REDACTED - FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION

Before the FILED/ACCEPTED FEDERAL COMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION Washington, D.C. 20554 DEC 30 2011 r:t!dcralg~.mmuniCations CommisSion . Ice of the Secretary In the Matter of ) Cable Communications, LLC, ) on behalf of its subsidiaries and affiliates ) ) CSR No. ~51 ij-- E. For Determination ofEffective Competition in: ) 12 Illinois Franchise Areas )

To: Chief, Media Bureau

PETITION FOR SPECIAL RELIEF

Comcast Cable Communications, LLC, on behalf of its subsidiaries and affiliates

("Comcast"), pursuant to Sections 76.7 and 76.907 ofthe Commission's rules,1 requests that the

Commission find that Comcast's cable operations face "effective competition" in 12 Illinois franchise areas (collectively the "Franchise Areas,,).2

The Communications Act of 1934, as amended (the "Act"), and the Commission's rules provide that cable television rates may be regulated only in the absence of effective competition.3

Cable operators are entitled to demonstrate that effective competition exists on a franchise-by­ franchise basis.4 When a cable operator demonstrates that effective competition exists within a franchise area, cable rates in the affected area are no longer subject to regulation.s

147 C.F.R. §§ 76.7 and 76.907.

2 See Exhibit 1 347 U.S.c. § 543(a)(2); 47 C.F.R. § 76.905(a).

4 47 C.F.R. § 76.907.

5 See Implementation o/Sections o/the Cable Television Consumer Protection and Competition Act of1992, Rate Regulation, 8 FCC Red. 5631, 5664-5665 (1993) ("Rate Order").

I>VV1' 18608710vl 0107080-000049 REDACTED - FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION

Under the "competing provider" test set forth in Section 623(l)(l)(B) ofthe Act and

Section 76.905(b)(2) ofthe Commission's rules (the "Competing Provider Test"), a cable system

will be deemed subject to effective competition if:

(i) the franchise area is served by at least two unaffiliated multichannel video programming distributors ("MVPDs"), each ofwhich offers comparable programming to at least 50 percent ofthe households in the franchise area; and

(ii) the number of households subscribing to multichannel video programming other than the largest MVPD exceeds 15 percent of the households in the franchise area. 6

As demonstrated below, the Competing Provider Test is satisfied in each of the Franchise

Areas - Clarendon Hills, Downers Grove, Elmhurst, Evanston, Forest Park, Hinsdale, Northfield,

Oak Park, River Forest, Westmont, Willowbrook, and Wilmette - because two unaffiliated DBS

providers serve over 50 percent of the Franchise Area's households with comparable programming and the aggregate penetration rate reported for "Competing Providers" exceeds the

15 percent threshold in each ofthe Franchise Areas. 7

I. THE COMPETING PROVIDER TEST IS SATISFIED IN EACH OF THE FRANCmSE AREAS

The two prongs ofthe Competing Provider Test are straightforward and objective. Both prongs ofthis Test are clearly satisfied in each of the Franchise Areas.

6 47 U.S.C. § 543(l)(l)(B)(i) and (ii); 47 C.F.R. § 76.905(b)(2)(i) and (ii).

7 As explained below, the competing penetration figures for each of the Franchise Areas includes subscribers from local MVPD competitor AT&T, as well as from the two major DBS providers.

2 OWT 1860871Ov 1 0107080-000049 REDACTED - FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION

A. More Than Two Unaffiliated MVPDs Offer Programming Comparable to Comcast to Over 50 Percent of the Households in the Franchise Areas.

The first prong ofthe Competing Provider Test requires that a franchise area must be served by "at least two unaffiliated multichannel video programming distributors...,,8 This requirement is easily satisfied, because the two major direct broadcast satellite providers

(DirecTV, Inc. and , Corp.) ("DBS Providers") are unaffiliated with Comcast and

"offer" programming that is comparable to Comcast to more than 50 percent of the households in

Comcast's Franchise Areas.

Service of an MVPD will be deemed "offered" when it is both technically and actually available.9 The Commission has determined that DBS service is presumed to be "technically available" throughout the country due to its nationwide satellite footprint. 10 Comcast's Franchise

Areas are well within the satellite footprint ofDirecTV and Dish Network. Thus, both DirecTV and Dish Network are "technically available" in the Franchise Areas.

DBS service is presumed to be "actually available" ifhouseholds in a franchise area are made "reasonably aware" that the service is available. 11 The Commission has stated that "a party may use evidence ofpenetration rates in the franchise area (the second prong ofthe competing provider test ... ) coupled with the ubiquity of DBS services to show that consumers are

847 U.S.C. § 543(1)(1)(B)(i); 47 C.F.R. § 76.905(b)(2)(i). Section 602 ofthe Communications Act of 1934, as amended, defines "multichannel video programming distributors" to include cable operators, as well as DBS and MMDS providers. See 47 U.S.C. § 522(13).

9 Rate Order, ,-r 29.

10 See MediaOne ofGeorgia, Inc; Petitionfor Revocation ofthe Certification ofGwinnett County, Georgia, 12 FCC Rcd. 19406, ~ 5 n.16 (1997) (citing Rate Order, at 5660-5661).

II See Rate Order at,-r 32 (citations omitted). See also Charter Communications, LLC d/b/a Charter Communications Petition for Determination ofEffective Competition in Fourteen North Carolina Communities, et ai, 19 FCC Rcd. 7003, ,-r 4 (2004).

3 DWT 18608710vl 0107080-000049 REDACTED - FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION

reasonably aware of the availability ofDBS service.,,12 The same reasoning applies here.

DirecTV and Dish Network are among the largest MVPDs in the nation. 13 With approximately

33.6 million subscribers nationwide,14 comprising over 33.6 percent of all MVPD subscribers, 15

ubiquitous advertising, and the substantial DBS penetration figures in the Franchise Areas, it is

clear that consumers in the Franchise Areas are "reasonably" aware of the availability of DBS

competitors. 16

12 Comcast Cable Communications, LLC Petitionfor Determination ofEffective Competition in Various Michigan Communities, 23 FCC Rcd. 9595, ~ 5 (2008), citing Mediacom Illinois LLC et at Eleven Petitions for Determination ofEffective Competition in Twenty-Two Local Franchise Areas in Illinois and Michigan, 21 FCC Rcd. 1175 (2006) ("Comcast - Various Michigan Communities"). Thus, the Commission has not required the production of advertising to demonstrate that households in the franchise area are "reasonably aware" of the availability of DBS service. See Bright House Networks, LLC Petition for Determination ofEffective Competition (Lake Alfred and Dundee FL), 22 FCC Rcd. 4390, ~ 6 (2007) ("Over more than ten years, we have made htmdreds of findings that households in particular franchise areas are reasonably aware that they may purchase DBS services based on localized evidence. These accumulated showings amount to substantial evidence that households in all franchise areas are reasonably aware that they may purchase DBS services. In at least one earlier reported decision, we found households in a franchise area to be reasonably aware that they may purchase DBS service solely based on evidence ofDBS's nationwide growth and local subscriptions, without, reference to advertising or other promotion.") ("Bright House Networks - Florida").

13 See Thirteenth Annual Assessment ofthe Status ofCompetition in the Market/or the Delivery ofVideo Programming, MB Docket No. 06-189, FCC 07-206, ~ 76 (reI. Jan. 16,2009).

14 See Press Release, DirecTV, DirecTV Announces First Quarter 2011 Results (May 5,2011) (reporting that, as of Mar. 31,2011, DirecTV had 19.4 million subscribers), available at http://investor.directv.comlreleasedetail.cfm?ReleaseID=574719; Press Release, DISH Network, DISHNetwork Reports First Quarter 2011 Financial Results (May 2,2011) (reporting that, as of Mar. 31, 2011, Dish Network had approximately 14.2 million subscribers), available at http://dish.client.shareholder.com/releasedetail.cfm?ReleaseID=573404. 15 Press Release, SNL Kagan's Us. Multichannel Subscribers 4th Quarter 2010 Results, SNL Kagan, March 15,2011, available at http://www.snl.com/InTheMedia.aspx (reporting approximately 100.1 million video subscribers in the U.S.).

