Project Tracking Report 1

PROJECT TRACKING OF UBEC AND NPHCDA CONSTITUENCY PROJECTS. Project Tracking Report 2 ABOUT PPDC

Founded in 2003, PPDC is a citizen sector organization that seeks to promote increased citizens’ participation in governance in a way that supports improved integrity in public sector governance systems through monitoring and reporting on public finance expenditure.

We are driven by the desire to have a more transparent and accountable government as well as empowered citizens who will actively participate in governance processes. Our programs and activities are formulated in a manner intended to drive institutional and behavioral change.

PPDC pioneered procurement and contract monitoring activities in using the FOI Act as a tool to source relevant procurement data from public institutions and continues to do so.

To minimize the challenges of citizen’s access to procurement data, the ‘Budeshi’ (www.budeshi.ng) platform was created. It serves as a hub for citizens to access procurement data in digital and easy-to-use formats. It has grown to consist of over 10,000 datasets.

We successfully advocated for the adoption of the Open Contracting Data Standards (OCDS) and currently lead the charge in demanding its full implementation in states across the country. Through our consistent targeted approach, over 10 states have signed up to the partnership.

As part of our diverse methodology to achieve our goal, Homevida initiative was conceived to target young scriptwriters and filmmakers. The aim is to influence the content of Nigerian filmmaking with integrity values while providing incentives. Digital Inclusion and Safer Internet (DISI) focuses on promoting access to digital technology in a way that preserves safety and freedom on the internet. We collaborate with local partners to provide pathways for citizens to participate in Governance at all levels using tech tools. We carry out cutting edge research, data mining, analysis, and visualizations coupled with extensive communications experience. PPDC is a steering member of the Constituency Project Tracking Group (CPTG) of the Independent Corrupt Practices and Other Related Offences Commission (ICPC) which is tracking constituency projects across the country from 2015- 2018

PPDC is also a member of Open Data Working Group (Nigeria) set up by the Ministry of Communication Technology that seeks to increase the utility of data held by public institutions.

PPDC in partnership with Nigerian Educational Research & Development Council (NERDC) is working together to ensure that every Nigerian child has access to basic digital safety knowledge/skills through the adoption of online safety in the National Curriculum, the curriculum is set to reach over 56million Nigerian children yearly. This is supported by Google.

For more information about PPDC visit (www.procurementmonitor.org) Project Tracking Report 5

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

Within the last 5 years PPDC, through its Community Based Monitors (CBMs) and Local CSO and Media partners in various states and regions across the country have tracked and monitored over 500 health and education projects across 20 states. Through the CBMs, local CSO partners and Investigative journalists, PPDC has promoted accountability and transparency in the execution of public projects by the government across local communities in order to prevent corruption and ultimately improve service delivery and value for money.

The use of CBMs has become the most effective strategy in strengthening community action and uptake of data by citizens to hold their immediate governments accountable. Drawn from various communities, the CBMs are trained on data journalism, contract tracking, reporting, advocacy, and dialogue with government stakeholders on taking actions and making reflective policies for improved procurement outcomes. Citizens’ understanding and use of contractual data will enable them to trigger actions within their communities, spark wider data use and report these findings to authorities.

Between June and September 2020, the Public and Private Development Centre (PPDC), through its Community-Based Monitors (CBMS) tracked 144 Education and Health constituency projects implemented by the Universal Basic Education Commission (UBEC) and the National Primary Health Care Development Agency (NPHCDA) in twelve states across the six geo-political zones using contractual data on ‘BUDESHI’. This monitoring is aimed at ensuring that projects are implemented in line with contract specifications and to bring the attention of relevant stakeholders where it’s needed, ultimately ensuring the projects are of value and benefit to the communities. Project Tracking Report 6

PROJECTS

PRIMARY HEALTHCARE CENTRES (NPHCDA) Project Tracking Report 7

NORTH - CENTRAL

Project: Construction of PHC (Type 1)

Location: Wase District, Wase LGA, Plateau State Contractor: Blossom concept Ltd Budget amount: N21m Contract amount: N12.85m Year: 2016

STATUS: The project was not on site

Project: Construction of PHC (Type 1)

Location: Lamba District, Wase LGA, Plateau State Contractor: Skotdabfog Int’l Contractors Budget amount: N14.23m Contract amount: N8.83m Year: 2016

STATUS: The project was not on site Project Tracking Report 8

NORTH - EAST

Project: Construction of PHC (Type 3)

