The Ethyl Controversy

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Ethyl Controversy Ethyl The Ethyl Controversy How the news media set the agenda for a public health controversy over leaded gasoline, 1924-1926 William J. (Bill) Kovarik Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Maryland DAI 1994 55(4): 781-782-A. DA9425070 © 1993, 2013 Prof. William J. Kovarik, Ph.D. All rights reserved 1 Ethyl Title page 1 Table of Contents 2 Introduction - 2013 3 1. The Ethy Controversy 11 2. Literature Review 30 3. Discovery from Dayton 65 4. News from Bayway 105 5. Ethyl's internal controversy 139 6. Confrontation in Washington 166 7. Ethyl & the News Media 203 8. Science news in the 1920s 234 9. Authority & perspective 282 A1. Chronology (improved) 301 A2. Glossary 320 A3. Cost of Octane (table) 323 A4. Alternatives to TEL 326 A5. Bibliography (original) 339 A6. Research notes 356 2 Ethyl Introduction and historiographic notes December 2013 Twenty years after I defended The Ethyl Controversy dissertation at the University of Maryland's College of Journalism, it's time to make the dissertation available as an easy-to- distribute file for other historians. Although the dissertation is already public, the delay in wider distribution has involved hoped-for releases of additional industry documents which have not yet taken place. Even so, a few historiographic notes are in order. To begin with, an important origin of this dissertation was my desire to follow up on 15 years of active journalism in environmental controversy, from about 1977 to 1992, particularly with respect to the oil industry and its products and alternatives. Before the dissertation, I had been privileged to write two books about biofuels and ethanol: one for the London-based International Institute for Environment and Development in 1983 and another with two friends, Hal Bernton and Scott Sklar, in 1982. I'd been especially interested in the role of the press in reporting the controversy and in providing information that helped (or sometimes did not help) to unravel the mysterious technical and political fog that surrounded the arcane but environmentally significant topic of "octane" boosting additives for gasoline. Ethanol was well known as one of these additives, but was also considered to be the stepchild of the oil industry, at best an "alternative" to leaded gasoline's tetra-ethyl-lead (TEL) additive, which was always depicted as the standard, economical and most logical choice. Yet there were a host of anomalies and omissions in this hegemonic depiction of the "standard" fuel additive TEL throughout its 90 years of life. One of the most interesting was an apparent Soviet-style erasure of history in a paper by Graham Edgar, an Ethyl company chemist. The paper depicted the benefit of tetra-ethyl lead in volumetric terms as compared to other substances. A chart and its caption claimed TEL was technologically the best option because it took the least amount of the substance to obtain the same octane-boosting results. There were 11 alternatives depicted, but the chart left room for 12. It occurred to me that a non-political chemist wouldn't line up 11 of anything and leave the twelfth place free. Could someone have cut something out of the picture? Given the volumetric progression, this twelfth additive would very likely have been ethyl alcohol, an octane booster that had to be added at higher volumes to achieve the effect in gasoline. 3 Ethyl From: Graham Edgar, "Tetraethyllead," paper to the American Chemical Society, Division of Petroleum Chemistry, New York, Sept. 3-7, 1951. Clearly room has been left for a mysterious twelfth substance, a hydrocarbon, whose properties would mirror benzene or isooctane as a fuel additive. The lacunae is not likely to be anything but ethyl alcohol. Alcohol as a fuel had been so well known to engineers from the earliest days of the automobile that European engineers created their own special "muse of biofuels," the adaptation of Polyhymnia, on this dissertation's cover (Also see additional note in Appendix 8). Yet, apparently, the American oil and chemical industry considered ethanol so politically dangerous 4 Ethyl that it could not even be acknowledged in a scientific paper 50 years later. How was that possible? The contrasting images, and many similar misrepresentations from the American oil industry, stayed with me through years of research. At the time, I was one of a handful of researchers who understood that dozens of refinery workers had died writhing in straight jackets, and hundreds more severely damaged for life, and that millions of consumers had been adversely affected by TEL and leaded gasoline.1 So what this missing twelfth image represented, it seemed to me, was in its own way as Orwellian, as sinister and as deadly as those old Soviet era photos in which a missing person had been assassinated or shipped off to Siberia. My own research was taking place in the 1980s against the