8:28 Start and Recess Because of Defected Projector

January, 2007 15-07-0???-00-0005

IEEE P802.15

Wireless Personal Area Networks

Project / IEEE P802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs)
Title / Minutes Summary of IEEE 802.15.5 Meetings
Date Submitted / January 17, 2008
Source / Tae Rim Park
EE Dept. CUNY
140th St. & Convent Ave
New York, NY 10031 / Voice: +1-212-650-7260
Fax: +1-212-650-8249
E-mail:
Re: / IEEE 802.15 Interim Meeting in Taipei
Abstract / IEEE 802.15.5 Minutes.
Purpose / Minutes of IEEE 802.15.5 sessions.
Notice / This document has been prepared to assist the IEEE P802.15. It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein.
Release / The contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution becomes the property of IEEE and may be made publicly available by P802.15.

802.15.5 Meeting Minute

January 2008, Howard Hotel, Taipei

Monday AM2, January 14

10:30 Chair called the meeting to order.

· Chair reviewed patent policy.

· Chair reviewed the agenda. The agenda was accepted unanimously.

· Chair showed the meeting minutes of the last meeting and the minutes were accepted unanimously.

· Chair reported on the status of Letter Ballot 37 (Authorization) passed and Letter Ballot 38 is on going and closes on Jan 14, 2008 anywhere on the earth. Therefore, we can conduct preliminary discussion now but the final resolution to be deferred to Wednesday.

10:50 Pre-discussion on comments

· Mr. Poegel’s comments

o P18L11: MHSME is too long à DISCUSS AGAIN with Editor

o P20L11: Remove comment on 2003 version à accept

o P28L12: diagonal arrow is possible? à DISCUSS AGAIN, check or make another way

§ Correct typo ‘describing’ to ‘describing’ ???

o P37L20: LQI length à change to 8bit

o P43L43: Correct NLME and NWK à change to MSHME and MESH

o P50L15: TxOption is exclusive à change to bit map

o P51L11: inconsistent order à check and fix to one LSB first or MSB first.

· Mr. Schmidt’s comments

o P49L10: PAN ID is not present in the line à delete PANID, also consider changing PAN ID to MESH ID

o P49L16: 4 bit version à Keep 4bit version

o P50L1: start number for version à Keep 0x0001 but need to discuss for reliable broadcasting

o P24P1: typo à correct to MHSME

o P30Table10: how to get version info à check all fields. If necessary add bacon payload

o P41L33: NLME à change to ‘MHSME’

· Mr. Park’s comments

o Mesh layer à change to ‘mesh sublayer’

o Abstract à change

o Line spaceà adjust

o Fully mesh à full mesh

o Supporting mesh à full and partial mesh

o Defining words à describe consistent way

o b1 is not reserved à delete that

o ‘Status’ or ‘status’ for all documents

o P30L7 : add operation for non MC starting

6:00 Meeting recessed until Tuesday AM1.

Tuesday AM1, January 15

8:00 Chair called the meeting to order.

· Chair reviewed patent policy.

8:20 Meeting is recessed for 10 minutes to compile comments.

8:30 Pre-discussion on comments

8:15 Meeting is recessed for 5 minutes to compile comments.

8:45 Pre-discussion on comments

· Review of current comments (d2P802-15-5_Draft_LB-comments-sheet-Compiled-r0.xls)

o 127 Editorial, 80 Technical

10:00 Meeting recessed until Tuesday AM2.

Tuesday AM2, January 15

10:30 Chair called the meeting to order.

10:40 Pre-discussion on comments

12:30 Meeting recessed until Tuesday PM1.

Tuesday PM1, January 15

1:30 Chair called the meeting to order.

1:50 Meeting is recessed for 10 minutes to compile comments.

2:00 Report of comments

· d2P802-15-5_Draft_LB-comments-sheet-Compiled-r2.xls

o 356 comments: 161 Editorial, 195 Technical

2:10 Presentation by Sungwoo Park on HR-WPAN editing (Doc. 15-08-0057-01-0005)

3:30 Meeting recessed until Wednesday AM1.

Wednesday AM1, January 16

8:00 Chair called the meeting to order.

8:10 Chair reviewed patent policy.

8:15 Chair reported the letter ballot result

Passed ( Yes 77, No 5, Abs 26) Yes (94%) No (6%): Ballot count will be finalized after comparing it with what WG chair has.

8:20 Discussion for comment resolution