Location: Malar, Bogoro LGA, State Contractor: Mekaan Investment Ltd Budget amount: N105m Contract amount: N49.82m Year: 2016

STATUS: The project has been completed since 2017 but not in use, awaiting commissioning. The building has started deteriorating as the zinc and ceiling has collapsed. Project Tracking Report 9

Renovation and Upgrading of Maduguva Project: Health Center

Location: Mubi South LGA, Adamawa State Contractor: Cynergy Associates Ltd Budget amount: N60m Contract amount: N9.17m Year: 2016

STATUS: The project has been Abandoned. Project Tracking Report 10

NORTH - WEST

Project: Construction of PHC (Type 1)

Location: Warari Gwandu LGA, Kebbi State Contractor: Tos Resources Nig. Ltd. Budget amount: N21m Contract amount: N12.85m Year: 2016

STATUS: Completed since 2016, but not in use, awaiting commissioning Project Tracking Report 11

Project: Construction of PHC (Type 1)

Location: Basaura, Jega LGA, Kebbi State Contractor: Clirax Ventures Ltd. Budget amount: N21m Contract amount: N12.85m Year: 2016

STATUS: Completed since 2016, but not in use, awaiting commissioning Project Tracking Report 12

Project: Construction of PHC (Type 1)

Location: Bindawa LGA, State Contractor: Hafdala Corporate Ltd. Budget amount: N/A Contract amount: N58.12m Year: 2016

STATUS: The project was not found Project Tracking Report 13

SOUTH - EAST

Project: Construction of PHC (Type 1)

Location: Umuokeh, Obowo LGA, Imo State Contractor: Cubes Consult Nig. Ltd. Budget amount: N21m Contract amount: N8.83m Year: 2016

STATUS: The project specification was not followed as a staff quarter was constructed instead of a PHC and even after completion in 2016, it’s been abandoned and not in use. Project Tracking Report 14

Project: Construction of PHC (Type 1)

Location: Ogroko, Ideato South LGA, Imo State Contractor: Sward Engineering Nig. Ltd Budget amount: N21m Contract amount: N8.83m Year: 2016

STATUS: The project was said to have been earlier completed but was demolished by the former governor of Imo state, promising to relocate the PHC elsewhere, how- ever, to date it is still abandoned. The community currently makes use of a hall as the only PHC in the community.

Rehabilitation Of Ndiememe Ohafor Aram Project: Health Centre

Location: Arochukwu/Ohafia Fed. Const, Abia State Contractor: Lucido Investment Ltd. Budget amount: N10m Contract amount: N9.85m Year: 2016

STATUS: The project was not done Project Tracking Report 15

SOUTH - SOUTH

Project: Construction of PHC (Type 1)

Location: LGA, Akwa-Ibom State Contractor: Geometrix Consultant 1. Builders Ltd Budget amount: N21m Contract amount: N22.07m Year: 2016

STATUS: The project was not found

Project: Construction of PHC (Type 1)

Location: Ikot Ekpene LGA, Akwa Ibom State Contractor: Meksbenny Ltd. Budget amount: N20m Contract amount: N12.85m Year: 2016

STATUS: The project was not found on site Project Tracking Report 16

Project: Construction of PHC (Type 1)

Location: Essien Udim LGA, Akwa Ibom State Contractor: Meksbenny Ltd. Budget amount: N20m Contract amount: N12.85m Year: 2016

STATUS: The project was not found on site

SOUTH - WEST

Project: Construction Of Cottage Hospital

Location: Irepodun/olorunda/ /orolu Federal Constituency, Contractor: Hmf Construction Ltd. Budget amount: N245m Contract amount: N209.3m Year: 2016

STATUS: The project was not on site. Project Tracking Report 17

PROJECTS

SCHOOLS (UBEC) Project Tracking Report 18

NORTH - CENTRAL

Renovation/Rehabilitation of Kawakawa Project: Primary School

Location: Kwakwaah, Hong LGA, Adamawa State Contractor: Lassa Interglobal Concept Ltd. Budget amount: N27.71m Contract amount: N24.1m Year: 2015

STATUS: The project was not done

Project: Construction of a Block of 2 Classrooms

Location: Maiha, Maiha LGA, Adamawa State Contractor: A.A Lawan Moda Investment Ltd. Budget amount: N/A Contract amount: N11.97m Year: 2017

