American Council for an Erergy Torkelson Economy Oliver Energy Eficiency Institute Oliver Jordan Oliver Strain Oliver Harden Mueller Metz Pittman Talbert Bucchare Pizzo Cohen Acciaioli Buscemi Olson Goetz Domagalski O'Keefe London Bucchare Dunayczan Gronzo Fritzler Smith Ratnala Mueller Lernmen Ford Krill Brennan Wemy Bockes Kitzmiller Huebner Arrow smith Becher Buccilli Klok MacFarlane wern~ Zick Wi tzenmann West Cook Wilgus Illegible Hauk Oblin Warden Illegible Lynch Goldberg Taylor Hays Shelton Livingston Ragland ROY Moore Murray Hall Leiser Arnold Kaczkowski Ellis Akkashian Gonway Wargo Bockes Lin Huebner Cleveland Grassi Stoops Johannessen Carnes Johannessen Santos Johannessen Neugebauer Long Kubicina Hall Mack Carr Stromayer
)* " k . \ v " " .- omments of Martin G. Kushler The PAYS (Pay As You Save) Collaborativ gan Public Service Commission, March 7, 2 by Martin G. Kushler, Ph.D. Director, Utilities Program ncil for an Energy-Efficient Economy Court Williamston, Michigan 48895
Thank-you for the opp to comment on this matter. I was an active participant in the PAYS Callaborati s, have reviewed the limited available evaluation data on the PAYS program, sessed this program concept in the context of utility energy efficiency progr ience around the nation. I just have a few observations and recommendations t th the Commission.
The PAYS conc a mechanism for financing energy efficiency bill. This is a well-known generic concept within sewhere as a supplementary program component ., in California). The PAYS founders have added a marketed PAYS as a proprietary product. I am ntal testing of this program component concept expressed below). However, I think the consider the extent to which it explicitly endorses a general concept.
2. On-bill financing S concept) is NOT A COMPREHENSIVE PROGRAM, it is of a comprehensive energy efficiency service. Other crucial co mprehensive energy efficiency program include elements such a ing and customer education; outreach and training "trade ally" participants; other customer financial monitoring and evaluation; etc. The PAYS e funding for any of those other key program se costs onto the customer on-bill financing would make the co bitive. The utility should be paying for the costs of a ergy efficiency resource procurement. (That is approximately 25 states that have utility-funded
3. Only one state has i lem nted a PAYS program (New Hampshire), and that state also has explicit utilit fun ing that provides those other program elements. Moreover, the only a ailab e evaluation of the PAYS program showed that having those other program leme ts available was very important to customers, and helped facilitate the use of th PA S on-bill financing mechanism (e.g., customers would combine rebates and"I lnanc I ng, in order to do more comprehensive energy efficiency ment or generic on-bill make clear that a PAYS s not constitute a complete er elements (As described ive and successfbl energy asized that operating a nt should not be used as re comprehensive , . FILED
Harlan Lachman 802.879.8895 1
March 1,2006 via Electronic Mail
Executive Secretary Michigan Public Service P.O. Box 302221 6545 Mercantile Way; Lansing MI 489 11-5990
RE: Statement of Ene gy E iency Institute, Inc. in Case No. U-13808 Detroit Edison's hird port to the Commission on the Status of the "Pay As You Sav @I1 S@)Collaborative Dear Ms. Kunkle: tI Attached please find the of the Energy Efficiency Institute, Inc. to be filed in the above proceeding. If pos e post this PDFhile along with other comments on the appropriate page in the C n's electronic case filing system and distribute it in the appropriate manner to the Thank you in advance for ?ur atI ention to this matter. I I Sincerely, Harlan Lachman, President
Encl. A .- .,A L.aLCHIGAN
ICHIGAN PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION MAR -2 2006
In the matter of the appli e DETROIT ) EDISON COMPANY t Rate schedules governin supply of electric energy, nt Power Supply ) Cost Recovery plans, fact Case No. U-13808 its rate schedules for juris electricity and for miscell and regulatory asset reco Page 2 ill test whether it is possible to implement the PAYS@ tariff
gh EEI believes that non-participants should help to pay for
as we explain later in this letter, we also believe that the
rmation in Michigan and throughout the country.
s, we recommend that the MPSC order approve Edison's request to proceed with its gned and clarify that PAYS@ tariffs are permissible in
This will be a preced ng order. Therefore, we also request that the MPSC include the following three clarific its order in this case in order to avoid misconceptions about the nature of PAYSB and 's requirements for a PAYS@ tariff: Page 3 environment, the ec system reliability and security, and, based on the law of supply
and demand, omers' energy costs.
et-based system in which customers who use the PAYS@ tariff
pay for the installed es, EEI believes that since non-participants also benefit, they
should pay some rom the beginning of the development of the PAYS@
system, EEI -participants would contribute to the cost of infrastructure
costs for this pilot described in 1.6 in Attachment B of
Edison's report.
2) Apportioning start- ong participants in a pilot is inequitable. With a market-
cannot know how many customers will take part in the
recover start-up costs from participants will be at best a
ed either too little or too much.
enting this limited pilot to test if the PAYS@ tariff is
ake available to all customers. If all start-up costs are
son's PAYS@ pilot, every customer who uses the
will be getting a free ride. The pilot participants will have already paid for the stIF rt-up osts for infrastructure that post-pilot customers will use at no cost.
3 .) Finally, adding a fee t start-up costs to pilot measure costs will result in cost- effective measures fai1 ing t qualify as PAYS@ products. The more fees that are added to the PAYS@ customer s, the fewer measures that will pass the PAYS@ screening
test. Hence, adding st sts to pilot participants' PAYS@ charges will prevent pilot
participants from t effective measures that would benefit them, their utility Page 4 EEI Comments in Case Page 5 pay the up-front costs qualified measures, will result in lower utility and customer
efficiency measures would not buy.
2. These will lower these customers' usage and their
with the basic principles of supply and demand,
will lower system c ake bills more affordable for all customers.
3. If bills are more a all customers, fewer customers will have trouble
paying their bills and 's overall bad debt will be reduced from the levels it
would experience in of the PAYS@ tariff availability.
