DOCSLIB.ORG

[Select This Text and Type Over It to Start the Front Matter]

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
[Select This Text and Type Over It to Start the Front Matter] July 2003 Vol. 15, No. 4 (C) COMPOUNDING INJUSTICE: The Government's Failure to Redress Massacres in Gujarat Table of Contents I. Summary ................................................................................................................................................................4 Impunity for Attacks Against Muslims ..................................................................................................................5 Inadequate Assistance for Victims and Continued Anti-Muslim Discrimination ..................................................6 Communalism as a Political Strategy .....................................................................................................................7 II. Main Recommendations to Indian Authorities .....................................................................................................8 To the State Government of Gujarat .......................................................................................................................9 To the Government of India ...................................................................................................................................9 III. Background to the Violence .............................................................................................................................. 10 Overview of the Violence ..................................................................................................................................... 10 State Complicity in the Attacks ............................................................................................................................ 11 The Sangh Parivar ............................................................................................................................................... 12 Distribution of Weapons and Training by the Sangh Parivar .......................................................................... 13 Foreign Funding of Sangh Parivar Activities .................................................................................................. 14 IV. Impunity for Attacks against Muslims .............................................................................................................. 15 The Naroda Patia Case ......................................................................................................................................... 16 The Gulbarg Society Case .................................................................................................................................... 19 Non-Prosecution of Rape Cases ........................................................................................................................... 22 Bias in the Courts ................................................................................................................................................. 25 The Shah-Nanavati Commission of Inquiry ......................................................................................................... 26 V. Police Shootings and False Charges against Victims ......................................................................................... 27 Police Shootings ................................................................................................................................................... 27 False Charges Against Victims ............................................................................................................................ 29 VI. The Godhra Investigation .................................................................................................................................. 30 The Godhra Massacre ........................................................................................................................................... 30 The Prevention of Terrorism Act.......................................................................................................................... 32 Uses of ―Terrorism‖ ............................................................................................................................................. 34 Godhra‘s victims .................................................................................................................................................. 35 VII. Attack on Akshardham .................................................................................................................................... 35 VIII. Inadequate Relief to Victims .......................................................................................................................... 38 Failure to Provide Humanitarian Assistance ........................................................................................................ 38 The Forcible Closure of Relief Camps ................................................................................................................. 39 Ongoing Insecurity of Returnees .......................................................................................................................... 40 IX. Lack of Government Compensation for Victims .............................................................................................. 41 Compensation Guidelines ..................................................................................................................................... 41 Compensation for Damages to Homes ................................................................................................................. 43 Compensation for the Death of Family Members ................................................................................................ 45 X. Economic Marginalization of Muslims .............................................................................................................. 46 ―Ghettoization‖ ..................................................................................................................................................... 47 Discriminatory Economic Boycotts...................................................................................................................... 48 The Effect on Children‘s Education and Identity ................................................................................................. 49 XI. Communalism as a Political Strategy ................................................................................................................ 