STATUS: The project was not done Project Tracking Report 19

Construction of 2 Classrooms in Junior Project: Secondary School, Madagali

Location: Madagali, Adamawa State Contractor: Bhasma Prospice Ltd. Budget amount: N/A Contract amount: N11.97m Year: 2018

STATUS: The project was not done

Construction of A Blocks of 3 Classrooms at Project: Tafawa Balewa Housing Estate

Location: Arochukwu/Ohafia Fed. Const, Abia State Contractor: Sure Delivery Nig. Ltd Budget amount: N12.35m Contract amount: N/A Year: 2017

STATUS: The project was not on site Project Tracking Report 20

NORTH - WEST

Renovation/rehabilitation of Yashe Primary Project: School

Location: Yashe Town, Kusada LGA, Katsina State Contractor: N/A Budget amount: N22.89m Contract amount: N30m Year: 2015

STATUS: Project specification was not followed. Instead of renovation/rehabilitation of classrooms, the contractor built 2 new blocks of classrooms which were done shabbily as the building has started collapsing. Project Tracking Report 21

SOUTH - EAST

Renovation/rehabilitation of St. Anthony Project: School, Azia

Location: Azia, Ihiala South LGA, Anambra State Contractor: Pranval Contracting Nig. Ltd. Budget amount: N/A Contract amount: N35m Year: 2015

STATUS: The project has been abandoned since 2016. Project Tracking Report 22

Construction of a Block of 3 Compartment Project: Toilet with Borehole and Overhead Tank in Nnorie Technical Secondary School

Location: Ngor Okpala LGA, Imo State Contractor: Dademoh Projects Budget amount: N/A Contract amount: N7.41m Year: 2018

STATUS: The project does not exist Project Tracking Report 23

Construction of a Block of 4 Classrooms Project: with 80 Pupils Desks/chairs, Four Teachers Tables and Chairs

Location: Ekebedi Oboro, Ikwuano LGA, Abia State Contractor: Sonite Communication Ltd. Budget amount: N/A Contract amount: N15.89m Year: 2016

STATUS: The project has been abandoned and the school in dire need of new classrooms and pupil’s desks and chairs and a toilet. Project Tracking Report 24

SOUTH - SOUTH

Renovation of a Section of a Block of 2 Project: Classrooms

Location: Iton Odoro, Ikono LGA, Akwa Ibom State Contractor: 1st Straw Nigeria Ltd. Budget amount: N/A Contract amount: N4.85m Year: 2018

The project has not been done and the school is STATUS: in dire need of classrooms as existing ones are dilapidated.

Project: Construction of VIP Toilet and Furniture

Location: Ebugu, Mbo LGA, Akwa Ibom Contractor: Tekisvic Services Ltd. Budget amount: N/A Contract amount: N12.55m Year: 2016

STATUS: The toilet has been completed since 2018, but not yet in use as it hasn’t been handed over to the school authority. The building has started deteriorating. Project Tracking Report 25

Project: Completion of Perimeter Fencing

Location: Nung Oku Itina , Akwa Ibom State Contractor: Arachnida Networks Nig. Ltd. Budget amount: N/A Contract amount: N3.88m Year: 2018

STATUS: The project has been abandoned

Supply of Furniture and Construction of Project: Toilet in PCN Primary School, Apiapum

Location: Apiapum, Obubra LGA, Cross River State Contractor: Saoland Global Link Ltd. Budget amount: N/A Contract amount: N9.41m Year: 2016

STATUS: The project is incomplete. Only Furniture was supplied, the toilet has been abandoned. Project Tracking Report 26

Provision of Furniture and VIP Toilet in Project: Community Secondary School, Nsofang

Location: Nsofang, Etung LGA, Abia State Contractor: Akuland Group Ltd. Budget amount: N/A Contract amount: N7.53m Year: 2016

STATUS: The project is incomplete. only the toilet was built, the Furniture was not supplied. Project Tracking Report 27

SOUTH - WEST

Construction/Complete 32 Blocks of Project: Classrooms, with Staff Room and Toilets at Ansar-ud-deen Middle School

Location: Erin Osun, Osun State Contractor: Americlean Global Services Ltd. Budget amount: N/A Contract amount: N190m Year: 2016

STATUS: The project has been abandoned Project Tracking Report 28

FINDINGS FROM THE MONITORING

1. Most of the projects implemented by the contractors were of poor quality.

2. The community, its leaders, the school managements, and nurses in charge of the PHC’s had no idea of the project details to monitor its implementation.

