ECPVSC Paper 18/2011-12 For Discussion

Buildings Energy Efficiency Funding Schemes under the Environment and Conservation Fund

Purpose

This paper seeks –

(a) Members’ agreement to approve 90 funding applications and not to accept eight funding applications for the Energy Efficiency Projects (EEP) of the Buildings Energy Efficiency Funding Schemes (BEEFS) under the Environment and Conservation Fund (ECF).

(b) Members’ support to seek approval from the ECF Committee for three funding applications of values exceeding HK$2.0 million for the EEP of the BEEFS under the ECF.

Summary

2. As at 3 January 2012, a total of 220 and 1,329 applications were received for Energy-cum-carbon Audit Projects (ECA) and EEP respectively. Since the Energy Conservation Projects Vetting Sub-committee (ECPVSC) meeting on 17 August 2011, 98 funding applications have been vetted. Out of these 98 applications, 90 funding applications are recommended for approval, six funding applications are recommended not to accept due to inadequate information received for assessment, one funding application is recommended not to accept due to ineligible applicant and one funding application is recommended not to accept due to works commenced before Energy Conservation Projects Vetting Subcommittee (ECPVSC) approval.

3. In addition to the above, 12 funding applications were withdrawn by the applicants which are listed below.

Projects withdrawn by the Applicants

Project No. Applicant Funding Sought Energy Efficiency Project - The Incorporated Owners of $45,340.00 Cheong Ming Building Cheong Ming Building (Ref. EEP-0236)

- 1 - ECPVSC Paper 18/2011-12 For Discussion

Project No. Applicant Funding Sought Energy Efficiency Project - Residential $210,623.00 Residence Oasis Owners Sub-committee (Ref. EEP-0269) Energy Efficiency Project - The Incorporated Owners of $102,520.00 Perfect Industrial Building Perfect Industrial Building (Ref. EEP-0382) Energy Efficiency Project - The Incorporated Owners of $702,146.00 Uptown Plaza Uptown Plaza (Ref. EEP-0386) Energy Efficiency Project- The Incorporated Owners of $45,000.00 Wah Mei Building Wah Mei Building (Ref. EEP-0397) Energy Efficiency Project- The Incorporated Owners of $820,590.00 Ravana Garden Ravana Garden (Ref. EEP-0439) Energy Efficiency Project- The Incorporated Owners of $54,180.00 Golden Phoenix Court Golden Phoenix Court (Ref. EEP-0499) Energy Efficiency Project- The Incorporated Owners of $42,500.00 W Kingley Industrial Kingley Industrial Building Building (Ref. EEP-0618) Energy Efficiency Project- Tseung Kwan O Plaza Owners' $12,100.00 Tseung Kwan O Plaza Committee (Ref. EEP-0887) Energy Efficiency Project- The Incorporated Owners of $328,000.00 Cheong Wah Commercial Cheong Wah Commercial Building Building (Ref. EEP-1212) Energy Efficiency Project- The Incorporated Owners of $3,317,500.00 Chong Chien Court, Wyler Chong Chien Court, Wyler Gardens Gardens (Ref. EEP-1214) Energy-cum-carbon Audit The Owners' Committee of $150,000.00 Project- McDonald's McDonald's Building Building (Ref. ECA-0214) $5,830,499.00

- 2 - ECPVSC Paper 18/2011-12 For Discussion

4. The following application has been rejected with the reason that the building concerned does not have Owners’ Corporation or Owners’ Organisation or Residents’ Organisation established.

Project Rejected due to Ineligible Applicant

Project No. Application Funding Sought ECA0213 Neich Tower $31,500.00

5. The following six applications have been rejected with the reason that inadequate information have been received from the applicants despite sending at least two reminder letters and a conclusion letter to each applicant. Thus, the information provided in the application is inadequate for the assessment to proceed further.

Projects Rejected with Inadequate Information

Project No. Application Funding Sought EEP1036 Fai Hon Building, Energy Efficiency $290,000.00 Project EEP1157 Independence Building, Energy $165,000.00 Efficiency Project EEP1179 (Phase 2 - Block 1), $435,000.00 Energy Efficiency Project EEP1197 Galaxia & , Energy $0.00 Efficiency Project EEP1258 Cheong Fat Factory Building, Energy $0.00 Efficiency Project EEP1269 Victory Industry Building, Energy $0.00 Efficiency Project $890,000.00

6. The following application has been rejected with the reason that the proposed project had commenced works before the approval from the ECPVSC. Thus, the assessment of this application is unable to proceed further.