4. Moreover, bad debt a :d with all purchasers of PAYS@ qualified measures will
be reduced:
a. Customers who hal~ebe paying their bills and who purchase efficiency measures
using the PAYS@ tariff ill have lower bills than they would have had without the
PAYSB purchase, :here 7 reducing the number of these customers who might
have trouble ~a~indthej ?ills.
b. Customers who h sly had trouble paying bills will also have lower bills
(even with PAY han they otherwise would have, hence the current
amount of bad d stomers will be reduced.
5. There is little likelihoo t related to measure failure. If a PAYS@-qualified
measure fails, warr the cost of repair required to maintain the
payment obligation at he lo on. If for any reason the contractor does not honor the
warranty, bonding or a irre able letter of credit will ensure that the warranty is honored. Even if warr ity sions are insufficient to cover repair costs required to EEI Comments in Case No. Page 6 maintain the paym ion, the PAYSB Certification Agent will have a
contractual right irs and, by extending the term of the payments, collect all repair costs from t hose t etting the savings. In the New 8 pilots, customers who purchased PAYS@ products and
ff obligations had payment rates significantly better than the
. As mentioned above, PSNH's pilot served MUSH
ed bad debt, clearly as low or lower than the rate for all other utilities' MUSH customers
New Hampshire erative's PAYS@ pilot served all customers including
tomers. Its PAYSB related bad debt was less than eight hundredths of one percent rate than the bad debt for any utility company in the country.
Allowing utilities to related bad debt from all customers will not only lower the cost of capital, the number of PAYS@-qualified measures all customers can purchase, it ctly lower all customers' costs. Page 7
CONCLUSION
recommended above.
Respectfully submitted,
Harlan Lachman; President eeivt.com Good Morning, ! I Couple of things I would go over and be heard on.
1. Michigan is way for a good Energy Saving Program. I do mean more talking and educating. We need to start putting the products in the hands of th f Michigan to help them save energy. This needs to be open to all customers. r is is used to help the economic growth of Michigan to bring new their bottom line. Energy efficient
3. The Pays but is limited to only a select group of customers for to explore more options and other programs to that
to find an over all program that offers energy savings to all , and water in Michigan should be to do this then they should be blocked
to step to the plate and become a leader in the field of ople of Michigan stand up for are rights and tell the Utilities the best when it comes to energy efficiency. We are way over due for an en rogram. Many of the people here in the state worry every pay there gas and electric bills. It time for us to stop talking
Sincerely i I Charles M. Wood New Boston, Michigan 48164 Dated February 25,2006 Dear Chairman Lark,
Best Regards,
Page 1 of 1
Felice, Li -g - P wv From: Gary Harden [garyha'den comcast.net] Sent: Saturday, December 18, 2 4 6:44 PM To: MPSC-Commissione -s Subject: DTE Rate Increase Dear Sirs, 4 1 I1 Ok, now it is getting ridculous. In ays of recession in Michigan, I fail to understand how you can authorize an increase of almost 23% (from 62+.01426) from last year to this year for natural gas. You know as well as I, once a rate has been establi never be recinded - I'm talking about the interim two-year adjustment.
How about thinking a bit more of this state instead of DTE and MichCon. It's too bad about benefit increase costs, but other to absorb some of that increase and employees also. Are all of you employees of natural A 23% increase is BS. I I Gary Harden Ph: (734) 572-1022 [email protected] ......
:.,,,<,.,~*,.<,,$~ .; :T,:f[ ii8,>'74.
>\.L.f 8 h*> . -;;;>,.."i i '<() F<.,7 ?. .:, :-:-,.-: -3 >,>,.?\>,‘v,.t>k.
.; n7,i? :21;j;,;ia SC~L*~G~ November 22,2004 NLJd:ial,l.cicL*in
J. Peter Lark, Chairman ' MPSC P.O. Box 3022 1 - - Lansing, Ml48909 -1 I Dear Mr. Lark, I I1 Please help make renew re available and affordable in Michigan. In Case U-13808, the MPSC should orb (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage ' by lowering the price. In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is wind power. As we deplete our supply of fossil fuels e types of energy. Please take these steps now
Sincerely,
Jill M. Met. November 30, 2004
Ms. Laura Chapyelle MPSC P.0.Box 30223 Lansing, MI 48909
Dear Ms. Chappelle:
Please make renewable ni i more available and affordable in Michigan. The price of- wind energy is droppin M :the cost of power from fossil fuel is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wi nd wes. The MPSC should orde it Edisoti to invest in aEordable wind energy and encourage customel's to for "green power" Izy lowering the price. Case kU- 13808.
The WSC should orde rners Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green Case kU- 1403 1. We, the undersigned, w buld yreciate a response to this letter Sincerely, I
-7"- ,.-".A y .., ,- ;>, ,<: I- .-.- ; .- ,+I, .,,? ,L':l ::,,.,I$ p la. ..! r*. ..,: L1 U LI.VPI 6.) Shelby Talbert 1
Catherine Talbett I
30429 Townley h4adison Heights, MI 48 248-259-55 16 J. Peter Lark Chairman MlPSC
Sir it should be cl that we must fmd alternatives to fossil fuels. I am sure you are rn of the dwindling natural resources then most and will keep this in vote on case U-13808 and case U-1403 1. I would encowage 4ou t order that Detroit Edison invest in affordable wind energy in 08 and order consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy
Untitled
I I BEC 8 2 2004 Michigan Public service Dear Mr. Nelson. Commission Please support the cause of ren Michigan. In case U-13808the MPSC shourd order Detroit Edkn pie. Ln case @1$031, &ehffP%C: C- to expand its use of wind energy and Bmer the cat of its "greenper" pragr wind energy is currently droppirig whik the cost of power from i~cmwirLd: pti&er, rvwirLgii[W5e changes wiii heip ti;e conjijmers of the ~iaf~and at hefp to keep r.ur air deaner. Flpar~respond to this !~tterso that csfi ...... -...... :;- i . ViccNJ",I bll,) ..'IcP, a r ;;ijp~o;:;in ;rj:+ance,
Page l
J. Peter Lark, Chairman MPSC P. 0.Box 3022 1 Lansing, Mi 48909 DEC 0 2 2004
Chairman Lark:
I write to ask you to make renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan.
