Host Use by Four Sympatric Species of Cuckoos in Bangladesh
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
International Journal of Fauna and Biological Studies 2017; 4(3): 48-56 ISSN 2347-2677 IJFBS 2017; 4(3): 48-56 Received: 09-03-2017 Host use by four sympatric species of Cuckoos in Accepted: 10-04-2017 Bangladesh Sajeda Begum Department of Zoology, Jahangirnagar University, Sajeda Begum Savar, Dhaka, Bangladesh Abstract The study on host selection by four sympatric cuckoos has been conducted in Bangladesh. Sympatric parasites should show niche segregation through variation in host use. Asian koel (Eudynamys scolopacea) parasitized Common myna (Acridotheres tristis), Long-tailed shrike (Lanius schach) and House crow (Corvus splendens); Indian cuckoo (Cuculus micropterus) parasitized Black drongo (Dicrurus macrocercus). Jungle babbler (Turdoides striata) was parasitized by Jacobin cuckoo (Clamator jacobinus) and Common hawk cuckoo (Cuculus varius), but the breeding season of these two cuckoo species did not overlap. Parasitism rates by cuckoo species in three habitats; human habitations, mixed scrub forests and monotypic plantations showed a significant difference for most host species between habitats, which explains that cuckoos preferred specific habitats even if their favourite host also occurred elsewhere. Indian cuckoo, Common hawk cuckoo and Jacobin cuckoo showed excellent egg mimicry with their hosts while Asian koel showed good mimicry to one of three host species. Keywords: Asian koel, Common hawk cuckoo, Jacobin cuckoo, Indian cuckoo, sympatric, host selection 1. Introduction Most studies of avian brood parasites deal with their interactions with hosts, which has been presented as a model system for coevolution 25, 51, 66, 62. Since it is costly for hosts to be parasitized, natural selection has favoured host defences, like aggression against parasites near their nests [51, 63, 74] and recognition and rejection of parasitic eggs 24, 26, 49, 51. In most cases these adaptations have been studied in systems where one parasite species utilize one or a few host species 4, 31. Systems where several parasite species occur in sympatry have been far less studied 15, 19, 20, 33, 40. Related species living in sympatry should be expected to have segregated into different ecological niches to avoid interspecific competition. This is known as the 34 27, 30, 53, 68 “Gause’s principle” . There exists substantial support for this hypothesis in birds . Friedmann (1928) 32 was the first to adopt the principle to brood parasites because he concluded that such niche segregation also must occur among sympatric cuckoo species in Africa. It is logical to assume that niche differences as a consequence of interspecific competition between sympatric brood parasites could be manifested in the preference for 45 7 different host species . This was in fact supported by Baker (1942) who recorded 15 sympatric cuckoo species in Assam, India, which parasitized different host species or bred at different times, thus avoiding competition with each other 71. Later, such prevention of same host use through interspecific competition was shown by Brooker and Brooker (1989) 15 and 41 Higuchi (1998) who investigated host selection among sympatric cuckoo species in Australia and Japan, respectively. Furthermore, Yom-Tov and Geffen (2005) 77 found that among cuckoos, the number of host species increase with latitude, which is indicative of competitive release and niche expansion. Co-existing brood parasitic species of cowbirds may 20 also reduce potential interspecific competition for nests through differential host use . A very preliminary study on cuckoos in Bangladesh mostly focused on the basic biology and natural history by describing parasite and host interaction has revealed 10-12. Taking these studies into consideration the picture is, however, still that the knowledge of niche segregation in avian brood parasites is scarce and incomplete. Host selection among Correspondence sympatric brood parasites is driven, in part, by their breeding habitat preferences as parasitism Sajeda Begum may be strongly influenced by habitat characteristics as reported for Brown-headed cowbirds Department of Zoology, (Molothrus ater) 8, 13, 67 and Common cuckoo (Cuculus canorus) hosts 17. Habitat preference Jahangirnagar University, is closely related to food availability in most bird species. Food requirements of nestlings may, Savar, Dhaka, Bangladesh ~ 48 ~ International Journal of Fauna and Biological Studies however, differ from those of adults 37. Brood parasites may with ornamental trees, (Mimusops elengi, Livistona chinensis, therefore disconnect the aspects of their breeding and foraging Murraya paniculata, Polyalthia longifolia and Swietenia requirements and rather select habitats with high