16 See, e.g., Comcast - Various Michigan Communities, ~ 5; Bright House Networks - Florida, ~ 6.

4 DWT 1860871 Ov 1 0107080-000049 REDACTED - FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION

The Competing Provider Test also requires that the programming offered by the

competing providers must be "comparable" to the programming offered by the cable operator. 17

The Commission's rules define comparable programming as "at least 12 channels of video

programming, including at least one channel of nonbroadcast service programming.,,18 The

Commission has repeatedly recognized that the DBS Providers offer comparable programming

to Comcast under the Commission's Competing Provider Test. 19 Each of the DBS Providers

offer well over 100 video channels, most ofwhich are non-broadcast services.20 And, as shown

in the attached channel line-up, Comcast's programming service offerings in the Franchise Areas

are substantially similar to the DBS programming services?1

Based on the above facts, Comcast has satisfied the first prong ofthe Competing Provider

Test.

B. The Competing Providers Serve Greater Than 15 Percent of the Households In Comcast's Franchise Areas.

The second prong ofthe Competing Provider Test requires that the subscriber base of

competing MVPDs, other than the largest MVPD, exceeds 15 percent offranchise area

households. The Commission rules provide that once this first prong of the Competing Provider

Test is satisfied, as it is with the DBS service offerings in this case, the subscribers of all

qualifying MVPDs count toward the 15% penetration figure necessary for a detennination of

17 See 47 U.S.C. § 543(1)(1)(B)(i); 47 C.F.R. § 76.905(b)(2)(i). 18 47 c.P.R. § 76.905(g).

19 See, e.g., Comcast Cablevision ofMaryland, Inc., Petitions for Determination ofEffective Competition (Charles County, MDJ, 19 FCC Red. 7130, ~ 4 (2004) ("We find that the programming ofDBS providers satisfies the Commission's program comparability criterion because DBS providers offer more than 12 channels of video programming, including more than one non-broadcast channel.").

20 See Channel Line-ups of DirecTV and Dish Network, attached hereto as Exhibit 2. 21 See Comcast Channel Line-up, attached hereto as Exhibit 3.

5 DWT 18608710vl 0107080-000049 REDACTED - FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION

effective competition (even if they are not available themselves to more than 50% of local

households)?2 Accordingly, the Competing Provider subscriber tallies presented in this Petition

for the Franchise Areas include subscribers from AT&T, as well as from the two major DBS

providers.

Comcast obtained AT&T's subscribership in the Franchise Areas directly from MVPD

competitor AT&T?3 As shown in Exhibit 3, AT&T offers competing cable service in each of

the Franchise Areas?4

The process of determining the precise number of DBS subscribers within a franchise

area is not an exact science because DBS Providers track their subscribers according to the zip

codes where each subscriber resides, rather than by political jurisdiction. In this case, Comcast

relied on ZIP+4 codes associated with the Franchise Areas in order to determine the number of

DBS subscribers within the Franchise Areas. The Commission has previously accepted ZIP+4

codes as "reasonable and sufficiently reliable for purposes of determining the presence of

effective competition,,,25 and previously has stated its preference for this approach.26

22 See 47 C.F.R. § 76.905(f) (Emphasis added); see also Time Warner Entertainment Co., L.P. et al. v. FCC, 56 F3d 151 (D.C. Cir. 1995) (holding that the subscriber ownership ofall MVPDs, . other than the largest MVPD, may be aggregated to satisfy the 15 percent threshold). 23 AT&T's "comparable" channel lineup is set forth in Exhibit 4. 24 AT&T's subscribership information was provided to Comcast on the condition that Comcast would seek confidential treatment with respect to such information. Accordingly, Comcast hereby requests that the Commission grant confidential treatment to AT&T's subscriber information and provide AT&T a reasonable opportunity to procure confidential treatment of such information prior to disclosure if the Commission objects to treating the information confidentially. Comcast submits AT&T's subscriber figures for the Franchise Areas as Confidential Exhibit 5 to this Petition (with a separately-submitted redacted version for inclusion in the public file). See CoxCom, Inc., 22 FCC Red. 4384, ~ 2 n.6 (2007).

25 See Cable One, Inc. Petition for Determination ofEffective Competition in Pocatello. Idaho, 18 FCC Red. 12792, ~ 8 (2003), quoting Falcon Cable Systems II, a California Limited Partnership, d/b/a Charter Communications Petitionfor Determination ofEffective Competition in Twelve Oregon Cities, 17 FCC Red. 4648 (2002).

6 DWT 18608710vl 0107080-000049 REDACTED - FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION

To detennine the relevant ZIP+4 codes for the Franchise Areas, Comcast contacted

Media Business Corp. ("MBC," previously known as "SkyTrends"). MBC has developed a

process to accurately identify the ZIP+4 codes that correspond with the political boundaries of a

particular community. This process utilizes enhanced mapping software that correlates ZIP+4

codes with the U.S. Census Department's "block group" level households. The "block group"

measurement is the most precise Census tool available to measure households within a very

small geographical area. With this software, MBC was able to identify the ZIP+4 codes that lie

within each ofthe Franchise Areas?7

Comcast next provided all ofthe ZIP+4 codes for the Franchise Areas to the Satellite

Broadcasting and Communication Association ("SBCA"). SBCA is the national trade

association representing the two major DBS Providers, and it has assumed the responsibility for

compiling subscribership data and responding to data requests from cable operators and

franchising authorities engaged in effective competition proceedings. The DBS subscriber

numbers reported in the attached Effective Competition Tracking Reports ("ECTR") from SBCA

reflect the total DBS subscribers within the individual ZIP+4 codes associated with each ofthe

Franchise Areas.28

Finally, Comcast compared the subscribership figures reported by SBCA and AT&T with

its own subscribership, and was able to confirm that its own subscribership exceeded DBS and

AT&T subscribership in each ofthe Franchise Areas. Comcast is clearly the largest MVPD in

the Franchise Areas.

26 See Public Notice, "Commission Announces New Standards for Showings of Effective Competition For Cable Service," 23 FCC Rcd. 12067 (2008). 27 See Letter from MBC (explaining ZIP+4 methodology), attached hereto as Exhibit 6. 28 See Exhibit 7 (providing total ZIP+4-based DBS subscribership for the Franchise Areas, as well as all ZIP+4 data relied on in the Petition).

7 DWT 18608710vl 0107080-000049 REDACTED - FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION

To determine whether the combined DBS and AT&T subscribership exceeds the

statutorily mandated 15 percent threshold in the Franchise Areas, Comcast compared the

Competing Providers' subscribership to the most recent u.s. Census occupied household unit

figures for each community.29 This comparison yields the aggregate penetration rates for

Competing Providers in each of the Franchise Areas.

As detailed in Confidential Exhibit 9, the aggregate subscriber penetration rate for the

DBS Providers and AT&T exceeds the 15 percent threshold required under Section 623(1)(1)(B)

ofthe Act. 30 Accordingly, Comcast meets the second prong of the Competing Provider Test.

Because Comcast meets both prongs ofthe Competing Provider Test in the Franchise

Areas, it faces effective competition in each of the Franchise Areas.

CONCLUSION

Comcast has demonstrated herein that it is subject to effective competition in each ofthe

Franchise Areas under the Competing Provider Test. Based on the evidence presented herein,

Comcast respectfully requests that the Media Bureau issue an order acknowledging the presence

29 The occupied household numbers for the Franchise Areas was obtained from the 2010 U.S. Census, available at http://www.factfinder2.census.gov, the relevant pages ofwhich are attached hereto as Exhibit 8.

30 As noted above, Comcast is seeking confidential treatment with respect to the AT&T subscribership data for the Franchise Areas. Accordingly, AT&T's penetration rate, as well as the combined DBS provider and AT&T subscriber penetration rate for the Franchise Areas is submitted as part of Confidential Exhibit 9 to the Petition (with a separately-submitted redacted version for inclusion in the public :file).

8 DWT 18608710vl 0107080-000049 REDACTED - FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION

ofeffective competition in each ofthe 1211linois Franchise Areas as offiling date ofthis

Petition.

