Youth Access Tobacco Enforcement Program Report

April 1, 2014 – March 31, 2015

Questions or requests for additional copies of this report:

New York State Department of Health Bureau of Community Environmental Health & Food Protection Tobacco Enforcement Program Empire State Plaza - Corning Tower Room 1395 Albany, New York 12237 Telephone: (518) 402-7600 Fax: (518) 402-7609

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

Special thanks go to the local health department enforcement officers, the New York City Department of Consumer Affairs and the youth who participated in the access compliance check surveillance program. For more than 17 years, these dedicated agencies and individuals have been the leaders in the State’s effort to increase retailer compliance with the public health law in our communities.

Staff of the New York State Department of Health’s Bureau of Community Environmental Health and

Food Protection, Tobacco Enforcement Program prepared this report with data provided from the local enforcement officers, other state agencies and programs within the Department of Health.

The New York State Department of Health’s Tobacco Control Program and the New York State

Education Department supplied information regarding tobacco use and trends among minors. The

State Department of Taxation and Finance provided registration and revenue data. The Department of

State’s Office of Fire Prevention and Control supplied data regarding fires.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

PREFACE ……………………………………………………………………………………….. 5

PROGRAM OVERVIEW………………………………………………………………………. 6

PROGRAM PURPOSE ………………………………………………………………………… 8

STATUS AND ACCOMPLISHMENTS …………………………………………………….… 8

APPENDICES ……………………………………………………………………………………17

APPENDIX 1: Number and Type of Investigations, April 1, 2014 - March 31, 2015.

APPENDIX 1A: Sale to Minor Violation Rate by County, 5 year Summary

APPENDIX 2: Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors, April 1, 2014 - March 31, 2015.

APPENDIX 3: Youth Risk Behavior Survey (YRBS) Comparison – New York State Results for

2007, 2009, 2011 and 2013

APPENDIX 4: 2014 National Youth Tobacco Survey - New York State Results

APPENDIX 5: Allocation of Tobacco Enforcement Program Funding, April 1, 2014 - March

31, 2015.

APPENDIX 6: New York State Fire Reporting System Tobacco Related Fire Statistics,

January 1, 2014 – December 2014. PREFACE

The purpose of New York’s Adolescent Tobacco Use Prevention Act is to aid in reducing morbidity and mortality caused by tobacco use by reducing children’s access to cigarettes and other tobacco products. It has been well documented that most smokers begin before they are 18 years old and half before they are 15. Many people who start smoking as youth find it nearly impossible to quit during their lifetime. For more than 17 years, state and local enforcement officials have experienced increasing success at reducing youth access to tobacco products and improving retailer compliance with the Adolescent Tobacco Use Prevention Act, and have reduced the rate of non-compliance by retailers from 19% in 1997 to 5.06% in 2014-2015.

The Adolescent Tobacco Use Prevention Act requires retailers to obtain positive proof that the person buying cigarettes is over the age of 18. Retailers found in violation of this law are subject to fines and loss of their tobacco registrations and lottery licenses for repeated violations. The law also limits the location of vending machines and limits the venues in which free tobacco products can be distributed. These enforcement measures are aimed at making tobacco products less accessible to minors and are a part of the State's comprehensive anti-smoking program.

This Annual Report is prepared by the Tobacco Enforcement Program, located in the New York State Department of Health’s Center for Environmental Health. The report covers the period April 1, 2014 to March 31, 2015. The report includes the following information:

. Number of tobacco compliance checks that were conducted; . Names and addresses of tobacco vendors who sold tobacco products to youth and were penalized; . New York State results of 2013 Youth Risk Behavior Survey (YRBS); . Tobacco sales data from the State Department of Taxation and Finance; and . Tobacco-related fire injury data from the Department of State’s Fire Reporting System.

During the 2014 – 2015 program year, state and local enforcement officers conducted 30,712 inspections of tobacco retailers to assess compliance with the State’s Public Health Law (Adolescent Tobacco Use Prevention Act). Of these inspections, more than 23,241 included unannounced compliance checks where minors attempted to purchase tobacco and other restricted products under the direct supervision of the enforcement officials. Over 7,471 additional visits were made to determine compliance with Department of Health signage requirements and Department of Taxation and Finance registration requirements, to educate retailers about the Public Health Law, to verify vending machine supervision and location compliance and to investigate complaints. A total of 1,742 enforcement actions were taken for sales of tobacco products to minors and more than $1.49 million in fines were assessed.

