DOCSLIB.ORG

Algebraic Analysis of Trivium-Like Ciphers (Poster)

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Algebraic Analysis of Trivium-Like Ciphers (Poster) Proceedings of the Twelfth Australasian Information Security Conference (AISC 2014), Auckland, New Zealand Algebraic analysis of Trivium-like ciphers (Poster) Sui-Guan Teo1 Kenneth Koon-Ho Wong1 Harry Bartlett2 Leonie Simpson2 Ed Dawson1 1Institute for Future Environments 2Science and Engineering Faculty Queensland University of Technology 2 George Street, Brisbane QLD 4000, Australia fteosuiguan, [email protected], fh.bartlett, lr.simpson, [email protected] Abstract extended to ciphers in which q > 1 bits of internal state are non-linearly updated at each step and q or Trivium is a bit-based stream cipher in the final port- more linear combinations of the state are output as folio of the eSTREAM project. In this paper, we ap- keystream. However, whether these techniques can ply the algebraic attack approach of Berbain et al. be extended to ciphers in which q > 1 bits of inter- to Trivium-like ciphers and perform new analyses on nal state are non-linearly updated, while only q0 < q them. We demonstrate a new algebraic attack on linear combinations of the state-bits are output, has Bivium-A. This attack requires less time and memory not been demonstrated and is posed as an open ques- than previous techniques to recover Bivium-A's ini- tion (Berbain et. al., 2009). tial state. Though our attacks on Bivium-B, Trivium and Trivium-N are worse than exhaustive keysearch, 1.1 Contributions of paper the systems of equations which are constructed are smaller and less complex compared to previous al- Our algebraic analysis on Trivium-like ciphers, we gebraic analyses. We also answer an open question provide an answer to Berbain et al.'s open ques- posed by Berbain et al. on the feasibility of ap- tion. Specifically, we use Bivium-A/B, Trivium and plying their technique on Trivium-like ciphers. Fac- Trivium-N as case-studies, as q0 < q in all cases. We tors which can affect the complexity of our attack on apply Berbain et al.'s method of representing the feed- Trivium-like ciphers are discussed in detail. Analy- back bits as linear combinations of internal state bits sis of Bivium-B and Trivium-N are omitted from this and keystream bits. manuscript. The full version of this paper is available To assist us in our analysis, we introduce a new on the IACR ePrint Archive. variable j, which describes the number of registers the keystream generation function takes inputs from. 1 Introduction We show that the value of j has a significant impact on the success of our algebraic attack on these ci- 0 Trivium (Canni´ereand Preneel, 2005) is a bit-based phers. The values of q , q and j for the Trivium- stream cipher selected in the final portfolio of the like ciphers are given in Table 1. Some improvements eSTREAM project (Robshaw, 2008). Trivium uses achieved with this new method compared to exist- an 80-bit key and an 80-bit IV to initialise a 288- ing one are presented. Additionally, we investigate bit nonlinear feedback shift register (NLFSR). Each the effect which varying the keystream function and 64 feedback bit positions have on the complexity of our key-IV pair can be used to generate up to 2 bits analysis on the Trivium family. of keystream. Trivium's structural simplicity makes it a popular cipher to cryptanalyse, but to date, no attacks in the public literature are faster than exhaus- Bivium-A Bivium-B Trivium Trivium-N tive keysearch. q 2 2 3 3 Algebraic attacks (Courtois and Meier, 2003) are q0 1 1 1 1 commonly applied to stream ciphers based on shift j 1 2 3 3 registers. To attack Trivium, Raddum (2006) used an algebraic relabelling technique, where the state- Table 1: Parameters for Trivium-like stream ciphers update bits are represented using new variables, instead of nonlinear combinations of initial state bits (Courtois and Pieprzyk, 2002). This prevents equations of high degrees from being generated. For 2 Trivium and its variants keystream generators which use a linear output func- tion (as Trivium-like ciphers