Law REVIEW September 2007

NEWS IN BRIEF

SALRC: P J Schwikkard and A celebration of the Law Dennis Davis have been ap- OF THE honorary degrees which pointed to the SA Law Reform UCT has conferred in the last hun- Commission. There are only dred years, many have been awarded seven members of the SALRC to lawyers. Yet more LLDs (Honoris which plays an important role causa) have been conferred on those in revising and updating the who have played a valuable role in law. society, often through participation in politics of all kinds. In December 2006, UCT was proud to honour four distinguished Merit award: Jonathan Bur- chell has been given a Merito- lawyers, all of whom have used the rious Publication Award (the law both to emphasize its intimate runner-up to the UCT Book relationship with justice and its Award) for the third edition capacity to bring people together of his Principles of Criminal through critical engagement with Law. each other. ‘Two of the honorary graduands, Justice & Judge Dennis Davis, are alumni of the Faculty Fellowship: Cathy Powell has been accepted to the SJD pro- and very much household names in gramme at the University of ,’ comments Professor Toronto, and been awarded a Hugh Corder, Dean of Law. ‘Justice Fellowship for three years to Sachs suffered greatly from the ef- allow her to do this fulltime. fects of a car bomb placed by apart- heid operatives in Maputo in 1988, Distinguished lawyers (from l-r): Justice Sachs, Judge Davis, Sir Bob Hepple and Prof Dr Zimmermann gather with the but recovered sufficiently to play a Vice-Chancellor (centre) Professor Ndebele before the December graduation ceremony. leading role in the constitutional ne- Doctoral Students: Mpfa- riseni Budeli made history as gotiations which led to the birth of a always after hours and without ma- strong links with the faculty and the two great legal systems of the the first black South African democratic South Africa in the early terial reward. He is probably best his contributions have enriched the developed world, the civil law and woman PhD in the Faculty 1990s. He is renowned as a commit- known, however, to the general pub- study of labour law not only at UCT the common law. The Law of Obliga- of Law. She is pictured below ted, creative, courageous and outspo- lic for his pioneering use of televi- but more broadly in South Africa’. tions: Roman Foundations of the Civil- with her supervisor and men- ken man of the law and the arts, as sion to bring the critical issues of ‘The fourth honorary graduand ian Tradition, led to UCT conferring tor, commercial law professor, well as for being one of the first peo- law and justice into homes across is Reinhard Zimmermann who was on him the LLD for distinguished Evance Kalula. ‘A product of ple appointed to the Constitutional the country.’ appointed at the remarkably young published work.’ the University of Limpopo Court in 1994.’ ‘Sir Bob Hepple QC is the honor- age of 29 to succeed the legendary ‘It is entirely fitting that UCT where she did her LLB, her ‘Outstanding lecturer, researcher ary graduand with the least strong Professors Ben Beinart and JC de should have honoured these four LLM and was appointed as a and commentator (writing a regular connection to UCT: indeed, he is a Wet as the W P Schreiner Professor lawyers who have in common, not lecturer, Ms Budeli is one of column in the Cape Times, with Ger- graduate of Wits! Bob Hepple, like of Roman and Comparative law. He only their status at some time as an a growing number of doctoral ald Gordon QC, during the states of Albie Sachs, went to the Bar after left for Regensburg in 1988 but did Honorary Professor of the Faculty of students in the Faculty,’ said emergency of the late 1980s), Davis graduation, and took cases which not lose either his interest in South Law, but also distinguished careers Professor Kalula. A total of writes prolifically across a broad placed him firmly on the left of the African law or his contacts with its in the pursuit of justice through the 40 doctoral students, drawn spectrum of the law. As a judge he political spectrum. He went into ex- lawyers, however, and has played law,’ said Corder. from various countries in Af- has delivered a number of ground- ile in 1963, as a consequence of the host to successive generations of The oration at the ceremony was rica, Europe and North Amer- breaking judgments, while at the Rivonia Trial, and followed an aca- bright young graduates and estab- given by Emeritus Professor Francis ica is projected in 2008. same time continuing to teach at demic career in . Since his lished legal academics in pursuit of Wilson and is reproduced in full on ‘It is also gratifying that an both LLB and LLM levels at UCT, unbanning in 1990, Hepple has had his passion, the harmonisation of page 6. increasing number are women and law teachers.’ said Kalula. UCT Law@Work Professional Development Project IN JUST the first half of 2007, the to UCT Law@Work, the Professional conjunction with the Compliance Professional Education Project has Development Project. Institute of South Africa for the 6th reached over 450 people, in compari- 2007 kicked off with a seminar on time; son with the total of 609 delegates The Legal Aspects of Banking Supervi- Sectional Titles Scheme Management for the entire 2006 year. There was sion by visiting German academic, in association with Paddocks learn- an excellent attendance at Companies Professor Christian Hafke; a 3-day ing; this is the 3rd course run since Bill - taking stock. A day of lectures on course on Telecommunications Law, January 2006 with another one cur- the New Companies Bill and there is al- offered for the second time by Hud- rently underway; Sports Law lecturer Rochelle le Roux ready great interest in the Workshop son Janisch, followed. The 1-day Securitisation – supported by the with participant Molly Roberts. on the Consumer Protection Bill sched- workshop on the National Credit South African Securitisation Forum, uled for the 28th of September. Act was such a success that a sec- for the 2nd time; ‘It is clear that the Project deliv- ond workshop was run and a third The Certificate in Legal Writing, an duced this year’, continued Wasserfall. ers a valuable service in keeping the is scheduled in September. A 3-day old favourite with the legal fraternity ‘The first is the Certificate Course in wider “legal” community informed course on Understanding Contracts and corporates, is scheduled to take International Tax law and the second of developments in the legislative for Effective Control ran for the third place in September. This certificate is a 3–day course in Entertainment field, said Manager, Irena Wasserfall. time in August. course is now in its 6th year and is Law, presented by Debbie Lazaus, a In the spirit of ongoing professional The following certificate courses presented by Professor Halton Chea- UCT graduate who recently returned development for the entire commu- were run from March through to dle and renowned legislative drafter, to South Africa after having worked nity in legal matters, it has been de- June: Sports Law – for the 8th time;- Canadian Phil Knight. at a top entertainment law firm in Los cided to change the Project’s name Compliance Management – run in ‘Two new courses are being intro- Angeles.’ Law REVIEW 1 News

COMMENT FROM THE DEAN From the Chair of the Development Committee SOME YEARS ago, the Law Faculty, with a good measure would place a fairly heavy burden on even fairly affluent 2006 ENDED on such a wonderful of foresight, established a Development Committee and households and are beyond the capacity of many aspir- note; firstly there was the gala just over five years ago appointed a person to take charge ant law students from previously disadvantaged back- dinner for 200 in Baxter Hall, then of the Development and Marketing Portfolio. This ini- grounds. Much of the Development Committee’s activi- there was the Graduation High Tea tiative, which has been most ably driven by the Dean, has ties are accordingly devoted to raising funds for aspirant & Awards Ceremony in the Faculty, paid good dividends in several respects as I will outline law students from previously disadvantaged backgrounds and finally the extraordinary and hereunder. Perhaps the most rewarding accolade is the and I am proud to say that we currently support 15 such emotion-laden grad ceremony in fact that the University as a whole has adopted the Law students within the Faculty. Jammie. Faculty’s model. One of the important objectives of the The Faculty itself has endeavoured to address this situ- The palpable sense of common Development Committee has been to re-establish contact ation through various means. One such initiative is the achievement and pride is something with our Law Faculty alumni. Professional Development Project which harnesses the that will always stay with me and In this respect, the initiative has proved a great suc- intellectual capital of our professional staff and outside immense thanks are due to students cess. All of us can, I believe, attest to a greater level of professionals to offer short courses on developments in and staff, alumni and friends, for “connectivity” with our alma mater. It has not just been the law. This brings in a modest surplus (in 2006, it their part in it all. I trust that those about the success of the reunion weekends; the Beinart ran to R375 000) which we can obviously use at our dis- of you not with us in December lectures; last year’s gala dinner and the numerous ad hoc cretion. In addition, funds raised from our alumni and will enjoy reading all about it in functions. It has also been about the friends remains a vitally important this edition. Law Faculty alumni and friends giving component in dealing with the fund- Staying with achievement, we back to the Faculty in various tangible ing “gap” and is the most direct and had our biggest crop ever of cum and intangible ways. This has consid- effective way in which we can all make laudes; eleven in fact. Of the seven diverse justice system is positive. erably enhanced the status of the Law a difference. Through the generosity LLB graduates hired by a New York My thanks to you our alumni, and Faculty and has facilitated visits by top of many of you, we have been able to law firm, five were from UCT, to the profession for their support. academics and practitioners from a provide bursary support to the above- and doctoral candidates stand at There are always so many growing list of countries. mentioned students and in addition, the highest level ever. Our Moot individuals to thank but I would It would be fair to say that the Law we have an array of prizes on offer as teams continue to excel, but it is like to single out two people. My Faculty is on reasonably solid ground well as significant support for focused however in the realm of student Deputy, Evance Kalula, has worked but it is perhaps relevant to address the research. Fundraising in this form, governance that I take most pride with me for four years and, aside issue of the Faculty’s finances. Since however, is not always sustainable this year. Both student bodies have from his administrative support and 1999, the University has operated on and is dependent upon many factors done magnificent work and have advice, he has left us an enormous a fairly devolved model of faculty gov- which are sometimes beyond our con- brought back glories of the past legacy – a huge network of academics ernance. In the financial area, this trol. In order to address this issue, we in student activism; 2006 also saw and students from across Africa has meant that each Dean has to apply annually for a have established an endowment fund, the revenue from the first LLB group to have done who have come to UCT primarily budget for the succeeding year, based on expenditure and which can be applied annually to allow the Law Faculty community service voluntarily, and because of the work he has done in revenue in the current year. Past experience has shown to do the good things which it has been doing to date. the community service project is the area of labour law. He takes a that the University allows very modest increases for re- In addition to providing support for students from dis- growing in depth and strength. well-deserved sabbatical in 2007, muneration and operating expenses. For example, these advantaged backgrounds, some of the initiatives which Further indicators of success but I look forward to his return in latter expenses have been kept to an increase of 3,5% per we wish to support through the endowment fund are are the fact that we have exchange 2008. annum over the last five years with no increase allowed the participation by a team of students in a prestigious agreements with eight leading Secondly, it is the 30th in 2003. Moreover, any strategic initiatives which may international moot competition; the establishment of a law schools internationally and anniversary of the start of Dennis be proposed have to compete with those put forward by new research unit to focus on good governance through in Africa, and in fact are almost Davis’s teaching career, (and I have other faculties. the law; the provision of administrative infrastructure inundated with such requests, and been fortunate to have shared 20 of It currently costs approximately R37,6m to run the for the community service obligations which all LLB stu- the fact that we have been able to those), and he continues to be not Law Faculty for a year and the subsidy which the Fac- dents now have to perform; and the like. attract top academics to our three only among the hardest working ulty receives (effectively from the State) is approximately We are also seeking funding for the endowment of new chairs as well as to the lecturing and most gifted of teachers, but also R18,6m, leaving a R19m shortfall. In the Law Faculty, teaching positions in certain specific areas of the law not staff (details on p. 10). a person who comes to the party staffing expenditure accounts for approximately 90% covered by the Faculty at present. These initiatives re- That is not to say that there are whenever the Faculty needs him – of our annual budget. It is trite to say that the qual- quire significant support. For example, it costs approxi- no challenges! The Ben Beinart guest speaker at reunion week end, ity of any faculty is dependent almost exclusively upon mately R19m to endow a professorship in perpetuity. Hardship Fund that was established professional development courses, the quality of its academic and other staff. This is not In 2009, law would have been taught at UCT for 150 in 2004 has been used for the contributor to curricula…the list is an issue upon which there can be any compromise. In years and it is our vision that the celebration around this first time this year, and by more endless. the circumstances, one of the primary objectives of the significant milestone will include a campaign to raise a than one student. Implementing Finally, as I go into my last year Development Committee is to raise funds to assist the target amount of R15m for our endowment fund. We equity in employment has had its and a bit as Dean and start to tie Dean in ensuring that we maintain the highest possible have a number of exciting projects in mind to achieve frustrations, but with the successful up various ends, I would really standard in this area. this ambitious objective and you will, no doubt, be hear- implementation of the black African appreciate input as to how you think A significant part of the R19m funding shortfall re- ing from us in this regard in the near future. If you have South African LLB scholarship we are doing. Please do complete and ferred to above has to be funded by student fees. Our any ideas we would be very interested to hear them! scheme this year, and continuing return the questionnaire enclosed. fees have now reached a relatively high level. A year of Sincerely into 2008, I believe the medium With best wishes and thanks, LLB study costs between R19 000 and R25 000 and a David Nurek, to long term outlook for a truly Hugh Corder fulltime LLM costs approximately R32 000. These costs Chairman: Courts approve scholar’s analysis gan’s recent work on wrongfulness scholars, to be found in most text- Instead, he claimed, the courts had in an article in the South African Law in the South African law of delict books and taught in most law fac- two altogether different conceptions Journal in 2005. Within two years of certainly has had an impact. ulties, has been that harm-causing of wrongfulness. One, which was ap- its publication, the Supreme Court The law of delict is the branch conduct was wrongful only if it was plied when harm had been caused of Appeal has cited it, with approval, of law which determines when per- unreasonable, judged with the wis- negligently, made wrongfulness in several judgments. Fagan’s col- sons who have harmed others must dom of hindsight. Thus the joy-rider turn on the reasonableness, not of league, Professor Danie Visser, com- compensate them for it. According who speeds down a crowded street, conduct, but of imposing liability. ments: ‘It is rare that one has the to the South African law of delict, but miraculously hits no one, acts The other, which was applied when good fortune of having such an im- the victims of harm-doing cannot negligently but not wrongfully. Thus harm had been caused intentionally, mediate impact on the heart of delict demand compensation from the also the doctor who kills her patient did make wrongfulness turn on the and South African law.’ harm-doer unless the harm-doer by administering a drug which she reasonableness of conduct, but not The battle is not yet over. Courts acted either intentionally or negli- reasonably believes has no danger- judged with hindsight. can change their minds. And, in ONE OF the ways that a legal schol- gently. But that is not enough. The ous side-effects acts wrongfully but It can take many years before the several recent publications, the ar may have an impact on society is harm-doer must also have acted not negligently. courts endorse a scholar’s views, even orthodoxy’s proponents have hit by changing its law. One of the ways ‘wrongfully’. In two book chapters and an arti- if they are sound. For courts only back, criticising Fagan’s views and that a legal scholar may change soci- What is it for an intentional or cle published over a five-year period, pronounce on scholarly views that the Supreme Court of Appeal for ety’s law is by getting the courts to negligent harm-causing act to be Fagan challenged this orthodoxy. He have a bearing on the cases before adopting them. However, for the accept his or her views about what wrongful? When is it not wrong- argued that, though the courts occa- them. Fagan has been fortunate in moment, Fagan’s views appear it is or ought to be. Judged against ful? For many years, the orthodox sionally paid lip service to the ortho- that regard. His most thorough in- to be gaining rather than losing that criterion, Professor Anton Fa- view amongst South Africa’s delict doxy, they did not actually apply it. vestigation of wrongfulness appeared acceptance. 2 Law REVIEW News

Research in the Faculty in 2006 Programme continues to assist Professor Margaret Hewett’s younger members of staff in longstanding and productive work, By Hugh Corder publications from each permanently gaze of an external review panel. The the early stages of their research in translating and editing the work appointed member of staff within benefits of this review will be felt in careers. of the Roman-Dutch authorities THE TEACHING of and research the year. It is interesting to note that the years to come. The search for a Professor was recognised by the award of the in law at university level date almost as many chapters in books Research by students as part of of Intellectual Property Law Orde van Oranje-Nassau (officier). back to the beginnings of higher (mostly peer-reviewed and frequently their curriculum at all levels of to fill the Chair established in Dr Jaco Barnard was given a UCT education. Research has typically published abroad) appeared as did degree in the Faculty continues to 2005 with generous funding Fellows’ Award, in recognition of his taken the form of the individual journal articles. thrive. All final year LLB students from the Innovation Fund of outstanding research achievements academic pursuing an intellectual Research work in the Faculty must produce at least one substantial the NRF finally bore fruit, with at an early stage of his career. project through the study of books continues to benefit from the UCT piece of written research in order to the appointment of Professor Many other individuals in the and cases, advancing knowledge in initiative to establish the position of graduate. The move several years ago Julian Kinderlerer who has a Faculty have made a significant the field by critical analysis of legal Director of Research and the Centre to expand and intensify the research distinguished career in the field impact on their areas of expertise concepts and judgments of the for Legal and Applied Research component of the coursework LLM of biotechnology and patent law. and some are working on projects courts. From time to time, groups Committee (CLEAR), a structure has now been consolidated, resulting Another important develop- that will feature in this section of scholars have collaborated which attempts to optimise the in many good dissertations, some ment is to be seen in Professor of the annual report in years to to produce major works, often features common to the several of which have been published Jan Glazewski’s research grant come. consolidating legal principle across research units in the Faculty. In and are reflected in the lists which from the NRF to pursue research Singling out some for special a field of law or comparing the regard to the latter, the Institute follow. Most pleasing has been the in the Antarctic Treaty Area and mention is by definition an invidious law of different national systems. of Criminology, the Institute of response to the initiative to attract Southern Ocean, together with task, but I am confident that all will This is the pattern which persists Development and Labour Law and doctoral students to the Faculty, his appointment by the Depart- acknowledge this; perhaps the most in the main today, with the trend the Centre for Socio-Legal Research with more than twice the number ment of Science and Technology important highlight of the research to joint works and contributions were all reviewed by the University of a few years’ ago now registered; to chair the committee respon- activity in the Faculty is the generic across legal systems perhaps more Research Committee towards the the challenge now being to ensure sible for the Antarctic Gateway sense of engagement with problems pronounced than formerly. end of the year, an exercise which successful completion of these Project. facing the law in its social context, Formal output remains high, demanded a healthy degree of degrees within a satisfactory time Two individual achievements and the collaborative spirit in which at an average of almost three introspective analysis and the critical period. The Emerging Researcher bear special mention. Associate such research is undertaken.

Postgrad@UCT

A Masters that matters Inside track on Tax AN UNPARALLELED choice of new Company Law Bill will come courses, over 50 in fact, is just one before Parliament in 2008, and we of the features of postgraduate stud- expect the current spike in enrol- ies in law at the University of Cape ments in Advanced Company Law Town. Another is the calibre of the to continue for the next few years.’ lecturers and the fact that the Fac- ‘There are currently more than ulty of Law has long had a tradition 400 post-LLB students at the Uni- of using international academics versity Faculty of Law; most are and local experts to co-teach on pro- part time students who live and grammes. work in Cape Town but UCT is the Take the Masters in Tax law for ex- preferred destination for students ample. The course is presented by a from 17 countries. Our policy is Judge, a top silk and the person who to have small, interactive classes wrote the definitive text on the sub- and this diversity indubitably adds ject; international expertise has come depth to the discussions,’ he said. from Professors Stephen Cohen and Annually, the top five courses are Bill Barker and local Tax and VAT International Trade, the PG Dip in gurus Wally Horak and Des Kruger Income Tax, Commercial Arbitra- are adjunct professors. tion, Competition Law and Ad- ‘The courses on offer are constant- vanced Company Law: Corporate ly changing. In 2008 an Intellectual Governance. A second group of Pictured from l-r: Godwin Magosha, Naomi Chirwa and Elaine Rumbak (absent Regis Chawatama) Property cluster will come on stream high enrolments includes Interna- as will a Legal Compliance Manage- tional Criminal Law, International Elaine Rumbak: Having a CA Godwin Magosha: The Tax LLM tures. Presentations give a chance ment course and a new Criminal Economic Law, International En- (SA) background I feel that the class composes of few students, to students to either challenge Justice course on Victims and Victi- vironmental Law, International exposure to taxation from a legal making it easy to facilitate as well judgments delivered by the courts mology,’ comments Dean of the Fac- Rights of the Child and Legal Writ- perspective has certainly given me as giving all participants a chance or interpretations of certain pro- ulty, Professor Hugh Corder. ‘The ing. a more complete understanding to have their say. What greater privi- visions by SARS, as well as inter- of the Income Tax Act and the le- lege is there than having a Judge of rogate provisions whose meaning gal system in South Africa. I have the High Court read your argument is well established. learned how to approach and re- and assess your skill in forming an Regis Chawatama: The study UCT Mafia in Hamburg solve a taxation problem in a way opinion with keen interest? of law at this School is an un- that I would not have done before The course focuses on internation- forgettable experience. The envi- PROFESSOR JOHN Hare met up with twenty LLM graduates in Ham- the LLM. al and domestic tax, detailed capital ronment is so international, the burg on August 12th. ‘For me to see you all spread out into the industry Naomi Chirwa: It was similar gains discussions as well as VAT and curriculum is unparalleled com- and clearly happy in what you are doing makes the classroom part of the for Naomi who had done a BCom Estate Duty. For each module, you plemented by lecturers sensitive to real world. It sure makes teaching worthwhile,’ he said. (Hons) in taxation; ‘this course has get 6 to 8 weeks of lectures, followed the varying students needs. Indeed given me a comprehensive under- by presentations by each student on UCT can well take pride in itself standing of International Tax law, a topic of choice covering one of is- as the hub of intellectual excel- VAT, CGT and Estate Duty.’ sues that were raised during the lec- lence in an African set up.

