DOCSLIB.ORG

M. Lillian Burke (1879-1952): Three Lost Chéticamp Carpets Edward Langille

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
M. Lillian Burke (1879-1952): Three Lost Chéticamp Carpets Edward Langille Document généré le 28 sept. 2021 04:55 Material Culture Review M. Lillian Burke (1879-1952): Three Lost Chéticamp Carpets Edward Langille Volume 80-81, 2014–2015 Résumé de l'article Mary Lillian Burke était l’artisane américaine qui, avec le soutien et URI : https://id.erudit.org/iderudit/mcr80_81art01 l’encouragement des filles d’Alexander Graham Bell, Elsie Grosvenor et Marian Fairchild, créa l’industrie artisanale du tapis hooké de Chéticamp dans les années Aller au sommaire du numéro 1930. De 1927 à 1940, Lillian Burke créait et vendait des tapis hookés de Chéticamp aux grands décorateurs newyorkais. De nos jours ses créations sont pratiquement inconnues. En dépit de leur succès tant commercial qu’artistique, Éditeur(s) pas un seul des tapis que Lillian Burke a vendus à New York n’a pu être identifié. Afin de mieux apprécier la qualité propre de ses créations, « Trois tapis (space) Cape Breton University Press perdus » réunit des articles de presse contemporains, des dessins originaux de Burke, et des photographies de trois créations remarquables. ISSN 1718-1259 (imprimé) 0000-0000 (numérique) Découvrir la revue Citer ce document Langille, E. (2014). M. Lillian Burke (1879-1952): Three Lost Chéticamp Carpets. Material Culture Review, 80-81, 1–16. All rights reserved © Cape Breton University Press, 2015 Ce document est protégé par la loi sur le droit d’auteur. L’utilisation des services d’Érudit (y compris la reproduction) est assujettie à sa politique d’utilisation que vous pouvez consulter en ligne. https://apropos.erudit.org/fr/usagers/politique-dutilisation/ Cet article est diffusé et préservé par Érudit. Érudit est un consortium interuniversitaire sans but lucratif composé de l’Université de Montréal, l’Université Laval et l’Université du Québec à Montréal. Il a pour mission la promotion et la valorisation de la recherche. https://www.erudit.org/fr/ Articles Articles EDWARD LANGILLE M. Lillian Burke (1879-1952): Three Lost Chéticamp Carpets Résumé Abstract Mary Lillian Burke était l’artisane américaine Mary Lillian Burke was an American artisan who, qui, avec le soutien et l’encouragement des filles with the support and encouragement of Alexander d’Alexander Graham Bell, Elsie Grosvenor et Marian Graham Bell’s daughters, Elsie Grosvenor and Fairchild, créa l’industrie artisanale du tapis hooké Marian Fairchild, created the Chéticamp hooked-rug de Chéticamp dans les années 1930. De 1927 à 1940, cottage industry in the 1930s. From 1927 to 1940, Lillian Burke créait et vendait des tapis hookés de Chéticamp aux grands décorateurs newyorkais. De Lillian Burke designed and marketed Chéticamp hooked rugs for leading New York decorators. Today, nos jours ses créations sont pratiquement inconnues. Lillian Burke’s creations are virtually unknown. En dépit de leur succès tant commercial qu’artistique, Despite their commercial and artistic success, not one pas un seul des tapis que Lillian Burke a vendus à New of the Chéticamp rugs Lillian Burke sold in New York York n’a pu être identifié. Afin de mieux apprécier la City has ever been identified. In an effort to gain an qualité propre de ses créations, « Trois tapis (space) appreciation of Lillian Burke’s creations, “Three Lost perdus » réunit des articles de presse contemporains, Chéticamp Carpets” examines contemporary press des dessins originaux de Burke, et des photographies reports, Burke’s original designs, and photographs of de trois créations remarquables. three of her outstanding creations. The time eke that changeth all, And all doth waxe, and fostred be, And all things destroyeth he… Guillaume de Lorris, The Romaunt of the Rose (tr. Chaucer) Fig. 1 Inspecting the “Big Rug,” Belle-Marche, Cape Breton, July 1937. Photograph: David Fairchild, Archives of the Fairchild Tropical Botanic Gardens, Coral Gables, FL. Revue de la culture matérielle 80-81 (automne 2014/printemps 2015) 1 This paper tells the story of three Chéticamp In the absence of the rugs Burke created, hooked carpets designed in the 1930s by the handcraft historians have eschewed commenting American artisan, rug designer, and entrepreneur, on her artistry, focusing rather on the social M. Lillian Burke (1879-1952). A recently discov- and economic significance of her work (McKay ered