do), Berbain et. al. Trivium is commonly represented in the literature as (2009) expressed new feedback bits of an NLFSR as being based on three non-autonomous binary NLF- linear combinations of keystream bits and internal SRs: A, B, and C, of sizes 93, 84 and 111 bits re- state bits. By doing so, the equations representing spectively (Bernstein, 2006). We omit the descrip- the feedback bits of an NLFSR will always be lin- tion of the initialisation process for the cipher, as it ear. Berbain et al. claim that their technique can be has no impact on our analysis. The reader is referred to the specifications of Trivium (Canni´ereand Pre- Copyright c 2014, Australian Computer Society, Inc. This neel, 2005) for a full treatment of its initialisation paper appeared at the Australasian Information Security processes. Let A denote the stages for register A Conference(ACSW-AISC 2014), Auckland, New Zealand, Jan- i uary 2014. Conferences in Research and Practice in Informa- and Ai(t) represent the contents of Ai at time t, for tion Technology (CRPIT), Vol. 149, Udaya Parampalli and Ian 0 ≤ i ≤ 92. Similar notations are used for registers B Welch, Ed. Reproduction for academic, not-for-profit purposes and C. The state-update functions of Trivium are as permitted provided this text is included. 77 CRPIT Volume 149 - Information Security 2014 follows: estimated that the complexity of recovering the initial 56 8 state of Bivium-B will take about 2 seconds. Eibach <A24(t) ⊕ C45(t) et. al. (2010) achieved 239:12 for Bivium-B with some Ai(t + 1) = ⊕C0(t) ⊕ C1(t)C2(t) i = 92; optimisations. Other algebraic analysis on Bivium- :Ai+1(t) 0 ≤ i ≤ 91: A/B use Boolean Satisfiability (SAT) solvers (Eibach 8 et. al., 2008; McDonald et. al., 2008) to recover the <B6(t) ⊕ A27(t) initial state, which are also better than exhaustive Bi(t + 1) = ⊕A0(t) ⊕ A1(t)A2(t) i = 83; keysearch. :Bi+1(t) 0 ≤ i ≤ 82: 8 3 New analysis of Trivium-like ciphers <C24(t) ⊕ B15(t) C (t + 1) = ⊕B (t) ⊕ B (t)B (t) i = 110; i 0 1 2 In this section, we apply Berbain et al.'s approach : Ci+1(t) 0 ≤ i ≤ 109: to the analysis of Bivium-A and Trivium. Similar analyses have been applied to Bivium-B and Trivium- At time t, Trivium's output function generates a N, which are available in the full version of our paper. keystream bit as follows: 3.1 New analysis of Bivium-A z(t) = A27(t) ⊕ A0(t) ⊕ B15(t) ⊕ B0(t) ⊕ C (t) ⊕ C (t), t ≥ 0 Bivium-A's keystream bit zα−1 depends on two se- 45 0 quence bits produced by register B. The sequence We extend this representation of Trivium and con- bits of B after 83 iterations are unknown. Applying sider the keystream as a sequence related to the Berbain at al.'s technique to the equation we can de- three underlying register sequences. The initial termine the equation for calculating the sequence bit state sequences of A; B; C are (A0;A1;:::;A92), Bα+83 for α ≥ 1: (B ;B ;:::;B ) and (C ;C ;:::;C ) respectively. 0 1 83 0 1 110 B = z ⊕ B New sequence bits Aα+92, Bα+83 and Cα+110 are pro- α+83 α+68 α+68 duced after α iterations of Trivium's state-update function as follows: We present a a divide-and-conquer approach to re- cover the initial state of Bivium-A. This involves first A = A ⊕ C ⊕ C ⊕ C C (1) forming a system of equations to recover the contents α+92 α+23 α+44 α−1 α α+1 of register B. Another system of equations is then Bα+83 = Bα+5 ⊕ Aα+26 ⊕ Aα−1 ⊕ AαAα+1 (2) formed using the now known contents of register B Cα+110 = Cα+23 ⊕ Bα+14 ⊕ Bα−1 ⊕ BαBα+1 (3) to recover the contents of register A. The first sys- tem of equations consists of the following equations: The keystream bit can be expressed as a linear com- bination of sequence bits from A, B and C as follows: zα−1 ⊕ Bα−1 ⊕ Bα+14 = 0 (5) Bα+83 ⊕ zα+68 ⊕ Bα+68 = 0 (6) zα−1 = Aα+26 ⊕ Aα−1 where Equation 5 is a keystream equation for Bivium- ⊕ Bα+14 ⊕ Bα−1 ⊕ Cα+44 ⊕ Cα−1 (4) A and Equation 6 the new equation representing Note that the sequence-based approach is analogous Bivium-A's sequence bit Bα+83 derived from our new to the relabelling approach of Raddum (2006). In analysis. For the first 69 iterations, we add two equa- this paper, we use these