New LLMs for 2008

EIGHT NEW courses come on stream in 2008. There is The other two new courses are Legal Compliance an Intellectual Property cluster with six areas on offer Management and Victims and Victimology. The Tax From l-r: Vincent Mayerhöfer, Jan-Niklaas Brons, Arne Stelzer, Erik Reinmuth, Claude – Biotechnology and IP Law, Medicine Law and Govern- programme is also being revamped. Pohlit, Nina Köbernik, Clemens Hillmer, Prof John Hare, Martin Kröger, Elmar Schleif, ance, Development issues in IP Law, Law Science and Eth- For further information contact the newly appointed Sigrid Wettwer, Volker Lücke, Nina Briskorn, Katrin Filz, Thore Schiller, Sven Deters, Flo- rian & Magdalena Gehrke ics and Advanced Intellectual Property Law. administrator: [email protected] Law REVIEW 3 Conferences

Ecological Sustainability Annual conference to SANDY PATERSON has been involved in two conferences. as regional governance structures, national educational depart- debate South Africa’s The first one on Entrenching a Sustainability Consciousness in ments, university management, students and private sector. Environmental Regime Africa was hosted by the United Nations Environmental Pro- The second conference was the 5th Annual Colloquium of gramme at its ‘home’ in Nairobi and was a review of the first the IUCN Academy of Environmental Law. The Academy com- THE ENVIRONMENTAL Law Association will phase of the Mainstreaming Environment and Sustainability in prises the world’s leading authorities on environmental law and be holding its Annual Conference on Recent De- Africa (MESA) Programme . the theme of this year’s Colloquium was Rio+15: A Legal Cri- velopment in Environmental Law and Governance The MESA Programme, which falls within the ambit of the tique of Ecological Sustainable Development. The Colloquium aptly at the Faculty of Law on Saturday, 3 November United Nation’s Decade of Education for Sustainable Develop- took place between Rio de Janeiro and Parati, with the former 2007. ment, seeks to raise awareness and integrate environmental and being the site of the infamous ‘Earth Summit’ in 1992 and the The Conference will comprise of critical papers sustainability issues into all educational curricula throughout latter, a world heritage site which owing to its low situation on the myriad of recent legislative developments Africa. will be the first city in Brazil to be flooded as a result of global and the bourgeoning environmental jurispru- The majority of initiatives during the first phase of the pro- warming. dence which continues to flow from the South gramme have focused on shifting the mindsets and raising Fueled by excellent Brazilian espressos, debates continued African Judiciary. the capacity of university academics. Subsequent phases of the late into the night. Those of you who know Sandy will appre- Anyone wishing more information on the Con- project will seek to extend its application to many more aca- ciate the frustration in his quip ‘sipping coffee as the oceans ference can contact [email protected]. demic institutions and to target additional key role players such rise.’ Town meets Gown in Ben Beinart’s name

THROUGH THE generosity of In 2005 the Vinerian Professor of erty, and homelessness. Webber Wentzel Bowens, UCT has English Law at All Souls, Oxford, He was previously Professor at hosted a series of five memorial Andrew Ashworth QC, a leading Columbia and Princeton, and lectures dedicated to the memory criminal justice lawyer, spoke on gave the Seeley lectures at Cam- of the legendary Ben Beinart, W.P. The Presumption of Innocence, a topic bridge University in 1996, the Schreiner Professor of Law at UCT of special interest to our practising 1999 Carlyle lectures at Oxford from 1950 – 1974. The first in the se- colleagues. University and the Wesson lec- ries was Redesigning the State for Right In March 2007, Professor Hudson tures at Stanford in 2004. Development and was given in 2003 Janisch, a native of South Africa The lecture was entitled The by Professor Yash Ghai. A Kenyan with degrees from Rhodes Univer- Meaning of Dignity and the Status and former professor of law at Dar sity, Cambridge University and the of Groups. Prof Waldron critically es Salaam and Warwick, Prof Ghai University of Chicago, spoke to the addressed the question of wheth- was then Professor of Public Law very topical question of The Internet : er dignity is/can be an attribute at Hong Kong and the chair of the Beyond the Reach of Law? of groups that would provide a Kenyan Constitutional Commission. In July we had the privilege of wel- basis for group enforcement of In 2004 the now retired Chief Justice, coming Professor Jeremy Waldron human rights and the protection , spoke to the sub- of the New York University School of group status. ject of socio-economic rights in our of Law. A leading legal philosopher, It is the intention of the Fac- constitutional democracy, a fitting Professor Waldron has written books ulty to print the series but for any Professor Mike Larkin, Head of Commercial Law, chats to Peter Grealey of topic for the 10th anniversary of the and articles on the theory of rights, of the above lectures please email Webber Wentzel Bowens. Constitution. constitutionalism, democracy, prop- [email protected].

News Snippets A New Kind of Leader refugees, asylum seekers, and South the police. Finally, leader Zamzam most progressive legal regimes in the African leaders interested in refugee Mohamed Hirsi established a weekly world. The SAFER leaders demon- issues. Professional backgrounds meeting with Somali women to edu- strated that, while service providers ranged from school teachers to ad- cate them about their rights. cannot shirk their responsibilities, mitted lawyers and veterinarians. As The Department of Home Af- refugees may only require a small the course progressed, the leaders fairs and many service providers push to help themselves. revealed themselves to be outspoken have proven themselves unwilling Anyone interested in SAFER should and dedicated to the discussions so to help guests in South Africa, yet contact the UCT Law Clinic at 021-650- that more time was allotted to ques- the country benefits from one of the 3775 tions and answers. The series culmi- nated in a two-day conflict resolution Deji Olukotun, UCT Law Clinic case study of a xenophobia conflict Inkundla yehlabathi...world forum online FORTY-TWO refugee and commu- workshop featured a different im- based on real events. IT IS so often the case that a new tions drawn from African history, nity leaders completed a comprehen- plicated right – from antidiscrimi- Leaders graduated with a certifi- broom sweeps clean, although post from 1960 to the present day. The sive course in rights assertion and nation rights to security and health cate that enables them to train other web 2.0, it is also a case of younger simulations involve 10 countries, a conflict resolution on May 30. care – and combined it with prac- refugees with the endorsement of the lecturers making use of technology! couple of national liberation move- Refugees and asylum seekers in tical information about accessing UCT Refugee Rights Project. They Both descriptions are true of Public ments and a human rights NGO. South Africa enjoy a wide array of le- resources to assert the right. are being entered into an on-line Law’s appointee, Salim Nakhjavani. Playing the role of legal advis- gal rights – on paper. In reality, legal In addition, guest speakers were network that will allow them access ‘It occurred to me that interna- ers, students have negotiated trea- rights are not fully utilized owing to invited to supplement the lectures. to legal updates and a rights manual tional law can seem obscure to stu- ties, drafted policy statements and a lack of information and resources. Superintendents of South African compiling the various lessons of the dents from South Africa and needs analysed the legal implications of After serving 3600 clients in 2006, Police Services, members of the course. Owing to demand, requests to be brought to life, and that most crises ranging from the ‘Red Terror’ the UCT Refugee Rights Project de- Human Rights Commission, the have been submitted to the Centre of the decisions of the UN Secu- in Ethiopia to claims for independ- termined that there are many areas Independent Complaints Directo- for Conflict Resolution for further rity Council and the International ence in the Southern Cameroon. in which refugees could learn to help rate, and the Women’s Legal Cen- skills training. Criminal Court relate to current Darfur is coming next. themselves. tre, among others, all contributed Initial feedback from the par- events in Africa,’ he said. Lecturer Cathy Powell finds that The Sustained Advocacy for Em- to the lively workshop discussions. ticipants indicates that the refu- ‘But I needed someone to make it the simulations have brought a dy- powered Refugees Project (SAFER) Substantive workshops were inter- gees are already utilizing their new happen, and we have been fortunate namic into the course - ‘they can’t offered a free, fourteen week work- spersed with teaching sessions in tools. Cape Refugee Solidarity, a in our research and development as- change the facts but they can play shop series in refugee rights and con- which the refugee leaders practiced new pan-African non-profit refugee sistant Shihaam Donnelly.’ with the law and this means that flict resolution to refugee and com- teaching what they had learned. organization, has used the train- Thanks to Shihaam, an intermedi- they are engaging with the facts in munity leaders. Enabling funding Attendance and audience partici- ing to strengthen the skill set of its ate year law student and ‘Secretary- powerful ways,’ she said. ‘It is also was provided by San Francisco-based pation far exceeded expectations. management team. Another leader, General’ of Inkundla Yehlabathi, a great advantage to be able to set Asylum Access, the United Nations While an initial 15 leaders were Wilson Ndjibu Toto, has developed some 180 students in 12 tutorial topics for tutorials and have groups High Commissioner for Refugees, targeted, more than fifty arrived at a neighbourhood watch in Pinelands groups interact in various simula- debate and prepare beforehand.’ and Atlantic Philanthropies. Each the first session. These included after encountering xenophobia from 4 Law REVIEW Conferences Conferences

Food for thought - the role of science in Chinese judges Institute of Development & Labour Law administrative law review & the SA For papers presented at the conference view at www.lexisnexus.com

Institute of Marine & Environmental Law, Department of Public Law legal system THE WORKSHOP in April, A De- ous Universities, including UCT, cent Work Research Agenda for South UWC, Wits, Stellenbosch, Fort IN FOODCORP (Pty) Ltd v DDG (per Davis J) again set them aside, Africa, was jointly organised by the Hare, Venda, Limpopo as well as Department of Environmental essentially deferring to the SCA. International Institute for Labour from institutions such as NAL- Affairs & Tourism, the Supreme Yet the approach rejected had been Studies (IILS) at the International EDI, SALDRU, the Trade Union Court of Appeal overturned a rul- subject to scrutiny by two separate Labour Office (ILO), Geneva, the In- movement and the ILO office in ing of the Cape High Court which reviews by leading world scientists stitute of Development and Labour , among others. The work- had confirmed the basis used by the in the field. Further, the primary Law (IDLL), UCT and the Sociology shop concluded with a roundtable Minister for the annual allocation basis of argument used by the SCA, of Work Unit (SWOP), Wits. session during which numerous re- of quotas for sardine and anchovy and subsequently by the Cape High Dr. Gerry Rodgers, Director of the search directions were formulated. – an approach which had been de- Court, to infer irrationality con- IILS, is in charge of the decent work THE ANNUAL LABOUR LAW veloped in a UCT PhD thesis. tained a simple mathematical flaw. agenda of the ILO. He explained the Conference has grown in stature On appeal the SCA found that In the seminar, Doug Butterworth TWELVE JUDGES of Yunnan role of the IILS as that of strengthen- over the last two decades and is “some of the results produced (by (Science) and Halton Cheadle (Law), Province visited UCT in May, ing the ILO’s knowledge base on la- now a forum at which diverse stake- the approach) were irrational and examined whether the courts acted and it fell to Professor Dick bour issues. The workshop was held holders address and seek meaning- inexplicable and consequently un- appropriately in effectively over- Christie to introduce them to as part of the initiative to invest in ful solutions to burning labour reasonable”, and referred the mat- ruling science that had been peer- the South African legal system. research into labour issues. The IILS issues in South Africa. There were ter back to the Minister for fresh reviewed at a very high level, and Those of you who were taught research strategy is to find ways in 840 delegates at the two day event determinations. whether there is a need for modified International Trade by Prof which research centres in Universi- in June. When those determinations were procedures in cases which hinge on Christie will appreciate that he ties can use the ILO machinery in Law faculty staff and associates made using a variant of the origi- complex scientific analyses. For pa- did it with great lucidity and their work to create longstanding col- of the Institute featured promi- nal approach, the Cape High Court pers presented email [email protected] great humour, using the case of laborations. A number of countries, nently, Professor Rochelle le Roux the beautiful slave girl Louisa including South Africa, India, China (member of the organising com- and her lover the young Capt. and Brazil are now involved in the mittee) delivered a paper on When van den Berg to explain the meld decent work project, which has both does a continuing employment relation- Law, Dignity and Transformative of English and Roman Dutch national and international goals. ship become intolerable?; Ms Andrea Constitutionalism law 200 years ago. The workshop themes, which M’Paradzi on BEE: Can there be Also presenting on behalf of emerged from national and global trickle-down benefits for workers?; Mr IN HONOUR of former Justice the Faculty was Conrad Rade- agendas, span the broad relationship Naleen Jeram The OPFA - Current A conference on the critical jurisprudence of the former Justice of the meyer, lecturer in Commercial between work and labour migra- difficulties and the effect of changing Constitutional Court, Laurie Ackermann held in July attracted over 100 law, who had spent three weeks tion, labour regulation and labour legislation; Ms Sarah Christie (with participants. in 2006 at the Centre for African protection, especially those that do Dr Avinash Govindjee) on BCEA: Justice Ackermann played a pivotal role in conceptualizing and de- Legal Studies in Xianting Univer- not conform to traditional models. questions and Answers and lastly Mr veloping dignity as the key concept of South Africa’s post- sity. He spoke of his fascination The IILS is particularly interested in Randall van Voore on Alternative constitutional law. By creating a forum for interaction between legal about learning first hand of some identifying the state of knowledge employment and the right to severance philosophy and judicial practice, the conference aimed to honour the of the challenges of moving to a on labour issues, developing research pay. South African Constitution as one of the most progressive in the world. socialist market economy. directions and networks, forging key The highlight of the conference At a time of global flux, the conference aimed to be a place holder 2007 will see two groups policy relationships, identifying ar- was the strong, and at times heated raising some of the most pressing jurisprudential issues of our time, of visitors - a group of judges eas in which international compara- debate that arose between trade including reconsideration of the relationship(s) between moral theory, from Sri Lanka and a group of tive methods would be most produc- unions and Professor Mike Morris philosophy and law. Topics addressed ranged from the relationship be- magistrates from Guangxi Prov- tive and addressing priorities. of UCT on the paper he presented tween dignity, freedom and liberty to the relationship between dignity ince interested in community Workshop sessions were on the entitled The rapid increase of Chinese and ubuntu as a worldview. policing. following themes: imports: How do we assess the indus- However, the conference did not just focus on the specifics of South - The South African Labour Market: trial, labour and socio-economic impli- African constitutional law but on the larger jurisprudential challenges Trends and Challenges cations. He suggested the Chinese that we face in today’s world, fraught as it is by violence and war as well African Network - Migration in an Evolving Regional imports may have a positive impact as the complexity of globalization. and Global Economy on the welfare of the lower income The conference structure consisted of both roundtables and formal of Constitutional - Workers’ Protection in the South Af- groups in South Africa. This was panels following themes set by keynote speakers Justice Kate O’Regan, lawyers (ANCL) rican Labour Market countered by Mark Heyward from Prof Drucilla Cornell, and Prof Allen Wood from the University of - Global Production Systems and TAC who claimed that the Morris Stanford. Other speakers and participants included Justice Yvonne In Law Review 2006 we reported their Impact on National and Local view does not take account of the Mokgoro, Justice Albie Sachs, Prof Jeremy Waldron from New York on the meeting of constitutional Economies. many job losses and its impact on University, Prof Frank Michelman from Harvard Law Faculty, Prof scholars and jurists from across Participants were drawn from vari- the human factor. Peggy Davis from the New York University and Prof Denise Ferreira da Africa. The update to that is Silva from San Diego University. that in April, the ANCL (which operated between 1997 & 2000) was re-launched at a conference Intellectual Property in Nairobi. A co-ordinating committee of TWO NATIONAL symposiums Principal Investigator of the UCT judges and practitioners from 11 around curricula were held at UCT, Oesophageal Research Group and different African countries (in- the first in August last year when President of the South African So- cluding , Nigeria, Biotechnology Law was under the ciety for Biochemistry and Molec- Morocco, Cote d’Ivoire and Ni- spotlight and the second in January ular Biology; and Jennifer Thom- ger) was established with UCT’s where the broader topic of IP edu- son, Professor of Microbiology at Christina Murray as President cation, training and research was ex- UCT and Chair of the National and Danwood Chirwa as Secre- plored. Biotechnology Advisory Commit- Chatting over tea are l-r Justice Kate O’Regan, Professor Peggy Davis tary General. On Biotechnology, the question tee (NBAC). The two-day sympo- (NYU) and conference organiser Jaco Barnard for convenor Debbie Collier was ‘if sium in January was one of a series we were to teach a course in Biotech- of similar symposia co-hosted by Traditional and Informal Justice Systems in Africa nology law, what would we teach?’ WIPO in other countries and it The new chair of IP Law. Professor brought together leading academ- TOM BENNETT and Chuma Trial and . The traditional courts but rather to ensure Kinderlerer, obviously brings to ics, practitioners, government offi- Himonga presented papers at a purpose of this conference, which that they maintained the requirements UCT his vast experience from a Eu- cials and members of the judiciary. meeting of experts organized by the included people from all parts of Af- of fair trial. During the conference, ropean perspective, but would we do The focus of the event was on how United Nations Office of the High rica, was to emphasize the fact that however, it became apparent that it differently in Africa? to strengthen intellectual property Commissioner for Human Rights at the vast majority of Africans have no standards which had been tailored to The symposium was addressed by research, training and education Windhoek in June 2007. access to formal court systems. For meet the needs of western states were experts in the field who were instru- to meet sustainable development The broad topic was Human Rights them, justice is still administered by not necessarily suitable for Africa, mental in drafting South Africa’s needs. and Traditional and Informal Justice traditional authorities. The critical where even better guarantees of jus- National Biotechnology Strategy, For further information email Systems in Africa: The Right to Fair question was thus not whether to retain tices might have evolved. including Professor Iqbal Parker, [email protected]

