LISTING OF CITATIONS - VALUATION APPEAL COMMITTEE

Hearing on 11th July 2018 at 10.00 am in Moray Council Annexe, Training Room 2, 2-10 High Street, Elgin, Iv30 1bx

Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

1 22859/56956 WORKSHOP THOMAS MCWHIRTER P 9,100 9,100 LOSSIEBANK T/A DECORA LTD BRIDGE STREET ELGIN F G BURNETT LTD A

2 22951/53725 DEPOT THE MORAY COUNCIL P 223,000 223,000 ASHGROVE ROAD ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

3 48172/56346 DEPOT NATIONAL GRID PROPERTY HOLDINGS LTD P 13,750 13,750 ASHGROVE ROAD ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

4 30908/61866 STORES ETC NATIONAL GRID PROPERTY HOLDINGS LTD P 30,250 30,250 ASHGROVE ROAD ELGIN JONES LANG LASALLE A

5 48179/54652 STORE ANDERSON & ENGLAND P 17,500 17,500 ASHGROVE ROAD ELGIN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

6 48908/63110 WORKSHOP ETC THE MORAY COUNCIL P 4,400 4,400 UNIT 6 2 CHANONRY ROAD NORTH ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

7 47317/63111 WORKSHOP ETC THE MORAY COUNCIL P 4,400 4,400 UNIT 7 2 CHANONRY ROAD NORTH ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

8 22972/54748 WAREHOUSE BOOKER LTD T 96,000 96,000 2 CHANONRY ROAD SOUTH T/A BOOKER CASH & CARRY ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

9 47708/53730 DEPOT THE MORAY COUNCIL P 30,500 30,500 4 CHANONRY ROAD SOUTH ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

10 47708/62536 DEPOT LOOMIS UK LTD T 30,500 30,500 4 CHANONRY ROAD SOUTH ELGIN ALEXANDER REECE THOMSON LLP A

11 22970/53112 WAREHOUSE SPEYFRUIT LTD P 18,000 18,000 5 CHANONRY ROAD SOUTH ELGIN WYMRE A

12 47645/54691 WORKSHOP ETC G L M MOTORS LTD T 18,750 18,750 6 CHANONRY ROAD SOUTH ELGIN

13 47645/63124 WORKSHOP ETC THE MORAY COUNCIL P 18,750 18,750 6 CHANONRY ROAD SOUTH ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

07/04/2018 Page 1 of 12 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

14 83830/56699 STORES TRAVIS PERKINS TRADING CO LTD T 62,500 62,500 7 CHANONRY ROAD SOUTH ELGIN DTZ A

15 86020/62318 WORKSHOP ACCESS PLATFORMS (ABERDEEN) LTD T 17,000 17,000 13 CHANONRY ROAD SOUTH ELGIN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

16 86020/63086 WORKSHOP THE MORAY COUNCIL P 17,000 17,000 13 CHANONRY ROAD SOUTH ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

17 86413/63108 WORKSHOP THE MORAY COUNCIL P 9,900 9,900 19 CHANONRY ROAD SOUTH ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

18 70343/53111 FACTORY SPEYFRUIT LTD T 77,500 77,500 12 CHANONRY ROAD SOUTH ELGIN WYMRE A

19 22961/52740 WORKSHOP NORTHERN FABRICATORS LTD T 80,500 80,500 1 CHANONRY SPUR ELGIN MONTAGU EVANS A

20 48406/52722 YARD NORTHERN FABRICATORS LTD T 16,000 16,000 2 CHANONRY SPUR ELGIN MONTAGU EVANS A

21 48406/63101 YARD THE MORAY COUNCIL P 16,000 16,000 2 CHANONRY SPUR ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

22 38992/53113 GARAGE PALMARIS PLANT HIRE LTD T 14,500 14,500 2 CHANONRY STREET ELGIN WYMRE A

23 22994/53689 STORE THE MORAY COUNCIL P 525 525 CRICKET PAVILION COOPER PARK ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

