Neonicotinoid Insecticides in New York State
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Neonicotinoid Insecticides in New York State economic benefits and risk to pollinators Travis A. Grout, Phoebe A. Koenig, Julie K. Kapuvari & Scott H. McArt Copyright © 2020 Cornell University Travis A. Grout: [email protected] Scott McArt: [email protected] Dyce Lab for Honey Bee Studies https://pollinator.cals.cornell.edu Final report (June 23, 2020) Cover photo by Emma Walters, Cornell University. Table of contents photo and, unless otherwise attributed, chapter heading images courtesy of USDA Agricultural Research Service. 3 Acknowledgements This risk assessment would not have been possible without input from numerous subject matter experts. We a re particularly grateful to our colleagues below, all of whom took time from their own projects to edit and improve the information provided in the report. Government and community relations: Julie Suarez (Associate Dean for Land Grant Affairs, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY) Pesticide management and regulation: Dan Wixted, Mary Centrella, and Mike Helms (Pesticide Management Education Program, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY) Integrated pest management: Jennifer Grant (NYS Integrated Pest Management Program, Cornell University, Geneva, NY) Field crops: Matthew O’Neal (Department of Entomology, Iowa State University, Ames, IA) Jaime Cummings (NYS Integrated Pest Management Program, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY) Margaret Smith (Department of Plant Breeding and Genetics, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY) Matthew Ryan (Soil and Crop Sciences Section, Cornell Univeristy, Ithaca, NY) Fruit crops: Art Agnello, Peter Jentsch, and Greg Loeb (Department of Entomology, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY) Julie Carroll (NYS Integrated Pest Management Program, Cornell University, Geneva, NY) Vegetable crops: Brian Nault and Tony Shelton (Department of Entomology, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY) Abby Seaman (NYS Integrated Pest Management Program, Cornell University, Geneva, NY) Ornamentals: Dan Gilrein (Cornell Cooperative Extension of Suffolk County, Riverhead, NY) Betsy Lamb (NYS Integrated Pest Management Program, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY) Turfgrass: Kyle Wickings (Department of Entomology, Cornell University, Geneva, NY) Jennifer Grant (NYS Integrated Pest Management Program, Cornell University, Geneva, NY) Conservation & forestry: Mark Whitmore (Department of Natural Resources, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY) Agricultural economics: Jennifer Ifft (Dyson School of Applied Economics and Management, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY) Proofreading and editing: Catherine Crosier and Lauren Cody (Cornell University, Ithaca, NY) Contents 1 Executive Summary ............................................. 19 2 Scope and Methods ............................................. 27 2.1 Identifying neonicotinoid uses in New York 29 2.2 Assessing relative value of insecticides 30 2.2.1 Limitations of the economic analysis .................................... 32 2.3 Assessing risk of insecticides to pollinators 34 2.3.1 Environmental Impact Quotient (EIQ) ................................... 35 2.3.2 Hazard Quotient (HQ) ............................................... 39 2.3.3 Lowest Observed Effect Concentration (LOEC) ........................... 40 2.4 Neonicotinoids and human health 41 2.5 Key assumptions of this document 42 3 Introduction to Neonicotinoids ................................... 48 3.1 Federal and State regulation 51 3.2 Mode of action 54 3.3 Development and history 54 3.4 Neonicotinoids used in New York 56 3.4.1 Nitroguanidine neonicotinoids ........................................ 57 3.4.2 Cyanoamidine neonicotinoids ........................................ 62 3.5 Common application methods 63 3.5.1 Seed treatment .................................................... 64 3.5.2 Foliar sprays ....................................................... 66 3.5.3 Soil treatments and chemigation ...................................... 66 3.5.4 Trunk injection and basal application ................................... 67 4 Neonicotinoid Uses and Substitutes ............................... 69 4.1 Field crops 70 4.1.1 Corn ............................................................. 72 4.1.2 Soybean ......................................................... 81 4.1.3 Wheat ........................................................... 85 4.2 Fruit crops 85 4.2.1 Apples and tree fruits ................................................ 86 4.2.2 Grapes ........................................................... 88 4.2.3 Berries ............................................................ 91 4.3 Vegetable crops 94 4.3.1 Cabbage and other crucifers ......................................... 