Jay Ambe Nagar, Wadala Truck Terminal, Vijay Nagar, M/W 152 BJP Asha Marathe C 69.83 35 F/N 174 BJP Krishnaveni Reddy C 60.59 116 Mahadeowadi Wadala R.T.O., Chandni Nagar

Ghatla, Santosh Nagar, Vasant Nagar, Kokri Aagar, C.G.S.Colony, Sect 7, M/W 153 SS Anil Patankar B 70.46 29 F/N 175 SS Mangesh Satamkar B 70.20 31 Sambhaji Nagar Motilal Nehru Nagar M/W 154 BJP Mahadev Shivgan Chembur Colony, Collector Colony, Ashok Nagar C 62.88 100 Indira Nagar, G.T.B. Nagar, L.T.M.G. Hospital F/N 176 INC Ravi Raja B 73.72 11 Mysore Colony, Mahul Village, Suman Nagar, Quarters, Sardar Nagar M/W 155 SS Shrikant Shetye C 67.16 54 Bharat Petroleum Refinary, Bhakti Park Punjabi Camp, Kane Nagar (North) Shanmukhanand Tunga Village, Udhyan Complex, Savarkar Nagar, F/N 177 BJP Nehal Shah B 72.49 18 L 156 SS Ashwini Matekar C 66.59 58 Hall, Five Garden, Hindu Colony Sakivihar, L & T Company Hindu Colony, Parsi Colony, Azad Nagar, Raheja Vihar, MHADA Colony, Sangharsh Nagar, F/N 178 SS Amey Ghole D 55.25 156 L 157 SS Aakansha Shetye D 51.12 179 Kohinoor Mills Big Park, Chandivali Studio, Chandivali Lake Shaikh Mishiri Dargah, Kane Nagar (South), Yadav Nagar, MHADA Colony, Tilak Nagar, F/N 179 INC Sufiyan Vanu C 64.21 87 L 158 SS Chitra Sangle D 54.21 164 B.P.T. Colony, Nadkarni Park MHADA Maidan Dosti Arcade, Sangam Nagar Shiv Shankar Nagar, Yadav Nagar, Asalpha, Mohili, Subhash Nagar, F/N 180 SS Smita Gaonkar C 64.80 81 L 159 BJP Prakash More C 64.10 90 Ganesh Nagar Shivpremi Nagar, Azad Nagar F/N 181 INC Pushpa Koli Korba Mithaghar, Shanti Nagar, Kherap Creek D 57.57 141 Milind Nagar, Bhim Nagar, Narayan Nagar, L 160 IND Kiran Landge C 65.68 69 Mahim Koliwada, Babasaheb Ambedkar Nagar, Home guard Tranning Centre G/N 182 SS Milind Vaidya D 51.41 178 Mahim Makrand Society Lokmanya Tilak Nagar, Krishna Nagar, Veer L 161 SS Vijayendra Shinde Savarkar Nagar, Netaji Nagar, Ashok Nagar, Lal C 65.47 72 G/N 183 INC Ganga Mane Nature park, Dharavi Depot, Naik Nagar D 56.91 145 Bahadur Shastri Nagar Laxmi Baug , Indira Nagar, Rajiv Gandhi Nagar, G/N 184 INC Babu Khan D 50.41 183 Shivaji Nagar, Sathi D’souza Nagar, Shramik Vidhyapith L 162 INC Wajid Qureshi C 66.46 59 Spenta Residency Park, Airport Runway G/N 185 SS Jagdish Thaivalapill Estrella Battery, Rajiv Gandhi Nagar E 48.84 191 Kajupada, Indira Nagar, Mayfair Industrial Area, L 163 SS Dilip Lande C 61.23 109 G/N 186 SS Vasant Nakashe Mukund Nagar (East) , Dharavi Village (East) E 49.90 186 Sakinaka Shahu Nagar, Dharavi Village, Navrang Compound, Premier Residency, Sanjay Nagar, Kamani, G/N 187 SS Mariammal Thevar D 50.75 180 L 164 BJP Harish Bhandirge D 58.44 131 Shammi Nagar Premier Colony, Navpada G/N 188 NCP Reshmabano Khan Seth Wadi, R. P. Nagar, Bhatia Nagar D 53.66 168 Cristiangaon, Jay Ambika Nagar, Bhartiysa Nagar, L 165 INC Mohammed Azmi B 72.40 19 Halavpool, Kohinoor Hospital G/N 189 SS Harshala More Hanuman Nagar, Labour Camp. C 60.90 113 Navjivan Colony, Wanjawadi, Kranti Nagar, Sandesh Nagar, Wadia Colony, Kismat G/N 190 BJP Sheetal Gambhir C 68.25 49 L 166 MNS Sanjay Turde Nagar, Shanti Nagar, Chatrapati Shivaji Talao, E 46.52 198 Geeta Nagar, V.S.N.L. Colony Bailbazar, Kurla Bus Dept. Sidhivinayak Temple, Mahalaxmi Sindhi Colony, G/N 191 SS Vishakha Raut C 65.18 78 Vinoba Bhave Nagar, Buddha Colony, Brahmanwadi, Shivaji Park L 167 INC Dilshad Azmi D 54.95 160 Kurla ‘L’ ward office Dadar(W), Babasaheb Ambedkar Nagar, G/N 192 SS Priti Patankar D 52.08 177 Kalpana Nagar, Taximen’s Colony, Maharashtra KamgarKrida Kendra L 168 NCP Saeeda Khan C 68.78 45 Nagar, Kurla Metropoliten Court, Bhabha Hospital G/S 193 SS Hemangi Worlikar Worli Village, BPT colony, Prabhadevi C 64.06 91 Nehru Nagar, Kamgar Nagar, Shivshakti Nagar, L 169 SS Pravina Morajkar C 65.70 68 G/S 194 SS Samadhan Sarvankar Century Bazar, Century Mill, Prabhadevi B 74.87 7 Kurla Mother Dairy G/S 195 SS Santosh Kharat B. D.D. Chawl, Railway Colony, Lower Parel (W) D 58.72 127 Qureshi Nagar, Takshshila Nagar, Rahul Nagar, L 170 NCP Abdul Mohammad J.T.B.Nagar, Evahrad Nagar, Marathi Vidnyan C 61.82 107 G/S 196 SS Ashish Chemburkar Worli Dairy, Mun Colony, Police Camp. B 73.16 12 Parishad Jijamata Nagar, Mahalaxmi Race Cource, G/S 197 SS Dattaram Narvankar B 72.24 21 Ramabai Nagar, Haji Ali MHADA Colony, Prem Nagar, Tadwadi, L 171 SS Sanvee Tandel B 73.78 9 Samarth Nagar, Chunabhatti, Municipal Hospital Sun Mill Lane, Mafatlal Mill, Western Railway G/S 198 SS Snehal Ambekar C 65.86 66 Workshop Dhuru wadi, Gandhi nagar L.T.Hospital, Sion Fort, Sion Talao Gandhi Market, F/N 172 BJP Rajeshree Shirwadkar D 55.49 154 Arthur Road Jail, Dhobi Ghat, Shanti Nagar, Matunga Police Station G/S 199 SS Kishori Pednekar A 81.25 2 Adharsh Nagar Somaiyya Hospital, Mun.Kamgar Vasahat, F/N 173 SS Ramdas Kamble C 69.31 39 Shindewadi Gautam Nagar, Naigaon B.D.D. Chawls, Pratiksha Nagar, Shastri Nagar F/S 200 SS Urmila Panchal D 55.04 159 Rajaram Wadi