24 23027/52704 WORKSHOP ETC JAMES JOHNSTON & CO OF ELGIN LTD P 13,500 13,500 GRAMPIAN WORKSHOPS WOOLLEN MANUFACTURERS GRAMPIAN ROAD ELGIN RYDEN LLP A

25 34744/63106 WORKSHOP THE MORAY COUNCIL P 8,200 8,200 3 LINKWOOD LANE ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

26 35394/53607 WORKSHOP THE MORAY COUNCIL P 7,300 7,300 4 LINKWOOD LANE ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

27 81946/58521 WORKSHOP MENZIES PARCELS LIMITED T 9,800 9,800 12 LINKWOOD PLACE ELGIN G L HEARN LIMITED A

07/04/2018 Page 2 of 12 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

28 48970/61875 WORKSHOP AJG PARCELS LTD T 12,250 12,250 13 LINKWOOD PLACE ELGIN G L HEARN LIMITED A

29 52704/54784 WORKSHOP ARNOLD CLARK AUTOMOBILES LTD T 15,750 15,750 15 LINKWOOD PLACE ELGIN MONTAGU EVANS A

30 52675/55618 WORKSHOP HI-Q MCCONECHYS T 24,250 24,250 17 LINKWOOD PLACE ELGIN J & E SHEPHERD A

31 23126/63825 WORKSHOP ELGIN REFRIGERATION P 24,000 24,000 1 LINKWOOD WAY SERVICES LTD ELGIN

32 23136/57645 WAREHOUSE REMBRAND TIMBER LIMITED T 55,500 55,500 14 LINKWOOD WAY ELGIN ANDREW REILLY ASSOCIATES A

33 38126/63901 WORKSHOP DAVID PATERSON GENERAL ENGINEERS P 42,250 42,250 18 LINKWOOD WAY LTD ELGIN

34 23156/54771 WORKSHOP A T S EUROMASTER LTD P 19,000 19,000 MOYCROFT ROAD ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

35 48408/52702 STORES ETC JAMES JOHNSTON & CO OF ELGIN LTD P 60,000 60,000 MOYCROFT ROAD WOOLLEN MANUFACTURERS ELGIN RYDEN LLP A

36 48832/52703 YARD ETC JAMES JOHNSTON & CO OF ELGIN LTD P 39,250 39,250 MOYCROFT WOOLLEN MANUFACTURERS ELGIN RYDEN LLP A

37 48832/58872 YARD ETC MCPHERSON LTD T 39,250 39,250 MOYCROFT ELGIN RYDEN LLP A

38 23170/57828 WORKSHOP GAP GROUP LTD P 81,500 81,500 MOYCROFT ROAD ELGIN GVA A

39 23170/57829 WORKSHOP GAP GROUP LTD P 77,000 77,000 MOYCROFT ROAD ELGIN GVA A

40 23171/52684 DEPOT RAVENHILL LTD P 46,250 46,250 MOYCROFT ROAD ELGIN RYDEN LLP A

41 23171/52718 DEPOT RAVENHILL LTD P 50,500 50,500 MOYCROFT ROAD ELGIN RYDEN LLP A

07/04/2018 Page 3 of 12 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

42 23262/63504 WORKSHOP SPRINGFIELD PROPERTIES LTD FURBS P 7,200 7,200 30 PERIMETER ROAD ELGIN RYDEN LLP A

43 23240/57822 WORKSHOP ETC GAP GROUP LTD P 28,250 28,250 14 PERIMETER ROAD ELGIN GVA A

44 23242/57690 WORKSHOP ROBERTSON GROUP (SCOTLAND) LTD P 191,000 191,000 10 PERIMETER ROAD ELGIN GVA A

45 82260/57691 WORKSHOP ROBERTSON GROUP (SCOTLAND) LTD P 28,000 28,000 12 PERIMETER ROAD ELGIN GVA A

46 23194/55169 FACTORY PINEFIELD GLASS T 68,500 68,500 1 PINEFIELD PARADE ELGIN F G BURNETT LTD A

47 23195/63934 FACTORY HIGHLAND METALS LTD P 112,000 112,000 3 PINEFIELD PARADE ELGIN RYDEN LLP A

48 23250/56701 STORES KEYLINE BUILDERS MERCHANTS T 72,500 72,500 5 PINEFIELD PARADE ELGIN DTZ A

49 23249/54136 STORES WILLIAM WILSON LTD P 89,500 89,500 9 PINEFIELD PARADE ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

