SUSTAINABLE AGRICULTURE NETWORK THE NATIONAL OUTREACH ARM OF USDA-SARE HANDBOOK SERIES BOOK 3
Managing Cover Crops Profitably SECOND EDITION
A publication of the Sustainable Agriculture Network with funding by the Sustainable Agriculture Research and Education Program of CSREES, U.S. Department of Agriculture
Sustainable Agriculture Network National Agricultural Library Beltsville, MD 20705-2351 Copyright © 1998 by the Sustainable Agriculture Network, Library of Congress Cataloguing-in-Publication Data with funding from the Sustainable Agriculture Research and Education (SARE) program of the Cooperative State Research Managing cover crops profitably.—2nd ed. Education and Extension Service (CSREES),U.S.Department of p. cm.–(Sustainable Agriculture Network handbook series Agriculture. Reprinted in 2000. bk. 3) Includes bibliographical references (p. ) and index. SAN, the national outreach partner of the USDA SARE pro- ISBN 1-888626-04-6 (pbk) gram, is a consortium of individuals, universities and govern- 1. Cover crops—United States—Handbooks, manuals, etc. ment, business and nonprofit organizations dedicated to the I. Sustainable Agriculture Network. II. Series. exchange of information on sustainable agricultural systems. SB284.3.U6M36 1998 631.5’82—dc2l 98-9887 For more information about the Sustainable Agriculture CIP Network, or about other SAN publications, contact: 2 4 6 8 9 7 5 3 1 Andy Clark SAN Coordinator Printed in the United States of America on recycled paper. c/o AFSIC, Room 304 National Agricultural Library The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) prohibits discrim- 10301 Baltimore Avenue ination in all its programs and activities on the basis of race, Beltsville, MD 20705-2351 color, national origin, gender, religion, age, disability, political PH: 301-504-6425 beliefs, sexual orientation, and marital or family status. (Not all FAX: 301-504-6409 prohibited bases apply to all programs). Persons with disabili- [email protected] ties who require alternative means for communication of www.sare.org program information (Braille, large print, audiotape, etc.) should contact USDA’s TARGET Center at 202-720-2600 (voice SARE is a competitive grants program. It provides funding for and TDD). research and education projects that promote agricultural systems that are profitable, environmentally sound and To file a complaint of discrimination, write USDA, Director, enhance the viability of rural communities nationwide. Office of Civil Rights, Room 326-W,Whitten Building, 14th and Independence Avenue, SW,Washington,DC 20250-9410 or call For more information about the SARE program and SARE (202) 720-5964 (voice or TDD).USDA is an equal opportunity grants, contact: provider and employer. Office of Sustainable Agriculture Programs U.S. Department of Agriculture Every effort has been made to make this book as complete and 1400 Independence Ave., S.W.,Stop 2223 as accurate as possible and to educate the reader.This text is Washington, D.C. 20250-2223 only a guide,however,and should be used in conjunction with other information sources on crop, weed and farm manage- Material for this book and its covers was researched written, ment. No single cover crop strategy will be appropriate and illustrated,edited and produced for the Sustainable Agriculture effective for all conditions. The editor/authors and publisher Network.The book concept, format, and selection of featured disclaim any liability,loss,or risk,personal or otherwise,which farmers and content reviewers were developed under the is incurred as a consequence, directly or indirectly, of the use auspices of the Sustainable Agriculture Network. and application of any of the contents of this book. To order copies of this book, send a check or purchase order Mention, visual representation or inferred reference of a prod- for $19 plus $3.95 shipping and handling to: uct, service, manufacturer or organization in this publication Sustainable Agriculture Publications does not imply endorsement by the USDA, the SARE program Hills Building, Room 10 or the authors.Exclusion does not imply a negative evaluation. University of Vermont Burlington,VT 05405-0082 Graphic design, interior layout and cover design: Diane Buric. Interior illustrations by: 1. Marianne Sarrantonio (reprinted Call 802-656-0484 to order by credit card. For first book sent with permission from the Northeast Cover Crop Handbook. outside of N. America, please add $6. Add $2.50 for each 1994. Rodale Institute. Emmaus, PA); and 2. Elayne Sears. additional book. Please include your mailing address and Copy Editing:Valerie Berton and Andy Clark. Indexing: Nancy telephone number. Hopkins. Printing: Jarboe Printing, Washington, D.C.. Cover photos by Tom Gettings;orchard photo by Chuck Ingels, Univ. The Sustainable Agriculture Network Handbook Series previ- of Calif. Extension. ous titles include Book 1: Managing Cover Crops Profitably (1st Edition), edited by the staff of the Rodale Institute; and This book was written by Greg Bowman, Christopher Book 2: Steel in the Field: A Farmer’s Guide to Weed Shirley and Craig Cramer, of CMR Editorial Services, for Management Tools,1997, edited by Greg Bowman. the Sustainable Agriculture Network. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
his book represents a true cooperative and Jim Stute, Michael Fields Agricultural Institute, effort. Most writing and research was by East Troy, Wis.; Richard Dick, Oregon State TChristopher Shirley, Greg Bowman and University; Jim Sims, Emeritus Professor, Montana Craig Cramer, formerly writers/editors for the State University; Chuck Ingels, University New Farm Magazine. Their experience writing of California Extension Service. Andy Clark, for the agricultural community shows in their Coordinator of the Sustainable Agriculture ability to incorporate a vast amount of research Network, oversaw the project and coordinated data and farmer experiences into this publication. the efforts of the writers, the designer and the Contributors Marianne Sarrantonio, University of editorial board. Maine, Orono, ME, Sharad Phatak, University of The complete manuscript was reviewed at least Georgia, and Andy Clark, Coordinator of the twice by each member of the editorial board. It was Sustainable Agriculture Network (SAN) each also reviewed by Mark Davis, Delaware State wrote sections of the book. Robert Myers, University;John Luna,Oregon State University; Wayne Reeves, Seth Dabney and Steve Diver, Appropriate Technology Chuck Ingels contributed to Transfer for Rural Areas (ATTRA), Appendix B, Up-and-Coming Fayetteville, Ark.; John and Cover Crops. Lorraine Merrill, Stuart Farm, Farmers played a major Stratham,N.H.;John Teasdale, role in developing the USDA-ARS, Beltsville, Md.; book, detailing their Phil Bauer, USDA-ARS, cropping systems and Florence, S.C.; Morris the management of Decker,Professor Emeritus, cover crops on their University of Maryland; farms. Some were con- Noah Ranells, North tacted repeatedly for Carolina State University; further clarification, and and Valerie Berton, SARE many also reviewed sec- communications specialist. tions of the manuscript. Individual chapters of The value of the contribu- Managing Cover Crops tions by farmers using cover Profitably, 2nd Edition were crops in the field cannot be under- reviewed by cover crop experts estimated. They generously gave of from the farm and research their time to provide true ground-testing and communities.These farmers and scientists are reality-checking to strenthen this publication. too numerous to mention here, but their contri- A volunteer editorial board consisted of faculty butions were invaluable to this effort. and researchers from around the country: Rob In preparation for the second edition, the first Myers, Jefferson Institute,Columbia, Mo., formerly edition was critically reviewed by Morris Decker, director of SARE; Fred Magdoff, Northeast Region Professor Emeritus, University of Maryland; Zane SARE, University of Vermont; Seth Dabney, USDA- Helsel, Rutgers University; and Andy Clark, SAN. ARS Soil Sedimentation Lab;Wayne Reeves, USDA- Fred Magdoff, who was the driving force behind ARS National Soil Dynamics Lab; Marianne the first edition, participated in planning and Sarrantonio, University of Maine; Walter Goldstein reviewing throughout the process.
BERSEEM CLOVER, an annual legume, produces abundant vegetation with multiple cuttings.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS 3 The first edition, written in 1991 by Mike support of the Sustainable Agriculture Network Brusko at Rodale Institute, was used liberally in (SAN). SAN is the communications and outreach the development and writing of this second arm of the SARE program. Other SARE support edition. came in the form of extensive planning, design, Mary Gold and Abiola Adeyemi, from the writing and editing by SARE communications Alternative Farming Systems Information Center specialist Valerie Berton, College Park, Md. SAN at the National Agricultural Library,provided com- publications committee chair Beth Holtzman, prehensive literature searching and facilitated the Burlington,Vt., contributed publication oversight, duplication and lending of cover crop literature contract management and overall good sense to the writers. Abiola Adeyemi also compiled about publishing sustainable agriculture infor- parts of the Appendices and provid- mation. Other members of the SAN ed clerical support,particularly dur- Management Committee commented on ing the reviews of the book. early plans for the book, helped develop Consulted repeatedly for budgets, and were consulted on other guidance and information aspects of the project as needed. were reviewers or authors As SAN Coordinator, I heartily thank all Seth Dabney, Sharad Phatak, members of the sustainable agriculture Marianne Sarrantonio, Jim Sims, community for their cooperation in provid- John Teasdale, Mary V. Gold ing information that will strenthen our agri- (National Agricultural Library, culture for future generations. Such Beltsville, Md.), Aref Abdul-Baki cooperation is truly the hallmark of the (USDA/ARS, Beltsville, Md.) and sustainable agriculture movement. Robert Bugg (University of California, Davis, Calif.). Andy Clark, Coordinator The USDA Sustainable Agriculture Sustainable Agriculture Network Research and Education (SARE) program Beltsville, Md. funded the project as part of its May, 1998
BARLEY, a cool season grain, controls erosion and weeds in dry years and on light soils.
4 MANAGING COVER CROPS PROFITABLY FOREWORD
over crops slow erosion, improve soil, with great potential as cover crops in particular smother weeds, enhance nutrient and climates or cropping systems are accessible Cmoisture availability, help control many through publications and cover crop experts list- pests and bring a host of other benefits to your ed in the appendices. farm. At the same time, they can reduce costs, Many of the proven species described in the increase profits and even create new sources of book may be more familiar as forage or cash income.You’ll reap dividends on your cover crop crops.These crops have been adapted for use as investments for years,because their benefits accu- cover crops, which, strictly speaking, are not mulate over the long term. harvested. Our primary intent in this book is to Cover crops can make you a better neighbor, describe the use of these crops as cover crops. too. They prevent nutrient leaching and runoff, Because economics plays a major role in deciding and reduce or eliminate the off-site impacts of which crops farmers include in their rotations,we herbicides and pesticides. do mention some important alternative uses that There is a cover crop to fit just about every make growing cover crops even more rewarding. farming situation.The purpose of this book is to If you plant one of these cover crops and want help you find which ones are right for you. the option to harvest it as a cash crop, consult Since the Sustainable Agriculture Network other resources for more complete information. (SAN) published Managing Cover Crops We have tried to include enough information Profitably in 1992, more and more farmers have for you to select and use cover crops appropriate tried cover crops and are researching their use in to your operation.We recommend that you define farming systems. Other research by university your reasons for growing a cover crop—the sec- and government scientists, agricultural profes- tion, Selecting the Best Cover Crops for Your sionals and numerous farm organizations has Farm (p. 30) can help with this—and take as contributed more information about how cover much care in selecting and managing cover crops crops can enhance traditional cropping systems. as you would a cash crop. This book distills published and unpublished Regional and site-specific factors can compli- cover crop experiences into a reader-friendly cate cover crop management. No book can ade- reference tool for use by farmers and agricultural quately address all the variables that make up a professionals. Our writers reviewed published crop production system. Before planting a cover literature in scientific journals and talked with crop,learn as much as you can from this book and farmers and researchers using cover crops. The talk to others who are experienced with that dedicated help of a knowledgeable editorial board cover crop. Consult state and local resources for and reviewers throughout the country rounded specific information about adaptation and man- out the book. agement of a cover crop in your area. See also A publication of this scope cannot possibly Recommended Resources (p. 162). describe all the cover crops currently in use.We We hope that this updated and greatly expand- have selected the most proven crops with the ed edition of Managing Cover Crops Profitably widest possible application in the continental will lead to the successful use of cover crops on United States. Because of space and time limita- a wider scale as we continue to increase the tions, several very promising species were omit- sustainability of our farming systems. ted or not given complete coverage. Some of these are mentioned in Appendix B, Up-and- Andy Clark, Coordinator Coming Cover Crops (p.158).Many other species Sustainable Agriculture Network (SAN) May, 1998
FOREWORD 5 MANAGING COVER CROPS PROFITABLY SECOND EDITION
Acknowledgments...... 3 Berseem Clover ...... 87 Foreword...... 5 • Crimson-Berseem Clover Combo How to Use ...... 7 Works as Corn Underseeding ...... 89 Benefits of Cover Crops...... 9 • Nodulation: Match Inoculant to Selecting the Best Cover Crops Maximize N...... 92 for Your Farm...... 12 Cowpeas ...... 95 Building Soil Fertility and Tilth • Cowpeas Provide Elegant Solution with Cover Crops ...... 16 to Awkward Niche ...... 98 • Cover Crops Can Stabilize Your Soil . . . 19 Crimson Clover ...... 100 • How Much N? ...... 22 Field Peas ...... 105 Managing Pests with Cover Crops ...... 25 • Peas Do Double Duty • Georgia Cotton, Peanut Farmers for Kansas Farmer ...... 110 Use Cover Crops to Control Pests...... 26 Hairy Vetch ...... 112 • Select Covers that Balance Pests, • Vetch Beats Plastic ...... 118 Problems of Farm ...... 30 Medics...... 119 Crop Rotations with Cover Crops ...... 34 • Jess Counts on GEORGE for N and • Full-Year Covers Tackle Tough Weeds. . . 38 Organic Matter...... 121 Overview of Charts ...... 43 • Southern Spotted Bur Medic Offers Chart 1:Top Regional Cover Crop Species. . . 47 Reseeding Persistence ...... 122 Chart 2: Performance and Roles...... 48 Red Clover...... 127 Chart 3A: Cultural Traits...... 50 Subterranean Clover ...... 132 Chart 3B: Planting ...... 51 Sweetclover...... 139 Chart 4A: Potential Advantages ...... 52 • Sweetclover: Good Grazing, Chart 4B: Potential Disadvantages ...... 53 Great Green Manure ...... 142 White Clover ...... 147 Cover Crop Species Woollypod Vetch ...... 151 Overview of Nonlegume Cover Crops. . . 54 Annual Ryegrass ...... 55 Appendices Barley ...... 58 A.Testing Cover Crops on Your Farm...... 156 Oats...... 62 B. Up-and-Coming Cover Crops ...... 158 Cereal Rye ...... 65 C. Recommended Resources ...... 162 • Rye Smothers Weeds Before Soybeans . . 67 D. Seed Suppliers...... 166 Winter wheat ...... 72 E. Farming Organizations with • Wheat Boosts Income and Cover Crop Expertise ...... 170 Soil Protection...... 74 F.Regional Experts...... 173 • Wheat Offers High-Volume G. Citations Bibliography ...... 180 Weed Control Too ...... 75 H. Resources from the Sustainable Buckwheat ...... 77 Agriculture Network ...... 198 Sorghum Sudangrass ...... 80 I. Reader Response Form ...... 200 • Summer Covers Relieve Compaction . . 84 Overview of Legume Cover Crops ...... 85 Index ...... 201 Grass/Legume Mixtures Expand Possibilities ...... 86
6 MANAGING COVER CROPS PROFITABLY HOW TO USE THIS BOOK
hink of this book as a tool chest, not a heart of the book, the chapters on each cover cookbook.You won’t find the one simple crop. The chapters offer even more practical T recipe to meet your farming goals.You will descriptions of how to plant, manage, kill and find the tools to select and manage the best cover make the best use of each species. crops for the unique needs of your farm. Don’t overlook Up-and-Coming Cover Crops In this tool chest you will find helpful maps and (p. 158) that briefly describes promising but charts, detailed narratives about individual cover lesser known cover crops. One of them may be crop species, chapters about specific aspects of right for your farm. cover cropping and extensive appendices that will lead you to even more information. 3. With some particular cover crops in mind, The entire text of Managing Cover Crops step back and look at the big picture of how you Profitably, 2nd Edition is available on CD-ROM. can fit cover crops into your farming operations. The electronic version is a great resource for agri- Sit down with a highlighter and explore these cultural educators and computer-savvy producers chapters: because it allows users to search for crops with • Benefits of Cover Crops (p. 9) explains one click of the mouse—and download sections important cover crop roles such as reducing into new files for presentations and fact sheets. costs, improving soil and managing pests. To order, see p. 199. • Selecting the Best Cover Crops (p. 12) helps you evaluate your operation’s needs and niches 1. Start with Top Regional Cover Crop Species (seasonal, cash-crop related, and profit potential). (p. 47). This chart will help you narrow your Several examples show how to fit crops to search by listing the benefits you can expect from detailed situations. the top cover crops adapted to your region.You’ll • Building Soil Fertility and Tilth (p. 16) discover which are the best nitrogen (N) sources, shows how cover crops add organic matter and soil builders, erosion fighters, subsoil looseners, greater productivity to the biological, chemical weed fighters and pest fighters. and physical components of soil.