51 The BJP Victory in Gujarat State Elections ......................................................................................................... 51 Criminal cases against elected officials ............................................................................................................ 54 Post-election violence in Gujarat .......................................................................................................................... 54 The Targeting of Christians in Gujarat ................................................................................................................. 55 Anti-conversion legislation .............................................................................................................................. 55 Government-sponsored surveys of Christians .................................................................................................. 56 Renewed attacks against Christians .................................................................................................................. 57 The Recruitment and Targeting of Dalits and Tribals .......................................................................................... 57 The Sangh Parivar‘s recruitment of Dalits and tribals ..................................................................................... 57 Attacks against Dalits ....................................................................................................................................... 61 Replicating the ―Gujarat Experiment‖ in Other States ......................................................................................... 62 The Ram Temple Campaign in Ayodhya ............................................................................................................. 63 XII. Recommendations to Indian Authorities and the International Community .................................................... 64 To the State Government of Gujarat ..................................................................................................................... 64 Justice ............................................................................................................................................................... 64 Relief and rehabilitation ................................................................................................................................... 65 Legislative and administrative reforms ............................................................................................................ 66 Security ............................................................................................................................................................. 66 To the Government of India ................................................................................................................................. 66 To India‘s Donors and Trading Partners .............................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • "Demons Within"
    Demons Within the systematic practice of torture by inDian police a report by organization for minorities of inDia NOVEMBER 2011 Demons within: The Systematic Practice of Torture by Indian Police a report by Organization for Minorities of India researched and written by Bhajan Singh Bhinder & Patrick J. Nevers www.ofmi.org Published 2011 by Sovereign Star Publishing, Inc. Copyright © 2011 by Organization for Minorities of India. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, digital, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise or conveyed via the internet or a web site without prior written permission of the publisher, except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical articles and reviews. Inquiries should be addressed to: Sovereign Star Publishing, Inc PO Box 392 Lathrop, CA 95330 United States of America www.sovstar.com ISBN 978-0-9814992-6-0; 0-9814992-6-0 Contents ~ Introduction: India’s Climate of Impunity 1 1. Why Indian Citizens Fear the Police 5 2. 1975-2010: Origins of Police Torture 13 3. Methodology of Police Torture 19 4. For Fun and Profit: Torturing Known Innocents 29 Conclusion: Delhi Incentivizes Atrocities 37 Rank Structure of Indian Police 43 Map of Custodial Deaths by State, 2008-2011 45 Glossary 47 Citations 51 Organization for Minorities of India • 1 Introduction: India’s Climate of Impunity Impunity for police On October 20, 2011, in a statement celebrating the Hindu festival of Diwali, the Vatican pled for Indians from Hindu and Christian communities to work together in promoting religious freedom.
    [Show full text]
  • Hindutva and Anti-Muslim Communal Violence in India Under the Bharatiya Janata Party (1990-2010) Elaisha Nandrajog Claremont Mckenna College
    Claremont Colleges Scholarship @ Claremont CMC Senior Theses CMC Student Scholarship 2010 Hindutva and Anti-Muslim Communal Violence in India Under the Bharatiya Janata Party (1990-2010) Elaisha Nandrajog Claremont McKenna College Recommended Citation Nandrajog, Elaisha, "Hindutva and Anti-Muslim Communal Violence in India Under the Bharatiya Janata Party (1990-2010)" (2010). CMC Senior Theses. Paper 219. http://scholarship.claremont.edu/cmc_theses/219 This Open Access Senior Thesis is brought to you by Scholarship@Claremont. It has been accepted for inclusion in this collection by an authorized administrator. For more information, please contact [email protected]. CLAREMONT McKENNA COLLEGE HINDUTVA AND ANTI-MUSLIM COMMUNAL VIOLENCE IN INDIA UNDER THE BHARATIYA JANATA PARTY (1990-2010) SUBMITTED TO PROFESSOR RODERIC CAMP AND PROFESSOR GASTÓN ESPINOSA AND DEAN GREGORY HESS BY ELAISHA NANDRAJOG FOR SENIOR THESIS (Spring 2010) APRIL 26, 2010 2 CONTENTS Preface 02 List of Abbreviations 03 Timeline 04 Introduction 07 Chapter 1 13 Origins of Hindutva Chapter 2 41 Setting the Stage: Precursors to the Bharatiya Janata Party Chapter 3 60 Bharat : The India of the Bharatiya Janata Party Chapter 4 97 Mosque or Temple? The Babri Masjid-Ramjanmabhoomi Dispute Chapter 5 122 Modi and his Muslims: The Gujarat Carnage Chapter 6 151 Legalizing Communalism: Prevention of Terrorist Activities Act (2002) Conclusion 166 Appendix 180 Glossary 185 Bibliography 188 3 PREFACE This thesis assesses the manner in which India’s Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) has emerged as the political face of Hindutva, or Hindu ethno-cultural nationalism. The insights of scholars like Christophe Jaffrelot, Ashish Nandy, Thomas Blom Hansen, Ram Puniyani, Badri Narayan, and Chetan Bhatt have been instrumental in furthering my understanding of the manifold elements of Hindutva ideology.