1. In case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.
2. In case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.
The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.
Sincerely,
Karen London
Copy: Ms. Laura Chappelle Mr. Robert Nelson
KAREN LONDON I 4012 YORBA LINDA ROYAL OAK. MI 48073 I November 18,2004
David Dunayczan 4104 Springer Ave Royal Oak, MI 48073
J. Peter Lark, Chairman MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909
RE: Renewable Energy Cases U-13808 and U-14031
Dear Mr. Lark,
I am greatly concerned about our great Michigan environment and the rising cost of fossil fuels and would like to take this opportunity to ask for your support to encourage our utilities to invest in wind energy as a source of green power. I think that technology has made wind energy more affordable and feel that with the rising cost of fossil fuels, wind energy is a smart investment for keeping the cost of power frorr~increasing as much and also provide a clean alternative to fossil fuels.
Please take every opportunity you can to increase our use of wind energy for both our economy and environment.
I would appreciate understanding your position on this matter.
Thank you,
Sincerely,
David Dunayczan November 19,2004
J. Peter Lark Michigan Public Service Commission P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, Michigan 48909
Dear J. Peter Lark, I am writing to ask you to take measures to help make renewable energy more available and more affordable in Michigan. Fossil fuels are being used for energy, with little apparent consideration to the pollutants they provide, and as if the supply was never ending. While these costs continue to rise, little is done to expand the use of renewable sources such as wind power. In Case U-1403 1, I would ask the MPSC to order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program. Similarly, in Case U- 13808, theMPSC should order Detroit Edison to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. As you know, wind energy is dropping while the cost of power fkom fossil fuels is rising. This means that it is vital that utilities invest in wind power. Thanks for all you do to serve the people of Michigan. I would appreciate hearing back from you with your plans regarding renewable energy in Michigan. Sincerely,
2 11 7 Belaire Drive Lansing, Michigan 489 10 5 17-487-0036 To Ms. Laura Chappelle,
I strongly believe that the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. (CASE U-13808).
Since the price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising, I think that it is it is &al that utilities invest in wind power. -- Thank you, Alekhya Ratnala. RECEIVED Loren Lemmen 124 Round Top Lansing, MI, 48917 Michigan Public Service Commission Dear J. Peter Lark,
-\--- Michigan needs to do more to make renewable energy more available and affordable. Please take this opportunity to support Case U- 1 3 808 and U- 14031. Wind energy costs are going down while power &om fossil fuels is going up and does not \require the use of our military and thc support of corrupt foreign governments. T~*U F& your time.
Sincerely,
Loren Lemmen 1 November 29,2004
Ms. Laura Chappelle MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909
Dear Ms. Chappelle,
I am writing to you today in regard to renewable energy. I believe that in Case #U- 13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price, The-price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power. I would like to know your position in this matter; a response letter would be appreciated. Thank you.
25001 Avon Ct. Novi, MI 48374 November 10,2004
Ms. Laura Chappelle MPSC PO Box 3022 1 Lansing, MI 48909
Dear Ms. Chappelle: - -- <- -- -. -- -- . I am writing to ask you to make renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan. Some ways to do this are:
1. In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and enwurage customers to sign up for "green power"by lowering the price.
2. In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the wst of its ''green power" program.
The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.
I would appreciate a response to this request.
Sincerely,
78'1 Longford Rochester Hills, MI 48309 November 10,2004
To whom it may concern,
In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order DetroitEdison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.
In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the ocst of its9'green power" program.
Wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fissil fuels is rising. It is vital to invest in wind power.
Thank you for your attention
Mary Beth Kitzmiller 797 Redwood Ct Rochester Hills, MI 48309 , , .-*"A - - -..- .- - * 4 -.,-- " - - -* ds. * - >." " -. -
- 2 "P ". -.. - " - - *~ " "
- -- -. A&*"- I& MSL%-\, , -mu1 48?C1+-A - - - - "- -. - - - . - ,-& - -- " <- " f * - 2 ,I"' rrd - ." --*- - ,... .- - - " - _. . ..-. - !40ulq-~4!liLm.~~".... - ... ..
95
., I- ^ 1- 1 ,- =.. *".-#*- a^/% '2<% , . "3, ------..- *.. , -, I.Tb.-j.,.'d' a,, a,, I
.3*< - .- - "-- " " 7 *%,~-* " " 2"
------d-~-______-_--+U--r~~-lid-*.---? -_-.- -&lu--- --&-. a&-*- +- A-" --- -- A-
-*, . - * .s <* --" - ..,-** " -.* A * -. """ --- -- < . - - - - -aA
<--..,.-. -." *- -- &-"-.."-. "- . .-" ,- -*<- = -&-- - .".* -
m ----
"a- ."
-. -.-,,"
--. ." >+
" . -- - ,. A-
-----,-^--I----- .-rr-- ..-" .-,--.,--\ ------" -. Sharon M Arrowsmith k 1320 Etowah Ave 1' Royal Oak MI 48067-3468 r - I - _I ryiimw~y 1------s---wE - - - l*.A<&%+ *-.-d " " Ms Laura Chappelle MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909
The door to door campaign of the Michigan Consumer Federation has encouraged me to write a letter to you regarding alternative sources of energy. I must admit I do not know all the details of this issue, however, it seems common sense to me that we should look for and encourage the use of other sources of energy besides fossil fbels.. .even if it costs more. Of course, the information the MCF provided me says the alternate fuels do or will cost less than fossil fuels, which makes it all the more attractive. But really, it is our responsibility to do what is right, no matter what the costs, when it comes to saving our environment. So, as instructed, I encourage the following:
In case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage the customers to sign up for green power by lowering public price.
In case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumer Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its green power program
As I do not know all the angles of this issue, if you have another side to present, please reply to this letter so that I may be more informed. But really, it seems to be a no- brainer.. .one of those simple niles to liqe by.. . protect the environment-£-have visited my Mom's family in Switzerland and lived in Germany myself for 18 months and it really seems people in Europe are more conscious about the environment. They control urban sprawl better, have stronger recycling programs, drive fuel efficient smaller vehicles, bring their own bags to the grocery store, use wind power.. . etc. The examples go on and on. While American's may talk about protecting the environment, it seems to me they do much less, especially when it involves any inconvenience to themselves in daily life. Sad.
