George Square Controversy Burrell Collection Listed My Favourite Building – Mike Russell MSP Ahssspr13 Updated Layout 1 17/04/2013 08:17 Page 2
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
AHSSSpr13 updated_Layout 1 17/04/2013 08:17 Page 1 THEAHSS MAGAZINE OF THE ARCHITECTURAL HERITAGE SOCIETY OF SCOTLAND www.ahss.org.uk AHSS Founded in 1956 – Over 50 years of Commitment I Spring 2013 I No. 33 West Coast Special George Square Controversy Burrell Collection Listed My Favourite Building – Mike Russell MSP AHSSSpr13 updated_Layout 1 17/04/2013 08:17 Page 2 New Members October 2012 - May 2013 Ms Angela Iannetta Mr Stewart Inkster Miss Hazel Johnson Mrs Bridget Mason Mr Jason Pirie Mr Douglas Read Mrs Marie A Reid Ms Jane Roy Dr Hugh Salvesen Mr Brian M Young Mr James Bate Mr Crinan Dunbar Ms Hilary Andexer Join us! Mrs Angela Dow Mr David S Anderson Discover more about Scotland's built heritage and take an active part in its protection Mr Ian Holland Mr Chris Johnstone and preservation by becoming a member of the Society. Mr Alasdair McKay We are committed to encouraging public understanding and appreciation of Mr Darren McLean Scotland's historic built environment. Working across Scotland, the Society supports Ms Janet Ireland & the preservation and restoration of historic buildings, towns and landscapes. Mr Paul Newman Mr Graham Mitchell We do this by: Professor David Muirwood Casework: The Society has a network of local cases panels which monitor Mr E Wall Mr Richard James Wildash applications for planning, listed building, and conservation area consents. Talks & lectures: A lively programme of architecture-related talks and lectures are Corporate Members organised across the Society's regional groups. Visits & tours: A variety of excursions to historic properties, gardens and places of Anderson, Bell Christie Architects architectural interest are regularly organised by the Society's regional groups. Art Institute of Chicago Publications: The Society produces an annual Journal with essays on architectural Benjamin Tindall Architects history and conservation. The Society's magazine, which comes out twice a year, also Craigleith Masonry Conservation Ltd provides a round up of current news from within the built environment sector in Edinburgh City Libraries Scotland with features from guest contributors. Gray, Marshall and Associates Historic Scotland Technical Benefits of membership Conservation Group LDN Architects • You immediately become part of the Society's campaign to protect Scotland's built heritage. National Gallery of Art, Washington Even if you take no active part, your support is vital to the Society. Royal Commission on the Ancient • Participation in the Society's active regional events programme including its National Study Tour. and Historical Monuments of • A free copy of the Society's magazine and academic journal Architectural Heritage. Scotland (RCAHMS) New membership rates from January 2013 RIBA Library (Approved at Annual General Meeting, October 2012) The Robert Gordon University The Royal Incorporation of Architects Single: £35.00 Small charity: £50.00 in Scotland (RIAS) Family: £50.00 Corporate: £140.00 Student: £15.00 Life: £700.00 Simpson & Brown Architects Educational body: £70.00 Life 65+: £350.00 T Graham & Son (Builders) Ltd Personal Benefactor: £85.00 Tod & Taylor Architects For all membership enquiries please contact our Membership Services provider Hall McCartney: Educational Members T: 01462 896688 F: 01462 896677 E: [email protected] Hall McCartney, Heritage House, PO Box 21, Baldock, Hertfordshire, SG7 5SH Centre Canadien d'Architecture Please note, the National Office no longer handles membership enquiries. Edinburgh College of Art Glasgow Life If you renew your membership by cheque you will already have received notice of the revised Historic Scotland Library rates. For members renewing by Standing Order you will short receive a letter from The New Club Library membership services giving details of the change in your subscription rate along with a new Paul Mellon Centre standing order mandate. Swets Information Services Ltd You can give extra support to the AHSS by completing the Gift Aid section of the form which University of Edinburgh, benefits the society by a further £8.75 on a single membership if you pay income tax at no Department of Architecture extra cost to you. University of St Andrews AHSSSpr13 updated_Layout 1 17/04/2013 08:44 Page 3 WELCOME AHSS welcome Spring 2013 l No. 33 elcome to the first AHSS Magazine of 2013. The focus of this issue is squarely President on the West Coast: with the amount of headlines generated by Glasgow City Simon Green MA, FSA, FSA Scot Council’s plans for George Square and the news of the Burrell Collection’s listed Chairman Peter Drummond status and upcoming renovation, there has been enough happening in the area recently to more than fill these pages! Hon Treasurer Hamish Macbeth WAs ever, we have a wide range of contributors, each offering their own