sequence equations in our tions and one variable into the system of equations: algebraic analysis. one equation representing the keystream, and one Bivium-A/B are reduced versions of Trivium util- equation and variable representing the sequence bit ising only two registers A; B with slightly modified for register B. For the last 39 iterations, we only add feedback functions. The reader is referred to Rad- the equations representing the sequence bits for B. dum (2006) for their specificiations. In Bivium-A, This gives us a final system of equations after 108 it- the keystream bit is generated using erations consisting of 192 variables in 177 equations. Solving this system of equations gives 215 possible so- zα−1 = Bα+14 ⊕ Bα−1 lutions. For each of these 215 possible solutions, we form which is composed with stages from only one register.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Stream Ciphers
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by HAL-CEA Stream ciphers: A Practical Solution for Efficient Homomorphic-Ciphertext Compression Anne Canteaut, Sergiu Carpov, Caroline Fontaine, Tancr`edeLepoint, Mar´ıa Naya-Plasencia, Pascal Paillier, Renaud Sirdey To cite this version: Anne Canteaut, Sergiu Carpov, Caroline Fontaine, Tancr`edeLepoint, Mar´ıaNaya-Plasencia, et al.. Stream ciphers: A Practical Solution for Efficient Homomorphic-Ciphertext Compression. FSE 2016 : 23rd International Conference on Fast Software Encryption, Mar 2016, Bochum, Germany. Springer, 9783 - LNCS (Lecture Notes in Computer Science), pp.313-333, Fast Software Encryption 23rd International Conference, FSE 2016, Bochum, Germany, March 20- 23, 2016, <http://fse.rub.de/>. <10.1007/978-3-662-52993-5 16>. <hal-01280479> HAL Id: hal-01280479 https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01280479 Submitted on 28 Nov 2016 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access L'archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- destin´eeau d´ep^otet `ala diffusion de documents entific research documents, whether they are pub- scientifiques de niveau recherche, publi´esou non, lished or not. The documents may come from ´emanant des ´etablissements d'enseignement et de teaching and research institutions in France or recherche fran¸caisou ´etrangers,des laboratoires abroad, or from public or private research centers. publics ou priv´es. Stream ciphers: A Practical Solution for Efficient Homomorphic-Ciphertext Compression?
    [Show full text]
  • Algebraic Analysis of Trivium-Like Ciphers
    Algebraic analysis of Trivium-like ciphers Sui-Guan Teo1;2, Kenneth Koon-Ho Wong1;2, Harry Bartlett1;2, Leonie Simpson1;2, and Ed Dawson1 1 Institute for Future Environments, Queensland University of Technology [email protected], fkk.wong, h.bartlett, lr.simpson, [email protected] 2 Science and Engineering Faculty, Queensland University of Technology 2 George Street, Brisbane Qld 4000, Australia Keywords: Stream ciphers, Trivium, Trivium-N, Bivium-A, Bivium-B, algebraic attacks Abstract Trivium is a bit-based stream cipher in the final portfolio of the eSTREAM project. In this paper, we apply the approach of Berbain et al. to Trivium-like ciphers and perform new algebraic analyses on them, namely Trivium and its reduced versions: Trivium-N, Bivium-A and Bivium-B. In doing so, we answer an open question in the literature. We demonstrate a new algebraic attack on Bivium-A. This attack requires less time and memory than previous techniques which use the F4 algorithm to recover Bivium-A's initial state. Though our attacks on Bivium-B, Trivium and Trivium-N are worse than exhaustive keysearch, the systems of equations which are constructed are smaller and less complex compared to previous algebraic analysis. Factors which can affect the complexity of our attack on Trivium-like ciphers are discussed in detail. 1 Introduction Trivium [7] is a bit-based stream cipher designed by De Canni´ereand Preneel in 2005 and selected in the final portfolio of the eSTREAM project [12]. Trivium has a 288-bit nonlinear feedback shift register (NLFSR) and uses an 80-bit key and an 80-bit IV to generate keystream.