Project No. Application Funding Sought

- 3 - ECPVSC Paper 18/2011-12 For Discussion

Project No. Application Funding Sought EEP1217 Dang Fat Building, Energy Efficiency $505,000.00 Project $505,000.00

7. The following 90 funding applications with the applied funding of value not exceeding HK$2.0 million are recommended for consideration.

Projects Recommended for Approval

Project Title Organization Duration Funding Sought Energy-cum-carbon The Owners' Committee December 2011 to Audit – Lippo Leighton of Lippo Leighton Tower June 2015 See Note 1 Tower (Ref. ECA0215) (Annex I) Energy-cum-carbon The Incorporated February 2012 to Audit – Union Park Owners of Union Park November 2015 Centre Centre (Ref. ECA0216) (Annex II) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated January 2012 to Project – Cheerful Owners of Cheerful June 2012 Garden Garden (Siu Sai Wan) (Ref. EEP0988) (Annex III) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated January 2012 to Project –Seaview Owners of Seaview December 2012 Commercial Building Commercial Building (Ref. EEP0992) (Annex IV) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated December 2011 to Project –Wah Kwai Owners of Wah Kwai June 2013 Estate Estate (Ref. EEP1006) (Annex V) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated March 2012 to Project –Fairlane Tower Owners of Fairlane August 2012 (Ref. EEP1010) Tower

- 4 - ECPVSC Paper 18/2011-12 For Discussion

Project Title Organization Duration Funding Sought (Annex VI) Energy Efficiency The Owners Committee February 2012 to Project –Ficus Garden of Ficus Garden June 2013 (Ref. EEP1015) (Annex VII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated March 2012 to Project - Broadview Owners of Broadview August 2013 Terrace Terrace (Ref. EEP1019) (Annex VIII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated February 2012 to Project - The Grandville Owners of the Grandville December 2012 (Ref. EEP1023) (Annex IX) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated March 2012 to Project - Yee Kuk Owners of Yee Kuk December 2012 Industrial Centre Industrial Centre (Ref. EEP1030) (Annex X) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated February 2012 to Project - South Sea Owners of South Sea June 2014 Apartment Apartment (Ref. EEP1031) (Annex XI) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated February 2012 to Project - Hoi Tao Owners of Hoi Tao August 2013 Building Building (Ref. EEP1033) (Annex XII) Energy Efficiency No. 8 Clear Water Bay February 2012 to Project - No. 8 Clear Road Residential October 2012 Water Bay Road Owners Sub-Committee (Ref. EEP1034) (Annex XIII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated January 2012 to Project –Marvel Owners of Marvel December 2013 Industrial Building Industrial Building (Ref. EEP1040) (Annex XIV)

- 5 - ECPVSC Paper 18/2011-12 For Discussion

Project Title Organization Duration Funding Sought Energy Efficiency The Incorporated January 2012 to Project - United Centre Owners of United Centre June 2012 (Ref. EEP1042) (Annex XV) Energy Efficiency Parkview January 2012 to Project - Hong Kong Owners’ Committee August 2012 Parkview (Ref. EEP1047) (Annex XVI) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated February 2012 to Project –Kwong Yuen Owners of Kwong Yuen January 2013 Estate Estate (Ref. EEP1051) (Annex XVII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporate Owners January 2012 to Project – Park Towers of Park Towers September 2012 (Ref. EEP1055) (Annex XVIII) Energy Efficiency Owners’ Committee of January 2012 to Project –Convention Convention Plaza October 2012 Plaza Apartments Apartments (Ref. EEP1066) (Annex XIX) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated March 2012 to Project – Owners of Kwun Tong July 2014 Industrial Centre Industrial Centre (Ref. EEP1073) (Annex XX) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated January 2012 to Project –Cheong Fat Owners of Cheong Fat May 2013 Building Building (Ref. EEP1078) (Annex XXI) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated February 2012 to Project –Kwong Yick Owners of Kwong Yick April 2013 Building Building (Ref. EEP1079) (Annex XXII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated February 2012 to