2. Next, find out more about the performance and management of the cover crops that look like good candidates for your farm. You’ll find two streams of information: • Charts quickly provide you with details to help you compare cover crops. Performance and Roles (p.48) lists ranges for N and dry matter pro- duction and ranks each cover crop’s potential for providing 11 benefits. Cultural Traits (p. 50) and Planting (p. 51) explains the growth, environ- mental tolerances, seeding preferences and estab- lishment costs for each crop. • Narratives. The Table of Contents (p. 6) and the page numbers accompanying each species in Charts 2, 3 and 4 direct you to the
SORGHUM-SUDANGRASS is a tall, warm-season grass that stifles weeds and decomposes to build soil organic matter.
HOW TO USE THIS BOOK 7 • Managing Pests with cover crops you want to Cover Crops (p. 25) try. The Appendices explores how cover include information crops change field to help you run reli- environments to able on-farm cover protect cash crops crop comparison from insects, dis- trials. You’ll also ease, weeds and find contact infor- nematodes. mation for cover • Crop Rotations crop experts in your (p. 34) explains how to region, seed suppliers integrate cover crops and and inoculant providers, cash crops in sequence from references to books and other year to year for optimum produc- academic papers cited in this book tivity from on-farm resources. and World Wide Web resources with more • Citations Bibliography (p. 180) lists many of cover crop information. the publications and specialists cited in the book. Citations within the book are numbered in paren- 5. Finally,share your cover crop plans with farmers theses. Refer to the numbered citation in the bib- in your area who have experience with cover liography if you want to dig deeper into a topic. crops. Your local Extension staff, regional IPM • Climatic Zone Maps inside the front and specialist or a sustainable farming group in your back covers help you understand differences in area may be able to provide contacts.Be sure to tap cover crop performance from location to loca- local wisdom.You can find out the cover crop prac- tion. You may find that some cover crops have tices that have worked traditionally, and the new performed well in tests far from where you farm, wrinkles or crops that innovative practitioners but under comparable climatic conditions. have discovered. The USDA Plant Hardiness Zone Map (inside front cover) shows whether a crop will Abbreviations used in this book survive the average winter in your area.We refer A = acre or acres to the USDA hardiness zones throughout the bu. = bushel or bushels book. DM = dry matter, or dry weight of plant material The U.S. Forest Service map, Ecoregions of F = (degrees) Fahrenheit the United States (inside back cover), served in. = inch or inches in part as the basis for the adaptation maps includ- K = potassium ed at the beginning of each cover crop chapter. lb. = pound or pounds This ecosystem map, while designed to classify N = nitrogen forest growth, shows localized climate differ- OM = organic matter ences, such as rainfall and elevation, within a P = phosphorus region. (See Bailey in Recommended Resources, p. = page p. 162). pp. = pages T = ton or tons 4. Now that you’ve tried out most of the tools, > = progression to another crop revisit the charts and narratives to zero in on the / = a mixture of crops growing together
Cultivars of SUBTERRANEAN CLOVER, a low-growing, reseeding annual legume, are adapted to many climates.
8 MANAGING COVER CROPS PROFITABLY BENEFITS OF COVER CROPS
over crops can boost your profits the first year you plant them. They can improve C your bottom line even more over the years as their soil-improving effects accumulate. Other benefits—reducing pollution,erosion and weed and insect pressure—may be difficult to quantify or may not appear in your financial statements. Identifying these benefits, however, can help you make sound, long-term decisions for your whole farm. What follows are some important ways to eval- Legume cover crops convert nitrogen gas in uate the economic and ecological aspects of the atmosphere into soil nitrogen that plants can cover crops. These significant benefits (detailed use. See Nodulation: Match Inoculant to below) vary by location and season, but at least Maximize N (p. 92). Crops grown in fields after two or three usually occur with any cover crop. legumes can take up at least 30 to 60 percent of Consult local farming groups and agencies with the N that the legume produced.You can reduce cover crop experience to figure more precise N fertilizer applications accordingly. For more crop budgets. information on nitrogen dynamics and how to cal- • Cut fertilizer costs culate fertilizer reductions, see Building Soil • Reduce the need for herbicides and other Fertility and Tilth with Cover Crops (p. 16). pesticides The N value of legumes is the easiest cover • Improve yields by enhancing soil health crop benefit to evaluate, both agronomically • Prevent soil erosion and economically. This natural fertility input • Conserve soil moisture alone can justify cover crop use. • Protect water quality • Hairy vetch boosted yield for no-till corn • Help safeguard personal health more than enough to cover its establishment Evaluate a cover crop’s impact as you would costs, a three-year study in Maryland showed. any other crop, balancing costs against returns in Further, the vetch can reduce economic risk and all forms. Don’t limit your calculations, however, usually will be more profitable than no-till corn to the target cover crop benefit. A cover often after a winter wheat cover crop. The result has several benefits. Many cover crops offer held true even if corn were priced as low as $1.80 harvest possibilities as forage, grazing or seed per bushel, or N fertilizer was applied at the rate that work well in systems with multiple crop of 180 lb. N/A (136). enterprises and livestock. • Medium red clover companion seeded with oats and hairy vetch had estimated fertilizer SPELLING IT OUT replacement value of 65 to 103 lb. N/A in a four- year study in Wisconsin, based on a two year rota- Here’s a quick overview of benefits you can grow tion of oats/legume > corn. Mean corn grain yield on your farm. Cover crops can: following these legumes was 163 bu./A for red clover and 167 bu./A for hairy vetch, compared Cut fertilizer costs by contributing N to cash with a no legume/no N fertilizer yield of 134 crops and by scavenging and mining soil nutrients. bu./A (328).
RED CLOVER is an annual or multi-year legume that improves topsoil. It is easily overseeded into standing crops or frostseeded into grains in early spring.
BENEFITS OF COVER CROPS 9 • Austrian winter peas, hairy vetch and beets in a Wyoming test. Using this brassica cover NITRO alfalfa can provide 80 to 100 percent of a crop after malting barley or silage corn substitut- subsequent potato crop’s nitrogen requirement, a ed profitably for chemical nematicides when study in the Pacific Northwest showed (322). nematode levels were moderate (184). • Fibrous-rooted cereal grains or grasses are A corn>rye>soybeans>wheat>hairy vetch rota- particularly good at scavenging excess nutri- tion that has reduced pesticide costs is at least ents—especially N—left in the soil after cash crop as profitable as conventional grain rotations harvest. Much of the N is without cover crops, an on- held within the plants until To estimate your potential going study in southeastern they decompose. Fall-seeded Pennsylvania shows (137). grains or grasses can absorb N fertilizer savings from a Fall-planted brassica cover up to 71 lb. N/A within three cover crop, see the sidebar, crops coupled with mechan- months of planting, a Mary- ical cultivation help potato land study showed (30). How Much N? (p. 22). growers with a long growing Addition of cover crops to season maintain marketable corn>soybean and corn>peanut>cotton rotations yield and reduce herbicide applications by 25 and appropriate timing of fertilizer application percent or more, a study in the inland Pacific usually reduce total N losses, without causing Northwest showed (322). yield losses in subsequent crops, a USDA-ARS computer modeling study confirms (293). Improve Yields by Enhancing Soil Health Cover crops improve soil by: Reduce the Need for Herbicides • Speeding infiltration of excess surface water Cover crops suppress weeds and reduce damage • Relieving compaction and improving structure by diseases, insects and nematodes. of overtilled soil Many cover crops effectively suppress weeds as: • Adding organic matter that encourages • A smother crop that outcompetes weeds for beneficial soil microbial life water and nutrients • Enhancing nutrient cycling • Residue or growing leaf canopy that blocks Building Soil Fertility and Tilth with Cover light, alters the frequency of light waves and Crops (p. 16) details the biological and chemical changes soil surface temperature processes of how cover crops improve soil health • A source of root exudates or compounds that and nutrient cycling. Leading soil-building crops provide natural herbicidal effects include rye (residue adds organic matter and Managing Pests with Cover Crops (p. 30) conserves moisture); sorghum-sudangrass (deep describes how cover crops can: penetrating roots can break compaction); and • Host beneficial microbial life that discourages ryegrass (stabilizes field roads,inter-row areas and disease borders when soil is wet). • Create an inhospitable soil environment for many soilborne diseases Prevent Soil Erosion • Encourage beneficial insect predators and Quick-growing cover crops hold soil in place, parasitoids that can reduce insect damage reduce crusting and protect against erosion due below economic thresholds to wind and rain. The aboveground portion of • Produce compounds that reduce nematode covers also helps protect soil from the impact of pest populations raindrops. Long-term use of cover crops increases • Encourage beneficial nematode species water infiltration and reduces runoff that can Using a rotation of malting barley>cover crop carry away soil. radish>sugar beets has successfully reduced sugar The key is to have enough stalk and leaf growth beet cyst nematodes to increase yield of sugar to guard against soil loss. Succulent legumes
10 MANAGING COVER CROPS PROFITABLY decompose quickly, especially in warm weather. living plants drawing too much moisture from the Winter cereals and many brassicas have a better soil in dry years. chance of overwintering in colder climates.These late-summer or fall-planted crops often put on sig- Protect Water Quality nificant growth even when temperatures drop By slowing erosion and runoff, cover crops into the 50s,and often are more winter-hardy than reduce nonpoint source pollution caused by legumes (302). sediments, nutrients and agricultural chemicals. In a no-till cotton system, use of cover crops By taking up excess soil nitrogen, cover crops such as winter wheat, crimson clover and hairy prevent N leaching to groundwater. Cover crops vetch can reduce soil erosion while maintaining also provide habitat for wildlife. high cotton yields, a Mississippi study shows (21). A rye cover crop scavenged from 25 to 100 percent of residual N from conventional and Conserve Soil Moisture no-till Georgia corn fields, one study showed. Up Residue from killed cover crops increas- to 180 lb. N/A had been applied. A barley es water infiltration and reduces evap- cover crop removed 64 percent of soil nitrogen oration, resulting in less moisture when applied N averaged 107 lb./A (177). stress during drought. Lightly incorporated cover crops serve Help Safeguard Personal Health dual roles. They trap surface By reducing reliance on agrichemi- water and add organic matter to cals for cash crop production, increase infiltration to the root cover crops help protect the zone. Especially effective at health of your family, neighbors covering the soil surface are and farm workers.They also help grass-type cover crops such as address community health and rye, wheat, and sorghum- ecological concerns arising from Sudangrass hybrid. Some water-effi- nonpoint source pollution attributed cient legumes such as medic and to farming activities. INDIANHEAD lentils provide cover crop benefits in dryland areas while Cumulative Benefits conserving more moisture than conven- You can increase the range of benefits tional bare fallow (316). by increasing the diversity of cover Timely spring termination of a cover crops grown, the frequency of use crop avoids the negative impact of between cash crops and the length of opposite water conditions: excess time that cover crops are growing in residue holding in too much mois- the field. ture for planting in wet years, or
WINTER WHEAT grows well in fall, then provides forage and protects soil over winter.