In the last 17 program years, state grants totaling nearly $77.7 million have been awarded to local enforcement officials to implement the Tobacco Enforcement Program, which resulted in a decline in the rate of retailer non-compliance from 19.0 percent to 5.06 percent. From September 1997 to March 2015, more than $34.1 million in fines have been levied against 44,894 retailers for selling tobacco to minors. The Department of Taxation and Finance has suspended the registrations of 3,065 tobacco retailers as a result of multiple enforcement actions for selling tobacco products to youth. There were also 819 lottery agent licenses suspended for multiple sales to minors. Of the 623,406 compliance inspections that have taken place during the 17 years, 451,572 were conducted with the assistance of minors attempting to purchase tobacco products. 5

New York State Department of Health (NYS DOH) Center for Environmental Health Youth Access Tobacco Enforcement Program Annual Report April 1, 2014 – March 31, 2015

Program Overview In March 2015, the New York State Department of Health (DOH) completed its seventeenth program year of statewide youth tobacco access enforcement. As part of the State’s continued commitment to preventing youth access to tobacco, $5.28 million was awarded to local enforcement officers during this program year to determine and enforce retail tobacco vendor compliance with Article 13-F of the Public Health Law, also known as the Adolescent Tobacco Use Prevention Act (ATUPA). This report covers the twelve-month period from April 1, 2014 through March 31, 2015.

The ATUPA enforcement program is part of the State's comprehensive tobacco control initiative, the New York State Tobacco Control Program (TCP) administered by the Bureau of Tobacco Control, Division of Chronic Disease Prevention. In 2014-2015, TCP was funded through a state appropriation of $39.3 million and two grants from the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) totaling $2.7 million.

The goals of TCP’s comprehensive tobacco control program are to prevent the initiation of tobacco use among youth and young adults, promote tobacco use cessation and eliminate exposure to secondhand smoke, particularly among tobacco-related disparate populations, i.e., those with low income, low education, and poor mental health and/or substance use disorders. TCP uses policy- driven, population-based and evidence-based interventions to accelerate tobacco control in New York State. DOH funds and manages statewide and community programs to work towards achieving environmental change on the state and local level, and expand tobacco dependence treatment by medical and mental healthcare systems.

Statewide and local level action is used to change the community environment to support the State’s tobacco-free norm and denormalize tobacco use through community education and mobilization. DOH funds Advancing Tobacco-Free Communities contractors who comprise two components – community engagement and youth action, branded as Reality Check. Community engagement work entails educating local community members and organizations, decision-makers, employers and policymakers about the harms of tobacco use and secondhand smoke exposure, and change public opinion about tobacco and tobacco use. Contractors implement a coordinated set of evidence-based strategies to build public and organizational support to reinforce the state’s tobacco-free norm and foster environments that demand policy change to reduce the impact of retail tobacco product marketing on youth and limit exposure to secondhand smoke in multiunit dwellings and in outdoor public spaces where people live, work and play. Through the Reality Check component, contractors engage middle and high school aged youth from diverse economic and cultural backgrounds to work to change community norms regarding tobacco use through activities aimed at deglamorizing and denormalizing tobacco use in their communities and by exposing the manipulative and deceptive marketing practices of the tobacco industry. Through civic engagement, youth program initiatives include community education linked to social action, media advocacy, media and community events, and advocacy with organizational decision-makers to advance tobacco-free norms through policy change. Both components work to foster community environments that support policies to reduce the impact of retail tobacco marketing on youth and reduce smoking imagery in youth-oriented media.

6

Health systems improvement strategies address tobacco dependence treatment and cessation from a health systems and organizational perspective. TCP funds Health Systems for a Tobacco-Free NY contractors who work with high-level administrators at large or local medical and mental health care systems to encourage and assist them in adopting and implementing policies to provide evidence- based, guideline-concordant tobacco dependence treatment among disproportionately affected populations as part of routine care. Emotionally evocative paid media campaigns promote tobacco use cessation by encouraging tobacco users who want to quit to speak with their healthcare providers for quit assistance or to contact the New York State Smokers’ Quitline (NYSSQL), which offers telephonic and web-based information, resources, coaching and starter kits of nicotine replacement therapy to help tobacco users quit.