    [Show full text]
  • Analysis of Lightweight Stream Ciphers
    ANALYSIS OF LIGHTWEIGHT STREAM CIPHERS THÈSE NO 4040 (2008) PRÉSENTÉE LE 18 AVRIL 2008 À LA FACULTÉ INFORMATIQUE ET COMMUNICATIONS LABORATOIRE DE SÉCURITÉ ET DE CRYPTOGRAPHIE PROGRAMME DOCTORAL EN INFORMATIQUE, COMMUNICATIONS ET INFORMATION ÉCOLE POLYTECHNIQUE FÉDÉRALE DE LAUSANNE POUR L'OBTENTION DU GRADE DE DOCTEUR ÈS SCIENCES PAR Simon FISCHER M.Sc. in physics, Université de Berne de nationalité suisse et originaire de Olten (SO) acceptée sur proposition du jury: Prof. M. A. Shokrollahi, président du jury Prof. S. Vaudenay, Dr W. Meier, directeurs de thèse Prof. C. Carlet, rapporteur Prof. A. Lenstra, rapporteur Dr M. Robshaw, rapporteur Suisse 2008 F¨ur Philomena Abstract Stream ciphers are fast cryptographic primitives to provide confidentiality of electronically transmitted data. They can be very suitable in environments with restricted resources, such as mobile devices or embedded systems. Practical examples are cell phones, RFID transponders, smart cards or devices in sensor networks. Besides efficiency, security is the most important property of a stream cipher. In this thesis, we address cryptanalysis of modern lightweight stream ciphers. We derive and improve cryptanalytic methods for dif- ferent building blocks and present dedicated attacks on specific proposals, including some eSTREAM candidates. As a result, we elaborate on the design criteria for the develop- ment of secure and efficient stream ciphers. The best-known building block is the linear feedback shift register (LFSR), which can be combined with a nonlinear Boolean output function. A powerful type of attacks against LFSR-based stream ciphers are the recent algebraic attacks, these exploit the specific structure by deriving low degree equations for recovering the secret key.
    [Show full text]
  • Slid Pairs in Salsa20 and Trivium
    Slid Pairs in Salsa20 and Trivium Deike Priemuth-Schmid and Alex Biryukov FSTC, University of Luxembourg 6, rue Richard Coudenhove-Kalergi, L-1359 Luxembourg (deike.priemuth-schmid, alex.biryukov)@uni.lu Abstract. The stream ciphers Salsa20 and Trivium are two of the ¯- nalists of the eSTREAM project which are in the ¯nal portfolio of new promising stream ciphers. In this paper we show that initialization and key-stream generation of these ciphers is slidable, i.e. one can ¯nd distinct (Key, IV) pairs that produce identical (or closely related) key-streams. There are 2256 and more then 239 such pairs in Salsa20 and Trivium respectively. We write out and solve the non-linear equations which de- scribe such related (Key, IV) pairs. This allows us to sample the space of such related pairs e±ciently as well as detect such pairs in large portions of key-stream very e±ciently. We show that Salsa20 does not have 256-bit security if one considers general birthday and related key distinguishing and key-recovery attacks. Key words: Salsa20, Trivium, eSTREAM, stream ciphers, cryptanalysis 1 Introduction In 2005 Bernstein [2] submitted the stream cipher Salsa20 to the eSTREAM- project [5]. Original Salsa20 has 20 rounds, later 8 and 12 rounds versions Salsa20/8 and Salsa20/12 were also proposed. The cipher Salsa20 uses the hash function Salsa20 in a counter mode. It has 512-bit state which is initialized by copying into it 128 or 256-bit key, 64-bit nonce and counter and 128-bit constant. Previous attacks on Salsa used di®erential cryptanalysis exploiting a truncated di®erential over three or four rounds.