BENEFITS OF COVER CROPS 11 SELECTING THE BEST COVER CROPS FOR YOUR FARM by Marianne Sarrantonio
over crops provide many benefits, paper.For each field,pencil in current or probable but they’re not do-it-all “wonder crops.” rotations, showing when you typically seed crops CTo find a suitable cover crop or mix and when you harvest them. If possible, sketch in of covers: a rough graph showing average daily temperature • Clarify your primary needs during the timeline, and another for average rain- • Identify the best time and place for a cover fall.Add other key information, such as frost-free crop in your system periods and times of heavy labor or equipment • Test a few options demand. This book makes selection of cover crops a lit- Look for open periods in each field, open tle easier by focusing on some proven ones. spaces on your farm or opportunities in your sea- Thousands of species and varieties exist,however. sonal work schedule. Also consider ways to The steps that follow can help you find crops that extend or overlap cropping windows. will work best with a minimum of risk and Here are examples of common niches in some expense. systems, and some tips:
1. Identify Your Problem or Use Winter fallow niche. In many regions,seed win- Review Benefits of Cover Crops (p. 9) to decide ter covers at least six weeks before a hard frost. what you want most from a cover crop. This Winter cereals are an exception and can be plant- simplifies your search. ed a little later.If ground cover needs are minimal, Some common goals for covers are to: plant rye until the frost period for successful over- • Provide nitrogen wintering, although N recycling will be limited. • Add organic matter You might seed a cover right after harvesting a • Improve soil structure summer crop, when the weather is still mild. In • Reduce soil erosion cooler climates, consider extending the window • Provide weed control by overseeding (some call this underseeding) a • Manage nutrients shade-tolerant cover before cash crop harvest. • Furnish moisture-conserving mulch White clover, annual ryegrass, rye, hairy vetch, Having one or two secondary goals can narrow crimson clover, red clover and sweetclover toler- the hunt when comparable covers could satisfy a ate some shading. primary role. You might want habitat for benefi- If overseeding, irrigate immediately if possible, cial organisms, better traction during harvest, or seed just before a soaking rain. Species with faster drainage or another benefit. small, round seeds, such as clovers, don’t need a lot of moisture to germinate and can work their 2. Identify the Niche way through tiny gaps in residue. Sometimes it’s obvious where and when to use a If you want to harvest a cereal grain cover crop, cover crop.You might want some nitrogen before interseeding a legume might increase disease a corn crop,or a perennial ground cover in a vine- risks due to lower air circulation or insect pest yard or orchard to reduce erosion or improve risk,so plan accordingly.Changing seeding rate or weed control. For some goals, such as building the rotation sequence may lessen this risk. soil, it may be hard to decide where and when to To ensure adequate sunlight for the cover crop, schedule cover crops. overseed before full canopy closure of the primary Look at your rotation first. Make a timeline of crop (at last cultivation of field corn, for example) 18 to 24 monthly increments across a piece of or a few weeks before the cash crop starts to die.
12 MANAGING COVER CROPS PROFITABLY Expect excessive field traffic around harvest- Properly managed, living mulches give many time? Choose tough, low-growing covers such growers year-round erosion protection,weed con- as grasses or clovers. Limit traffic or delay a field trol, nutrient cycling and even some nitrogen if operation to allow for cover crop establishment. they include a legume. Some tillage, mowing or Another option could be a reseeding winter herbicides can help manage the mulch (to keep it annual that dies back and drops seed each spring from using too much soil moisture, for example) but reestablishes in fall. Subclovers reseed well before crops are strip-tilled into the cover or in regions south of Hardiness Zone 6. Shorter- residue.White clover could be a good choice for season crimson clovers—especially varieties with sweet corn and tomatoes. Perennial ryegrass or a high hard-seed percentage that germinate over other nonaggressive turfgrasses work for beans, an extended period—work well in the Southeast tomatoes and other vegetables. where moisture is sufficient. Creating new niches. Have you honed a rota- Summer fallow niche. Many vegetable rota- tion that seems to have few open time slots? Plant tions present cover crop opportunities—and a cover in strips alternating with your annual veg- challenges. When double cropping, you might etable, herb or field crop. Switch the strips the have fields with a three- to eight-week summer next year. Mow the strips periodically and blow fallow. Quick-growing summer the topgrowth onto adjoining annuals provide erosion control, Look for open periods cash crops as mulch. In a bed weed management, organic mat- system, rotate out every third or ter and perhaps some N. in each field or open fourth bed for a soil-building Consider overseeding into a spaces on your farm. cover crop. spring crop with buckwheat, Another option: Band a cover millet or sorghum-Sudangrass, or or some insect-attracting shrubs a warm-season legume such as cowpeas. Or till around fields or along hedgerows to suppress out strips in the cover crop for planting a fall weeds or provide beneficial habitat where you vegetable crop and control the remaining cover can’t grow cash crops. between the crop rows with mowing, partial cultivation or herbicide spraying. 3. Describe the Niche Refer to your timeline chart and ask questions Small grain rotation niche. Companion seed a such as: winter annual cover crop with a spring grain, • How will I seed the cover? or frost seed a cover into winter grains. Soil • What’s the weather likely to be then? freezing and thawing pulls seed into the soil and • What will soil temperature and moisture helps germination. Another option if soil conditions be like? moisture isn’t a limiting factor in your region: • How vigorous will other crops (or pests) be? broadcast a cover before the grain enters boot • Should the cover be low-growing and stage (when seedheads start elongating) later in spreading, or tall and vigorous? spring. • What weather extremes and field traffic must it tolerate? Full-year improved fallow niche. To rebuild • Will it winterkill in my area? fertility or organic matter over a longer period, • Should it winterkill, to meet my goals? perennials or biennials—or mixtures—require • What kind of regrowth can I expect? the least maintenance. Spring-seeded yellow • How do I kill it and plant into it? blossom sweetclover flowers in summer of • Will I have the time to make this work? Year 2, has a deep taproot and gives plenty of • What’s my contingency plan—and risks—if the aboveground biomass. Also consider perennial crop doesn’t establish or doesn’t die on schedule? forages recommended for your area. • Do I have the needed equipment and labor?
SELECTING THE BEST COVER CROPS 13 4. Select the Best Cover Crop ing, reseeding grasses often suitable for orchard You have a goal and a niche. Now specify the floors. One of these might fill the bill with a traits a cover crop would need to work well. reseeding, winter annual legume such as crimson clover, rose clover, subclover, an annual vetch or Example 1. A sloping orchard needs a ground an annual medic, depending on your climate. cover to reduce erosion. You’d like it to con- tribute N and organic matter and attract ben- Example 2. A dairy lacks adequate storage in eficial organisms but not rodents,nematodes or fall and winter for the manure it generates, other pests. The cover can’t use too much which exceeds the nutrient needs for its silage water or tie up nutrients at key periods. Too corn and grass/legume hay rotation. much N might stimulate excessive leaf growth or The cover crop needs to: prevent hardening off before winter. Finally you • establish effectively after (or tolerate) silage want easy maintenance. corn harvest The cover crop should: • take up a lot of N and P in fall and hold it until • be a perennial or reseeding annual spring • be low-growing, needing minimal management For this dairy scenario, rye is often recom- • use water efficiently mended. Other cereal grains or brassicas could • have a soil-improving root system work if planted early enough. • release some nutrients during the year, but not too much N Example 3. In a moderate rainfall region after • not harbor or attract pests small grain harvest in late summer, you want For this orchard scenario, white clover is a soil-protecting winter cover that can supply probably the best option north of Zone 8. A N for no-till corn next spring. You want to kill mixture of low-growing legumes or a legume and the cover without herbicides. grass mix could also work. In warm regions, low- You need a legume that: growing clovers such as strawberry clover and • can be drilled in late summer and put on a lot white clover work well together, although these of fall growth species may attract pocket gophers. BLANDO • will overwinter brome and annual ryegrass are two quick-grow- • will fix a lot of N • can be mow-killed shortly before (or after) corn planting • could provide some weed-controlling, moisture-conserving residue Hairy vetch works well in the Northeast, Midwest and parts of the mid-South. Mixing it with rye or another cereal improves its weed- management and moisture-conservation poten- tial.Crimson clover may be an appropriate choice for the southeastern Piedmont. Austrian winter pea could be considered, alone or in a mix, in coastal plain environments. Where grain harvest occurs in late spring or early summer, LANA wool- lypod vetch might be a better choice.
HAIRY VETCH is an winter annual legume that grows slowly in fall, then fixes a lot of N in spring.
14 MANAGING COVER CROPS PROFITABLY 5. Settle for the Best Available Cover. . . It’s likely the “wonder crop” you want doesn’t exist. One or more species could come close, as the above examples indicate. Top Regional Cover Crop Species (p. 47) can provide a starting point. Check with regional experts. Keep in mind that you can mix two or more species.
6. . . .Or Build a Rotation Around Cover Crops. It’s hard to decide in advance every field’s crops, planting dates, fieldwork or management specifics. One alternative is to find out which cover crops provide the best results on your farm, then build a rotation around those covers. See Full-Year Covers Tackle Tough Weeds (p. 38). With this “reverse” strategy, you plan covers according to their optimum field timing, and then determine the best windows for cash crops. A Example 4. After a spring broccoli crop, you cover crop’s strengths help you decide which need a weed-suppressing cover that adds N cash crops would benefit the most. and organic matter, and perhaps mulch, into For now,however,you probably want to fit one which you will no-till seed fall lettuce or spinach. or more cover crops into your existing rotations. You want a cover that: The charts and narratives in this book can help • is very versatile you select some of the most suitable species for • grows fast in hot weather your farming system and objectives. See Crop • can be overseeded into broccoli Rotations with Cover Crops (p. 34) to get you • germinates on the soil surface under dry thinking more. When you’ve narrowed your conditions choices, refer to Appendix A, Testing Cover Crops • fixes N on Your Farm (p. 156) for some straightforward • persists until you’re ready to kill it tips on what to do next. Here, a quick-growing, warm-season legume such as cowpeas may work, especially if you can irrigate Adapted from Northeast Cover Crop Handbook to hasten establishment during dry conditions. by Marianne Sarrantonio, Rodale Institute, 1994.
WINTER (cereal) RYE is an annual grain that prevents soil and wind erosion. Its killed vegetation suppresses weeds for no-till planting.
SELECTING THE BEST COVER CROPS 15 BUILDING SOIL FERTILITY AND TILTH WITH COVER CROPS by Marianne Sarrantonio
oil is an incredibly complex substance. It has EROSION PROTECTION physical and chemical properties that allow Sit to sustain living organisms—not just plant Erosion of topsoil occurs on many farms, depriv- roots and earthworms,but hundreds of thousands ing fields of the most fertile portion that contains of different insects, wormlike creatures and the highest percentage of organic matter and microorganisms. When these organisms are in nutrients. Cover crops can play a major role in balance, your soil cycles nutrients efficiently, fighting soil erosion. stores water and drains the excess, and maintains A raindrop falling at high speed can dislodge an environment in which plants can thrive. soil particles and cause them to move as far as 6 To recognize that a soil can be healthy, one feet (28). Once a soil particle is loose, it is much has only to think of the soil as a living entity. It more vulnerable to being carried away by breathes, it transports and transforms nutrients, it running water. Any aboveground soil cover can interacts with its environment, and it can even puri- take some of the punch out of a heavy rainfall fy itself and improve over time. If you view soil as a simply by acting as a cushion for raindrops. dynamic part of your farming system, unsustainable A cover crop also can: crop management practices amount to soil neglect. • Slow the action of moving water just by That neglect could worsen as the soil sickens and creating an obstacle course of leaves, stems loses its life functions one by one. and roots through which the water must Regardless of how healthy or alive your soil is maneuver on its way downhill right now, cover crops can play a vital role in • Increase the soil’s ability to absorb and hold ensuring that your soil provides a strong founda- water, thereby preventing large quantities of tion for your farming system. While the most water from moving across the soil surface common reasons for including cover crops in • Help stabilize soil particles in the cover crop a farming system may relate to the current root system season, the continued practice of cover cropping The reduction in soil erosion due to cover becomes an investment in building healthy soil cropping will be roughly proportional to the over the long term. amount of cover on the soil. The Universal Soil Cover crops improve soil in a number of ways. Loss Equation developed by the USDA Soil Protection against soil loss from erosion is per- Conservation Service (now the Natural Resources haps the most obvious soil benefit of cover crops, Conservation Service) predicts that a soil cover of but providing organic matter is a more long-term just 40 percent when winter arrives can reduce and equally important goal. Cover crops con- erosion substantially until spring. tribute indirectly to overall soil health by catching It’s worthwhile to get covers established early, nutrients before they can leach out of the soil pro- to ensure that maximum soil cover develops file or by adding nitrogen to the soil.Their roots before winter rains. Consider overseeding covers can even help unlock some nutrients, converting at layby cultivation, aerial seeding before harvest them to more available forms. Cover crops pro- or planting as soon as possible after harvest. It’s vide habitat or a food source for some important also a good idea to maintain year-round soil cover soil organisms, break up compacted layers in the whenever possible. soil and help dry out wet soils.