I hope this letter encourages you to do the responsible thing for the environment.. .at all costs.
Sincerely, Sheila Buccilli Ms. Laura Chappelle MPSC P.O. Box 3022 1 Lansing, MI 48909
Ms. Chappelle:
You are currently considering two cases brought before you by Detroit Edison
and Consumers Energy. In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE)
to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green
power" by lowering the price. In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers
Energy also to expand its use of wind energy and cut the cost of its "green power" -,. program. We are rapidly running out of fossil fuels. Thus, its cost will continue to rise
precipitously. It is vital that utilities begin to invest more heavily in alternative energy
sources such as wind energy.
I would appreciate a reply concerning this matter.
Sincerely,
Shelby MacFarlane 1 '5- 7 s oax~~biqc_, A FXJ, . -ld~:~x,, g 3 9
.- -,
------A- - Mrs. Shelby MacFarlane 1375 Oakrock Ln Rochester Hills, MI 48309 James B. Zick 3279 Fairgrove Terrace Rochester Hills, Michigan 48309 HOV :! 7 21:j04 ', ,
November 12,2004 :, , , I , '\ / '1'. J i )i ,., Ms. Laura Chappelle MPSC P.O. Box 3022 1 Lansing MI 48909
Dear. Ms. Chappelle:
I am writing in support of the Michigan Consumer Federation in their efforts to increase the availability of clean and affordable renewable energy, to prohibit phone companies from charging a State Access Fee that has not been approved by regulatory bodies, and to uphold the Michigan ltem Pricing Law that was designed to protect consumers against scanner overcharges and retail fi-aud.
Specifically: In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price
In Case U- 14031, the MSPC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.
Point out that the price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power fi-om fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.
Given the rapidly rising costs of fuels used for transportation, heating, household and industrial purposes I am in support of any steps that can be taken to keep the costs within the reach of an affording consumer, personal or industrial. e,
Dear Ms. Laura Chappelle,
I understand you are on the MPSC.
,"- In Case U- 13808, I think you should order DTE to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to be able to sign up for green power by lowering the price.
In Case U-1403 1, I think you should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its green power program.
If you could write back to me and let me know what you are doing to look into these other options for us the consumer I would appreciate your effort.
Thank you,
Jeannie Wilgus 3 150 Grant Ave. Rochester Hills, MI 48309 Carol Hauk 1954 Gilsam Rochester Hills ,Mi 48309
Dear Ms. Laura Chappelle,
In Case U- 13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for " green power" by lowering the price.
In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Enegry to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power " program.
In fact the price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.
Thank You
Carol Hauk -
aMs. Carol Hauk 1954 Gilsam Ave. Rochester as,MI 48309
628 Bucknell Ct. Rochester Hills, Mi 48309 November 11,2004
Ms. Laura Chappelle MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909
Dear Ms. Chappelle,
I am writing to inform you of my opinions on a few important matters facing citizens of Michigan today. I am very concerned about the rising costs of fossil fuels and the shortages of these natural resources that will naturally occur in the future.
I believe that wind power holds real possibilities as a renewable and affordable resource if we could only encourage its development and use. In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Cansumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.
I appreciate your involvement on these issues and would also appreciate the honor of your reply to my concerns. Jeremy Taylor 3320 Brownley Gnurt Rochester Hills. NI 45309-3995 /&!/IW'D* 7A.4 fl45 pb &.-f- 30~I
LCI M/ +$jBflCP L-,&" I, Nc. o,
- &- & v-i?Dl4 J& J& d d- Ms. Laura Chappelle Michigan Public Service Commission P.O. Box 30221 Lansing , Michigan 48909
Dear Ms. Chappelle,
I have just been contacted by a volunteer of the Michigan Consumer Federation concerning the use of wind power in Michigan. I whole heartedly support this method of energy as being safe, renewable and clean.
Having traveled around this country and else ware and seen the windmills in the Great Plains and southern England, I feel this is an avenue we should pursue.
I would like tisee Case number U-13808 and case number U-14031 explored so that Edison and Consumers Power are aware that there is a definite interest in their "green power" programs. I feel that this is a safe, clean and constantly renewable resource of power in Michigan.
I understand that the price of wind power is dropping and this should be a major consideration with the rising price and finite amount of oil and fossil fuels available to us.
I would like to see Detroit Edison (of whom we are stock holders) and Consumers Power address this need.
Please let me know your stand on this.
Sincerely,
Marla Shelton 2337 Arizona Court Rochester Hills, Michigan 48309 712 E. Lincoln Royal Oak, Mi. 48067
Billie Ragland
-J.Peter Lark, Chairman MPSC PO Box 30221 Lansing, Mi. 48909
Dear Mr. Lark:
Subject: Renewable Energy
I am writing to you today to ask that you work to make renewable energy more affordable and available in Michigan. The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising making it vital for utilities to invest in wind power. You can help!
First, in case U-13808, the MPSC should order DTE to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. Second, in case U-14031, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy to lower the cost of its "green power" program.
Thank you for your time.
Billie Ragland
November 9,2004
1. Peter Lark, Chairman msc P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, Michigan 48909
Dear Sir,
Case U- 1 3808 and Case U- 1403 1 should be strongly encouraged ta lower the escalating costs of energy! Fossil fiiels are not the answer! The public needs relief The average consumer is tired of constantly rising casts and footing the bill of utility entrepreneurs making themselves ever richer.
Attention is needed now!
Sincerely, n
Robert C. Hall, Jr. 1003 Longfellow Royal Oak, Mi. 48067 Peter Lark, Chairman msc P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI-48909
Dear-Mr. Lark,
J am writing to a& you to cmsider a stronger positive stance on renewable enezgy in Michigan. I would appreciate seeing more governmental support of guidelines supporting renewable energy like wind and solar power where appropriate. At the beginning of this winter season, at least we have a lot of wind!