backdrop of the prevailing wisdom that environmentalism was an anti-scientific pseudo-religion, and that it had sprung up out of the fertile imaginations of the 1960s boomers. The view was widely discussed by people as diverse as radio personality Rush Limbaugh, novelist Michael Crichton and policy analyst Robert H. Nelson. It was an idea that many conservatives deeply wanted to believe for reasons that are rather far beyond this discussion. And yet, despite their claim to the scientific high ground, those who championed this 'environmentalism-as-religion sprung-up out-of-nowhere' idea never made much of an effort to prove it. My own not-so-astonishing historical research had shown just the opposite: that there had been plenty of public environmental controversy in the news media long before the 1960s, starting at least as far back as Benjamin Franklin and the Dock Creek water pollution controversy in 1739, and including virtually all of the other great names in American and European journalism. My research also showed that what we call environmental controversy -- public health, air pollution, water pollution, toxic chemicals, conservation of farm, forest and wilderness land-- was widespread through humanity's historical record. Today this is more or less taken for granted, but at the time environmental history was brand new and hotly controversial. Also, in 1991, I was concerned about how I might narrow my research framework for this dissertation, and kept thinking about the picture of the missing twelfth octane booster as opposed to Polyhymnia. Great historians like Gerald Markowitz and David Rosner had missed this one particular piece of the puzzle in Dying for Work, but I wasn't sure I could find it either. The breakthrough came in 1992, when I checked with what was then the General Motors Institute (now Kettering University) in Flynt, Michigan. I learned that 80 linear feet of "unimportant" archives from the office of leaded gasoline inventor Thomas A. Midgley Jr had been released only a few months beforehand. No one had taken the time to look through the mass of disorganized unclassified material. A former Marine colonel and US Energy Department official, William Holmberg, thought it might be important and insisted that I spend a week in Flynt going through the archives. Holmberg was absolutely right. Most of what we historians now know about the context of the development of leaded gasoline has come from those archives -- despite a rather large collection of historical information still (as of December, 2013) being withheld by industry. (Specifically, the successors to the Ethyl Corp., such as Afton 5 Ethyl Chemical and New Market Inc.) After this dissertation was completed in December, 1993, the conclusions ran so counter to what was then understood about leaded gasoline that I decided to present papers to a variety of historical and engineering groups and benefit from their reactions. Although confident about my own work, I was worried that I had overlooked something or, possibly, that the political interests around Ethyl Corp., a Virginia company, would find ways to attack me, since I was a Virginia- based academic without tenure at the time. I was aware, for instance, that Ethyl critics had been attacked in past decades, notably Clair Patterson of Cal Tech and Herbert Needleman of the University of Pittsburgh. The first papers from the dissertation went to the Society of Automotive Engineers, the Society of Automotive Historians, and the Association for Education in Journalism and Mass Communications. The best that can be said of the SAE was that it was technically equipped to understand the problem, but psychologically constrained to avoid its implications. The paper was presented at a conference, and for some engineers, it was a bombshell. I vividly remember one Japanese engineer quickly scanning through it and gasping "this changes everything." Yet the SAE refused to publish the paper in its series for reasons it would not discuss. 1995, at the SAH, on the 50th anniversary of Farm Chemurgy conference, I was privileged to discuss "Henry Ford, Charles Kettering and the Fuel of the Future," which was subsequently published by the SAH in 1998. That paper has been widely cited, for example, by musician and car enthusiast Neil Young, former CIA director James Woolsey, and former White House counsel C. Boyden Gray, and many other historians. Branching out, I presented a papers on the topic to the American Society for Environmental History in 2003 and was invited to submit an article to the International Journal of Occupational and Environmental Health in 2005. Both of these were well received without a word of criticism. The one criticism of the dissertation's thesis took place at the Society for the History of Technology conference in 2007. I presented a paper on the motives of three famous engineers -- Henry Ford, Charles Kettering and Harry Ricardo -- with respect to fuel development.