    [Show full text]
  • Extending the Salsa20 Nonce
    Extending the Salsa20 nonce Daniel J. Bernstein ? Department of Computer Science (MC 152) The University of Illinois at Chicago Chicago, IL 60607{7053 [email protected] Abstract. This paper introduces the XSalsa20 stream cipher. XSalsa20 is based upon the Salsa20 stream cipher but has a much longer nonce: 192 bits instead of 64 bits. XSalsa20 has exactly the same streaming speed as Salsa20, and its extra nonce-setup cost is slightly smaller than the cost of generating one block of Salsa20 output. This paper proves that XSalsa20 is secure if Salsa20 is secure: any fast attack on XSalsa20 using q queries and succeeding with probability p can be converted into a fast attack on Salsa20 succeeding with probability at least p=(q + 1). Keywords. Extended nonces, stream ciphers, high security, high speed, security proofs 1 Introduction eSTREAM, the ECRYPT Stream Cipher Project, called for submissions of stream ciphers in November 2004. It received more than 30 proposals from 97 cryptographers in 19 countries, and over the subsequent years collected a total of 200 papers. The “final eSTREAM portfolio," containing four software stream ciphers and four hardware stream ciphers, was announced in April 2008. The portfolio was revised in September 2008 to eliminate a hardware stream cipher, F-FCSR v2, that had been broken. eSTREAM focused on 80-bit keys for hardware and 128-bit keys for software, but three of the final four software ciphers also have high-security variants: • Sosemanuk, 256-bit key, 128-bit nonce, 4:22 cycles/byte, 3:43 cycles/byte; • Salsa20, 256-bit key, 64-bit nonce, 3:91 cycles/byte, 3:86 cycles/byte; and • HC-256, 256-bit key, 256-bit nonce, 34:91 cycles/byte, 4:15 cycles/byte.
    [Show full text]
  • Golden Fish an Intelligent Stream Cipher Fuse Memory Modules
    Golden Fish: An Intelligent Stream Cipher Fuse Memory Modules Lan Luo 1，2，QiongHai Dai 1，ZhiGuang Qin 2 ，ChunXiang Xu 2 1Broadband Networks & Digital Media Lab School of Information Science & Technology Automation Dep. Tsinghua University ，BeiJing, China,100084 2 School of Computer Science and Technology University of Electronic Science Technology of China, ChengDu, China, 610054 E-mail: [email protected] Abstract Furthermore, we can intelligent design the ciphers according to different network environments [4-5]. In In this paper, we use a high-order iterated function order to demonstrate our approach, we construct a generated by block cipher as the nonlinear filter to simple synchronous stream cipher, which provides a improve the security of stream cipher. Moreover, by significant flexibility for hardware implementations, combining the published rounds function in block with many desirable cryptographic advantages. The cipher and OFB as the nonlinear functional mode with security of the encryption and decryption are based on an extra memory module, we enable to control the the computational complexity, which is demonstrated nonlinear complexity of the design. This new approach by AES and NESSIE competition recently, where all fuses the block cipher operation mode with two the finalists fall into the category “no attack or memory modules in one stream cipher. The security of weakness demonstrated”, in which people can go for this design is proven by the both periodic and the simplest, and most elegant design comparing an nonlinear evaluation. The periods of this structure is more complicate and non-transparent one. To guaranteed by the traditional Linear Feedback Shift implement the idea above, we take output feedback Register design and the security of nonlinear mode (OFB) of the block cipher as the nonlinear filter characteristic is demonstrated by block cipher in stream cipher design.
    [Show full text]
  • Correlation Cube Attacks: from Weak-Key Distinguisher to Key Recovery
    Correlation Cube Attacks: From Weak-Key Distinguisher to Key Recovery B Meicheng Liu( ), Jingchun Yang, Wenhao Wang, and Dongdai Lin State Key Laboratory of Information Security, Institute of Information Engineering, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100093, People’s Republic of China [email protected] Abstract. In this paper, we describe a new variant of cube attacks called correlation cube attack. The new attack recovers the secret key of a cryp- tosystem by exploiting conditional correlation properties between the superpoly of a cube and a specific set of low-degree polynomials that we call a basis, which satisfies that the superpoly is a zero constant when all the polynomials in the basis are zeros. We present a detailed procedure of correlation cube attack for the general case, including how to find a basis of the superpoly of a given cube. One of the most significant advantages of this new analysis technique over other variants of cube attacks is that it converts from a weak-key distinguisher to a key recovery attack. As an illustration, we apply the attack to round-reduced variants of the stream cipher Trivium. Based on the tool of numeric mapping intro- duced by Liu at CRYPTO 2017, we develop a specific technique to effi- ciently find a basis of the superpoly of a given cube as well as a large set of potentially good cubes used in the attack on Trivium variants, and further set up deterministic or probabilistic equations on the key bits according to the conditional correlation properties between the super- polys of the cubes and their bases.