I look forward to seeing your support of U-13808, and urge you to order DTE to invest in affordable wind energy and I will do my part to support this initiative by using the energy provided by renewable resources just like I consume energy right now. J appreciate your guidance and direction for the energy providers to provide affordable renewable power in Michigan.
In case U-14031 please order Consumers Energy to expand it's use of wind energy and to maintain a lower cost for it's "green power" program.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Ron Arnold, I3.D. 1102 Irving Ave. Royal Qak, MI 48067
November 12,2004
J. Peter Lark, Chairman MPSC PO Box 30221 Lansing, MT 48909
Dear Mr. Lark,
I write to request that you take efforts to make renewable energy a higher priority in Michigan. In case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for green power by lowering the price. In case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the costs of it green power program.
I hope that you will take into account these requests.
Sincerely,
John P. Gonway 2535 Jackson Drive Rochester Hills, MI 48309 J. Peter Lark, Chairman MPSC P.O.Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909
Dear Chairman Lark,
The MPSC can ensure that we receive affordable, clean power by requiring utilities to do all of the following:
1. Replace power produced from high-cost plants with wind power at a lower cost. - -- 2 Require utilities to invest in pollution-free wind power rather than spend billions to keep aging, polluting coal-fired plants operating. 3. Charge "green power" rates that encourage rather than discourage customer from buying pollution-free electricity. 4. Commit to meet hture electric needs with clean and affordable wind power.
In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. In Case U-14031, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of the wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.
Since the price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil hels is rising, making it vital the utilities invest in wind power is just plain good business for everyone.
Sincerely,
Beverley Bockes 9 14 N. Verlinden Ave. Lansing, MI 48915 C
1
t
? I k s "S 'b" 8 s,. k~%3Lp&k -- . - 1 7 200s . - - f -- -- - ; CdyOJ;/\(yYlOvlcl wsc -
: PO -.I 3022\ -; c'a!yPn-, .
L-sW )"' L(8S04 A
I
A +
; ae,h. &"0
e * --Olol Q-&W;- NWS -
6
I
I I Sicenpe~) ,
8
- -
?
a 1
i. 3.*,c. r
i Y v s i; l. 9, h xw - "*"i. . < " - A &. " , & *-L< ; * % ..* * -h ." *A -,a* *" *1+ +, ~. a&" - .! t&+,*,+. ;&bxd-%-~&- *&&d&cdw,,&&& J. Peter Lark, Chairman MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909
I am writing to express my concern over high energy prices. I believe you need to do all that you can to encourage the use of non-fossil fuels. I am in agreement with cases U-13808 and U- 14031. While prices may be slightly higher for non-fossil fuel sources at this point, the long term benefits far outweigh the short term costs. Please reply and let me know what actions you will be ' taking to making this happen.
Chris P. Grassi 2565 Brilliance Rochester Hills, MI 48309
---
- L H. GEORGEJOHANNESSEN
10 November 2004
Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P. 0.Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909
REF: Case U-13808 Case U- 14031
Dear Mr. Nelson,
You have the opportunity in the referenced cases to send a message to Detroit Edison "DTE" and Consumers Energy that they should focus their investment on wind and other renewable energy sources rather than on updating or refurbishing out-dated coal burning facilities. The cost of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising. Consumers should be able to depend on you to ensure their future power needs are met with lower-priced and environmentally sound energy sources. If our power companies do not choose to or are not forced to invest in the development of these "green power" sources, consumers will not get to make wise energy choices.
I ask that in Case U-13808 you order DTE to invest in affordable wind energy and to encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.
I ask that in Case U-1403 1 you order Consumers Energy to expand its investment in wind energy and to lower the cost of its "green power" program.
I appreciate your consideration of this request and look forward to your reply.
Sincerely,
ddy&FwH. George J h essen
757 REDWOODCOURT ROCHESTERHILLS, MI 48309-2446 248.575.0846 Josephine M. Long 565 Maryknoll Drive Rochester Hills, MI 48309
November 10,2004
Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909
Re: Renewable Energy
Dear Mr. Lark:
I am writing you concerning wind powered energy. I have traveled a bit, and I noted that the western United States has many windmills generating electricity. I also have a summer home in Canada, and right up the road from us is a beautiful windmill generating electricity for a farm and its surrounding area.
Through a bit of research, I understand that the cost of wind energy is dropping, while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising, and my home utility bills certainly reflect the increase.
Can the Michigan Public Service Commission seriously investigate the possibility of wind powered energy in Michigan? I understand case U-13808 could order DTE to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering prices. I also understand case U- 14031 could order Consumer Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program. I believe it is worth the investigation.
With regdto preserving our natural resources and using the powerful resource of wind, 1believe we could better serve the people of Michigan with the cleaner and renewable form af wind energy, whereby everyone wins by living in a purer and more affordable state. I would appreciate your thoughts regarding this matter. November 9,2064
Mi. Robert Nelson MPSC P.O.Box 30221 Lansing, Michigan 48909
Dear Sir,
Case U-13808 and Case U-1403 1 should be strongly encouraged to lower the escalating costs of energyt Fossil %els are not the answer! The public needs relief. The average consumer is tired of constantly rising costs and footing the bill of utility entrepreneurs making themselves ever richer.
Attention is needed now!
Robmt C.Hall, Jr. 1003 Longfellow Royal Oak, Mi. 48067 Robert Nelson, MPSC P. 0. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909
Dear Mr. Robert Nelson,
I am a Michigan Consumer. I am asking you, a member of the Michigan Public Service Commission, to make renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan. In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison @TE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. Also, In Case U-14031, the MSPC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program. The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power fiom fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power. Please do your part. Looking forward to a reply.
Thanking you in advance,
~fithiaA. Carr
Cynthia Carr 3293 D~vcnportLn. Rochester Hills, MI 48309 ,
November 12,2004
J. Peter Lark, Chairman MPSC PO Box 3022 1 Lansing, MI 48909
Mr. Lark
In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy toexpand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program. The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power fiom fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.
Please reply to:
Angela Oliver 2831 York Road Rochester Hills, MI 48309-3132 annela283 10,~ahoo.com November 12,2004
Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC PO Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909
Mr. Nelson
In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. In Case U- 14031, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program. The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power Erom fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.