Law REVIEW 5 Distinguished Lawyers

over 20 years ago and was elected cal notion of socio-economic rights. Judge Dennis Best Teacher at Wits Law School These judgements are also an ex- ‘They chose conscience over Davis ten years later. Even now, after his pression of what is perhaps Dennis elevation to the bench, Judge Davis Davis’ most singular contribution power’ Professor Francis Wilson has continued to teach virtually a in South Africa, that of a public by Professor Francis Wilson full lecturing load at LLB and LLM intellectual. This is a role which, as ONCE UPON a time when I was a very young student I was fortunate levels in the Faculty of Law at UCT. such brave souls as Edward Said and enough to be taken by an older friend to see, in , Paul Scofield as Whilst, along the way, being a Visit- Noam Chomsky have demonstrated, Sir Thomas More in Robert Bolt’s magnificent play, A Man For All Sea- ing Professor at both Harvard and requires a great deal of courage. One sons. Rather like reading Tolstoy’s War & Peace it was one of those forma- the University of Toronto. His writ- is often very exposed; often contro- tive experiences which change one forever. Leaving as it did, on all of us ing - over 100 articles in academic versial. Nor can one always be right. who saw it, an indelible impression of the fundamental importance of journals and co-authorship of some For on the hostings of radio, televi- law in society and of the tension that can exist in law between conscience 8 books - covers a wide, wide spec- sion or the daily press one often has and power. Thomas More, Lord Chancellor of England, son of a judge trum from constitutional law, via to think on one’s feet. And yet pub- and supreme advocate of the law, chose conscience against what he con- tax, insurance and jurisprudence to lic intellectuals are the life-blood of a sidered an abuse of power by his King, Henry VIII. He paid with his life. criminology. democracy. For they are prepared to That lesson, of the fundamental importance of integrity, of core human Dennis Davis is a Judge of the sally forth from the ivory tower (or values, in the maintenance of the rule of law was one which the example High Court of South Africa, and the solemn judicial chamber) to use of Sir Thomas More as seen through the eyes of Robert Bolt and Paul Judge President of the Competi- their intelligence and their learning Scofield, drove home to us all. tion Appeals Court. He has also to joust on the hot and dusty plains Today we are here to honour four remarkable lawyers for their life’s PERHAPS THE very first character- served as a Judge of the Labour Ap- of conventional wisdom. This can work. How do we classify them? They come in all shapes and sizes. Tall istic that one associates with Den- peal Court. In all these positions be very uncomfortable but, if skil- & thin; considerably shorter and somewhat rounder; average sized; and nis Davis is his energy. Watching his judgements have been marked fully done, can have a huge impact - drawing on South Africa’s great wealth of 11 official languages plus all him in action, reading of his ac- by independence, innovation and in shaping society for the better. kinds of permutations and combination of these 11- one whom we might complishments, checking his list of courage. One thinks, for example, Dennis Davis has never shirked describe as a “one-armed bandiet” which is not at all the same thing as a publications, one wonders how he of two path-breaking judgements: his responsibility as an intellectual. one-armed bandit. Important concepts, as all good South African lawyers can possibly do so much. Grootboom and the Rail Com- Through his newspaper articles, ra- know, can get badly lost in translation. ‘But if they come in all shapes and As a professional lawyer, Dennis muters Action Group. The first dio interviews but most especially in sizes, what is it that unites them? Davis is something of a polymath dealing with the complex but vital the television shows - such as Future Reflecting on this as an outsider, a mere economist to boot, it seems who has made significant contribu- issue of the responsibility of soci- Imperfect and You Be The Judge - in to me that the singular contribution of South Africa to world law in tions across multiple aspects of law ety, as embodied in the state, for which he has played such a leading the past century has lain in the creative tension between tradition and including - running alphabetically socio-economic rights - in this case part he has done a huge amount to transformation. - Competition Law; Constitutional housing of individuals; the second help South Africans to think more o The law perhaps more than any other academic discipline or profes- Law; Insurance Law; Labour Law; relating to the rights of individual deeply about the role of law and its sion draws energy and insight from the deepest historical roots. Roman and Tax Law. consumers to security and protec- contribution to society. law, after all, is two thousand years old. As an academic he has been a tion whilst using the services of Yet even this very significant role o At the same time that law, drawing on the inherited wisdom of professor of Law at UCT and direc- a major provider. In both cases, of a public intellectual is but an ex- the ages about the behaviour of human nature, has to adapt and tor of the Centre for Applied Legal whilst there is still debate about tension of what Dennis Davis him- transform to new circumstances. The tension between these two Studies at Wits. Quite apart from whether the judgements will go for- self regards as his most important poles, of tradition and transformation, can at times become very his many publications - more than ward unchallenged in their entire- work, namely teaching; for he is a acute as it has been in South Africa during the past sixty years. from the pens (or the computers) ty, there is no question that Judge born and brilliant teacher and it is o Yet it is precisely out of this tension - often unbearably painful of most judges - he has always been Davis opened important new space good to recognize the fundamental both for individuals and for the society as a whole - that the creativ- an outstanding teacher. At UCT he in the South African legal system importance of great teaching in this ity of the law that has touched the world in recent years has sprung. won a Distinguished Teacher award where others can expand the criti- honorary degree. o No-one can read the trials of or Bram Fischer, both lawyers, without being deeply moved by their commitment to the rule of law, whilst finding themselves bound to break the very laws under People which adopted the Freedom important books which had consid- which they lived. Or of the great O.R.Tambo, another lawyer, explain- Albie Sachs Charter. By 21 he was practising as erable influence on younger South ing to the Queen of England that he was actually a “Terrorist”. an advocate at the Cape Bar and was African lawyers when they were able o Like Sir Thomas More in his confrontation with King Henry VIII four well-known for his defence of people to read them---either on a visit to the hundred years before , they had to choose between conscience and power. charged under the racist and security northern hemisphere or back home o And it is the environment generated by their agony and their choices laws of the time. Like all too many of as samizdat. One was simply entitled, that have shaped us all. apartheid’s most effective opponents Justice in South Africa; the other, well o The four lawyers who UCT is proud to honour today have all, in their he was banned by administrative fiat ahead of its time and the precursor very different ways, been part of that creative, at times agonising, ten- and turned effectively into a social of a watershed judgement by the sion between tradition and transformation as they have sought to build leper: prohibited from meeting more Constitutional Court thirty years a legal system for our times. than one other person at a time; con- later, Sexism and the Law. Another fined to the magisterial district of seminal article was his analysis of The Cape Town; forbidden to speak or Instruments of Domination in a book Faith in law is the cement of society. It write in public; condemned, as all on Change in Contemporary South Afri- banned people were, to be his own ca edited by Leonard Thompson and is South Africa’s singular good fortune jailer. Subsequently he was incarcer- Jeffrey Butler. that through the difficult years of our ALBIE SACHS also comes from ated, in terms of the notorious 90-day Then in 1977 Sachs accepted a one of those distinguished South detention law, in solitary confine- chair as Professor of Law at Eduardo transition, both before and after 1994, African families whose members ment for 168 days, only to emerge Mondlane university in Maputo. In were courageous participants in the unscathed to write one of the classic 1983 he became Director of Research so many lawyers have responded so mag- struggle for liberation over more accounts of such an experience in his in the Mozambiquan Ministry of than one generation. On turning deeply moving Jail Diary (published Justice. During this time working nificently to the challenges of our time. six in 1941, at the height of the sec- exactly forty years ago) which was closely with the leader of the ANC- ond world war, he received a card read around the world. The person in-exile, Oliver Tambo [after whom They have mixed the cement which binds from his father, - him- to whom that book is dedicated and his young son is named] he helped self one of the country’s greatest who did much to keep him going in to draft the statutes & the Code of us together. We thank them all. and most courageous trade union prison with food parcels and smug- Conduct of the ANC. In 1988 he leaders - expressing the wish that he gled messages, Dot Cleminshaw, is was blown up by a bomb placed in mittee and the National Executive all the art work brought in to the would grow up to be a soldier in with us today. his car by Apartheid security agents of the ANC to take an active part in process) as a symbol of transforma- the fight for liberation. In 1966, at the age of 31, Albie and lost an arm and the sight of an the negotiations for a constitutional tion, from prison to constitutional Well, at the age of 17 Albie Sachs Sachs left the country to spend the eye. Seeing the extraordinary footage, democracy. court. enlisted in the next quarter of a century in exile. captured by a passing camera, of his In 1994 he was appointed one of The recently published book, which, though non-violent, marked The first 11 years he spent in Eng- bombed body flying through the air the first judges of the Constitutional Light on a Hill, edited by Bronwyn the beginning of a more assertive land, studying and teaching. He ob- one wondered at the time how he Court where, quite apart from his le- Law-Viljoen, in which he has writ- and militant political resistance tained a Ph.D. from the University would ever survive that blow. But he gal work, he has played a leading role ten a good deal is a fitting record to apartheid. As he moved out of Sussex and taught law for seven did. in choosing the imaginative site of of that process which his own cou- of his ‘teens he went to years at the University of Southamp- And in 1990 he returned home as a the Old Fort and help- rageous life symbolises. And for to be part of the Congress of the ton. During these years he wrote two member of the Constitutional Com- ing to shape it (not least by means of which we honour him today. 6 Law REVIEW Distinguished Lawyers

Professor Reinhard Zimmermann cluding the prestigious Leibnitz mas. The teaching of law is demeaned if olence. And yet, Cape Town still remains the long term rule of law in this Prize which he used to fund a major the idea of justice is flouted in practice; for me a very special place…” country. research program involving South and not even a subject such as Roman With hindsight it is possible to At the same time we like to think African Scholars. But perhaps his law remains unaffected at a time when see just how much his work and his that it was his interaction with this most notable book in recent years the traditional values upon which a principled stand on a number of is- Faculty in this country during the has been a study, by a German, of university training is founded become sues whilst he was in South Africa dark days of that difficult decade what happened to German Jew- caught up in a maelstrom of partisan- during the 1980s and his far-ranging that have helped to make him the ish lawyers fleeing to Britain from ship and intolerance, of repression and support for the UCT Law Faculty great international lawyer that he the Nazi madness. Jurists Uprooted: opportunism, of violence and countervi- since then have helped to strengthen is today. German Speaking Émigré Lawyers in Twentieth Century Britain, OUP,2005 is a book which we should all read. self was caught up, with Mandela and ten prodigiously and is the author In recent years he has been the Sir Bob Hepple the high com- or co-author of some 20 books IN 1981 a young lawyer in Germa- driving spirit in a comparative study mand, in the furnace of the Rivonia and a large number of chapters ny took an unusual and bold step. of the legal systems of Scotland Trial. The orator at the University and articles. Amongst his best At the age of 29, perhaps still 28, and South Africa which has led, College of London when Bob Hep- known books are: Race, Jobs and Reinhard Zimmermann applied so far, to the publication of three ple was awarded an honorary doctor- the Law in Britain (Penguin, 1968; for a professorship in a Faculty major books: one on each of the ate last year records what happened. 2nd.edn.1970) and Labour Laws of Law in far-away, controversial, two countries and the third being “After 90 days of detention without trial and Global Trade (Hart Publishing, unloved South Africa. And UCT, a comparative study of the mixed he was indicted with Mandela and oth- 2005). He is also co-author of: to its eternal credit, responded legal systems. The three are known ers on charges which carried the death Equality: a new framework: Report no less boldly by appointing this informally as Southern Cross; North- penalty. When the first indictment was of the Independent Review of the En- young man, then hardly known, to ern Cross; and Double Cross. Why one quashed, the charges were withdrawn forcement of UK Anti- one of its top chairs. Neither side might ask would a professor of law and Bob Hepple [who was released on Legislation (Hart Publishing, 2000) would ever be the same again. in Hamburg be working so hard to conditional bail] managed to flee the During the decade after 1994 During his seven years at UCT, bring together scholars from Cape country. Those were dark times. From honours were heaped upon him, drawing directly on his teaching Town and Edinburgh? that point on until Nelson Mandela’s any one of which would be con- experience here, he wrote 30 out To answer this difficult question release from prison, for a period of 27 sidered due reward for a life-time of the 32 chapters of his magnum it was necessary to turn to that great IN NELSON Mandela’s Long Walk years, Bob Hepple was a banned person of great service. I mention three. opus, The Law of Obligations: Foun- solver of mysteries in Southern Afri- to Freedom, there is a very small group in South Africa. He has never forgotten He was elected a Fellow of the Brit- dations of the Civilian Tradition ca, the No. 1 Ladies’ Detective Agency of families (I counted four) where that darkness; hence his tireless battle ish Academy; elected Master of a which was published here in Cape in Botswana. And from this impec- individuals from two different gen- against discrimination in all its forms”. Cambridge College (Clare); and Town to world acclaim in 1990. I cable source I discovered that there erations are mentioned as comrades The UCL orator further records that, he was knighted. Along the way have yet to find a lawyer or a lay- is a whole network of law profes- in the struggle. The Sisulus & the many years later when the Queen was he was appointed Queens Counsel reviewer who does not describe the sors---including Alexander (Sandy) Mandelas, of course, Mahatma Gan- hosting a reception for the South and a Bencher of Gray’s Inn. book with bated breath and in A McCall Smith, Dirk van Zyl Smit, dhi and his son Manilal one of the African president, Mandela spied At the same time this was the pe- triple plus terms. Quite simply it Danie Visser, and Reinhard Zim- leaders of the Defiance Campaign in him in the queue of guests waiting riod when, free to return to South was born and remains a classic. mermann---that spans the three cit- 1952, and the Hepples. Alex the long- to shake Her Majesty’s outstretched Africa and free to teach and to write, Returning to Germany, Rein- ies and goes back many years, in term trade union leader who was one hand. Breaking all protocol Mandela he became an honorary professor of hard Zimmermann went first to some cases to student days. There is of the founders (with Bishop Ambro- stepped forward to embrace him in a law at UCT (1999-2005) and where a chair at the University of Re- even a series of novels written by the se Reeves & Alan Paton) of the Trea- great bear hug, shouting, “Bob!!” he played a major role in inspiring gensburg before returning to his Edinburgh professor about German son Trial Defence Fund and who in But between Rivonia and Buck- the 3-volume 2336 page Cambridge beloved Hamburg as Director of law professors one of whom is a the fierce years after 1960 was chair- ingham Palace a lot of water had University Press Code of International the Max Planck Institute for For- character called Zimmermann. But man of the Defence and Aid Com- swirled around the shores of Robben Labour Law, published last year, and eign Private Law and Private Inter- I thought it would be unfair in so mittee and played a courageous and Island. edited over 7 years by Neville Rubin, national Law where he remains a solemn an assembly as this to drag effective role in drawing in a whole Landing in England, Bob Hepple himself a UCT graduate and an hon- dynamic source of energy on the in the fictional fantasies of a sandy phalanx of lawyers to defend black set about equipping himself in Eng- orary professor of law, in consulta- international legal academic scene. Scot. political activists from the torturing lish Law doing a post graduate LLB tion also with Evance Kalula, Direc- In 2000 for example he was co- Let us turn rather to Reinhard might of a frightened state; and his at Cambridge. After some years lec- tor of the Institute of Development editor (with Simon Whittaker) of Zimmermann’s own assessment, son Bob who, emerging from Wits as turing he accepted a personal chair and Labour Law at UCT. He also a book, Good Faith in European written in October 1989, of his a trained lawyer in 1957, went on to in Comparative Social and Labour served as the ILO expert on the Task Contract Law which is one of six seven years of teaching and writing lecture at the university and then to Law at the University of Kent. He Force that drafted the Labour Rela- volumes to appear (so far) on the at UCT on what he calls the Magic practise as an attorney in Johannes- was also chairing industrial tribu- tions Act 1995. common core of European Pri- Mountain. burg. In October 1962 he was called nals and went on to chair the Social Bob Hepple is a South African vate Law. The project, launched in “I do not want to suggest for a mo- in to advise Nelson Mandela in his Science Council’s panel to monitor lawyers who have used the insights 1993, is one dear to Reinhard Zim- ment that those years have always been trial for strike incitement when Man- labour legislation. Returning to aca- gained in the South African fur- mermann’s heart. It is aimed at as- easy. On the contrary: life as a law dela’s usual legal adviser Joe Slovo demic life he was appointed profes- nace to expand and deepen the sisting lawyers, to travel across the professor in a deeply divided polarised was prevented by his banning order sor of English Law at the University rule of law in Europe whilst using boundaries of the different local society, in which basic human rights from acting. Madiba records [p.311] College of London before going to all that he learnt there to strength- legal maps to be found in Europe. and fundamental precepts of justice are that he was “ably assisted” by Bob Cambridge where he was also ap- en the rule of law in the country of He has written much else and infringed daily and almost as a matter Hepple. pointed to an established chair of his birth, particularly in the field been showered with honours in- of routine, is riddled with moral dilem- Soon after that Bob Hepple him- Law. During these years he has writ- of labour. News Snippets Community Peace

THE SUPPLY of public services has It is these resources that Commu- the average resolution time is 3 days. not been able to meet the growing nity Peace Programmes (CPP) use in Peace Committees also support demand of communities for health, projects across Argentina, Australia, PeaceBuilding programmes that for education, for safety & security. Brazil, Canada and Uganda. address the root causes of various This undersupply of services is not The pilot project in South Africa socio-economic and environmental restricted to South Africa. was launched in 1997 in Zwelethem- issues. All over the world, not only do ba, Worcester. Today, over 260 cases This community justice and secu- states not have capacity but citizens per month are handled by 20 CPPs rity model, developed in South Af- cannot afford to pay for alternative in the Western & Eastern Cape as rica, has since been adopted in Ar- services. well as Lesotho and North West gentina, Canada, Australia, Uganda However, citizens have something Province. and Brazil. The Community Peace valuable to contribute – local knowl- More than this, in the more than Programme is a project within the edge and the capacity to use this ef- 14 000 cases handled, a Plan of Ac- Centre of Criminology at the Fac- fectively and for the common good. tion was derived in 98 % of cases and ulty of Law at UCT. Law REVIEW 7 Books