16 MANAGING COVER CROPS PROFITABLY ORGANIC MATTER ADDITIONS After the microorganisms have devoured the portions of the active fraction that are easiest to The benefits of organic matter include improved digest, a more dedicated subset of these microor- soil structure, increased infiltration and ganisms will start munching on the more com- water-holding capacity, increased cation plex and tough material, such as celluloses and exchange capacity (the ability of the soil to act lignins,the structural materials of plants.Since cel- as a short-term storage bank for positively charged lulose is tougher than simple sugars, and lignin plant nutrients) and more efficient storage of breaks down very slowly,they contribute more to nutrients. Without organic matter, you have no the humus or stable fraction. Humus is responsi- soil to speak of, only a dead mixture of ground-up ble for giving the soil that rich, dark, spongy feel- and weathered rocks. ing and for properties such as water retention and Organic matter includes thousands of different cation exchange capacity. substances derived from decayed leaves, roots, Plant materials that are succulent and rich microorganisms, manure and even groundhogs in proteins and sugars will release nutrients rapid- that died in their burrows. These substances ly but leave behind little long-term organic matter. function in different ways to build healthy soil. Plant materials that are woodier or more Different plants leave behind different kinds of fibrous will release nutrients much more slowly, organic matter as they decompose,so your choice but will promote more stable organic matter, or of cover crop will largely determine which soil humus, leading to better soil physical conditions, benefits you will receive. increased nutrient-holding capacity and higher Soil scientists may argue over how to classify cation exchange capacity. the various soil organic components. Most will In general, annual legumes are succulent. agree, however,that there is a portion that can be They release nitrogen and other nutrients quick- called the “active” fraction, and one that might ly through the active fraction, but are not very be called the “stable” fraction, which is roughly effective at building up humus. Long-term use equivalent to humus.There are many categories of succulent annual legumes can increase in between the active and stable fractions. soil humus, however, as recent research The active fraction represents the most easily suggests (354). decomposed parts of soil organic matter. It tends Grains and other grasses and nonlegumes will to be rich in simple sugars and proteins and contribute to humus production, but won’t consists largely of recently added residues, micro- release nutrients very rapidly or in large bial cells and the simpler waste products from quantities if incorporated as they approach matu- microbial decay. rity. Perennial legumes such as white and red Because microorganisms, like human organ- clover may fall in both categories—their leaves isms, crave sweet stuff, compounds containing will break down quickly, but their root systems simple sugars disappear quickly. Proteins also are may become tough and fibrous and can con- selected quickly from the menu of edible soil tribute to humus accumulation. goodies. When these compounds are digested, many of the nutrients that they contain are Cover Crops Help “Glue” Soil released into the soil. Proteins are nitrogen-rich, As soil microorganisms digest plant material, they so the active fraction is responsible for the produce some compounds in addition to the release of most N, as well as some K, P and other active and stable fractions of the organic matter. nutrients, from organic matter into the soil. One group of these by-products is known as The easily decomposed proteins and sugars burn polysaccharides.These are complex sugars that up almost completely as energy sources, and act as glues in the soil to cement small soil parti- don’t leave much behind to contribute to organic cles into clusters or aggregates. Many farmers matter building. use the term “crumb” to describe soil clusters
BUILDING SOIL FERTILITY AND TILTH 17 about the size of a grain of rice. A well- down of soil aggregates and the poor soil struc- aggregated or “crumby” soil—not to be confused ture often seen in overtilled soil. with someone else’s crummy or depleted soil— When adding cover crops to a system, mini- has good aeration. It allows better infiltration and mize tillage to maximize the long-term soil bene- retention of water. fits. Many of the cover crops discussed in this Cover crops can promote good aggregation in book are ones you can seed into growing crops or the soil through increased production of these no-till plant into crop residues. Otherwise, the and other microbial glues, recent research has gain in organic matter may be counteracted by shown. See Cover Crops Can Stabilize Your Soil higher decomposition rates. (p. 19). Well-aggregated soils also are less prone to compaction, which has been shown to reduce TIGHTENING THE NUTRIENT LOOP yields of vegetables such as snap beans, cabbage and cucumber by 50 percent or more (371). In addition to reducing topsoil erosion and improv- As they decompose, leguminous cover crops ing soil structure, cover crops enhance nutrient seem to be better than grasses for production of cycling in your farming system by taking up nutri- polysaccharides (6). However, polysaccharides ents that otherwise might leach out of the soil pro- will decompose in a matter of months, so their file. These excess nutrients have the potential to aggregation effect is likely to last only the season pollute groundwater or local streams and ponds. after the use of the cover crop. Of the common plant nutrients, nitrogen in the Grass species also promote good aggregation, nitrate form is the most water-soluble and there- but by a different mechanism. Grasses have a fore the most vulnerable to leaching. Anytime ‘fibrous’ root system—made of numerous fine soil is bare and appreciable rain falls, nitrates are roots spreading out from the base of the plant. on the move. Nitrate can be present in the soil These roots may release compounds that help at the end of a cropping season if the crop did not aggregate the soil between roots. use all the N applied. Decomposing organic mat- Organic matter builds up very slowly in the ter (including plant residues, compost and animal soil. A soil with 3 percent organic matter might manures) also can release nitrate-N, as long as the only increase to 4 percent after a decade or soil temperature is above freezing. Even in a field more of soil building. The benefits of increased where the yearly application of N is well-suited to organic matter, however, are likely to be apparent crop needs, nitrates can accumulate after crops long before increased quantities are detectable. are harvested and leach when it rains. Some, such as enhanced aggregation, water infil- Cover crops reduce nitrate leaching in two tration rates and nutrient release,will be apparent ways. They soak up available nitrate for their the first season; others may take several years to own needs. They also use some soil moisture, become noticeable (354). reducing the amount of water available to leach Your tillage method is an important considera- nutrients. tion when using cover crops to build soil,because The best cover crops to use for nitrate conser- tillage will affect the rate of organic matter accu- vation are nonlegumes that form deep, extensive mulation. It is difficult to build up organic root systems quickly after cash crops are matter under conventional tillage regimes. harvested. For much of the continental U.S., cere- Tillage speeds up organic matter decomposition al rye is the best choice for catching nutrients by exposing more surface area to oxygen, warm- after a summer crop. Its cold tolerance is a big ing and drying the soil, and breaking residue into advantage that allows rye to continue to grow in smaller pieces with more surfaces that can be late fall and put down roots to a depth of three attacked by decomposers. Like fanning a fire, feet or more. Where winters are mild, rye can tillage rapidly “burns up” or “oxidizes” the fuel, grow through the winter months. which in this case is organic matter. The Research with soil high in residual N in the resulting loss of organic matter causes the break- mid-Atlantic’s coastal plain showed that cereal rye
18 MANAGING COVER CROPS PROFITABLY Cover Crops Can Stabilize Your Soil The more you use cover crops, the better phosphorus that plants obtain. In return, the your soil tilth, research continues to show. fungi receive energy in the form of sugars One reason is that cover crops, especially that plants produce in their leaves and send legumes, encourage populations of beneficial down to the roots. fungi and other microorganisms that help Growing a cover crop increases the bind soil aggregates. abundance of mycorrhizal spores. Legumes The fungi, called mycorrhizae, produce a in particular can contribute to mycorrhizal water-insoluble protein known as glomalin, diversity and abundance, because their roots which catches and glues together particles of tend to develop large populations of these organic matter, plant cells, bacteria and other beneficial fungi. fungi, recent research suggests (372). By having their own mycorrhizal fungi and Glomalin may be one of the most important by promoting mycorrhizal relationships in substances in promoting and stabilizing soil subsequent crops, cover crops therefore can aggregates. play a key role in improving soil tilth.The Most plant roots, not just those of cover overall increase in glomalin production also crops, develop beneficial mycorrhizal could help explain why cover crops can relationships.The fungi send out rootlike improve water infiltration into soil and extensions called hyphae, which take up enhance storage of water and soil nutrients, water and soil nutrients to help feed plants. even when there has been no detectable In low-phosphorus soils, for example, the increase in the amount of soil organic hyphae can increase the amount of matter.
took up more than 70 lb. N/A in fall when plant- nutrients can be brought up from deeper soil lay- ed by October 1. Other grasses, including wheat, ers by any deep-rooted cover crop.The nutrients oats, barley and ryegrass, were only able to take are then released back into the active organic mat- up about half that amount in fall. Legumes were ter when the cover crop dies and decomposes. practically useless for this purpose in the Although phosphorus (P) doesn’t generally Chesapeake Bay study (30). Legumes tend to leach, as it is only slightly water-soluble, cover establish slowly in fall and are mediocre N crops may play a role in increasing its availability scavengers, as they can fix much of their own N. in the soil. Some covers, such as buckwheat and To maximize N uptake and prevent leaching, lupins, are thought to secrete acids into the soil plant nonlegumes as early as possible. In the that put P into a more soluble, plant-usable form. above study, rye took up only 15 lb. N/A when Some cover crops enhance P availability in planting was delayed until November. It is impor- another manner. The roots of many common tant to give cover crops the same respect as any cover crops, particularly legumes, house benefi- other crop in the rotation and plant them in a cial fungi known as mycorrhizae. The mycor- timely manner. rhizal fungi have evolved efficient means of absorbing P from the soil, which they pass on to Not Just Nitrogen Cycling their plant host.The filaments (hyphae) of these Cover crops help bring other nutrients back into fungi effectively extend the root system and help the upper soil profile from deep soil layers. the plants tap more soil P. Calcium and potassium are two macronutrients Keeping phosphorus in an organic form is the with a tendency to travel with water, though not most efficient way to keep it cycling in the soil. generally on the express route with N. These So the return of any plant or animal residue to the
BUILDING SOIL FERTILITY AND TILTH 19 soil helps maintain P availability. Cover crops equal—some are genetically inferior when it help retain P in your fields by reducing erosion. comes to fixation. Beans (Phaseolus spp.) are notoriously incapable of a good symbiotic rela- Adding Nitrogen tionship and are rarely able to fix much more than One of nature’s most gracious gifts to plants and 40 lb. N/A in a whole season. Cowpeas (Vigna soil is the way that legumes, with the help of rhi- unguiculata) and vetches (Vicia spp.), on the zobial bacteria, can add N to enrich your soil. If other hand, are generally capable of high fixation you are not familiar with how this remarkable rates. Check Chart 2 Performances and Roles process works, see Nodulation: Match Inoculant (p. 48) and the sections on individual cover crops to Maximize N (p. 92). for information about their N-fixation potential. The nitrogen provided by N-fixation is used Even under the best of conditions, legumes efficiently in natural ecosystems, thanks to the rarely fix more than 80 percent of the nitrogen soil’s complex web of interacting physical, chem- they need to grow,and may only fix as much as 40 ical and biological processes. In an agricultural or 50 percent. The legume removes the rest of system, however, soil and crop management what it needs from the soil like any other plant. factors often interfere with nature’s ultra-efficient Legumes have to feed the bacteria to get them to use of organic or inorganic N. Learning a bit work, so if there is ample nitrate already available about the factors affecting N-use efficiency from in the soil,a legume will remove much of that first legume plants will help build the most sustainable before expending the energy to get N-fixation cropping system possible within your constraints. going. In soils with high N fertility, legumes may fix little or no nitrogen.See How Much N? (p.22). How Much N is Fixed? While it is tempting to think of legume nodules A number of factors determine how much of the as little fertilizer factories pumping N into the N in your legume came from “free” N, fixed from surrounding soil, that isn’t what happens. The N2 gas: fixed N is almost immediately shunted up into the • Is the symbiosis (the interdependence of stems and leaves of the growing legume to form the rhizobia and the plant roots) effective? See proteins, chlorophyll and other N-containing Nodulation: Match Inoculant to Maximize N (p. compounds.The fixed nitrogen will not become 92). Use the correct rhizobial inoculant for the available to the next crop until the legume legume you’re growing. Make sure it’s fresh, was decomposes. Consequently, if the aboveground stored properly, and that you apply it with an part of the legume is removed for hay,the majori- effective sticking agent. Otherwise, there will be ty of the fixed nitrogen also leaves the field. few nodules and N-fixation will be low. What about the legume roots? Under condi- • Is the soil fertile? N-fixation requires iron, sul- tions favoring optimal N fixation, a good rule of fur and molybdenum to function properly. Soils thumb is to think of the nitrogen left in the plant depleted of these micronutrients will not support roots (15 to 30 percent of plant N) as being efficient fixation. Tissue testing your cash crops roughly equivalent to the amount the legume can help you decide if you need to adjust removed directly from the soil, and the amount in micronutrient levels. the stems and leaves as being equivalent to what • Is the soil getting enough air? N-fixation was fixed. requires that N-rich air get to the legume roots. Annual legumes that are allowed to flower and Waterlogging or compaction hampers the move- mature will transport a large portion of their ment of air into the soil. Deep-rooted cover crops biomass nitrogen into the seeds or beans. Also, can help alleviate subsoil compaction (371). once the legume has stopped actively growing, it • Is the pH adequate? Rhizobia generally will will shut down the N-fixing symbiosis. In annual not live long in soils below pH 5. legumes this occurs at the time of flowering; no • Does the legume/rhizobial pair have high fix- additional N gain will occur after that point. ation potential? Not all legumes were created Unless you want a legume to reseed itself, it’s
20 MANAGING COVER CROPS PROFITABLY generally a good idea to kill a legume cover crop when 60 percent of the soil pores are filled in the early- to mid-blossom stage. You’ll have with water, and declines significantly when mois- obtained maximum legume N and need not delay ture levels are higher or lower (193). This 60 planting of the following cash crop any further, percent water-filled pore space roughly corre- aside from any period you may want for sponds to field capacity, or the amount of water residue decomposition as part of your seedbed left in the soil when it is allowed to drain for 24 preparation. hours after a good soaking rain. Microbes are sensitive to soil chemistry as well. How Nitrogen is Released Most soil bacteria need a pH of between 6 and 8 How much N will soil really acquire from a to perform at peak;fungi (the slow decomposers) legume cover crop? Let’s take it from the point of are still active at very low pH.Soil microorganisms a freshly killed, annual legume, cut down in its also need most of the same nutrients as plants prime at mid-bloom. The management and require, so low-fertility soils support smaller pop- climatic events following the death of that legume ulations of primary decomposers, compared with will greatly affect the amount and timing of N high-fertility soils. Don’t expect N-release rates or release from the legume to the soil. fertilizer replacement values for a given cover Most soil bacteria will feast on and rapidly crop to be identical in fields of different fertility. decompose green manures such as annual Many of these environmental factors are out of legumes, which contain many simple sugars and your direct control in the near term. Management proteins as energy sources. Soil bacteria love to factors such as fertilization, liming and tillage, party and when there is lots to eat, they do some- however, also influence production and availabili- thing that no party guest you’ve ever invited can ty of legume N. do—they reproduce themselves, rapidly and repeatedly,doubling their population in as little as Tillage, No-Tillage and N-Cycling seven days under field conditions (246). Even a Tillage affects decomposition of plant residues in relatively inactive soil can come to life quickly a number of ways. First, any tillage increases soil with addition of a delectable green manure. contact with residues and increases the microbes’ The result can be a very rapid and large release access to them. The plow layer is a hospitable of nitrate into the soil within a week of the green environment for microbes, as they’re sheltered manure’s demise. This N release is more rapid from extremes of temperature and moisture. when covers are plowed down than when left on Second, tillage breaks the residue into smaller the surface. As much as 140 lb. N/A has been pieces, providing more edges for microbes to measured 7 to 10 days after plowdown of hairy munch. Third, tillage will temporarily decrease vetch (303). Green manures that are less protein- the density of the soil, generally allowing it to rich (N-rich) will take longer to release N. drain and therefore warm up more quickly. All Those that are old and fibrous or woody are gen- told, residues incorporated into the soil tend to erally left for hard-working but somewhat slug- decompose and release nutrients much faster gish fungi to convert slowly to humus over the than those left on the surface, as in a no-till sys- years, gradually releasing small amounts of tem.That’s not necessarily good news, however. nutrients. A real challenge of farming efficiently is to keep Other factors contribute significantly to how as much of the N as possible in a stable, storable quickly a green manure releases its N. Weather form until it’s needed by the crop. The best has a huge influence. The soil organisms respon- storage form of N is the organic form: the unde- sible for decomposition work best at warm composed residue, the humus or the microorgan- temperatures and are less energetic during cool isms themselves. spring months. Let’s consider the N contained in the microbes. Soil moisture also has a dramatic effect. Nitrogen is a nutrient the microbes need for build- Research shows that soil microbial activity peaks ing proteins and other compounds. Carbon-con-
BUILDING SOIL FERTILITY AND TILTH 21 How Much N? To find out if you might need more N than If the stand has less than 100 percent your green manure supplied, you need to groundcover, multiply by (the percent ground estimate the amount of N in your cover crop. cover / 100). In this example, for 60 percent To do this, assess the total yield of the green groundcover, you would obtain: manure and the percentage of N in the plants 3,800 x (60/100) = 2,280 lb. just before they die. Keep in mind that these are rough To estimate yield, take cuttings from several estimates to give you a quick guide for the areas in the field, dry and weigh them. Use a productivity of your green manure.To know yardstick or metal frame of known dimensions the exact percent N in your plant tissue, you and clip the plants at ground level within the would have to send it to a lab for analysis. known area. Dry them out in the sun for a few Even with a delay for processing, the results consecutive days, or use an oven at about 140 could be helpful for the crop if you use split F for 24 to 48 hours until they are “crunchy applications of N.Testing is always a good idea, dry.”Use the following equation to determine as it can help you refine your N estimates for per-acre yield of dry matter: subsequent growing seasons. Yield (lb.)/Acre = Total weight of dried samples (lb.) 43,560 sq. ft. The following rules of thumb may help here: X # square feet you sampled 1 Acre • Annual legumes typically have between While actually sampling is more accurate, 3.5 and 4 percent N in their aboveground you can estimate your yield from the height of parts prior to flowering (for young material, your green manure crop and its percent use the higher end of the range), and 3 to 3.5 groundcover. Use these estimators: percent at flowering.After flowering, N in the At 100 percent groundcover and 6-inch leaves decreases quickly as it accumulates in height*, most nonwoody legumes will contain the growing seeds. roughly 2,000 lb./A of dry matter. For each * For cereal rye, the height relationship is a bit different. Cereal rye additional inch, add 150 lb. So, a legume that is weighs approximately 2,000 lb./A of dry matter at an 8-inch height 18 inches tall and 100 percent groundcover and 100 percent groundcover. For each additional inch, add 150 will weigh roughly: lb., as before, and multiply by (percent groundcover/100). For most small grains and other annual grasses, start with Inches >6: 18 in.–6 in. = 12 in. 2,000 lb./A at 6 inches and 100 percent ground cover.Add x 150 lb./in.: 12 in. x 150 lb./in. = 1,800 lb. 300 lb. for each additional inch and multiply by (percent Add 2,000 lb.: 2,000 lb. + 1,800 lb. = 3,800 lb. groundcover/100).
