Imagining the Inoperative Community: Documentary Aesthetic in Roberto Bolaño and Alfredo Jaar
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Imagining the Inoperative Community: Documentary Aesthetic in Roberto Bolaño and Alfredo Jaar by Sebastian Ferrari A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (Comparative Literature) in The University of Michigan 2012 Doctoral Committee: Associate Professor Katherine M. Jenckes, Chair Professor Michèle A. Hannoosh Professor Gareth Williams Associate Professor Santiago Colás Associate Professor Daniel Noemi © Sebastian Ferrari, 2012 Dedication a mis padres / til mine forældre / to my parents ii Acknowledgments This dissertation represents the culmination of much research and writing but also many conversations, for which I am in debt to many individuals. I would like to thank first of all Kate Jenckes, the chair of my committee, for being in many ways the ideal interlocutor for my project. She has helped my ideas grow and take shape while also pushing back constructively when those ideas reached the limits of coherence. I feel fortunate and privileged to have been able to work under her mentorship. Many thanks as well to the other members of my committee. Santiago Colás shepherded me through many stages of my graduate career, even as early as the day I arrived on campus as a prospective student. His excellent teaching and precision in thought and expression have been an inspiration. Daniel Noemi was incredibly generous with his detailed and thorough feedback. Conversations over the years with Michèle Hannoosh have helped to crystallize my thought process and deepen my ideas on images and text-image relations. Gareth Williams’ excellent comments and questions at the defense were especially insightful and helpful in imagining future iterations of my project. I am indebted to several institutions for their funding of my research and writing: the Rackham Graduate School, the Sweetland Dissertation Writing Institute, and the Mellon Dissertation Seminar in the Humanities. Thanks to the Department of Comparative Literature for its constant support over the years. Special thanks go to Yopie Prins and Silke-Maria Weineck for their guidance and solidarity in administrative battles; and to Paula Frank and Nancy Harris for their daily conversation and good cheer. Thank you as well to the many students in Comparative Literature who made grad school a worthwhile and enjoyable endeavor. In the early and middle stages of the writing process I found great support and camaraderie in my writing group, due to the wit and insight of Andrea, Rebecca, Christina, and Vera. I’m glad to now be on the other side with all of you. Many friends and family have helped me along the way, whether they knew it or not. Thanks to Joe H. for getting me started on this literature thing way back in the mid-90’s. I’m with you in Rockland and beyond. Joe N., Annie, Yusuf, Carly, Jeremy, and Bashar, thanks for your companionship, whether near or far. Thanks to Alan, Robert, Carrie, Chris, Topher, and John R. for their solidarity and friendship over many cups of coffee and drinks. William and Frances, Kat and Colin, thanks for everything. Richard and Katherine, David and Nicole: thanks for your encouragement and support! Gracias Alicia, por todos los libros. Tusind tak Casper, Inger, René og Michael! iii This dissertation is dedicated to my parents. Gracias Jorge, por todo. Tak Irene, your presence is never forgotten. Thanks Sue, for being there for me. Finally, thanks to Joy, without whom this dissertation would never have been completed. Every day I’m amazed at my luck to have you in my life and to be a part of yours. - whatever a sun will always sing is you - iv Table of Contents Dedication………………………………………………………………………………... ii Acknowledgments………………………………………………………………………. iii Chapter One : Introduction ................................................................................................. 1 Chapter Two : The Encyclopedia and The Story: Political and Literary Identity in Roberto Bolaño’s Estrella distante and La literatura nazi en América ............................ 41 Chapter Three : The Catalogue of Femicides in Roberto Bolaño’s 2666: A Failure of Witnessing, the Beginnings of an Account ..................................................................... 113 Chapter Four : The Burial of the Image: Alfredo Jaar’s Inoperative Documentation .... 159 Chapter Five : Conclusion .............................................................................................. 