collection of Burke’s art work, comprising 1994: 203-205; Neal 1995: 111-23; McLeod 1999: one hundred and eighty four hand-painted 188, 191; Flood 2001: 104-13). It is worthwhile designs for Chéticamp hooked rugs, encourages recalling that Burke was not a social activist per scholarly interest in the grade-school teacher se, but an educator and a highly trained crafts- from Washington, DC, who, with the support woman skilled in bookbinding, educational sloyd of Marian Fairchild (1880-1962) and Elsie (woodworking), the graphic arts, sculpture, and Grosvenor (1878-1964), founded a hooked-rug metalwork, as well as textiles (Langille 2013: cottage industry in rural Cape Breton.1 From 50). It seems only fair that her legacy should be 1927 until 1940, during the bleakest years of the assessed in artistic rather than purely social terms. Great Depression, Cape Breton Home Industries And therein lies the rub. How can we evaluate (CBHI) marketed hundreds of Chéticamp hooked Lillian Burke’s artistry without examining the rugs in Baddeck, New York City, Montréal, and actual carpets she designed? elsewhere. In New York, Burke’s bespoke rug The question is more exigent than it first designs found favour with leading metropolitan appears. Consider for instance the treatment decorators, and throughout the 1930s Chéticamp Lillian Burke is given by the historian Ian McKay. rugs were commissioned by America’s most Under the opprobrious term of the “urban ap- prestigious decorating firms. In addition to her propriation” of handcrafts, McKay flatly accuses up-market clients, Burke’s flair for textile design the designer of “reinventing cultural tradition” caught the attention of rug-hooking enthusiasts merely for profit. McKay argues, among other like A. M. Laisé Phillips, of Hearthstone Studios, things, that Burke paid her workers a pittance, the architect Winthrop Kent, and the godfather that she “scientifically redesigned” the Chéticamp of the American hooked rug fraternity, Ralph hooked rug, and that in the process, she contrived Warren Burnham (Kent 1941: 31). At home, to sabotage traditional Nova Scotia folk art, sum- Alice Peck and Wilfrid Bovey of the Canadian marily described as “locally designed products Handicraft Guild (CHG) wrote enthusiastically carrying images of fishing life” (McKay 1994: of Burke’s Chéticamp hooked rugs, praising their 205). outstanding design and execution (Peck 1933; McKay’s indictment is quite inaccurate. Bovey 1934: 553). Traditional hooked rug design has never reflected An appreciable number of Burke’s hooked a single theme. Atlantic Canadian hooked rugs, rug sketches have survived but, sadly, the rugs she including those produced in Newfoundland, created have all but disappeared.2 Despite their have always depicted an eclectic variety of commercial and artistic success, not one of the patterns including floral, floral geometrical, Chéticamp rugs Lillian Burke sold in New York abstract geometrical, still-life religious, still-life City has ever been identified, let alone subjected nautical, landscapes, and portrayals of animals to rigorous provenance research, most likely (Lynch 1980). A favoured technique universally because CBHI did not label its products. The practised consisted in copying textiles in hooked Textile Museum of Canada does not display a work (Pocius 1979: 277). Traditional rug hooking single Lillian Burke design. The same is true of often took its inspiration from old pieces of fabric both the McCord Museum and the Canadian such as paisley shawls, cretonne, chintz, or calico Museum of History. At the outset of this essay, prints. Even sophisticated French carpet designs let us state that one of our goals is to alert the were given homespun treatment (Kent 1941: custodians of Canada’s material heritage to this 215). But in any event, we know that by the early unfortunate, but perhaps reparable, oversight. It 20th century Chéticamp hooked rugs were most is to be hoped that Burke’s hooked rug sketches often made from pre-stamped canvasses provided and photographs will one day help identify her by John E. Garrett and Son of New Glasgow lost work. (Chiasson 1985: 26). 