Please reply to:
Lori Oliver 283 1 York Road Rochester Hills, MI 48309-3 132 lori283 1@vahoo. corn November 12,2004
Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC PO Box 3022 1 Lansing, MI 48909
Mr. Nelson
In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program. The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power fiom fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.
Please reply to:
Matt Oliver 283 1 York Road Rochester Hills, MI 48309-3 132 matt283 1@,vahoo. com November 12,2004
Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC PO Box 3022 1 Lansing, NlI 48909
Mr. Nelson
In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program. The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.
Please reply to:
Eric Oliver 283 1 York Road Rochester Hills, MI 48309-3 132 eric283 lO,yahoo.com November 1,2004
Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P. 0.Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909 --. Dear Mr. Nelson:
I write to you asking you to make renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan. It was explained to me that Consumers Energy is using 3 windmills to help bring the cost of energy down. In Case U-1403 1 Consumers Energy should be strongly urged to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program. This would encourage rather than discourage customers fiom buying pollution-free electricity.
In Case U-13808 DTE should invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.
As energy prices continue to increase, renewable energy must be made available. Help to conserve our natural resources and use the power of the wind to provide our energy - it's free! Help to keep pollution to a minimum - wind doesn't produce pollution. The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.
Thank you for any support you can give on this matter.
Sincerely, ...--
Dennis & Brenda Mueller 'L 2649 Winter Park Rd. Rochester Hills, MI 48309 bkm247 1@,wowwav.com Stacy Pittman 111 1 South Wilson Ave Royal Oak, MI 48067
Mr. Robert Nelson ME'SC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909
Dear Mr. Nelson, - - - _____.__..___-A _ _--_I_ 1; 1; Case U-13808, the ME'SC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.
In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power7' program,
The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rinsing, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.
I would appreciate a reply to my concerns.
Sincerely,
Stacy M. Pittman A concerned citizen and consumer Mr.Robert Nelson MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, Mich. 48909
Dear Ms Chappelle,
I am concerned about energy supply and usage and would like to make the following points:
In Case U-13808, the MPSC+shouldorder Detroit Edison(DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program. The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power fkom fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.
Please reply and let me know what is being done about these issues.. .
Thank You, Karen Bucchare 1 107 E. Lincoln Royal Oak, Mich. 480
A,
'i
I- November 11 2004
Attention: Mr. Robert Nelson
I am writing to you concerning Clean, Affordable Energy in Michigan. Referring to Case U-13808 I agree that the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.
Also in Case U-1403 1, the MFSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" pragram. It is vital that utilities invest in wind power.
sincerely,
Lynn Cohen 2859 Y ork Rochester Hills MI, 48309
-.--
MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909
Dear Mr. Robert Nelson:
It is my understanding that in Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. Also in Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program. The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels in rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power. I would like to know what you going to do towards keeping these programs affordable and clean.
Thank you, Kayla Buscemi
25 1 1 W. Maple At Cranbrook Mr. D011dd OIKeefe I Blrrningharn, Mich, ' 48009 3141westwood Dr 31 31646-6200 B1mmfie~d.MI 48301 ,
From the Desk of SHIRLEY 0'KEEFE To J. Peter Lark,Chaiman MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, Mich. 48909
Dear Mr. Lark,
I am concerned about energy supply and usage and would like to make the following points:
In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison(DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program. The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.
Please reply and let me know what is being done about these issues.. .
Thank You , Karen Bucchare 1 107 E. Lincoln Royal Oak, Mich. 48067
J. Peter Lark, Chairman MPSC PO Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909
Chairman Lark,
In Case U-13808 and Case U-14031, Detroit Edison and Consumers Engery are able to provide Michigan residents with affordable energy that is also environmentally freiendly by the use of wind energy. Wind power is dropping in cost while fossel fuel use is increasing in fuel cost and plant maintenence, plus wind power helps preserve our environment and is not -- -.- ~a_poIaics,P~supporl Cases U-I3808 and U-I 4@l&- - help Michigan residents meet their energ needs with clean energy resources.
Thar~kyou,
Greg Smith 2933 Saint Clair Rochester Hills, MI 48309 November 1,2004
J. Peter Lark, Chairman MPSC P. 0.Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909
Dear Chairman Lark:
I write to you asking you to make renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan. It was explained to me that Consumers Energy is using 3 windmills to help bring the cost of energy down. In Case U-1403 1 Consumers Energy should be strongly urged to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program. This would encourage rather than discourage customers from buying pollution-free electricity.
In Case U-13808 DTE should invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.
As energy prices continue to increase, renewable energy must be made available. Help to conserve ow natural resources and use the power of the wind to provide our energy - it's free! Help to keep pollution to a minimum - wind doesn't produce pollution. The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.
Thank you for any support you can give on this matter.
Sincerely, '"'A u' & WjC-'" Dennis & Brenda Mueller 2649 Winter Park Rd. Rochester Hills, MI 48309 bkrn247 1~wowwav.com
...... In ,- .... QU~:.. U.-:..1.3.%G.f3 .. +.%a . P5.Csb.d\d ......
w der_. Detro\t.. E6.~0. . CVIE ). ?O . \fie~t.. .. IF ......
......
...... - ...... Ms. Laura Chappelle MPSC NOW 1 7 20nl P.O.Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909
Dear Ms. Chappelle,
The MPSC can ensure that we receive affordable, clean power by requiring utilities to do all of the following:
1. Replace power produced from high-cost plants with wind power at a lower cost. 2. Require utilities to invest in pollution-free wind power rather than spend billions to keep aging, polluting coal-fired plants operating. 3. Charge "green power" rates that encourage rather than discourage customer from buying pollution-free electricity. 4. Commit to meet fbture electric needs with clean and affordable wind power.
In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. In Case U-14031, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of the wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.
Since the price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil kels is rising, making it vital the utilities invest in wind power is just plain good business for everyone.
Sincerely, *&dl Beverley Bockes 9 14 N. Verlinden Ave. Lansing, MI 489 15
RECEIVED November 9,2004
Ms. Laura Chappelle MicUan Public w~e MPSC -_------>- Commission PO BOX 30221 Lansing, MI 48909
Dear Ms. Chappelle:
As a Michigan homeowner and taxpayer, I am interested in seeing Michigan make renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan.
