A Guide to Global Citizenship the 2019 Cbi Index
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Special Report August/September 2019 A GUIDE TO GLOBAL CITIZENSHIP THE 2019 CBI INDEX in association with CORPORATE STATEMENT MAP The 13 citizenship by investment jurisdictions Austria Bulgaria Tu rkey St Kitts and Nevis Antigua and Barbuda Malta Cyprus Cambodia Dominica Jordan St Lucia Vanuatu Grenada 2 AUGUST/SEPTEMBER 2019 CONTENTS August/September 2019 pwmnet.com cbiindex.com Published by: Financial Times Ltd, Bracken House, 1 Friday Street, London EC4M 9BT SPECIAL REPORT +44 (0)20 7873 3000 www.pwmnet.com Staff members can be contacted by dialing A GUIDE +44 (0)20 7775 followed by their extension number. TO GLOBAL Editor-in-Chief Yuri Bender 6376 [email protected] Deputy Editor CITIZENSHIP Elisa Trovato 6374 [email protected] Chief Sub-Editor THE 2019 and Senior Writer Elliot Smither 6379 [email protected] Advertising CBI INDEX Andrew Campbell 6865 Projects Director [email protected] Adrian Northey 6333 Global Business Director [email protected] Senior Marketing Manager Raj Rai 6340 [email protected] Senior Marketing Executive Dimple Khatri +44(0)20 7873 4028 [email protected] Publishing Director Angus Cushley 6354 Design Kostya Penkov 3255 [email protected] Production Daniel Macklin 4120 [email protected] Printed by Walstead Group in the UK Annual subscriptions: £415 | €525 | $675 Subscription Enquiries: tel: +44(0)20 7873 4240, [email protected] Change of Address Notification [email protected] © Financial Times 2019 PWM is a trademark of Financial 04 INTRODUCTION 14 BEYOND DUE DILIGENCE Times. “Financial Times” and Wealthy individuals and their families seek second The ability to revoke citizenship is an important tool “FT” are registered trademarks and service marks of the citizenship for a number of reasons and the benefits for both citizenship by investment jurisdictions and Financial Times Ltd. All rights reserved. No part of this for nations offering CBI schemes can be considerable successful applicants to their programmes publication may be reproduced or used in any form of advertising without prior permission in writing from the 06 THE 2019 CBI INDEX 16 METHODOLOGY editor. No responsibility for loss The citizenship by investment industry has continued The CBI Index is built around seven pillars, occasioned to any person acting or refraining from acting as a its rapid evolution with countries boosting their visa- designed to satisfactorily measure global result of material in this publication can be accepted. On free offerings and adding new investment routes citizenship programme features and jurisdictional any specific matter, reference should be made to an desirability appropriate adviser. Registered 07 FDI FOR THE PEOPLE Office: Number One Southwark Citizens should benefit from programme-generated 20 KEY FINDINGS Bridge, London SE1 9HL, UK The Financial Times adheres to foreign direct investment. Yet some nations have been The CBI Index’s key findings present an evaluation of a self-regulation regime under the FT Editorial Code of more successful than others each country both overall and within the parameters Practice: www.ft.com/editorial of the seven pillars code 08 PAST, PRESENT, AND FUTURE The citizenship by investment industry is one that is 24 THE SEVEN PILLARS constantly in flux and is not to be entered lightly An overview of the seven pillars that form the CBI Index 10 COLLABORATION It is likely that cooperation between nations in the 26 PROGRAMME PROFILES citizenship by investment industry will grow A closer look at the 13 citizenship by investment programmes which make up the 2019 CBI Index 11 TAX RESIDENCE Citizenship and tax residency confer different sets of 34 COUNTRY SNAPSHOTS rights and obligations on individuals Key information about the 13 nations that make up the CBI Index 12 CASE STUDY One of the main features of the Caribbean citizenship by investment programmes is thorough due diligence, explains Kieron Sharp, CEO of FACT Due Diligence Published in youtube.com/ Professional Wealth @FT_PWM association with: FTPWM Management Group PWMNET.COM 3 CBI a valuable tool for those who see themselves as global citizens WRITTEN BY YURI BENDER countries travel more freely. A second INTRODUCTION citizenship or passport can also be a good insurance policy if things turn Wealthy individuals and their ugly back home. There is definitely a families seek second Demand, they say, is now hierarchy, in descending citizenship for a number of spreading to all corners of the globe. reasons while the benefits for “Investors from unstable regions order of disdain for nations offering CBI schemes will use citizenship by investment (CBI) to shield assets from countries that sell their can be considerable nationalisation, social unrest or revolutionary risk,” says one senior citizenships too cheaply articipants in an industry private banker. JOHN ERRINGTON ERRINGTON BOSE IMMIGRATION SERVICES which offers citizenship Legal consultancy firms which for predominantly smaller specialise in providing CBI solutions nations, in exchange for many jurisdictions, including one of the most lucrative