Respectfully submitted,

Comeast Cable CommunicatioDS, LLC, on behalf of its subsidiaries and aft'iliates

By: ---J.:"'-"~~~..d-"":'-~~~~lo&;;L-\-­ S v J. Horvitz Frederick W. Giroux

Davis Wright Tremaine LLP 1919 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W., Suite 800 Washington, D.C. 20006 (202) 973-4200

December 30, 2011 Its Attorneys

9 OWT 186087IOvI 0107080-000049 REDACTED - FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION

CERTIFICATION PURSUANT TO 47 C.F.R. § 76.6(il)(4)

The below-signed signatory has read the foregoing Petition for Special Relief, and to the

best of my knowledge, information and belief formed after reasonable inquiry, it is well

grounded in fact and is warranted by existing law or a good faith argument for the extension,

modification or reversal ofexisting law; and is not interposed for any improper purpose.

Respectfully submitted,

Comeast Cable Communications, LLC, behalf of its subsidiaries and affiUates

By:

Davis Wright Tremaine LLP 1919 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W., Suite 800 Washington, DC 20006 (202) 973-4200

Its Attorney

December 30, 20 I ]

DWT 18608710vl 0107080·000049 REDACTED - FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION

DECLARATION OF WARREN FITTING

I, Warren Fitting, declare, under penalty ofperjury that:

1. I am the Senior Director ofRegulatory Accounting for Comcast Cable Communications, LLC ("Comcast").

2. I have read the foregoing Petition for Special Relief ("Petition") and am familiar with the contents thereof and the matters referred to therein.

3. I have reviewed Comcast's respective cable subscriber numbers for the Franchise Areas at issue in this Petition, the DBS subscriber numbers provided by SBCA for the individual Franchise Areas, and the AT&T subscriber numbers as described in the Petition. Comcast is the largest multichannel video program provider in the Clarendon Hills, Downers Grove, Elmhurst, Evanston, Forest Park, Hinsdale, Northfield, Oak Park, River Forest, Westmont, Willowbrook, and Wilmette Franchise Areas.

4. The facts contained within the Petition are true and correct to the best ofmy knowledge, information and belief.

j Date Warren Fitting

DWT 18608710vl 0107080-000049 REDACTED - FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION

EXHIBIT 1 REDACTED - FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION

PSID#O06193

CUID# COMMUNITY IL1132 CLARENDON HILLS IL0402 DOWNERS GROVE IL0395 ELMHURST IL0601 EVANSTON IL0363 FOREST PARK IL1134 HINSDALE IL1135 HINSDALE IL1360 NORTHFIELD IL0311 OAK PARK IL0456 RIVER FOREST IL0904 WESTMONT IL1142 WILLOWBROOK IL0423 WILMETTE

12907149.1 REDACTED - FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION

EXHIBIT 2 REDACTED - FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION

Print chanriefs.f~ Z1P:COde trim lNolocals llYllllable)" PP.INT El

3net (HD) 1E21107 0Isney Channel (West) 291 Hope· 368 RFDTY 345 Afi:E lE!QI 265 DisneyXD (8Q] 292 INSP 364 ReelzChllnnel 238 ABC Family IHQI 311 Documentary Channel 267 ION Television 305 SOAPnet 262 American Movie Classics lHQI 254 E! Entertainment 236 ION Television West 347 Science Channel 1BQ]284 lAMe) ESPN lEg) 206 Independent Film 559 ShopNBC 316 Animal Planet EQ!282 ESPN 3D (HD) EQ!106 Channel (IFC) Speed Channel !8Ql607 Audience Network If@ 239 Investigation Discovery 285 ESPt;lZ IEQJ 209 Spike 1EQ/241 BBCAmerica 264 (ID) ESPNEWS IBQI 207 Styte 235 BYUTY 374 Jewelry Television 313 ESPNU !8Ql208 Syfy Channel IEiQIZ44 Big Ten Network lHQ) 610 Jewish life Television· 366 EWTN 370 Biography Channel IHQJ i66 lifetime l8Q] 252 TBS 1BQ]247 Enlace Christian 448 lifetime Movie Network 253 TCTNetwork 3n Black Entertainment IHQJ 329 Television· Television (BET) LinkTY 375 TNT l8Q!245 FUEL TY lEQI 618 Bloomberg Television 353 Logo 272 TV Guide Network 2n FX lBQI 248 Boomerclng 298 WORlDVlEW"' TV Land 304 Food Network lBQI 231 MHz 2183 Bravo i§237 MLB Network TV One 328 Fox Business Network lBQJ 359 m213 cas Sports Network I't!i2J 613 MSNBC TeenNick 303 Fox Movie ChaMel 258 IBQJ 356 CCTV-9 2053 MTV 331 Tennis Channel 18Ql217 Fox News Channel l8QJ 360 \8QI CMT [HQ] 327 MTV2 The Hub 294 Free Speech TV" 348 333 CHBC lBQI 355 Military Channel The Learning Channel 1EQ1280 Fuse 339 287 CNBC World 357 TV The Sportsman Channel 605 GEM NET (Global 2068 NASA 289 CNN IHQJ 202 EXpansion Media NBAlY lHQl216 The Word Network 3n CSPAN 1 350 Network)· NFL Network m212 Travel Channel 1E!i212n GOD TV 365 CSPANZ 351 NHL Network IBQIZ15 Trinity Broadcasting 3n GSN, the network for Network (TBN) Cartoon Network (East) IEQJ Z96 233 NRB 378 Pme5 TruTY 246 Cartoon Network (West) 297 Nat Geo WILD 283 Galavision 404 Turner Classic Movies 256 Centric 330 GolTY HD English lEQl 620 National Geographic 00276 (TCM) Chiller Channel 257 Golden Eagle USA Network \EQl242 363 Nick Jr. 301 Christian Television 376 Broadcasting· Univision 402 Network (CTN) Nickelodeon (East) 1BQ!299 Golf Channel m2l8 VHl l8Q!335 Church Channel 371 Nickelodeon (West) 300 Gospel Music Channel 338 VH1 Classic 337 aoo 308 Nicktoons Network 302 Great American Country 326 Versus 1EQ]603 Comedy Central IHQ/ 249 OWN 279 HZ 271 WE: Women's Cooking- Channel 232 260 HDTheater [EQJ 281 OvationlY 274 Entertainment Current TV 358 HDNet 1BQl306 Oxygen 251 I WGN America !BQi307 DIY Network 230 HITN· 438 PBS 0 Weather Channel I8Q] 362 Daystar 369 Hallmark Channel I@] 312 PBS Kids Sprout 295 World Harvest Television 367 Discovery'Channel IEQIZ78 Headline News 204 Planet Green lBEI286 n3D IBQ] 103 Discovery Frt &: Health 261 History Channel 1EQl269 PursuIt Channel 608 Disney Channel (East) 1HID290 Home It. Garden 1EQ1229 Q.VC 275 Television (HGTV) Home Shopping Network 240

PR~MI!JMS

5STARMAX HD East IBQlsitJ FliX ON D£MANDG> 1557 Nl:JreM/JIX. 1BQ!517 STAAZIIl) ON DEMAND 1527 ~HtiEast IEQ] 523 FOX Deportes 624 Outdoor Channel 606 Showtime Beyond HD I8Q] 550 ActionMAX HD m 519 Aix 557 SHOWTIME I8QI 545 Showtime Next HD IBQl 551 Cinemax East IHQI 515 Fox Soccer ,Channel l8QI 619 SHOWTIME (West) IHQI 546 Showtime Women HD 18QI 552 Cinemax West lEQI 516 GollY 620 SHOWTlME2 lEQI 547 Sundance Channel 558 ENCORE (East) IBQl 535 HBO (East) l8QI 501 SHOWTIME Extreme I8QI 549 SUndance ON DfJMND 1558 ENCORE (West) 536 HBO (West) IHQJ 504 SHOWT1ME ON DEMAND 1545 THE MOVIE CHANNEl1M 1554 ENCORE Action 541 HBO 2 (East) lBQJ 502 SHOWTIME Showcase It§ 548 ON DEMAND ENCORE Drama 540 HBO 2 (West) 505 STAR! (East) l8QJ 527 TMC Xtra HD East lEgJ 556 ENCORE Family TVG • The Interactive 542 HBO Comedy HD lEQI 506 (West) 528 602 IHQI Horseradng Network The Movie Channel IBQI 554 (East)

http://www.directv.com/DTVAPP/compare/printablePackageChannels.jsp?packageId=960...1117/2011 ~ -0- - --­ REDACTED - FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION

