Catalytic Properties of the Caspases
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Cell Death and Differentiation (1999) 6, 1054 ± 1059 ã 1999 Stockton Press All rights reserved 13509047/99 $15.00 http://www.stockton-press.co.uk/cdd Review Catalytic properties of the caspases HR Stennicke1 and GS Salvesen*,1 bond hydrolase, and includes endopeptidases and exopepti- dases. Caspases are strict endopeptidases. From a mechan- 1 The Program for Apoptosis and Cell Death Research, The Burnham Institute, istic point of view most proteases utilize their ability to force the 10901 North Torrey Pines Road, La Jolla, California, CA92037, USA trigonal planar peptide bond into a tetrahedal geometry as a * Corresponding author: GS Salvesen, The Program for Apoptosis and Cell prerequisite for hydrolysis. Thus, the majority of the available Death Research, The Burnham Institute, 10901 North Torrey Pines Road, La binding energy is used for stabilizing this tetrahedral Jolla, California, CA 92037, USA. Tel: +1 (619) 646 3114; Fax: +1 (619) 646 3189; E-mail: [email protected] intermediate rather than merely forming an enzyme-substrate complex. The ability to catalyze the hydrolysis of the peptide Received 20.5.99; accepted 21.9.99 bond at neutral pH and ambient temperatures therefore Edited by D Nicholson characterizes proteases, where various catalytic mechanisms are located in a variety of otherwise unrelated protein scaffolds. At least five distinct catalytic mechanisms have been Abstract discovered in proteases, but irrespective of the type of Caspase stands for cysteine-dependent aspartate specific residues involved in the particular mechanisms, the key protease, and is a term coined to define proteases related to features are identical. About the point in the reaction coordinate where the enzyme pulls the peptide bond into interleukin 1b converting enzyme and CED-3.1 Thus their tetrahedral geometry, a nucleophile adds to the carbonyl enzymatic properties are governed by a dominant specificity carbon of the scissile bond. In some families of proteases (the for substrates containing Asp, and by the use of a Cys side- metallo- and aspartic protease classes) this is simply done by chain for catalyzing peptide bond cleavage. The use of a Cys making a water molecule nucleophilic through specific side chain as a nucleophile during peptide bond hydrolysis is interactions to groups in the protease. In others (the common to several protease families. However, the primary cysteine, serine, and threonine protease classes) a side- specificity for Asp turns out to be very rare among protease chain within the protease acts as the nucleophile, forming a families throughout biotic kingdoms. Of all known mammalian covalent adduct (an ester) with the substrate during catalysis. proteases only the caspase activator granzyme B, a serine Hydrolysis of substrate by these latter classes occurs by protease, has the same primary specificity. In addition to this displacement of the ester. The second step in peptide bond unusual primary specificity, caspases are remarkable in that hydrolysis is the protonation of the a-amino moiety of the leaving group, which is particularly important in cysteine certain of their zymogens have intrinsic proteolytic activity. proteases such as the caspases due to the lower stability of This latter property is essential to trigger the proteolytic the thiol ester intermediate compared to regular esters. pathways that lead to apoptosis. Here we review the known In the case of the caspases it is the formation of a enzymatic properties of the caspases and their zymogens tetrahedral intermediate by promotion of a cysteine residue within the broad context of structure:mechanism:activity to act as a nucleophile that is the pivotal point in catalysis relationships of proteases in general. and thus, we will focus on this particular mechanism for promoting hydrolysis. The organization of the catalytic site, Keywords: protease; proteolysis; catalytic mechanism; caspase the geometry of the residues, and the distance between them, all have a variety of implications for protease Abbreviations: AMC, 7-amino-ymethyl-coumarin; +PA, tissue functions in vivo. This particular point becomes very clear plasminogen activator when comparing two proteases that uses the same catalytic machinery to promote the breakage of the peptide bond, but on quite different scaffolds as it is the case for the caspase family and the papain family. Though they use Breaking the peptide bond essentially the same catalytic mechanism, these two The emergence of amino acids as the building blocks of families of cysteine proteases have some very significant proteins allows for the combination of stability, strength, and differences in the promotion of catalysis as well as the structural features unique to the peptide bond. However, this organization of the substrate binding site. strength and stability of the peptide bond also makes specific cleavage or degradation of proteins by hydrolysis much more Catalytic mechanism than a simple `just add water' problem. This is evident from the fact that non-catalyzed hydrolysis of proteins requires Like other cysteine proteases, the caspases contain a prolonged heating even in the presence of strong acids. catalytic Cys-His pair with Cys285 acting as the nucleophile Thus, enzymes that cleave peptide bonds (peptidases or and His237 acting as the general base to abstract the proton proteases) have high energy barriers to overcome. The term from the catalytic Cys and promote the nucleophile (Figure 1). protease is synonymous with peptidase, meaning peptide The numbering of caspase residues follows the caspase 1 Catalytic properties of the caspases HR Stennicke and GS Salvesen 1055 3 convention. Interestingly, serine proteases (such as trypsin, drop in kcat. In the caspases this third component of the tissue plasminogen activator, and subtilisin) also frequently catalytic triad is not a side-chain, but rather is proposed to be contain a His residue that accompanies the catalytic Ser. In the backbone carbonyl group of residue 177, which in the model cysteine protease papain, where the cysteine caspase 1 is a proline and in caspase 3 a threonine.4,5 protease catalytic mechanism has been studied most Unfortunately, the importance of this third member is difficult extensively, it is believed that the Cys-His dyad exists as an to establish in the caspases since the interactions are to a ion-pair where the thiol proton of the catalytic Cys has been backbone moiety, which cannot easily be experimentally transferred to the acceptor His before substrate binding.2 Pre- verified by mutagenesis. Furthermore, alignment of the polarization of the catalytic nucleophile represents one of the known mammalian caspases (Accession PF00656)6 does major differences between the serine and cysteine proteases, not reveal any significant conservation in the region since in the serine proteases the nucleophile is believed to surrounding the putative third member of the triad, allowing develop along the reaction coordinate. While the ability of the us to raise the hypothesis that the putative third member may catalytic His to abstract a proton from the catalytic Cys is not exist in the caspase structure and mechanism. extremely important, the ability to protonate the a-amino group Investigations of the pH dependence of caspase of the scissile bond is expected to be at least as important in catalysis have provided useful insights into the catalytic the caspases. The reason for the importance of the mechanism. Human caspases exhibit only minor differ- protonation of this group lies in the properties and reactivity ences in pH profiles, and all are maximally active within the of the thiol ester: its susceptibility to nucleophilic attack. Thus, pH range and ionic strength of cell cytosols.7,8 They all if the a-amino group is not protonated the reformation of the exhibit a rather narrow bell-shaped pH dependence with peptide bond will be favored over the release of the leaving optima in the range 6.8 ± 7.2 signifying the existence of one group, and consequently proteolysis will not occur. active form of the enzyme with the increase in activity most In many proteases the side-chain of a third residue plays a likely due to the de-protonation of the catalytic Cys residue. significant role in the promotion of catalysis. The majority of In this respect the caspases closely resemble other the members of the papain family contain an Asn side-chain unrelated cysteine proteases such as papain in their that is believed to orient the histidine in the Cys-His ion-pair, activity pH profiles although the pH-profile is much more thereby influencing catalysis.3 Indeed, when Asn175 is narrow than that found for papain.9 Interestingly, the replaced by an alanine in papain, the catalytic activity is substitution of the third member of the catalytic triad in decreased by more than 100-fold mainly due to a significant papain also results in a considerable narrowing of the pH profile due to the increased distance between the catalytic residues.3 This observation supports the lack of a third member of the catalytic triad in caspases since examination of the structure of papain complexed with leupeptin reveals a distance between the catalytic residues to be 3.75 AÊ ,10 which is significantly less than the distance of 5.2 AÊ found in the caspase:aldehyde structures.4,5 Interestingly, the large distance between catalytic Cys and His residues in caspase structures argues against an ion pair, with the implication that the Cys may not be pre-polarized. The substrate binding site The substrate binding site in all proteases is composed of a fairly large number of amino acid residues that secure proper alignment of the substrates prior to hydrolysis and help promote catalysis through stabilization of the transition state. The binding site is divided into a number of sub-sites (see Figure 2), each securing a single amino acid residue of the substrate by multiple interactions. In addition to interactions Figure 1 The minimal caspase catalytic site.