150 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 151 overall rank and score keÀe³e&He×leer

Political 2019 Ward CN* Councillor name Area Party Grade Score Rank 1. ceeHeob[-cetu³eceeHeve ceespeHeÆer Spring Mill Compound, Police Colony, F/S 201 INC Supriya More E 43.91 209 B.P.T.Colony, Mhada Colony, B.P.C.L. Complex Òepeeves efJeefJeOe #es$eeleerue le%e J³ekeÌleerbMeer efJe®eejefJeefvece³e keÀªve cetu³eceeHeve He×leer efJekeÀefmele kesÀueer Deens. F/S 202 SS Shraddha Jadhav Parmanandwadi, Shivaji Nagar, Sewri (West) B 70.06 33 jepekeÀejCe, meceepeefJe%eeve, ceekexÀì jerme®e&, ceeO³eces DeMee efJeefJeOe #es$eeleerue le%e J³ekeÌleeRveer ³ee keÀeceer DeeHeues Krishna Nagar, Railway Chawl, F/S 203 SS Sindhu Masurkar C 61.91 105 Vighnaharta Sukhkarta Soc. ³eesieoeve efoues Deens. DeHesef#ele GÎsMe meeO³e nesC³ee®³ee ¢<ìerves mebMeesOevee®eer DeeKeCeer keÀjleevee Heg{erue ÒeMveeb®ee KEM Hospital, Mint Colony Ambewadi Lalbaug F/S 204 SS Anil Kokil B 72.54 16 ÒeeOeev³eeves efJe®eej kesÀuee iesuee. Market, Megh Wadi, Ganesh Galli De. keÀesCel³ee efvekeÀ

152 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 153 3. ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeerb®³ee celeoejmebIeeleerue veeieefjkeÀeb®eer celes, l³eeb®³eeefJe

154 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 155 2. De@HeÀer[sJnerì Üejs peenerj kesÀuesueer ceeieerue (YetlekeÀeueerve) ceeefnleer De. GHeefmLeleer efveJe[CegkeÀer®³ee JesUer De@efHeÀ[sJnerìÜejs peer ceeefnleer efoueer peeles leer cnCepes veiejmesJekeÀe®es efMe#eCe, iegvnsieejer ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeRveer mebyebefOele meYeeie=nebceO³es GHeefmLele jeneJes Je keÀecekeÀepe keÀjeJes ³eemeeþer veeieefjkeÀ l³eebvee Heeée&Yetceer Je efJeÊeer³e ceeefnleer ³eeb®ee ³eeceO³es meceeJesMe Deens. SketÀCe 100 HewkeÀer 7 ceeke&À ³ee IeìkeÀebmeeþer efveJe[tve osleele. l³eecegUs ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeRveer 100… efkebÀJee l³ee®³ee peJeUHeeme keÀeueeJeOeer meYeeie=nele GHeefmLele efouesues Deensle. DemeCes Del³eeJeM³ekeÀ Deens. l³eecegUs GHeefmLeleer®³ee ìkeÌkesÀJeejerJej iegCeebkeÀve Deens ë 100… GHeefmLeleer cnCepes De. efMe#eCe 15 iegCe DeeefCe 0… cnCepes 0 ]iegCe. pej ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeerves oneJeer Heeme efkebÀJee l³eeHeg{erue Mew#eefCekeÀ Hee$elee veceto kesÀueer Demesue lej 1 iegCe Dev³eLee ye=.cegb.ce.Hee. ceO³es Òel³eskeÀ veiejmesJekeÀ ne ceneveiejHeeefuekesÀ®ee meom³e Demelees lemes®e Jee[& meefcel³eeb®ee meom³e 0 iegCe efoues Deensle. SkeÀefJemeeJ³ee MelekeÀeleerue SkeÀ efJekeÀmeveMeerue osMe ³ee veel³eeves DeeHeu³ee veeieefjkeÀeb®es Demelees. ³eeefMeJee³e keÀener veiejmesJekeÀ ns Heg{er}ÒeceeCes efJeefMe<ì keÀe³e& meefcel³eeb®es meom³e Demeleele. efMe#eCe ne ceeveJeer efJekeÀemee®ee SkeÀ ÒecegKe efvekeÀ