PREM!UMS

ENCORE Love 537 HBO F"amily tEast) EP.I 501 STARZ Cinema HD EQl 531 The Movie Channel 555 (West) ENCORE Suspense 539 HBO FamRy (West) 508 STARZ Comedy HD fBQl 5Z6 ThriUerMAX HD lEQ)m ENCORE Westerns 538 HBO Latfno IBQI 511 STARZEdge IEQI 5Z9 WMAXHDEast JBQ/ 521 EHCORE~ ON DfItIAND 1535 HBO S"tgnature EQl 503 STARZ InBlack IEQI 530 ESPN-Qassic Sports 614 HBOZOneHo-­ /BQ) 509 STARZ Kids & Family HD E:eI 525

AltitUOe Sjxxts & Ent. IBm 681 FSArtzona 'i3Ql686 FS South PIUs (2) m-648 R:OOT SPORTSRody \EQl683 681 FS Cincinnati IEQI 661 FS Southwest IEQJ 676 Mountain Altitude Sports IHQ] 682 SportSouth FS Detroit 663 FS Southwest Plus IEQ! 677 m649 Alternate 682 SportSouth Plus 1EQ1650 CSN Bay Area FS Detroit Plus lEiQJ 664 FSWest [8QJ 692 1E21696 SportsNet New York 639 IB§I 639 CSN Bay Area Alternate IEQ\ 697 FS Ronda IBQI 654 MASN 640 l8QI64O SportsTime Ohio 662 1mB 662 697 FS Florida Plus IE!Ql 655 MSG Plus 635 00635 Sun Sports 1EBl653 CSN california 1HQl698 FSMidwest EQI671 Madison Square Garden IEQI 634 CSN California a_It 699 Sun Sports Plus m656 699 fS Ndlt.h IBID 668 634 Chicago NESN 628 1EQ1628 Yankee Ent. It Sports It§ 631 CSN Alt. lIZ 667 fSOhio m660 Prime Ticket 1EQI 694 (YES) 631 CSN MidAl.tantic: Alt. 1BQ1643 FSSouth i:!QJ 646 ROOT SPORTS Northwest 1EQI 687 CSN MidAtiantic 64Z 1HQ1642 fS South Plus IEQJ 647 CSN New England 630 JBQJ 630 ROOT SPORTS Pittsburgh IEQI 659 Comcast~et 1t!Q1665 Chicago 5

SONitrAP: 60"5 803 --soWletAP: eoue8e Rock 831 SONICTAP: Italian Bistro 881 SdNICTAP: Regional an .Revolution SONleTAP: Dance 859 Blend Mexlcan SONICTAP: 70's Hits 804­ SONICTAP: Italian 882 SOHlCTAP: Retro Disco 845 SONJCTAP: Familiar 880 Contemporary SONICTAP: 8-Tracks 840 FavOrItes SONlCfAP: Rock en 878 SONICTAP: Jazz 852 SOHICTAP: BO's Hits 805 SONICTAP: Fiesta 870 Espinol 874 SONICTAP: 9O's Hits 806 Tropical SONICTAP: Latin Hits 871 SONlCfAP: Salsa SONICTAP: 823 SONICTAP: Adult 832 839 SONICTAP: Latin Jazz 879 SOHICTAP: Showtunes Alternative Flashback/New Wave SONICTAP: light 866 SONICTAP: Silky Soul 843 SONOAP: Folk Rock 813 SONICTAP: AdUlt 821 Classical SONICTAP: Silver SCreen 822 Contemporary SONICTAP: Full-Metal 830 SONICTAP: love Songs 819 SONICTAP: Singer- 836 SONICTAP: Alternative 834 Jacket SONICTAP: Malt Shop 802 Songwriters SONICTAP: Gospel Glory SOHICTAP: Baflamosl 869 827 Oldies SONICTAP: Smooth Jazz 851 SONICTAP: Great 855 SONICTAP: Mariachi 876 SONfCTAP: Be-Tween 867 SONICTAP: Soft Hits 849 Standards SONICTAP: Metro Blend 853 SONICTAP: Beautiful 820 SONICTAP: Groove 824 SONICTAP: Spike 841 Instrumentals Lounge SONICTAP: Modem 814 Country SONICTAP: SubTerranean 858 SONICTAP: S" 801 SONICTAP: Hafr Guitar 829 Band/Swing 'I SONICTAP: Modem 860 SONICTAP: Symphonic 864 SONICTAP: Bluegrass 812 SONICTAP: Hallelujah 8Z8 Workout SONICTAP: The Boombox 846 SONICTAP: Blues 854 SONICTAP: Hit Country 809 SONICTAP: Music:a De Las 8n SONICTAP: The 868 SONICTAP: Holidays Ii: 815 Americas Playground SOHICTAP: Carnaval 877 Happenings SONIeTAP: New Age 856 B~lefro SONICTAP: The Spirit 826 SONICTAP: Classic Hits SONICTAP: HonkyTonk 811 SONICTAP: Old SChool. 844 SONICTAP: Today's Hits 816 837 Tavern Funk Blend SONICTAP: Traditional 808 SOHICTAf': Classic Jazz 850 SONICTAP: Hot Jamz 825 SONICTAP: PUMP! 861 Country Vocal Blend SONICTAP: Hottest Hits 818 SONICTAP: Piano 865 SONICTAP: Tranquility 884 SONICTAP: Classic R&B 842 SONICTAP: Hurbano 875 SONICTAP: Rat Pack 807 SONICTAP: Y2k Hits 817 SONICTAP: Classic Rock 833 SONICTA!': Hype 847 SONICTAP: Reality Bites 838 SONICTAP: Zen 857 SONICTAP: Classic Rock 862 SONICTAP: Ink'd 835 SONICTAP: Red, Rock 810 Wor1

*The following channels require a special dish or equipment: MHz, GEM NET, Hope Channel, JLTV, Once, HITN, V-Me, Enlace, Golden Eagle Broadcasting, and Free Speech TV_ Please call 1-800-531-5000 for more information.