In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.
In Case-U-1403-1,the MPSCZshould mde~ConsumersEnergy to-expand-itsuse of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.
It is vital that utilities invest in wind power, as the cost of fossil fuels is rising, while the price of wind energy is dropping.
I am most concerned about this issue from an environment and economic viewpoint.
Thank you for your consideration.
% A
Royal Oak, Michigan
K Ave. 48067 November 10,2004 RECEIVED DEC 0 'F! 7nn4
Michigan Public Service J. Peter Lark, Chairman Commission MPSC PO Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909
Dear Mr. Lark:
I am writing to ask you to make renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan. Some ways to do this are:
1. In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sipup for "green power" by lowering the price.
2. In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.
The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.
I would appreciate a response to this request.
Sincerely, '7%w-$ LLw Mary L. Werny 781 Longford Rochester Hills, MI 48309 - ')EcfrvEo DEc .- '2 7004 Mj~his.~ ,:A ,.., Ob'ic service I. IL.~. .Lfi~p,. cr-\~??ec~E
-.
/~j. ~p9~. 1340~ 1 tLe M 35~SH~OL~
. OLZWP~~~O~TET~ICOU @'it)To !buE% l"~ A~O~O%CZ< . w r b E/UE 6Ly &~b.6~iuZ&Z--
Lus%~r~sTi 516~ Fdk - Po* 5 \(
, QW?~&~JGME yffi~z- P C~\K- 19031 TiM?SC 5t-(od& i wm co~~o/cl~&FwCGY 70 Gf>m) 5 6Z. WE-~D~~GYPADC~W- ~*cfiorr\5 cezv ?dfl< .~czo'~.R4n,* -
. *." -rn~ibLs.FA 'mb\$G
------+- ..-- I ."-" ; WITZENMANN
1 1 : Witzenrnann USA I 2200 Centerwood Drive I Warren, M~ch~gan48091 November 9,2004
Linda Cook Michigan Public Service Collsmission 1201 Cherokee Ave. Royal Oak, MI 48067
Mr. J. Peter Lark, Chairman MPSC P. 0. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909
Dear Mr. Lark,
Recently, I was informed of two cases up for consideration which order both DTE energy and Consumers Energy to invest in and expand use of wind energy in order to not only reduce energy costs but also, and more importantly, to start taking advantage of natural resources in order to preserve our environment from further damage. These cases are U- 13808 and U-14031.
It has been documented in several articles how the cost of energy from wind is dropping, while the cost of using fossil fuels for power is rising. Michigan is obtaining less than a fraction of a percentage of its total energy expenditure from wind power. And as you are well aware, many people in Michigan are having a difficult time making ends meet as a result of job loss.
As a public service commissioner, you should consider the needs of the people that you've been elected to represent and do what you can to ensure that the local energy companies are ordered to invest in alternative and cleaner modes of energy in order to lower costs and what has not been damaged to the environment.
Thank you for your time. I would be interested in hearing what comes of these cases.
Sincerely, Michigan PUNG S$rultW t - RECEIVED DEC 2 2004 Michigan Public SeMce Commission
J. Peter Lark, Chairman MPSC DEC 2 2004 P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909 Michigan Public Service Commission Dear Chairman Lark:
I am writing to ask that y~u~rder petfait Edison to invest in affordable wind energy in order to reddce, Michigan's dependence oy fsssi'r -fuels. Further,white C-o~suqersEnergy is to be commended for it$ ffse of wind energy, your Cgrnmis~ig~should urge the company to increase such use. The moaetary &YE df fossil hels continy~io ciimb. Globtltlyspeaking,-our &p*n-ee -ern oil and other fgssil. fu& $?ding our nation precious natural resources and eveh lives. Please consider these concerns when d& decisions in your capacity as Chair wffheC&ssion. 10 November 2004 J. 'ichi~an Public service ~r.Peter Lark, Chairman Commission MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909
RE: Power Generation
I am writing this short letter to you because, as I note their actions, the power companies seem to be looking backwards rather than moving fonvard to new technologies in the generation of power in Michigan. It is probably easier for them to use old and outmoded coal fired power plants and spend billioiis to reduce pollution (and increase our costs) than it is for them to address the real issue of reducing our costs by utilizing renewable energy such as wind energy.
In the case of U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and then to encourage customers to sign up for green power by lowering the price. Such action will result in a benefit to Detroit Edison, will help to preserve our environment, and will be of value to their customers. Let them know that we are not back in the nineteenth century with coal fired boilers. It's time to move forward.
In the case of U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind power and lower the cost of its green power program. It is obvious that the cost of power generated from fossil he1 is rising and will continue to rise. Technology for wind power generation is now available and the cost of wind energy is dropping. Let's take a big step and move into the 21' century! Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909
Dear Mr. Nelson,
I am writing you to ask that you consider the use of alternate energy sources to supply power to Michigan consumers. There are other sources of energy then coal and gas. I encourage you to consider the application of wind energy as encouraged in Case U-13808 and Case U-14031. Our clean air and water is our most precious resource. Please consider other energy sources that will leave a betterenvironment for my grandchildren.
I would like to hear what your opinion is on using wind or solar energy for use in Michigan.
~cbertLivingston 4228 Hampton Blvd. Royal Oak MI, 48073 Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909
Mr. Nelson,
In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power"- by lowering the price.
In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumer Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower cost of its "green power" program.
Point out that the price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.
Please reply to this request.
Thank you,
Lauretta R. Roy *,I523 Etowah Royal Oak, MI 48067 Ms. Chappelle,
Thank you for taking the time to read my letter. Iwill be brief. Iam asking for your help in reducing the ever escalating costs of energy.
In case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.
In case U-14031, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green powerff program. - Thank you for yoliiretimeand your help in this extremely important matter. would be interested in hearirlg your thoughts on these ideas. Thanks again!
