Existing Biodiversity, Non-Indigenous Species, Food-Web and Seafloor Integrity Gens Indicators
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
! ! WP 3 Deliverable 3.1 Existing biodiversity, non-indigenous species, food-web and seafloor integrity GEnS indicators Deliverable 3 . 1 Dissemination level Public' LEAD CONTRACTOR JRC!–!Joint!Research!Center,!European!Commission! AUTHORS Heliana!Teixeira!(JRC),!Torsten!Berg!(MariLim),!Karin!Fürhaupter!(MariLim),!Laura!Uusitalo!(SYKE),!Nadia!Papadopoulou!(HCMR),! Kemal!Can!Bizsel!(DEU),!Sabine!Cochrane!(APN),!Tanya!Churilova!(MHIONASU),!AnnaOStiina!Heiskanen!(SYKE),!Maria!C.!Uyarra!(AZTI),! Nikolaos! Zampoukas!(JRC),! Angel!Borja!(AZTI),! Baris!Akcali!(DEU),!Jesper!Harbo!Andersen!(AU),!Olivier!Beauchard! (NIOZ),!Marco! Berzano!(CONISMA),!Nihayet!Bizsel!(DEU),!Martynas!Bucas!(KUCORPI),!Jordi!Camp!(CSIC),!Susana!Carvalho!(KAUST),!Eva!Flo!(CSIC),! Esther! Garces! (CSIC),! Peter! Herman! (NIOZ),! Stelios! Katsanevakis! (JRC),! Remzi! Kavcioglu! (DEU),! Dorte! KrauseOJensen! (AU),! Olga! Kryvenko! (MHIONASU),! Christopher! Lynam! (Cefas),! Krysia! Mazik! (UHULL),! Snejana! Moncheva! (IOOBAS),! Suzanna! Neville! (Cefas),! Murat!Ozaydinli!(DEU),!Mairi!Pantazi!(HCMR),!Joana!Patricio!(JRC),!Chiara!Piroddi!(JRC),!Ana!M!Queirós!(PML),!Silje!Ramsvatn!(APN),! J.!German!Rodriguez!(AZTI),!Naiara!RodriguezOEzpeleta!(AZTI),!Chris!Smith!(HCMR),!Kremena!Stefanova!(IOOBAS),!Fernando!Tempera! (JRC),!Vassiliki!Vassilopoulou!(HCMR),!Helena!Verissimo!(IMAR),!Elif!Can!Yılmaz!(DEU),!Anastasija!Zaiko!(KUCORPI),!Argyro!Zenetos! (HCMR)! SUBMISSION DATE 31!|!January!|!2014! 1 Deliverable 3.1 Existing biodiversity, non-indigenous species, food-web, and seafloor integrity GEnS indicators ' ' 2 Contents' 1.! Technical!summary! 4! 2.! Introduction! 6! 2.1.! Scope!and!content!of!the!deliverable!............................................................................................................!6! 2.1.1.! Brief!summary!of!the!structure!of!this!report!........................................................................................!7! 2.2.! Assessment!of!GEnS!for!the!MSFD:!building!on!existent!knowOhow!and!initiatives!...................................!10! 2.3.! Catalogue!of!Indicators!–!potential!uses!and!value!to!endOusers!................................................................!15! 3.! Overview!of!indicators!to!support!biological!diversity!(D1),!nonOindigenous!species!(D2),!foodOweb! (D4),!and!seafloor!integrity!(D6)! 20! 3.1.! DEVOTES!Catalogue!of!Indicators:!general!overview!of!indicators’!characteristics!....................................!20! 3.2.! Indicators’!potential!to!address!MSFD!GEnS!assessment!criteria!and!indicators!for!D1/D2/D4/D6!...........!25! 3.2.1.! Descriptors!...........................................................................................................................................!25! 3.2.2.! Criteria!..................................................................................................................................................!28! 3.3.! Indicators’!coverage!of!biodiversity!components,!habitats,!pressures!and!spatial!EU!coverage!................!41! 3.3.1.! Biodiversity!components!......................................................................................................................!42! 3.3.2.! Habitat!type!..........................................................................................................................................!48! 3.3.3.! Pressures!..............................................................................................................................................!56! 3.3.4.! Spatial!coverage!...................................................................................................................................!60! 4.! Regional!seas:!ecosystem!overview!and!indicators’!capability! 64! 4.1.! NorthOEast!Atlantic!......................................................................................................................................!64! 4.1.1.! Ecosystem!overview!.............................................................................................................................!64! 4.1.2.! Indicators!availability!and!capability!....................................................................................................!71! 4.1.3.! Gaps!in!the!NorthOEast!Atlantic!............................................................................................................!78! 4.2.! Baltic!Sea!......................................................................................................................................................!79! 4.2.1.! Ecosystem!overview!.............................................................................................................................!79! 