llnl1011 ) Channela p~ , I c """""'. a .l~; ,E.St/4P ~-~ EPIXl W~ EPIX2 EPtX2 ~ HMC 1IaIlriIilc_ ChlMeI HD'rHR HDl1IuIer HDHMV HDNatMaWes IHDlE IndtdPleK LOGO LOGO M~V1V ANO!:L AnglIIQile ....TV _TMr "'...._~J1.1lil. ANGL2 1 '",.', ....-,.-'.w APL .....PlIhet 810 lie IiIJ\i 1lIobInIIela~ 800M IIaomerat1u ... H~@~ BUYI ~ HBOot eiiSSN c~ Sports Iietm 8B02E H~!(E);'" GCNE GGJY-£ H80SG HBO$IpIIIlII'" CCNEW CCI'HewI , HBD-W tiu!i:(t\:-' C~OK ~CllI!ineI HBOZW 1IB/J2{W) w CSPN2 C-aPAII1 HBOFM "80:~ O~TR DayaIar HBOeY HBO Cemildy 1M' HBOZ HBOlone:Mn'lov DIY DIY tn· .lrlC. IlV!L ._ .___ ~._..~, .._..~ .,. Ul DOC IIacIInenlIry Channel HBOI1 HBO latino FOOD feod IItwllt 118 .SAI.£ SIIa 225 FXNWS FOX 'New-,iChlnn'.I' ·r sleDZ FS.C FOX SlIGcGr Chlnnel fll-.·jfOI!~·-iboP --.-.. - ..'., -·-224 Encol'll (E) SAP GEMS Gema~ild.~y· ", Sttrt (1:) 8/lP Still rNI SAl' G4~ Gr8ll1 Am8lt8n Coumry (GAC) 1&7 • MIlD "'land \Gt HLMHK Hallmlrk Clllnnl' . Stm1~~ StaI1 Cinema SAP $~rz Comedy StaiZ I"Blllck SAP ALTUD ~~&~ bz~& .•w CSll(O ColI~~hW~ CSN BA Comcast SparUIIelllri IfI!8 CS~CA Curn:ast$iDflfietCifooil CSNCH _~Chk:8g0 CSN MA CoIlaSl SIxt1liNet 1MAtld: CSNNE Coml:aStSpatsNet NewEtWJilIl ESPCL ESPrt &Ia,1&IJ•. fSC fox Socar CIaTllI WE CAN AN8~YOURi FOKS+ full SoI:l:lr 1'*1," QUESTIONS-ONliNE: FOXAZ full Splrta kImnu fOXCN Foll SporII ~ e dlsh.comlsupportcenter.' ~l fOXo Foil !pO IJ tacebook.comIdIsh~ ­ fOXFI. folll!porllM twItter.comldlsh,*~~ FOXMW Fox Splrta IItMal ~",JI,,"" .: FUXII Fox SporIIM /1l1I·D.NII...... III.II.ltIl 'IIIl ....·'l'w...... IIII111111111 IiflIl..... Connect your receiver to broadband Intemet or a phone Ine to get more out of .U.a.III..IIIII._ SAP ••,.,...IIIIIIllIIlIIIIIJIil ....-..llIIIllI••ltIl HIL ~ your DISH eeNice. For moM Info .1\1 dl.h.l;OlJI/8~nRfdled• ...... !I _.~ 1IIr ·....."1lIIIllII.III_ ...... III III_IiIII/...... , . ~._ _ ~.._ _._ _ --.U4__._ _ "" ...... ,.,.. LLU._ ._ .'~I ...,IL,. 'I&.I.~ I ~'i·'1V~ l~~::t:a· .,_I11111 I.~·_.. IIl!l IIIII .... ~~ I:!h~ =:: • ,,=______::r="._.,.....11 ' ..:::...... __ ,.=-.... III I::il _ -" . d':aJ;l. ': l80fII ABO fImIIJ AIM MUel_AmmlMl ANSEL r~.;c· ANGL2 APL' '0 IJ1V :::TIfNdon OIlCA BITV .~~, BIIY Burl DET BooM BOlHllll~g 'AP TODN CiI~an' ••tWa~:(~, W 81.. CHILR TDOIW carta.n N"wark (W) DRA.o CLOD .r.­ CCTVE C~ eBssN CNBCW QM . "'\'~>\(~~. CCNEW ~ cuRrt COOK Cooldno Chlnnel IJI/ JI. CHRCH ~--. DiaXiJ DIY ~ N ... "l'~~1IJiII" CIIT CUT Qr ENC~R ~~., ~, C1tBC CJBO, OlVSN ENtRW .~;,~ r:;~,'\'<\,i ,,°"""'*"':1~,,1t:'.,£N\1 1• el. C•• Oblf EACllI ElIiiIl/IAt:Uon . cr,;oy _dY.OintiIL GSI( 'EDRM4' ~=·i;:::.:,;),~ CSPNZ HLMRX'( EIFAM, DmR 'IIMW"~- . . ''1i~ilill' • •. c., .... r~" = .... MSIBe FOXMO fex."-';·: • ...! EI EI E11l1ttarn.,nt Ttlnlsll. NTIlEO' FSC Fox Saa:er Channel ESPN ESflI NBATV FUEL FUEL E8P~ Tv ESPN2 NFL GIIC gme ESNWS E~PlEWS NHLN GAC Gre8~Aintil1can (tAro'·; ESPNU ESPNU CiluWY FOOD Faad N,".rk IKJR H2 lit FXNWS FOX Newl Channel NUVO HMC ItIItIIn MnIe WoaeI' FX FX SAP OVATN HUB IiIb Gems & Jewelry TV OWN MIL OEMS OXYGN, ""·lbmel HDNET H~~ ,"D'cin~ MPLEX MnIePIel RFDTV MON2 IISTV HilTY . IIIST Hlltary SOAP RIT8W 1IIl&n WILD SPEED -~. HLN HLN NICKT ....0UIdlIar CbenneI, 39& I OlDCH HRTV Hcil1ellaclng TV I SlYLE HSN HSN TNCK GREEN If8ft2 118N2 . FTRAE· Sc' FTRAW SPMAII ==-.~""'.i'··"; IClV In CoImJ TdjNIsIan T8nnIt C/lIImei ,"':"':A. .t .. ,,: , 4GO'"Cl ,1St' llIU TEN is .,;:a.~ TCM mc-w The MoYlll' Channal:(W)W I UNVSN mcxw TIle ~~ ...(VI) IAl' UNVSW EPlllS ThJ ._"SfX!Ult .,' 't:z1l;;~ WE VERlA \VIa /Il1/ waN V8. Ytms ,r YHlCl. VlI1Cl lMiIIt ~ Ccuity ': . :~ E1ectonlc , Denc.' , ,.., CD ='.~~.I i Hlp-Hop/~8 ARTS ~"= JIZZ ,Iil. CSMN ....II_i_. LeIIn &"-tlonal EWtN Pojl '}'. ~~ ::&~t~:.:I' ••••• Roo\( ... Hils ..__"_._••_."••••••..•"' I~. StendWd. HIlN,'" '1!lfII~\w ...... _., ' ""' .. "'''',''''.IlIII'l'''!. • AP·...... fIIIl " _ ••lIO....~...... III....dD, .JIJI1·n~ •••A1' \..r ..llO. REDACTED - FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION

EXHIBIT 3 REDACTED - FOR PUBLIC INS

Elmhurst Area Ci1107.11

37 Comcast SportsNet Chicago 181 Food Network HO/\/\ 134 Fuse 38 CLTV 197 Disn~ Channel HO"" 135 MTV2 39 CNBC 198 ABC amil~ HO"" 141 Tr3s: MTV. Muska y Mas 40 The Weather Channel 199 The Golf Cannel HO/\/\ 142 MTV Jams 2 WBBM (CBS) / HO 189/\/\ 41 AMC 200 Comcast SportNet HO/\/\ 143 LOGO 3 HSN 42 Comedy Central 203 ESPN2 HO/\/\ 146 CMT 4 WGBO (UNI) / HO 182/\/\ 43 E! 204 TNT in HO/\/\ 150 Ovation 5 WMAQ (NBC) / HO 188/\/\ 44 History 205 HO Theater"" 161 GSN 6 Government Access 45 Lifetime 207 Universal HO/\/\ 162 BBC America 7 WLS ~BC~/ HO 187/\/\ 46 Nickelodeon 208 A&E HO/\/\ 168/412 NFL Network 8 WPW lli' T) / HO 184"" 47 Cartoon Network 209 Palladia HO/\/\ 169 NFL Network HO"" 9 WGN (C ) / HO 192/\/\ 48 Discovery Channel 216 CNN HO/\/\ 178 CNBC World 10 WCIU The U/ HO 183"" 49 TNT 218 Discovery HO/\/\ 201 Planet Green 11 wnw raS) I HD 191/\/\ 50 TBS 219 TBS HO/\/\ 206 National Geographic HO/\/\ 12 WFLD OXI/ HD 190AA 51 ABC Family 221 USA HO"" 212 Science HO/\/\ 13 > WCPX IION) / HD 238/\/\ 52 TLC 224 Animal Planet HO"" 215 TeenNick 14 WSNS TEl) / HO 193"" 53 HGTV 225 Nickelodeon HO/\/\ 220 OWN (Oprah Winfrey 15 WXFT HD 194/\/\ 54 Disney Channel 226 Cartoon Network HO/\/\ Network) 16 Educational Access 58 FX 227 Hallmark Movie Channel 222 Discovery Fit & Health 17 WJYS" 59 MSNBC HO"" 231 ESPNews HO/\/\ 18 TV Guide Network 60 Food Network 228 Lifetime H0"" 232 CBS ~orts Network HOM 19 Public Access 61 Travel Channel 229 Lifetime Movie Network 233 MLB etwork HO/\/\ 20 WYCC WBS)" / HO 240/\/\ 64 BTN HO"" 235 NBA TV HO"/\ 21 WYIN ~BS) 65 truTV 234 NHL Network HO"" 253 ESPNU HO/\/\ 89/164 ShopN C" 66 BET 237 s~eed Channel HOM 261 Planet Green HO /\ /\ 95 CSPAN 68 The Golf Channel 256 B NHOM 263 Encore HO"" 97 avc 70 Galavisi6n - in Berwyn, 262 E!HO/\/\ 272 Science 98/138 TLN" Cicero & Brookfield; on 264 Fox Business Network 273 National Geographic 100 Comeast Network" Digital Preferred and HO"" 274 Military Channel 110 Cable Marketplace 1" MultiLatino channel 597 in 265 Fox News Channel HOM 279 Fuse HO"/\ 113 Cable Marketplace 3" other areas 266 CNBC HO"" 280 IFC HO"" 114 Leased Accesg:ot available 72 s~eed Channel 267 FX HO"" 281 WE HOM in Berwyn, Sr . field or 73 T Land 269 BID HOM 283 Disne~ XO HOM Cicerp" 75 VERSUS 270 The Weather Channel 284 MGM 0/\/\ 217 ABC Live Well HD/\/\ 101 Comcast Network 101 HO"" 298 CMT HO/\/\ 341 NBC Chicago Nonstop" 102 Cable Marketplace 2 278 Bravo HO"" 299 GMC HO/\" 342 Universal Sports (via WMAQ­ 103 Leased Access 282 QVC HOA" 319 Turner Classic Movies DT)" 104 CSPAN 2 285 Comcast Info Channel HO"" 345 ABC 7 Live Well" 105 CSPAN 3 HO"" 402 ESPNews 353 AntennaTV (via WGN-DT)" 106 Fox Business Network 287 S~le HO"" 405 ESPNU 357 Me-TV" 118 S~'e 288 G HO"" 410 MLB Network 358 Me-TOO" 119 E TN 289 TV One HO"" 416 S~ortsman Channel 359 THIStv" 123/71 Oxtgen 290 Spike HO/\/\ 418 C Sseorts Network 360 The UToo" 127 PB KIDS S~rout 293 Travel Channel HO"" 439 NBAT 368/629 wnw V-me" 128 Bloomberg elevision 294 Comedy Central HO"" 471 CMT Pure Country 369 wnw Create" 129/159 Jewelry Television 295 BET HO/\/\ 472 MTV Hits 370 wnw Prime" 131 Hallmark Channel 296 MTV HO"" 473 VHl Classic 372 WYCC World" 136 G4 297 VH1 HO/\/\ 474 VHl Soul 385/687 WJYS2" 149 MoviePlex 317 MSNBC HOM 475 GMC 386 MCTV (via WJYS-DT)/\ 160 318 Headline News HO/\" 481 Centric 389/596 LATV \Via WOCK-OTb" 172 ¥~bne 320 truTV HO"" 484 GAC 390/599 mea8 v Wa WOCK- T)" 180 Bravo 321 Hallmark Channel HO/\/\ 486 The World Network 391/689 KB (via OCK-DTt 230 Trinity Broadcasting 322 HSN HO/\/\ 487 Retirement LiVi~ TV 392/690 Asian American Ne work (via 255 BTN 323 History International HO"" 501 Turner Classic ovies WOCK-DW' 271 Investigation Discovery 324 InvestIgation Discovery 502 WE 393/598 Azteca America" 275 BIO HO"" 503 IFC 396/657 Estrella TV (via WESV-LD)" 276 Histo~ International 333 XFINITY 30" /\/\" 505 Sundance Channel West 701-746 Music Choice Channels" 404 NHl etwork 334 ESPN 30"""" 507 ReelzChannel 877 WFLM 87.7 (via WCHU)" 485 Daystar Television Network 516 Encore WAM 504 Lifetime Movie Network 517 Encore 508 Hallmark Movie Channel 519 Encore Love 692·693 Comcast Xtra 521 Encore Mystery 107 Current 522 RetroPlex 24 Animal Planet 108 Nat Geo Wild 523 En core Western 26 Fox News Channel 109 SOAPNet 527 Encore Drama 28 ~ikeTV 116 Weatherscan Local 528 IndiePlex 29 TV 001 On Demand 120 Nick Jr. 529 Encore Action 30 VH1 171 AMC HOM 121 DIY 586 FliX 31 USA Network 173 ESPN HO"" 122 Disney XD 597 Galavisi6n - on Expanded 32 A&E 174 VERSUS HO"" 124 Cooking Channel Basic chanel 70 in Berwyn, 33 ESPN 175 Histo~ HO"" 126 Nicktoons Network Cicero & Brookfield 34 ESPN2 176 130 The Hub 603 mun2 35 Headline News TLC H "" 673 MYX (Filipino) 177 S~~ HO"" 132 Nick Too 36 CNN 179 H V HO"" 133 The Africa Channel

See reverse for alist of towns included in Elmhurst Area. (Somcast 607 Canal 52MX 586 FLIX 608 CNN en Espanol IC5lNSPmfJ'~eoannel 609 ESPN Deportes 59~' 11ie~OvieCnannel Xtra 610 Cine Mexicano 611 Caracol TV Internacional Includes Limited Basic Service, HD broadcast channels, A&E, Animal S~eed 612 Ecuavisa Internacional 72 Channel 613 EI Garage Planet, BET, Cartoon Network, CNN, 168f412 N LNetwork 614 AYM Sports Comedy Central, CSPAN, CSPAN 2 169 NFL Network HO"" 615 HTV Musica Discovery Channel, Disney Channel. 227 Hallmark Movie Channel 616 Mexicanal El. EWrN Food Network, Fox News 427/683 NEO Cricket (Indian) HO"" 617 Disney XD Channel, Histo!}', HSN Jewelry 660 STAR India NEWS 231 ESPNews HO"" 618 Multimedios Television, lifellmel.9VC. Spike TV, 661 STAR ONE 232 CBS ~orts Network HO"" USA Network. The weather Channel MLB etwork HOIIII 619 Viendo Movies West 662 STAR India GOLD 233 620 Gran Cine and where available. the corresponding 663 STAR India PLUS 234 NHL Network HOIIII HD channels for these networks. NBA TV HOIIII 621 Canal 24 Horas 664 SET Asia 235 622 GolTV (en Espanol) HDTV equipment is required to view 665 TV Asia 236 The Tennis Channel HD"" gigital Economy HD channels.) 253 ESPNU HOIIII 623 Infinito 666 Zee TV 254 NFL RedZone HO"" 624 Video Rola 667 CCTV·4 (Chinese) 260 TV Games Network 625 TV Venezuela 668 CT4 Zhong nan (Chinese) 401 Fox Soccer Channel 626 La Familia Network 669 SBTN (Vietnamese) 402 ESPNews 627 TeleFormula 670 TFC (Fllipinol 403 ESPN Classic 628 Canal Sur 185 Showtime HD"" 671 GMA Pinoy TV (Filipino) 404 NHL Network 630 TV Colombia 186 HBO HO"" 672 GMA Ufe TV (Filipino) 405 ESPNU 631 TV Chile 195 Cinemax HO"" 674 TV JAPAN 406 Outdoor Channel 632 Latele Novela 196 Starz HO"" 675·678 Polish Super Pack: TV 407 HorseRacing TV 633 TBN-Enlace USA 257 Starz Kids & Family HOIIII Polonia. TVP INFO. Radio 410 MLB Network 634 jSorpresa! 258 Starz Comedy HOIIII Jedvnka, Radio Trojka 411 NFL RedZone 635 nuvoTV 259 Starz Edge HOM 679 Railtalia (Italian) 413 Fox College Sports Atlantic 636 Discovery Familia 300 HBO 2 HOIIII 680 RTN~RUSSm) 414 Fox College Sports Central 637 EWTN E~Ranol 301 HBD Comedy HOIIII 684 ART Arabic) 415 Fox College Sports Pacific 638 Cable No icias 304 HBO Zone HO"" 688 TV5 ONDE (French) 416 sRortsman Channel 639 Mexico 22 305 HBO latino HO"" 417 T eTennis Channel 640 TeleRitmo TV 307 ActionMax HDIIII 418 CBS Sports Network 641 Once Mexico 308 Showtime Too HOIIII 642 Mexico TV 309 Showtjme Showcase HOIIII 420 ~sNet New York 421 ntainWest Sports 643 Sur Peru 310 Showtime Extreme HOIIII Includes CSPAN, CSPAN 2, Disney Network 644 TV Dominicana 314 The Movie Channel HD"" Channel, Disney XD, DIY, Food 422 Comcast SportsNet New 645 Telemicro 316 5StarMAX HO"" Network, Headline News, HGTV, England 646 Telefe Internacional 533 Starz National Geographic, Nickelodeon, 423 Sun Sports 647 UtiHsima 535 Starz Edge PBS KIDS Sprout, TeenNick, The Hub, 424 FSN Prime Ticket 648 CBTV Michoacan 537 Starz in Black Science, The Weather Channel and 425 Comcast SportsNet Bay Area 649 HITN-TV 538 Starz Cinema Trinity Broadcasting, 439 NBATV 650 WAPA America 539 Starz Kids & Family 481 Centric 651 TVE Internacional 540 Starz Comedy 652 TeleHit 543 Playboy TV 489 Military Histor~ 490 Crime & Inves igation 653 Ritmoson 550 HBO East Network 654 Bandamax 551 HBO West 655 De Pelicula 552 HBO 2 440·449 TEAM PPV 506 Fox Movie Channel 450 TEAMHO PPVIIII 508 Hallmark Movie Channel 656 De Pelicula Clasico 554 HBO Signature 556 HBO Family 459 GAMEH02 PPV"" 558 HBO Latino 460 GAMEHO PPV"" 559 HBO Comedy 461-470 GAME PPV 560 HBO Zone 477-480 GAME PPV Only available as a component of 561 Cinemax West 829 iN DEMAND HD PPV"" 001 On Demand 562 Cinemax East 830-832 iN DEMAND PPV 595 Playboy TV en Espanol (canal MultiLatino Max and Ultra packages 833-838 ESPN Sports PPV and includes the following channels: 564 MoreMax discrecional) 566 ActionMax 840 TEN 597 Galavision Bravo. ESPN, ESPN 2, Galavlsion 841 Vavoom (where available.), The Golf Channel, 567 5StarMAX 600 Viendo Movies 575 Showtime 842 Playboy TV 601 Discovery en Espanol lifetime Movie Network. MTV, 844 Real Nickelodeon, PBS KIDS Sprout, 577 Showtime Too 602 Fox Deportes 579 Showtime Showcase 845 Penthouse TV 603 mun2 Comcast SportsNet Chicago, Svfy, TBS, TlC, TNT, Versus, arid Vtf1. 581 Showtime Extreme 604 Cine Latino 583 Showtime Next 605 History en Espanol 584 Showtime FamilyZone 606 Tr3s: MTV, Musica y Mas 585 Showtime Women