156 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 157 ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeRvee meYeeie=nele efJe®eejuesu³ee ÒeMveebceO³es Heg{erue ÒekeÀej®es ÒeMve efJe®eejele Iesleues Deensle ë GHejeskeÌleuuesefKele JeieeakeÀjCeebJej DeeOeeªve ÒeMveeb®³ee iegCeJeÊee/cenÊJeeuee Keeueerue ÒeceeCes Yeej Je Òel³eskeÀer • keÀe³e&¬eÀce Heef$ekeÀe SkegÀCe 100 HewkeÀer iegCe efoues iesues Deens, Heg{erue He´l³eskeÀ JeieeakeÀjCeele efJe®eejuesu³ee He´Mveeb®³ee mebK³es®³ee ûegHe • njkeÀleer®es cegÐes HejmeWìspe®³ee DeeOeejeJejÀve iegCeJellee osC³eele Deeuesueer Deens. • DeuHeeJeOeer met®evee cegÐes/keÀle&J³es DeeJeM³ekeÀ mJes®íeOeerve veeieefjkeÀ DeeJeM³ekeÀ jep³e/keWÀê SkegÀCe • 66(De) DevJe³es oerIe& mJeªHee®es ÒeMve (Interpellation) • 66(ye) Je 66(keÀ) Debleie&le efJe®eejCee kesÀuesues ÒeMve iegCe 8 6 3 1 18 • þjeJeeb®³ee met®evee • meYesle ceeb[uesues ÒemleeJe F. veeieefjkeÀeb®³ee le¬eÀejeR®³ee leguevesle ceeb[uesu³ee mecem³eeb®es ÒeceeCe • leele[er®es keÀecekeÀepe ye=nvcegbyeF& ceneveiejHeeefuekesÀves veeieefjkeÀeb®³ee le¬eÀejer ng[ketÀve keÀe{C³eemeeþer Je veeWoJeC³eemeeþer SkeÀ He×efle • mLeieerefle®ee þjeJe efJekeÀefmele kesÀueer Deens. ¿ee le¬eÀejeR®ee jKejKeeJe keWÀêerke=Àle le¬eÀej veeWoCeer ³eb$eCes®³ee (meermeerDeejSme) • ®e®ee& DeLeJee meYee mLeieerefle®ee ÒemleeJe Je ÒemleeefJele megOeej Debleie&le kesÀuee peelees. l³eeb®eer veeWoCeer SkeÀ mee@HeÌìJes³ej J³eemeHeerþele kesÀueer peeles efpeLes l³eeb®eb JeieeakeÀjCe • DeLe&mebkeÀuHeer³e DeboepeHe$ekeÀeJej meJe&meeOeejCe ®e®ee& efJeefYeVe ÒeJeiee&le le¬eÀejer®³ee efJeYeeie Je mJeªHee®³ee DeeOeejeJej, [eme, ceueefveëmeejCe, jmles, HeeCeer HegjJeþe • GHemet®evee Jemeenle DeefOekeÀejer, Fceejle Fl³eeefo, kesÀuee peelees. ueeskeÀ ÒeefleefveefOe Demeu³eeves DeMeer DeeMee kesÀueer peeles • efveJesove keÀer veiejmesJekeÀ veeieefjkeÀeb®³ee le¬eÀejeR®³ee efveJeejCeemeeþer ÒeMve efJe®eejleerue efkebÀJee cegÎs ceeb[leerue. cnCetve ³ee efJeYeeieele meJee&efOekeÀ ÒeMve efJe®eejCeeN³ee ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeeruee keÀceeue 10 iegCe efceUt MekeÀleele. ûegHe HejmeWìspe meoj ceeHeob[ veiejmesJekeÀebveer ceeb[uesu³ee cegÐeebMeer veeieefjkeÀeb®³ee le¬eÀejeR®eer Je keWÀêerke=Àle le¬eÀej veeWoCeer  jBkeÀ ÒeceeCes ns iegCeebkeÀve kesÀues Deens. ³eb$eCeeÜejs DeefYeuesefKele DeekeÀ[îeeb®eer kesÀuesu³ee letueveebJej DeeOeeefjle Deens. ¿ee ceeHeob[eKeeueer cees[Ceejs ìkeÌkesÀJeejerle 10 ns keÀceeue iegCe Deensle DeeefCe 0 ns efkeÀceeve iegCe Deensle. ye=nvcegbyeF& ceneveiejHeeefuekesÀ®es efJeYeeie Keeueerue ÒeceeCes Deensle. Fceejleer Jemeenle DeefOekeÀejer, ceueefveëmeejCe, keÀ. ®e®exle menYeeie ceeueceÊee, GÐeeve, HejJeevee, ye=nvcegbyeF& ceneveiejHeeefuekeÀe efJe