- 6 - ECPVSC Paper 18/2011-12 For Discussion

Project Title Organization Duration Funding Sought Project –Kadak Owners of Kadak July 2013 Building Building (Ref. EEP1081) (Annex XXIII) Energy Efficiency Scenic View Owners January 2012 to Project –Scenic View Committee August 2012 (Ref. EEP1083) (Annex XXIV) Energy Efficiency Estate Owners’ February 2012 to Project – Committee of Laguna July 2012 (Ref. EEP1085) Verde (Annex XXV) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated January 2012 to Project –Grandway Owners of Grandway November 2012 Garden Garden (Ref. EEP1091) (Annex XXVI) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated June 2012 to Project –Clague Garden Owners of Clague January 2013 Estate Garden Estate (Ref. EEP1092) (Annex XXVII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated January 2012 to Project –Cheong Shing Owners of Cheong Shing December 2012 Court Court (Wah Ming Road) (Ref. EEP1093) (Annex XXVIII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated January 2012 to Project –Fully Building Owners of Fully May 2013 (Ref. EEP1099) Building (Annex XXIX) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated January 2012 to Project –Summit Court Owners of Summit Court June 2013 (Blocks A, B, C & D) (Ref. EEP1100) (Annex XXX) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated January 2012 to Project –Happy Garden Owners of Happy May 2013 (Ref. EEP1102) Garden

- 7 - ECPVSC Paper 18/2011-12 For Discussion

Project Title Organization Duration Funding Sought (Annex XXXI) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated March 2012 to Project –Belgravia Owners of Belgravia October 2012 Heights Heights (Ref. EEP1103) (Annex XXXII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated January 2012 to Project –Foo Tat Owners of Foo Tat December 2012 Building Building (Ref. EEP1104) (Annex XXXIII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated February 2012 to Project –Sea View Owners of Sea View July 2014 Estate Block A (A1 & Estate (Watson Road) A2 Lift) (Ref. EEP1116) (Annex XXXIV) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated February 2012 to Project –Sea View Owners of Sea View July 2014 Estate Block B (B1, B2 Estate (Watson Road) & B3 Lift) (Ref. EEP1117) Annex XXXV) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated February 2012 to Project –Sea View Owners of Sea View July 2014 Estate Block C (C1, C2 Estate (Watson Road) & C3 Lift) (Ref. EEP1118) (Annex XXXVI) Energy Efficiency City Committee City February 2012 to Project – One Shatin January 2013 Shatin (Ref. EEP1122) (Annex XXXVII) Energy Efficiency Villa by the Park February 2012 to Project – Villa by the Owners’ Committee November 2012 Park (Ref. EEP1124) (Annex XXXVIII)

- 8 - ECPVSC Paper 18/2011-12 For Discussion

Project Title Organization Duration Funding Sought Energy Efficiency The Incorporated February 2012 to Project – Blessings Owners of Phase 1 of December 2012 Garden Blessings Garden (Ref. EEP1128) (Annex XXXIX) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated April 2012 to Project – Cliffview Owners of Cliffview September 2013 Mansion Phase II Mansion Phase II (Ref. EEP1132) (Annex XL) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated January 2012 to Project - Owners of Dragon March 2013 (Ref. EEP1137) Centre (Annex XLI) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated January 2012 to Project – Le Palais Owners of Le Palais July 2012 (Ref. EEP1140) (Annex XLII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated January 2012 to Project – Lee Ka Owners of Lee Ka September 2013 Industrial Building Industrial Building (Ref. EEP1141) (Annex XLIII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated January 2012 to Project – Ming Nga Owners of Ming Nga April 2013 Court Court (Ref. EEP1145) (Annex XLIV) Energy Efficiency The Owners’ Committee January 2012 to Project – Well On of Well On Garden May 2012 Garden (Ref. EEP1146) (Annex XLV) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated January 2012 to Project – Cheong Yuen Owners of Cheong Yuen June 2012 Building Building (Ref. EEP1147) (Annex XLVI) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated January 2012 to

