Re-thinking the future of our schools
Making high-quality Jewish education accessible to more Jewish children in Victoria.
DISCUSSION PAPER AUGUST 2021
Acknowledgements A Working Group, comprising Leah Balter, and input into and feedback on our paper. In extending Nathan Cher, Graham Goldsmith AO, Mark Harrison, my appreciation, I would like to emphasise that the Genia Janover, Lisa Kennett and Emeritus Professor schools were not involved in the creation of this Andrew Markus AO, has come together from time to Discussion Paper, and that members of the Working time to assist me in reviewing drafts of this paper. Group do not necessarily agree with all its suggestions. Nechama Bendet, assisted by Rochel Loebenstein, Members represent a cross section of the community, undertook the research, analysis and preparation have strong experience in the issues under discussion, of the paper. Laurence Slomoi of Slomoi Immerman but do not speak for any specific school they may be or Partners reviewed the financial modelling. have been affiliated with. In the absence of a communal planning body in Victoria like the JCA in New South We are grateful for the financial support of the Wales and the Australian Capital Territory, the individuals and philanthropic foundations listed below Working Group has sought to identify opportunities and to the Australian Jewish Funders and JCCV for to improve access to quality Jewish education, assisting with enabling the discussion paper to be adopting a custodial rather than fiduciary approach. shared across the Victorian Jewish community. Each That is, we have examined the school system and how of these organisations agree that we need to discuss well it serves the community as a whole, rather than the challenges our schools will be facing over the next focussing exclusively on the interests and imperatives 20 years and that we need to start discussing the pros of the individual schools. The United Jewish Education and cons of a range of options. They do not necessarily Board, which provides Jewish education to the agree with all the findings of the Discussion Paper 40 percent of children in our community who find and they do not necessarily agree with the proposed themselves outside the Jewish schools, is a key options. stakeholder in this discussion. This report, along with some Frequently Asked I want to acknowledge the Working Group’s vital Questions, a video by Alan Schwartz and the support. I also thank Bialik College, King David School, opportunity for you to provide feedback, can be Leibler Yavneh College and Mount Scopus Memorial accessed at jewishschoolsproject.com. College for their cooperation at President, Principal and CFO level, by making their time available in open Alan Schwartz AM and frank discussion, and for providing financial data, Convener, Victorian Jewish Schools Project
Anonymous P & S Bassat Supporter Foundation
Justin Liberman An open letter from Alan Schwartz
Education is at the heart of our Jewish life. The highest quality Jewish schooling guarantees both our The Discussion Paper communal strength and the intellectual and social aims to open up an flourishing of every child. In Victoria, our community has built one of the world’s finest Jewish education urgent communal systems. conversation about the But a combination of powerful demographic, cultural and financial forces is threatening the future of our future of our schools. schools. Authoritative demographic projections show that over the next 20 years, the population of Jewish school age children in Victoria will fall by nearly to send their children elsewhere. The problem is 25 percent – or 2,200 students. That could mean acute in the primary years, when families can choose anywhere between 800 to 1700 fewer students in our low-cost, high-quality government schools with high four mainstream schools, Bialik College, King David concentrations of Jewish children. Some students School, Leibler Yavneh College and Mount Scopus return to the Jewish schools for secondary school but Memorial College. It could also mean losses to schools many do not. The economic impacts of the COVID-19 of fee and grant income reaching $10 million a year in pandemic are making the pressures on parents even 2031, and about $18.5 million a year in 2041. stronger. But this is not a problem for the distant future. In other words, our schools face a triple threat of Already, there is a diminishing commitment to Jewish demography, culture and finances that our whole day school education, and escalating school fees are community needs to understand and address. exacerbating the problem. In short, fewer children are receiving a Jewish Day School education. About 18 months ago I convened a Working Group (whose members are listed opposite) to develop As a result, the proportion of Jewish children in a strategy that prepares the community for these Jewish schools is falling, as more families choose challenges. Our objectives are to:
• inform the community about the gravity of … the proportion the crisis, • develop options and facilitate community of Jewish children discussion, and • bring together school councils, community in Jewish schools leaders and philanthropists who can lead the is falling, as more change when a consensus emerges in the community that change is both necessary families choose to and desirable. This Victorian Jewish Schools Project 2021 Discussion send their children Paper is the first step of a multi-year strategy. It elsewhere. describes the gravity of the situation and canvasses
RE-THINKING THE FUTURE OF OUR JEWISH SCHOOLS 3 four possible options for addressing it. It makes no debate and evaluate specific options now so that at the recommendations but aims to open up an urgent appropriate time, we are well prepared to make the communal conversation about the future of our necessary changes as seamlessly and as positively as schools. possible.
Over the next 12 months we will initiate extensive We know that no self-appointed group can decide community consultations and broaden the support the fate of our schools – this is a matter for the entire base of the Working Group to include leading community. We also know that it is not reasonable to philanthropists and community leaders. We are open expect the four schools alone to carry the burden of to expanding this conversation to include all Victorian finding the right solution for the entire community. The Jewish schools. In 2022, we will publish our second Working Group seeks to fill this gap by undertaking Discussion Paper. the broadest possible community consultation.
We plan to update and publish the Discussion Paper To ensure that no Jewish child is denied a superb, every year until a clearer path forward, supported affordable Jewish education, we need to talk urgently by the community, emerges for our schools. We will about the challenges facing our schools. I invite you then issue a final report, which will include a detailed to contribute to this critical conversation. Together, description of the preferred option, and a broad we will find the right solution for our children and implementation plan. grandchildren, and for the future of our community.
This conversation is not a new one. We have debated the future of our schools for many years. But this time is different. The Working Group has studied the evidence and concluded that the combined forces of
demography, culture and finances will force change Alan Schwartz AM upon our four cherished schools. We need to develop, Convener, Victorian Jewish Schools Project
To ensure that no Jewish child is denied a superb, affordable 0 A amily earning 200 with three Jewish education, we children in Jewish day school is paying need to talk urgently 90 or 60 o their post ta income in ees. about the challenges 60 facing our schools. 40 3 Children
A amily earning 150 with two 2 Children children in Jewish day school is paying To learn more about this important initiative or to join the Jewish schools 20 60 or 51 o their post ta income in ees. community conversation go to jewishschoolsproject.com