Mass-reach health communications are used to increase awareness of the dangers of tobacco use and secondhand smoke exposure, prevent youth initiation, motivate tobacco users to quit, expose tobacco industry propaganda, deglamorize and denormalize tobacco use and educate community members and decision-makers about tobacco control. Targeted campaigns also educate healthcare providers about their role as providers of tobacco dependence treatment and increase knowledge about and use of Medicaid cessation benefits. Paid media includes advertising on television, radio, print, the Internet and other channels. Contractors, Reality Check youth and mobilized community members and leaders write and put out press releases, opinion pieces and letters to the editor to draw attention to the problems of tobacco use and secondhand smoke exposure. They also host events to garner free, earned media coverage that informs communities and decision-makers and increases support for policy change that supports the tobacco-free norm.

Surveillance and evaluation activities are used to ensure that TCP uses effective and proven strategies to obtain the goal of a tobacco-free New York State. These activities monitor program progress and impact, provide technical assistance and guidance, and manage the effective and efficient investment of state tobacco control funding. Evaluation data from media studies, surveys and observational projects contribute to the ongoing improvement of the program, help focus key messaging and determine the effective use of media. TCP strives to contribute to the science of tobacco control through a variety of data collection activities related to program initiatives and dissemination of program findings.

7

Program Purpose The goal of the Tobacco Enforcement Program is to lower the prevalence of tobacco use among youth by reducing tobacco product sales and preventing the onset of its use by this population. Specifically, the program seeks to improve tobacco retailer compliance with ATUPA.

Status and Accomplishments The New York State Department of Taxation and Finance (DTF) reports the total number of registered tobacco retailers in New York State, including the total number of vending machines. A total of 22,343 tobacco retailers were registered as of August 2014.

Number of DTF registered tobacco retailers in New York State

NYS DTF Registered Tobacco Retailers by Year 28,000 25,982 26,000 24,440 24,198 24,000 23,380 22,343 22,032 21,947 22,000 20,834 19,885 20,000

18,000

16,000

Number of Registered Retailers Registered of Number 14,000

12,000

10,000 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014

Year

8

DTF reported number of registered vending machines The total number of vending machines registered in New York State by DTF during 2014 was 88. This is down from 807 registered in 2010 and considerably lower than the 4,434 registered in 2000.

The Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act (Tobacco Control Act) (Public Law 111- 31; 123 Stat. 1776) was enacted on June 22, 2009, amending the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (FFDCA) and providing the U.S. Food & Drug Administration (FDA) with the authority to regulate tobacco products. Effective June 22, 2010 vending machines are only permitted in facilities where no one younger than 18 years of age is present or permitted to enter at any time.

DTF reported number of cigarettes sold in New York State Approximately 4.56 billion cigarettes were sold in New York State for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2015. Of this number, approximately 1.24 billion were sold in New York City.

DTF Reported Cigarette Sales 25.00 22.40

20.00 ) 17.90 18.00 Billions 15.00 14.20 13.10 12.50 12.50 12.48 12.46

10.28 9.40 10.00 8.40

Cigarettes Sold ( 7.80 6.80 7.00 5.08 4.60 4.80 4.56 5.00 3.50 3.20 3.10 3.10 3.00 2.57 2.30 1.90 1.55 1.39 1.24

0.00 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014

Year # Cigarettes sold statewide # Cigarettes sold NYC

9

DTF reported tax revenue collected in New York State Excluding local sales tax, the tax revenue collected by DTF from the sale of cigarettes and tobacco products for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2015, totaled approximately $1.313 billion from retailer licensure, vending machine registrations and the excise tax. Retail licensure and vending machine registrations yielded $7.02 million in the 2014-2015 State Fiscal Year. The excise tax on cigarettes yielded $1.261 billion, and taxes on other tobacco products yielded $45.7 million.