Sincerely,
Dennis A. Murray M~~~~~~~ missionpublic service 24922 Sarah Flynn I Novi, Mi 48374 J. Peter Lark, Chairman MPSC P.0 .Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909
Rosalind Leiser 4303 Seminole Royal Oak, MI 48073
Dear Chairman Lark
Since the first Earth Day, over twenty-five years ago, I have been in favor of conserving +mqg+4&-wemw&takn6wj-+risi~~U~~ --- supplies. One of the solutions to these problems is wind power. The cost of wind power is dropping while the cost of power from more conventional energy sources, such as fossil fuels, is rising making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.
In Case U-13808m the MPSC should require DTE invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sigh up for the "green power" program.
In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should require Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of the "green power" program. 1 I would appreciate any updates in this issue. I I Sincerely,
Rosalind Leiser &$?) November 15,2004 ' .,
Ms. Laura Chapelle MPSC P.O.Box 30221 Lansing, Mi 48909
Dear Ms. Chapelle, In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power77by lowering the price.
In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.
The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.
Sincerely,
Susan Kaczkowski 4402 Elmwood Royal Oak, Mi 48073 Ms. St hanie Akkasllian 4217 ~TeronaCir. gVhr- Robert N~els&nn Royal Oak, MI 48073 November 15,2004 WK PI). Box 3022 1 Lam* MI 8U3cm
energy. I itm nrkmg that you 'helplo amk.e ufforLSitb1e in h4ichigm swfiany, in sl~oulda& Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in afforhble wid energy md et~mgealstsn~a to sign up for "green gawer* by Iow~~~811~price.
I[n adrlitirzn, .in case Id- 1430 1, the MPX shotdd C~LCZPPIZ&TSEnergy to %wildits d-d energy adlowet- the cost of its 'green.ptver" program SG1m the prim of wind a~ergyis &-qping9w11il.e the ax&of powr fkm1 forssil file'hs iq rising it is vital that utilities invd in wind power. .-'-- --- __--,,.. , .__-_._.. . , . MICHAEL WARGO ...... ' ,,,,...,...,..,, .,.,..,.,...,"',.,. ' ,,,,,....., " ,,,, ' ,,,,...'.,',,,,,,,,,,. '<',,,",,,,,,,....,...,,,,,,,,,, ...... ,,.,,...< .... '.. ,.,.... ,.. <...,, Mr. Michael Wargo ',, :; 3: I"? 2 2 ,,a%::.: t,.; i,sA8,,+L84 t. s<,r.,,!,,;,. -'-"t~.oj.G,l! c~~fi.;.jg,; .!?,a'y.% 4402 Buckingham 1 Royal Oak, MI 48073 J. Peter Lark, Chairman MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing MI 48909
Dear Mr. Lark
I am writing this letter asking support from the Michigan- Public Service Commission to make renewable energy m6rk available and affordable in Michigan.
In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price.
In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.
The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising; I feel it is imperative that the utilities invest in wind power.
I would appreciate a reply to this letter and I would hope that you would encourage the use of wind energy.
Sincerely, J Elizabeth K. Lin 2809 Trailwood Rochester Hills, MI 48309-1441
November 9,2004
Mr. J. Peter Lark, Chairman NIPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909
Dear Mr. Lark,
With the onset of winter, the temperatures are rapidly decreasing along with the number of daylight hours. In this season, costs of increased electric and gas costs come to mind. It has been brought to my attention that I can expect to see oil, natural gas, and electric costs rising over last winter's costs. In addtion, I'm concerned with the fact that Michigan produces nearly half of its electricity from coal-fired plants, producing pollutants.
With these facts in mind, I am urging you to consider the use of renewable energy sources that do not produce pollution, like wind and solar power. In the long run, renewable energy will protect the environment and keep utilities affordable for the end client. Why spend money cleaning up pollution created by consumption of fossil fuel when a free resource is available?
In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. -In €?as&-1403 1, the M-PSC should order Consumers Energy to expand itsase of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program.
The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fuels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power.
Thank you for your consideration.
~lizabkd~.Lin w~d.6 6 AON -- - 2 - - 1. In Case U-13808, the MPSC should order Detroit Edison (DTE) to invest in affordable I wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green poweryyby lowering the price. 2. In Case U-14031, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program. 3. Point out that the price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil fbels' is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power. 7 - -- - -1------
------Gel??@ &Jean Stoops 48' CfkryBbssom Ln. "~h~terH@s, !MI 48306
Ulli Neugebauer, 224 Canterbury Trail, Rochester Hills, MI 48309
Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P.O. Box 30221 Lansing, MI 48909
Dear Mr. Nelson,
We have to start saving energy so our children can enjoy life as much as we do. For this reason the MPSC should order DTE to invest in affordable wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green power" by lowering the price. (Case U- 13808). Further the MSPC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of it's "green power" program. (Case U-1403 1) My information show me that the cost of wind energy is dropping while the cost of fossil energy is rising, which makes it vital to invest in wind power.
Hopefully you are the right man to brifig these issues to life!
Sincerely
43@ " si, Vi" ' HOV I 2 ?El04 Ulli Neugebauer
am cu 15;b I 6 bjJ f.; 4 1 From: James R. Kubicina 2423 Chalet Drive Rochester Hills, Michigan 48309
IVovember 8.2004
To: Mr. Robert Nelson MPSC P.O. BOX30221 r Lansing MI 48909
Dear Mr. Robert Nelson,
- - - -In -- Case U-138081 the - _MPSC - __-A_-_ should order Detroit- - Edison..- - - (DTE) to invest in affordable ------.-- - wind energy and encourage customers to sign up for "green-pTwerW@ 1owefing'tE price. In Case U-1403 1, the MPSC should order Consumers Energy to expand its use of wind energy and lower the cost of its "green power" program. The price of wind energy is dropping while the cost of power from fossil kels is rising, making it vital that utilities invest in wind power. Could you please send me a reply on my suggestions? Thank you very much. Sincerely, James R. Kubicina
J. Peter Lark MPSC PO Box 30221 Lansing, RII 48909
Dear Mr. Lark,
Please make renewable energy more available and affordable in Michigan. The use of wind power in Case U-1403 1 would expand its use and lower the cost of green power. Thank you for your consideration in this vital matter.
- .. - A.
382 Gunder Drive Rochester Hills, MI