    [Show full text]
  • Computer Science and Cybersecurity (Cs&Cs
    ISSN 2519-2310 CS&CS, Issue 3(11) 2018 UDC 004.056.55 STATISTICAL PROPERTIES OF MODERN STREAM CIPHERS Oleksii Nariezhnii, Egor Eremin, Vladislav Frolenko, Kyrylo Chernov, Tetiana Kuznetsova, Yevhen Demenko V. N. Karazin Kharkiv National University, 6 Svobody Sq., Kharkiv, 61022, Ukraine [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected] Reviewer: Ivan Gorbenko, Doctor of Sciences (Engineering), Full Professor, Academician of the Academy of Applied Radioelec- tronics Sciences, V. N. Karazin Kharkiv National University, 4 Svobody Sq., Kharkiv, 61022, Ukraine [email protected] Received on September 2018 Abstract. In recent years, numerous studies of stream symmetric ciphers in Ukraine are continuing, the main purpose of which is to argue the principles of creating a new cryptographic algorithm, which can be based on the national standard. One of the essential aspects in choosing from many alternatives is the statistical properties of the output pseudorandom sequence (key stream). In this paper, the results of comparative studies of statistical properties of out- put sequences, which are formed by various stream ciphers, in particular, by world-known algorithms Enocoro, Dec- im, Grain, HC, MUGI, Mickey, Rabbit, RC-4, Salsa20, SNOW2.0, Sosemanuk, Trivium and the Ukrainian crypto- graphic algorithm Strumok, that was developed in recent years, are presented. For comparative studies, the NIST STS method was used, according to which experimental studies are performed in 15 statistical tests, the purpose of which is to determine the randomness of the output binary sequences. Each of the tests is aimed at studying certain vulnerabilities of the generator, that is, points to the potential usage of different methods of cryptographic analysis.
    [Show full text]
  • Breaking Trivium Stream Cipher Implemented in ASIC Using Experimental Attacks and DFA
    sensors Article Breaking Trivium Stream Cipher Implemented in ASIC Using Experimental Attacks and DFA Francisco Eugenio Potestad-Ordóñez * , Manuel Valencia-Barrero , Carmen Baena-Oliva , Pilar Parra-Fernández and Carlos Jesús Jiménez-Fernández Departament of Electronic Technology, University of Seville, Virgen de Africa 7, 41011 Seville, Spain; [email protected] (M.V.-B.); [email protected] (C.B.-O.); [email protected] (P.P.-F.); [email protected] (C.J.J.-F.) * Correspondence: [email protected] Received: 1 November 2020; Accepted: 1 December 2020; Published: 3 December 2020 Abstract: One of the best methods to improve the security of cryptographic systems used to exchange sensitive information is to attack them to find their vulnerabilities and to strengthen them in subsequent designs. Trivium stream cipher is one of the lightweight ciphers designed for security applications in the Internet of things (IoT). In this paper, we present a complete setup to attack ASIC implementations of Trivium which allows recovering the secret keys using the active non-invasive technique attack of clock manipulation, combined with Differential Fault Analysis (DFA) cryptanalysis. The attack system is able to inject effective transient faults into the Trivium in a clock cycle and sample the faulty output. Then, the internal state of the Trivium is recovered using the DFA cryptanalysis through the comparison between the correct and the faulty outputs. Finally, a backward version of Trivium was also designed to go back and get the secret keys from the initial internal states. The key recovery has been verified with numerous simulations data attacks and used with the experimental data obtained from the Application Specific Integrated Circuit (ASIC) Trivium.
    [Show full text]
  • Response to “Slid Pairs in Salsa20 and Trivium”
    Response to \Slid Pairs in Salsa20 and Trivium" Daniel J. Bernstein ? Department of Computer Science University of Illinois at Chicago Chicago, IL 60607{7045 [email protected] The paper \Slid Pairs in Salsa20 and Trivium" by Priemuth-Schmid and Biryukov states various \attacks" on Salsa20 and Trivium. The paper claims that \Salsa20 does not have 256-bit security," that its \attacks" demonstrate a “certificational weakness" in Salsa20, that \it is crucial for the security of Salsa20 that nonces are chosen at random," that the \attacks" can be \exploited in certain scenarios," etc. These claims are entirely without merit. The \attacks" on Salsa20 are vastly more expensive than the standard brute-force attacks discussed in the original Salsa20 documentation. (I haven't looked at the \attacks" on Trivium.) Specifically, the best \attack" in the paper receives ciphertexts from 2191 users and finds a 256-bit key after time 2192 on a machine of size roughly 2192. This is described as an \improved" version of a trivial birthday attack that needs ciphertexts from 2192 users. See Table 3 in the paper. For comparison, standard cipher-independent brute-force attacks receive a very small amount of ciphertext and find a 256-bit key after time 2128 on a machine of size roughly 2128. More sophisticated, but still standard, cipher- independent brute-force attacks receive ciphertexts from (for example) 264 users and find a 256-bit key after time 296 on a machine of size roughly 296. (See, e.g., my 2005 paper \Understanding brute force.") Standard brute-force attack New \attack" 264 inputs 2191 inputs time 296 to break one input time 2192 to break one input machine cost 296 machine cost 2192 The fundamental reason that the new \attack" is so expensive, compared to standard attacks, is that the \attack" starts from a hypothesized key-pair 256 relation R(k0; k1) that is satisfied with probability only about 1=2 .