taining compounds such as sugars are mainly to eat. So any newly released or existing mineral energy sources, which the microorganisms use as N in soil gets scavenged by new bacteria. fuel to live. The process of burning this fuel Materials with a high carbon to nitrogen (C:N) sends most of the carbon back into the atmos- ratio, such as mature grass cover crops, straw or phere as carbon dioxide, or CO2. any fibrous, woody residue, have a low N con- Suppose a lot of new food is suddenly put into tent.They can “tie up”soil N, keeping it immo- the soil system, as when a green manure is bilized (and unavailable) to crops until the plowed down. Bacteria will expand their carbon “fuel supply” starts depleting.Tie-up may populations quickly to tap the carbon-based last for several weeks in the early part of the energy that’s available. All the new bacteria, growing season, and crop plants may show the though, will need some N, as well as other nutri- yellowing characteristic of N deficiencies. That ents,for body building before they can even begin is why it often makes sense to wait one to three
22 MANAGING COVER CROPS PROFITABLY • For perennial legumes that have a between 10 and 40 lb. N/A for each 1 percent significant number of thick, fibrous or woody organic matter. Cold, wet clays will be at the stems, reduce these estimates by 1 percent. low end of the scale and warm, well-drained • Most cover crop grasses contain 2 to 3 soils will be at the high end.You also may percent N before flowering and 1.5 to 2.5 receive benefits from last year’s manure, green percent after flowering. manure or compost application. • Other covers, such as brassicas and Other tools could help you refine your buckwheat, will generally be similar to, or nitrogen needs. On-farm test strips of cover slightly below,grasses in their N content. crops receiving different N rates would be an To put it all together: example. Refer to Appendix A, Testing Cover Total N in green manure (lb./A) = yield (lb./A) x % N Crops on Your Farm (p. 156) for some tips on 100 designing an on-farm trial. In some regions, a pre-sidedress N test in spring could help you To estimate what will be available to your estimate if supplemental N will be cost- crop this year, divide this quantity of N by: effective. Bear in mind that pre-sidedress • 2, if the green manure will be testing does not work well when fresh plant conventionally tilled; residues have been turned in—too much • 4, if it will be left on the surface in a no-till microbial interference relating to N tie-up may system in Northern climates; give misleading results. • 2, if it will be left on the surface in a no-till For more information on determining system in Southern climates. your N from green manures and other Bear in mind that in cold climates, N will amendments, see the Northeast Cover Crop mineralize more slowly than in warm climates, Handbook, or the Farmers’ Fertilizer as discussed above. So these are gross estimates Handbook, listed in Appendix C (p. 164). and a bit on the conservative side. —Marianne Sarrantonio, Ph.D. Of course, cover crops will not be the only N sources for your crops.Your soil will release
weeks after killing a low-N cover before planting and, as stated earlier, the N is mineralized more the next crop, or to supplement with a more rapidly from mixtures than from pure grass. A readily available N source when a delay is not fall-seeded mixture will adjust to residual soil N practical. levels.When the N levels are high, the grass will Annual legumes have low C:N ratios, such dominate and when N levels are low, the legume as 10:1 or 15:1. When pure stands of annual will dominate the mixtures.This can be an effec- legumes are plowed down,the N tie-up may be so tive management tool to reduce leaching while brief you will never know it occurred. making the N more available to the next crop. Mixed materials,such as legume-grass mixtures, may cause a short tie-up, depending on the C:N Potential Losses ratio of the mixture. Some N storage in the micro- A common misunderstanding about using green bial population may be advantageous in keeping manure crops is that the N is used more excess N tied up when no crop roots are there to efficiently because it’s from a plant source. This absorb it. is not necessarily true. Nitrogen can be lost from Fall-planted mixtures are more effective in a green manure system almost as easily as from immobolizing excess soil N than pure legumes chemical fertilizers, and in comparable amounts.
BUILDING SOIL FERTILITY AND TILTH 23 The reason is that the legume organic N may be release of N so it’s not as vulnerable to loss. + converted to ammonium (NH4 ), then to ammonia Consider also that some portion of the N in the - (NH3) or nitrate (NO3 ) before plants can take it up. green manure will be conserved in the soil in an Under no-till systems where killed cover crops organic form for gradual release in a number of remain on the surface, some ammonia (NH3) gas subsequent growing seasons. can be lost right back into the atmosphere. Nitrate is the form of N that most plants prefer. OTHER SOIL-IMPROVING BENEFITS Unfortunately, it is also the most water-soluble form of N. Whenever there is more nitrate than Cover crops can be very useful as living plows to plant roots can absorb, the excess may leach with penetrate and break up compacted layers in the heavy rain or irrigation water. soil. Some of the covers discussed in this book, As noted earlier, nitrates in excess of 140 lb./A such as sweetclover, have roots that reach as may be released into warm,moist soil within as lit- deep as three feet in the soil within one crop- tle as seven to 10 days after plowing down a high- ping season.The action of numerous pointy little N legume, such as a hairy vetch stand. Since the taproots with the hydraulic force of a deter- following crop is unlikely to have much of a root mined plant behind them can penetrate soil system at that point, the N has a ticket for where plowshares fear to go. Grasses, with their Leachville. Consider also that the green manure tremendously extensive root systems, may may have been plowed down to as deep as 12 relieve compacted surface soil layers. Sorghum- inches—much deeper than anyone would con- sudangrass can be managed to powerfully frac- sider applying chemical fertilizer. Moreover, ture subsoil. See Summer Covers Relieve green manures sometimes continue to decom- Compaction (p. 84). pose after the cash crop no longer needs N.This One of the less appreciated soil benefits of N also is prone to leaching. cover crops is an increase in the total numbers To summarize, conventional plowing and and diversity of soil organisms.As discussed ear- aggressive disking can cause a rapid decomposi- lier, diversity is the key to a healthy, well-func- tion of green manures, which could provide too tioning soil. Living covers help supply much N too soon in the cropping season. No-till year-round food for organisms that feed off root systems will have a reduced and more gradual by-products or that need the habitat provided on release of N, but some of that N may be vulnera- a residue-littered soil surface. Dead covers ble to gaseous loss, either by ammonia volatiliza- supply a more varied and increased soil diet for tion or by denitrification. Thus, depending on many organisms. management, soil and weather situations, N from Of course, unwanted pests may be lured to the legume cover crops may not be more efficiently field. Effective crop rotations that include cover used than N from fertilizer. crops, however, tend to reduce rather than Some possible solutions to this cover crop increase pest concerns. Pest-management consid- nitrogen-cycling dilemma: erations due to the presence of a cover crop are • A shallow incorporation of the green manure, discussed in the next chapter, Managing Pests as with a disk,may reduce the risk of gaseous loss. with Cover Crops (p. 25). • It may be feasible to no-till plant into the Finally, cover crops may have an added advan- green manure, then mow or incorporate it tage of drying out and therefore warming soils between the rows several weeks later, when cash during a cold, wet season.The flip side of this is crop roots are more developed and able to take that they may dry the soil out too much and rob up N. This has some risk, especially when soil the following crop of needed moisture. moisture is limiting, but can provide satisfactory There are no over-the-counter elixirs for renew- results if seedling survival is assured. ing soil. A long-term farm plan that includes • Residue from a grass/legume mix will have a cover crops, however, can help ensure your soil’s higher C:N than the legume alone, slowing the health and productivity for as long as you farm.
24 MANAGING COVER CROPS PROFITABLY MANAGING PESTS WITH COVER CROPS By Sharad C. Phatak
rop crops are poised to play increasingly productive for row crops and vegetables for the important roles on North American farms. first two to three years. High yields of agronomic CIn addition to slowing erosion, improving and horticultural crops are profitable, with soil structure and providing fertility, we are learn- comparatively few pesticide and fertilizer inputs. ing how cover crops help farmers to manage After that—under conventional systems with cus- pests. With limited tillage and careful attention tomary clean tillage—annual crops require higher to cultivar choice, placement and timing, cover inputs.The first several years of excessive tillage crops can reduce infestations by insects, diseases, destroys the food sources and micro-niches on nematodes and weeds. Pest-fighting cover crop which the soil organisms that help suppress pests systems help minimize reliance on pesticides,and depend. When protective natural biological as a result cut costs, reduce your chemical expo- systems are disrupted, pests have new openings sure, protect the environment, and increase con- and crops are much more at risk. sumer confidence in the food you produce. Cover crop farming is different from clean-field Farmers and researchers are using cover crops monocropping, where perfection is rows of corn to design new strategies that preserve a farm’s or cotton with no thought given to encouraging natural resources while remaining profitable. Key other organisms.Cover crops bring more forms of to this approach is to see a farm as an “agro- life into the picture and into your management ecosystem”—a dynamic relationship of the min- plan. By working with a more diverse range of eral, biological, weather and human resources crops,some growing at the same time in the same involved in producing crops or livestock.Our goal field, you’ve got a lot more options. Here’s a quick is to learn agricultural practices that are environ- overview of how these systems work. mentally sound,economically feasible and socially acceptable. Insect Management Environmentally sustainable pest management In balanced ecosystems, insect pests are kept in starts with building healthy soils. Research in check by their natural enemies. These natural south Georgia (see sidebar Georgia Cotton, pest controls—called beneficials in agricultural Peanut Farmers, p. 26) shows that crops grown systems—include predator and parasitoid insects on biologically active soils resist pest pressures and diseases. Predators kill and eat other insects; better than those grown on soils of low fertility, parasitoids spend their larval stage inside another extreme pH, low biological activity and poor soil insect, which then dies as the invader’s larval structure. stage ends. However, in conventional systems, There are many ways to increase biological synthetic chemical treatments that kill insect activity in soil. Adding more organic material by pests also typically kill their natural enemies. growing cover crops or applying manure helps. Conserving and encouraging beneficial organisms Reducing or eliminating pesticides favors diverse, is key to achieving sustainable pest management. healthy populations of beneficial soil flora and You should aim to combine strategies that make fauna. So does reducing or eliminating tillage that each farm field more hospitable to beneficials. causes losses of soil structure, biological life or Reduce pesticide use, and, when use is essential, organic matter. These losses make crops more select materials that are least harmful to beneficials. vulnerable to pest damage. Avoid or minimize cultural practices such as tilling Farming on newly cleared land shows the and burning that kill beneficials and destroy their process well. Land that has been in a “cover crop” habitat. Build up the sustenance and habitat that of trees or pastures for at least 10 years remains beneficials need. Properly managed cover crops
MANAGING PESTS WITH COVER CROPS 25 Georgia Cotton, Peanut Farmers Use Cover Crops to Control Pests TIFTON, Ga.—Here in southwestern Georgia, a cover crop of rye, crimson clover, cahaba I’m working with farmers who have had vetch or subterranean clover. dramatic success creating biologically active Spring—Strip-till rows 18 to 24 inches wide, soil in fields that have been conventionally leaving the cover crop growing between the tilled for generations.We still grow the strips.Three weeks later,plant cotton. traditional cash crops of cotton and peanuts, • Year 2. Fall—Replant cereal rye or cahaba but with a difference.We’ve added cover vetch, allow crimson or subclover hard seed crops, virtually eliminated tillage, and added to germinate. new cash crops that substitute for cotton Spring—Strip-till cotton. and peanuts some years to break disease • Year 3. Fall—Plant rye. cycles and allow for more biodiversity. Spring—Desiccate rye with herbicides. Our strategies include no-till planting (using No-till plant peanuts. modified conventional planters), permanent • Year 4. Year 1 starts the cycle again. planting beds, controlled implement traffic, Vegetable farmers frequently use fall-planted crop rotation and annual high-residue winter cereal rye plowed down before vegetables, cover crops.We incorporate fertilizer and or crimson clover strip-tilled before planting lime prior to the first planting of rye in the vegetables.The crimson clover matures, conversion year. This is usually the last tillage drops hard seed, then dies. Most of the seed we plan to do on these fields for many years. germinates in fall. Cereal/legume mixes have Together, these practices give us significant not been more successful than single-crop pest management benefits within three years. cover crop plantings in our area. Growers are experimenting with a basic Some vegetable farmers strip-till rows into winter cover crop>summer cash crop rye in April. The strips are planted in early rotation. Our cover crops are ones we May to Southern peas, lima beans or snap know grow well here. Rye provides control of beans. Rye in row middles will be dead or disease, weed and nematode threats. Legume nearly dead. Rye or crimson clover can crops are crimson clover, subterranean clover continue the rotation. or cahaba vetch.They are planted with the Vegetable farmers also broadcast crimson rye or along field borders, around ponds, near clover in early March. They desiccate the irrigation lines and in other non-cropped areas cover, strip-till rows, then plant squash in April. as close as possible to fields to provide the The clover in the row middles will set seed food needed to support beneficials at higher then die back through summer. The crimson populations. strips will begin to regrow in fall from the When I work with area cotton and peanut dropped seed, and fall vegetables may be farmers who want to diversify their farms, we planted in the tilled areas after the July squash set up a program that looks like this: harvest. • Year 1. Fall—Adjust fertility and pH Insecticide and herbicide reduction begins according to soil test. Deep till if necessary the first year, with no applications needed to relieve subsurface soil compaction. Plant by the third or fourth year in many cases.