    [Show full text]
  • Concerned Citizens Tribunal - Gujarat 2002 an Inquiry Into the Carnage in Gujarat
    Concerned Citizens Tribunal - Gujarat 2002 An inquiry into the carnage in Gujarat Hate Speech The carnage in Gujarat was marked by unprecedented levels of hate speech and hate propaganda. Some examples: Chief Minister Narendra Modi Terming the (Godhra) attack as ‘pre-planned, violent act of terrorism’, Mr Modi said that state government was viewing this attack seriously. — The Times of India, Feb 28, 2002. "With the entire population of Gujarat very angry at what happened in Godhra much worse was expected". — Narendra Modi, at a Press Conference in Gujarat, Feb 28, 2002. Modi said he was ‘absolutely satisfied’ with the way in which the police and State Government handled the backlash from Godhra incident and ‘happy’ that violence was largely contained… "We should be happy that curfew has been imposed only at 26 places while there is anger and people are burning with revenge. Thanks to security arrangements we brought things under control".When asked that not a policeman was visible in most areas where shops were looted and set on fire, he said he hadn’t received any complaint. — The Indian Express, March 1, 2002. "Investigations have revealed that the firing by the Congressman played a pivotal role in inciting the mob." — CM Narendra Modi on Chamanpura incident where former MP Ahsan Jaffri was burned alive with 19 of his relatives. On being asked what could have lead to the Ex-MP opening fire it was ‘probably in his nature’ to do so. — The Hindustan Times, March 2, 2002. Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi on Friday termed ‘barbaric’ the murder of former Congress MP Ehsan Jafri along with 19 of his family members, but said there was firing from inside the house.
    [Show full text]
  • Compounding Injustice: India
    INDIA 350 Fifth Ave 34 th Floor New York, N.Y. 10118-3299 http://www.hrw.org (212) 290-4700 Vol. 15, No. 3 (C) – July 2003 Afsara, a Muslim woman in her forties, clutches a photo of family members killed in the February-March 2002 communal violence in Gujarat. Five of her close family members were murdered, including her daughter. Afsara’s two remaining children survived but suffered serious burn injuries. Afsara filed a complaint with the police but believes that the police released those that she identified, along with many others. Like thousands of others in Gujarat she has little faith in getting justice and has few resources with which to rebuild her life. ©2003 Smita Narula/Human Rights Watch COMPOUNDING INJUSTICE: THE GOVERNMENT’S FAILURE TO REDRESS MASSACRES IN GUJARAT 1630 Connecticut Ave, N.W., Suite 500 2nd Floor, 2-12 Pentonville Road 15 Rue Van Campenhout Washington, DC 20009 London N1 9HF, UK 1000 Brussels, Belgium TEL (202) 612-4321 TEL: (44 20) 7713 1995 TEL (32 2) 732-2009 FAX (202) 612-4333 FAX: (44 20) 7713 1800 FAX (32 2) 732-0471 E-mail: [email protected] E-mail: [email protected] E-mail: [email protected] July 2003 Vol. 15, No. 3 (C) COMPOUNDING INJUSTICE: The Government's Failure to Redress Massacres in Gujarat Table of Contents I. Summary............................................................................................................................................................. 4 Impunity for Attacks Against Muslims...............................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Report on International Religious Freedom 2006: India
    India Page 1 of 22 India International Religious Freedom Report 2006 Released by the Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor The constitution provides for freedom of religion, and the Government generally respected this right in practice. However, the Government sometimes did not act swiftly enough to counter effectively societal attacks against religious minorities and attempts by some leaders of state and local governments to limit religious freedom. This resulted in part from legal constraints on national government action inherent in the country's federal structure and from shortcomings in its law enforcement and justice systems, although courts regularly upheld the constitutional provision of religious freedom. Despite Government efforts to foster communal harmony, some extremists continued to view ineffective investigation and prosecution of attacks on religious minorities, particularly at the state and local level, as a signal that they could commit such violence with impunity, although numerous cases were in the courts at the end of the reporting period. While the National Government took positive steps in key areas to improve religious freedom, the status of religious freedom generally remained the same during the period covered by this report. The United Progressive Alliance (UPA) continued to implement an inclusive and secular platform based on respect for the country's traditions of secular government and religious tolerance, and the rights of religious minorities. Terrorists attempted to provoke religious conflict by attacking Hindu Temples in Ayodhya and Varanasi. The Government reacted in a swift manner to rein in Hindu extremists, prevent revenge attacks and reprisal, and assure the Muslim community of its safety.
