Social Tolerance of Homosexuality: the Patterns of Chinese Societies
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Social Tolerance of Homosexuality: The Patterns of Chinese Societies by Alexi Tianyang Hu B.A., Lanzhou University, 2015 A Thesis Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of MASTER OF ARTS in the Sociology Department Alexi Tianyang Hu, 2020 University of Victoria All rights reserved. This Thesis may not be reproduced in whole or in part, by photocopy or other means, without the permission of the author. We acknowledge with respect the Lekwungen peoples on whose traditional territory the university stands and the Songhees, Esquimalt and WSÁNEĆ peoples whose historical relationships with the land continue to this day. Supervisory Committee Social Tolerance of Homosexuality: The Patterns of Chinese Societies by Alexi Tianyang Hu Lanzhou University, 2015 Supervisory Committee Min Zhou, the Department of Sociology Supervisor Douglas Baer, the Peter B. Gustavson School of Business Outside Member ii Abstract In this thesis, three culturally similar yet distinct Chinese societies, China, Taiwan, and Singapore, are analysed in the context of their (in)tolerance towards homosexuality. Although they share many cultural similarities rooted in Chinese cultural heritage, these three societies are not always socially and politically homogenous. Differences in the political and social systems among the three societies contribute to divergences in social tolerance of homosexuality. Therefore, social tolerance of homosexuality and the social mechanisms behind it are explored in this thesis in order to comprehend the three Chinese societies better. The thesis starts with an introduction to the primary purpose of the research and contextualises homosexuality in historically traditional Chinese culture. It then discerns whether Chinese people are more or less homophobic compared with others on a global scale. Next, through quantitative approaches and under Inglehart’s postmaterialist theoretical framework, the research examines the socioeconomic and sociopolitical heterogeneity among Chinese societies. Overall, the findings confirm that homosexuality is still a form of identity politics in Chinese societies, and political and economic structures profoundly influence the tolerance of homosexuality. Also, Mainland China displays some unusual patterns with respect to the relationship between the economy and the tolerance, which sheds new light on the particularity of Chinese politics. iii Table of Contents SUPERVISORY COMMITTEE ...................................................................................................................... II ABSTRACT ............................................................................................................................................... III TABLE OF CONTENTS ............................................................................................................................... IV LIST OF TABLES ........................................................................................................................................ VI LIST OF FIGURES ..................................................................................................................................... VII ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ......................................................................................................................... VIII CHAPTER 1 ............................................................................................................................................... 1 1.1 INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................................................... 1 1.2 CONTEXTUALIZING THE HISTORY OF HOMOSEXUALITY IN CHINESE SOCIETIES ................................ 4 1.2.1 Ancient Era: A Unique Homosexual Culture ......................................................................... 5 1.2.2 Republican Era: from West to East ........................................................................................ 8 2.1 MAINLAND CHINA: FROM ‘DARK’ AGES TO REFORM ERA: HOMOSEXUALITY IN COMMUNIST CHINA ................................................................................................................................................................. 10 2.2 THE RISE OF CHINESE HOMOSEXUAL RESEARCH AND THE STATUS QUO ...................................... 13 3 A BRIEF HISTORY OF HOMOSEXUALITY IN TAIWANESE SOCIETY ........................................................ 15 4.1 A BRIEF INTRODUCTION OF HOMOSEXUALITY IN SINGAPORE .......................................................... 18 4.2 A SYNOPSIS OF HISTORY OF SINGAPORE ........................................................................................ 19 4.3 THE HISTORY OF HOMOSEXUALITY IN SINGAPORE .......................................................................... 20 CHAPTER 2 ............................................................................................................................................. 22 INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................................................... 22 HOMOSEXUALITY: THE BIRTH OF IDENTITY POLITICS ............................................................................. 22 A BRIEF INTRODUCTION OF SOCIOLOGICAL RESEARCH ON HOMOSEXUALITY ..................................... 24 1. Early studies .................................................................................................................................. 24 2. Two predominant modern theories in homosexual research ................................................. 25 2.1 Post-materialist thesis ................................................................................................................ 25 2.2 World society theory................................................................................................................... 27 UNDERREPRESENTATION OF NON-WESTERN WORLD IN HOMOSEXUAL RESEARCH ........................... 29 ARE CHINESE PEOPLE MORE OR LESS HOMOPHOBIC? A SIMPLE OLS ANALYSIS ............................ 30 CONCLUSION............................................................................................................................................ 34 CHAPTER 3 ............................................................................................................................................. 36 RESEARCH BACKGROUND ...................................................................................................................... 36 RESEARCH HYPOTHESES ........................................................................................................................ 40 DATA ........................................................................................................................................................ 49 METHOD ................................................................................................................................................... 55 RESULTS .................................................................................................................................................. 55 DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION............................................................................................................... 77 CHAPTER 4 ............................................................................................................................................. 84 DATA AND METHODS ............................................................................................................................... 95 iv VARIABLES AND MEASUREMENTS .......................................................................................................... 95 STATISTICAL MODELS ........................................................................................................................... 103 RESULTS ................................................................................................................................................ 105 DISCUSSION ........................................................................................................................................... 119 CONCLUSION.......................................................................................................................................... 128 CHAPTER 5 CONCLUSION AND DISCUSSION ......................................................................................... 140 A CRITICAL REVIEW OF POST-MATERIALIST THESIS AND WORLD SOCIETY THEORY ............................ 140 WHY CAN TAIWAN BECOME THE MOST TOLERANT CHINESE SOCIETY TO HOMOSEXUALITY?............. 143 THE ANOMALY OF POST-MATERIALIST THEORY IN CHINA..................................................................... 144 LIMITATIONS ........................................................................................................................................... 151 BIBLIOGRAPHY ..................................................................................................................................... 155 APPENDIX ............................................................................................................................................ 177 v List of Tables TABLE 1 DESCRIPTIVE STATISTICS FOR VARIABLES USED IN THE ANALYSIS ........................................... 32 TABLE 2 ESTIMATES FOR OLS MODEL PREDICTING TOLERANCE TOWARD HOMOSEXUALITY ................ 33 TABLE 3 DESCRIPTIVE STATISTICS FOR MULTIPLE PREDICTORS