DTF Reported Tobacco Revenue

1.8

1.6 1.517 1.55 1.453 1.365 1.4 1.34 1.313

1.2 1.12 (Billions) 1.02 1.02 1.01 0.976 0.9714 0.9818 0.9735 1 Revenue 0.8 0.6716

0.6

0.4

Tobacco Product Tax Tax Product Tobacco 0.2

0 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Year

DOH reported the following information:

Number and type of compliance checks conducted in NYS State and local enforcement officers conducted 30,712 compliance inspections during the seventeenth program year (April 1, 2014 to March 31, 2015). Of these, 23,241 were compliance checks where underage youth attempted to purchase tobacco and other restricted products. Additional visits were made to determine compliance with DTF registration or DOH signage requirements, to educate operators of the Public Health Law requirements, to verify vending machine supervision and location compliance, or to investigate complaints. Appendix 1 reflects a county-by-county listing of compliance investigations. Appendix 1A reflects a county-by-county 5 year summary of the sale to minor violation rate.

10

Number of complaints filed against registered tobacco retailers in NYS During the time period April 1, 2014 to March 31, 2015, a total of 377 inspections were conducted in response to 267 complaints received concerning ATUPA violations. Two hundred twenty-seven complaints were filed against registered tobacco retailers. Included in Appendix 1 is a county-by- county breakdown of this data.

Retailers reported by local enforcement officers to have paid fines or otherwise penalized due to enforcement action in NYS During the time period April 1, 2014 to March 31, 2015, state and local enforcement officers conducted 30,712 inspections of tobacco retailers to assess compliance with ATUPA. A total of 1,742 enforcement actions were taken for ATUPA violations and more than $1.49 million in fines were assessed. The names and addresses of penalized tobacco retailers are listed by county in Appendix 2.

Number of tobacco users and trends among minors in New York State New York State conducts a Youth Tobacco Survey every other year to develop statewide estimates of tobacco use and related behaviors and attitudes for students from grades 6 to 12. The survey includes questions about tobacco use, exposure to environmental tobacco smoke, minors' ability to purchase or otherwise obtain tobacco products, knowledge and attitudes about tobacco and familiarity with pro- tobacco and anti-tobacco media messages. A total of 72 public, parochial and other private schools agreed to participate in the survey, with a total of 8,464 students completing the survey in 2014. The results of the survey are applicable to New York State youth attending middle school or high school. There was a significant downward trend in current use of cigarettes by high school and middle school students in each year from 2000 through 2014. Additional data from the 2014 National Youth Tobacco Survey are found in Appendix 4.

Youth Tobacco Use New York State Youth Tobacco Survey

30 27.1

25 20.4 20 18.5 16.3 14.7 15 12.6 11.9 10.5 10 7.3

% who smoke 6.3 4.8 4.1 5 3.8 3.3 3.1 1.1 0 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014

Survey Year Middle School High School

11

Funding disbursement Appendix 5 lists the funding amounts distributed to 35 county health departments, the New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, and the New York City Department of Consumer Affairs to conduct youth access tobacco enforcement activities. As guided by Section 1399-hh of the Public Health Law, funding was based on the number of retail facilities registered with DTF to sell tobacco products within the local health department’s jurisdiction. Nine State Health Department district offices conducted compliance checks in the 22 upstate counties that do not, or did not elect to, conduct enforcement activities in their counties.

Enforcement During the time period April 1, 2014 to March 31, 2015, a total of 113 vendors were reported to DTF from April 1, 2014 to March 31, 2015 for lack of required registration to sell tobacco products. As a result, DTF verified the status of the facilities, directed unregistered retailers to obtain a registration, and fined them up to $3,500 for non-compliance.

During compliance checks conducted from April 1, 2014 to March 31, 2015, youth purchased tobacco and other restricted products 1,175 times. By the close of the program year, 1,742 non-compliant retailers were fined $1,497,050 for ATUPA violations. Fines collected for this period totaled $1,306,994.

During the reporting period from April 1, 2014 to March 31, 2015, a total of 118 retailer registrations to sell tobacco products were suspended by DTF as a result of multiple enforcement actions for selling tobacco to youth. Of this total, 109 were suspended for six months and 9 were suspended permanently. There were also 35 lottery agent licenses suspended for six months for multiple sales to minor violations.