3. The project details and contractor name differs from data provided by the implementing agencies.

4. No needs assessments were conducted before awarding the projects.

5. Some projects have no signpost showing details of the project.

6. Poor maintenance culture/No sustainability Plan.

7. Some of the projects have been completed for over 5 years, but awaiting commissioning.

8. Some of the projects were built in inaccessible sites, and have been abandoned. Project Tracking Report 29

PROJECTS

PRIMARY HEALTHCARE CENTRES (NPHCDA) Project Tracking Report 30

NORTH - EAST

BUDGET CONTRACT YEAR OF S/N PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR STATE STATUS AMOUNT AMOUNT AWARD

Construction of PHC (Type 1) at Gamawa in Gamawa Federal 1. Lane Limited N44.6m N21.63m 2016 Bauchi Completed constituency of Bauchi State

Construction Of PHC (Type 1) In Mwari Ward Two-4-Seven 2. Along Kabwir Road N35,000,000 N21,907,525 2016 Bauchi Completed Modernise Ltd. Bogoro LGA, Bauchi State Construction Of PHC (Type 1) In Mwari Ward Zumar Global 3. Along Kabwir Road Services N35,000,000 N8,830,295 2016 Bauchi Completed Bogoro Lga , Bauchi Limited State

Renovation and upgrading of Duvu Cygnus Int’l 4. N/A N7,109,235 2016 Adamawa Completed Health Care Centre in Ltd. Mubi Project Tracking Report 31

NORTH - WEST

BUDGET CONTRACT YEAR OF S/N PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR STATE STATUS AMOUNT AMOUNT AWARD

On Budeshi: Tambos Business Construction of Phc Ventures Ltd. (Type 3) In Kwanar Suri in 1. N70,000,000 N58,124,473 2016 Katsina Completed Bindawa Lga of Katsina On Sign Post: State Hafdala Corporate Ltd. Project Tracking Report 32

SOUTH - EAST

BUDGET CONTRACT YEAR OF S/N PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR STATE STATUS AMOUNT AMOUNT AWARD

Drilling Of Motorized Borehole At, Ogeoko, 1. Ideato South LGA of Imo State Jopos N/A N12,159,000 2016 Imo Completed Drilling of Solar Industries Ltd Motorized Borehole at Umuokeh, Obowo 2. community,, Local Government Area of Imo State Project Tracking Report 33

SOUTH - SOUTH

BUDGET CONTRACT YEAR OF S/N PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR STATE STATUS AMOUNT AMOUNT AWARD

Rehabilitation Of Afia Krisbas Nsit Uru Nko Primary Ventures 1. Health Centre In Nsit N18,625,482 N10,500,000.00 2016 Akwa Ibom Completed Nig. Ltd Ibom Of Akwa Ibom State Drilling Of Motorized Borehole At Eyo Abasi Village In Akwa Ibom 2. South Senatorial District, Stales Ltd. N15,003,452 N/A 2016 Akwa Ibom Completed At Oron Village In Akwa Ibom South Senatorial District Project Tracking Report 34

SOUTH - WEST

BUDGET CONTRACT YEAR OF S/N PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR STATE STATUS AMOUNT AMOUNT AWARD

Construction Of Phc (Type 1) At Oke Baale, Oruku Nigeria 1. N35,000,000 N21,986,873 2016 Osun Completed Osogbo In Osogbo Lga Ltd Of Osun State

In Ago-Ayo, Oke-Ijetu Osogbo LGA, It is Drilling Of Motorized complete Borehole At Ima Area. and in use. Halts Matrix 2. Ilobu, Irepodun Lga And N/A N10,029,600 2016 Osun Limited Oke Baale, Oshogbo In Ima area LGA Of Osun State at Ilobu, - lodun LGA, it is out of service

Construction of PHC (type 1) at Ima 3. Area,Ganga, Ilobu In Ad-team Ltd. N35,000,000 N35,000,000 2016 Osun Completed Irepodun LGA of Osun State Project Tracking Report 35

PROJECTS

SCHOOLS (UBEC) Project Tracking Report 36

NORTH - CENTRAL

BUDGET CONTRACT YEAR OF S/N PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR STATE STATUS AMOUNT AMOUNT AWARD

On Budeshi: Nankam Renovation of A Services Ltd. section of Block of two 1. classrooms at Bassa/ On Site: N/A N5,985,000 2017 Plateau Completed North Federal Sketches constituency Global Ventures