- 9 - ECPVSC Paper 18/2011-12 For Discussion

Project Title Organization Duration Funding Sought Project – Full Yau Court Owners of Full Yau July 2012 (Ref. EEP1149) Court (Annex XLVII) Energy Efficiency Estate Owners’ February 2012 to Project – Vianni Cove Committee of Vianni September 2013 (Ref. EEP1152) Cove (Annex XLVIII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated May 2012 to Project – Kwan Lee Owners of Kwan Lee August 2013 Building Building (Ref. EEP1153) (Annex XLIX) Energy Efficiency Owners’ January 2012 to Project – The Cullinan Sub-Committee November 2012 (Ref. EEP1154) (Annex L) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated January 2012 to Project – Wing Sing Owners of Wing Sing April 2012 Court Court (Ref. EEP1155) (Annex LI) Energy Efficiency Bel Air Heights Owners’ January 2012 to Project –Bel Air Heights Committee January 2013 (Ref. EEP1158) (Annex LII) Energy Efficiency The Development January 2012 to Project – Seaview Owners’ Committee of August 2012 Crescent Seaview Crescent (Ref. EEP1159) (Annex LIII) Energy Efficiency The Owners’ Committee March 2012 to Project –Sky One of Sky One April 2013 (Ref. EEP1162) (Annex LIV) Energy Efficiency Owners’ Committee of January 2012 to Project – Kornhill Gardens April 2013 Gardens (Ref. EEP1166) (Annex LV)

- 10 - ECPVSC Paper 18/2011-12 For Discussion

Project Title Organization Duration Funding Sought Energy Efficiency The Incorporated March 2012 to Project –Neptune Owners of Neptune June 2013 Terrace Terrace (Tai Man Street) (Ref. EEP1167) (Annex LVI) Energy Efficiency Owners April 2012 to Project –Amoy Gardens Committee (Phase II) August 2012 (Ref. EEP1168) (Annex LVII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated July 2012 to Project –Monticello Owners of Monticello November 2012 (Ref. EEP1170) (Annex LVIII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated January 2012 to Project –The Somerset Owners of the Somerset June 2013 (Ref. EEP1171) (Annex LIX) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated February 2012 to Project –Tsui King Owners of Tsui King August 2012 Court (Water Street) Court (Water Street) (Ref. EEP1172) (Annex LX) Energy Efficiency Central Park & Park April 2012 to July Project –Central Park & Avenue Residential 2012 (LED – Owners’ sub-committee residential lift lobbies) (Ref. EEP1173) (Annex LXI) Energy Efficiency Central Park & Park June 2012 to Project –Central Park & Avenue Residential September 2012 Park Avenue (T5 – Owners’ sub-committee residential floor staircases) (Ref. EEP1174) (Annex LXII) Energy Efficiency Central Park & Park June 2012 to Project –Central Park & Avenue Residential October 2012 Park Avenue (T5 – Owners’ sub-committee residential refuse room)

- 11 - ECPVSC Paper 18/2011-12 For Discussion

Project Title Organization Duration Funding Sought (Ref. EEP1175) (Annex LXIII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated February 2012 to Project –Perth Garden Owners of Perth Garden June 2013 (Ref. EEP1176) (Annex LXIV) Energy Efficiency The Owners’ Committee March 2012 to Project – Waterside of Waterside Plaza May 2014 Plaza (Ref. EEP1180) (Annex LXV) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated April 2012 to Project –Smithfield Owners of Smithfield November 2012 Court Court (Ref. EEP1182) (Annex LXVI) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated April 2012 to June Project –King Tak Owners of King Tak 2013 Terrace Terrace (No.4 King Tak (Ref. EEP1183) Street) (Annex LXVII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated February 2012 to Project –Sea View Owners of Sea View July 2014 Estate Block A (A3 & Estate (Watson Road) A4 Lift) (Ref. EEP1184) (Annex LXVIII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated February 2012 to Project –Sea View Owners of Sea View July 2014 Estate Block B (B4, B5 Estate (Watson Road) & B6 Lift) (Ref. EEP1185) (Annex LXIX) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated March 2012 to Project –On Lok Yuen Owners of On Lok Yuen August 2012 Building Building (Ref. EEP1187) (Annex LXX) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated January 2012 to