12

Impact of 17 program years

FFY 1998 FFY 1999 FFY 2000 FFY 2001 FFY 2002 FFY 2003 FFY 2004 FFY 2005

Number of checks to assure compliance 20,942 19,146 24,156 27,190 27,010 30,074 29,951 26,616 regarding prohibiting sale of tobacco to minors

Number of checks to assure compliance with 6,997 5,117 8,701 19,781** 13,268** 13,451** 12,398** 12,906** other regulatory requirements *

Number of sale to minor violations NA NA 3,115 2,884 2,819 3391 3,350 3,457

Retailer non-compliance rate (based on sales to NA NA 13% 11% 10.4% 11% 11% 13% minors)

Number of enforcement actions taken for 4,046 3,270 2,919 2,496 2,723 2,192 3,172 3,590 ATUPA violations

Fines Assessed $1,001,800 $915,925 $819,410 $1,842,260 $2,171,469 $3,060,435 $3,978,513 $3,641,085

Fines Collected $768,410 $633,215 $950,100 $1,279,437 $1,990,176 $2,389,074 $2,804,721 $2,446,837

Number of suspended tobacco registrations 2 4 22 23 82 20 74 152

Number of suspended lottery licenses NA NA NA 3 25 4 20 38

Number of unregistered retailers reported to the 3,600 930 1,338 738 454 410 200 105 DTF

* Other Regulatory Requirements include proper DTF registration compliance, posting required signs, educating operators of the Public Health Law requirements, verifying vending machine supervision and proper location, attempting compliance checks and/or investigation of complaints. ** Includes compliance checks conducted by adult inspectors for out of the package cigarettes, self-service restrictions, bidis, gutka, etc. ¹ Total for years 3 through 15, data not collected in the first two program years. 2 The FFY 2011program year covers 18 months, October 1, 2010 to March 31, 2012. 3 The tobacco enforcement program year now follows the State Fiscal Year (SFY).

13

17 Year FFY 2006 FFY 2007 FFY 2008 FFY 2009 FFY 2010 FFY 20112 SFY 20123 SFY 2013 SFY 2014 TOTAL

Number of checks to assure compliance regarding prohibiting sale of tobacco to 29,890 28,075 29,364 26,372 25,032 36,219 23,693 24,600 23,241 451,571 minors

Number of checks to assure compliance 10,560** 9,739** 9,266** 9,009** 8,432** 10,635** 7,099** 6,804** 7,471 171,834 with other regulatory requirements *

Number of sale to minor violations 2,949 2,120 2,424 1,836 1,476 1,808 1,262 1,221 1,175 46,654¹

Retailer non-compliance rate (based on 10% 7.6% 8.3% 7.0% 5.9% 4.99% 5.3% 4.96% 5.06% 11.34%¹ sales to minors)

Number of enforcement actions taken 3,210 2,302 2,639 1,790 1,750 1,919 2,063 3,071 1,742 44,894 for ATUPA violations

Fines Assessed $2,598,600 $1,646,600 $1,912,270 $1,191,710 $1,375,500 $1,520,450 $2,229,275 $2,730,038 $1,497,050 $34,132,390

Fines Collected $2,211,547 $1,504,215 $1,365359 $1,256,019 $1,228,567 $1,295,838 $1,440,557 $2,599,128 $1,306,994 $27,470,194

Number of suspended tobacco 475 608 256 412 235 274 105 127 118 3,065 registrations

Number of suspended lottery licenses 147 149 86 91 68 91 21 41 35 819

Number of unregistered retailers 220 228 426 201 138 1,401 722 498 113 11,722 reported to DTF

* Other Regulatory Requirements include proper DTF registration compliance, posting required signs, educating operators of the Public Health Law requirements, verifying vending machine supervision and proper location, attempting compliance checks and/or investigation of complaints. ** Includes compliance checks conducted by adult inspectors for out of the package cigarettes, self-service restrictions, bidis, gutka, etc. ¹ Total for years 3 through 15, data not collected in the first two program years. 2 The FFY 2011 program year covers 18 months, October 1, 2010 to March 31, 2012. 3 The tobacco enforcement program year now follows the State Fiscal Year (SFY).

14

Tobacco Retailer Non-Compliance Rate

20% 19%

18% 17%

16%

14% 13% 13%

12% 11% 11% 11% 10% 9.9% 10% 8.3% 8% 7.6% 7%

Compliance Rate 5.9% - 6% 5.3% 4.99% 4.96% 5.06% Non 4%

2%

0% 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011* 2012** 2013 2014

Year

The tobacco retailer non-compliance rate for FFY 1998 & 1999 is based on the number of enforcement actions for illegal sales to minors; the 2000-2012 rate is based on the actual number of sales to minors.