Construction of A Block of Two (2) Classrooms At SY-KINS 2. N/A N8,867,35 2018 Plateau Completed LGEA Primary School, Ventures Ltd. Mabe, Langtang North

Construction of A Block of 2 classrooms Haga Concept 3. at community primary N/A N7,275,000 2018 Plateau Completed Ltd. school, Turu, Jos South Federal constituency Renovation of A Block of 2 classrooms at Tymme Energy Local Government 4. Integrated N/A N 6,566,663 2018 Plateau Completed Primary School Warok, Resources Ltd Langtang North Federal Constituency Project Tracking Report 37

BUDGET CONTRACT YEAR OF S/N PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR STATE STATUS AMOUNT AMOUNT AWARD

Renovation of a block Conception of 2 classrooms at LEA and 5. N/A N7,946,601 2018 Plateau Completed primary school Mwel, Realization Ltd. Pankshin LGA

Renovation of a 2 Mazio 6. classroom LEA zamadede N/A N4,850,000 2018 Plateau Completed NigeriaLtd. Langtang North LGA

Renovation of 3 classroom blocks at LEA Artra Ventures 7. N/A N4,750,000 2017 Plateau Completed primary school Kakruk Ltd Barkin Ladi, Plateau state. Project Tracking Report 38

NORTH - WEST

BUDGET CONTRACT YEAR OF S/N PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR STATE STATUS AMOUNT AMOUNT AWARD

Renovation/rehabilitation HomeStead 1. Of Bagiwa Primary Construction N40,365,644 N/A 2015 Katsina Completed School Co.Ltd

A . S. K Fulani Renovation/rehabilitation 2. Construction N28,750,000 N20,000,450 2014 Katsina Completed Of Koda Primary School Nig Ltd

Renovation/rehabilitation A.h.m Global 3. Of Mohammed Dodo N46,000,000 N29,120,560 2015 Katsina Completed Concepts Primary

Renovation of Muhammad Buhari Communes at 4. N50,000,000 N28,748,120 2015 Katsina Completed primary school in Daura Nigeria Ltd LGA Project Tracking Report 39

BUDGET CONTRACT YEAR OF S/N PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR STATE STATUS AMOUNT AMOUNT AWARD

Renovation of sani zango Akunna 5. primary school in zango N35,011,139 N29,923,173 2015 Katsina Completed Martata Ltd. LGA

Renovation/Rehabilitation Eddyon 6. Of Tama Model Primary N30,020,15 N28,756,350 2015 Katsina Completed Systems Ltd. School In Bindawa LGA

Renovation Of Dan Makarba 7. Yusufa Primary School In engineering N32,420,000 N23,000,000 2015 Katsina Completed Bindawa LGA Nig

Renovation Of Bakori 8. Madel Primary School In Dawan Musa N23,000,000 N20,005,510 2015 Katsina Completed Bakori LGA Global

Renovation Of Madawaki 9. Abubakar Primary School N/A N40,000,000 N34,500,000 2015 Katsina Completed In Daura LGA Project Tracking Report 40

BUDGET CONTRACT YEAR OF S/N PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR STATE STATUS AMOUNT AMOUNT AWARD

Construction of 2 classrooms at Shiko Tos Resources 10. N21,000,000 N12,848,346 2018 Kebbi Completed Primary School in Dandi Nig. LTD LGA Kebbi State

Construction and Furnishing of 3 classrooms Block, VIP Honey 11. Toilets in @ Aleiro Central Orsamoni Nig. N/A N13,854,16 2017 Kebbi Completed Primary School LGA, In Ltd. Kebbi Central Senatorial District

Construction of Two Class As-Subhan Rooms and Furniture in 12. General N/A N9,700,000 2018 Kebbi Completed Kangiwa Primary School, Nigeria Argungu

Construction and furnishing of 3 classroom Mne global 13. N/A N13,854,166 2017 Kaebbi Completed blocks, VIP Toilet in Alelu invest Primary School.