50 23231/57720 STORE ETC YESS ELECTRICAL T 29,000 29,000 22 PINEFIELD PARADE REGIONAL OFFICE MANAGER ELGIN WYMRE A

51 23264/53690 STORES THE MORAY COUNCIL P 17,500 17,500 COUNCIL EQUIPMENT STORES PINEFIELD ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

52 82211/63506 STORE SPRINGFIELD PROPERTIES LTD FURBS P 475 475 STOREROOM PINETREE HOUSE PINEFIELD CRESCENT RYDEN LLP A ELGIN

53 23283/62441 WAREHOUSE J P MCDOUGALL & CO LTD T 16,750 16,750 3 TYOCK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE ELGIN JONES LANG LASALLE A

54 23295/54135 WORKSHOP WOLSELEY CENTERS LTD T 17,000 17,000 22 TYOCK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

55 23297/52693 WORKSHOP DINGBRO MOTOR FACTORS LTD T 24,250 24,250 24 TYOCK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE ELGIN RYDEN LLP A

07/04/2018 Page 4 of 12 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

56 23304/63822 WORKSHOP RICHARD IRVIN & SONS LTD P 14,500 14,500 30 TYOCK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE ELGIN RYDEN LLP A

57 38989/52701 WAREHOUSE JAMES JOHNSTON & CO OF ELGIN LTD P 27,750 27,750 36 TYOCK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE WOOLLEN MANUFACTURERS ELGIN RYDEN LLP A

58 23311/53610 YARD ETC THE MORAY COUNCIL P 7,300 7,300 KIRKHILL WOOD WOODSIDE ROAD ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

59 86819/56738 WAREHOUSE SCREWFIX DIRECT LTD T 14,750 14,750 SPRINGFIELD INDUSTRIAL ESTATE EDGAR ROAD ELGIN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

60 89925/63164 WAREHOUSE EDMUNDSON ELECTRICAL LTD T 33,750 33,750 SPRINGFIELD INDUSTRIAL ESTATE EDGAR ROAD ELGIN WYMRE A

61 23333/57820 WAREHOUSE CEILING TO FLOOR LTD T 21,500 21,500 EDGAR ROAD ELGIN POLLOCK PROPERTY ADVISORS LTD A

62 23383/62319 STORE ROBERTSON PROPERTY LTD P 2,000 2,000 NEW ELGIN ROAD ELGIN GVA A

63 23414/54138 YARD ETC HAWCO & SONS LTD T 12,000 12,000 THE WARDS ELGIN GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

64 23414/54145 YARD ETC HAWCO & SONS LTD T 13,750 13,750 THE WARDS ELGIN GERALD EVE LLP A

65 81376/52602 STORES SANUS MOOR LTD P 5,700 5,700 212 HIGH STREET ELGIN GRANT STEWART CHARTERED SURVEY A

66 23813/57131 DEPOT BT PROPERTY P 15,750 15,750 SOUTH STREET RATING AND VALUATION ELGIN COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL A

67 23893/56948 STORES ETC CITY PLUMBING SUPPLIES T 18,000 18,000 4 WARDS ROAD (HOLDINGS) LTD ELGIN CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD A