supply moisture, physical niches and food in the already in place when you plant spring or sum- form of insects, pollen, honeydew and nectar. mer crops.However,if you fully incorporate cover By including cover crops in your rotations and crops, you destroy or disperse most of the benefi- not spraying insecticides, beneficials often are cials that were present. Conservation tillage is a
26 MANAGING COVER CROPS PROFITABLY The farmers get weed control by flail mowing • Weeds. Strip-tilling into over-wintered herbicide-killed, fall-planted rye, leaving about cover crops provides acceptable weed 6 inches of stubble. One or two post-emerge control for relay-cropped cucumbers (264). herbicide applications should suffice in the Conventional management of rye in our area first few years. I don’t recommend cultivation is usually to disk or kill it with broad- for weed control because it increases risks of spectrum herbicides such as paraquat or soil erosion and damages the protective outer glyphosate. leaf layer that helps prevent plant diseases. • Diseases. I’ve been strip-tilling crimson We see changes on farms where the clover since 1985 to raise tomatoes, peppers, rotations stay in place for three or more years: eggplant, cucumbers, cantaloupes, lima beans, • Insects. Insecticide costs are $50 snap beans, Southern peas and cabbages. I’m to $100/A less than conventional crop using no fungicides. Our research staff has management in the area for all kinds of raised peanuts no-tilled into cereal rye for the crops.The farmers using the alternative past six years, also without fungicides. system often substitute with insect control • Nematodes. If we start on land where materials such as Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt), pest nematodes are not a major problem, pyrethroids and insect growth regulators this system keeps them from becoming a that have less severe environmental impact. problem. These products are less persistent in the field Even though the conventional wisdom says environment, more targeted to specific pests you can’t build organic matter in our climate and do less harm to beneficials. By planting and soils, we have top-inch readings of 4 cover crops on field edges and in other non- percent organic matter in a field that tested crop areas, these farmers are increasing the 0.5 percent four years ago. numbers of beneficials in the field We are still learning, but know that we can environments. rotate crops, use cover crops and cut tillage Pests that are no longer a problem on the to greatly improve our sustainability.In our cover-cropped farms include thrips, bollworm, experience, we’ve reduced total costs by as budworm, aphids, fall armyworm, beet much as $200 per acre for purchased inputs armyworm and white flies. On my no-till and tillage. Parts of our system will work in research plots with cover crops and long many places. Experiment on a small scale to rotations, I’ve not used insecticides for six years look more closely at what’s really going in your on peanuts, for eight years on cotton and for 12 soil and on your crops. As you compare insights years on vegetables. I’m working with growers and share information with other growers and who use cover crops and crop rotations to researchers in your area, you’ll find cover crops economically produce cucumbers, squash, that help you control pests, too. peppers, eggplant, cabbage peanuts, soybeans —Sharad C. Phatak and cotton with only one or two applications of insecticide—sometimes with none.
better option because it leaves more of the cover Cover crops left on the surface may be living, crop residue on the surface. No-till planting only temporarily suppressed, dying or dead. In any disturbs an area 2 to 4 inches wide,while strip-till- event, their presence protects beneficials and ing disturbs an area up to about 24 inches wide their habitat. The farmer-helpful organisms are between undisturbed row middles. hungry, ready to eat the pests of cash crops that
MANAGING PESTS WITH COVER CROPS 27 are planted into the cover-crop residue. The The beneficial bugs destroyed all the beetles by ultimate goal is to provide year-round food and evening. habitat for beneficials to ensure their presence • Cucumber beetles seen attacking cucumber within or near primary crops. plants were similarly destroyed by beneficials We’re just beginning to understand the effects within a day. of cropping sequences and cover crops on bene- • Lady beetles in cover crop systems help to ficial and insect pest populations. Researchers control aphids attacking many crops. have found that generalist predators, which feed Properly selected and managed, cover crops on many species, may be an important biological can enhance the soil and field environment to control. During periods when pests are scarce or favor beneficials. Success depends on properly absent, several important generalist predators managing the cover crop species matched can subsist on nectar, pollen and alternative prey with the cash crops and anticipated pest threats. afforded by cover crops. This suggests you can While we don’t yet have prescription plantings enhance the biological control of pests by using guaranteed to bring in all the needed benefi- cover crops as habitat or food for the beneficials cials—and only beneficials—for long lists of cash in your area. crops, we know some associations : This strategy is important for farmers in the • We identified 13 known beneficial insects South, where pest pressure can be especially associated with cover crops during one growing heavy. In south Georgia, research showed that season in south Georgia vegetable plantings (34, populations of beneficial insects such as insidious 36, 39). flower bugs (Orius insidiosus), bigeyed bugs • In cotton fields in south Georgia where (Geocoris spp.) and various lady beetles residues are left on the surface and insecticides (Coleoptera coccinellidae) can attain high densi- are not applied, more than 120 species of benefi- ties in various vetches, clovers and certain crucif- cial arthropods, spiders and ants have been erous crops. These predators subsisted and observed. reproduced on nectar, pollen, thrips and aphids, • Fall-sown and spring-sown insectory mixes and were established before key pests arrived. with 10 to 20 different cover crops work well Research throughout Georgia, Alabama and under orchard systems. These covers provide Mississippi showed that when summer vegetables habitat and alternative food sources for beneficial were planted amid “dying mulches”of cool-season cover crops, some beneficial insects moved in to attack crop pests. Recent research has looked carefully at how beneficials and crops interact. In undisturbed, biodiverse settings, the interactions are complex and intricate. Crop plants, when attacked by pests, send signals to which other insects respond. Appropriate beneficials move in to find their prey (349). Maximizing natural predator-pest interaction is the primary goal of biologically based Integrated Pest Management (IPM),and cover crops can play a leading role. For example: • Colorado potato beetle were observed at 9 a.m. attacking eggplant that had been strip-till planted into crimson clover. By noon, assassin bugs had clustered around the feeding beetles. BUCKWHEAT grows quickly in cool, moist weather.
28 MANAGING COVER CROPS PROFITABLY insects. This approach has been used successfully minimize disease losses (259, 260, 331, 333, 334). by California almond and walnut growers partici- Now we realize that burying cover crop residues pating in the Biologically Intensive Orchard and disrupting the entire soil profile eliminates Systems (BIOS) project of the University of beneficial insect habitat and weed control bene- California (142). fits. The increased use of conservation tillage The level of ecological sustainability depends increases the need to manage crop disease with- on the grower’s interests, management skills and out burying cover crops. situation. Some use no insecticides while others Plant infection by microorganisms is rare (254). have substantially reduced insecticide applica- A pathogen has to cross many barriers before it tions on peanut, cotton and vegetable crops. can cause a disease to roots, stem or leaves.You • In Georgia, Mississippi and South Carolina, can use cover crops to reinforce two of these minimally tilled crimson clover or cahaba vetch barriers. before cotton planting have been successful in reducing fertilizer N up to 50 percent and insecti- Plant cuticle layer. This often waxy surface layer cide inputs by 30 to 100 percent. is the first physical barrier to plant infection. • Many farmers are adopting a system of trans- Many pathogens and all bacteria enter the plant planting tomatoes, peppers and eggplant into a through breaks, such as wounds, or natural open- killed hairy vetch or vetch/ ings, such as stomata, in this rye cover crop. Benefits Cover crops can enhance the cuticle layer. This protective include weed, insect and dis- layer can be physically dam- ease suppression, improved soil and field environment aged by cultivation, spraying fruit quality and overall lower to favor beneficial insects. and sand-blasting from wind production cost. erosion, as well as by the • Leaving “remnant impact and soil splashing strips” of a cover when most of the crop is from raindrops and overhead irrigation. In well- mowed or incorporated provides a continuing developed minimum-till or no-till crop systems refuge and food source for beneficials, which with cover crops, you may not need cultivation might otherwise leave the area or die. This for weed control (see below) and you can mini- method is used in orchards when continued mize spraying.Organic mulches from living,dying growth of cover crops would cause moisture or killed covers that hold soil and stop soil splash- competition with trees. ing protect crops from injury to the cuticle. • Insect movement is orchestrated in a system developed by Oklahoma State University for Plant surface microflora. Many benign organ- pecan growers. As legume mixtures senesce, isms are present on the leaf and stem surface. beneficials migrate into trees to help suppress They compete with pathogens for a limited sup- harmful insects. Not mowing the covers from ply of nutrients.Some of these organisms produce August 1 until shuck split of the developing natural antibiotics. Pesticides, soaps, surfactants, pecans lessens the unwanted movement of stink spreaders and sticking agents can kill or disrupt bugs, a pest which can damage green pecans the activities of these beneficial microorganisms, (209). In California, lygus bugs on berseem clover weakening the plant’s defenses. Cover crops can or alfalfa are pests of cash crops. Be careful that help this natural protection process work by cover crop maturity or killing a cover doesn’t reducing the need for synthetic crop protection force pests into a neighboring cash crop. materials. Further, cover crop plant surfaces can support healthy populations of beneficial Disease Management microorganisms, including types of yeasts, that Growers traditionally have been advised to turn can migrate onto a cash crop after planting or under plant debris by moldboard plowing to transplanting.
MANAGING PESTS WITH COVER CROPS 29 Select Covers that Balance Pests, Problems of Farm Many crops can be managed as cover crops, including cotton, soybean and most but only a few have been studied specifically vegetables. Rye will not control weedy grasses. for their pest-related benefits on cash crops Because it can increase numbers of cut worms and field environments. and wire worms in no-till planting conditions, Learn all you can about the impacts of a rye is not the most suitable cover where those cover crop species to help you manage it in worms are a problem ahead of grass crops like your situation. Here are several widely used corn, sweet corn, sorghum or pearl millet. cover crops described by their effects under • Wheat (Triticum aestivum)—A winter conservation tillage in relation to insects, annual grain, wheat is widely adapted and diseases, nematodes and weeds. works much like rye in controlling diseases, • Cereal Rye (Secale cereale)—This winter nematodes and broadleaf weeds.Wheat is not annual grain is perhaps the most versatile as effective as rye in controlling weeds cover crop used in the continental United because it produces less biomass and has less States. Properly managed under conservation allelopathic effect. tillage, rye has the ability to reduce soil-borne • Crimson Clover (Trifolium diseases, nematodes and weeds. Rye is a non- incarnatum)—Used as a self-reseeding winter host plant for root-knot nematodes and soil- annual legume throughout the Southeast, fall- borne diseases. It produces significant biomass planted crimson clover supports and increases that smothers weeds when it is left on the soil-borne diseases, pythium-rhizoctonia surface and also controls weeds complex and root-knot nematodes. It allelopathically through natural weed- suppresses weeds effectively by forming a suppressing compounds. thick mulch. Crimson supports high densities As it grows, rye provides habitat, but not of beneficial insects by providing food and food, for beneficial insects. Thus, only a small habitat. Because some cultivars produce “hard number of beneficial insects are found on rye. seed” that resists immediate germination, Fall-planted rye works well in reducing soil- crimson clover can be managed to reseed in borne diseases, root-knot nematodes and late spring so that it resumes its growth in late broadleaf weeds in all cash crops that follow, summer and fall.