158 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 159 ³eeÒekeÀejs iegCeeb®eer efJeYeeieCeer keÀjleevee meeJe&peefvekeÀ mesJeemegefJeOee DeeefCe Ye´<ìe®eejcegkeÌle keÀe³e&He×leer ³ee cegÐeebvee  ³eeÒeceeCes ìeiexì ûegHe efveef½ele Peeu³eeJej l³ee®eer efuebie DeeefCe Je³eesieìe®es ³eesi³e ÒeefleefveefOelJe ³esC³ee®³ee Flej oesve cegÐeeb®³ee leguevesle DeefOekeÀ cenÊJe osC³ee®ee nslet Deens. ueeskeÀÒeefleefveOeer l³eeb®³ee efJeefJeOe ÒekeÀej®³ee ¢<ìerves efJeYeeieCeer efveef½ele kesÀueer. keÀeceecegUs ueeskeÀefÒe³e Demet MekeÀleele Jee l³eeb®³eeefJe

160 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 161  Dee³eDeejSme ®³ee DeeOeej js

162 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 163 The next few pages will elaborate the study design and details of the study THE methodology conducted to judge the performance of Municipal Councillors in Mumbai; but before we get into details, it is important to understand the sources of data and its broad usage in the ranking matrix. 1. Matrix - Scale of Ranking The following information was required to judge the performance of each The Matrix for measuring the functioning of the Municipal Councillors has been Municipal Councillor in the city: designed by Praja with inputs from reputed people with sectoral knowledge in 1. Some of the tangible parameters like an elected Municipal Councillors governance, social science, market research, media. attendance in the Corporation and the Committee Meetings, the number of questions (issues) she/he has raised in the above forums (Corporation In order to design the research and get the desired output, it was important to and Committee Meetings), importance of those questions, and utilisation answer the following two questions: of funds allotted to her/him. a. On what parameters should the performance of Municipal Councillors 2. Some parameters on her/his background such as educational qualification, be evaluated? income tax records & criminal record (if any). b. How should the research be designed in order to represent areas of each 3. Some soft parameters like the perception/impression of the people in his/ Municipal Councillors and meet the right people? her constituency, awareness about them, satisfaction with their work and improvement in the quality of life because of the Municipal Councillor. For the first question, The Indian Democracy functions on rules and strictures laid down in The Constitution of India adopted on 26th November, 1949. Once the areas of evaluation were finalised, it was important to decide upon the The constitution has been amended on numerous occasions and various acts methodology which would best provide the required information. Information have been passed and adopted by subsequent assemblies to strengthen mentioned in points 1 & 2 above was gathered from RTI & by means of the functioning of centre, state and local self government institutions. secondary research. Municipal Councillor Scores have been derived out of All these acts/legislations with their base in the constitution give our elected maximum 100 marks with 70% weightage given to tangible facts about the representative needed powers for functioning; have built the needed checks Municipal Councillor. For the information on the 3rd point a primary survey was and balances; and serve as the source of the terms of reference for the conducted amongst the citizens in each constituency to evaluate the perceived elected representatives on all aspects of their conduct as the people’s performance of the Municipal Councillor. 30% weightage was given to perceived representatives. Hence, the first parameter for evaluating the performance of performance of Municipal Councillors in the minds of common man. Municipal Councillors is based solely in the mechanisms and instruments and The data used for points 1 and 2 has been collected from government sources: duties and responsibilities as led in the Constitution of India, in particular, the 12th Schedule of the Constitution that was introduced through the 73rd and a. Election Department, MCGM. 74th Amendments of the Constitution, and the Mumbai Municipal Corporation b. Under Right to Information Act from Municipal Secretary, MCGM (MCGM Act, 1888. Head Office and BEST). However, The Constitution itself derives its power from the free will of its citizens c. Under Right to Information Act from Assistant Engineer (Maintenance), as also the document itself states that it has been adopted, enacted and given MCGM (from all the 24 Administrative Wards of MCGM). to themselves by the people. Hence the perceptions of the people who are d. Under Right to Information Act from Mumbai Police. represented by the elected representatives are the other important, necessary e. Website of District Court, Maharashtra (court.mah.nic.in) parameter for evaluating the performance of the elected representatives (the Municipal Councillors). Thus, to answer the second question it is necessary People’s perception as per point 3 has been mapped through an opinion poll of 22,845 to study people’s perceptions of the Municipal Councillors performance, by people across the city of Mumbai by Hansa Market Research conducted through a structured questionnaire. who represent them from their respective constituencies.