68 23909/62277 SORTING OFFICE ROYAL MAIL GROUP PROPERTY P 13,500 13,500 BOGTON PLACE G L HEARN LIMITED A

69 24101/54863 WORKSHOP ETC A E S LIMITED P 18,000 18,000 LEA ROAD FORRES DUNLOP HEYWOOD A

07/04/2018 Page 5 of 12 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

70 34014/62405 WORKSHOPS ETC DICKSONS MOTORS (FORRES) LTD P 35,250 35,250 ST CATHERINE'S ROAD FORRES SMART & CO A

71 24166/53600 WORKSHOPS ETC THE MORAY COUNCIL P 5,400 5,400 9 SOUTH STREET FORRES GERALD EVE LLP A

72 24198/57718 STORES ETC KOLBJORN BORSETH P 18,000 18,000 17 TYTLER STREET T/A AROMANTIC FORRES ALLIED SURVEYORS SCOTLAND A

73 24219/53726 WORKSHOP ETC THE MORAY COUNCIL P 11,000 11,000 WATERFORD ROAD FORRES GERALD EVE LLP A

74 88839/56946 YARD ETC CONTRAFLOW LTD T 9,600 9,600 14 WATERFORD CIRCLE FORRES WYMRE A

75 24209/62540 STORES WHITE & CO PLC P 49,000 49,000 1 WATERFORD WAY FORRES G L HEARN LIMITED A

76 36729/63097 STORE ETC THE MORAY COUNCIL P 7,300 7,300 3 GRESHOP ROAD FORRES GERALD EVE LLP A

77 24385/57876 WORKSHOP ETC D & S METALS P 87,000 87,000 16 WEST ROAD FORRES J & E SHEPHERD A

78 43505/63840 WORKSHOP ETC A J ENGINEERING & T 12,000 12,000 19 WEST ROAD CONSTRUCTION SERVICES LTD FORRES J & E SHEPHERD A

79 33931/63828 WORKSHOP ETC A J ENGINEERING & P 79,000 79,000 25 WEST ROAD CONSTRUCTION SERVICES LTD FORRES J & E SHEPHERD A

80 24515/52699 STORE BREEDON AGGREGATES SCOTLAND LTD T 3,900 3,900 CLODDACH FORRES GERALD EVE LLP A

81 39654/53729 DEPOT THE MORAY COUNCIL T 2,600 2,600 WESTER NEW FORRES FORRES GERALD EVE LLP A

82 39654/63917 DEPOT LEITHS (SCOTLAND) LTD P 2,600 2,600 WESTER NEW FORRES FORRES

83 36507/53553 GARAGE THE MORAY COUNCIL P 1,100 1,100 SITE 36 HARBOUR GERALD EVE LLP A

07/04/2018 Page 6 of 12 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

84 24904/53694 WORKSHOP ETC THE MORAY COUNCIL P 21,500 21,500 UNIT 7 COULARDBANK INDUSTRIAL ESTATE COULARDBANK ROAD GERALD EVE LLP A

85 89087/63065 WORKSHOP THE MORAY COUNCIL P 3,300 3,300 UNIT 6 COULARDBANK BUSINESS CENTRE 21 COULARDBANK ROAD GERALD EVE LLP A LOSSIEMOUTH

86 49912/63067 STUDIOS THE MORAY COUNCIL P 5,900 5,900 UNITS 3 & 4 COULARDBANK BUSINESS CENTRE 21 COULARDBANK ROAD GERALD EVE LLP A LOSSIEMOUTH

87 48816/63068 STUDIO THE MORAY COUNCIL P 3,000 3,000 UNIT 2 COULARDBANK BUSINESS CENTRE 21 COULARDBANK ROAD GERALD EVE LLP A LOSSIEMOUTH

88 86944/63126 STUDIO THE MORAY COUNCIL P 3,000 3,000 UNIT 1 COULARDBANK BUSINESS CENTRE 21 COULARDBANK ROAD GERALD EVE LLP A LOSSIEMOUTH

89 30692/53599 STORE THE MORAY COUNCIL P 875 875 HIGH STREET LOSSIEMOUTH GERALD EVE LLP A

90 25092/53788 WORKSHOP ETC THE MORAY COUNCIL P 7,500 7,500 MORAY COUNCIL DEPOT SHORE STREET LOSSIEMOUTH GERALD EVE LLP A

