“I'm in Love with Someone That Doesn't Exist!!” Bleed in the Context of a Computer Game Annika Waern Mobile Life @ Stockholm University [email protected]
Total Page：16
File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb
“I'm in love with someone that doesn't exist!!” Bleed in the context of a Computer Game Annika Waern Mobile Life @ Stockholm University [email protected] ABSTRACT ROMANCE IN COMPUTER GAMES It is not unusual for computer games to include romance, Dragon Age is not the first computer game to feature but most games treat romance as a narrative theme rather romance. Romance has featured in at least three ways in than as an integrated part of gameplay. In this article I computer games: as part of a fixed storyline, as an investigate the gameplay experience in the game Dragon optional (and sometimes branching) side story to the main Age, a single-player game that allows players to actively story, and as a gameplay mechanism. engage in romance. Based on an investigation of blog and The first is by far the most common option. Even action community comments, we argue that this sometimes will games will sometimes briefly hint at an ongoing romance create an experience that is similar to the “bleed” effect in (such as when Alyx – the female companion - hugs the non-computerised role-play, and that the player to some protagonist character in Half Life 2). Story-based games extent shares emotions with his or her character. sometimes offer rich romantic story lines; examples are Keywords Fahrenheit and its successor Heavy Rain. In such games Role-play, bleed, role-playing game, romance the romance is fixed, written into the main story of the INTRODUCTION game, and by and large independent of the players’ 1 Games invoke all sorts of emotions in players. The act of actions in the game . playing will in itself make us frustrated, happy, victorious, In contrast, the romantic storyline of Mass Effect is and exhausted [1], and different players look for different interactive, allows the player to choose which character to forms of emotional engagement in games [5]. But when it pursue, and can have multiple endings. This allows for a comes to more complex emotions, games tend to play on greater amount of player agency, as players can choose our emotional strings by introducing story lines that lie whether they want to engage in romance at all, which beyond the control of the player. Such stories create character to romance and, to some extent, how the emotions in much the same way as movies do: the story romance will develop. Baldurs’s Gate II, an older game takes us on an emotional ride where we empathize with and the spiritual predecessor of Dragon Age, actually took characters but do not actively share their emotions. This is this approach further than Mass Effect by offering many true for most computerized role-playing games: even more romantic options with complex trajectories. though the player takes on the role as a character in the However, whereas romance is part of the main storyline game world, he or she need not share the emotions of that in games like Farenheit, it is more of a side-quest in Mass character in order to play it. Effect and Baldur’s Gate. This stands in strong contrast to non-computerized role- Romance can also be made into a game-play mechanism. play, in which players must actively engage in acting out This has been little used in story-oriented games (apart the emotions of the character. Role-play has the power of from that Mass Effect and Dragon Age will award creating very strong bonds between the emotions of the achievements for pursuing successful romances), whereas player and those of the character: it is very difficult to act it is a key element in the Sims, where characters can fall in out an emotion without at least to some extent love and have sex in order to produce children. experiencing it oneself. But is this difference inherent to ROMANCE IN DRAGON AGE the medium, or can computerized gameplay generate As in Baldur’s Gate, the main romantic options in similar experiences? In this article, I argue that it can, Dragon Age play out between the players’ character and even when pre-scripted and in a single-player setting. The some of the “party members” – the characters that join the article focuses on love, an emotion that we seldom expect protagonist in pursuit of the main quest, and that the to experience as part of gameplay. player can control in battle. Similar to Mass Effect and Baldur’s Gate, the romantic storylines also develop over time and can end in multiple ways. In addition, some of Nordic DiGRA 2010. DiGRA © 2010 Authors & Digital the Dragon Age storylines tie very closely into the main Games Research Association (DiGRA). Personal and educational classroom use of this paper is allowed, 1 Although in both games, actual sex scenes need to be commercial use requires specific permission from the unlocked through skilled play. author. storyline, up to and including the very end of the game. The discussion in this article is based on material The romances develop through pre-scripted dialogue collected through such web searches. There is no good trees, and must be initiated by the player: if the player way to deal with this material quantitatively. For example, does not choose to flirt, the romance will not develop. the simple search term “Dragon Age Romance” yields 1 Which options of romance that are open to the player 140 000 hits (April 2010), but most of the hits concern the depend on the race, societal status, and gender of the gameplay mechanics of Dragon Age romance and provide character the player has chosen to play, something that little insight into player engagement. Moreover, a creates very interesting reactions with players. It is quantitative analysis based on such search terms alone possible to briefly pursue several romances at once, but will miss many forum entries that respond to previous eventually the player is forced to choose one character to posts. Thus, one must manually scan thousands of pursue. comments and blog posts to retrieve relevant comments. Aside from the main romantic options, Dragon Age will I selected to inductively collect and classify comments sometimes hint at romance (or sex) with minor characters. until reaching saturation - in other words, until comments These storylines are far less complex than the main no longer revealed new kinds of attachments. I started by romantic options and are left outside the scope of this scanning the 100-300 first hits for search terms combining article. ‘romance’ with the names of the four major romanceable Gameplay effects of romance characters in the game. This would sometimes lead to Romance in Dragon Age has a gameplay function, as it is refined searches (e.g. scanning a full forum thread found tightly tied into the game’s “approval” system. through a single hit). In all, I ended up with 62 entries that Throughout the game, the player can boost the player to some extent reflect the broader variety of players’ characters’ relationship with the party members. This is emotional responses to the game romances. The material done through various means: giving them gifts and is not stochastically representative due to the inductive performing actions that they approve of are the main retrieval method, why no statistics is presented in this methods. High approval ratings strengthen the party article. members’ battle skills. I have selected to use only material from forum In order to pursue a romance, the player must first raise discussions, blogs, and published articles that relate the the approval rating for the character he or she wishes to authors’ personal game experience. Official and unofficial pursue. At a certain approval level (varying for the game guide sites and WIKIs, reviews, fan fiction, and different characters), the player gets access to dialogue interviews with the game designers and developers were options that allow the character to flirt with the party all excluded. Guides, reviews and interviews were member. Romancing party members will lead to huge excluded since these do not describe personal game boosts in approval. Since high approval rates strengthen experiences but aim to describe the game in a more the party members, there is a gameplay incentive for generic manner. Fan fiction, on the other hand, provides players to initiate one or several romances. From a pure excellent documentation on personal emphatic reactions gameplay perspective, it seems to be optimal to to a game, but departs too far from the original play sequentially pursue most of the available romances in the experience to be useful in the context of this article. same play-through. The citations included in the article are stripped of all METHOD context information. The age and gender is omitted since The romance options in Dragon Age are interesting from community members seldom disclose this information in multiple perspectives: they are not gender-neutral (as they forum discussions (and when they do, we cannot be sure depend on the gender of the player’s selected avatar), they that participants volunteer their true age or gender). It offer gameplay rewards, and they develop in would also be a privacy violation to disclose the identity unpredictable ways. Consequently, discussions on Dragon of the authors (even if it is an online identity), why source Age romance feature frequently in forum and blog information has been omitted throughout. When quoting discussions devoted to the game. What makes these signed articles in online magazines, full citation discussions so interesting is that they often feature strong information is provided in footnotes. Unless otherwise affect – players express strong emotional attachment to stated, all citations were retrieved in April 2010. the storylines and the game characters.