210 Works Cited…………………………………………………………………………… 216 v Chapter One: Introduction At the heart of this dissertation is a concern for and interest in how a certain genre, form, and intentionality change when placed into a different context and used for a different means. The genre in question here is the particularly nebulous one of documentary, whether it be expressed in photography, writing, actual documentation, or some other form. The gap between the theory and practice of what documentary work does creates a space for the intervention of aesthetic practices, in which it is possible to reconfigure the documentary impulse and form. The literary and artistic works I examine here come out of a background in which the circulation of documentation is immense and its importance is viewed with great urgency while also being delegitimized or problematized in important ways. Genocidal or mass crimes committed by the state or other actors in Latin America and elsewhere must be documented and communicated; at the same time, the means through which such documentation is formulated and communicated have come into question in several different ways: traditional documentary work has undergone severe questioning in the last three decades; the value of a photograph has changed with the emergence of digital media; and the structures of the state which previously underwrote the cultural value and weight of documents have been corrupted by ties to previous orders (some of which committed the crimes in question), handicapped by amnesty laws, or weakened by the ascending power of the neoliberal market. And perhaps most importantly, there is the dilemma posed by having to document erasure and disappearance. Confronted with this problem, documentary 1 work, I suggest, turns toward more literary or figurative forms of gesturing at what remains beyond and before the typical frame of documentary work. The Chilean novelist Roberto Bolaño and the Chilean artist Alfredo both saw the burden placed on documentary forms and documentation and its precarious nature under that weight. In their work they incorporate documentary forms and expectations, even as they attempt to exceed their typical principals of production and meaning-making. Unlike the sharp bifurcation drawn by the Chilean theorist Nelly Richard between the avant- garde and the social sciences in their responses to the coup in Chile, Bolaño and Jaar show a lack of fear in inhabiting either set of discourses, and pass between each with fluency; this fluency and dialectic is an integral part of what I’ve called “documentary aesthetic.” I also describe this as a kind of inoperative or suspended documentation which occurs when the gesture of documenting is lifted up from its traditional coordinates and network of meaning-making and reference, and becomes free to join forces with other aesthetic techniques. In this separation the documentary apparatus is divorced from the ideology which traditionally sustains the authority of documentation, and it thus becomes capable of questioning, if not indicting, that ideology. This is what happens, for instance, in the creative reuse and recontextualization of identity documents in Jaar’s work or as instrumentalized by the Mothers of the Plaza de Mayo. This dissertation also contributes to the work of understanding Bolaño’s oeuvre by examining in greater specificity one aspect of his style. His writings are marked by forms strongly associated with the dictatorships and their aftermath: the testimonial or confessional voice (in Nocturno de Chile (2000), Amuleto (1999)); the portfolio of interviews assembled from an investigation (Los detectives salvajes (1998)); the 2 catalogue of the dead (2666 (2005)) or the encyclopedia of artists, itself another form of catalogue (La literatura nazi en América (1996)); the phone calls, letters and correspondence between exiles (Llamadas telefónicas (1997)). This dissertation attends to the impact of these forms on our reading of Bolaño. In chapter two, I attempt to read how the narrative techniques of Estrella distante, in response specifically to the fake anthology of fascist writers that composes the entirety of La literatura nazi en América, offer an understanding and expression of identity and community that reflect the fact that, in the post-coup era in Chile, identity and community are essentially fractured and always haunted by the possibilities foreclosed by the coup. By dialectizing the isolated entries of the encyclopedic form of La literatura nazi en América with the hyperactive and overdetermined doubling of stories and identities in Estrella distante, we glimpse a first instance of how the documentary aesthetic works at pointing out the foreclosure inherent in documentary form while absorbing and reconfiguring the ordering discourse of the encyclopedia into its own aesthetic framework. Similarly, I argue that in the novel 2666 the reworking of the catalogue form, a poetic form extracted from ancient epic poetry which traditionally is supposed to give the listener or reader a sense of order and place, represents the