Construction and Z20 global furnishing of 3 classroom Services Dhm 14. N13,854,166 N13,854,166 2017 Kebbi Completed blocks, VIP toilet in (I) Merchants Nig Etene Primary School. Ltd. Project Tracking Report 41

BUDGET CONTRACT YEAR OF S/N PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR STATE STATUS AMOUNT AMOUNT AWARD

Construction and furnishing of 3 classroom Hummingbird 15. blocks, VIP toilet in @ projects and N/A N13,854,166 2017 Kebbi Completed Janzomo Primary School, Services Int Ltd LGA Construction and furnishing of 3 classroom Paranova 16. blocks, VIP toilet in @ N/A N13,854,166 2017 Kebbi Completed Nig. Ltd. Kashin Zama Primary School. Construction of a block of 2 classrooms 45 Nos. pupils desks/chairs, 1 A, D Multi 17. nos. teachers table/chairs Business links N/A N9,167,500 2016 Kebbi Completed with 2 compartments VIP ompany Ltd. toilets at kawara village Birnin kebbi Project Tracking Report 42

NORTH - EAST

BUDGET CONTRACT YEAR OF S/N PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR STATE STATUS AMOUNT AMOUNT AWARD

Construction of one Haitrix block of two class rooms Innovation 1. N/A N10,933,103 2018 Bauchi Completed with at Pilot Primary Services Ltd School Disina Shira LGA

Construction of Examination Hall at Gov. XXL Haulage 2. Day Secondary School N/A N19,400,000 2018 Bauchi Completed Ltd Narabi Toro LGA Bauchi State Construction of one block of 3 classrooms with Teachers and pupils seat Quickfix 3. N/A N19,400,000 2018 Bauchi Completed at Upper basic secondary Property Ltd school, Gwanatar Dass LGA Construction of one block of 3 classrooms with Teachers and Pupils 4. Quickfix N/A N19,400,000 2018 Bauchi Completed seat at Maryam Primary Property Ltd. school Tafawa Balewa Town Project Tracking Report 43

BUDGET CONTRACT YEAR OF S/N PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR STATE STATUS AMOUNT AMOUNT AWARD

Construction Of 1 No. Of Block Of (3) Three Classrooms With VIP Vikun Nig 5. Toilet And Furniture In N/A N22,486,310 2017 Bauchi Completed Limited Sarki Sabiya Primary School Senegal Giade LGA

Construction Of Diamond Leed 6. Exam Hall At Sunnah N/A N19,400,000 2018 Bauchi Completed Limited Science School Gumau

Construction And Furnishing Haitrix Of 1 Block Of 3 7. Innovation N/A N22,486,310 2017 Bauchi Completed Classroom And VIP Services Ltd Toilet At Pilot Primary School Shira LGA

Construction of 1 block Genuine 8. of 2 classrooms at N/A N7,469,000 2018 Adamawa Completed Infrastructure Mamukan Shehu, Jada Nig. Project Tracking Report 44

BUDGET CONTRACT YEAR OF S/N PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR STATE STATUS AMOUNT AMOUNT AWARD

Construction of a block of two classroom in 9. RSM Nig. Ltd. N/A N9,700,000 2018 Adamawa Completed Junior Secondary School, Jiddel, Michika LGA

Waiza Renovation/Rehabilitation Global 10. of Aliyu Mustapha N54,061,914 N47,010,360 2015 Adamawa Completed Resources College Nig Ltd

K K Kamb Renovation/Rehabilitation and Sons 11. of Aliyu Mustapha N38,237,500 N33,250,000 2015 Adamawa Completed Nig Ltd College

KM Kamb Renovation/Rehabilitation Venture 12. of Aliyu Mustapha N55,568,098 N47,895,620 2015 Adamawa Completed Nig Ltd College Project Tracking Report 45

BUDGET CONTRACT YEAR OF S/N PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR STATE STATUS AMOUNT AMOUNT AWARD

Renovation/Rehabilitation of Pambla and Tighimi Anlisa Nigeria 13. N55,568,098 N48,320,086 2015 Adamawa Completed Primary School, Michika Ltd. LGA

Emnamu Renovation/Rehabilitation Global 14. of Uba Central Primary N50,679,005 N44,068,700 2015 Adamawa Completed Enterprises School Nig Ltd Project Tracking Report 46

SOUTH - EAST

BUDGET CONTRACT YEAR OF S/N PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR STATE STATUS AMOUNT AMOUNT AWARD

Construction of a block of 3 classrooms and Obet- 1. N/A N24,826,549 2018 Imo Completed furnishing at Amanogu Obet Nig Ltd. Orsu LGA, Imo State

Construction Of Science Laboratory At St. K Class Global 2. Columbus Amaimo High N/A N7,414,874 2018 Imo Completed Furniture Ltd School Ikeduru Imo East Senatorial District Provision Of Furniture And Equipment In Nnorie Technical Secondary Pro - Logistics 3. N/A N2,425,000 2018 Imo Completed School, Ngor-okpala Ltd LG, Imo East Senatorial District