Recommended publications
  • 2019 Annual Report Are Commission-Free
    Table of Contents 1 Letter to Our Shareholders 4 Financial Highlights 6 Our Businesses Midstream Chemicals Refining Marketing and Specialties 7 Our Value Chain 8 Our Strategy Operating Excellence Growth Returns Distributions High-Performing Organization 28 Board of Directors 30 Executive Leadership Team 31 Non-GAAP Reconciliations 32 Form 10-K | ON THE COVER AND TABLE OF CONTENTS Lake Charles Refinery WESTLAKE, LA In 2019, Lake Charles Manufacturing Complex achieved a sustained safety record of more than 55 months, equivalent to 7.5 million safe work hours. 2019 PHILLIPS 66 ANNUAL REPORT 1 To Our Shareholders We have the right strategy in place to create shareholder value, and our employees are executing it well. Phillips 66 achieved 34% total shareholder return during 2019, which exceeded our peer group average and the S&P 100. In 2019, we delivered earnings of $3.1 billion and earnings per share of $6.77. Adjusted earnings were $3.7 billion or $8.05 per share. During the year, we generated $4.8 billion of operating cash flow. We reinvested $3.9 billionback into the business and returned $3.2 billion of capital to shareholders through dividends and share repurchases. We increased our quarterly dividend 12.5% and announced a $3 billion increase to our share repurchase program. Since our formation, we have returned $26 billion to shareholders through dividends, share repurchases and exchanges, reducing our initial shares outstanding by 33%. Operating excellence is our No. 1 priority and core to everything we do. Our goal is zero incidents, zero accidents and zero injuries. We believe this is attainable, and we strive for it daily.
    [Show full text]
  • 2020 Fact Book 2 Our Businesses Our Strategy Midstream Chemicals Refining Marketing and Specialties Energy Research & Innovation Global Asset Map General Information
    Cover Photo: Taft Storage Facility at Gray Oak Pipeline TAFT, TX Contents 3 4 5 OUR BUSINESSES OUR STRATEGY MIDSTREAM Ferndale Ferndale Rail Terminal* Renton North Spokane Tacoma (MT) Yellowstone Cut Bank Moses Lake Thompson 17Falls Rail 24 14 Spokane Terminal Palermo* UROPE DLE EA Portland D Great Falls E I ST Portland (MT) Missoula Rail Terminal M Yello Glacier Sacagawea* Missoula wsto Helena Roundup Keene CDP* ne Billings Crude* Bozeman Billings Billings Humber SPCo & S-Chem ooth Sheridan* Semino Bakk Beart en Bayway MiRO CHEMICALS REFINING * MARKETING AND SPECIALTIES Bighorn e* Linden* Q-Chem I & II Casper* Tremley Pt. (MT)* * Po Rock Springs wd Bayway Rail eminoe er Ri Terminal* S Harbor Red Line Oil North Salt Lake Pioneer ve Des Moines s r Sacramento Rockies Expr Hartford Lincoln ess Line 20 ess Richmond (MT) Rockies Expr San Francisco Denver Borg Conway Kansas City* Po 0 Rockies Expres to Wichita wd Paola er-Den Gold Line* Wood River er Riv Wichita N.* Products* HeartlandPaola* Blue Line 0 Wichita S.* E. St. ver Jeerson City* Junction er Louis* Southern Hills* m Cherokee North* r*Hartford* Line 30 re Line 40 ol Standish* La Junta * h Ponca City* Explo his Ponca City ld Line C Crude* Go 0 Los Angeles Medford* eeMount Vernon* ok t Los Angeles Borger CherEas Torrance Cherokee Colton Borger to Amarillo* Blue LineSouth* Glenpool* Ponca Selmer Line O* * CushPo* Albuquerque* K PL Sk AC ATA Line* elly ST Cushing City SA Oklahoma City* Amarillo* -Belvieu Los Angeles AL Borger Oklahoma Crude* * Explor Wichita Falls* Lubbock* Savannah North
    [Show full text]
  • October 2004
    HOME Site Search ABOUT US NEWS EVENTS CROSS CORE CUTTING RESEARCH EDUCATION ACTION DISCIPLINES THEMES Inside The Earth Institute a monthly e-newsletter October 2004 Message from Jeff Sachs In the News The Columbia Spectator, October 1, 2004 This fall, the Earth Institute is supporting two new graduate programs: a Masters of Arts in Climate and Society, developed primarily by the International Research Institute for Climate Prediction, and a Ph.D. in Sustainable Development, which will be the first doctoral degree granted by the School of International and Public Affairs. The Discovery Channel, September 27, 2004 Real Video (8:10) Edward Cook, a paleoclimatologist from the Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory, was