Geomorphology of Vancouver Island: Mass Wasting Potential I © 2005 Province of British Columbia
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Geomorphology of Vancouver Island: Mass Wasting Potential Victoria, British Columbia Research Report No. RR 01 December 2005 by RH Guthrie Regional Geomorphologist Geomorphology of Vancouver Island: Mass Wasting Potential i © 2005 Province of British Columbia Library and Archives Canada Cataloguing in Publication Data Guthrie, R. H. (Richard Hamilton), 1969- Geomorphology of Vancouver Island [electronic resource]: mass wasting potential. Includes bibliographical references: p. Available on the Internet. ISBN 0-7726-5468-9 1. Geomorphology - British Columbia – Vancouver Island. 2. Mass-wasting – British Columbia – Vancouver Island. I. British Columbia. Ministry of Environment. II. Title. GB428.5.C3G87 2005 551.41’09711’2 C2005-960251-1 Citation Guthrie, R.H. 2005. Geomorphology of Vancouver Island [electronic resource]: mass wasting potential. B.C. Ministry of Environment, Victoria, BC. Research Report No. RR01. Copies of this report are available online through B.C. Ministry of Environment at http://wlapwww.gov.bc.ca/wld/pub/pub.htm Disclaimer: Interpretation of the results and analysis are solely those of the author and do not represent the opinions of the Ministry of Environment or the Government of British Columbia. ii Geomorphology of Vancouver Island: Mass Wasting Potential Geomorphology of Vancouver Island: Mass Wasting Potential iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The assistance of Charles Penner in creating the initial map is gratefully acknowledged. I am also grateful to Stuart Atkins who provided substantial air photograph interpretation from which most of the analyses are derived, and to Catherine Shilston who worked on analysis and organization of the many datasets that resulted from the air photograph interpretations. Ross Petit and Shari Lindsay provided substantial GIS and cartographic support to the project. Gail Harcombe of the Ministry of Environment provided or arranged editorial review. Finally, I’m grateful to Steve Evans of the University of Waterloo and Oldrich Hungr of the University of British Columbia for providing technical reviews of the manuscript. ii Geomorphology of Vancouver Island: Mass Wasting Potential Geomorphology of Vancouver Island: Mass Wasting Potential iii ABSTRACT The Geomorphology of Vancouver Island is a series of nine thematic maps, one of which is a map of mass wasting potential for Vancouver Island. This report represents a description of the Mass Wasting Potential Map and the results of analyzing the regional character of landslide potential. Vancouver Island has been divided into four major zones: the Wet West Coast, Moderately Wet Central Island, Moderately Dry East Coast, and Alpine (zones I–IV, respectively). Landslide frequencies are proposed at 0.012, 0.007, and 0.004 events per square kilometre per year for zones I–III respectively, and several times higher for zone IV. Mass movements in zones I–III are generally dominated by debris slides and debris flows averaging about 11,000 2m , but ranging nearly three orders of magnitude. The Alpine Zone (Zone IV) contains substantial areas of rock fall and snow avalanches in addition to debris slides and flows. Two sub-zones related to bedrock geology were established because of associated differences in landslide behaviour: the Island Plutonic Suite appears to be more stable under natural (typically unfractured and unweathered) conditions, but is less stable under conditions that alter the rock (e.g., road building and frost shattering), and the Sicker Group is generally less stable than adjacent bedrock types. Other geological considerations were also incorporated into the map. The impact of logging and road building on landslide frequency is considered. Results indicate that logging activities increase landslide frequencies by more than 10 times, and the presence of roads increases landslide area by 22 to 43 times. These results corroborate previous studies. iv Geomorphology of Vancouver Island: Mass Wasting Potential Geomorphology of Vancouver Island: Mass Wasting Potential v TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction and Background................................................................................... 1 Methods .................................................................................................................... 2 Definitions .......................................................................................................... 3 Debris slides and debris flows ....................................................................... 3 Rock falls and talus slopes ............................................................................. 5 Snow avalanches............................................................................................ 6 Cautions: Scale and Regional Variability ............................................................ 6 Results and Discussion.............................................................................................. 7 General Results ................................................................................................... 7 Mass Wasting Potential Map Zones .................................................................... 8 Wet West Coast (Zone I) ............................................................................. 9 Moderately Wet Central Island (Zone II) ..................................................... 9 Moderately Dry East Coast (Zone III) ........................................................ 10 Alpine (Zone IV) ........................................................................................ 10 Frequency Distribution .................................................................................... 10 Landslides and Geology on Vancouver Island.................................................... 12 Sub-zone b: The Island Plutonic Suite ........................................................ 13 Sub-zone c: The Sicker Group .................................................................... 16 Other potential sub-zones and bedrock considerations................................ 16 The influence of surficial geology on landslide rates .................................... 16 The Influence of Logging on Landslide Rates .................................................... 17 The Influence of Road Building on Landslide Rates .......................................... 18 Conclusions............................................................................................................. 19 References................................................................................................................ 20 Appendix I............................................................................................................... 22 List of Tables Table 1. Velocities of typical coastal landslide movement types (landslide data from Cruden and Varnes 1996) ................................................................................. 3 Table 2. Size and area of landslides from 35 randomly selected sites over 200 km2 of terrain on Vancouver Island ................................................................................... 8 Table 3. The number of landslides in each zone......................................................... 9 Table 4. Density and frequency of natural landslides by zone for Vancouver Island ....................................................................................................................... 10 iv Geomorphology of Vancouver Island: Mass Wasting Potential Geomorphology of Vancouver Island: Mass Wasting Potential v Table 5. Watershed-based landslide frequencies for Vancouver Island mass wasting zones compared with frequencies from previous watershed-based studies ................. 12 Table 6. Previous research showing landslide frequency relative to bedrock geology..................................................................................................................... 14 Table 7. Natural landslide frequencies for zones I-III for the dominant bedrock formations on Vancouver Island............................................................................... 15 Table 8. Logging-related landslide frequencies (including roads) for all zones for the dominant bedrock formations on Vancouver Island ........................................... 15 Table 9. Natural landslides (debris slides and flows) in the Alpine Zone on Vancouver Island ..................................................................................................... 15 Table 10. The impact of logging on density and frequency of landslides in this study ........................................................................................................................ 18 Table 11. The relative contribution of roads to landslide frequencies on Vancouver Island in this study ................................................................................................... 18 List of Figures Figure 1. The physiographic regions of Vancouver Island........................................... 2 Figure 2. Schematic representing the gathering of data for a mass wasting potential map for Vancouver Island, British Columbia ............................................................. 3 Figure 3. Stereo air photograph of a debris slide into a river on Vancouver Island ..... 4 Figure 4. Photograph of a debris slide from a road on Vancouver Island ................... 4 Figure 5. A stereo air photograph of a channelized debris flow on Vancouver Island .. 4 Figure 6. A stereo air photograph of a rock fall on Vancouver Island.........................