    [Show full text]
  • Analysis of Area-Efficiency Vs. Unrolling for Estream Hardware Portfolio Stream Ciphers
    electronics Article Analysis of Area-Efficiency vs. Unrolling for eSTREAM Hardware Portfolio Stream Ciphers Fares Alharbi 1, Muhammad Khurram Hameed 2, Anusha Chowdhury 3, Ayesha Khalid 4, Anupam Chattopadhyay 5 and Ibrahim Tariq Javed 6,* 1 Computer Science Department, Shaqra University, Shaqra 15526, Saudi Arabia; [email protected] 2 Computer Science Department, Bahria University, Islamabad 44000, Pakistan; [email protected] 3 Department of Computer Science and Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology, Kanpur 208016, India; [email protected] 4 School of Electronics, Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, Queens University, Belfast BT7 1NN, UK; [email protected] 5 School of Computer Science and Engineering, Nanyang Technological University, 50 Nanyang Ave, Singapore 639798, Singapore; [email protected] 6 Lero-The Irish Software Research Centre, University of Limerick, V94 T9PX Limerick, Ireland * Correspondence: [email protected] Received: 22 October 2020; Accepted: 12 November 2020; Published: 17 November 2020 Abstract: The demand for low resource devices has increased rapidly due to the advancements in Internet-of-things applications. These devices operate in environments that have limited resources. To ensure security, stream ciphers are implemented on hardware due to their speed and simplicity. Amongst different stream ciphers, the eSTREAM ciphers stand due to their frugal implementations. This work probes the effect of unrolling on the efficiency of eSTREAM ciphers, including Trivium, Grain (Grain 80 and Grain 128) and MICKEY (MICKEY 2.0 and MICKEY-128 2.0). It addresses the question of optimal unrolling for designing high-performance stream ciphers. The increase in the area consumption is also bench-marked.
    [Show full text]
  • Correlation Cube Attacks: from Weak-Key Distinguisher to Key Recovery?
    Correlation Cube Attacks: From Weak-Key Distinguisher to Key Recovery? Meicheng Liu, Jingchun Yang, Wenhao Wang, and Dongdai Lin State Key Laboratory of Information Security, Institute of Information Engineering, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100093, P. R. China [email protected] Abstract. In this paper, we describe a new variant of cube attacks called correlation cube attack. The new attack recovers the secret key of a cryptosystem by exploiting conditional correlation properties between the superpoly of a cube and a specific set of low-degree polynomials that we call a basis, which satisfies that the superpoly is a zero constant when all the polynomials in the basis are zeros. We present a detailed procedure of correlation cube attack for the general case, including how to find a basis of the superpoly of a given cube. One of the most significant advantages of this new analysis technique over other variants of cube attacks is that it converts from a weak-key distinguisher to a key recovery attack. As an illustration, we apply the attack to round-reduced variants of the stream cipher Trivium. Based on the tool of numeric mapping introduced by Liu at CRYPTO 2017, we develop a specific technique to efficiently find a basis of the superpoly of a given cube as well as a large set of potentially good cubes used in the attack on Trivium variants, and further set up deterministic or probabilistic equations on the key bits according to the conditional correlation properties between the superpolys of the cubes and their bases. For a variant when the number of initialization rounds is reduced from 1152 to 805, we can recover about 7-bit key information on average with time complexity 244, using 245 keystream bits and preprocessing time 251.
    [Show full text]