quoted in this Quicktime Video (8:10) article on research that Lewis and Clark's expedition succeeded in part through favorable climate conditions. The causes and costs of extreme poverty were Earth Institute Receives $4.2 Million discussed by Jeff Sachs and colleagues in a recent Medical News Today, September 21, 2004 Grant to Break Down Barriers and paper published by the Brookings Institute. In his The work of Awash Teklehaimonot, a health expert at e-newsletter video, Jeff stresses the need to use the the Earth Institute, supports the accelerated expansion Increase the Ranks of Women in Earth results of this paper to inform ways to help Africa out of of the health system in Ethiopia. Sciences and Engineering its poverty trap. download Brookings paper The National Science Foundation (NSF) has awarded the The Columbia Spectator,
    [Show full text]
  • NJS: an Interdisciplinary Journal Summer 2017 27
    NJS: An Interdisciplinary Journal Summer 2017 27 NJS Presents A Special Feature New Jersey and the Great War: Part I By Dr. Richard J. Connors DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.14713/njs.v3i2.83 As April 2017 marked the 100th anniversary of America’s entry into World War I, this edition of NJS has several related offerings. These include this special feature, an adapted version of the first half of Dr. Richard J. Connors’ new book, New Jersey and the Great War (Dorrance, 2017). We will publish the second half in our Winter 2018 issue. Those who can’t wait, or who want to see the unedited text (to include endnotes, illustrations, and tables) can always purchase the book online! We are most grateful to Dr. Connors for allowing us to share his insightful and comprehensive work in this way, and hope you will help us ensure the widest possible dissemination by sharing the very timely piece with your colleagues, students, family, and friends. Preface When my generation were youngsters, “the war” was the Great War, now known as World War I. On Memorial Day we bought artificial flowers in remembrance of the veterans lying in European cemeteries “where poppies grow between the crosses, row on row.” On Armistice Day, November 11, we went to our local cemeteries to honor departed neighbors, especially those whose bodies were re-interred from France. At the movies, rarely air-conditioned, for a ten cent admission we watched Lew Ayres in All Quiet on the Western Front, or Errol Flynn in Dawn Patrol, plus the latest Buck Rogers serial.
    [Show full text]
  • Refinery Database 7.1.08
    Status of Refinery Air Permitting Actions for Oil Refineries in the United States (current as of July 1, 2008) Current Permit Capacity Dates & Deadlines Writer or Permitting Authority Application / Draft or Proposed (barrels Action (if (Comments, hearings, Project Description (and purpose - Other State Refinery (the state agency, unless Permits / Other Documents (if Project Status per any) meetings, etc.) e.g. , "tar sands" - if known) Specific otherwise noted) available) calendar Contact (if day) known) General Authority for AL: Alabama Dept. of Environmental Management 1400 Coliseum Blvd Montgomery, Alabama Alabama 36110-2059 ph:(334) 271- 7899 http://www.adem.state.al.us/AirDivisi on/AirDivisionPP.htm . Goodway Refining LLC (Atmore) 4,100 Gulf Atlantic Operations LLC 16,700 (IDLE) (Mobile) Hunt Refining Co (Tuscaloosa) 34,500 Shell Chem LP (Saraland) 80,000 Alaska Department of Environmental Conservation, Air Permit Program, Alaska 410 Willoughby Ave., Suite 303, P.O. Box 111800, Juneau, AK 99811-1800 http://www.dec.state.ak.us/ . BP Exploration Alaska Inc 12,500 (Prudhoe Bay) ConocoPhillips Alaska Inc 15,000 (Kuparuk) Flint Hills Resources Alaska LLC 210,000 (North Pole) Pedro Star Inc (North Pole) 17,500 Pedro Star Inc (Valdez) 48,000 Tesoro Alaska Petroleum Co 72,000 (Kenai) Status of Refinery Air Permitting Actions for Oil Refineries in the United States (current as of July 1, 2008) Trevor Baggiore Permits Section Manager Arizona Department of Environmental Quality Phoenix Main Office Arizona 1110 W. Washington St. Phoenix, AZ 85007 ph: (602) 771- 2321 http://www.azdeq.gov/function/permit s/index.html . Final Title V / PSD permit issued Sept.