Renovation of classrooms Sumfat Nig at Central School, Oziri 4. Ltd. N/A N5,307,500 2018 Imo Completed Inyeshi, Ikeduru Local Government. Project Tracking Report 47

BUDGET CONTRACT YEAR OF S/N PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR STATE STATUS AMOUNT AMOUNT AWARD

Renovation and furnishing of 1 Block of 3 Fon Apple 5. classrooms at Umuariam Integrated N/A N8,730,000 2018 Imo Completed Secondary Technical Services Ltd. School, Obowo, Obowo

Provision Of Furniture To Central School Umueze 6. N/A N1,455,000 2018 Imo Completed 1 Ehime Meano LG, Imo Peakgate Ltd. North Senatorial District

Renovation of a block of 2 classrooms and 7. furnishing at Uzoagba Delony N/A N7,668,432 2018 Imo Completed Central School, Uzoagba Petroleum Ltd. Ikeduru LG. Renovation Of A Block Of 3 Classrooms, At Lokpanta National Five Cees 8. School,Lokpanta, Global N/A N8,733,249 2018 Abia Completed Umunneochi LG, Abia Concept Ltd. State Project Tracking Report 48

BUDGET CONTRACT YEAR OF S/N PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR STATE STATUS AMOUNT AMOUNT AWARD

Renovation Of A Block Of 3 Classrooms at ndiawa Five Cees 9. Primary School Amaorie/ N/A N8,733,249 2018 Abia Completed Global mbato Umunneochi LG. Concept Ltd Abia State Construction Of A Block Of Two Classrooms at 10. Umutowe Central School Impex Agro N/A N9,500,000 2017 Abia Completed Olokoro, South Allied Ltd L.G.A Renovation Of 1 Block Of 3 Classrooms And Eromgo Complete 11. Vip Toilet At Uru Primary Universal N/A N19,400,000 2018 Abia but no toilet School Lokpaukwu Concept was built Ummunneochi LGA Limited

Renovation Of A Block Five Cees Complete Of 3 Classrooms, At 12. Global N/A N8,733,249 2018 Abia but no toilet Amamba Central School Concept Ltd. was built Isuikwuato LGA Project Tracking Report 49

BUDGET CONTRACT YEAR OF S/N PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR STATE STATUS AMOUNT AMOUNT AWARD

Renovation of A block of Eromogo 3 Classrooms at Amaibo Universal 13. N/A N8,733,2499 2018 Abia Completed Central Primary School Concept Isiukwuato L.G.A Limted

Renovation of a block of 3 Classrooms at Mubiako 14. Community School Worldwide N/A N15,733,24 2018 Abia Completed Eziama Nneato, Services Ltd Umunneochi L.G.A

Renovation of a block 3 Five Cees Classrooms at Mgbelu 15. Global N/A N8,733,249 2018 Abia Completed Umunnekwu Primary Concept Ltd School, Isiukwuato LGA

Renovation of A block Eromogo of 3 Classrooms at Universal 16. N/A N8,733,249 2018 Abia Completed Obunaebere Primary Concept School Isiukwuato L.G.A Limited Project Tracking Report 50

SOUTH - SOUTH

BUDGET CONTRACT YEAR OF S/N PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR STATE STATUS AMOUNT AMOUNT AWARD

Renovation Of A Section Arachnida 1. Of Block Of 2 Classrooms N/A N6,650,000 2017 Akwa Ibom Completed Networks Ltd At Afaha , Eket.

The equip- Provision Of Instructional ment was Materials And Science supplied And Laboratory Chambers even though 2. Equipment At Girls Global N/A N7,905,849 2018 Akwa Ibom the school College, Ikot Ibiok, Eket Resources Ltd has no Local Government, Akwa laboratory. Ibom State They had to improvise Project Tracking Report 51

SOUTH - WEST

BUDGET CONTRACT YEAR OF S/N PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR STATE STATUS AMOUNT AMOUNT AWARD

External Works Including Fencing, landscaping/ Paving of Parking Area Interfem Nig 1. N/A N74,006,000 2018 Osun Completed and Gate House of Ltd Community Education Centre

Construction And As at the Interfem Furnishing Of Community time of visit, 2. Reconstruction N/A N192,075,000 2018 Osun Education Centre Oke- work was Company Ltd ila, Ifedayo LG ongoing.