Wille’s Principles; 9th edition

recent one – you will find a chapter of the law and South African legal Who would want to change a headed ‘Enrichment’. As the original history. The treatment of these top- book like that? Well, it did eventu- opening sentence states, this deals ics in the first edition is very limited ally become necessary to change it in with an ‘obligation that arises on the and naïve to the modern eye, but the order to maintain the value that this part of one person to make restitu- important point is that its presence reviewer found in Wille’s book. The tion of property or to pay a compen- reflects the view that lawyers cannot first phase of fundamental change sation in money to another person, live by rules alone – they must think took place under the leadership of whenever the former has, without about the law, abstract from its daily Dale Hutchison when he produced legal title, been enriched at the ex- practice, and place its rules and prin- the eighth edition, along with Be- pense of the latter’. This basic princi- ciples in the context of what Wille linda van Houten, Danie Visser and ple and its concrete manifestation in called the essentials of the law. Corrie van der Merwe. This was the specific legal remedies can be traced These two characteristics of the first edition to be produced by mul- back to Roman law; but, as Wille first edition – its dedication to rea- tiple authors, and the result was a sig- writes, the old authorities (and most son rather than the repetition of au- nificantly expanded work in which of his contemporaries) did not rec- thority; and its concern with placing each of the main parts - Persons and Conributing UCT authors (l-r): Anne Pope, Danie Visser, Karin Lehman, Ro- ognize that this was a truly distinct laws in the context of the ‘the law’, Family, Property and Succession, chelle le Roux, Francois du Bois (editor), Chuma Himonga and Dale Hutchison form of obligation – they described lived on in subsequent editions. and Obligations was thoroughly re- (Absent: Mohamed Paleker) this kind of obligation as arising As with many works, lessons were worked and modernized. quasi ex contractu. Wille wrote that learnt from the reception and use of That happened in 1991; since then this is ‘indefensible, as there is no the first edition, and so the second the whole ethos of our legal system By Francois du Bois contract (either) express or implied’. edition was much expanded – ‘the has changed thoroughly. We now The obligation ‘is implied by the law matter contained in the text has have a Constitution incorporating a WILLE’S PRINCIPLES has a special preface Prof Wille wrote that ‘the from the fact of enrichment’. increased by two thirds’ prof Wille Bill of Rights, and this Constitution place in the history of this faculty. It object of this book is to set out the ‘It follows’, he wrote, ‘that the ob- wrote in his second preface, although is not only supreme, but also ‘trans- was the main publication produced basic principles of our civil law sys- vious term to employ for this cause the use of smaller type meant that formative’. It is, firstly, expressly ap- by the first full-time law professor at tematically, in clear unmistakable of obligation is the simple one of the page numbers remained much plicable to all law and all persons, the , George language, and as comprehensive as enrichment’. ‘Grotius laid this down closer to the original. Five new chap- and the interpretation of legislation Wille, appointed in 1920. possible in an elementary work’. 300 years ago’, Wille wrote, ‘but ters were added. and the development of the com- Prof Wille came to academia rela- I will say something about this in it is curious that later writers have Looking at subsequent editions, mon law and customary law must tively late in life, at the age of 40. His a moment, but would first like to preferred the terminology of the Ro- one sees that not much was changed promote the Bill of Rights and its professional life up to then had been quote a passage from the preface that man law’. So following the dictates until the publication of the 8th edi- values. It is, secondly, emancipatory, spent in practice at the Johannesburg gives a clear sense of the nature of of reason other than of authority, tion in 1991. By this time there were that is, meant to free us from the Bar, where he went immediately after the work. Wille wrote: Wille then chose to entitle his chap- about 700 pages of text and one more shackles of a colonial past. the end of the Anglo-Boer SA War. “In style, matter, and size the book ter ‘Enrichment’. chapter. True, the work was updated Both features of the Constitution After having gone to school in Eng- has been largely modelled on the Significantly, the South African fairly regularly, and this gradually have profound implications for a land, he studied in Cambridge and immortal work of Grotius, supple- book like Wille. The first feature was then called to the Bar at the Mid- mented by the treatises of the later means that even a book that con- dle Temple in London. But he was Roman-Dutch jurists, and brought It is always a very difficult matter to be able to cerns itself with civil/private law top- South African by birth, and as his up to date by incorporating the lead- ics must engage with Constitutional surname indicates, partly German by ing decisions of our courts and the determine exactly where the golden mean lies questions. The second means that descent. more important enactments of our it is no longer acceptable to treat He had a clear liking, and consid- legislatures. The book commences between on the one hand making a work suit- South African civil/private law as erable talents for legal writing, and with an introductory part which if it consists of an updated version within a few years of joining the bar deals very briefly with the making of able for students but too elementary for prac- of Roman-Dutch Law – i.e. as if it published his first book, on Landlord law in general, and of our law in par- ticing lawyers, and on the other hand making is a local version of a European tra- and Tenant Law (in 1910). This was ticular, and then proceeds to treat of dition. It is essential to treat this as followed seven years later by a co-au- the various divisions and branches it a valuable reference book for lawyers but but part of our law – in other words, thored text, Mercantile Law of South of the law and of the relationships to incorporate alongside it the laws Africa – usually referred to as Wille between them. A discussion of these too ponderous and abstruse for students. that derive from indigenous African and Millin, the names of the two co- topics, which is usually found only traditions – in other words what the authors. in books on analytical jurisprudence, Constitution calls customary law. It was on the strength of these is of far greater practical value then Law Journal’s reviewer of the second led to a reversal of the weight of Ro- In this edition we have tried to that he was appointed to UCT. The is generally realised”. edition, which appeared in 1945, man-Dutch writers, on the one hand, give effect to both of these points. University was, formally, only some I want to lift out two points from observes that Wille’s choice of ter- and legislation and cases on the oth- First, the general part was completely 4 years old at the time of Wille’s ap- this quotation. The first concerns the minology ‘aroused protest when the er hand. As one would expect, these re-written, specifically in order to pointment, for it had been incorpo- position of Roman-Dutch Law rela- first edition appeared, but is now be- more modern sources of law came emphasize the centrality of the Con- rated and established as a University tive to court decisions and legislation. coming generally more known’. to predominate in the footnotes, as stitution to all South African law, by the SA Parliament in 1916 – a time In this book, he indicates, the writ- If you look at the new, ninth edi- South African law developed over and the equal status of the strands of when Parliament was itself still very ings of Roman-Dutch lawyers of the tion, you will see that time has con- the decades. But the basic structure, our law that are, historically, African young. But in less formalistic terms 17th and the 18th centuries provide firmed the wisdom of Wille’s choice. approach and length (more or less) and European in origin. the institution was considerably old- the core of the law; court decisions There is still a chapter on Enrich- was maintained over the course of Secondly, every chapter has been er, because the University of Cape and legislation merely updates it. ment, and in it you will be able to some 50 years. This is not surprising rewritten to reflect this transforma- Town represented the continuation We are so used to finding our law see how the term ‘enrichment’ has because the book was a noted success, tion in the ethos of our legal system in a new guise of the South African in statutes and law reports that this totally eclipsed in our law the notion right from the start. To quote from a as far as possible. The extent to which College. And here, at the SAC, legal sounds quaint to modern ears, but it of quasi contract. review of the second edition: this required changes and the man- education had already begun in 1859 is an important reminder of the fact The second point that I want to “ It is always a very difficult matter ner in which this was done varies per with the appointment of the first that legal rules originate, both his- lift out from my quotation of the to be able to determine exactly where chapter, but I want to acknowledge part-time professor. If one looks at torically and conceptually, in reason: preface to the first edition is Wille’s the golden mean lies between on the the cheerful willingness of all my co- the history of the University of Cape something over which legislators and statement that ‘the discussion of top- one hand making a work suitable authors to do this. Town in this way, then it took quite judges do not have a monopoly. ics that are usually found in books for students but too elementary for In an obituary published upon long for the study of law to be taken Anyone who looks at this first edi- on analytical jurisprudence is of far practicing lawyers, and on the other Wille’s death in 1966, Ben Beinart seriously enough as an academic dis- tion will see that it is suffused with greater practical value then is gener- hand making it a valuable reference wrote: ‘His books have won an abid- cipline to be thought worthy of full- an awareness of this, with an aware- ally realised’. He refers here to the book for lawyers but too ponderous ing place in our legal literature and time faculty - some 61 years! ness of the legal author’s responsibil- first part of the book which contains and abstruse for students. Professor continue to serve as legal text books Wille joined four part-timers, and ity to bring reason to bear on the chapters with headings such as ‘Na- Wille, however, seems to have suc- for years to come. May future edi- it took another four years before a resolution of practical problems and tional Law’, ‘Essentials of National ceeded in achieving his aim very suc- tors of the works have the capacity second full-time professor was ap- the elaboration of the law. Law’, ‘The Making of National Law’, cessfully. His “Principles” are now to maintain their position’. I hope pointed; and considerably longer Let me give you an example of ‘The Roman-Dutch Law’, ‘The Divi- not only a student’s handbook but we have succeeded by remaining true before the Faculty was generally a how Wille did this in a work which sions of National Law’ etc. and which may justly claim to be of value to to the spirit of this work and the full-time one. was meant, as he said, mainly to set houses discussions of topics such as the lawyer as setting out the guiding intellectual convictions in its pages, Wille’s Principles of South African out the basic principles of our law. the nature of law and of rights, the principles and the latest cases on any though we replaced the words used Law was published in 1937. In his In that first edition – as in the most various sources of law, the divisions particular point.” by Prof. Wille. 8 Law REVIEW Students

Constitutional Precision and Flair Masechaba Bookholane Court Coup I AM really proud to say that this year I have had the immense privilege of being part of a truly dynamic and driven Law Students` Council. From the word go it became apparent that I was going to be part of something special. Our mantra for the year was ‘plans mean nothing if they are not going to be executed with precision and flair by a dedicated team.’ Precision and flair was precisely what we spent each day trying to achieve. A big part of our vision for the year was based on the desire to heighten awareness around exactly who we are, what we do, and why we occupy the positions that we do. We wanted to keep students in the know, and we wanted them to keep us TEN UCT Law graduates and fi- conscious of that task. nal-year students are among 27 lo- Soon after coming into office in 2006, we were charged with executing cal applicants handpicked by Con- a mammoth task: we had to begin preparation for the 2007 Law Faculty stitutional Court Justices to work Orientation. Since 2006, the Law Faculty had been running its own Orienta- as researchers in their offices. tion Programme, which was separate from the main upper campus Orienta- This is the largest number of tion Programme, and it was the sole task of the Law Students’ Council. We UCT-trained researchers to be received much assistance from a member of staff, Dr Jaco Barnard, as well appointed to the Constitutional as the Student Information and Orientation (SIOC) Office on upper cam- 2006/7 LSC Back (l-r): Matthew Karabus, Olufolahan Adeleke, Adam Herman Court. These contracts usually run pus. The Orientation Programme took place on Wednesday 7 February and & Joseph Fine. Front (l-r): Masechaba Bookholane, The Dean, Professor Hugh between 12 and 18 months. Thursday 8 February, and it was a successful and well-orchestrated event. Dur- Corder, and Sufinnah Singlee. Absent: Cheri Young & Abena Danso “It’s a very prestigious position,” ing Orientation, we sold Law golf shirts and the response was overwhelming. Dean of Law Professor Hugh We hope that next year’s Council will continue with this initiative, as the golf students and helped streamline the textbook buying process quite efficiently. Corder said, “offering candidates shirts are not dated and can be sold during any year. The initiative was well supported. a wealth of experience, which is One of the more challenging tasks of 2007 was aiding the law students who During the June winter vacation the LSC organised for a group of students highly marketable afterwards. This were facing exclusion. This was the first year that student representatives were from the final and intermediate year classes to be given the opportunity to is an important affirmation of the permitted to sit on the various Readmission and Review Committees. Even spend a week at the Wynberg Magistrates’ Court, doing some job shadowing. quality of our students - and the though we were not permitted to have a law student from the council sitting The experience allowed students to witness the justice system in motion and quality of skills and knowledge on the Law Faculty Readmission and Review Committee, there was however to familiarise themselves with the practicalities of the process. The feedback taught in the LLB programme.” student representation from the SRC. It was encouraging to note that, as a from the students indicated that on the whole, it was a worthwhile and in- Six of the 11 Constitutional student body, we could play an active role in aiding some, even though not teresting experience. Court Justices will have UCT- all the students, who found themselves in this particular predicament. We The UCT Law Students’ Scholarship was one initiative that we were proud trained researchers working for consulted our Dean on the matter extensively and it was encouraging that to inherit from our predecessors and every effort was made by us to ensure them. Initial selection also indi- our concerns were heard and acted upon. that the fund would be able to be sustained financially for many more years. cates that Chief Justice The LSC continued the Mentorship Programme within the faculty, and We were pleased that this year, yet again, the LSC could award the scholar- will have a full house of three made some necessary improvements. The programme was made compulsory ship and contribute R 8 000 towards the tuition of a deserving final year UCT-trained candidates. for all first year law students, and the response from them was a positive one. student. The candidate chosen this year not only displayed academic merit, Established in 1994 to protect The Programme required students to meet at least once with their mentor but also immense commitment to giving back to the community through the rights enshrined in the coun- and thereafter however often the parties chose to meet. The mentors were tireless service. try’s Constitution, the Constitu- there to give assistance to their mentees, be it academic or otherwise. The year has been a challenging and growing one. Not only did I have the tional Court’s judgments are uni- The Adams book sale, which happened for the first time last year, con- opportunity to serve my fellow students, but I was also taught many valuable versally respected and referred to. tinued this year. Adams Books kindly made their services available to law lessons through the experience and I have been enriched. The authorities cited in the foot- notes alone offer legal scholars and practitioners a rich and singu- lar source of comparative law. The Court has handed down UCT Masters the Moot many landmark judgments, with a profound impact on South Af- This branch of law is not taught in and simulations, each brief was new; rican law. These have included the LLB curriculum. The students, we were with students from all over rulings on the death penalty, the and their supervisor Cathy Powell, the world, many of them postgradu- rights of prisoners to vote and the had to study the topic in their own ates, and with people working in right of women to inherit under time. Essays were submitted by 86 the field, such as the 18 jury mem- the African customary law of in- teams; 56 were selected, and UCT bers and the 14 tutors appointed to testate succession. was one of them.’ support the teams (in dealing with Researchers play a valuable The UCT team of Janice Bleazard, stress, not with the law!),’ comments role in supporting the Justices Shingira Masanzu and Duncan Wild Shingi. ‘The final round was pre- for whom they work. They spend has just returned from the competi- sided over by leading IHL expert, hours researching in law libraries tion in El Escorial, Spain where they Marco Sassoli, the Minister of For- and electronic resources to find reached the finals. They were one of eign Affairs for Spain.’ the legal authority needed to write only four English-speaking teams Duncan spoke about the critical the briefs that underpin these (together with two Spanish and one practical skills acquired, and about judgments. French team) in the finals, and Shin- the fact that it had all been worth- The work of the researchers Humanitarian Law mooters (from l-r): Janice Bleazard, Shingira Masunzu and gi was adjudged best oralist in her while. assumes particular prominence Duncan Wild with ‘coach’ Cathy Powell, lecturer in Public Law. section of 16 English teams. ‘We basically worked through the when the Justice for whom they Asked about the competition, the vac. with just a week off for Christ- work is writing the judgment of team was unanimous in the passion mas. In February and March the the Court, or in dissent from the IT WAS in mid-2000 that the Fac- demic analysis and critical thinking that they now feel about Internation- organising committee of the Jean- majority view. “In providing justi- ulty of Law moved to Middle with the practice of law. One ele- al Humanitarian Law. Pictet Competition sent us reading ficatory arguments,” Corder said, Campus, and some months later ment of this ‘practice’ is the compul- ‘It was an awesome experience lists and question packs and we had “the researchers assist indirectly in that one of the lecture rooms was sory Moot training,’ said the Dean, to meet people who are involved simulation sessions with Cathy once shaping the development of the transformed into the Oliver Tambo Professor Hugh Corder. in these issues – delegates from the a week.’ law.” Moot Court. ‘A spin - off has been the success ICRC (International Committee of Since 2002, law students have The UCT researchers chosen to work There was now a venue for students rate of our various mooting teams, the Red Cross), Government legal notched up innumerable successes, as researchers for Constitutional Court to experience something of what it is and this is the more remarkable be- advisors, various Human Rights and winning the 2005 All African Hu- Justices over the course of the next year to argue a case in court and in 2001, cause the individuals involved, and Refugee Law specialists, internation- man Rights Moot Competition and are: Alistair Price, Lyle Cupido, Re- the Faculty Board took a decision to this includes dedicated academic al court prosecutors, and weaponry coming fourth out of 120 in the becca van Es, David Simonsz, Claire make ‘moots’ a compulsory element staff, have to make a commitment experts – and to see in action the international round of the Jessup Ballard (all LLB graduates), Lerato of the LLB programme. which is in addition to the rigorous intersection of politics, strategy and International Law Moot in Wash- Lamola, Nick Friedman, Mieke Kry- ‘Our graduates are sought after demands of the LLB programme. the law,’ said Janice. ington. nauw, Jeremy Raizon and Gabriella both in South Africa and abroad Take for example our recent suc- ‘There were also the demands of UCT will host the South African Razzano (all final-year LLB students). and one of the reasons I believe is cess at the Jean-Pictet Competition the competition itself; each day was round of the Jessup Moot early in that our curriculum combines aca- in International Humanitarian Law. a series of unpredictable role plays 2008. Law REVIEW 9 Staff

New appointments Remembrances Denis Cowen of Life, the Universe and Everything Three new chairs - Criminology, Welcome to (have you read The Hitchhiker’s (1917 – 2007) Customary Law and Intellectual Guide to the Galaxy?) which were Senior Lecturer Professor/Dean the political events of the time in Property Private Law which I took my tiny part, and above all one of the problems of being a By Professor Danie Visser youthful student who was often on Dr Helen Scott has BA (Hon) and Clifford Shearing: Fourth Beach at Clifton. Julian Kinderlerer LLB degrees from UCT and BCL, I WILL always be grateful for the Yes indeed. I learned more from MPhil and DPhil degrees from NRF, Chair in African Security & just more than 20 years that I had him at Hiddingh Hall than just law. NRF Innovation Fund Chair in Oxford. Her research interests fall Justice (at the time, the ONLY the privilege of knowing Denis Co- That he and Denis Cowen should Intellectual Property Law principally within the comparative NRF research chair outside the wen. Denis became a Professor in pass away so close is quite a coinci- law of obligations, particularly un- ‘‘The intellectual property ‘crisis’ natural sciences in the whole the Faculty of Law in 1946, and he dence, in view of their involvement justified enrichment and delict/ derives from the myriad issues country) left for the University of Chicago in in the book on Negotiable Instru- tort. She is also interested in civil- raised by the commodification of 1961. I arrived at UCT in 1984, and ments. P.S I remember Nina too. She ian legal history, and recently pub- indigenous knowledge, the arts and The vision of Professor Shearing is it would not have been surprising if was in my class, and they married lished an article on defamation life forms which the information to enhance explanatory and nor- I had only known about him as one while I was a student.’ in Roman law. She is currently age has spawned. The existing legal mative understandings of security of the legends of the Faculty from working on a book based on her framework reflects the need to re- and justice governance in Africa, long ago. But things turned out dif- doctoral research, provisionally ti- ward inventors of machinery in the and more globally, through a focus ferently. tled “Unjust Enrichment in South industrial age. It fails to deal with on physical and environmental se- He had returned to Cape Town Ina Ackermann African law”, which will be pub- the complexities that currently face curity. and so, happily, our biographies in- lished by Hart early in 2008. (1950 – 1993) those who balance the legitimate ‘We are committed to building tersected. One has different kinds of interests of the holder of intellec- a research programme for effective, friends in one’s life – with some one Alumnus/lecturer Lecturers tual property on the one hand and efficient and accountable multi-lev- can just shoot the breeze or watch By Professor Hugh Corder those of the wider community on el governance within Africa while a rugby match: Denis was not one the other. developing sustainable research, Wahieda Amien, Andrew Hutchi- of these. Indeed, I think that he was ‘To bring about a more just and teaching, policy and implementa- son & Thalia Kruger (Commercial wholly incapable of small talk. Rath- INA ACKERMANN obtained her equitable order in the field of intel- tion capacity within the ‘global Law); Julian Jonker (Private Law) er, he was the friend that brightened LLB degree from this faculty in 1972, lectual property, it is vital that new south,’ said Shearing. ‘We will and Julie Berg & Kelly Phelps my life with great ideas, which he when female law students were rela- proposals, derived from independ..- develop digitally-assisted courses (Criminal Justice) fired off with astonishing regularity tively rare. She went on to practise ently-driven research, be encour- that will bring the best minds in (and not just loose ideas, but well- law as an attorney, and married and aged; I believe UCT is well placed the world directly into Africa class- constructed, orderly ideas, although had two sons, Justin and Luke. She Wahieda Amien, BA LLB UCT to play the pivotal role in this. rooms.’ LLM (Western Cape). Currently a none the less original and exciting returned to the academic staff of the Ph.D. candidate at the University for their orderliness). The ability to Faculty in 1985, as one of the first Drucilla Cornell of Ghent, Belgium. Research inter- fire people up with ideas was perhaps women to be appointed permanently ests: Family law, gender equality the greatest gift that he gave his stu- to its ranks. She taught commercial Chair in Customary Law, ed Jurisprudence for so long that and freedom of religion. dents and all of us who knew him. law subjects, and soon became a vi- Indigenous Values and Dignity it has de-valued African indigenous His brilliance allowed him to tal and energetic part of the staff,

Jurisprudence traditions. make a lasting impact on no fewer continuing to be a top class squash My commitment then is to find Julie Berg, MSocSci in Criminolo- than four areas of law. player and enthusiastic runner. ‘My vision for the chair is no less and organise the much needed gy (UCT), has research interests in Constitutional law: Harris and oth- Her laughter enlivened many a than to bring the best of Africa and work on the Living Customary security governance innovations ers v Minister of the Interior 1952 (2) Faculty gathering. She was struck by the best of Europe together but this Law and the Living African Tradi- in Africa; plural policing and pri- SA 428 (A); Banking law: Negotiable cancer for the first time in 1990, but cannot be done without challenging tions that inform the lives of the vate security; police and policing instruments textbook with Professor the illness went into remission, and the Eurocentrism that has dominat- majority of South Africans.’ accountability; and the privatisa- Gering; Property law: New patterns of she was able to enjoy a productive tion of prisons landownership: the transformation sabbatical leave in Melbourne, Aus- .. of the concept of ownership as plena tralia, in 1992. Soon after her return Moving on Wilf Scharf Andrew Hutchison, BA LLB LLM in re potestas and Environmental law: to teaching in 1993, the cancer reap- (UCT), has just started working Rooi Els Local Council v Somchem. peared. Ina bore the treatment brave- ‘WILF’S EXPOSURE to gangs, community on a Ph.D. in contract law; topic: Of course Denis could be wonder- ly, but died in May that year. courts, forms of rural justice, the lives of prison- Fundamental Change of Circum- fully unreasonable at times - but I One of the last memories that we ers and politics of compromise which brought stances in Contract Law. never minded that - and I think none have of her was the extraordinary ex-political detainees and cops together in the of his friends did, because I think graduation ceremony which took early 1990s gave him an extraxordinary edge Julian Jonker, LLB MPhil ‘UCT’, that everyone knows that that goes place on 1st May 1993 at St Luke’s in the classroom. In the seminar room he used has also followed non-legal pur- with the territory of genius. And I Hospice in Kenilworth, when the real life scenarios for educational use. His de- suits, including work as a research- will always be grateful that he always Rand Afrikaans University awarded parture leaves a gap in the teaching repertoire er at the District Six Museum. His told one straight out when you made Ina her LLM degree cum laude, for a of the Department.’ Elrena van der Spuy was current research projects lie in a mistake – someone who does that thesis entitled “ The Inchoate Docu- speaking at the dinner held for Associate Pro- is a true friend who helps one grow. ment”, in the presence of Professors .. legal theory, legal pedagogy and fessor Scharf in March. He had been with the multilingualism, and are closely How much we will all miss him. Jannie Otto and Derek van der Mer- Faculty for 25 years aligned with his interests as con- we of the RAU as well as Professor venor of the Academic Develop- (now Judge) Frans Malan. ment Programme Leonard Gering In her memory, the Ina Ackermann Moving up Fund was established with donations (1928 - 2007) from family, friends and colleagues, Thalia Kruger, BA LLB Stellen- Associate Professor: Elrena van Law) and Debbie Collier (Com- the revenue from which makes possi- bosch, Ph.D. Catholieke Univer- Alumnus/Academic der Spuy (Criminal Justice). Senior mercial Law). Lecturer: Aifheli ble the award annually of an Ina Ack- siteit Leuven, Belgium, her PhD Lecturers: Jaco Barnard (Private Tshivashe (Public Law) By Mervyn Bennum (1960) ermann Scholarship ( for a woman was in the area of Private Interna- graduate intending to practise law) tional Law and was entitled Civil ‘HE WAS a brilliant and ferociously and the Ina Ackermann Prize (for International Jurisdiction rules in the EU and rigorous lawyer and a passionately the best student in the course Com- collaboration their impact on the third State. exact lecturer, and withal a very gen- mercial Transactions Law). tle and humane and considerate man These two projects recently re- Library staff member, Kelly Phelps, BA in English and who cared greatly for his students. ceived an injection of funds at the Jasmine Ismail (left) Anthropology (UCT), BSocSci with Benjamin Sefako, I have personal reasons to remember instigation of Ina’s brother Neil; in- from the Botswana Honours in Criminology (UCT), these traits with gratitude and affec- stead of flowers for their late father, High/Appeal Court Li- BA Law (Cambridge University). tion, for they all came together when monies were contributed to UCT in brary, who spent two Research interests: Criminal Law, I was struggling miserably with the her name. Those of us who knew her weeks at UCT in June, Criminology, Prisons and Sen- law relating to Negotiable Instru- miss her still. Her picture hangs with an internship facilitat- ed by alumnus, Judge tencing Theory and Practice. ments, H/P, Insurance, and Motor that of Mike Blackman in the Com- Pat Tebbutt. Vehicle Insurance, plus the stresses mercial Law Reading Room. 10 Law REVIEW Roll of Honour