    [Show full text]
  • Oil Comparables Weekly 06/21/19
    June 21, 2019 Oil Comparables Weekly 06/21/19 Stratas Advisors Weekly Data Weekly Changes 5 Year Average this Report Week Prior Week Yr Ago Week Week Δ W-o-W Δ Y-o-Y Δ W-o-5YA Stocks (Million Barrels) 6/14/2019 6/7/2019 6/15/2018 2014-2018 Total U.S. Crude Oil 482.36 485.47 426.53 444.60 -3.11 55.84 37.77 Gasoline 233.22 234.91 240.04 230.33 -1.69 -6.82 2.89 Distillate 127.82 128.37 117.41 135.18 -0.55 10.41 -7.36 Big 3 843.41 848.76 783.98 810.10 -5.35 59.43 33.30 Total Petroleum 1,295.16 1,295.38 1,186.52 1,219.44 -0.22 108.65 75.72 Cushing Crude 53.58 52.94 32.61 47.62 0.64 20.98 5.96 Crude Supply (Million Barrels per Day) Field Production 12.20 12.30 10.90 9.40 -0.10 1.30 2.80 Canadian Crude Imports 3.69 3.68 3.57 3.00 0.01 0.12 0.69 Total Crude Imports 7.47 7.61 8.24 7.66 -0.14 -0.78 -0.19 Crude Demand (Million Barrels per Day) Refinery Runs 17.26 17.06 17.70 16.60 0.20 -0.44 0.66 Exports 3.422 3.122 2.374 0.834 0.30 1.05 2.59 Baker Hughes US Active Rotary Rig Counts Oil 789 788 862 824 1 -73 -35 Gas 177 181 188 199 -4 -11 -22 Total 967 969 1,052 1,025 -2 -85 -58 Closing Spot Prices ($/bbl) Today Report Wk Year Ago 5YA 6/21/2019 6/14/2019 6/22/2018 2014-2018 WTI Weekly Close 57.28 52.51 68.98 64.90 4.77 -11.70 -7.62 BDT Weekly Close 64.83 62.89 75.03 68.52 1.94 -10.20 -3.69 Differential, BDT-WTI Weekly Close 7.55 10.38 6.05 3.62 -2.83 1.50 3.93 WTI Weekly Average 54.70 52.49 66.39 54.21 2.21 -11.69 54.21 BDT Weekly Average 63.13 62.41 74.01 58.72 0.71 -10.89 58.72 Differential, BDT-WTI Weekly Average 8.42 9.92 7.62 4.51 -1.50 0.80
    [Show full text]
  • Burton Introduces Thermal Cracking for Refining Petroleum John Alfred Heitmann University of Dayton, [email protected]
    University of Dayton eCommons History Faculty Publications Department of History 1991 Burton Introduces Thermal Cracking for Refining Petroleum John Alfred Heitmann University of Dayton, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://ecommons.udayton.edu/hst_fac_pub Part of the History Commons eCommons Citation Heitmann, John Alfred, "Burton Introduces Thermal Cracking for Refining Petroleum" (1991). History Faculty Publications. 92. https://ecommons.udayton.edu/hst_fac_pub/92 This Encyclopedia Entry is brought to you for free and open access by the Department of History at eCommons. It has been accepted for inclusion in History Faculty Publications by an authorized administrator of eCommons. For more information, please contact [email protected], [email protected]. 573 BURTON INTRODUCES THERMAL CRACKING FOR REFINING PETROLEUM Category of event: Chemistry Time: January, 1913 Locale: Whiting, Indiana Employing high temperatures and pressures, Burton developed a large-scale chem­ ical cracking process, thus pioneering a method that met the need for more fuel Principal personages: WILLIAM MERRIAM BURTON (1865-1954), a chemist who developed a commercial method to convert high boiling petroleum fractions to gas­ oline by "cracking" large organic molecules into more useful and marketable smaller units ROBERT E. HUMPHREYS, a chemist who collaborated with Burton WILLIAM F. RODGERS, a chemist who collaborated with Burton EUGENE HOUDRY, an industrial scientist who developed a procedure us­ ing catalysts to speed the conversion process, which resulted in high­ octane gasoline Summary of Event In January, 1913, William Merriam Burton saw the first battery of twelve stills used in the thermal cracking of petroleum products go into operation at Standard Oil of Indiana's Whiting refinery.