perspective and point of Commisioning Editors view on the issues facing the sector. The competition to revamp George Square in Glasgow is probably Gordon Barr one of the most publicly controversial architectural projects in recent years – with over 4,000 people Laura Gutierrez signing a petition calling for the rejection of all shortlisted options. While the long term future of the Reviews Editor square is still under discussion, we feature writer and critic Johnny Rodger’s take on the controversy, Mark Cousins some rather off-the-wall alternative proposals and the views expressed by the Society’s Strathclyde Design cases panel. We hope the opinions contained within these pages will challenge and entertain our Pinpoint Scotland Ltd. readers in equal measure. We both have strong and fond associations with the Society, Gordon as a long time member and frequent contributor to previous magazines and Laura as a former Director. It has been a privilege to NATIONAL OFFICE work alongside each other to bring this magazine together – we hope you enjoy this issue. The Architectural Heritage Society of Scotland Laura Gutierrez and Gordon Barr Riddle’s Court 322 Lawnmarket Edinburgh EH1 2PG T 0131 557 0019 E [email protected] www.ahss.org.uk © AHSS and contributors, 2013 The opinions expressed by contributors in this publication are not necessarily those of the AHSS. The Society contents apologies for any errors or inadvertent infringements of copyright. 03 Editors’ Welcome – Laura Gutierrez and Gordon Barr The AHSS gratefully acknowledges assistance from Historic Scotland 04 towards the production costs of the View from the Chair – Peter Drummond AHSS Magazine. 06 Newsround The AHSS gratefully acknowledges assistance from the Royal Commission 12 Features on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Scotland with archive 12 Talking Points image reproduction and towards production costs of the AHSS 18 Magazine. My Favourite Building – Michael Russell, MSP 19 Projects 29 RCAHMS 32 Point of View 34 Behind the Scenes 36 Historic Scotland Listing and Designed Landscapes Team Update 41 Reviews 49 Members Area 49 Casework 53 Recent Activites 54 One Minute Memory – Hunter Reid 55 Programme of Events Errata – There were two errors in the Autumn 2012 edition of the Magazine (No 32). (1) The article on Page 14 about the Ulster Architectural Heritage Society the organisation was wrongly printed with "of Scotland" at the end of the title. Cover image: Chromolithograph (2) The photographs for the Strathclyde Group North Wales Study Tour were wrongly credited to "Hamish McPherson" it of Municipal Buildings and should have been "Hamish Macbeth". George Square, 1898 © G Barr SPRING 2013 I THE ARCHITECTURAL HERITAGE SOCIETY OF SCOTLAND I 3 AHSSSpr13 updated_Layout 1 17/04/2013 08:17 Page 4 EDITORIAL VIEW FROM THE CHAIR View from the Chair All the MSPs who spoke did so than 2531 buildings on it. I will be the first compellingly, with a clear understanding of to acknowledge that there have been 1424 the issues faced and the importance of our properties saved since the register was set built heritage. The Cabinet Secretary up in 1990, which on the face of it is an highlighted the work of the Buildings at Risk impressive 60 a year. But in the same Peter register, which helped save 32 buildings with period we also lost 410 to demolition. That Drummond a further 26 in the pipeline. is 17 a year. National Chairman, This is just the kind of thing which I There may well be hope for the 199 AHSS would like to hear more of, as policymakers category A listed buildings still on the address issues so close to our hearts. register, but I find myself wondering about However I need to sound two notes of the remaining 2332 category B and C On 20th February, I caution. properties. These very often make a vital attended a debate at the Firstly, only eight MSPs attended the contribution to our villages and towns, but Scottish Parliament on debate. Out of 129. A number who I know are so rarely the recipient of grant “Scotland’s Historic have considerable interest in our sector assistance due to their lower priority. Buildings”. were unavailable due to the pressure of Without action, they may very well join the O the The motion was commendable – work, but it worries me greatly that such a 410 which have been lost to us forever. Parliament recognises what it considers the fantastic resource for the people of What I would very much like to see is vital role that historic houses and buildings Scotland draws such modest numbers. I the enthusiasm of Ms. Hislop, Chic Brodia, play in preserving Scotland’s rich history... cannot help but think that if this was a Graeme Dey, and others at the debate Scotland’s historic buildings are a fantastic debate about a healthcare or education translated into wider engagement from resource for the people of Scotland and will issue, then we would have seen many times the entire chamber and effective action be for future generations, and acknowledges that number.