2 Material Culture Review 80-81 (Fall 2014/Spring 2015) The imputation that Lillian Burke made a It was, in fact, not until 1961, almost ten years fortune designing Chéticamp hooked rugs has after Lillian Burke’s death, that that the American been dealt with elsewhere (Langille 2012: 76). Let Folk Art Museum in Manhattan received its us state emphatically that, contrary to rumour, provisional charter and opened its collections Burke did not grow rich designing Chéticamp for public viewing. In light of folk art’s uncertain hooked rugs. Even at the height of her career, status during her lifetime, it seems unreasonable Burke’s income was modest, especially by New to expect Lillian Burke’s views on the subject to York standards. As for the accusation that her conform to a latter-day definition. Chéticamp workforce was paid a pittance—75¢, In order to understand Barbeau’s attitude 85¢, or $1.00 per square foot of hooking—a (and, by inference, Lillian Burke’s as well), we 1935 memorandum circulated by the Canadian must briefly consider the impact the Arts and Handicraft Guild to its affiliates allows us to put Crafts school of thought�����������������������
Load more

Recommended publications
  • 2014 - 2015 Scholarship Report About the University
    2014 - 2015 SCHOLARSHIP REPORT ABOUT THE UNIVERSITY Founded in 1853, St. Francis Xavier University (StFX) in Antigonish, Nova Scotia, began as a small STFX STATISTICS FOR 2014-2015 school of higher studies established by the Catholic Church. Today, StFX is widely recognized as one of Canada’s leading undergraduate universities with a longstanding tradition of academic excellence, UNDERGRADUATE STUDENTS 4,729 innovation in teaching, research and service to society. It brings together over 4,500 students for studies in arts, sciences, business, education and applied professional programs. The University is FULL-TIME 3,923 known for its strong traditions of social engagement and service to humanity, as well as for the PART-TIME 806 numerous communities with which it engages. These traditions are preserved by the research work of GRADUATE STUDENTS 577 StFX faculty with First Nations communities, the Coady International Institute, and Service Learning FULL-TIME experiences for students, as well the work of initiatives such as the StFX-based National Collaborating 91 Centre for Determinants of Health. PART-TIME 486 TOTAL STUDENT ENROLMENT 5,306 Although known as a primarily undergraduate-focused university, StFX offers several Graduate Studies programs at the Master’s level, as well as a joint PhD program in Education Studies delivered FACULTY & ACADEMIC STAFF in partnership with Acadia University and Mount Saint Vincent University. Research is a pervasive FULL-TIME FACULTY 238 aspect of StFX and the University’s research activity has grown in the past several decades. Research at StFX is generally regarded as an inclusive endeavour embracing the full range of intellectual, PART-TIME FACULTY 75 scholarly and creative activities focused on the discovery, integration, interpretation and application ACADEMIC STAFF 86 of knowledge.
    [Show full text]
  • We Are the Rug Hooking Capital of the World”: Understanding Chéticamp Rugs (1927-2017)
    “We are the Rug Hooking Capital of the World”: Understanding Chéticamp Rugs (1927-2017) by © Laura Marie Andrea Sanchini A thesis submitted to the School of Graduate Studies In partial fulfilment of the Requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of Folklore Memorial University December 3rd, 2018 St John’s Newfoundland Abstract This thesis is the story of how utilitarian material culture was transformed into a cottage industry, and eventually into high art. Chéticamp rug hooking is an artistic practice, one wrapped up in issues of taste, creativity, class and economics. Rug hooking in Chéticamp rose to prominence in the first half of the 20th century when Lillian Burke, a visiting American artist, set up a rug hooking cottage industry in the area. She altered the tradition to suit the tastes of wealthy patrons, who began buying the rugs to outfit their homes. This thesis examines design in rug hooking focusing on Chéticamp-style rugs. Captured within design aesthetics is what the rugs mean to both those who make and consume them. For tourists, the rugs are symbols of a perceived anti-modernism. Through the purchase of a hooked rug, they are able to bring home material reminders of their moment of experience with rural Nova Scotia. For rug hookers, rugs are a symbol of economic need, but also agency and the ability to overcome depressed rural economic conditions. Rug hooking was a way to have a reliable income in an area where much of the labour is dependent on unstable sources, such as natural resources (fishing, lumber, agriculture etc.).