    [Show full text]
  • The Pioneer Prime Minister Atal
    Year 2002 Vajpayee Doublespeak 'GUJARAT BOOSTED SECULARISM DEBATE' December 26 2002 Source: The Pioneer Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee feels that the energy that had erupted in Gujarat needs to be properly channelised. He also thinks that the Gujarat outcome will help the nation understand secularism in the proper perspective. "Ab Shabdon ke sahi aarth lagaye ja rahe hain," Mr Vajpayee said in an interview with Hindi daily Dainik Bhaskar, hinting that the true meaning of these words was being understood now. "Secularism had become a slogan. No attempt was being made to probe what the real form of secularism should be. It was not being debated. Little wonder, we remain fiercely secular for 364 days and launch an election campaign from temples on the 365th day," he remarked. "Unhe Deviji ke mandir mein puja karke abhiyan chalane mein koi aapatti nahin hoti," Mr Vajpayee quipped. He was probably taking a dig at Congress President Sonia Gandhi who had launched her election campaign in Gujarat after offering puja at Ambaji temple. He burst into laughter when asked if his Government, too, was surviving because of "Deviji", hinting that he faced no real threat from the Opposition as long as Mrs Sonia Gandhi remained the Congress president. Asked if the Gujarat episode would help him keep the country united, Mr Vajpayee said, "Ye jo urja nikali hai, use santulit rakhna hoga. Aur ise is yukti se nirman mein lagana hoga jisase hamare jeewan ke jo mulya hain, unki rakhsa ho sake (The energy that has been generated should be kept in balance.
    [Show full text]
  • Three Years Later, When Cell Phones Ring
    Best Breaking News THREE YEARS LATER, WHEN CELL PHONES RING Who spoke to whom, when Gujarat was burning Two CDs with more than 5 lakh entries have been lying with the Gujarat ** Using cellphone tower locations, the data also gives information on the police and are now with the Nanavati-Shah riots panel. These have records physical location of the caller and the person at the other end. of all cellphone calls made in Ahmedabad over the first five days of the riots which saw the worst massacres. PART ONE Two compact discs could change that. For, they contain records of all Tracking VHP’s gen secy on day 1,2 (published 21 November 2004) cellphone calls made in Ahmedabad from February 25, 2002, two days Vishwa Hindu Parishad’s General Secretary in Gujarat is a pathologist called before the horrific Sabarmati Express attack to March 4, five days that saw Jaideep Patel. He was booked for rioting and arson in the Naroda Patiya the worst communal violence in recent history. massacre, the worst post-Godhra riot incident in which 83 were killed, many of them burnt alive. The police closed the case saying there was not This staggering amount of data - there are more than 5 lakh entries - was enough evidence. Records show that Patel, who lives in Naroda, was there investigated over several weeks by this newspaper. They show that Patel when the massacre began, then left for Bapunagar which also witnessed was in touch with the key riot accused, top police officers, including the killings and returned to Naroda.