The Roll of Honour records graduates, by first law degree, for whom we have current contact details; please let us know of any omissions and the whereabouts of any ‘missing.’ [email protected]

1931 Muller, B LLB Torrington, MJ LLB Wise, RM LLB Wilken, WA LLB Yach, DM LLB Rose-Innes, LA LLB Traubm CJ LLB Wilken, MGL LLB Niehaus, JPD LLB Sakinofsky, E LLB Tudor, OI LLB 1966 1977 Tucker, JA LLB Wood, RH LLB 1972 1935 Von Schirnding, G LLB Abrahamse, JN BA/LLB Abel, JL LLB Vorster, CT BA/LLB 1961 Acton, ACJ LLB Hare, JE LLB Bolus, JG LLB Cairns, MC LLB Blumberg, HG LLB Hersch, LM LLB Bowman, MR LLB 1954 Bean, WA LLB Edelstein, LE BA/LLB Kessler, LE LLB Brusser, RA LLB 1937 Borman, DB LLB Field, BES LLB Knutzen, RJ LLB Cainer, PM LLB Fick, EMC LLB Darroll, R LLB Grossman, CS LLB Lewis, SI LLB Calderwood, AJ LLB Whaley, WR LLB Hund, JT LLB Farlam, IG LLB Hallis, J LLB Liebeck, DR LLB Cooke, MI LLB Jaffey, AJE LLB Finn, MB LLB Ipser, CW LLB Petersen, RO LLB Cooke, RJ LLB 1940 Jowell, NI LLB Hartley, TC LLB Katz, JH LLB Rood, LG LLB Corder, HM LLB King, EL LLB Hathaway, EW LLB Kruger, SJT LLB Schapiro, A LLB Daniel, K LLB Alexander, JD LLB McNally, NJ BA/LLB Macrobert, DL LLB Leinberger, PK LLB Steytler, CD LLB Dillon, KE LLB Barnes, BG BA/LLB Menell, I LLB Matthis, EA LLB Lombard, C BA/LLB Theron, JP LLB Dixon, ME LLB Flederman, AJ BA/LLB Ndlovu, HE BA/LLB Mbalu, BBB BA/LLB Train, RW BA/LLB Wylde, MD LLB Gallie, PD LLB Ospovat, NT LLB Millar, WJ LLB Willsmer, NM LLB Baker, S LLB Gautschi, AR LLB 1943 Raubenheimer, AS LLB Plummer, AJN LLB Witepski, CM LLB Beale, RJE LLB Geach, WD LLB Seligson, M LLB Rabie, GA LLB Withers, PJ BA/LLB Glago, JM LLB Kriger, SB LLB Turpin, WH LLB Spears, MJ LLB 1973 Gordon, GR LLB Ackermann, PB LLB 1967 Hall, BM LLB 1944 Blotnick, A BCOM/LLB Hampshire, GN LLB 1955 1962 Boydell, JN BA/LLB Butler, A BA/BPROC Horak, JCR LLB Steyn, MT LLB Delaney, TB LLB Conyer, AJ LLB Kassel, HF LLB Tebbutt, PH LLB Burger, WG LLB Brown, BC LLB Dickens, DL LLB du Toit, D LLB Katzin, WD LLB Theron, SW LLB Consani, EA LLB De Hart, D BA/LLB Gomes, JJ LLB Engers, KAB BBUSSC/LLB Kemp, RD LLB Cox, GC LLB Dickson, LE LLB Kantor, M LLB Leitch, RA LLB Kessler, A BA/LLB 1945 de la Hunt, DO LLB Gill, KF LLB Marsh, NI LLB Lenhoff, DA LLB Kruger, GL LLB Dewar, IM LLB Immerman, JI LLB Oliver, RJL BA/LLB Livingstone, HJ LLB Le Roux, LR LLB Gracie, NC LLB Hofmeyr, GRD LLB Jowell, DE LLB Pearson, P LLB Quy, JS BCOM/LLB Levetan, SB LLB Labia, JBR LLB Oosthuizen, JJ LLB King, BBH LLB Ranchod, BG LLB Roos, CW LLB Levin, MH LLB Press, S BA/LLB Motalan, AM LLB Serrurier SC, LRG LLB Schneider, MJ LLB Long, N LLB 1946 Squires, HG LLB Musikanth, SJ LLB Theron, GDV LLB MacFarlane, SC LLB Odes, MW LLB 1968 Uijs, DAJ LLB Matzdorff, TT LLB Corbett, MM LLB 1956 Sander, IF LLB Zeisler, BEC LLB Meintjes, NK LLB Levy, HW LLB Scoble, GBN LLB Ashmead, GL BA/LLB Moffat, RJS LLB Mda, M LLB Cox, IS LLB Singer, L LLB Crozier, BD BCOM/LLB 1974 Neifeld, LM LLB Horn, JW LLB Stumbles, JRW LLB Gautschi, JR LLB Paddock, GJ LLB 1947 Leslie, RD LLB Weinkove, L LLB Krige, GW LLB Allen, JJE LLB Paton, FM LLB Malherbe, JF LLB Lockwood, BE LLB Baumgarten, L BCOM/LLB Pinto, MD LLB Aaron, QC S LLB Reynolds, PEB BA/LLB 1963 Mc Clune, GW LLB Donen, MJ LLB Sacher, JJ LLB Von Hirschberg, CFG LLB Sachs, AL LLB Myers, DF LLB Duncan, TM LLB Schneider, L LLB Walt, A LLB Shave, RA LLB Burne, GG LLB Richings, FG LLB Goodwin, PA LLB Stofberg, DR LLB Zeederberg, WF BA/LLB Dawes, DA BA/LLB Roditi, SN LLB Krige, DJ LLB Stubbings, HC LLB 1957 Gianturco, CVC LLB Scheppening, C LLB McNaught Davis, J LLB Trisos, HC LLB 1948 Hoffman, CM LLB Strachan, IP BA/LLB Meyerowitz, P LLB Van Niekerk, K LLB Bruk, I LLB Holderness, HH LLB Wadee, YA LLB Segal, LB LLB Vincent, RJ LLB van der Spuy, AS LLB Buirski, D LLB Howell, MJ LLB Watson, JR LLB Sher, JL LLB Whelan, PE LLB Von Hirschberg, M LLB Cox, DV LLB Kahn, FW LLB Sibul, B LLB Wisenberg, PM LLB Hethey, N LLB Kroon, F LLB 1969 Walt, HP BCOM/LLB Zabow, RC LLB 1949 Janse van Rensburg, JF BA/LLB McLean, GW LLB Jowell, C LLB Roberts, AA LLB Borchers, GA LLB 1975 1978 Averbuch, SM LLB Lourens, JJN BA/LLB Simpson, MJ BA/LLB Charnock, MI LLB Blaine, DG LLB Nel, HC LLM Steyn, PN LLB Constantinides, NG LLB Anderson, I LLM Adami, NJ BBUSSC/LLB Fagan, JJ LLB Smalberger, JW LLB Syminton, JG LLB Gilbert, DJW LLB Bloch, JM LLB Barrow, OJ LLB Friedman, G LLB Thomson, RG LLB Theron, EP LLB Goodwin, MT LLB Buchanan, RG LLB Braithwaite, J LLB Smit, DJ LLB Hay, GK BCOM/LLB Budlender, GM LLB Caldow, JNR LLB 1958 1964 Lazar, CB BA/LLB Chronis, PM LLB Clerke, VA LLB 1950 Mandy, DB LLB Davis, DM BCOM/LLB Crosland, GM LLB Austin, RHF LLB Bruce-Brand, SJA LLB Rondi, DJ LLB Firth, HL LLB De Castro, CW LLB Bester, JJJ BA/LLB Comrie, RG LLB Burman, SB LLB Smith, WF BA/LLB Frank, TJ LLB Friedlander, JI LLB Kaplan, SM LLB Donaldson, JS LLB Camerer, SMB LLB Williams, RC LLB Gordon, DA BCOM/LLB Gibberd, DC LLB Liebenberg, JGC LLB Getz, LJ LLB Costa, PJD LLB Gratjios, A LLB Gogarty, RCA LLB Magid, AMP LLB Hendler, HN LLB Dean, WHB LLB 1970 Hendry, KH LLB Griffiths, S LLB Prinsloo, HF BA/LLB Herbstein, DM LLB Fischer, CF LLB Hutchison, DB LLB Griffiths, PJ LLB Turpin, CC LLB Horn, RR LLB Flax, L LLB Bartels, JEC LLB Irish, DF LLB Hanmer, NE LLB Jacobson, WR LLB Herman, AH LLB Burnett, JRT LLB Macsymon, RG LLB Harvey-Kelly, C LLB 1951 Kaplan, MI LLB Jacoby, BD BA/LLB Clarkson, CMV LLB Morris, HDS BCOM/LLB Haysom, NRL LLB Macfarlane, JS LLB Louw, NNC LLB Clegg, DJM LLB Morris, T LLB Heaton Nicholls, CE LLB Cavvadas, JP LLB Marais, RM LLB Margo, RH LLB Diemont, NJ LLB Nichol, PJ LLB Hofmeyr, SM LLB De Beer, M LLB Musgrove, BM LLB Miller, JD LLB Friedman, JHC BA/LLB Paige, DP LLB Koep, PF LLB Goldberg, DM LLB Pretorius, P BA/LLB Miller, LN LLB Fulton, RM LLB Russell, JA LLB Leon, PSG LLB Graham-Smith, N LLB van der Merwe, EJL LLB Polakow, EA LLB Henkes, RJ BA/LLB Whittaker, LA LLB Malherbe, PN LLB Kessler, SM LLB Prest SC, CB LLB Lloyd, DJ LLB McEwan, JM LLB Peart, RH LLB 1959 Rothwell SC, DW LLB Masterson, LC LLB 1976 Morrison, AD LLB Zackon, BH LLB Russell, CM LLB McDougall, RD LLB Nel, PF LLB Alston, DG LLB Scott, DG LLB McGregorm, BWC LLB Ackermann, N LLB Pretorius, JT LLM 1952 Beinart, SO LLB van Schalkwyk, GD LLB Smit, A LLB Blanckenberg, PJ LLB Raynor, L LLB Briggs, CP LLB Volks, RG LLB van der Merwe, PJ LLB Bromley, J LLB Sanders, PR LLB Aaron, QC IJ LLB Pienaar, JL LLB Wulf, CJ LLB Dixon, HJ LLB Scholtz, WM LLB Cook, LH LLB Pulford, KA BA/LLB 1971 Felthun, ML BCOM/LLB Spence, PR LLB Finnemore, PU LLB Spilkin, SP LLB 1965 Glazewski, J LLB Tatham, NR BA/LLB Grosskopf, EM LLB Stern, LE LLB Botha, LBF LLB Hall, GP LLB Urquhart, GA LLB Karabus, A LLB Wiese, CH BA/LLB Bashall, FJ LLB Buffenstein, EB LLB Ingwersen, PH LLB Van Wyngaardt, M LLB McKenzie, HS LLB Greig, A LLB Charnock, GN LLB Johnstone, RS BBUSSC/LLB Wachtel, MH LLB Muller, FW LLB 1960 Hodgson, MH LLB Croly, CV BBUSSC/LLB Jones, NH LLB White, TC LLB Nicol, DE LLB Krige, EG LLB Dittmer, JS BCOM/LLB Lindenberg, CE LLB Palley, CDT LLB Bennun, ME LLB Kristafor, JGJ LLB Farber, JHM BA/LLB MacRobert, JMJ LLB 1979 Pearce, AH BCOM/LLB Bliden, MW BA/LLB Kruger, SJP LLB Flack, PH LLB Madden, PL LLB Prisman, CB LLB Bruce-Brand, AAM LLB Lieberman, MB LLB Hamp-Adams, PJ LLB McClarty, RD LLB Barnes, BM LLB Rosenberg, R LLB de Haes, CVF LLB Lipshitz, J LLB Jacobs, AF LLB Mitchell, PD BA/LLB Barwise, PM LLB Schneider, I LLB Dower, JMR LLB Pegrum, WH LLB Jooste, RD LLB Mitchell, DJ LLB Benjamin, PS LLB Frangs, CA LLB Rogers, MJ LLB Leslie, AB LLB Russell, IM LLB Berthold, PJ LLB 1953 Hodes, MM LLB Selikowitz, S LLB Lipschitz, P LLB Sharp, AD LLB Blomkamp, PJ LLB Jowell QC, JL LLB Snitcher, CE LLB Michau, PJ LLB Unite, J LLB Boag, MA LLB Abel, CA LLB Lubbock, SM LLB Southey, EM LLB Nell, ATR LLB van der Spuy Louw, CD BA/LLB Boshoff, AH LLB Charnock, AA LLB Martin, PB LLB Tabachnik, E LLB Puckrin, CE LLB van Dorsten, JL LLB Brukman, TG LLB Francis, MJD LLB Pienaar, AV LLB Vaatz, A LLB Todres, PH LLB Venn, SF LLB Caiger, AG LLB Katz, R LLB Rubin, NN LLB van der Merwe, JN LLB Trakman, LE LLB Wilson, DIK LLB Claassen, MJ LLB Le Riche, CFS LLB Stander, M LLB Vivian, IR LLB Tselentis QC, M LLB Woolf, MR LLB Costello, JL LLB Law REVIEW 11 Roll of Honour