Soilborne pathogenic fungi limit production of In soils with high levels of disease inoculum, vegetables and cotton in the southern U.S. (332, however, it takes time to reduce population lev- 333, 334, 335). Rhizoctonia solani, Pythium els of soil pathogens using only cover crops. myriotylum, Pythium phanidermatum and After tests in Maine with oats, broccoli, white Pythium irregulare are the most virulent patho- lupine (Lupinus albus) and field peas (Pisum genic fungi that cause damping-off on cucumbers sativum) as covers,researchers cautioned it may and snap beans. Sclerotium rolfsii causes rot in take three to five years to effectively reduce all vegetables and in peanuts and cotton. Infected stem lesion losses on potatoes caused by R. plants that do not die may be stunted because of solani (190).Yet there are single-season improve- lesions caused by fungi on primary or secondary ments, too. For example, in an Idaho study, roots,hypocotyls and stems.But after two or three Verticillium wilt of potato was reduced by 24 to years in cover cropped, no-till systems, damping- 29 percent following Sudangrass green manure. off is not a serious problem, experience on south Yield of U.S.No.1 potatoes increased by 24 to 38 Georgia farms and research plots shows. Higher percent compared with potatoes following soil organic matter may help. barley or fallow (322).
30 MANAGING COVER CROPS PROFITABLY • Subterranean Clover (Trifolium no-till system substantially reduces root-knot subterraneum)—A self-reseeding annual nematodes, soil-borne diseases and broadleaf legume, fall-planted subterranean clover carries weeds. By using clovers and vetches in your the same risks as crimson clover with soil- fields and adding beneficial habitat in non- borne diseases and nematodes. It suppresses cultivated areas, you can increase populations weeds more effectively in the deep South, of beneficial insects that help to keep insects however, because of its thick and low growth pests under control. Mixed plantings of a small habit. Subclover supports a high level of grains and legumes combine benefits of both beneficial insects. while reducing their shortcomings. • Cahaba White Vetch (V.sativa X V. As pesticides of all types (fungicides, cordata)—This cool-season annual legume is a herbicides, nematicides and insecticides) are hybrid vetch that increases soilborne diseases reduced, the field environment becomes yet suppresses root-knot nematodes. It increasingly resilient in keeping pest outbreaks supports beneficial insects, yet attracts very in check. Plantings to further increase high numbers of the tarnished plant bug, a beneficial habitat in non-cultivated areas can serious pest. help maintain pollinating insects and pest • Buckwheat (Fagopyrum esculentum)— predators, but should be monitored to avoid A summer annual non-legume, buckwheat is build-ups of potential pests. Researchers are very effective in suppressing weeds when only beginning to understand how to manage planted thickly.It also supports high densities these “insectary plantings.” of beneficial insects. It is suitable for sequential Editor’s Note: Each cover crop listed here, planting around non-crop areas to provide except for cahaba vetch, is included in the food and habitat for beneficial insects. It is charts (pp. 48 and following) and is fully very attractive to honeybees. described in its respective section. Check the A well-planned crop rotation maximizes Table of Contents (p. 6) for location. benefits and compensates for the risks of —Sharad C. Phatak cover crops and cash crops. Planting rye in a
Nematode Management This coexistence would be the case in the undis- Nematodes are minute roundworms that interact turbed field or woodland described above. directly and indirectly with plants. Some species In conventional crop systems, pest nematodes feed on roots and weaker plants, and also intro- have abundant food and little environmental resis- duce disease through feeding wounds. Most tance. This can lead to rapid expansion of plant nematodes are not plant parasites,but feed on and parasitic species, plant disease and yield loss. interact with many soil-borne microorganisms, Cropping systems that increase biological diversi- including fungi, bacteria and protozoa. Damage ty over time usually prevent the onset of from plant-parasitic nematodes results in a break- nematode problems. Reasons may include a down of plant tissue, such as lesions or yellow dynamic soil ecological balance and improved, foliage; retarded growth of cells, seen as stunted healthier soil structure with higher organic growth or shoots; or excessive growth such as matter. In Michigan, some potato growers report root galls, swollen root tips or unnatural root that two years of alfalfa to limit nematodes branching. between potato crops is sustainable for them If the community of nematodes contains because of improvements to potato production diverse species, no single species will dominate. and lower pest control costs (20).
MANAGING PESTS WITH COVER CROPS 31 Once a nematode species is established in a better than if the cover was buried more deeply field, it is usually impossible to eliminate it. Some by moldboard plowing. Associated greenhouse covers can enhance a resident parasitic nematode tests in the study showed that incorporated rye population if they are grown before or after was effective against root-knot,reniform and stub- another crop that hosts a plant-damaging nema- by root nematodes, as well (14). tode species. Malt barley, corn, radishes and mustard some- If a nematode pest species is absent from the times worked as well as the standard nematicide soil, planting a susceptible cover crop will not to control sugar beet nematode in Wyoming sugar give rise to a problem,assuming the species is not beets,a 1994 study showed.Increased production introduced on seed, transplants or machinery more than offset the cover crop cost, and lamb (296). One Iowa farmer reports that researchers grazing of the brassicas increased profit without analyzing his fields have found no evidence that diminishing nematode suppression. The success hairy vetch,a host for soybean cyst nematode,has is conditional upon a limited nematode density. caused any problem with the pest in his soy- The cover crop treatment was effective only if beans. This may be due to his use compost in there were fewer than 10 eggs or juveniles per strip-cropped fields with an oats/hairy cubic centimeter of soil. A moderate sugar beet vetch>corn>soybean rotation (346). nematode level was reduced 54 to 75 percent in You can gradually reduce a field’s nematode about 11 weeks, increasing yield by nearly 4 tons pest population or limit nematode impact on per acre (184). crops by using specific cover crops. Nematode control tactics involving covers include: Weed Management • Manipulating soil structure or soil humus Cover crops are widely used as smother crops to • Rotating with non-host crops shade and out-compete weeds. Cereal grains • Using crops with nematicidal effects, such as establish quickly as they use up the moisture, fer- brassicas tility and light that weeds need to survive. Cover crops may also improve overall plant Sorghum-sudangrass hybrids and buckwheat are vitality to lessen the nematode impact on yield. warm-season crops that suppress weeds through But if you suspect nematode trouble, send a soil these physical means and by plant-produced sample for laboratory analysis to positively identi- natural herbicides (allelopathy). fy the nematode species.Then be sure any cover Cereal rye is an overwintering crop that sup- crops you try aren’t alternate hosts for that pest presses weeds both physically and chemically. If species. Area IPM specialists can help you. rye residue is left on the soil surface, it releases Using brassicas and many grasses as cover allelochemicals that inhibit seedling growth of crops can help you manage nematodes. Cover many annual small-seeded broadleaf weeds, such crops with documented nematicidal properties as pigweed and lambsquarters. The response of against at least one nematode species include grassy weeds is more variable.Rye is a major com- sorghum-sudangrass hybrids (Sorghum bicolor X ponent in the killed organic mulches used in no- S. bicolor var. sudanese), marigold (Tagetes till vegetable transplanting systems. patula), hairy indigo (Indigofera hirsuta), showy Killed cover crop mulches last longer if the crotalaria (Crotolaria spectabilis), sunn hemp stalks are left intact, providing weed control well (Crotalaria juncea) and velvetbean (Mucuna into the season for summer vegetables. Two deeringiana). implements have been modified in recent years You must match specific cover crop species specifically to enhance weed suppression by with the particular nematode pest species, then cover crops. The undercutter uses a wide blade manage it correctly. For example, cereal rye to slice just under the surface of raised beds, sev- residue left on the surface or incorporated to a ering cover crop plants from their root mass.An depth of several inches suppressed Columbia attached rolling harrow increases effectiveness lance nematodes in North Carolina cotton fields (69, 70, 71, 72). A Buffalo rolling stalk chopper
32 MANAGING COVER CROPS PROFITABLY does no direct tillage, but aggressively bends and cuts crops at the surface (132). Both tools work well on most legumes when they are in mid- bloom stage or beyond. Killed mulch of a cover crop mix of rye, hairy vetch, crimson clover and barley kept processing tomatoes nearly weed-free for six weeks in an Ohio test. This length of time is significant, because other research has shown that tomato fields kept weed-free for 36 days yield as much as fields kept weed-free all season (71, 115). Cover crops can also serve as a “living mulch” to manage weeds in vegetable production. Cover crops are left to grow between rows of the cash crop to suppress weeds by blocking light and out-competing weeds for nutrients and water. They may also provide organic matter,some nitro- gen (if legumes), beneficial insect habitat, erosion prevention, wind protection and a tough sod to Cover crops often suppress weeds early, then support field traffic. prevent erosion or supply fertility later in the sea- To avoid competition with the cash crop,living son. For example, shade-tolerant legumes such as mulches can be chemically or mechanically red clover or sweetclover that are planted with suppressed. In the Southeast, some cool-season spring grains grow rapidly after grain harvest to cover crops such as crimson clover die out natu- prevent weeds from dominating fields in late sum- rally during summer crop growth and do not mer. Overseeding annual ryegrass or oats at soy- compete for water or nutrients. However, cover bean leaf yellowing provides a weed-suppressing crops that regrow during spring and summer— cover crop before frost and a light mulch to sup- such as subterranean clover, white clover and red press winter annuals, as well. clover—can compete strongly for water with Cover crops can play a pest-suppressing role spring-planted crops unless the covers are ade- on virtually any farm. As we find out more about quately suppressed. the pest management benefits of cover crop sys- In New York, growing cover crops overseeded tems, they will become even more attractive within three weeks of potato planting provided from both an economic and an environmental good weed suppression, using 70 percent less perspective. Traditional research will identify herbicide. Yield was the same as, or moderately some new pieces of these biologically based reduced from, the standard herbicide control systems. However,growers who understand how plots in the two-year study.Hairy vetch,woolypod all the elements of their farm fit together will vetch, oats, barley, red clover and an oats/hairy be the people who will really bring cover crops vetch mix were suppressed as needed with fluaz- into the prominence they deserve in sustainable ifop and metribuzin (280). farming.
CRIMSON CLOVER, a winter annual legume, grows rapidly in spring to fix high levels of nitrogen.
MANAGING PESTS WITH COVER CROPS 33 CROP ROTATION WITH COVER CROPS
Readers’ note: > indicates progression to may be the ideal window for establishing a cover another crop; / indicates a mixture of crops crop. Consider using an early-maturing cash crop growing at the same time. to allow for timely planting of the cover crop.The ideas in this book will help you see cover crop ne of the biggest challenges of cover opportunities in what used to look like problems. cropping is to fit cover crops into your Ocurrent rotations, or to develop new COVER CROPS FOR CORN BELT GRAIN rotations that take full advantage of their benefits. AND OILSEED PRODUCTION This section will explore some of the systems used successfully by farmers in different regions In addition to providing winter cover and build- of the U.S. One might be easily adapted to fit your ing soil structure, nitrogen (N) management will existing crops, equipment and management. probably be a major factor in your cover crop Other examples may point out ways that you can decisions for the corn>soybean rotation. A fall- modify your rotation to make the addition of planted grass or small grain will scavenge leftover cover crops more profitable and practical. N from the previous corn or soybean crop. Whether you add covers to your existing rota- Legumes are much less efficient at scavenging N, tions or totally revamp your farming system, it is but will add N to the system for the following crucial that you devote as much planning and crop. Legume/grass mixtures are quite good at attention to your cover crops as you do to your both. cash crops. Failure to do so can lead to failure of the cover crop and cause problems in other parts Corn>Soybean Systems of your system. Also remember that there is likely Keep in mind that: corn is a heavy nitrogen feed- no single cover crop that is right for your farm. er; soybeans benefit little, if at all, from cover crop Ultimately, rotating cover crops might be your N; and that you have a shorter time for spring best strategy. (See, for example, California legume growth before corn than before soybeans. Vegetable Crop Systems, p. 37). Like any other crop, pest pressures may build up if a cover crop Cover crop features: rye provides winter cover, is grown too often in the same field. scavenges N after corn, becomes a long-lasting (6- Before you start: week) residue for your beans to suppress weeds •Review Benefits Of Cover Crops (p. 9) and and hold moisture; hairy vetch provides spring Selecting the Best Cover Crops For Your Farm ground cover,abundant N and a moderate-term (3 (p. 12) to 4 week) mulch for the next corn crop; field • Decide which benefits are most important peas are similar to vetch, but residue breaks to you down faster; red clover is also similar, but pro- • Read the examples below,then consider how duces slightly less N and has less vigorous spring these cover crop rotations might be adapted regrowth; berseem clover grows quickly to pro- to your particular conditions vide several cuttings for high-N green manure, • Talk to your neighbors and the other “experts” then winterkills. in your area, including the contact people list- Here are some options to consider adapting to ed in Regional Experts (p. 173) your system: • Start small on an easily accessible plot that you will see often Corn>Rye>Soybeans>Hairy Vetch. In Zone 7 Be an opportunist—and an optimist. If your and warmer, you can grow a cover crop every cropping plans for a field are disrupted by weath- year between your corn and full-season beans. er or other conditions outside of your control,this Also, you can use wheat or another small grain to