91 49314/63064 YARD SCOTTISH WATER P 1,050 1,050 SHORE STREET HEAD OFFICE LOSSIEMOUTH PROPERTY SERVICES GERALD EVE LLP A

92 84821/63425 WORKSHOP ETC SPRINGFIELD PROPERTIES LTD P 16,000 16,000 THE LEVEL BIRNIE ELGIN RYDEN LLP A

93 25256/52749 STORES THE CHIVAS & GLENLIVET GROUP P 12,250 12,250 NORTHERN OPERATIONS ELGIN MONTAGU EVANS A

94 83357/52695 YARD JAMES JONES & SONS T 3,900 3,900 BALNACOUL RYDEN LLP A

95 25401/53695 WORKSHOP THE MORAY COUNCIL P 11,750 11,750 8 INDUSTRIAL ESTATE FOCHABERS GERALD EVE LLP A

96 36777/53544 DEPOT THE MORAY COUNCIL P 50,000 50,000 1 MOSSTODLOCH INDUSTRIAL ESTATE FOCHABERS GERALD EVE LLP A

97 25503/57713 WORKSHOP ETC DIGNITY FUNERALS LTD P 5,000 5,000 99 MAIN STREET T/A WILLIAM R MAIR GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

07/04/2018 Page 7 of 12 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

98 46988/53609 YARD THE MORAY COUNCIL P 9,900 9,900 BANK STREET GERALD EVE LLP A

99 25552/57655 WORKSHOP SCOTTISH AMBULANCE SERVICE P 7,200 7,200 BARON STREET BUCKIE GERALD EVE LLP A

100 39408/52738 WORKSHOP FORSYTHS LTD P 71,500 71,500 CLUNY HARBOUR BUCKIE MONTAGU EVANS A

101 25704/54846 STORE REGENCY OILS LTD T 230 230 JETTY CLUNY HARBOUR BUCKIE GERALD EVE LLP A

102 25705/53692 STORE THE MORAY COUNCIL P 250 250 JETTY CLUNY HARBOUR BUCKIE GERALD EVE LLP A

103 25782/52735 STORE ETC FORSYTHS LTD P 7,200 7,200 7 COMMERCIAL ROAD BUCKIE MONTAGU EVANS A

104 50170/54850 STORE REGENCY OILS LTD P 625 625 29 COMMERCIAL ROAD BUCKIE GERALD EVE LLP A

105 25811/54848 STORES REGENCY OILS LTD P 5,200 5,200 31 COMMERCIAL ROAD BUCKIE GERALD EVE LLP A

106 25815/52739 FACTORY FORSYTHS LTD P 89,000 89,000 33 COMMERCIAL ROAD BUCKIE MONTAGU EVANS A

107 25818/52732 WORKSHOP ETC FORSYTHS LTD P 8,600 8,600 36 COMMERCIAL ROAD BUCKIE MONTAGU EVANS A

108 25821/56700 STORES ETC TRAVIS PERKINS TRADING CO LTD P 17,750 17,750 43 COMMERCIAL ROAD BUCKIE DTZ A

109 25831/53790 DEPOT THE MORAY COUNCIL P 24,750 24,750 CUNNINGHOLES ROAD BUCKIE GERALD EVE LLP A

110 83081/57834 WAREHOUSE CERTAS ENERGY UK LTD T 67,500 67,500 CUNNINGHOLES ROAD BUCKIE WILKES HEAD & EVE LLP A

111 25941/52737 YARD FORSYTHS LTD P 5,800 5,800 MACLARENS BRAE BUCKIE MONTAGU EVANS A

07/04/2018 Page 8 of 12 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

112 34605/63119 YARD ETC THE MORAY COUNCIL P 15,500 15,500 11 MARCH ROAD EAST BUCKIE GERALD EVE LLP A