De Klerk, PM LLB van der Merwe, JA LLB Dugmore, AG LLB Behardien, G LLB Mayo, PQ LLB 1989 De villiers, NS LLB White, GL LLB Dunn, DW LLB Bell, RA LLB McCurdie, JL LLB Dempsey, PJ LLB Fagan, EW LLB Birbeck, AN LLB Nimmo, F LLB Alberts, RB LLB Dickie, RA LLB 1982 Fisher, MA LLB Blight, AM LLB Omar, Z LLB Appollis, LBJ LLB Divett, MJ LLB Fletcher, M LLB Boulton, JK LLB Perold, D LLB Arendse, P LLB Friedland, HJ LLB Albertyn, CH LLB Florence, CR LLB Broers, PJA LLB Powell, SD LLB Arvan, A LLB Halliday, B LLB Bardin, EE LLB Fox, SK LLB Campbell, J LLB Ramono, MS LLB Baillie, BA LLB Krige, LJ LLB Barlow, LGV LLB Gassner, BD LLB Cleaver, AL LLB Renecle, GS LLB Berman, PR LLB Kriger, SI LLB Burton, DMG LLB Greenwood, CM LLB Cockrell, APH LLB Rivalland, M LLM Biebuyck, R LLB Kyriacos, F LLB Charnock, G LLB Gruss, MA LLB Davidson, MAC LLB Schàfer, MT LLB Blum, D LLB La Grange, LP LLB Chiat, AR LLB Heunis, TL LLB De Klerk, J LLB Scheiner, SM LLB Breetzke, BJ LLB Ladley, AS LLB Coltart, D LLB James, BS LLB De La Hunt, VLA LLB Seale, MC LLB Brooks, GD LLB Loxton, DA LLB Corbett, PA LLB Jamie, I LLB Delbrooke-Jones, MR LLB Sloth -Nielsen, JJ LLM Brown, DK LLB Luyt, DC LLB Davis, ME LLB Kantor, PFL LLB Ebrahim, R LLB Smith, W LLB Butler, JC LLB Maughan, TL LLB Feilchenfeld J LLB Kesler, J LLB Ebrahim, AA LLB Souter, RJ LLB Caine, N LLB McDougall, NG LLB Floris, E BA/LLB Lane-Mitchell, WP LLB Elphick, GDB PGDip Swersky, A LLM Campbell, BA LLB Meer, YS LLB Futeran, OK LLB Maas, AP LLB Evans, MJR LLB Van Der Nest, PL LLB Castle, LJ LLB Mort, JWT LLB Gavin, CJ LLB Mall, S LLB Franke, SJ LLB van Geuns, CE LLB Chance, L LLB Nel, PJ LLB Hall, CH LLB Marais, AF LLB Freitag, IT LLB Vivier, S LLB Collen, HP LLB Pandit, S LLB Harrison, HRC LLB Margolis, C LLB Gawith, KL LLB Wannenburgh, WH LLB Collen, J LLB Potter, FBR BA/LLB Helman, L LLB Matyszak, DA LLB Goldberg, AV LLB Welz, DR LLB Commins, BK LLB Pringle, EL LLB Jessop, BJW LLB Meiring, WB LLB Grant, E LLM Wesselink, PS LLB Cowdry, BJ LLB Robertson, KE LLB Katz, L LLB Mgoqi, WA LLB Harvey, DM LLB White, A LLB Delport, CR LLB Sandler, JS LLB Klitzner, I LLB Miller, D LLB Heins, JF LLB Wilkin, J LLB Du Plessis, CD LLB Stephens, BL LLB Koen, SJ LLB Newman, JJC LLB Hiscox, S LLB Wilson, JG LLB Evans, JT LLB Strauss, WP LLB Lehmann, CM LLB Nichols, DJ LLB Hunter, EQM LLB Winkler, TG LLM Farrow, L LLB Swersky, CR LLB Lockhart, MD LLB Perrins, RH LLB Hutchison, IG LLB Wolhuter, CD LLB Gershuny, BC LLB Tainton, RW LLB Manca, BJ LLB Rassool, CS LLB January, CA LLB Worsley, MT LLB Gonsalves, D LLB Webster, AC LLB Margolin, AJ LLB Richardson, GF LLB Jenkings, KE LLB Zurnamer, RN LLB Goosen SC, GG LLB Morphet, LA LLB Rose Innes, LL LLB Kahanovitz, CS LLB Gough, MP LLM 1980 Mortakis M LLB Rutherford, CE LLB Katzeff, P LLB 1988 Grindlay, L LLB Murray, MEC BA/LLB Saunders, AW LLB Kemp, PL LLB Hakime, SA LLB Alman, H LLB Murray, DA LLB Segal, DL LLB Kuehl, HM LLM Andrew, HI LLB Hasson, MS LLB Arendse, NM LLB Rushton, GI LLB Sievers, FSG LLB Levin, ME LLB Baker, EJ LLB Herbert, JD LLB Barlow, LT LLB Saldanha, VC LLB Smuts, SW LLB Maritz, WJS LLB Bavasah, Z LLB Heuer, MG LLB Bellairs, MGRS LLB Silvestri, MGL LLB Stanich, A LLB Marwood, J LLB Bean, GR LLB Hoctor, SV LLB Bembridge, AF LLB Skovgaard-Petersen, M LLB Stelzner, RGL LLB Massyn, AJ LLB Blumberg, D LLB Hofman, KAL LLB Beneke, CL LLB Smuts, PW LLB Steytler, JCC LLB McNally, JPV LLB Cleaver, BA LLB Hope, PJL LLB Blaine, BM LLB Sonnenberg, GJ LLB Strachan, AK LLB Melunsky, D LLB Clucas, I LLB Hopgood, AP LLB Bolton, GM LLB Theron, AP LLB Taylor, I LLB Miller, P LLB Cohen, J LLB James, CR LLB Booth, W LLB Walton, ML LLB Thompson, DM LLB Montgomery, G LLB Couldridge, D PGDip Jordaan, L LLB Burger, LL LLB White, D LLB van Onselen, J LLB Oliver, GA LLB Cunningham, CN LLB Kaplan, S LLB Carrington, MSJ LLB Wylie, AW LLB van Rooyen, H LLB Ospovat, CL LLB Dajee, VG LLB Khan, MR LLB Cheeseman, R LLB van Zyl, K LLB Palmer, M LLB De Abreu, JM LLB Leeman, SE LLB Chorn, A LLB 1983 Volmink, PS LLB Paton, RB LLB De beer, RB LLB Maestroni, FJ LLB Conradie, L LLB Wadee, SI LLB Pentz, A PGDip Dichmont, C LLB Malherbe, JA LLB De Lancey, M LLB Baum, M LLB Walbeck, MA LLB Purves, RL LLB Dicks, MG LLB Maxwell, CJ LLB Fassois, S LLB Canca, MP LLB Williams, RT LLB Raubenheimer, JD PGDip Eden, PA LLB Mitchell, SD LLB Galombik, RJ LLB Chapman, SA LLB Zoeller, CH LLB Richman, A LLB Ehlers, MS LLB Modlinne, TM LLB Harris, AS LLB Dahl, GM LLB Scheiner, B LLB Erleigh, DP LLB Norman, RB LLB Heneck, GP LLB Damerell, DA LLB 1985 Schipper, GJ LLB Fagan, AG LLB Pama, P LLB Huntley, R LLB De Lange, JH LLB Schoonbee, C LLB Gaffoor, S LLB Pfaff, DE LLB Jacobs, F LLB Eggmann, GI LLB Alexander, MH LLB Sorour, KD LLB Gellman, AR LLB Ramjee, A LLB Kakiades, D LLB Emmett, E LLB Amien, K LLB Spencer, DA LLB Gessler, ML LLB Rosingana-Bouwer, K LLB Kantor, BA LLB Frampton, GA LLB Aucamp, PM LLB Stelzner, S LLB Groeblinghoff, B LLB Rubin, AG LLB Kesler, SP LLB Goosen, MP LLB Chippendale, S LLB Stewart, AJ LLB Guy, SG LLB Sadien, R LLB Louw, CA LLB Grobler, SJ LLB Corbett, AW LLB Taylor, MJS LLB Harty, MR LLB Shawinsky, D LLB Melnick A LLB Harper, GM LLB Elliott, GD LLB Tromp, JJ LLB Heydorn, AJ LLB Snitcher, JD LLB Morris-Davies, A LLB Harries, RE LLB Figueira, MJ LLB Tuson, SP LLB Hofmeyr, WA LLB Solomons, DL LLB O’Regan, CME LLB Hill, CSC LLB Fudge, R LLB van der Schyff, JA LLB Howell, RG LLB Spisto, MP LLB Paver, DA LLB Jacobs, A LLB Gad, RM LLB van Rooyen, SM LLB Hubner, DR LLB Stephenson, YL LLB Rademeyer, AF LLB Jacobs, JH LLB Garman, RM LLB Wallace, SI LLB Jones, AP LLB Torrington, PA LLB Reid, DA LLB Jansen, CB LLB Kamerman, JA LLB Wendland, WB LLB Jones, GC LLB Tudor, DG LLB Rudman, GS LLB Kaplan, LC LLB Light, C LLB Yeo, DJ LLB Joubert, EG LLB van Niekerk, MG LLB Schulschenk, GM LLB Llewellyn, JH LLB Linde, PR LLB Zieff, JM LLB Kaplan, J LLM Vercammen, CM LLB Sher, ML LLB Midgley, WJ LLB Marcus, R LLB Katz, AF LLB Von Broembsen, M LLB Silke, KN LLB Nathan, LN LLB McNally, KJ LLB 1987 Klein, JE LLB Von Schirnding, SR LLB Smith, GEF LLB Nicolson, DJ LLB Middlebrook, CD LLB Larter, AH LLB Vrancken, PHG LLM Thompson, CR LLB Nilssen, NME LLB Moore, CR LLB Alexander, AC LLB Luck, MD LLB Walther, SG LLB Trisk, KJ LLB Penkin, KM LLB Muller, DE LLB Allen, M LLB Maartens, PJ LLB Wells, TE LLB Trisk, JE LLB Rudolph, DE LLB Nel, CB LLB Battigelli, DM LLB Mackay-Davidson, SA LLB Wheeldon, MB LLB Truter, HC LLB Schweitzer, AG LLB Ornelas, RCDF LLB Berg, R LLB Mathews, DCS LLB Witz, A LLM Ward, MCD LLB Siddle, AM LLB Pate, DW LLB Brindley, PWS LLB Meyerson, D LLB Woodland, GW LLB Simon, JI LLB Penny, M LLB Buchanan, BC LLB Michaelides, G LLB 1990 Yuill, I LLB Singer, JH LLB Pete, SA LLM Burton, DG LLB Muller, JA LLB Snyman, AH LLB Robinson, APM LLB Chemaly, SL LLB Mynhardt, PS PGDip Apollos, JW LLB 1981 Spoor, R LLB Roelf, DW LLB Cole, JD LLM Nicholls, J LLB Batchelor, AW LLB Stranex, M LLB Rogers, OL LLB Davey, PM LLB Orford, TM LLM Beckurts, LK LLB Bridges, RC LLB Tatham, DS BA/LLB Saunders, DJ LLB De Klerk, D LLB Orrie, G LLB Bellairs, TM LLB Dukas, PJ LLB Tee, RJ LLB Searle, GD LLB Dibb, T LLB Paarman, KE LLB Beningfield, PG LLM Durbach, A LLB Turner, GE LLB Shalala, BP LLB Dugmore, CM LLB Pascoe, CA LLB Berridge, JB LLB Ferrandi, RC LLB Tyfield, LR LLB Sholto-Douglas, AR LLB Dupper, OC LLB Pocock, AS PGDip Berrisford, AS LLB Finlason, CDA BA/LLB Vanider-Hill, LC LLB Strasheim, PM LLB Field, WD LLB Provan, GG PGDip Borcherds, LL LLB Freund, AJ LLB Visser, VE LLB van der Horst, E LLB Fielding, LM LLB Read, SD LLB Bosman, AL LLB Hacking, E LLB Ward, DFS LLB van Embden, SB LLB Fischer, CF LLB Rossouw, GL LLB Brown, AD LLB Hoffman, JM LLB van Rooyen, MR LLB George, SR LLB Sauerman, AE LLB Busswell, BA LLB Illmer, A LLB 1984 von Schirnding, NK LLB Gess, KG LLB Schippers, A LLM Campbell-Pitt, CJ LLB Kawalsky, D LLB Walt, JM LLB Goldberg, BL LLB Schneider, CT LLB Clark, PNC LLB Lipshitz, IM LLB Anderson, RM LLB Westcott, MR LLB Goldberg, LL LLB Shandling, M LLB Copeling, SCC LLB Louw, J LLB Back-Cunningham,MM LLB Zimmermann, J LLB Goolam, NMI LLB Simpson, AM LLB Curic, S LLB Maclennan-Smith, KBE LLB Bawa, N LLB Gorka, DB LLB Skidmore, LH LLB Davies, KH LLB Martin, LO LLB Bentley, RD LLB 1986 Greenberg, PH LLB Stein, L LLB Dibb, TN LLB Peart, NS LLM Bromley, M LLB Hamman, DB LLM Taikina, ER PGDip Dicker, TA LLB Pollard, SM LLB Buchinsky, GB LLB Adhikari, AH LLB Hardcastle, JF LLB Thompson, LF LLB Dicks, G LLB Raubenheimer, SD LLB Coleman, GB LLB Agoston, EJ LLB Henkes, JP LLB Tindle, PW LLB Everett, WI LLB Rose-Innes, LA LLB Collins, MR LLB Andrews, AE LLB La Grange, EN LLB Tropper, ZT PGDip Everson, JCL LLB Rosenberg, SP LLB Cranswick, DA LLB Ashbolt, DH PGDip Lategan, OF LLB van Draanen, SB LLB Ferguson, TM LLB Smart, GL LLB De Kock, RJ LLB Barnett, MF LLB Le Roux, BE LLB Walters, G LLB Fitzmaurice, G LLB Stockenstrom, M LLB De Quintal, MT LLB Barratt, C LLB Liebenberg, S LLB West, VL LLB Franke, MA LLB Tyfield, MJL LLB Delgado, M LLB Bayman, GD LLB Maserumule, PA LLB Wolhuter, LW LLB Gardiner, GJ LLB Valentine, CJ LLB Douglas, VB LLB Beckurts, C LLB Maurer, CA LLB Yanoutsos, PB LLB Gates, NP LLB

12 Law REVIEW Roll of Honour

Gevisser, AJ LLB Knopp, JI LLB Maher, AD LLB Du Toit, RT LLB Clark, GG LLB Williams, Z LLB Goldberg, SG LLB Kraus, C LLB Malan, JHJ LLB Eastwood, WJM LLB Clerke, FLL LLM Wilson, MS LLB Gordon-Turner, FJ LLB Kushner, F LLB Mayer, VJ LLB Eia, PC LLB Colman, KM LLB Winstain, RC LLB Gradel, CG LLM Lehmann, KH LLB Mc Petrie, JM LLB Erasmus, SF LLB Cook, JD LLM Zeeman, PR LLB Green, DR LLB Lester, DC LLB McKerron-Heese, AN LLB Esat, IE LLM Coutts-Trotter, BA LLB Zive, MR LLB Hall, JH LLB Lester, K LLB McKinnell, JM LLB Evison, CM LLB Cowen, SJ LLB Zylstra, JB LLB Hancock, W LLB Marais, M LLB McLeod, HC LLB February, JG LLB Croeser, JM LLB Hartzenberg, GV LLB Margolis, B LLB Mears, KA LLB Flude, PVG LLB Curnow, BR LLB 1995 Katzeff, L LLB Markman, D LLB Mlangeni, RS LLB Friedman, MI LLB Dingle, LM LLB Kemp, GY LLB McLoughlin, S LLB Mokawem, LA LLB Fury, GW LLB Dittke, M LLB Allardice, DA LLB Koen, RA LLB Mihalik, PF LLB Mokgatle, OM LLB Gaelejwe, PK LLB Dix-Fairweather, SF LLB Amien, W LLB Lamprecht, SG LLB Muhlohlonyi, MM LLB Murphie, IR LLB Galiel, MG LLB Dixon, MD LLB Appollis, CD LLB Lanz, VL LLB Olivier, DA LLB Ndauendapo, GN LLB Gallinetti, JS LLB Donnelly, MM LLB Aronstan, A LLB Lashbrooke, AM LLB Park, LA LLB Newham, FT LLM Getz, K LLM Du Toit, CP LLB Baepi, JM LLB Lawrenson, NC LLB Paul, SI LLM Ngalwana, VR LLB Gobodo-Mbomvu, BP LLB Eliott, RAB LLB Bailey, JA LLB Lombaard, L LLB Peters, SE LLB O’Sullivan, MA LLB Gouws, D LLB Engelbrecht, BD LLM Barnes, LH LLB Lunney, SD LLB Pienaar, J LLB Paizes, E LLB Groll, GE LLB Essop, F LLB Bawa, N LLB Mallach, SA LLB Pithey, B LLB Phillips, S LLB Hambly, CE LLB Evans, JE LLB Bedwell, GG LLB McLennan, FB LLB Pope, GS LLB Pickering, DA LLB Henfrey, N LLB Farlam, PBJ LLB Behrman, HM LLB Milner, JA LLB Price, RE LLB Pitman, JAL LLB Holmes, KA LLB Faure, H LLB Birkholtz, R LLB Moses, JJ LLM Raichman, WJ LLB Powers, JAC LLB Hooper, JP LLB Feldman, BI LLB Bonnici, GL LLB Neumann, CG LLB Rajah, GM BA/LLB Rampheri, MCR LLB Hosiana, S LLB Franzman, D LLB Borien, J LLB Niland, CB LLM Roux, TR LLB Rohleder, M LLB Hurst, MJ LLB Frost, AJ LLB Bottaro, AL LLB Oswell, B LLB Sacks, BG LLM Rosenberg, AG LLB Iles, DC LLB Frye, IS LLB Bowling, BS LLB Peters, K LLB Savage, KM LLB Rossouw, JD LLB Ipser, MA LLB Gaibie, Z LLB Brink, AA LLB Powell, DM LLB Schulze, EH LLM Saban, Z LLB Irmer, I LLB Geral, DJ LLB Broughton, C LLB Price, TO LLB Sinclair, S LLB Schiff, LD LLB Jennings, ML LLB Gillespie, M LLB Bruk, J LLB Prowse, L LLB Solms, A LLB Scholtz, JM LLB Jones, EA LLM Girdwood, GW LLM Bull, AC LLB Rademan, J PGDip Steinberg, W LLM Schulman, J LLB Joseph, RA LLB Glaser, M LLM Chabana, TL LLB Rothmann, LP LLB Steytler, MM LLB Sekha-Molusi, FL LLB Kantor, AH LLB Guy, BT LLB Cleary, M LLB Rothmann, KG LLB Stumbles, RK LLB Shev, GL LLM King, MJ LLB Hardy, BJA LLM Cull, DRS LLB Sandford, LDR LLB Sutton, RS LLB Shevel, DM LLB Klose, N LLB Haupt, NK LLB De Bruin, S LLB Schàfer, DA LLB Turner, BA LLB Shikongo, ENS LLB Klotz, GP LLB Havemann, CCW LLB De La Harpe, RA LLB Schelhase, AP LLB Tyndall, BJ LLB Siljeur, PJ LLB Kode, GM LLB Hodges, RL LLB Downing, J LLB Schrauwen, DC LLB van Eeden, PA LLM Silkstone, CJ LLB Lambrechts, WA LLB Isaacs, GV LLB Dyosi, LB LLB Seftel, LP LLB Wareham, L LLB Smith, CA LLM Lee, J LLB Jackson, MP LLB Erasmus, AE LLB Shapiro, R LLM Westgarth-Taylor, LN LLB Solomon, AE LLB Levey, AW LLB Jenneker, A LLB Esterhuizen, GA LLB Shapiro, Y LLB Wilson, HN LLB Soltynski, MM LLB Levick, MS LLB Johnson, EVE LLB Fisher, QH LLB Shapiro, SV LLB Winson, S LLB Stein, L LLB Liebenberg, GB LLM Joubert, J LLB Gaibie, Z LLB Simon, TA LLB Witzmann, ME LLB Struik, PT LLB Louw, RH LLM Karjiker, S LLB Gordon, RDE LLB Slabbert, AJ LLB Wroe-Street, GA LLB Summersgill, BJ LLB Mack, CP LLB Katz, TA LLB Greig, MA LLB Smart, D LLB Swanepoel, JJ LLB Mahler-Coetzee, JD LLB Kavadias, S LLM Grohovaz, J LLM Smith, TD LLB 1992 Taylor, LJ LLB Marinus, GB LLB Knoetze, BJ LLM Gutuza, TL LLB Smith, MPH LLB Thomas, MM LLB Matisonn, LK LLB Kootbodien, T LLB Haupt, N LLB Stewart, MK LLB Allwright, CG LLB Tooley, A LLB McManus, KI LLM Kotlowitz, DM LLB Hendry, B LLB Straughan, R LLB Anderson, HE LLM Tsotetsi, LL LLB Mills, AM LLB Laing, JGA LLB Herrmann, KR LLB Sun, K LLM Bailey, CR LLB Tucker, MS LLB Mtengenya, KMS LLB Lange, FA LLB Hirschson, D LLB Tanzer, EG LLB Barrish, J LLB Turner, PW LLB Murphy, RM LLM Lazarus, D LLB Hume, AS LLB Thornycroft, TL LLB Baynham, MA LLB van Breda, HH LLB Murphy, AJA LLM Lloyd, CL LLB Jacobs, J LLB Tilley, AR LLB Beagley, S LLB van de Vijver L LLB Musikanth, AJ LLB Loftus, S LLB Jarvis, AM LLB Titus, RR LLB Bergh, J LLB van der Meulen, H LLB Nelson, DE LLB Lombaard, D LLM Kantor, D LLB Townsend, AI LLB Boome, RS LLB van der Riet, PA LLB Nelson, KB LLB Madzonga, MR LLB Kellen, LP LLB Twigg, AJD LLB Bosman, MJ LLM van Hoffen, AG LLB Nielsen, B LLB Mallet, ER LLB Klimczak, A LLB van Niekerk, A LLB Brand, RM LLB van Rooyen, AA LLB Nolte-Crimp, M LLB Mia, SC LLB Kruse, GF LLB Vermeer, VB LLB Bruggemann, BH LLM van Schalkwyk, NJ LLB Nong, MP LLB Mills, PC LLB Lerm, M LLM Way, PL PGDip Bulbring, UJ LLB van Voore, RJ LLB Odell, AJ LLB Minitzer, L LLB Lotz, D LLB Cane, J LLB van Wyk, AC LLB Oliphant, LL LLB Moerat, S LLB Ludidi, CZ LLB 1991 Carmichael, SJ LLB van Zyl, C LLB Osterberg, WJ LLB Mofokeng, MM LLB Lumb, GC LLB Carnegie, B LLB Versfeld, MG LLB Pappadopoulos, DH LLB Moolenschot, S LLB Manson, V LLB Abraham, G LLB Cavvadas, DP LLB Webb-Wilsenach, G LLB Phala, FP LLB Mosegomi, D LLB Matwa, ZL LLB Adams, BL LLB Ciolli, M LLB Weiner, R LLM Powell, CH LLB Mtshali, M LLB Mayou, CI LLB Aguiar, ADS LLB Cleaver, RP LLB Wilson R LLB Reilly, CJ LLB Mubangizi, JC LLM McIntosh, A LLB Ahmed, R LLB Cohen, JC LLB Wiseman, JG LLB Retief, CD LLB Namiseb, JT LLB Meneghetti, AD LLB Alexander, GAJ LLM Cohen, DNL LLB Wood, JG LLB Reyburn, P LLB Nongogo, LC LLB Methula, SM LLB Archer, VJ LLB Coleman, TA LLB Wright, TL LLB Robb, J LLB Nunes, T LLB Mgidi, FS LLM Berk, MA LLB Copeling, EJC LLB Young, WF LLB Ruch, L LLB O’Connell, LA LLB Miller, EH LLB Berman, B LLB Coxwell, CV LLB Zieff, PE LLB Russell, MD LLB Paleker, M LLB Mitchell, TJ LLB Bird, BAC LLB Crouse, LD LLB Russell, TL LLB Pansegrouw, KA LLM Mjila, AV LLB Bishop, IC LLB Davids, E LLB 1993 Saggau, A LLM Phillipson, JE LLB Mofolo, LM LLB Bloch, DJ LLB De Vos, DW LLB Selikowitz, G LLB Potgieter, R LLB Mookrey, Y LLB Bloch, DW LLB Do Nascimento, CM LLB Abrahams, N LLB Silke, JM LLM Preston, MJ LLB Motsa, KJ LLB Campbell-Pitt, DJ LLB Doucas, E LLB Acton, RAJ LLB Smallberg, NW LLB Pugh, LWG LLB Moyce, PA LLB Daly, VK LLB Drew, DF LLM Alcock, SD LLB Steer, JB LLB Reynolds, C LLB Mthimkulu, SS LLB Damsell, VM LLB Durandt, AJ LLB Allen, N LLB Steere, GP LLB Ringo, N LLB Nadler-Visser, J LLB Daniels, MR LLB English, DR LLB Anstey, NG LLB Terry, PA LLB Rossouw, LA LLB Naicker, HM LLB Davies, AC LLB Feldman, J LLB Auret, MJH LLB Tobias, OC LLB Samuels, AJ LLB Naidu, S LLB De Jong, Y LLB Fernandes, OJ LLB Barends, CJ LLB van Deventer, T LLB Scheiflinger-Campbell, AP LLB Neethling, AD LLM De Sousa Aguiar, A LLB Fernandes, D LLB Barry, BS LLB van Niekerk, HA LLM Scott, TS LLB Nobanda, LP LLB Downie, HM LLB Gordon, AA LLB Bartlett, JRN LLM Vergunst, A LLB Setiloane, SD LLB Ntshingila, EB LLB Duffey, HD LLB Gunston, TG LLB Becker, MP LLB Wall, CA LLB Shaw, RF LLB Ntshona, YV LLB Edwards, PA LLB Hall, RK LLB Beckmann, NF LLM Ward, KM LLB Shirk, A LLB Palmer, BR LLB Foxcroft, SJ LLB Harrison, SW LLB Bester, N LLB Wheeler, LJ LLM Shrosbree, LK LLB Parker, M LLB Gaffoor, F LLB Horne, R LLB Bingel, M LLB Whiting, KM LLB Slabbert, Y LLM Pillay, K LLB Galant, G LLB Human, TDA LLB Boswarva, EC LLM Williams, CK LLB Smalberger, AM LLB Qaba, RNLLB Glyn, SG LLB Humphrey, SI LLB Boxall, TJ LLM Wolter, GW LLB Smith, OL LLB Raichman, W LLB Gomes, DP LLB Hutton, S LLB Bradfield, GB LLM Smith, CS LLB Redpath, JF LLB Gootkin, RB LLB Inglesby, MRC LLB Bruk, H LLM 1994 Swanson, NA LLB Reid, FGC LLB Goudvis, RA LLB Ipser, AW LLB Bulbring, SL LLB Tamaris, TN LLB Reiff, T LLB Grimwood, S LLB Janisch, HT LLB Cane, J LLB Adams, F LLB Teichmann, K LLB Ribbans, KL LLB Hack, SJ LLB Jury, BN LLB Carrim, YT LLB Attenborough, CE LLB Theys, EE LLM Ritchie, JM LLB Haldane, LK LLB Keller, GM LLB Cavernelis, DB LLM Bangerter, JD LLB Thompson, MJ LLM Roeleveld, JJ LLM Hickman, RD LLB Knoesen, T LLB Cook, JL LLB Barratt, MR LLB Todd, PG LLB Schroder, JM LLB Hislop, GP LLB Krige, M LLB Coughlan, WS LLB Bartman, M LLB Todd, R LLB Segall, L LLB Hoffman, JS LLB Leeb-du Toit, R LLB Cullis, J LLB Becker, RD LLB van Hoffen, AC LLB Seria, S LLB Isaacs, GR LLB Lewis, MS LLB Dagnall, NJ LLB Booth, J LLB van Zyl, H LLM Shikhati, MG LLB Jacobs, I LLB Liebenberg, KM LLB Daniels, H LLM Boss-Shollei, GJ LLM Vatalidis, A LLB Siyaka, SB LLB Janisch, MW LLB Lotter, WA LLB Davids, DB LLB Boswarva, YO LLM Vayanos, A LLB Slingers, HS LLB Jelliman, CA LLB Loureiro, J LLB Davidson, C LLB Bowley, AR LLB Vayanos, M LLB Smith, TA LLB Jolliffe, GA LLB Louwrens, JNT LLB de Mink, J LLB Caldwell, KL LLB Ward, SL LLB Stegmann, MH LLB Katz, SD LLB Lynch, VP LLB Delcarme-Mills, DG LLB Casey, EA LLB Whitesman, GJ LLB Stiebel, MP LLB Kiersen, S LLB MacGregor, A LLB Dlamini, FM LLB Cetywayo, N LLB Willcox, MJ LLB Stirling, EA LLB Law REVIEW 13 Roll of Honour