4.2.2.! Indicators!availability!and!capability!....................................................................................................!86! 4.2.3.! Gaps!in!the!Baltic!Sea!.........................................................................................................................!104! 4.3.! Black!Sea!....................................................................................................................................................!108! 4.3.1.! Ecosystem!overview!...........................................................................................................................!108! 4.3.2.! Indicators!availability!and!capability!..................................................................................................!125! 4.3.3.! Gaps!in!the!Black!Sea!..........................................................................................................................!134! 4.4.! Mediterranean!Sea!....................................................................................................................................!136! 4.4.1.! Ecosystem!overview!...........................................................................................................................!136! 4.4.2.! Indicators!availability!and!capability!..................................................................................................!147! 4.4.3.! Gaps!in!the!Mediterranean!Sea!..........................................................................................................!166! 5.! Overall!GAP!analysis! 171! 5.1.! Gaps!in!relation!to!MSFD!descriptors,!criteria!and!indicators!...................................................................!171! 5.2.! Gaps!in!relation!to!biodiversity!components!and!habitats!........................................................................!172! 5.3.! Gaps!in!relation!to!the!most!important!pressures!.....................................................................................!173! 5.4.! Gaps!in!the!status!of!development!of!the!indicators!.................................................................................!173! 5.5.! Gaps!in!the!coverage!of!the!Indicator!catalogue!.......................................................................................!174! 6.! Molecular!tools!in!synergy!to!emerging!indicators:!reviewing!the!potential!application! 175! 7.! Selecting!indicators!from!the!Catalogue! 177! 7.1.! Main!questions!driving!selection!of!indicators!..........................................................................................!177! 7.2.! Scoring!of!criteria!and!ranking!of!indicators!..............................................................................................!179! 8.! Relevance!for!future!DEVOTES!outputs! 183! 9.! References! 186! 10.! List!of!annexes! 198! 3 Deliverable 3.1 Existing biodiversity, non-indigenous species, food-web, and seafloor integrity GEnS indicators 1. Technical summary Within!the!DEVOTES!project,!a!catalogue!of!existing!indicators!of!marine!biodiversity!and!closely!related! topics! such! as! nonOindigenous! species,! foodOwebs,! and! seafloor! integrity! (EU! Marine! Strategy! MSFD! Descriptors! 1,! 2,! 4,! 6)! has! been! established.! Currently,! the! catalogue! includes! 557! entries! with! information!on!metadata!ranging!from!indicator!descriptions,!data!requirements,!assignment!to!MSFD! descriptors/criteria/indicators! and! developmental! status! to! geographical! coverage! and! applicable! habitats,!biodiversity!components!and!related!pressures.!Both!operational!indicators!and!indicators!in! earlier!stages!of!development!are!included.!The!aims!of!the!catalogue!are!twofold:!firstly,!to!identify!the! strengths!and!possible!gaps!of!the!European!indicator!set!in!order!to!be!able!to!focus!the!development! of!new!indicators!where!it!is!most!urgently!needed;!and!secondly,!to!foster!transfer!of!knowOhow!across! countries!and!marine!regions,!so!that!indicators!operational!in!one!area!could!be!potentially!adapted!to! other!areas.!To!enable!efficient!learning!also!from!outside!the!European!borders,!the!catalogue!includes! indicators!not!only!from!the!EU!but!also!from!countries!outside!the!EU.! The! catalogue! is! available! as! a! database! with! accompanying! software,! DEVOTool,! which! enables! browsing!the!metadata!as!well!as!extracting!lists!of!indicators!using!various!criteria.!Lists!of!indicators! best!fulfilling!any!set!of!criteria!can!be!produced,!enabling!users!to!search,!for!example,!for!indicators! that!could!be!suitable!to!fill!an!identified!gap!in!their!marine!area.!Additionally,!an!analysis!capability!is! included!that!can!produce!simple!rankings!of!specific!subsets!of!indicators!based!on!different!criteria! and!calculations.!The!tool!and!the!indicator!catalogue!will!be!continuously!updated.! In!this!deliverable,!the!collected!set!of!indicators!was!analysed!for!coverage!and!gaps!in!general!and!for!