Construction Of A Block Of Two Classroom With Tunnex 3. Stores With Furnishing At Laboratory N/A N14,784,000 2018 Osun Completed Papa Community Middle Eng. Ltd High School, Papa Iwo. Rehabilitation And Furnishing Of Blocks Dekfam Nig. 4. Of Classroom In C.A.C. N/A N135,100,000 2016 Osun Completed Company Ltd Grammar School, Osogbo. Project Tracking Report 52

BUDGET CONTRACT YEAR OF S/N PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR STATE STATUS AMOUNT AMOUNT AWARD

Construction/Complete Blocks of Classrooms, Bizerve Nig. 5. Staff Room and Toilets N/A N193,000,000 2016 Osun Completed Ltd at Islahudeen Grammar School Rehabilitation & Furnishing of 15 Blocks Jessean Global 6. of 3 Classrooms each at N/A N135,000,000 2016 Osun Completed Concept Ltd Laro Middle School. Oke-Fia, Osogbo. Budeshi: Construction/ Completion of Block 7. of Classrooms with ICT Ragal Consult N/A N190,000,000 2016 Osun Completed Centre, Local Authority Ltd. Primary School Construction of a block of 2 classrooms with stores 8. furnishing at Anglican Ritesin Africa N/A N14,784,000 2018 Ondo Completed Grammar School, Iju- Ltd Itaogbolu Project Tracking Report 53

BUDGET CONTRACT YEAR OF S/N PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR STATE STATUS AMOUNT AMOUNT AWARD

Construction of a block of two classrooms with Rrk inspire 9. store with furnishing at N/A N14,784,000 2016 Ondo Completed services Ltd. Oyemekun Grammar School, Construction of a block of two Classrooms with Obet Obet 10. stores with furnishings at N/A N14,784,000 2018 Ondo Completed Nig. Ltd Methodist High School, Idanre

Construction of a block of Sambalco 2 classrooms with office 11. enterprises N/A N14,784,000 2018 Ondo Completed with furnishing at Akure company Muslim College, Akure Limited

Construction Of A Block Of Two Classroom With Tamgaj 12. N/A N14,784,000 2018 Ondo Completed Stores With Furnishing At Corporate LAlli Iwaro Oka - Services Ltd. Project Tracking Report 54

BUDGET CONTRACT YEAR OF S/N PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR STATE STATUS AMOUNT AMOUNT AWARD

Construction of a Block of Two Classrooms with Segabo stores and furnishing at International 13. Ondo Boys High School, N/A N14,784,000 2018 Ondo Completed Company Ondo City, Nigeria Ltd. LGA.

Construction of a block of two classrooms with Obet Obet 14. stores and furnishing at N/A N14,784,000 2018 Ondo Completed Nig. Ltd Methodist High School, Idanre

Construction of a block of two classrooms with Sambalco 15. furnishing at Community enterprises N/A N14,784,000 2018 Ondo Completed Olua High School, company Igbara-Oke, Ifedore LGA Limited Project Tracking Report 55

BUDGET CONTRACT YEAR OF S/N PROJECT DESCRIPTION CONTRACTOR STATE STATUS AMOUNT AMOUNT AWARD

Construction of a block of two classrooms with office and stores at St. Alkanchi 16. N/A N13,675,200 2018 Ondo Completed Clara Primary School, Furniture Iwaro Oka, Akoko Nigeria Limited Southwest LGA Construction of a Block of Two Classrooms with office and stores at Holy Alkanchi 17. Trinity Primary School, N/A N13,675,200 2018 Ondo Completed Furniture Iwaro Oka, Akoko Nigeria Limited Southwest LGA Project Tracking Report 56

RECOMMENDATIONS

1. Timely release of contractual data for timely dissemination to local communities.

2. Conduct needs assessments before awarding the projects.

3. The community, its leaders, the school community and the health workers should be carried along in the implementation of the projects.

4. All projects should have signposts detailing the project specifications before execution.

5. Proper specifications of the project. For example, projects like renovation or rehabilitation should be adequately explained in detail the level of work to be done.

6. Changes in contract specifications should be communicated to the community prior to execution.

7. The Bill of Quantities (BOQs) should be made publicly available and to the host communities Project Tracking Report 57

Public & Private Development Centre (PPDC) 0706 661 8896 | 0800 283 3744 (Toll free) Email: [email protected]

www.procurementmonitor.org