Stock, JM LLB 1997 van Zyl, D LLB Stoffel, CW LLM Rugeiyamu, JK LLM Popatlal, S LLB Taylor, JMP LLB Wessels, H LLB Thompson, E LLB Saller, KS LLB Prechtel, D LLM Taylor-Wigley, RE LLB Adcock, SM LLB Williams, YA LLB Truter, JD LLM Samson, EP LLB Prince, M LLB Titus, UC LLB Arendse, NA LLM Wilson, H LLB Valley-Omar, R LLB Schenk, O LLM Rabkin, F LLB Toerien, CR LLM Baker, TN LLB Witbooi, EV LLB van der Poel, JP LLB Seedat, S LLM Roberts, N LLB Vassen, C LLB Belelie, TM LLB Wolpe, C LLB Van helden, RD LLB Seedorf, SA LLM Ross-Munro, JK LLB Versfeld, C LLB Bent, N LLB Wolpe L LLB Vassen, MR LLB Shreef, W LLB Saenger, J LLM Volschenk, GJ LLB Berman, M LLB Verhaeghe de Naeyer, ME LLM Sidzamba, N LLB Shephard, NJ LLB Watermeyer, MS LLB Blum, JB LLM 1998 Von Samson-Himmelstjerna A LLM Siegel, KM LLM Singh, T LLB Wilson, KL LLB Bohler, K LLM Walters, LV LLB Stansfield, GJ LLB Skjolaas, I LLM Wilson, SP LLB Buchmann, AW LLB Abdullah, N LLM Wanjau, MW LLM Stanton, SL LLB Smit, JS LLB Zalgaonkir, R LLB Bulbulia, S LLB Abrahamson, D LLB Warrin, LA LLB Steyn, EJS LLM Smythe, DL LLB Buswell, G LLM Abuya, EO LLM Willenberg, KH LLB Swindells-Lajzerowicz, J LLM Sulaiman, R LLB 1996 Casey, GWP LLB Allan, RA LLB Wilson, V LLB Thomas, DM LLB Wagner, JA LLB Cassim, H LLB Amm, GW LLB Zimmermann, Q LLB Torr, AM LLB Waldhauser, M LLM Ajam, N LLB Coetzee, LA LLM Asamani, YN LLM Zwiegelaar, GS LLB Turner, BC LLB Wharton, BC LLB Baiocchi, LJ LLB Conradie, BN LLM Aucamp, JL LLM van der Walt, TA, LLB Barber, J LLB Cosslett, TN LLB Baguley, DW LLB 1999 van der Walt, CP LLB 2001 Belger, AP LLB Cox, PID LLB Barclay, CA LLB van Tonder, C LLB Bell, VJ LLB Cronje, MA LLB Beja, X LLB Abrahams, L LLB Veldman, S LLB Abdurahman, Z LLB Bey, M LLB Crookes, AG LLB Black, CR LLB Allegrucci, AM LLB Vogt, J LLM Abrahams, R LLB Bietz, M LLM Dannecker, R LLM Boelaerts, VM LLM Aloo, LO LLM Waibale-Muganga, A LLB Ackermann, CFJ LLM Borgstrom, DP LLB Davies, B LLB Bohne, J LLM Apollonio, P LLB Wallace, RS LLM Affeld, JO LLM Botha, JS LLB de Bondt, J LLM Borman, PJ LLM Archbold, CW LLM Wilson, C LLB Ahmed, AK LLB Boyes, BK LLB de Villiers, DP LLB Brett, GB LLB Babamia, JA LLB Wollaston, DCS LLM Andrew, PCE LLB Bozalek, LJ LLM de Wet, ST LLB Bricout, RG LLM Barow, IW LLB Younger, MD LLM Baier, J LLM Brodziak, LJ LLB Dewar, G LLB Burger, PF LLB Barrow, S LLB Banderker, MS LLM Buis, JM LLB Dhlomo, KTN LLB Bush, NE LLB Bennett, A LLB 2000 Banyu, AE LLM Callaghan, HLJ LLM Dingley, RG LLB Buys, CR LLM Brandt, N LLB Bawjee, H LLB Chaplin, VO LLB Dini, TC LLB Camroodien, Z LLB Burger, AN LLB Abarder, K LLB Brand, JA LLB Christie, A LLB Dollie, A LLB Chabana, RJ LLB Burgess, MIR LLB Adhikari, M LLB Brand, C LLM Commins, D LLB Ellender, ZC LLB Chunilal, R LLB Chapman, AL LLB Agamah, DJK LLM Campbell, CD LLB Cooke, DJ LLB Elliott, CA LLB Clulow, JA LLM Cook, MA LLB Akapo, FR LLM Chicken, AJ LLB Coombe, DD LLB Ertner, RM LLM De Kock, N LLB Dankert, O LLM Alexander, HM LLB Cohen, CL LLB Cronje, HT LLB Fikelepi, UN LLB Diemont, MA LLM de Grahl, MJ LLM Allchin, AY LLB Cook, SL LLB De Klerk, GN LLB Fletcher, AJ LLB Dingley, DA LLB de Vos, AA LLM Bailey, N LLB Currie H LLB De Kock, MJ LLB Garces, JC LLB Dlothi, KZ LLB Dodd, SM LLB Baker, TL LLB Danford, S LLB Dramat, Y LLB Gerneke, NJ LLB du Toit, GA LLB Doerschner, S LLM Barchard, LV LLM Daniels, E LLB Du Toit, AM LLB Good, SM LLB Eastwood, JA LLB Douglas, C LLB Beinart, C LLB Darsot, MS LLM Ellis, J LLB Green, M LLB Foulkes, T LLB Draai, LJ LLB Berk, CD LLM de Havilland, N LLM Ferguson, S LLB Haldenby, DM LLB Foxcroft, JR LLB Du Plooy, HE LLB Bhana, D LLB de Jager, NC LLB Franco, EJ LLB Hans, CD LLB Frank, BR LLB Eagar, CJ LLM Boda, S LLB De Mendonca, T LLB Goosen, LJ LLB Henshall, TJ LLB Franks, DE LLB Elsner, K LLM Borwick, SJ LLB Deltgen, ATC LLM Hale, A LLB Hill, LC LLB Freiherr von Bodenhausen, BE LLM Erasmus, AA LLM Bosch, C LLM Ebrahim, Z LLB Harrison, CLC LLB Hinana, S LLB Ger, B LLB Etu-Seppala, MK LLM Chidrawi, WJ LLB Esau, HL LLB Holwill, RJ LLB Huber, M LLM Gogwe-Sibanda, J LLB Feandeiro, VI LLB Cloete, YA LLB Fiene, DHA LLB Horton, AMS LLB Hughes, BJ LLB Hamburger, GL LLB Finnern, A LLB De Villiers, PS LLB Freise, B LLM Howie, RJ LLB Jaff-Klein, D LLB Hammond, LS LLB Frauenknecht, SA LLM De Villiers, AJ LLB Garbman, N LLB Jeram, NGP LLB Jarvis, KM LLB Harris, JT LLB Gcelu, LS LLB Dunster, RJ LLB Gardner, Z LLB Johnstone, MP LLB Job, ES LLB Hector, CO LLB Gichangi, EW LLM Ebrahim, M LLB Gazi, N LLB Jones, JCA LLB Jones, B LLB Henshall, SJ LLB Gie, SAP LLB Franke, JM LLM Gehrke, F LLM Jorge, JAD LLB Jowell, S LLB Hofmeyr, A LLB Gikunda, NK LLM Gaibie, F LLB Gerstle, LHM LLB Koorowlay, MR LLB Juric, DF LLB Hogben, SL LLB Gloer, RH LLM Gambeno, M LLB Girolo, EM LLB Lacob, LM LLB Kahn, N LLB Hollman, HM LLB Goliath, PL LLM Georges, G LLM Globig, C LLM Langa, TP LLB Kesler, JM LLB Holt, E LLM Hearn, M LLB Glander, HS LLM Golding, LH LLB Langford, J LLB Keyser, A LLM Hubbard, GM LLB Herick, F LLM Grobler, NV LLB Grimstad, K LLM Lazarus, G LLB Khatib, M LLB Huntley, SP LLB Hillig, A LLM Hagenmeier, CCA LLM Gwaunza, ID LLB Levin, D LLB Konson, MP LLB Ick, H LLM Huntingford, GM LLB Harper, LS LLM Hancke, E LLB Lewis, GB LLB Konson, MM LLB Ismail, AV LLB Irvine, HPM LLB Hinrichs, EU LLM Hendricks, M LLB Louw, LN LLB Kralik, F LLM Jacobs, DD LLB Ismail, S LLB Holford, TW LLB Hey, R LLB Lucas, CP LLB Letcher, GK LLB Joffe, M LLB Jakoet, S LLB Hunt, CB LLB Hildebrand, M LLM Mahomed, AA LLB Letete, PI LLM Ketchemin, EP LLM Johaar, S LLB Husemeyer, NF LLB Hjelseth, G LLM Malebana, VM LLB Long, TAN LLB Koenig, SG LLB Karjieker, ZA LLM Ismail, N LLB Howarth, JA LLB Maloka, TC LLB Low, C LLB Laubscher, P LLM Kassen, S LLB Jackson, YAF LLB Jermyn, GD LLM Marshall, AS LLB Ludditt, L LLB Lee, JR LLB Kaufmann, S LLM Jacob DA LLB Jonker, JD LLB Mayers, JM LLB Macdonald, JW LLB Leslie, GA LLB Khojane, MG LLB Jansen, ZM LLB Julies, CS LLB Merensky, EL LLB Masithela, Y LLB Lister, BD LLB Kley, CFG LLM Johaar, A LLB Kalonda, KP LLM Meyer, H LLB Menigo, MNC LLB Mabanga, OB LLB Kraljevich, M LLB Kanias, N LLB Kemmann, K LLM Mhlanga, LJ LLB Meyer, CS LLB Malcolm, GJ LLM le Grange, AM LLM Karagiannis, A LLM Khan, F LLB Miller, S LLB Mgengwana, TJ LLB Males, LB LLB Lenz, U LLM Khalaki, PM LLB Koch, RCJ LLM Minty, AY LLB Mkhwanazi, T LLB Marcus, NN LLB Lidovho, MN LLM Khuluse, S LLB Kotze, JH LLM Mohamed, R LLB Mofokeng, NM LLB Marriott, BL LLB Lindop, JBF LLB Kirschner, AK LLM la Cock, K LLM Moodie, CH LLB Moosa, F LLM McBride, JGB LLB Lyons, SI LLM Kosviner, JR LLB le Roux, AR LLB Moore, KG LLM Motsoeneng, KS LLB Mcmullen, NJ LLB Mallen, BL LLB Kudo, RL LLB Machingambi, N LLB Moshesh, NN LLB Muller, CC LLB Meneses, GE LLB Manjezi, M LLM Langston, LD LLB Madisha, MM LLB Mponco, NP LLM Mustard, DR LLM Monamodi, RR LLB Millard, S LLB Makanjee, U LLB Majamane, Z LLB Munangati, NP LLM Ndema, Y LLM Mooki, O LLB Mopp, A LLM Mapongwana, BL LLB Maluleke, B LLB Noordien, S LLB O’Cuinneagain, MM LLB Morebodi, RE LLB Morrison, MG LLB Mashaba, GY LLB Manikai, F LLB Nordien, Q LLB Ohrendorf, J LLM Muckenheim, K LLM Motlekar, NB LLB Matshakaile, TN LLB Maphisa, K LLB Paterson, AR LLB Omar, F LLB Musi, CJ LLM Moultrie, RJA LLB Matthews, R LLM Maqhwara, MA LLB Petersen, A LLB Otto, R LLB Ndauendapo, ET LLB Mrkusic, IP LLB Mcdevitt, CJ LLB Marutle, FE LLB Pettit, MP LLB Place, CG LLM Nelson, RA LLB Mudeme, E LLB Melville, D LLB Mason, HW LLM Phehane, MTM LLB Pryce, TJ LLB Nesbitt, GE LLB Mueller, E LLM Michaels, PW LLB Mayaba, JB LLB Philander, HJ LLB Rolfe, MS LLB Newton, BN LLM Murru, AR LLB Miller, HA LLB Mc Caffrey, DH LLM Pregnolato, PM LLB Rothgiesser, SA LLB Nkomo, MJ LLB Mworia, NK LLM Mkhawana, KX LLB Mcdonnell, LJ LLB Prollius, S LLB Sayeed, IJ LLB Ntloko, NS LLM Neethling, AE LLB Moodley, YS LLB McKenna, BT LLB Qina, BT LLM Schlecht, K LLM Nyenhuis, J LLM Nijboer, BM LLM Mpahlaza, B LLB Mdhladhla, N LLB Qose, MS LLB Scott, DC LLB Oaker, WL LLM Nkosi, S LLM Mueller, S LLM Meyer, J LLM Qwelane, DD LLB Shaskolsky, GS LLB Orr, L LLB O’Carroll, AJ LLB Mueller-Broich, J LLM Molepo, MD LLB Riekert, SL LLM Soofie, MZ LLB Phamba, FP LLB Parenzee, LJ LLB Murison, LA LLB Moloisane, OR LLM Roets, AJ LLB Spottiswoode, KO LLB Reynolds, T LLB Perlzweig, D LLM Nel, E LLM Ndwanya, MG LLB Satgar, V LLM Stead, AC LLB Rosenthal, CE LLB Phillips, PM LLB Nockler, T LLM Ngwenya, MCX LLM Sathekge, MJ LLB Stevenson, SE LLB Sass, MY LLB Prentice, ML LLB Noor, N LLB Nordmann, A LLM Seedat, S LLB Stobart, BI LLB Scott, HJ LLB Quixley, GGM LLB Nyland, N LLM Ntlemeza, TH LLB Stokes, PC LLB Summers, RW LLB Seth, SCP LLB Radzinski, DR LLM O’Flaherty, KL LLB Parenzee, PE LLB Taylor, NC LLB Swart, M LLB Sethabela, KAM LLB Rajab-Budlender, N LLB Olivier, A LLM Parker, A LLB Theo, LJ LLB Talberg, J LLB Shevelew, M LLB Rasethuntsa, SP LLB Ord, J LLB Parker, G LLB Wallace, R LLB Taylor, JA LLB Siganagana, SA LLB Reineck, PA LLM Overdyck, KA LLB Pillay, M LLB Warner, AL LLB Tlake, E LLB Skeyi, PN LLB Rodgers, T LLB Oxenham, JMJ LLB Prain, JD LLM Williams, MK LLB Toefy, A LLB Spicer, JL LLB Rothfuchs, S LLM Petersen, ND LLB Price, S LLB Zeller, C LLB Tong, L LLB Springer, A LLB Roudi, A LLM Phayane MO LLB Prins, PA LLB