hunting Pfor investments in local CS Global Partners and Henley & grounds for CBI scheme providers. facilities including tourism and Partners, both based in London, Its inhabitants, and those of other infrastructure, report increasing say the main reasons their clients regions of growing wealth, are demand for their services. They put need second passports are security, demanding greater mobility and this down to growing wealth and plus broadening opportunities for Due to its massive are prepared to pay for citizenships the tendency for high net worth their families in business, travel and population and which allows this. individuals to become more globally education. growing economy, Chinese applicants account China has probably minded. the biggest influence for approximately 45 per cent They also see this acquisition of CHINESE DEMAND on the major and of applications approved by the citizenship by citizenship, for a price, as a legitimate Due to its massive population and investment major Caribbean CBI programmes, device to help people from restricted growing economy, China offers programmes according to Christofer Ashby, managing director of L’esterre Holdings Inc, a Grenada-based property developer specialising in CBI projects. For Chinese clients, investment migration is often driven by the education of their children, for whom they normally prefer Western, especially US, universities. Grenada’s CBI programme, for instance, offers a multiple E-2 visa treaty with the US, allowing approved applicants to live and work there with the majority of the benefits of a resident, but without the costs or time of obtaining an EB-5 US visa, according to Mr Ashby. Commentators assert that because there is now such a long waiting list for US and UK residence visas, “spill- over” clientele are directing their applications to CBI schemes from other centres. 4 AUGUST/SEPTEMBER 2019 INTRODUCTION SPECIAL REPORT Industry specialists report that the majority of CBI applications are for schemes from the likes of Dominica, Grenada and St Kitts and Nevis in the Caribbean, and Cyprus and Malta in the European Union. St Kitts & Nevis was the first nation to implement a CBI programme, country in order to provide their CBI Dominica’s scheme or Venezuela can happen anywhere, while Dominica’s is hugely investment stake. has helped to mitigate any day.” important to its economy, helping Caribbean property developers some of the Before, most wealthy individuals devastating damage to mitigate the devastating damage say that most investors from outside housing and chose to move to the UK or US, wreaked by Tropical Storm Erika in the region buying into real estate infrastructure wreaked but these destinations may have 2015 and Hurricane Maria in 2017. through CBI programmes already by Hurricane Maria in lost something of their traditional 2017 have legal funds both inside and appeal. WELL REGARDED outside their home jurisdictions. “A lot of Middle Easterners don’t At Errington Bose Immigration Critics of CBI schemes often want to come to the US, just as a lot Services in London, St Kitts and imply that the hubs which provide of Europeans don’t want to come to Nevis and Antigua and Barbuda passports accept migrating tycoons the UK anymore because of Brexit,” are seen as particularly popular who have broken strict exchange he says. for CBI applications, among the controls in their own countries, in “Families are looking at Malta, firm’s clientele, which has strong order to expatriate the substantial Portugal and Cyprus in the EU. Middle Eastern, Russian and Central sums needed to buy real estate or These are the countries opening American contingents. invest in industry. their doors with investor visas and “For clients with multiple But this is countered by the law offering facilitation of citizenship citizenship strategies, these firms. “Most of the ultra-high net and investment projects.” jurisdictions tend to fit their worth investment clients that we Henley & Partners also talk circumstances better than others,” deal with already changed their about a notion of “sovereign says John Errington, the specialist domicile years ago and now look equity”, where assets from wealthy law firm’s managing director. to further optimise their current individuals are transferred to Travel documents issued by other situation with regard to residence developing countries through their countries which are involved in and citizenship planning,” says Dr CBI programmes to help create CBI schemes are not always so well Juerg Steffen, Group CEO at Henley significant sovereign and societal respected, he suggests. & Partners. “This means they don’t value. “There is definitely a hierarchy, fall under the capital transfer Through engaging with the in descending order of disdain for limitations.” global community of high net countries that sell their citizenships This is confirmed by the CEO of a worth investors, developing nation too cheaply. It is not illegal, but it major global private bank, who says governments can achieve fiscal is not the purpose of EU treaties,” most clients from politically volatile independence and address growing warns Mr Errington.