164 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 165 It is very important to understand here that the matrix is objectively designed Scale of Ranking and provides no importance to the political party of the representative or to any personal/political ideology. Sr. Indicator Max Comments No. % Criminalisation of politics in the country has been growing since independence and is a phenomenon which if not checked now can destroy the democratic 3 Perception Based on a opinion poll of 22,845 people spread across different constituencies in the city of Mumbai foundations of our nation. Hence personal criminal record related parameters pertaining to the elected representative are taken into consideration such as: A Perceived Performance 11 Score on Public Services the FIR cases registered against them as stated in the election affidavit; new B Awareness & Accessibility 5 Score on Awareness amongst people about their FIR cases registered against them after being elected in the current term; and representative, their political party and ease of access important pending charge sheets. to the representative C Corruption Index 7 Score on perceived personal corruption of the Table 1: Scale for Ranking Performance for Councillor representative D Broad Measures 7 Score on overall satisfaction and improvement in Scale of Ranking quality of life Sr. Indicator Max Comments Total 30 No. % 4 Negative marking for new -5 For any new FIR registered during the year. 1 Present criminal cases registered during the year A Attendance in the 15 Refer Point 3a on page 169 for details. Negative marking for Corporation and 5 -5 For any Charge sheet in a criminal case. Charge sheet Committee Meetings 6 Negative marking for -5 This can be done on own website, newspaper, Praja B Number of Questions 10 Against Group Percentage Rank. 10 being the top no annual pro-active Website or any other source which should be announced Asked most percentiles and so on to the lowest for 0. disclosures by the elected publicly. C Participation during 5 Against Group Percentage Rank. 5 being the top representatives of Assets Also marks would be cut for wrong disclosures in the discussion most percentiles and so on to the lowest for 0. and Liabilities and Criminal above mentioned forums. record (*) D Importance of questions 18 Refer Point 3d on page 170 for details. asked by issues raised in Total 100 the question (*) This negative parameter on proactive disclosures has not been applied for the current year. E Issues raised compared to 10 Refer Point 3e on page 171 for details But as one the primary purpose of the Yearbook is to promote transparency amongst elected Citizen’s Complaints representatives, it is imperative that they proactively provide personal information on their personal annual economic status and to emphasise their probity in public life, they should F Total Discretionary Funds 5 Refer Point 3f on page 172 for details share every year their updated criminal record. Utilised during April, 2018 to March, 2019 2. Parameters for Past Records as per Affidavit Total 63 Parameters for Past Records are based on information in election affidavit that 2 Past includes educational, criminal and financial records of Municipal Councillors. A Education Qualification 1 A minimum of 10th Pass - 1; if not - 0 Total seven Marks out of Maximum 100 marks are allocated for this parameter. B Income Tax 1 Possessing PAN Card - 1; if not - 0 a. Education C Criminal Record 5 If the candidate has zero cases registered against her/ If the elected representative has declared in his affidavit, education qualification him, then 5; else as below: as 10th pass or more then on the scale one mark is allocated, else zero marks (1) Criminal Cases Registered excluding the following are given. charges: Murder, Rape, Molestation, Riot, Extortion - 3 st (2) Rest - 0 As a developing 21 century country, basic modern education is an important criterion for human development. Even at lowest clerical jobs in the Total 7 government, the government insists on a minimum educational level. Going by

166 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 167 the same logic and the times, it is prudent that a similar yardstick be applied constitution. Thus it is very clear that the weightages in the performance scale to our elected representatives. However, we also believe that the educational have to be more biased to these functions of the elected representatives parameter should be given a minimal weightage in the overall scheme vis‑a‑vis i.e. of Deliberation. other parameters, that are more crucial for judging performance of the elected representatives. a. Attendance b. Income Tax The mandate given by citizens to the representatives is to attend the business of the respective legislative houses. It is hence prudent that the representatives It is widely published and believed in India that annual income levels and attend 100% or near to 100% sessions of their respective houses. Hence the wealth of those who are elected sees a manifold increase in the few years marking is based on percentage of attendance: 100% getting 15 while 0% when they represent. Marks are allocated for possessing a PAN card (one getting zero. mark), as per the affidavit; else if not possessing a PAN card than zero marks are allocated. However, in the MCGM a councillor is always a member of the Corporation and a particular Ward Committee, and apart from that some of the councillors c. Criminal Record are members of various committees viz: Criminalisation of politics is a sad reality. A significant number of elected i. Standing Committee representatives have a criminal record i.e. 1) they have FIRs registered against them; 2) charge sheets filled; and 3) even convictions given by the ii. BEST Committee courts of law. iii. Works (City) Committee There is no excuse for not having moral probity in public life. It is the right of iv. Works (Suburb) Committee the citizens to have people representing them with no criminal records. Hence v. Improvements Committee the scheme of ranking has into account marks for people with clean records: vi. Education Committee i. Those with absolutely no criminal FIRs registered are given five marks. vii. Public Health Committee ii. Those with FIRs registered against, with cases containing the following viii. Women and Child Welfare Committee charges: murder, rape, molestation, riot and extortion are given zero marks. ix. Law and Revenue Committee iii. Those with other FIRs registered against, other than those mentioned in x. Tree Authority Committee No. ii above, are given three marks. xi. Market and Garden Committee We have negative markings as explained in No. 5 below for other parameters Thus, it is understood that there can be two categories of councillors and they related to crime records like charge sheet. need to be allocated the 15 marks in different ways: Kindly note that allocating scoring for each individual case would have been Attendance complex, instead scoring for cases after them being categorised as above Councillor Corporation General Ward Committee Different Committee Total seemed more logical and hence number of individual cases are not of that Body Meetings Meetings Meetings important but the category of case needed for the scoring. (GBM) (mentioned above) Category A 9 6 N.A. 15 3. Parameters for Present Performance in the Corporation and Committee Meetings Category B 7 4 4 15 In an indirect, representative democracy like India’s, citizens elect their b. Number of Questions representatives so that these representatives can represent them in the There cannot be really a set benchmark for the right number of questions or houses of legislation and deliberate on issues related to the citizens and form issues that have to be asked by a representative. However given the range needed legislations under the guidelines of and using the mechanisms of the and complexity of issues that our country is facing, it is necessary for the