quality hosts mahagoni) are present as plantations in and around human for proper parental care, irrespective of food availability for settlements 10, 11. b) Mixed scrub forests with plantations and themselves 67, 73. In addition, it is well-known that isolated marsh patches. This habitat has a scattered characteristics like perch availability or proximity for distribution and is characterized by naturally-grown tree observing host behaviour and locate host nests are important species like Ficus bengalensis, Syzygium cumini, Zizyphus sp. aspects of habitat quality 3, 8, 22, 52, 57. Furthermore, host Dalbergia sissoo, Albizia spp. etc. and some planted tree breeding season, nest accessibility, host abundance, and species like Acacia auriculiformis, Shorea robusta, Swietenia vulnerability to nest predation are all factors that may mahagony, Artocarpus heterophyllus and Mangifera indica. influence the choice of hosts in brood parasites 5, 16, 24, 38, 41, 70, Bushes like Chrysopogon sp., Cassia sophera, Cassia tora, 72. In addition to varying habitat preference, sympatric brood Mymosa pudica, etc. are also present in this habitat. The low- parasite species may be of different size 15, and therefore, as lying areas remain dry during winter and summer and are a consequence, they may be segregated by ecological niche used as agricultural lands. During the monsoon season these separation 32. In addition to the spatial aspect, brood parasite areas are filled with water and become marshy. c) Monotypic species or tribes may also be separated in timing of breeding plantations including Terminalia arjuna, Gmelina arborea and Lagerstroemia speciosa which have medicinal value for 29, 54, 55, which may reduce the interspecific competition the local people. Some fruit yielding plants like Syzygium among cuckoo species in sympatry. Egg morphology and cumini, Artocarpus heterophyllus and Cocos nucifera are also mimicry are important factors for selection of suitable hosts planted around such monotypic plantations by the local as the cuckoo egg must be incubated in the presence of a host people. This habitat also includes a few number of banyan clutch for proper incubation and hatching 25, 44, 58. Therefore, tree, Ficus bengalensis at the periphery of the plantations 10, selection for egg mimicry and egg crypsis also drives the 11 sympatric competitive cuckoo species into host partitioning . 15, 41. In the present study the aim was to investigate interactions between four parasitic cuckoo species viz. the Asian koel (Eudynamys scolopacea), Common hawk cuckoo (Hierococcyx varius), Jacobin cuckoo (Clamator jacobinus) and Indian cuckoo (Cuculus micropterus) living in sympatry in Bangladesh, at the south-eastern part of the Indian subcontinent. These cuckoos are known to parasitize different host species 2, 7, 9, but very little is known about their host use and possible competition in areas where they occur in sympatry. From the “Gause’s principle” the hypothesis that there is potential for interspecific competition between the co- occurring cuckoo species, which should have led to niche segregation. The main prediction following this hypothesis is that these cuckoo species should parasitize different host species in different habitats 10. Otherwise, if more than one species parasitize the same host they should be likely to differ in other basic ways, e.g. either different breeding seasons or different arrival dates in the breeding habitat, or parasitizing the same host in different habitats 56. During field work in Bangladesh investigations have been carried out to test these predictions. Data on host choice, parasitism rates and the degree of mimicry between cuckoo and host eggs were collected. Cuckoo arrival date, breeding period and habitat preference of hosts and parasites were also collected. Fig 1: Map of the Jahangirnagar University campus (Source: Begum, 2. Materials and methods 2011) 2.1 Study Area The study was conducted in Jahangirnagar University Some basic data on the four cuckoo species are given in Table Campus, central part of Bangladesh (2352 N, 9016 E), 32 3. Since, however, their biology is relatively poorly known km north of Dhaka city (Fig.1). The size of the entire campus though some additional information about them are described area is approximately 200 hectares consisting of diverse in more detail by 10, 11, 56. vegetation in and around human settlements. Three distinct habitat types in the study area were classified based on type of 2.2 Field procedures vegetation and presence of buildings; a) Human habitations Nests of all passerines breeding in the study area were with orchards and gardens, which includes buildings and tin searched during the breeding seasons. Breeding data on shed houses used for residential, academic and administrative different cuckoos and hosts