Desert Flows Assessment Environmental Water Needs of Riparian & Aquatic Ecosystems in the Desert Watersheds of the U.S
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Desert Flows Assessment Environmental Water Needs of Riparian & Aquatic Ecosystems in the Desert Watersheds of the U.S. and Mexico Kelly E. Mott Lacroix, Elia Tapia, and Abraham E. Springer March 2016 University of Arizona Water Resources Research Center and Northern Arizona University Watershed Ecohydrology Program Desert Flows Assessment Environmental Water Needs of Riparian and Aquatic Ecosystems the Desert Watersheds of the United States and Mexico Kelly E. Mott Lacroix, Elia Tapia, and Abraham E. Springer 2016 i Desert Flows Assessment – 2016 University of Arizona Water Resources Research Center and Northern Arizona University Watershed Ecohydrology Program ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This report was made possible by funding from the Desert Landscape Conservation Cooperative (LCC) via the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation. We thank the members of the DLCC Critical Management Question One team for their advice and review of this document and the Desert Flows Database as well as the 47 land and water managers who took a survey in early 2015. Their responses have shaped the format of the database and this report. ii Desert Flows Assessment – 2016 University of Arizona Water Resources Research Center and Northern Arizona University Watershed Ecohydrology Program CONTENTS Figures ...................................................................................................................................................................... iv Tables ......................................................................................................................................................................... v Executive summary .................................................................................................................................................... 1 Key findings ............................................................................................................................................................ 1 Recommendations ................................................................................................................................................. 2 I. Introduction ...................................................................................................................................................... 4 II. The Desert Landscape Conservation Cooperative (DLCC) Geography .............................................................. 5 III. Desert Flows Database Methodology ............................................................................................................... 9 Phase I - Review/Modification of the Arizona Environmental Flows Database .................................................... 9 Phase II - Literature Review ................................................................................................................................... 9 Phase III - Database Construction, Data Entry, and Data Analysis ....................................................................... 10 IV. Summary and Gap Analysis ............................................................................................................................. 14 Extent of inventory of studies.............................................................................................................................. 14 Methods Used to Determine Environmental Flows ............................................................................................ 18 Quality of Methods .............................................................................................................................................. 21 Elements studied (e.g., flora/fauna monitoring) ................................................................................................. 22 Extent of Riparian and Water Needs/Responses Studies .................................................................................... 24 Relationships Between Riparian Vegetation and Terrestrial and Aquatic Species .............................................. 50 Human Aspects of Environmental Flows Studied ................................................................................................ 51 Risks and Stressors for Ecosystems and Species in the Desert Watersheds of the U.S. and Mexico .................. 53 V. Conclusions and Recommendations .................................................................................................................. 55 VI. References ......................................................................................................................................................... 58 Appendix A: Guide for Use of the Desert Flows Database .................................................................................... A-1 Appendix B: Study Information by Study Index ..................................................................................................... B-1 Appendix C: Study Information by Study Author................................................................................................... C-1 Appendix D: Studies by River ................................................................................................................................. D-1 Appendix E: Species with Flow Needs and Flow Response Data ........................................................................... E-1 iii Desert Flows Assessment – 2016 University of Arizona Water Resources Research Center and Northern Arizona University Watershed Ecohydrology Program FIGURES Figure 1. DLCC Geography ............................................................................................................................................. 5 Figure 2. Location of Perennial streams in the DLCC Geography .................................................................................. 7 Figure 3. Desert LCC Watersheds .................................................................................................................................. 8 Figure 4. Literature Query Method ............................................................................................................................. 10 Figure 5. Method for Standardizing Environmental Flow Needs and Flow Response Data ........................................ 13 Figure 6. Extent and Number of Studies by River Reach ............................................................................................. 16 Figure 7. Flow Methods Classification ......................................................................................................................... 18 Figure 8. Methods by Ecoregion .................................................................................................................................. 19 Figure 9. Quality of Methods in Database ................................................................................................................... 21 Figure 10. Quality of Methods by Ecoregion ............................................................................................................... 22 Figure 11. Studied elements in the DLCC Geography .................................................................................................. 23 Figure 12. Most and Least Studied Elements by Ecoregion ......................................................................................... 23 Figure 13. Extent of Flow Need and Flow Response Studies ....................................................................................... 25 Figure 14. Extent of Flow Needs or Flow Responses Studies for Mesquite ................................................................. 28 Figure 15. Extent of Flow Needs and Flow Responses Studies for Populus ................................................................ 28 Figure 16. Flow Needs and Flow Responses Studies for Salix ..................................................................................... 29 Figure 17. Flow Needs and Flow Responses Studies for Tamarisk .............................................................................. 29 Figure 18. Extent and Number of Studies of Environmental Flow Needs ................................................................... 30 Figure 19. Extent and Number of Species Studied for Flow Needs ............................................................................. 31 Figure 20. Extent and Number of Flow Response Studies ........................................................................................... 42 Figure 21. Count of Species by River with Flow Response Studies .............................................................................. 43 Figure 22. General Categories of Risks and Stressors for the Desert Watersheds of the U.S. and Mexico ................. 53 Figure 23. Detailed Risks and Stressors for Selected General Categories ................................................................... 54 Figure 24. Top Seven General Risks and Stressors by Ecoregion ................................................................................. 55 iv Desert Flows Assessment – 2016 University of Arizona Water Resources Research Center and Northern Arizona University Watershed Ecohydrology Program TABLES Table 1. DLCC Watersheds............................................................................................................................................. 6 Table 2. Database Tables and Fields ...........................................................................................................................