168 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 169 representative to raise as many issues as they can, which are necessary for health, renaming of roads, etc. are covered. The Discretionary duties the citizens. Hence to stimulate the representatives to ask maximum number include issues related to slum development, open spaces, gardens, road of questions the scale uses the percentile system for scoring. transport, energy, electricity, water bodies (dams, irrigation), community halls/ Devices used for asking ‘Questions’ that have been considered in the marking: temples, etc. • Agenda Raised In the present scale, we have culled out certain services from the Obligatory • Point of Order duties that are essentially civic in nature and where the MCGM has monopoly • Short Notice Question for delivery of these services to the citizens of Mumbai. The issues that can • Interpellation: Right to ask question under section 66 (A) of MMC Act be raised on these services are related to subjects such as drainage, roads, • Discussion on urgent public matters under section 66 (B) of MMC Act water supply, solid waste management, etc. • Asking statement from Municipal Commissioner under section 66 (C) • Notice of Motions Apart from these issues, an councillor can raise subjects that are not under • Proposal Raised the direct purview of the corporation but are covered by the state and central • Urgent Business governments. Such as, crime, foreign affairs, agriculture, animal husbandry, • Adjournment of meeting and business to be transacted at adjourned meeting MMRDA (Mumbai Metropolitan Regional Development Authority), etc. • General discussion on budget estimation Based on the above classifications the weightages for the quality/importance • Proposal for adjournment of debate or meeting and Amendments proposed of the questions has been designated as below from the total marks out • Amendment Proposal of 100 in the overall scale. Further they have been weighted with the group • Appeal percentage for number of questions asked in each category. The marking for this section is out of a maximum 10 marks that the representative Issues/ Obligatory Discretionary Civic State/ Total can get for being the person with the maximum number of questions asked. Duties (Obligatory) Central The marking here is done against Group Percentage Rank: 10 being the top most percentile and so on to the lowest for 0. Marks 8 6 3 1 18 c. Participation during Discussion e. Issues raised compared to Citizen Complaints Apart from raising a question or an issue, it is important that Councillors participate in the ensuing discussion either on the question raised by their MCGM has developed a system for tracking, recording citizen complaints. fellow councilors or on proposals received by the Municipal Commissioner. These complaints are maintained under the Centralised Complaint Registering These discussions are noted in the General Body Meeting along with the System (CCRS). They are registered into a software platform where they Councillor’s name. We have taken this data through RTI (Right to Information) are classified into different categories by departments and the nature of the and allocated markings out of a maximum 5 marks that the representative complaint such as drainage, road, water supply, colony officer, building, etc. can get for being the person with the maximum number of times they have As citizens’ representatives, it is expected that Municipal Councillors also ask participated in the discussions: questions or raise issues to resolve citizens issues (complaints). Hence the current parameter is based on comparing issues raised by councillors related 5 being the top most percentile and so on to the lowest for 0. to the citizen complaints based on the RTI information procured related to d. Importance of questions asked by issues raised in the question the data maintained by CCRS. The departments of MCGM that are covered under this criteria are as follows: Buildings, Colony officer, Drainage, Estate, The duties of the Municipal Corporation are laid down precisely under the Garden, License, MCGM related, Pest control, Pollution, Roads, Shop and Mumbai Municipal Corporation Act, 1888. They are further divided into Establishment (S & E), Solid Waste Management (SWM), Storm Water Drainage, Obligatory duties (Section 61, 62) and Discretionary duties (Section 63). Toilet and Water Supply. The Obligatory duties include issues related to roads, water supply, sewerage, buildings, disaster management, municipal properties, primary education, A maximum of 10 marks have been allocated for this parameter.