- 12 - ECPVSC Paper 18/2011-12 For Discussion

Project Title Organization Duration Funding Sought Project –Federate Owners of Federate May 2012 Building Building (Ref. EEP1188) (Annex LXXI) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated June 2012 to Project –Tolo Ridge Tai Owners of Tolo Ridge August 2013 Po Tai Po (Ref. EEP1189) (Annex LXXII) Energy Efficiency Bel-Air Owners’ March 2012 to Project –Residence Committee September 2012 Bel-Air (Phase 1); Bel-Air Rise (Phase 3); Bel-Air No 8 (Phase 6) (Ref. EEP1195) (Annex LXXIII) Energy Efficiency Kenswood Court Estate March 2012 to Project – Kenswood Owners Committee August 2012 Country Club (Ref. EEP1196) (Annex LXXIV) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated June 2012 to Project – Midland Owners of Midland December 2013 Centre Centre (Ref. EEP1199) (Annex LXXV) Energy Efficiency Owners Committee of March 2012 to Project – Hong Fai Hong Fai Court and June 2013 Court and Hong Wang Hong Wang Court Court, Healthy Village Healthy Village Phase 1 Phase 1 (Ref. EEP1203) (Annex LXXVI) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated February 2012 to Project – Kin Sun Owners of Nos 11, 13, November 2012 Building 15, 17 & 19, Yen Chow (Ref. EEP1204) Street (Annex LXXVII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated January 2012 to

- 13 - ECPVSC Paper 18/2011-12 For Discussion

Project Title Organization Duration Funding Sought Project – Joyful Owners of Joyful April 2012 Building Building (Ref. EEP1207) (Annex LXXVIII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated February 2012 to Project – Kam Kin Owners of Kam Kin April 2012 Mansion Mansion (Ref. EEP1209) (Annex LXXIX) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated January 2012 to Project – San Wan New Owners of Sai Wan New April 2012 Apartments Apartments (Ref. EEP1213) (Annex LXXX) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated April 2012 to Project – European Owners of European October 2013 Asian Bank Building Asian Bank Building (Ref. EEP1218) (Annex LXXXI) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated May 2012 to April Project – Wealth Owners of Wealth 2013 Building Building (Ref. EEP1219) (Annex LXXXII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated June 2012 to May Project – Wing Wah Owners of Wing Wah 2013 Building Building (Nos. 28, 28A, (Ref. EEP1220) 30 and 30A Fuk Wing (Annex LXXXIII) Street) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated May 2012 to Project – Wah Yuen Owners of Wah Yuen March 2013 Chuen (lighting) Chuen (Ref. EEP1221) (Annex LXXXIV) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated May 2012 to April Project – Wah Yuen Owners of Wah Yuen 2013 Chuen (Lift & Chuen Escalator) (Ref. EEP1222)

- 14 - ECPVSC Paper 18/2011-12 For Discussion

Project Title Organization Duration Funding Sought (Annex LXXXV) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated May 2012 to Project – Tuen Mun Tai Owners of Tuen Mun Tai March 2013 Hing Gardens, Phase II Hing Gardens, Phase II (Ref. EEP1226) (Annex LXXXVI) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated June 2012 to Project – Yau Woo Owners of Yau Woo December 2013 Building Building (Ref. EEP1228) (Annex LXXXVII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated March 2012 to Project – Hoi Ming Owners of Hoi Ming May 2012 Court (Babington Path) Court (Babington Path) (Ref. EEP1231) (Annex LXXXVIII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated June 2012 to April Project – King Man Owners of King Man 2013 Court Court (Ref. EEP1246) (Annex LXXXIX) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated June 2012 to Project – Cheong Yuen Owners of Cheong Yuen March 2013 Building Building (Ref. EEP1265) (Annex XC) $32,417,092.00

8. The following three funding applications with the applied funding of value exceeding HK$2.0 million are recommended for seeking approval from the ECF Committee.

Projects recommended for seeking approval from the ECF Committee

Project Title Organization Duration Funding Sought

- 15 - ECPVSC Paper 18/2011-12 For Discussion

Project Title Organization Duration Funding Sought Energy Efficiency The Incorporated March 2012 to Project –Bedford Owners of Bedford March 2014 See Note 1 Gardens Gardens (Ref. EEP1039) (Annex XCI) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated June 2012 to Project –Tsui Ning Owners of Tsui Ning February 2014 Garden Garden (Ref. EEP1114) (Annex XCII) Energy Efficiency The Incorporated September 2012 to Project –Chi Lok Fa Owners of Chi Lok Fa April 2014 Yuen Yuen (Ref. EEP1169) (Annex XCIII ) $10,512,900.00

Advice sought

9. Members are invited to support the recommendation as detailed in paragraph 7 & 8 above.

The Electrical and Mechanical Services Trading Fund January 2012

Note 1 : Please refer to the website of the Buildings Energy Efficiency Funding Schemes www.building-energy-funds.gov.hk

- 16 -