    [Show full text]
  • Acute Tetraethyllead Poisoning
    Arch. Toxikol. 24, 283--291 (1969) Acute Tetraethyllead Poisoning M. STASIK, Z. BYCZKOWSKA, S. SZENDZIKOWSKI,and Z. FIEDOttCZUK Clinical and Pathomorphological Department, Institute of Occupational Medicine, L6@, Poland, Department of Forensic Medicine, Medical Academy, L6dA l%eceived September 16, 1968 Summary. Four cases of accidental poisoning with tetraethyllead are described. Three out of four of the patients died. In the first case, pure ethyl fluid was accidentally ingested. Dominating the clinical picture of this patient were signs of greatly elevated intracranial pressure. Three other persons were poisoned as a group. They unknowingly inhaled tetra- ethyllead contained in a paint solvent they used. In these three cases, the intoxication manifested itself predominantly as a mental disorder suggestive of schizophrenia. Gross and microscopic changes observed in the fatal cases gave evidence of a capillary vascular lesion, particularly involving the vessels of the CNS. Liver damage and less severe damage to the heart muscle and kidney parenchyma were also noted. The distribution as well as the extent of the above mentioned lesions correlate approximately with the distribution and concentration of triethyllead in the various internal organs. Key- Words: Tetraethyllead -- Mental Disorder -- Damage to Parenchymatous Organs. Zusammen/assung. Die Verfasser berichten fiber 4 F/ille, yon denen 3 tSdlich waren, zuf~lliger Vergiftungen durch das sog. Ethylfluid, das Bleitetra~thyl enthElt. Im ersten Fall trat die t6dliche Vergiftung infolge irrtfimlich getrunkenem Ethylfluid auf. Als klinisches Symptom entstand erh6hter intrakranieller Druck. In den drei n~ehsten F~llen besa6 die Vergiftung einen kollektiven Charakter und war durch den Respirationstrakt zustande gekommen; zwei von den Vergifteten sind gestorben.
    [Show full text]
  • Technical Note TN-106 a Guideline for PID Instriment Response
    Technical Note TN-106 05/15/VK A GUIDELINE FOR PID INSTRUMENT RESPONSE CORRECTION FACTORS AND IONIZATION ENERGIES* Example 1: RAE Systems PIDs can be used for the detection of a wide variety of With the unit calibrated to read isobutylene equivalents, the reading gases that exhibit different responses. In general, any compound with is 10 ppm with a 10.6 eV lamp. The gas being measured is butyl ionization energy (IE) lower than that of the lamp photons can acetate, which has a correction factor of 2.6. Multiplying 10 by 2.6 be measured.* The best way to calibrate a PID to different compounds gives an adjusted butyl acetate value of 26 ppm. Similarly, if the is to use a standard of the gas of interest. However, correction factors gas being measured were trichloroethylene (CF = 0.54), the adjusted have been determined that enable the user to quantify a large number value with a 10 ppm reading would be 5.4 ppm. of chemicals using only a single calibration gas, typically isobutylene. In our PIDs, correction factors can be used in one of three ways: Example 2: With the unit calibrated to read isobutylene equivalents, the reading 1. Calibrate the monitor with isobutylene in the usual fashion to is 100 ppm with a 10.6 eV lamp. The gas measured is m-xylene read in isobutylene equivalents. Manually multiply the reading (CF = 0.43). After downloading this factor, the unit should read about by the correction factor (CF) to obtain the concentration of 43 ppm when exposed to the same gas, and thus read directly in the gas being measured.
    [Show full text]
  • United States Patent Office Patented Aug
    2,849,302 United States Patent Office Patented Aug. 26, 1953 thasaraywarrasants, 2. east one hydrogen atom attached thereto. That is, each of the tertiary halogens is capable of forming hydro 2,849,392 gen halide with a hydrogen atom attached to a different ANTIKNoCK COMPOSITIONS carbon atom which is in a position alpha to the halogen 5 bearing carbon. In this description the term tertiary car Raymond G. Lyben, Detroit, Mich., assigner to Ethy bon atom is defined as a carbon atom which has three Corporation, New York, N. Y., a corporation of Dear other carbon atoms attached thereto by single bonds. Ware Thus, the novel scavenging agents of this invention are No Drawing. Application May 31, 955 certain chlorohydrocarbons, bromohydrocarbons and Seria Rio. 52,284 chlorobromohydrocarbons. The halohydrocarbon scav enging agents of this invention can be derived from al 7 Clains. (C. 44-69) kanes, cycloalkanes, alkenes, cycloalkenes, and hydrocar bon-substituted derivatives thereof. The smallest hydro carbon radical which can provide a scavenger of this in This invention relates to improved antiknock composi s vention contains five carbon atoms; e. g., 1,2-dihalo-1,2- tions. These compositicins encompass antiknock fluids dimethylcyclopropane. In order to provide scavengers and leaded fuels. In particular, this invention relates to having the desirable volatility characteristics with respect a class of hydrocarbons having a particular molecular to the lead antiknock agent, I prefer to employ uniform structure for use as a scavenger with lead antiknock con ly stable scavengers having up to 20 carbon atoms. pounds. Thus, it will be seen that the carbon content of my scav With the discovery of the antiknock effectiveness of or engers ranges from 5 to 20 carbons per molecule.