170 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 171 f. Utilisation of Discretionary Funds Utilised April 2018 to March 2019 n Level 2 – This level included areas like Hospitals & other Medical facilities Municipal Councillors get a total of Rs. 60 lakhs in every financial year. This fund & Appropriate Schools & Colleges. It was given a weightage of 4 points. they can spend as per their discretion on certain specified development work n Level 3 – This level included areas like Power Supply, Instances of Crime, in their constituencies. It is necessary that the funds are utilised in a planned Law, Order situation & Pollution problems. It was given a weightage of phased manner to achieve optimal results. Hence, the marks given are based 1 point. on percentage of the funds utilised out of the maximum Rs. 60 lakhs for the financial years 2018-2019: Research Design: (1) 100% (or more) to 91% - five marks; (2) 90% to 76% - four marks; (3) 75% n A Municipal Councillor is a representative elected by the voters to over to 61% - three marks; (4) 60% to 51% - two marks; and (5) 50% and below see the functioning of the ward. - zero marks. n Winner of elections in each ward is termed as a Municipal Councillor and has the power to manage the functioning of the ward. 4. Parameters for People’s Perception as per Opinion Poll n This division helps to provide clear delegation of responsibilities at the Since perceived performance was given a weightage of 30 points, we divided it ground level. further in to four broad areas in order to evaluate the performance in detail. All n Since, our study focused on evaluating the performance of Municipal these four areas were given differential weightage based to the importance in Councillors it was necessary to cover and represent all the wards to which defining the Municipal Councillors performance. The weightages were divided each of these Municipal Councillors belonged. in the following scheme: n Hence, we decided to cover a sample from each ward. We decided to cover n Perception of Public Services (impression of the people about the facilities all the 227 municipal wards equally, with a sample of Approximately 100 in in the area) was given a weightage of 11 points, each ward. n Awareness & Accesibility of the Municipal Councillor was given a weightage of 5 points, n The total sample for the study covered: 227 municipal wards x Approx n Corruption index was given a weightage of 7 points and 100 respondents = 22,845 respondents. n Broad overall measures were given a weightage of 7 points n Next step was to define the target group for the study. We finalised on covering within each ward: The rationale for giving the above scoring points was to give more importance to the key issues like facilities in the area & corruption as compared to Municipal p Both Males & Females Councillor being aware and accessible or overall feel of the people being positive. p 18 years and above (eligible to vote) This is because we believe that scoring positively overall or being popular is n Once the target group was defined, quotas for representing gender and actually a function of your work in different areas. Hence, these areas should be age groups were set. given more importance than the overall satisfaction. Moreover a blanket overall n The quotas were set on the basis of age and gender split available through performance for an individual may be good but when interrogated deeply about Indian Readership Study (Large scale baseline study conducted nationally different traits the positives and negatives can be clearly pointed. by Media Research Users Council (MRUC) & Hansa Research group for The next step after assigning weightages to government’s four broad areas Mumbai Region). was to make sure that facilities which come under local jurisdiction to get more n The required information was collected through face to face interviews importance than the ones which come under the state or central government’s with the help of structured questionnaire. jurisdiction. Hence the weightage for Perception of Public Services was further n In order to meet the respondent, following sampling process was followed: divided into a hierarchy of 3 levels to meet the desired objective. p Approximately 100 interviews were conducted in each municipal ward. Level 1 included facilities which are more critical to local government whereas Level 3 included facilities that are more critical to state government. p 2 – 3 prominent areas in the ward were identified and the sample was divided amongst them. These areas were mainly crowded areas such n Level 1 – This level included areas like Condition of Roads, Traffic Jams & as market place, railway stations, malls etc. Congestion, Availability of public gardens, Availability of public transport facilities, Water Supply, Water logging problems, Cleanliness & Sanitation p Respondents were intercepted in these areas and the required facilities, Availability of footpaths and pedestrian walking areas, Availability information was obtained from them. of public toilets & Cleanliness of public toilets. It was given a weightage of n Sample composition of age & gender was corrected to match the universe 6 points. profile using the baseline data from IRS.

172 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 173 Parameters of Evaluation: Sr. Parameters Broad groupings Scores Maximum While deciding the parameters of evaluation for a Municipal Councillor, we decided No. Score to capture the information on four important aspects. These were as follows: 7 Power Supply Impression of people - Level 3 67 100 n Impression of the people about different facilities in his/her area 8 Instances of Crime Impression of people - Level 3 57 100 p Condition of Roads 9 Law & Order situation Impression of people - Level 3 61 100 p Traffic jams & Congestion of roads 10 Pollution problems Impression of people - Level 3 56 100 p Availability of public gardens/open playgrounds 11 Hospitals and other medical Impression of people - Level 2 67 100 facilities p Availability of public transport facilities like Auto, Taxis & Buses 12 Appropriate schools and Impression of people - Level 2 68 100 p Hospitals and other medical facilities colleges p Appropriate schools and colleges 13 Availability of Footpaths and Impression of people - Level 1 61 100 p Power Supply pedestrian walking areas p Water Supply 14 Condition of Roads Impression of people - Level 1 58 100 p Water Logging during rainy season 15 Traffic jams & Congestion of Impression of people - Level 1 57 100 p Pollution problems roads 16 Availability of public gardens/ Impression of people - Level 1 62 100 p Instances of Crime open playgrounds p Law & Order situation 17 Availability of public transport Impression of people - Level 1 59 100 p Cleanliness & Sanitation facilities facilities like Auto, Taxis & p Availability of Footpaths and pedestrian walking areas Buses p Availability of public toilets 18 Water Supply Impression of people - Level 1 62 100 p Cleanliness of public toilets 19 Water Logging during rainy Impression of people - Level 1 56 100 season n Awareness & Accessibility of the Municipal Councillor 20 Cleanliness & Sanitation Impression of people - Level 1 59 100 n Perception of corruption for Municipal Councillor facilities n Broad overall measures like overall satisfaction with Municipal Councillor 21 Availability of public toilets Impression of people - Level 1 62 100 & improvement in quality of life because of Municipal Councillor. 22 Cleanliness of public toilets Impression of people - Level 1 62 100 Illustration of Scorecard for a Municipal Councillor: Scores of Netted Variables Below is an illustration of scorecard for a Municipal Councillor which will help us to understand the scoring pattern: Sr. Netted Variables Weightage Assigned Scores Maximum No. Score Parameter Scores 1 Awareness & Accessibility 5 74 100 Sr. Parameters Broad groupings Scores Maximum 2 Broad overall measures 7 64 100 No. Score 3 Corruption Index 7 72 100 1 Recall for party name to which Awareness & Accessibility 77 100 4 Impression of people - Level 1 6 59 100 the Municipal Councillor 5 Impression of people - Level 2 4 68 100 belongs 6 Impression of people - Level 3 1 62 100 2 Recall for Name of the Awareness & Accessibility 77 100 Municipal Councillor 3 Accessibility of the Municipal Awareness & Accessibility 69 100 Weighted Final Scores Councillor Perceived performance score of the Municipal Councillor = 4 Satisfaction with the Municipal Broad overall measures 59 100 Councillor ((5*74)+(7*64)+(7*72)+(6*59)+(4*68)+(1*62))/100 = 20.1 out of 30 5 Improvement in Lifestyle Broad overall measures 69 100 This score was further added with the performance on hard parameters and 6 Corruption Corruption Index 72 100 a composite score for each Municipal Councillor was derived.

