Competitive Exclusion Principle and the Partnership Conundrum: What can teach us about solving conflicts and working together

Sarah Low Philadelphia Field Station US Forest Service – Northern Research Station Objectives

• Think differently about partnerships by applying management principles and ecological terms to inter-organizational dynamics • Focus on the role of in partnership success • Look at some examples of successful partnerships • Think about niches in light of our own partnerships

Photo: Illinois Extension

Photo: Leslie J. Mehrhoff, University of Connecticut, IPANE, http://invasives.eeb.uconn.edu/ipane/ • “Partnerships are important to us. I can’t reiterate that enough. We couldn’t do this alone. That said, we don’t like to compete for things like purchasing land.” – Anonymous, said at a project tour Hypothetical Tree Planting Example

• Municipality is responsible for street trees • group wants to street trees • Philanthropic organization wants to fund the planting of trees Competitive Exclusion Principle

• If two non-interbreeding occupy the same and occupy the same geographic then one will eventually displace the other  (Hardin, Science 1960) Competitive Forces

• Competition for Profit - rivalry among existing competitors Competitive Forces

• Potential Entrants - threat of new entrants Competitive Forces

• Customers – bargaining power of buyers Competitive Forces

• Suppliers - bargaining power of suppliers Competitive Forces

• Substitute Products - threat of substitute products or services Competitive Forces

• Competition for Profit - rivalry among existing competitors • Potential Entrants - threat of new entrants • Customers - bargaining power of buyers • Suppliers - bargaining power of suppliers • Substitute Products - threat of substitute products or services

Michael Porter – “The Five Competitive Forces That Shape Strategy” • “The most successful companies are those that expand the industry profit pool in ways that allow them to share disproportionately in the benefits.”

 Michael Porter – “The Five Competitive Forces That Shape Strategy” Blah, blah, blah, business management jargon, blah, blah, blah Let’s Reframe Competition

What forces of competition exist in the world of urban forestry? Let’s Reframe Competition

• Grants • Donations • Volunteers • New organizations with inspiring missions (or new spins on old ideas) • Influence Let’s Reframe Competition

Possible Translation:

The most effective non-profit organizations are those that expand the available resources in ways that advance the mission.

Resource Partitioning

• Competing shift to occupy different niches Partitioning • “thinking comprehensively about an industry’s structure can uncover opportunities: differences in customers, suppliers, substitutes, potential entrants, and rivals that become the basis for distinct strategies yielding superior performance.” (Porter)

Why work together?

• Sometimes…. Because you have to (the grant agreement told us to) • Limited resources available for everyone • Everyone having trouble getting funding • Lots of work to do

• And mostly to advance the mission

FRAME Collaborative Research

• Forest Fragmentation and Managed

PhillyTreeMap Example

Collaborative Trail Design Partnership Example What to Communicate

• Clarify decision rights • Ensure information flows where it’s needed • Communicate a clear sense of everyone’s respective roles and responsibilities

▫ “The Secrets to Successful Strategy Execution” Neilson et al, 2008 Keys to Building Trust

• Reciprocity

• Face-to-Face Communication

▫ Derived from Elinor Ostrom (2003) Things to keep in mind:

• Know your own interests and say it out loud

• Develop relationships with partners before the grant announcement

• Find ways to partition the resources Group Work • What is your niche? • How are you unique? Different missions, different audiences, different geography? • What do you each bring to this table? • What potential competition might exist between you? • How can you partition the niche so that you can all benefit? • Can you be better together? • Should you be partnering with the groups at the table? Advice from Cesar Chavez

• "We cannot seek achievement for ourselves and forget about progress and prosperity for our community...Our ambitions must be broad enough to include the aspirations and needs of others, for their sakes and for our own." References • Neilson et al. “The Secrets to Successful Strategy Execution” in Harvard Business Review, 2008

• Michael Porter. “The Five Competitive Forces That Shape Strategy” in Harvard Business Review, 2008

• Elinor Ostrom “Toward a Behavioral Theory Linking Trust, Reciprocity, and Reputation” in Trust and Reciprocity, 2003

• Vince D’Amico, et al. FRAME. US Forest Service and the University of Delaware Questions?

• Sarah Low, Coordinator of the Philadelphia Field Station, USDA Forest Service – Northern Research Station • [email protected]