113 63963/53549 DEPOT THE MORAY COUNCIL P 22,250 22,250 14 MARCH ROAD EAST BUCKIE GERALD EVE LLP A

114 50993/57863 WORKSHOP HOWDEN JOINERY PROPERTIES LTD T 35,750 35,750 2A MARCH ROAD WEST BUCKIE FISHER WILSON A

115 25959/63419 FACTORY A W ADAM & J G ADAM P 27,000 27,000 DOUGLAS CENTRE MARCHMONT CRESCENT BUCKIE RYDEN LLP A

116 33874/54853 STORE REGENCY OILS LTD P 11,250 11,250 13 MARINE PLACE BUCKIE GERALD EVE LLP A

117 38811/54851 STORE ELSPETH W MILNE P 600 600 UNIT 1 34 MARINE PLACE BUCKIE GERALD EVE LLP A

118 30111/54847 STORE ELSPETH W MILNE P 550 550 UNIT 2 34 MARINE PLACE BUCKIE GERALD EVE LLP A

119 31936/54845 STORE ELSPETH W MILNE P 600 600 UNIT 3 34 MARINE PLACE BUCKIE GERALD EVE LLP A

120 30112/55541 STORE ELSPETH W MILNE P 550 550 UNIT 4 34 MARINE PLACE BUCKIE GERALD EVE LLP A

121 30050/54843 STORE ELSPETH W MILNE P 550 550 UNIT 5 34 MARINE PLACE BUCKIE GERALD EVE LLP A

122 31937/54840 STORE ELSPETH W MILNE P 550 550 UNIT 6 34 MARINE PLACE BUCKIE GERALD EVE LLP A

123 25983/57719 FUNERAL REST ROOM DIGNITY FUNERALS LTD P 11,250 11,250 4 NEWLANDS LANE BUCKIE GRAHAM & SIBBALD A

124 26001/61877 WORKSHOP ETC RT HON THE EARL OF SEAFIELD P 2,800 2,800 LINTMILL CULLEN SEAFIELD ESTATE A

125 26064/53552 GARAGE THE MORAY COUNCIL P 1,000 1,000 AT REAR OF OLD SCHOOL SEAFIELD ROAD CULLEN GERALD EVE LLP A

07/04/2018 Page 9 of 12 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

126 26292/63369 STORES CROWN ESTATE SCOTLAND P 2,500 2,500 TUGNET (INTERIM MANAGEMENT) PER SAVILLS (UK) LTD FOCHABERS SAVILLS A

127 26452/52697 WORKSHOP ETC BOYD INTERNATIONAL LTD P 19,750 19,750 BOYD FOOD MACHINERY BUCKIE RYDEN LLP A

128 26517/53727 DEPOT THE MORAY COUNCIL P 65,500 65,500 BRIDGE STREET KEITH GERALD EVE LLP A

129 33553/52606 FACTORY MACNAUGHTON HOLDINGS LTD P 31,750 31,750 UNIT 1 ISLA BANK MILLS STATION ROAD PRESTON TAIT A KEITH

130 36434/57922 WAREHOUSE ETC GREERS OF ELGIN LTD T 40,750 40,750 UNIT D ISLA BANK MILLS STATION ROAD GVA A KEITH

131 85314/64059 OFFICE GRIEVESON LOGISTICS T 10,750 10,750 UNIT E ISLA BANK MILLS STATION ROAD GVA A KEITH

132 49097/53696 WORKSHOP THE MORAY COUNCIL P 14,250 14,250 UNIT H ISLA BANK MILLS STATION ROAD GERALD EVE LLP A KEITH

133 49098/63130 STORES ETC THE MORAY COUNCIL P 15,250 15,250 UNIT J ISLA BANK MILLS STATION ROAD GERALD EVE LLP A KEITH

134 34093/53457 WORKSHOP MALCOLM GRANT & MURRAY GRANT T 5,600 5,600 UNIT Z T/A GRANT OF BUCKIE ISLA BANK MILLS STATION ROAD KEITH