Addison, Bedford Park, Bellwood, BensenVille, Berkeley, Berwyn, Bloomingdale, Brandywine, BridgeView, Broadview, Brookfield, Burbank, Burr Ridge, @omcast Carol Stream, Cicero, Clarendon Hills, Countryside, Darien, Downers Grove, Elmhurst, Elmwood Park, Forest Park, Forest View, Franklin Park, Itasca, Glendale Heights, Harwood Heights, Hillside, Hines Hospital, Hodgkins, Indian Head Park, Justice, LaGrange Park, LaGrange. Leydon Twp, lombard, Lyons, lyons Twp, Maywood, McCook, Melrose Park, Norridge, Northlake, North Riverside, Norwood Park Twp, Nottingham Park, Oak Brook, Oakbrook Terrace, Oak Park, Proviso Twp. River Forest, River Grove, Riverside, Roselle, Rosemont, Schiller Park, Stickney, Stone Park. Summit, Westchester, Western Springs. Westmont, Willowbrook, Willow Springs, Wood Dale, Woodridge and Villa Park

Nolllll servlces are avaiIiIbIe in all areas. PrIdng. programmlllg. d1anneIlocalion IIIlll patkaglng 1$ subjetllO chal1\}e. comcast service is subject ID Ihe tel'1TI$1IIlll condilklns of Cllmcast CllllIs PdIcies and Prac1ice$. Asubsc(llltion to lJmlllld!laslc Servlce is required 10 receiIIo oIher servlCllS or levels 01 SllI\'iCe of YIdeo PlllQIamming. SOme servlcesroQlJitea CableCARD or areceiver and remote at an additional charqe. eal CDII1cast at 1-l1OO-XFINlTY fomstricllollS lIJIII complete details. "AVllilaije 10 ClJSIllmer$ willt Limited Baslc 5e!vice who use alfigilal roclliver or compatible equipment. MTo receive channsls oflered in HO, aHO tellMsion (not Plovilled). HOW llQIlipmonl and SUbsl;ripliotl tllthe channel's service level or Ul1dertYin!l Plemlumservlce iII\lfequired. """AVlliaIjeto CUSlDll1elswith Expanded Bw;k; who use aIligilil teceiver or I:O/lIpllb1lleeQlipmonl. M""Aftil3D TV. compatlbfeequipmenland Comcasl 30 authorizaUon are reQUIted. 'D~ EcOnOtl1'/ does not fndlJl1e On Demand and cannot be combined with servlce lovels IhlIllndUde Of require Expanded Basic. "Family Tier requires subsatpllon 10 limited BasIc servk:e. &annoI be combined with service levels thai Include or require Expanded Basic and does not include Music Choice or On Demand.

No lOlIlIS los servlcios est!n disporibles en Iodas las areas. PrecIos, PtllQlamacioo, lJIJIcacioo de canales YflIllI!Jllles eslan ~tas acambios. Servldos de ComcasllWtl &/JIetos alas condiciOnes de los Tennlnos yP611zilSlltl COnlcasI callie. Suscripei6n al Umited Basic ServIcees requerilla para obtener oIros serviallS 0niveIes de setVido lltlprogramal;ioo de video. Algunos SllfViciosteQUleren unalllljIlIlIde C8llIeo CableCARD 0un tece/llOt lfigilal ycontrol fBlllOW aun cargo adlCional. Llame 8 Comcaat 1I11-800-XFINtTY para restrIc:cIOnes ydetain completos. "0lSlJ0nibIe aclIenIes con III niveI de Umiled Basic ServIce quienes usan un recepior dIglliI 0 equ/jlocompab'ble. ""Para reelber canales en ata deflnicioo (HO) so requlere una l!iIevlsIiln de alta deflnlcl6n (Hom. eQUIpo para televisor de alta deflllldlin (no Inclulde) ysuscripcl6n al niveI de setVIclo llonde 58 ubica eI canal or seMelO premium subyacenltl. A""llisponiWl adientes con 1II niveI de Expanded Bas/t; qUCIlllS usan 1JI recepIor digilii eequIpo compallbIe. """"'Sf tequ!ere lllllMsioo de 30. eQlipo compalillle yaulOriZadiln cIll3D de Comcas\'Oigital EllOllOtTlV no induye On Demand y no se IlIlede comllinar con Jiveln de seMele que Iflduyen 0requleten Expanded BflSlc. "Spaque\e FamBy TIer tllQlJllil'O S1JSQipcicin allimtted Basic Service. no puede set combioaOO con riYcles de servido QlJe incluyen ereqlJietan al seMelo Expanded Basic yno Incluye los canales de musica Music Cheice uOn Demand.

8771/2000 (0010, 0090-0110,0370,0500,0850-1410,1650-1830. 1870-1910) GCR·CLU-G1 REDACTED - FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION

EXHIBIT 4 nnp:IIWWW.an.COIDIcnanneumeup/u-vt:rst:/\;InUUlt:l-lUlCUjJ.J:lp IIU.....I~-••. REDACTED - FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION AT&T U-verse Channel Lineup

ZIP code: 60029 Change I As 01: November 2B, 2011 Show only: PMnl

Search·by channel names Compare Packages U450 U300 U200 U100 U-family U-basic Ex.: CNN, Cartoon, ESPN ? Reset

Clear comparisons U300 TV Package $84/mo. View premium add-on clHl1flSls 'f' Compare TV Packages Sort by: Channel Name Channel Create your own slde-bY-

v.MAQ-5 (NBC) 5 WGBO-66 (UNI) 6 WLS-7 (ABC) 7

-C1E;:l( filters WPWR-50 (MY NE1WORK 8 WGN-9 (THE C'N) 9 WCIU-26 (Ind,) 10 TV) Filter by Category WTTW-11 (PBS) 11 WFlD-32 (Fox) 12 WOCK-CD-13 (MEGA TV) 13