14 Law REVIEW Roll of Honour

Ragni,Ragni, C LLLMLM Logday, H LLM Kettner, B LLM Hendricks, CS LLM Choritz, S LLB Ricketts, DL LLB Ringleben,Ringleben, C LLLMLM Luecke, VBJ LLM Knill, KG LLB Herholdt, A LLM Christiansen, L LLM Robbie, SM LLB Roelofse,Roelofse, PPLL LLLMLM Mackintosh, KS LLB Kreische, B LLM Hilgenberg, J LLM Claassens, HJB LLB Rochester, V LLM Rose,Rose, C LLLBLB Maclay, CI LLB Kwawukume, PC LLM Human, L LLB Cook, LJ LLB Rogers, CM LLB Rubenstein,Rubenstein, H LLLBLB Markovitz, LH LLB Legler, D LLM Hunter, ZA LLB Cote, D LLM Rugege, U LLB Sattar,Sattar, MMMM LLLBLB Marx, M LLM Light, M LLB Hutchison, A LLB Croxford, DR LLB Saban, W LLB Scheithauer,Scheithauer, A LLLMLM Mbi, J LLB Lottersberger, A LLM Ioannou, M LLM Cupido, L LLB Sanderson-Smith, T LLB Schuscheng,Schuscheng, SSAA LLLMLM Mdluli, SMN LLB Loynes, TA LLB Katchi, ISO LLM Cutler, CN LLB Saruchera, L LLB Schwalb,Schwalb, JJPP LLLMLM Mendelsohn, JM LLB Lwatula, M LLB Kathemba, V LLB Dagut, H LLM Sax, P LLB Sellars,Sellars, IIDD LLLBLB Mengel, K LLB Maalim, MJ LLM Kemp, MH LLM Daniel, A LLB Schonwetter, T LLM Sherman,Sherman, RRGG LLLBLB Minyuku, TW LLB Maclean, KS LLB Kerr, SJ LLB Davidson, AD LLB Scrutton, RD LLB Siganga,Siganga, DDLL LLLMLM Morrissey, AHA LLB Makoni, TT LLB Kiragu, RM LLB Davies, K LLB Sheen, TH LLB Simmons,Simmons, RRJJ LLLMLM Mzwakali, M LLB Moakes, JK LLB Krensel, A LLM De Wet, M BCOM Law Siddle, R BCOM Law Slabber,Slabber, JJHH LLLMLM Narcy, LMD LLB Monyo, AE LLB Kuhn, RG LLM Deupmann, P LLM Simon, T LLB Stevens,Stevens, IIRJRJ LLLBLB Ntsebeza, DB LLM Murcott, MJ LLB Lanfranchi, R LLB Dlamini, S LLB Singh, P LLM Steventon,Steventon, TTHH LLLBLB Nyangane, T LLB Murombo, T LLM Lee, A LLB Druker, KG LLM Snitcher, A LLB Stocks,Stocks, DDLL LLLBLB O’Connor, C LLB Murza, MA LLM Lewis, MC LLB du Toit, L LLB Steenkamp, J LLM Strandvik,Strandvik, UUBB LLLBLB Oehley, WM LLM Niederfahrenhorst, W LLM Louw, JT LLB Eadie, M BCOM Law Surty, F LLB Strelau,Strelau, S LLLMLM Pagel, PC LLM Nikani, AM LLB Maistry, U LLB Finck, C LLB Tacon, CL LLB Streufert,Streufert, A LLLMLM Parker, AB LLB Norton, SL LLB Martins, BAD LLM Fitzpatrick, EFL LLB Thomson, SC LLB Thomas,Thomas, R LLLBLB Radebe, KS LLB Olivier, BPF LLB Mashanyare, CM LLB Fotakis, H LLB van Es, RE LLB Ulrich,Ulrich, A LLLMLM Ramjee, N LLB Olivier, OR LLM Matiza, VJ LLB Fung, S LLM van Zyl, EC LLB Underwood,Underwood, RRHH LLLBLB Raposo-Deininger, AR LLB Oxtoby, CC LLB Mckay, JR LLB Furness, C LLM van Zyl, M LLM vanvan dderer WWesthuizen,esthuizen, L LLLBLB Ravele, IH LLB Paiva, K LLB Mckenzie, AR LLB Gibson, MM LLB Wagener, S LLB vanvan EEeden,eden, MMEE LLLBLB Rose, B LLM Passaportis, DA LLB Meyer, LC LLB Greenbaum, B LLM Watson, GH LLB vanvan NNiekerk,iekerk, A LLLBLB Schiller, T LLM Pather, N LLB Mkwanazi, B LLM Greisdorfer, J LLB West, S LLM vanvan RReenen,eenen, D LLLBLB Schuld, RA LLM Podewiltz, O LLB Mnisi, SS LLB Gubula, NG LLB Wilkin, JP LLB vanvan WWyk,yk, K LLLMLM Sherren, ND LLB Pohler, J LLM Mohamed Hoosain, M LLB Hargey, F LLB Williams, A LLM Vasiljevic,Vasiljevic, M LLLBLB Shoniwa, S LLB Pohlmann, U LLM Moodley, K LLB Haroun, S LLB Wishart, S LLM Walker-Woodard,Walker-Woodard, N LLLBLB Simao, IMD LLB Potter, GP LLB Moyo, E LLB Heiyantuduwa, S LLB Woolley, SJ LLB Wiid,Wiid, G LLLBLB Simon, J LLB Proemmel, M LLM Moyo, PT LLB Hendrie, EH LLB Wilson,Wilson, MMCICI LLLBLB Sinclair, D LLB Pswarayi, CFG LLB Mulcahy, JM LLB Heyns, R BCOM Law 2006 Witten,Witten, LLWW LLLMLM Smythe, TA LLB Radloff, WM LLM Mushambi, DD LLB Hlophe, N LLB Zeeman,Zeeman, RRJJ LLLBLB Solomons, I LLM Rawoot, Z LLB Mwaniki, PK LLM Hochstrasser, D LLB Banda, T LLB Zolty,Zolty, K LLLBLB Steindl, ML LLB Sachikonye, CC LLB Nchunga, ACN LLM Hofmeyr, C LLM Beineke, D LLM Stempowski, PL LLB Sagonda, AM LLB Nieman, N LLB Horst, L LLM Bhoola, SJ LLM 20022002 Straehl, A LLM Samuriwo, N LLB Nkhoma, TS LLB Ibrahim, F LLM Bruhin, R LLM Strauss, WP LLM Schar, GR LLB Oppenheim, MAJ LLB Ince, RCR LLB Chirenje, KM LLM Abrahams,Abrahams, T LLLMLM Sukazi, TM LLM Schleif, EOC LLM Pincus, D LLB Jacobs, L LLB Frank, DS LLB Alkhovik,Alkhovik, D LLLBLB Surjan, M LLM Schneider, DPS LLM Pohlit, C LLM January, TZ LLB Gant, EDT BCOM Law Allegrucci,Allegrucci, NNMM LLLBLB Teixeira, AL LLB Schoendorf, P LLM Posniak, M LLB Jephson, GG LLB Glass, T LLM Allison,Allison, AAJJ LLLBLB Theile, H LLM Seider, NM LLM Rabie, J LLM Joolay, S LLM Grant, TJ LLB Beale,Beale, G LLLBLB Tito, ST LLB Sekoboto, LN LLM Rawat, A LLM Joseph, M BCOM Law Hattingh, PJ LLM Benade,Benade, JJGG LLLMLM Tobien, NO LLM Serchuk, DE LLB Reid, RK LLB Julius, DL LLB Heemann, F LLM BernsteinBernstein D LLLBLB Trauernicht, EJ LLM Shaw, JCM LLB Rittmann, M LLB Kang, Y LLM Hufen, JA LLM Berrisford,Berrisford, KKEE LLLBLB Udoyen, ONJ LLB Sipondo, AA LLM Rosa, ASD LLM Ker, R LLB Kamanja, SW LLM BlochBloch vvonon BBlottnitz,lottnitz, K LLLMLM van der Westhuizen, M LLM Smith, N LLB Rosholt, SM LLB Knoepfle, M LLM Karmis, T LLB Botes,Botes, JJHH LLLMLM van Gijsen, F LLM Smith, CEC LLB Roux, P LLM Koekemoer, I LLB Kuuya, V LLB Briskorn,Briskorn, N LLLMLM van Zyl Smit, J LLB Speirs, JC LLB Sablay, S LLB Lamara, W LLB Limbe, S LLM Carlson,Carlson, MMKK LLLMLM Vassen, PN LLM Stipp, R LLM Savahl, A LLB Lee, Y LLB Loeschhorn, S LLM Carmichael,Carmichael, DDHH LLLBLB Vilakati, MM LLB Suhr, JC LLM Shackleton, WC LLB Lejaha, T LLM Mabasha, SS LLB Coetzee,Coetzee, MMEE LLLMLM Von Ramin, RLN LLM Taliep, S LLB Shamu, T LLB Lewenson, R LLB Mateusiak, A LLM Dahnert,Dahnert, GGASAS LLLBLB White, S LLB Tumbraegel, K LLM Sithole, T LLB Lindon, A LLB Mboya, K LLM dede BBourbon,ourbon, MMLL LLLBLB Williams, KL LLB Vundla, LA LLB Steinhilber, M LLM Luck, RT LLB Mhlontlo, SW LLM DeDe LLaa HHarpe,arpe, R LLLBLB Wilson, SK LLB Wegner, S LLM Stern, O LLB Maggott, L LLB Mkono, W LLM Deininger,Deininger, RRAA LLLMLM Young, AS LLB Wessels, E LLM Talberg, T LLB Mala, A LLB Mosbahi, J LLM Deters,Deters, S LLLMLM Zakeyo, BT LLB Wettwer, S LLM Tangkuampien, P LLB Mashinini, S LLB Oberst, S LLM Diefenbacher,Diefenbacher, KKAA LLLMLM Wides, DR LLB Thwala, N LLB Mathewson, B LLM Osman, AQ LLB Dippenaar,Dippenaar, E LLLBLB 2003 Wilson, SA LLB Traverso, N LLB Matongera, N LLB Pohlking, J LLM Distelkoetter,Distelkoetter, J LLLMLM Winderley, PJ LLB Truswell, SS LLM Matshediso, M LLM Ramodibedi, NE LLB Dlamini,Dlamini, B LLLBLB Adams, CD LLM Youens, PJ LLB Tshaka, WM LLB Mayes, C LLB Roelf, C LLB DosDos SSantos,antos, AAII LLLMLM Amosun, O LLB Tungay, GD LLB Mckinley, D LLM Ruefenacht, ES LLM Downing,Downing, AAJJ LLLMLM Augustine, CA LLB 2004 Van Breda, S LLB Mclaren, T LLB Strydom, M LLB Dutschke,Dutschke, M LLLBLB Barnes-Webb, CA LLB Van Breda, ST LLM Minshull, Y LLB Tadadjeu Dongmo, S LLM Dyer,Dyer, L LLLBLB Behrens, A LLM Beamish, HK LLB Van Den Berg, DN LLB Mji, N LLB Testa, SM LLM Estedt,Estedt, F LLLMLM Berard, BL LLB Bell, RH LLB Van Dugteren, SG LLB Mlilo, N LLB Zaramba, R LLM Filz,Filz, KKMVMV LLLMLM Berger, JMD LLM Botha, LC LLM van’t Riet, N LLB Mongie, L LLB Fine,Fine, L LLLBLB Bhuka, NW LLB Botha, JS LLM Vengesa, M LLB Morgan, CMF LLB Fisher,Fisher, N LLLBLB Boardman, AC LLB Bouah, LJ LLM Wagener, M LLM Morse, T BCOM Law Foolo,Foolo, G LLLBLB Brickhill, JR LLB Brandenburger R LLB Wamaitha, MF LLB Moseki, M LLM Fortune,Fortune, TTCC LLLMLM Brown, F LLB Brink, RG LLM Weston, GI LLB M’paradzi, A LLB Foster,Foster, JJMM LLLBLB Burchell, MJ LLB Burnell, MG LLB Williams, CW LLM Myeni, W LLB Galant,Galant, N LLLBLB Buthelezi, KL LLB Butterworth, AJ LLB Williams, EL LLM Nacerodien, MF LLB Gallie,Gallie, JJBRBR LLLBLB Cohen, J LLB Campbell, WE LLM Wright, MA LLB Narshi, M LLB Gangen,Gangen, T LLLBLB Collier, DW LLM Canterbury, DF LLB Ndumo, ME LLM Girardet,Girardet, FFCGCG LLLMLM da Silva, AH LLB Christensen, VC LLB 2005 Nel, E LLB Gomane,Gomane, S LLLBLB Daniels, C LLB Cotterell, B LLM Neumann, C LLM Govender,Govender, V LLLBLB de Bruyns, R LLB Curnow, AR LLB Abdurahman, Z LLM Nhenga, T LLM GrosseGrosse HHolthaus,olthaus, TTCC LLLMLM de Vries, F LLB Daniels, YCH LLM Adams, MR LLB Nkomo, J LLB Gwazube,Gwazube, MMDD LLLBLB du Plessis, I LLM Dano, M LLB Adhikarie, Z LLM Novis, SJ LLB Haacke,Haacke, G LLLBLB du Preez, S LLB de Almeida Neto, A LLB Albrecht, S LLM Nupen, LA LLB Haroun,Haroun, M LLLBLB Ebbing, M LLM de Coning, EJ LLB Ambala, C LLB O’Donovan, K LLB Hartley,Hartley, S LLLBLB Eberhard, FA LLB de Sousa, JM LLB Appollis, AL BCOM Law Ofunne, N LLM Havemann,Havemann, LLPP LLLBLB Eschmann, S LLM Dennis, L LLB Bahati, A LLM Padayachee, L LLM Hayes,Hayes, JJEE LLLBLB Essack, R LLB Evans, R LLM Ballard, CJ LLB Pandor, NS LLB Heinicke,Heinicke, TTPP LLLMLM Es-Said, K LLM Fitzgerald, RMG LLB Banda, T LLB Pardini, AMT LLB Hoosain,Hoosain, S LLLBLB Faafeng, JHM LLM Fourie, J LLM Barday, MZ LLB Pienaar, SP LLB Iles,Iles, KKDD LLLBLB Franklin, EM LLB Franks, S LLM Barron, SI LLB Pierce, VI LLB Ingram,Ingram, DDMVMV LLLBLB Gayaparsad, M LLB French, A LLB Becker, CRZ LLB Pietersen, SF LLB JansenJansen vvanan RRensburg,ensburg, EECC LLLMLM Gebbensleben, TH LLM Gameeldien, R LLB Belcher, V LLB Pike, AJ LLB Johnstone,Johnstone, S LLLBLB Gilder, AJ LLM Gastaldi, M LLB Benson, GE LLB Pillay, D LLB KadhilaKadhila AAmoomo,moomo, SSPP LLLBLB Goldblatt, JP LLB Goebel, P LLM Biancospino, M LLM Pinnock, S BCOM Law Kaprey,Kaprey, F LLLBLB Haasbroek, CE LLM Gonyora, TP LLB Bosman, DN LLB Potter, T LLB Kariem,Kariem, A LLLMLM Hawkey, K LLB Greyling, N LLB Bouverie, J LLB Power, J BCOM Law Kellner,Kellner, T LLLMLM Hildebrand, J LLB Gwaza, W LLB Brass, S BCOM Law Price, AM LLB Kramer,Kramer, TTHH LLLBLB Hilliard, SL LLB Hannington, B LLB Braun, J LLM Rabali, P LLB Kummel,Kummel, BBPOPO LLLMLM Julie-Purcell, AR LLB Harber, LM LLB Buschtoens, C LLM Rabbitts, N BCOM Law Lamping,Lamping, E LLLMLM Kachimera, VCC LLB Harker, GS LLB Chakawa, C BCOM Law Rabie, N LLM Lange,Lange, RRGG LLLBLB Kadelbach, P LLM Hassan, R LLB Chanetsa, NJ LLB Ramnarain, T LLB Legwaila,Legwaila, TTDD LLLMLM Kahle, GCB LLB Hausmann, A LLM Chikura, C LLB Remler, T LLM Lisulo,Lisulo, AALL LLLMLM Kazee, S LLB Hayat, S LLB Chong, S LLB Richmond, TG LLB Law REVIEW 15 Alumni Updates

News of Alumni Alumni in the News How to give to Law@UCT IT IS something of a long standing joke between the Dean of Hu- 2002: Kerry Williams (Masters of SIR FRANK BERMAN, UCT Fund is open manities and the Dean of Law that one of our law graduates was Law at University College London law alumnus and Rhodes Schol- to all groups heard to say that the Faculty has not only never asked him for any with distinction) hopes to publish ar, has been conferred with the who suffered money, it has also never told him how to go about giving it! a shortened version of her disserta- Grand Decoration of Honour in p e r s e c u t i o n tion which looks at particular poli- Gold with Star, by the Republic on religious, There are many ways to give to the faculty and we are very happy cy techniques which may be used to of Austria. He has been, since it racial, national to talk to you individually – email [email protected] or pursue affordable medicines in the was founded in 2001, the Chair- and similar telephone (27) (21) 650 5602. developing world. man of the Claims Committee of grounds. The Mndeni Vilakati (LLM in 2006) the General Settlement Fund of Fund has re- To give online: www.uct.ac.za/dad/funddev/giving/ works for the Swaziland Govern- the Republic of Austria for the ceived several hundred thousand Cheques payable to UCT can be sent to The Dean, Faculty of Law, ment as a crown counsel in the At- Compensation of Victims of Nazi claims, from claimants in over 70 University of Cape Town, PB Rondebosch, 7701; Deposit directly torney-General’s Chambers. Persecution. He was appointed to countries. into the UCT No 1 A/C, Standard Bank R’bosch, Current Ac- the position by the Governments To cope with this enormous count: 071 503 854: Please annotate with “Law endowment/other” 1998: Jonathan Mayers (LLM, of Austria and the USA. mass of material, the accent from and fax proof of payment to (021) 650 5662 NYU) joined the New York Bar; The Fund, based in Vienna, was the start has been on simplicity he worked for a firm of attorneys set up by Austrian legislation, to and efficiency which has led to the and in 2006 joined Barclays Bank acknowledge moral responsibility development of new and original Alumni scholarship awards 2007 as in-house counsel for their Equity for the losses suffered through approaches, not seen before in Finance Group working on various Nazi persecution in Austria. The mass claims procedures. derivatives and structured financ- ing products Reunion weekend 1997: Emma Witbooi was back in 2007 for a two month lecturing Class of 1986 Back l-r Anton Rich- stint in Marine and Environmental man, Davout Wolhuter, Earl Hunter, Law; three years ago she left to take Justin Hardcastle and Mike Evans Front l-r Ingrid Frietag, Andy Stew- up a Commonwealth Scholarship art, Colin Kahanovitz, Susan Stelzner, to study for her PhD at Univer- Mandy Taylor, Paul Katzeff and Em. sity College London; she is now a Prof. Solly Leeman. mum, and living in Vienna.

1985: Andrew Brown, alumnus, : 2006 author and advocate, was the guest Medallists speaker at the 2006 Graduation High Tea & Awards ceremony; his experience as a student in the 1980s when ‘ordinary people were stuck in a terrible system’ was a most apt lead in to the grad ceremony that Back l-r: Thandeka Qangule, Siphokazi Melamane, Zanele Modutwane. Front l-r: Phatiswa Batyi, Wandisa Phama, Thulani Dyushu followed (see p.1).

The Campus l-r Fatima Osman (& Ionann prize), Allison Bateman, Emma Wormald, Johan of Eden Smit, Shingira Masonzu, Gabriel Cross, Janice Bleazard ( & Berman prize), Cali Ferreira and Dina Shigel. Absent: Jullie Kourie, Kerry-Leigh Kopke, Andrew Welz By Amanda Boardman and Lauren Kohn (centre right front with fellow alumnus MEC Cameron Dugmore) Dean in North America IN MY case, the study of law was not IN MAY Professor Corder spoke on two occasions to the topic of Ju- so much vocational training but a dicial Activism in South Africa since 1994. Both functions were hosted by springboard to a rewarding new line alumni, Louis Goldberg (New York) and Henry Blumberg (Toronto), of work. I completed my BA at UCT beds, no books, no paper or pens, educates and transforms individuals and were well attended by alumni, colleagues from other universities in 1998, majoring in English, French no lecturers and no curriculum…it from impoverished communities in and friends of UCT. and Italian, and then after a year’s was a long way from university as I the Southern Cape in entrepreneur- traveling, returned to UCT and ob- knew it. But I was so touched by the ship and enterprise”. tained an LLB in 2003. At that stage students’ stories and their hunger to Much of what I learned studying I wasn’t convinced I wanted to be a be educated that I stayed and became and practicing law is useful to me lawyer but figured the only way to be determined to do whatever I could now and I find I draw upon all my certain was to become one! to make the vision into a reality. past experiences either directly or in- While completing articles at Cliffe In the last 18 months, with a tiny directly to work out how to deal with Dekker at the end of 2005 I knew my staff which at times was only me and things. Even the hours spent photo- heart wasn’t in it. I cut and pasted one colleague, we have created Eden copying during articles has proved contracts and haggled over prices of Campus. I have done everything useful – I am the first called when broken furniture with auctioneers from lecturing in marketing, English the photocopier jams! Reunion in Toronto: l-r Henry Blumberg, Hugh Corder and Les Kottler. on behalf of bereaved widows…there and even maths, to painting ponds, The world of my students is so very were some interesting cases that chal- to feeding students, to designing edu- far from the one I grew in, surround- lenged me intellectually but on the cational policies and legal structures, ed by such privilege where I took for whole I was frustrated. In February holding disciplinary hearings, hiring granted that I could go to university 2006 I drove to a one horse town staff, firing staff, fundraising…right for as many years as I wanted to and called Karatara near Sedgefield, on now I focus on administrative and study whatever course I wanted. I the Garden Route to see an ambi- management functions and teach can truly see now how fortunate I tious project dreamt up by an entre- Business English once a week but I am. My work challenges me on every preneur named Steve Carver. never know what a day might hold. level, intellectually, emotionally and On arrival I found an abandoned Eden Campus is currently providing spiritually. Now and then I have the old age home leased to the project 50 students with a Certificate in Mar- odd yearning to practice law and de- by the Knysna Municipality, and keting accredited by Nelson Man- liver brilliant closings when I watch Breakfast in New York: (back l-r) Justin Goldblatt, Michael Pettit, Profes- sor Penelope Andrews (CUNY), and Ian Anderson (front l-r): Velile Memela 40 students from very economically dela Metropolitan University. Our too much Boston Legal but for now and Monwabisi Zukani, 2007 Fellows on the South African Visiting Lawyer deprived backgrounds desperate mission is “to consciously create a I believe I am absolutely where I am Program. for tertiary education and that was financially and environmentally sus- meant to be and that this is a great about it! There were no desks, no tainable green business school that blessing. Visit: www.edencampus.co.za 16 Law REVIEW