34 MANAGING COVER CROPS PROFITABLY replace the cover crop before beans, in a three- Worried about soil moisture? There’s no crop, two-year rotation (corn>wheat>doublecrop question that growing cover crops may consume beans). In all cases, another legume or a soil moisture needed by the next crop. In humid grass/legume mixture can be used instead of a sin- regions, this is a problem only in an unusually dry gle species cover crop. Where it is adapted, you spring.Time permitting, allow 2 to 3 weeks after can use crimson clover or a crimson/grass mix- killing the cover crop to alleviate this problem. ture instead of vetch. While spring rainfall may compensate for the In cooler areas, plant rye as soon as possible moisture demand of most cover crops by normal after corn harvest. If you need more time in the planting dates, rye can quickly dry out a field. fall, try overseeding in rowed beans at drydown Later in the season, killed cover crop residues “yellow leaf”stage in early fall, or in early summer in minimum tillage systems can conserve at the last cultivation of corn. Seeding options moisture and increase yields. include aerial application where the service is In dryland areas of the Southern Great Plains, economical, using a specialty high-body tractor lack of water limits cover crop use. (See Dryland with narrow tires,or attaching a broadcast seeder, Cereal Cropping Systems, p. 40). air seeder or seed boxes to a In any system where you cultivator. Growers are looking to add are using accumulated soil Kill the rye once it is about moisture to grow your cash knee-high, or let it go a bit a small grain to their crop, you need to be extra longer, killing it a couple of corn>soybean rotation. careful. However,as noted in weeks before planting beans. this section and elsewhere Killing the rye with herbi- in the book, farmers and cides and no-tilling beans in narrow rows allows researchers are finding that water-thrifty cover more time for cover crop growth, since you don’t crops may be able to replace even a fallow year have to work the ground. If soil moisture is low, without adversely affecting the cash crop. consider killing the rye earlier. Follow the beans with hairy vetch or a vetch/small grain mixture. Corn>Rye>Soybeans>Small Grain>Hairy Legumes must be seeded at least 6 weeks before Vetch. This rotation is similar to the hard frost to ensure winter survival. Seed by corn>rye>soybeans rotation described above, drilling after soybean harvest, or by overseeding except you add a year of small grains following before leaf drop. Allow the vetch (or mixture) to the beans. This is the standard rotation in the grow as long as possible in spring for maximum N grain-growing regions of Paraguay and Brazil, fixation. where it is critical to maintain soil organic matter. Worried about planting your corn a bit In crop rotation research from different areas, late because you’re waiting for your cover crop to many benefits accrue as the rotation becomes mature? Research in Maryland, Illinois and else- longer. This is because weed, disease and insect where suggests that planting corn towards the pest problems generally decrease with an end of the usual window when using a legume increase in years between repeat plantings of the cover crop has its rewards. The delay can result same crop. in greater yields than earlier planting, due to Residue from small grains provides good organ- greater moisture conservation and more N pro- ic matter for soil building, and in the case of win- duced by the cover crop, or due to the timing of ter grains, the plants help to prevent erosion over summer drought (62, 64, 243, 338). Check your winter after soybeans loosen up the soil. If seed- state variety trial data for a shorter season corn ing with small grains, select cover crops that will hybrid that yields nearly as well as slightly longer stand shade and some traffic. season corn.The cover crop benefit should over- The length of the growing season will deter- come many yield differences. mine how you fit in cover crops after full-season
CROP ROTATION WITH COVER CROPS 35 soybeans in the rotation. Consider using a short- or oats for grain, frost-seed red clover or sweet- season bean if needed in order to achieve timely clover in March, harvest the grain, then let the planting after soybean harvest.Calculate whether clover grow until it goes dormant in late fall. cover crop benefits will compensate for a possi- Follow with corn the next spring. Some sec- ble yield loss on the shorter season beans.If there ondary tillage can be done in the fall,if conditions is not enough time to seed a legume after har- allow.One option is to attach sweeps to your chis- vest, use a small grain rather than no cover crop el plow and run them about 2 inches deep, cut- at all. ting the clover crowns (326). The small grain scavenges leftover N following Alternatively, grow the small grain to maturity, beans. Legume cover crops reduce fertilizer N harvest, then immediately plant a legume cover needed for following corn, a heavy N feeder. If crop such as hairy vetch or red clover in August or you cannot seed the legume at least six weeks early September. Soil moisture is critical for quick before a hard frost, consider overseeding before germination and good growth before frost. For leaf drop or at last cultivation. much of the northern U.S., there is not time to An alternate rotation for the lower mid-South plant a legume after soybean harvest,unless it can is corn>crimson clover (allowed to go to seed) be seeded aerially or at the last cultivation. If > soybeans > crimson clover (reseeded) > corn. growing spring grains, seed red clover or sweet- Allow the crimson clover to go to seed before clover directly with the small grain. planting beans. The clover germinates in late sum- Adding the small grain to the rotation helps mer under the beans. Kill the cover crop before control white mold on soybeans, since two years corn the next spring. If possible, choose a differ- out of beans are needed to reduce pathogen pop- ent cover crop following the corn this time to ulations. Using a grain/legume mix will scavenge avoid potential pest and disease problems with available N from the bean crop, hold soil over the crimson clover. winter and begin fixing N for the corn. Clovers or vetch can be harvested for seed,and red or yellow Precaution. In selecting a cover crop to clover can be left for the second year as a green interseed, do not jeopardize your cash crop if soil manure crop. moisture is usually limiting during the rest of the Using a spring seeding of oats and berseem corn season! Banding cover crop seed in row clover has proved effective on Iowa farms that middles by using insecticide boxes or other also have livestock. The mix tends to favor oat devices can reduce cover crop competition with grain production in dry years and berseem pro- the cash crop. duction in wetter years. Either way the mixture provides biomass to increase organic matter and 3 Year: Corn>Soybean>Wheat/Red Clover. build soil. The berseem can be clipped several This well-tested Wisconsin sequence provides N times for green manure. for corn as well as general rotation effects in weed suppression and natural controls of disease and Precaution. Planting hairy vetch with small insect pests. It was more profitable in recent grains may make it difficult to harvest a clean years as the cost of synthetic N increased. Corn grain crop. Instead, seed vetch after small grain benefits from legume-fixed N, and from the harvest. improved cation exchange capacity in the soil that comes with increasing organic matter levels. COVER CROPS FOR VEGETABLE PRODUCTION With the changes in base acreage requirements in the 1996 Farm Bill, growers in the upper Vegetable systems often have many windows for Midwest are looking to add a small grain to their including cover crops. Periods of one to two corn>bean rotation.The small grain, seeded after months between harvest of early planted spring soybeans,can be used as a cover crop,or it can be crops and planting of fall crops can be filled grown to maturity for grain.When growing wheat using fast-growing warm-season cover crops such
36 MANAGING COVER CROPS PROFITABLY as buckwheat, cowpeas, sorghum-sudangrass Some farmers maximize the complementary hybrid, or another crop adapted to your condi- weed-suppressing effects of various cover crop tions. As with other cropping systems, plant a species by orchestrating peak growth periods, winter annual cover crop on fields that otherwise rooting depth and shape, topgrowth differences would lie fallow. and species mixes. See Full-Year Covers Tackle Where moisture is sufficient, many vegetable Tough Weeds (p. 38). crops can be overseeded with a cover crop, which will then be established and growing after vegetable 3 Year: Winter Wheat/Legume Interseed> harvest. Select cover crops that tolerate shade and Legume>Potatoes. This eastern Idaho rotation harvest traffic, especially where there will be multi- conditions soil, helps fight soil disease and ple pickings, such as in tomatoes or peppers. provides N. Sufficient N for standard potatoes depends on rainfall being average or lower to Cover crop features: Oats add lots of biomass, prevent leaching that would put the soil N below are a good nurse crop for spring-seeded legumes, the shallow-rooted cash crop. and winterkill, doing away with the need for spring killing and tilling. Sorghum-sudangrass 1 Year: Lettuce>Buckwheat>Buckwheat> hybrid produces deep roots and tall, leafy stalks Broccoli>White Clover/Annual Ryegrass.The that die with the first frost. Yellow sweetclover Northeast’s early spring vegetable crops often is a deep rooting legume that provides cuttings of leave little residue after their early summer har- green manure in its second year. White clover is vest. Sequential buckwheat plantings suppress a persistent perennial and weeds, loosen topsoil and good N source. Residue from small grains attract beneficial insects. In Zone 5 and cooler, Buckwheat is easy to kill by plant rye, oats or a summer provides organic matter for mowing in preparation for fall annual (in August) after snap soil building. . . to prevent transplants. With light tillage bean or sweet corn harvest to incorporate the relatively for organic matter produc- erosion over winter. small amount of fast-degrad- tion and erosion control, ing buckwheat residue, you especially on sandy soils. Incorporate the follow- can then sow a winter grass/legume cover mix to ing spring, or leave untilled strips for continued hold soil throughout the fall and over winter. control of wind erosion. Planted at least 40 days before frost, the white If you have the option of a full year of cover clover should overwinter and provide green crops in the East or Midwest, plant hairy vetch in manure or a living mulch the next year. the spring, allow to grow all year, and it will die back in the fall. Come back with no-till sweet or California Vegetable Crop Systems field corn or another N-demanding crop the Innovative work in California includes rotating following spring. Or, hairy vetch planted after cover crops as well as cash crops, adding diversi- about August 1 will overwinter in most zones ty to the system.This was done in response to an with adequate snow coverage. Allow it to grow increase in Alternaria blight in LANA vetch if until early flower the following spring to achieve planted year after year. full N value. Kill for use as an organic mulch for no-till transplants or incorporate and plant a 4 Year: LANA Vetch>Corn>Oats/Vetch>Dry summer crop. Beans>Common Vetch>Tomatoes>S-S Hybrid/ You can sow annual ryegrass right after har- Cowpea>Safflower. The N needs of the cash vesting an early-spring vegetable crop, allow it to crops of sweet corn,dry beans,safflower and can- grow for a month or two, then kill, incorporate ning tomatoes determine,in part,which covers to and plant a fall vegetable. grow. Corn, with the highest N demand, is pre-
CROP ROTATION WITH COVER CROPS 37 Full-Year Covers Tackle Tough Weeds TROUT RUN, Pa.—Growing cover crops for a a week or two after planting but before leaves full year between cash crops helps Eric and open up to trap sweetclover seeds, while Anne Nordell control virtually every type of onions are overseeded near harvest.The weed nature throws at their vegetable farm— Nordells walk up and down every other row even quackgrass. with a manual Cyclone seeder (canvas bag The couple experimented with many with a hand-crank spinner).They harvest the different cover crops on their north-central cash crop, then let the clover grow through Pennsylvania farm before adapting a system summer. used to successfully battle quackgrass Yellow blossom sweetclover—one of the on a commercial herb farm in the Pacific best cover crop choices for warm-season Northwest. Between cash crops, the Nordells nitrogen production—puts down a deep grow two winter cover crops to smother taproot before winter if seeded in June or weeds.A brief stint of aggressive summer July,observes Eric.“That root system loosens tillage between the two cover crops keeps the soil, fixes nitrogen, and may even bring annual weeds from setting seed. up minerals from the subsoil with its long Regular use of cover crops in their half- tap root.”He points out that the clover alone acre strips between rows of vegetables also would not suppress weeds.The sole-seeding improves soil quality and moisture retention works on their farm because of their while reducing erosion.“Vegetable crops successful management efforts over a return very little to the soil as far as a root decade to suppress overall weed pressure system,”says Eric, a frequent speaker on by crop rotation and varied cover crops. conservation practices at conferences in the In spring, the sweetclover grows until it Northeast.“You cut a head of lettuce and have is about knee-high in mid-May. Then the nothing left behind. Growing vegetables, we’re Nordells clip it just before it buds.They let always trying to rebuild the soil.” the regrowth bloom to attract pollinators The Nordells’ short growing season— and beneficial insects to the field, before which typically ends with the first frost in clipping it again in July. September—makes it challenging to squeeze In early- to mid-July,the Nordells moldboard in cover crops on their six cultivated acres. plow the sweetclover to kill it.They leave the Yellow blossom sweetclover is overseeded ground in bare fallow,working it again with a at 20 to 24 lb./A into early crops such as springtooth harrow to hit perennial weeds at onions or spring lettuce. Lettuce is overseeded the weakest point of their lifecycle. After that,
ceded by LANA vetch, which produces more N than of the N required by the subsequent tomato crop, other covers. Before tomatoes, common vetch works with about 30 to 40 lb. N/A added as starter. best. A mixture of purple vetch and oats is grown A mixture of sorghum-sudangrass and cowpeas is before dry beans, and a mix of sorghum-sudangrass planted following tomato harvest. The mixture and cowpeas precedes safflower. responds to residual N levels with N-scavenging by In order to get maximum biomass and N the grass component to prevent winter leaching. production by April 1,LANA vetch is best planted early The cowpeas fix enough N for early growth of the enough (6 to 8 weeks before frost) to have good subsequent safflower cash crop, which has relative- growth before “winter.”Disked in early April,LANA pro- ly low initial N demands. The cover crop breaks vides all but about 40 lb.N/A to the sweet corn crop. down fast enough to supply safflower’s later-season Common vetch, seeded after the corn, can fix most N demand.
38 MANAGING COVER CROPS PROFITABLY the couple harrows every two to three weeks The Nordells plow the rye/vetch mix to bring weed roots and rhizomes to the soil after it greens up in late March to early April, surface, where they bake in the summer sun. working shallowly so as not to turn up as The harrowing also kills flushes of annual many weed seeds.They forego maximum weeds before they can set seed. biomass and N for earlier planting of their After five years in this weed-killing cash crop—tomatoes, peppers, summer rotation, the Nordells were able to cut back broccoli or leeks—around the end of May. on harrowing, which they now coordinate The bare fallow during mid-summer plus with rainfall and weed pressure. In the early spring incorporation of overwintering unusually dry summer of 1997, for example, cover crops are the best preventive to slugs they did not harrow at all after plowing. and grubs, they have found. In mid-August, the Nordells plant a second, Thanks to their weed-suppressing cover overwintering cover crop. In this rotation, crops, the Nordells typically spend less than they seed a mix of rye and hairy vetch.They 10 hours a season hand-weeding their three broadcast and lightly incorporate about 80 acres of cash crops, and never need to hire pounds rye and 30 pounds vetch per acre. outside weeding help.“Don’t overlook the The rye establishes quickly,putting on good cover crops’ role in improving soil tilth and growth both above and below the surface, making cultivation easier,”adds Eric. Before while the vetch fixes nitrogen.Another cover cropping, he noticed that their silty combination is yellow,red and white clover in soils deteriorated whenever they grew two a 2:2:1 ratio by volume.“We’re looking for a cash crops in a row.“When the soil structure green field by Labor Day,”Eric says.“We want declines, it doesn’t hold moisture and we a good sod before we get our first freeze.” get a buildup of annual weeds,”he notes. Rye and vetch are a popular combination The Nordells can afford to forego a cash to manage nitrogen.The rye takes up excess crop to keep half their land in cover crops N from the soil, preventing leaching.The because their tax bills and land value are not vetch fixes additional nitrogen which it as high as market gardeners in a more urban releases after it’s killed the following spring setting.“We take some land out of production, prior to planting the next cash crop. but in our situation, we have the land,”Eric With the August seeding, the Nordells’ says.“If we had to hire people for weed rye/vetch mixture produces most of its control, it would be more costly.” biomass in fall. See Recommended Resources (p. 162) to order a video describing this system.