    [Show full text]
  • Islamophobia Monitoring Month: April 2021
    ORGANIZATION OF ISLAMIC COOPERATION Political Affairs Department Islamophobia Observatory Islamophobia Monitoring Month: April 2021 OIC Islamophobia Observatory Issue: April 2021 Islamophobia Status (APR 21) Manifestation Positive Developments 25 20 15 10 5 0 Asia Australia Europe International North America Organizations Manifestations Per Type/Continent (APR 21) 9 8 7 Count of Discrimination 6 Count of Verbal & Physical Assault 5 Count of Hate Speech Count of Online Hate 4 Count of Hijab Incidents 3 Count of Mosque Incidents Count of Policy Related 2 1 0 Asia Australia Europe North America 2 MANIFESTATION (APR 21) Count of Discrimination 15% Count of far-right Count of Verbal & campaigns Physical Assault 32% 6% Count of Hate Speech 12% Count of Online Hate 6% Count of Hijab Incidents Count of Policy Count of Mosque 1% Related Incidents 16% 12% Count of Positive Development on POSITIVE DEVELOPMENT Inter-Faiths (APR 21) 7% Count of Supports Count of Public on Mosques Policy 3% 21% Count of Counter- balances on Far- Rights Count of Police 28% Arrests 14% Count of Court Count of Positive Decisions and Trials Views on Islam 17% 10% 3 MANIFESTATIONS OF ISLAMOPHOBIA NORTH AMERICA IsP140186-US: Facebook, Mark Zuckerberg sued over anti-Muslim hate speech, violence— On April 8, Muslim Advocates, a civil rights group, had sued Facebook and top executives, which included Mark Zuckerberg and Sheryl Sandberg, where they alleged that the company misled the public on the safety of the platform. The complaint filed in federal court in Washington, D.C., argued that Facebook dupes lawmakers, civil rights groups and the public at large when it made broad claims that it had removed content that spews hate or incites violence and yet it did not.
    [Show full text]
  • Breathing Life Into the Constitution
    Breathing Life into the Constitution Human Rights Lawyering In India Arvind Narrain | Saumya Uma Alternative Law Forum Bengaluru Breathing Life into the Constitution Human Rights Lawyering In India Arvind Narrain | Saumya Uma Alternative Law Forum Bengaluru Breathing Life into the Constitution Human Rights Lawyering in India Arvind Narrain | Saumya Uma Edition: January 2017 Published by: Alternative Law Forum 122/4 Infantry Road, Bengaluru - 560001. Karnataka, India. Design by: Vinay C About the Authors: Arvind Narrain is a founding member of the Alternative Law Forum in Bangalore, a collective of lawyers who work on a critical practise of law. He has worked on human rights issues including mass crimes, communal conflict, LGBT rights and human rights history. Saumya Uma has 22 years’ experience as a lawyer, law researcher, writer, campaigner, trainer and activist on gender, law and human rights. Cover page images copied from multiple news articles. All copyrights acknowledged. Any part of this publication may be reproduced, copied or transmitted as necessary. The authors only assert the right to be identified wtih the reproduced version. “I am not a religious person but the only sin I believe in is the sin of cynicism.” Parvez Imroz, Jammu and Kashmir Civil Society Coalition (JKCSS), on being told that nothing would change with respect to the human rights situation in Kashmir Dedication This book is dedicated to remembering the courageous work of human rights lawyers, Jalil Andrabi (1954-1996), Shahid Azmi (1977-2010), K. Balagopal (1952-2009), K.G. Kannabiran (1929-2010), Gobinda Mukhoty (1927-1995), T. Purushotham – (killed in 2000), Japa Lakshma Reddy (killed in 1992), P.A.
    [Show full text]
  • Travelling in Bangalore, South India, in the Summer of 2004 I Am Struck by the Billboards for American and British Products
    Intercultural Communication Studies XIV-3 2005 D’Silva Globalization, Religious Strife, and the Media in India Margaret Usha D’Silva University of Louisville Abstract Participating in the global market has changed not only India’s economy but also its culture. Perhaps as a reaction to Westernization and Christian missionary work, a fundamentalist Hindu movement called the Hindutva movement has gained popularity in India. The cultural movement became strong enough to allow its political front electoral victory in the 1999 elections. This essay examines the Hindutva movement’s fundamentalist character in the context of recent transformations in postcolonial India. Introduction Upon visiting Bangalore, a city of some six million people in South India, in the summer of 2004, I was struck by the billboards for Western products. Pizza Hut, Cadbury’s, and others advertised their products alongside Tata and Vimal. On the streets, white faces mingled with brown ones. East Asian, European, and Slavic conversations created new sounds with the cadence and accents of Indian languages. Food vendors offered vegetable burgers alongside samosas. The signs of globalization were dominant in this city. In other parts of India, the signs were not as prominent. However, globalization was the buzzword used by businessmen, politicians, and intellectuals to partly explain the rapidly changing face of India. Participating in the global economic market has had other consequences for this country of a billion people. The cultural fabric has experienced constant wear and tear as Western modes of behavior and work were gradually incorporated into everyday life. This essay examines the changes and situates the growth of the fundamentalist movement in the context of transformations in post-colonial India.