WXFT-60 (TF) 16 WYCC-20 (PBS) 20 WWME-23 (Ind.) 23 FavoMtes '1 WWT0-35 (TBN) 35 As Seen On TV 37 WCPX-38 (ION) 38

HD WOCH-41 (KBC) 41 WSNS-44 (TEL) 44 v.MEU-48 (Ind.) 48

WYIN-56 (PBS) 56 WCHU-61 (AZTECA) 61 WJY5-62 (Ind.) 62 Movies Valu TV 82 AT&T U-verse Shopping 1 84 AT&T U-versa Front Row 100 Sports

News TNT (Turner Network 108 TNT (Turner Network 109 TBS 112 Television) Television) - West Local TBS-West 113 Smithsonian Channel 118 Discovery Channel 120 Educational USA Network 124 FX Network 128 EI Entertainment Televislon 134

Filter by Premium Package TV Land 138 Comedy Cenlral 140 Spike TV 145

G4 149 Syfy 151 Chiller 153 Movie Pkgs. BET (Black Entertainment 155 TV One 157 cloo 161 Sports Pkgs. Television)

Crime & Investigation 163 tnuTV 164 truTV - West 165 International Pkgs_ Network

A&E 166 GSN - Game Show Network 173 ABC Family Channel 178

Bravo 181 LOGO 183 BBCAmerica lBB

Current TV 189 mun2 192 nuvoTV 194

COMPRA 196 Jewelry Television 197 AT&T U-verse Shopping 4 198

AT&T U-verse Movies 200 CNN (Cable News Network) 202 CNN Headline News 203

CNNI (CNN Intemational) 205 FOX News Channel 210 Fox Business NetwOrk 211

MSNBC 215 CNBC 216 CNBCWortd 217

Bloomberg Television 222 The Weather Channel 225 BUY TV 228

C-SPAN 230 C-SPAN2 231 C-SPAN3 232

ABC News Now 243 AT&T U-verse Shopping 2 247 TlC 250

Animal Planet 252 Travel Channel 254 OWN - Oprah Winfrey 256 Network

Science 258 Military Channel 259 Investigation Discovery 260

NASA TV 264 National Geographic Channel 265 Nat Geo WILD 266

History 270 BIO 272 H2 274

Military History Channel 276 Disney Channel 302 DlsneyXD 304

Nickelodeon 314 Nick2 316 Nicktoons 318

Nick Jr. 320 Teen Nick 322 Cartoon Network 325

Cartoon Network - West 326 Boomerang 327 qubo 328

The Hub 335 PBS Kids Sprout 337 Smile of a Child TV 340

Lifetime Television 360 Lifetime Movie Network 362 SOAPnet 365

of4 11/28/2011 8:19 AM nnp:rrwww.att.COInJCnannemneUp/U-venie/l;UiUlllCJ-UllCUp·PP.IV.....l<;-... REDACTED - FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION

tvMall 367 Oxygen 368 372

Style Networlt 360 AT&T U-verse Shopping 3 399 Customer Notification 400

avc 420 Home Shopping Network 422 ShopNBC 424 (HSN)

Jewelry Television 428 AT&T U-verse Shopping 4 429 Home & Garden Television 450 (HGTV)

Food Networlt 452 DIY NetwOrk (Do-It-Yourself 454 Cooking Channel 456 Network)

Planet Green 465 Discovery Fit & Health 466 ION Life 466

Wealth TV 470 tvMall 471 SWRV 501

MTV (Music Television) 502 MTV2 504 MTVTr3s 506

MTVJllms 508 MTVHils 509 m1vU 510

Centric 515 BET Gospel 516 VH1 518

VH1 Classic 520 VH1 Soul 522 CMT (Country Music 525 Television)

CMT Pure Country 527 Great Amerlcan Country 529 fuse 535 (GAC)

FUEL TV 536 TBN - Trinity Broadcasting 560 Eternal Word Television 562 Network Network (EWTN)

Daystar 563 INSP (Inspiration Networlt) 564 The Church Channel 565

FamilyNet 566 BYU 567 JCTV 570

The Word Networlt 575 World Harvest Television 578 FAITH 580

AT&T U-verse Sports 600 ESPN 602 ESPN Classic 603

ESPNEWS 604 ESPNU 605 ESPN2 606

NFL Networlt 630 NBATV 832 MLB Nelworlt 634

VERSUS 640 Golf Channel 641 BTN 650

Speed Channel 652 Fox Soccer 654 Sports Alternate 1 691

Sports Alternate 2 692 Sports Alternate 3 693 Sports Alternate 4 694

Sports Alternate 5 695 Sports Alternate 6 696 Sports Alternate 7 697

Comcast SportsNet Chicago 741 Comcast SportsNet Chicago 742 Turner Classic Movies (TCM) 790 Alternate

Fox Movie Channel 7g2 AMC 795 IFC 797

Sundance Channel 798 ReelzChannel 799 U-verse Showcase 800

Showtime 852 Showtime - West 853 Showtime Too 654

Showtime Too - West 855 Showtime Showcase 856 Showtime Showcase - West 657

Showtime Extreme 858 Showtime Extreme - West 859 Showtime Beyond 660

Showtime Family Zone 862 Showtime Next 864 Showtlme Women 866

The Movie Channel (TMC) 882 The Movie Channel (TMC) - 883 TMC Xtra 684 West

TMC Xlra - West 885 FlIX B90 Starz 902

Slarz - West 903 Slarz Edge 904 Starz inBlack 906

Starz Cinema 90B Starz Movieplex 909 Starz Comedy 910

Slarz Kids & Family 912 IndiePJex 914 RetroPlex 916

Encore 932 Encore - West 933 Encore Love 934

Encore Suspense 936 Encore Action 938 Encore Westerns 940

Encore Drama 942 Encore Espanol 943 Encore Family 944

AT&T U-verse Movies 945 Customer Notification 11 00 AT&T U-verse Movies 1200

Jewelry Television 1426 AT&T U-verse Sports 1600 U-verse Showcase 1600

Customer Notification 2500 WGBO-66 (UNI) 3002 Galavision 3003

WXFT-60 (TF) 3005 WSNS-44 (TEL) 3007 WOCK-CD-13 (MEGA TV) 300B

of4 11/28/2011 8:19 AM ------

lU,"p.fl VY W 'WY ..Q\\..\.tVUlt "',.UUU-l\lfUu.a\ioout" W.- Y,-"J,QlV/ "'.I~,l"""I,"J-U,u,,,u:t'.J.~t' ...vvu.~.... REDACTED - FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION

mUJ12 3009 COMPRA 3014 WCHU-61 (AZTECA) 3019

qubo 3061 EWTN E$panol 30n M"TVTr3s 3142

Gold9ll Boy Pres9llla 3312 CC"TV-9 3602 SWFN 5100

Hit List 5101 Hlp-Hop and R&B 5102 MCMIxTapa 5103

DBIlce-Eleclronica 5104 Rap 5105 Hip-Hop Cluslcs 5106

Throwback Jamz 5107 R&B Classics 5106 R&BSoul 5109

Gospel 5110 Reggae 5111 Classic Ro.ck 5112

Relro Rock 5113 Rock 5114 Metal 5115

Alternative 5116 ClIIsslc Alternative 5117 Adult Alternative 5118

5011 Rock 5119 Pop Hits 5120 90s 5121

80s 5122 70s 5123 Solid Gold Oldies 5124

Party Favorites 5125 Stage & Screen 5128 K1dzOnlyl 5127

Toddler Tunes 5128 Todays Country 5129 TrueCounby 5130

Classic Country 5131 ContemporalY Chiistian 5132 Sounds of the Sll8SOns 5133

Soundscapes 5134 Smooth Jazz 5135 Jazz 5136

Blues 5137 Singelll & Swing 5138 Easy Listening 51311

Classical MasleIplac:es 5140 Light Classical 5141 Musica Urbana 5142

Pop LatIno 5143 Tl1:lPlcalas 5144 Mexicana 5145

Romances 5146 Live MU.ltivtew AJtemata 1 9211 live Multlvtew Alternate 2 9212

Live Multiview Alternate 3 9213 Live MultMew Alternate 4 9214 Live Multivtew Alternate 5 9215

of4 1112812011 8:19 AM