174 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 175 Weighting the data: When conducting a survey, it is common to compare the figures obtained in THE FOUR LION TORCH a sample with universe or population values. These values may come from the same survey from a different time period or from other sources. In this case, we compared the age & gender compositions achieved in our DeMeeskeÀ mlebYeeJejerue ®eej efmebn ns meÊee, Oew³e&, DeefYeceeve DeeefCe DeelceefJeéeeme ³eeb®es ÒeleerkeÀ Deensle. DeeHeu³ee survey with the similar compositions in IRS study (Indian Readership Survey). jep³eIeìvesle DeO³eeËle meeJe&Yeewce Yeejlee®³ee mebkeÀuHee®es les ÒeleerkeÀ Deens. cegbyeF&leerue meJee&efOekeÀ iegCe efceUJeCeeN³ee In the process, minor deviations for demographics were corrected. 3 veiejmesJekeÀebvee Deece®ee ÒeCeece DeeefCe les ³ee Yeejleer³e HejbHejs®es Kejs HeeuevekeÀlex Deensle Demes Deecneuee Jeeìles. Hence, weighting not only helped us to remove the demographic skews from Keeueerue veceto kesÀuesu³ee Jemlegefve<þ cetu³eebkeÀve Òeef¬eÀ³esletve DeeefCe DeeHeu³ee yejesyejer®³ee veiejmesJekeÀeb®³ee leguevesle our sample data but also ensured that the representation of demography ÒeYeeJeer keÀeceefiejer keÀªve l³eebveer ns DeJJeue mLeeve efceUJeues Deens. pe³eefnbo. was correct.

5. Parameters for Negative Marking Negative marking for new FIR cases registered If there has been a new FIR registered against the elected representative after his election then this happens to be a matter of concern; and hence out of the marks earned by the representative, five marks would be deducted. Do note that in the process of allocating marks does not take into account number of new criminal FIR cases, but simply takes into account even a single occurrence for allocating marks based on the severity of the crime.

Negative marking for Charge Sheet registered A charge sheet signifies prima facie evidence in the case. This is again a serious concern for moral probity of the representative. Hence out of the marks earned by the representative, five marks would be deducted. Do note that in the process of allocating marks does not take into account number of criminal charge sheets, but simply takes into account even a single occurrence for allocating marks based on the severity of the crime.

Negative marking for no annual pro-active disclosures by the elected representatives of Assets and Liabilities and Criminal record As per the election commission norms the candidate standing for elections #1: GOLD have to file an affidavit detailing amongst other things, their own asset and liabilities and criminal records. The candidate who gets elected later, does not #2: SILVER #3: BRONZE share this information with his constituency or the election commission until and unless he/she stands for re-election or for a new election on different seat or post. However given the need of the time, we feel that it is necessary The four lions of the Ashoka Pillar, symbolising power, courage, pride and that the elected representatives proactively make their assets and liabilities confidence are the ethos behind the Indian Republic as embedded in our (income status) and criminal records available to their constituencies at the Constitution. We salute the top 3 ranking Municipal Councillors of Mumbai as end of every financial year when they are representing. This can be done torch bearers of this idea. They have topped the list by on an objective ranking through Newspapers or other Public Medias or through their own Websites or system as explained earlier in this report card, performing more efficiently through Praja Website. This will bring larger transparency. relative to their peers. Jai Hind.

176 MUMBAI REPORT CARD MUNICIPAL COUNCILLORS 2019 177 THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA WE, THE PEOPLE OF INDIA, HAVING SOLEMNLY RESOLVED TO CONSTITUTE INDIA INTO A SOVEREIGN SOCIALIST SECULAR DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC AND TO SECURE TO ALL ITS CITIZENS: JUSTICE, SOCIAL, ECONOMIC AND POLITICAL; LIBERTY OF THOUGHT, EXPRESSION, BELIEF, FAITH AND WORSHIP; EQUALITY OF STATUS AND OF OPPORTUNITY; AND TO PROMOTE AMONG THEM ALL FRATERNITY ASSURING THE DIGNITY OF THE INDIVIDUAL AND THE UNITY AND INTEGRITY OF THE NATION.

Victoria Building, 1st Floor, Agiary Lane, Off Mint Road, Fort, Mumbai 400 001 Phone: +91 22 2261 8042 • www.praja.org 178 MUMBAI REPORT CARD