    [Show full text]
  • Conference Paper No.44
    ERPI 2018 International Conference Authoritarian Populism and the Rural World Conference Paper No.44 Communalism as discourse: Exploring Power/Knowledge in Gujarat riots of 2002 Siddharth Dhote 17-18 March 2018 International Institute of Social Studies (ISS) in The Hague, Netherlands Organized jointly by: In collaboration with: Disclaimer: The views expressed here are solely those of the authors in their private capacity and do not in any way represent the views of organizers and funders of the conference. March, 2018 Check regular updates via ERPI website: www.iss.nl/erpi ERPI 2018 International Conference - Authoritarian Populism and the Rural World Communalism as discourse: Exploring Power/Knowledge in Gujarat riots of 2002 Siddharth Dhote Introduction This paper talks about communal violence in Gujarat during 2002. The paper argues for communalism to be conceptualized as a discourse and understand how knowledge regarding communal issues are produced. The research would deal with Hindu Communalism led by the Sangh Parivar in the case of Gujarat. The Sangh Parivar is led by Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), and its affiliated organizations include the Bhartiya Janta Party (BJP), Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP), Bajrang Dal, and Rashtriyasevika Samiti. It has “sustained the ideological propaganda against minority communities remaining subservient to the Hindu Rashtra” (Puniyani 2003: 21). This paper uses Foucault’s power/knowledge framework to understand how Sangh Parivar, also called the Sangh, used Symbols, Ideologies, Institutions, and Identities during the riots in Gujarat. By using the four concepts the paper will seek answers to one, how the Sangh managed to mobilize people on lines of religion. Two, how the Sangh prevents other political movements, other than on lines of religion from becoming more dominant.
    [Show full text]
  • South Asia Multidisciplinary Academic Journal, 24/25 | 2020 Hindutva’S Blood 2
    South Asia Multidisciplinary Academic Journal 24/25 | 2020 The Hindutva Turn: Authoritarianism and Resistance in India Hindutva’s Blood Dwaipayan Banerjee and Jacob Copeman Electronic version URL: http://journals.openedition.org/samaj/6657 DOI: 10.4000/samaj.6657 ISSN: 1960-6060 Publisher Association pour la recherche sur l'Asie du Sud (ARAS) Electronic reference Dwaipayan Banerjee and Jacob Copeman, « Hindutva’s Blood », South Asia Multidisciplinary Academic Journal [Online], 24/25 | 2020, Online since 01 November 2020, connection on 15 December 2020. URL : http://journals.openedition.org/samaj/6657 ; DOI : https://doi.org/10.4000/samaj.6657 This text was automatically generated on 15 December 2020. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License. Hindutva’s Blood 1 Hindutva’s Blood Dwaipayan Banerjee and Jacob Copeman 1 Like many other nationalist movements, Hindu nationalism “understand[s] and order[s] the world through ‘cultural essentials’ of religion, blood, and other practices related to the body—food, marriage, death” (Hansen 1999:11). In what follows, we focus particularly on how blood as a political substance of Hindu nationalism congeals ideology in material forms. Specifically, we trace how blood is imagined and exteriorized by Hindutva leaders and adherents: in ideological texts, in donation camps, through the offering of activists’ own blood to political figures, in blood- portraiture of political figures, and in bloodshed during episodes of communal violence. 2 Tracing these imaginations and exteriorizations, we identify three ways in which blood has become a medium and conceptual resource for Hindutva practice. First, we trace how Hindu nationalist ideologues equate blood with the nation’s spatial boundaries, demanding that non-Hindus recognize an ancient, essential blood-tie and assimilate back into the Hindu fold.
    [Show full text]