135 85537/55619 WORKSHOP ETC CLARK & SUTHERLAND LTD P 41,250 41,250 3A WESTERTON ROAD NORTH KEITH SJ ASSOCIATES (UK) TD A

136 51922/63091 STORE THE MORAY COUNCIL P 3,600 3,600 8 WESTERTON ROAD NORTH KEITH GERALD EVE LLP A

137 51924/63117 STORE THE MORAY COUNCIL P 3,700 3,700 10 WESTERTON ROAD NORTH KEITH GERALD EVE LLP A

138 26738/52692 FACTORY THL HOME IMPROVEMENTS LTD P 15,750 15,750 5 WESTERTON ROAD SOUTH KEITH SJ ASSOCIATES (UK) TD A

139 88277/63123 YARD THE MORAY COUNCIL P 17,000 17,000 SITES 1 - 3 WESTERTON ROAD SOUTH KEITH GERALD EVE LLP A

07/04/2018 Page 10 of 12 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

140 26779/53608 YARD THE MORAY COUNCIL P 3,500 3,500 COTTAGE WOOD REGENT STREET KEITH GERALD EVE LLP A

141 26916/53598 STORE THE MORAY COUNCIL P 12,250 12,250 AUCHINHOVE KEITH GERALD EVE LLP A

142 26935/62417 DEPOT SCOTTISH WATER P 6,500 6,500 HEAD OFFICE KEITH PROPERTY SERVICES GERALD EVE LLP A

143 73303/58870 YARD MCPHERSON LTD T 3,700 3,700 BLUEHILL RYDEN LLP A

144 73303/63914 YARD LEITHS (SCOTLAND) LTD P 3,700 3,700 BLUEHILL ABERLOUR

145 27136/53117 SHOP ETC WALKERS SHORTBREAD LIMITED P 32,000 32,000 99 HIGH STREET ABERLOUR WYMRE A

146 27156/53791 GARAGE ETC THE MORAY COUNCIL P 1,000 1,000 MARY AVENUE ABERLOUR GERALD EVE LLP A

147 53979/53673 STORE THE MORAY COUNCIL P 800 800 GOODS SHED SPEYSIDE WAY BLACKSBOAT GERALD EVE LLP A

148 27275/53794 GARAGE ETC THE MORAY COUNCIL P 2,200 2,200 SKATENEUK ABERLOUR GERALD EVE LLP A

149 48554/54124 YARD HIGHLAND DISTILLERS LTD P 42,250 42,250 BY GLENROTHES DISTILLERY ABERLOUR MONTAGU EVANS A

150 89983/52736 STORES ETC G & A CONSTRUCTION LTD T 17,000 17,000 DRUMBAIN FARM ROTHES ABERLOUR MONTAGU EVANS A

151 27351/52723 WORKSHOP FORSYTHS LTD P 3,800 3,800 44 HIGH STREET ROTHES MONTAGU EVANS A

152 27398/52721 WORKSHOP FORSYTHS LTD T 4,900 4,900 UNIT 1 INDUSTRIAL ESTATE STATION STREET MONTAGU EVANS A ROTHES

153 27570/52700 DEPOT THE MORAY COUNCIL P 6,100 6,100 CONGLASS LANE GERALD EVE LLP A

07/04/2018 Page 11 of 12 Proposed Values Agreed Values No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent NAV RV NAV RV

154 85447/52727 WORKSHOP ETC GRANTS () LTD P 12,500 12,500 33A BALVENIE STREET DUFFTOWN MONTAGU EVANS A

155 27716/52720 WORKSHOP ETC GRANT & ANDERSON LTD P 8,500 8,500 14 BALVENIE STREET DUFFTOWN MONTAGU EVANS A

156 55386/53693 STORE THE MORAY COUNCIL P 400 400 TININVER STREET DUFFTOWN GERALD EVE LLP A

07/04/2018 Page 12 of 12