94 4.3.2 Potatoes .......................................................... 97 4.3.3 Snap bean ........................................................ 99 4.3.4 Sweet corn ....................................................... 101 4.3.5 Squash, pumpkin, and other cucurbits ................................. 103 4.4 Ornamentals, turf, and landscape management 106 4.4.1 Outdoor ornamentals .............................................. 107 4.4.2 Commercial turf management ....................................... 111 4.4.3 Private homes and gardens ......................................... 113 4.5 Conservation and forestry 114 4.5.1 Asian longhorned beetle ............................................ 115 4.5.2 Emerald ash borer ................................................. 115 4.5.3 Hemlock woolly adelgid ............................................ 117 5 Value of Neonicotinoids in New York ............................. 119 5.1 Methodology 121 5.1.1 Literature review .................................................. 122 5.1.2 Analysis ......................................................... 123 5.2 Field corn 127 5.2.1 Yield effects ...................................................... 129 5.2.2 Cost effectiveness relative to alternatives ............................... 141 5.3 Soybean 145 5.3.1 Yield effects ...................................................... 148 5.3.2 Cost effectiveness relative to alternatives ............................... 157 5.4 Fruit crops 162 5.4.1 Apples and tree fruits ............................................... 162 5.4.2 Grapes .......................................................... 167 5.4.3 Berries ........................................................... 170 5.5 Vegetable crops 171 5.5.1 Cabbage and crucifers ............................................ 171 5.5.2 Potatoes ......................................................... 174 5.5.3 Snap bean ....................................................... 176 5.5.4 Sweet corn ....................................................... 177 5.5.5 Squash, pumpkin, and other cucurbits ................................. 178 5.6 Ornamentals, turf, and landscape management 180 5.7 Conservation and forestry 183 6 Risks of Neonicotinoids to Pollinators ............................. 185 6.1 Introduction to New York’s pollinators 187 6.1.1 Wild bees and other insect pollinators ................................. 189 6.1.2 Insect pollinators and New York agriculture ............................. 190 6.2 Regulatory reviews of neonicotinoid risks 191 6.2.1 U.S. Environmental Protection Agency risk assessment . 192 6.2.2 New York State Department of Environmental Conservation reviews . 194 6.3 Environmental fate of neonicotinoid insecticides 195 6.3.1 Seed treatment dust and spray drift ................................... 195 6.3.2 Persistence/movement in soils and uptake by non-target plants . 197 6.4 Changes in loading of pesticides to the environment 198 6.5 Risk to pollinators: Hazard Quotient results 200 6.6 Risk to pollinators: LOEC results 203 6.6.1 Literature review and analysis methods ................................ 205 6.6.2 Hazard of neonicotinoids to bees ..................................... 207 6.6.3 Exposure of bees to neonicotinoids .................................... 210 6.6.4 Risk to bees from neonicotinoids ...................................... 220 6.7 Relative risk of neonicotinoid insecticides compared to alternatives 226 7 Conclusions, Data Gaps, and Further Research . 234 7.1 Field crops: Benefits, risks, and data gaps 234 7.2 Fruit crops: Benefits, risks, and data gaps 240 7.3 Vegetable crops: Benefits, risks, and data gaps 243 7.4 Ornamentals, turf & landscape: Benefits, risks, and data gaps 244 7.5 Conservation and forestry: Benefits, risks, and data gaps 246 Acronyms ...................................................... 247 A Studies contributing to benefits analysis .......................... 396 B Studies contributing to risk analysis .............................. 412 List of Figures 2.1 Example of hazard, exposure, and risk .............................. 35 2.2 Interpreting Field Use Environmental Impact Quotient (FUEIQ) . 37 3.1 Neonicotinoid use in New York, 1995-2014 ........................... 57 3.2 Chemical structure of common neonicotinoids ....................... 58 3.3 Coated soybean seeds .......................................... 64 3.4 Foliar application of a pesticide ................................... 66 3.5 Insecticidal trunk injection (left) and bark basal spray (right) . 67 4.1 Acres of field corn harvested in New York counties (in thousands), 2017 . 71 4.2 New York soybean production .................................... 82 5.1 States and provinces included in state-, regional-, and North American-level analysis, all commodities ........................................... 126 5.2 Number of corn field