    [Show full text]
  • Good Chemistry James J
    Columbia College Fall 2012 TODAY Good Chemistry James J. Valentini Transitions from Longtime Professor to Dean of the College your Contents columbia connection. COVER STORY FEATURES The perfect midtown location: 40 The Home • Network with Columbia alumni Front • Attend exciting events and programs Ai-jen Poo ’96 gives domes- • Dine with a client tic workers a voice. • Conduct business meetings BY NATHALIE ALONSO ’08 • Take advantage of overnight rooms and so much more. 28 Stand and Deliver Joel Klein ’67’s extraordi- nary career as an attorney, educator and reformer. BY CHRIS BURRELL 18 Good Chemistry James J. Valentini transitions from longtime professor of chemistry to Dean of the College. Meet him in this Q&A with CCT Editor Alex Sachare ’71. 34 The Open Mind of Richard Heffner ’46 APPLY FOR The venerable PBS host MEMBERSHIP TODAY! provides a forum for guests 15 WEST 43 STREET to examine, question and NEW YORK, NY 10036 disagree. TEL: 212.719.0380 BY THOMAS VIncIGUERRA ’85, in residence at The Princeton Club ’86J, ’90 GSAS of New York www.columbiaclub.org COVER: LESLIE JEAN-BART ’76, ’77J; BACK COVER: COLIN SULLIVAN ’11 WITHIN THE FAMILY DEPARTMENTS ALUMNI NEWS Déjà Vu All Over Again or 49 Message from the CCAA President The Start of Something New? Kyra Tirana Barry ’87 on the successful inaugural summer of alumni- ete Mangurian is the 10th head football coach since there, the methods to achieve that goal. The goal will happen if sponsored internships. I came to Columbia as a freshman in 1967. (Yes, we you do the other things along the way.” were “freshmen” then, not “first-years,” and we even Still, there’s no substitute for the goal, what Mangurian calls 50 Bookshelf wore beanies during Orientation — but that’s a story the “W word.” for another time.) Since then, Columbia has compiled “The bottom line is winning,” he said.
    [Show full text]
  • Invention and Innovation in the Petroleum Refining Industry
    This PDF is a selection from an out-of-print volume from the National Bureau of Economic Research Volume Title: The Rate and Direction of Inventive Activity: Economic and Social Factors Volume Author/Editor: Universities-National Bureau Committee for Economic Research, Committee on Economic Growth of the Social Science Research Council Volume Publisher: Princeton University Press Volume ISBN: 0-87014-304-2 Volume URL: http://www.nber.org/books/univ62-1 Publication Date: 1962 Chapter Title: Invention and Innovation in the Petroleum Refining Industry Chapter Author: John L. Enos Chapter URL: http://www.nber.org/chapters/c2124 Chapter pages in book: (p. 299 - 322) Invention and Innovation in the Petroleum Refining Industry JOHN L. ENOS MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY AN INNOVATION is the combination of many different activities. Gener- ally an invention is made and recognized, capital is obtained, plant is acquired, managers and workers are hired, markets are developed, and production and distribution take place. As the innovation proceeds the original conception may be altered to make it more amenable to commercial realities. Accomplishing these activities consumes re- sources. At any point in the sequence failure may occur, delaying or even frustrating the innovation. In studying the petroleum refining industry I observed several pro- cessing innovations following one another in time and generating technological progress.' I then sought their origins in terms of the original ideas and the men who conceived them. In this paper I shall discuss the relations between the inventions and the subsequent inno- vations, focusing on the intervals between them, the returns to the inventors and innovators, and the changes in the proportions in which the factors of production in petroleum processing were combined.
    [Show full text]