    [Show full text]
  • Book Review the Story of Lillian Burke July 18
    1 HARP, The People’s Press is delighted to review The Story of Lillian Burke by Edward Langille, which was published in Canada in 2019 by Boularderie Island Press. The Story of Lillian Burke is a must-read for any arts-health practitioner or anyone with an interest in the history of occupational therapy (OT) and the burgeoning arts-in-medicine movement. Through the lens of this one remarkable woman, Edward Langille traces the history of these movements, which will serve as an important addition to the reading list/curriculum for professional accreditation in these fields, as well as in the therapies that focus on the arts, including music, visual arts, drama, and dance. His biography closes in on her prodigious talent as a designer and craftswoman 2 in the field of rug-hooking. But it also highlights her considerable skill as a pianist and dramaturge, which she brought to play at the New York Psychiatric Institute in the 1940s after joining the Department of Occupational Therapy and assuming responsibility for the Institute’s new music therapy programme . Adolph Meyer (1866-1950) is recognized as a founder of OT. Under his direction, the Institute was one of the first hospitals in the United States to advocate for “recreational therapy” to treat physical and mental illnesses. He was also at the forefront of changing the negative names of hospitals from insane asylums or lunatic hospitals to mental hospitals. This groundbreaking step to recognize patients as whole persons is reflected in the programs that Lillian created at the Institute when OT was in its infancy.
    [Show full text]
  • NS Royal Gazette Part I
    Nova Scotia Published by Authority Part I VOLUME 227, NO. 39 HALIFAX, NOVA SCOTIA, WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 26, 2018 PROVINCE OF NOVA SCOTIA Mark Furey IN THE MATTER OF SECTION 254(1) OF Attorney General and Minister of Justice THE CRIMINAL CODE OF CANADA September 26-2018 Under the authority vested in me by Section 254(1) of the Criminal Code of Canada, I hereby designate: This is to certify that on August 1, 2018 at 14:13 in the afternoon change(s) was/were made under the provisions of Gavin Neal Greenland the Change of Name Act for the following individual(s): Royal Canadian Mounted Police From: JOHNNA JEAN NICKERSON Province of Nova Scotia To: JOHN J NICKERSON Year of Birth: 1991, born: HALIFAX, NOVA SCOTIA as being qualified to operate an approved instrument, the Intox EC/IR II, and therefore a “qualified technician” in This is to certify that on August 1, 2018 at 14:25 in the respect of breath samples, within the meaning of Section afternoon change(s) was/were made under the provisions of 254(1) of the said Criminal Code of Canada. the Change of Name Act for the following individual(s): From: EMILY MEREDITH TUTTY DATED at Halifax, Nova Scotia, this 20th day of July, To: STEVEN MEREDITH TUTTY 2018. Year of Birth: 2004, born: HALIFAX, NOVA SCOTIA Mark Furey This is to certify that on August 1, 2018 at 14:42 in the Attorney General and Minister of Justice afternoon change(s) was/were made under the provisions of the Change of Name Act for the following individual(s): September 26-2018 From: HARLEE ELIZABETH DAWN MCGRAW To: HARLEE PRISCILLA
    [Show full text]
  • Annual Report on Research Activities at Saint Francis Xavier University
    Annual Report on Research Activities at Saint Francis Xavier University 2014-2015 Prepared for the Nova Scotia Ministry of Advanced Labour & Education 1 Annual Report on Research Activities at Saint Francis Xavier University – 2014-2015 Compiled by Dr. Richard Isnor, Associate Vice President Research and Graduate Studies, January, 2016 This report was prepared to correspond with the template agreed upon by universities in Nova Scotia and the NS Department of Labour & Advanced Education, as of September of 2013. It is intended to report each January on the research activity of the previous year. For some areas, the reporting period is according to fiscal year (April 1, 2014 to March 31, 2015; e.g. funding statistics). In other areas, the reporting is according to academic year (September 1, 2014 to August 31, 2015; e.g. enrolments) or calendar year 2014 (e.g. publications). Note: This report contains data from years later than the reporting period in some instances, since it was prepared in early 2016 and later year’s data was available. Introduction Research is fundamental to St. Francis Xavier’s institutional role as a university and is recognized as one of the primary functions of the university’s faculty. Research both informs and is intertwined with the university’s role as a post-secondary educational institution, and is an essential component of the university’s commitment to service. The Major Research Objectives of Saint Francis Xavier University’s 2012-17 Strategic Research Plan (SRP) are: • To build and enhance an environment
    [Show full text]
  • Articles Articles
    Articles Articles EDWARD LANGILLE M. Lillian Burke (1879-1952): Three Lost Chéticamp Carpets Résumé Abstract Mary Lillian Burke était l’artisane américaine Mary Lillian Burke was an American artisan who, qui, avec le soutien et l’encouragement des filles with the support and encouragement of Alexander d’Alexander Graham Bell, Elsie Grosvenor et Marian Graham Bell’s daughters, Elsie Grosvenor and Fairchild, créa l’industrie artisanale du tapis hooké Marian Fairchild, created the Chéticamp hooked-rug de Chéticamp dans les années 1930. De 1927 à 1940, cottage industry in the 1930s. From 1927 to 1940, Lillian Burke créait et vendait des tapis hookés de Chéticamp aux grands décorateurs newyorkais. De Lillian Burke designed and marketed Chéticamp hooked rugs for leading New York decorators. Today, nos jours ses créations sont pratiquement inconnues. Lillian Burke’s creations are virtually unknown. En dépit de leur succès tant commercial qu’artistique, Despite their commercial and artistic success, not one pas un seul des tapis que Lillian Burke a vendus à New of the Chéticamp rugs Lillian Burke sold in New York York n’a pu être identifié. Afin de mieux apprécier la City has ever been identified. In an effort to gain an qualité propre de ses créations, « Trois tapis (space) appreciation of Lillian Burke’s creations, “Three Lost perdus » réunit des articles de presse contemporains, Chéticamp Carpets” examines contemporary press des dessins originaux de Burke, et des photographies reports, Burke’s original designs, and photographs of de trois créations remarquables. three of her outstanding creations. The time eke that changeth all, And all doth waxe, and fostred be, And all things destroyeth he… Guillaume de Lorris, The Romaunt of the Rose (tr.
    [Show full text]
  • 2015-2016 Research & Scholarship Report
    2015-2016 RESEARCH & SCHOLARSHIP REPORT ABOUT THE UNIVERSITY Founded in 1853, St. Francis Xavier University (StFX) in Antigonish, Nova Scotia, began as a small school of higher studies established by the Catholic Church. Today, StFX is widely recognized as one of Canada's leading undergraduate universities with a longstanding tradition of academic excellence, innovation in teaching, research and service to society. It brings together over 4,500 students for studies in arts, sciences, business, education and applied professional programs. The University is known for its strong traditions of social engagement and service to humanity, as well as for the numerous communities with which it engages. These traditions are preserved by the research work of StFX faculty with First Nations communities, the Coady International Institute, and Service Learning experiences for students, as well the work of initiatives such as the StFX-based National Collaborating Centre for Determinants of Health. The recent launch of the newly created Mulroney Institute of Government will substantially expand and build on the StFX tradition of training leaders in public service, as well as undertaking research and scholarship on a broad range of public policy and governance topics. Although known as a primarily undergraduate-focused university, StFX offers several Graduate Studies programs at the Master’s level, as well as a joint PhD program in Education Studies delivered in partnership with Acadia University and Mount Saint Vincent University. Research is a pervasive aspect of StFX and the University’s research activity has grown in the past several decades. Research at StFX is generally regarded as an inclusive endeavour embracing the full range of intellectual, scholarly and creative activities focused on the discovery, integration, interpretation and application of knowledge.
    [Show full text]