* The FFY 2011 contract period covers the 18 months from October 1, 2010 to March 31, 2012. ** The tobacco enforcement program year now follows the State Fiscal Year (SFY). 15

Fires and related injuries and deaths caused or believed to be caused by tobacco products* The New York State Department of State’s Fire Reporting System data for the period of January 1, 2014 to December 31, 2014 identified 884 fires classified as being caused by abandoned or discarded cigarettes. There were 20 deaths and 20 injuries to civilians resulting from fires caused by tobacco products. Four firefighters were also injured. Appendix 6 includes a breakdown of tobacco-related fire statistics by county. * Data reported by The New York State Department of State

Survey of attitudes and behaviors regarding tobacco use among minors* The New York State Education Department conducts a Federal Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) funded statewide "Youth Risk Behavior Survey" (YRBS) of students in New York State schools (including New York City schools). The survey contains several questions on youth tobacco use and is conducted every two years. For each survey, a new sample of schools and students is selected; student participation is voluntary. In 2013, 10,643 ninth through twelfth grade students from 83 schools participated. New York State data from the YRBS for years 2007, 2009, 2011 and 2013 are included in Appendix 3. *Data reported by The New York State Education Department

16

APPENDICES

17

Appendix 1 Tobacco Enforcement Program Number and Type of Investigations April 1, 2014- March 31, 2015

Complaints Registered Against Compliance Partial Complaint Other Sales to Fined / County Vendors Registered Checks Inspections Investigations Visits Minors Penalized Vendors Statewide Totals 22343 232 23241 7471 377 2895 1175 1742 Albany 387 0 365 401 0 18 4 4 Allegany 57 0 54 1 0 0 3 3 Broome 234 0 215 194 0 34 1 3 Cattaraugus 55 0 70 51 0 0 6 6 Cayuga 70 0 178 107 0 6 4 1 Chautauqua 126 0 134 117 0 4 1 3 Chemung 90 0 105 11 0 0 5 6 Chenango 60 0 66 1 0 0 3 2 Clinton 109 0 135 109 0 1 0 0 Columbia 95 0 164 9 0 0 0 2 Cortland 48 0 43 47 0 0 4 3 Delaware 67 0 64 0 0 1 0 0 Dutchess 349 0 391 78 6 6 36 47 Erie 946 0 945 1537 0 99 36 41 Essex 57 0 64 7 0 1 1 1 Franklin 59 0 61 11 0 2 0 0 Fulton 56 0 58 20 0 0 3 3 Genesee 56 0 66 66 0 5 3 4 Greene 72 0 68 0 0 6 1 2 Hamilton 12 0 15 1 0 2 0 0 Herkimer 69 0 70 13 0 0 4 4 Jefferson 127 0 123 8 0 3 1 3 Lewis 31 0 26 2 0 2 0 1 Livingston 67 0 66 3 0 0 0 0 Madison 52 0 55 59 0 1 0 1 Monroe 694 0 688 1 0 51 27 27 Montgomery 80 0 64 35 0 0 0 0 Nassau 1451 0 1329 1604 3 43 63 61 New York City 10352 227 8713 710 364 1864 715 1255 Niagara 201 0 216 217 0 18 9 10 Oneida 248 0 187 0 0 21 13 10 Onondaga 456 0 400 2 0 0 21 19 Appendix 1 Tobacco Enforcement Program Number and Type of Investigations April 1, 2014- March 31, 2015

Complaints Registered Against Compliance Partial Complaint Other Sales to Fined / County Vendors Registered Checks Inspections Investigations Visits Minors Penalized Vendors Statewide Totals 22343 232 23241 7471 377 2895 1175 1742 Ontario 92 0 91 4 0 4 2 2 Orange 403 0 465 404 0 18 24 28 Orleans 31 0 58 31 0 4 1 1 Oswego 116 0 116 119 0 7 2 3 Otsego 76 0 72 0 0 8 0 0 Putnam 113 0 122 2 0 13 6 6 Rensselaer 194 0 192 1 0 6 13 13 Rockland 267 0 880 703 0 13 12 9 Saratoga 214 0 185 32 0 22 1 1 Schenectady 205 5 216 8 2 18 8 9 Schoharie 30 0 33 29 0 0 1 1 Schuyler 20 0 19 0 0 0 0 0 Seneca 36 0 29 31 0 0 0 0 St. Lawrence 122 0 113 1 0 4 4 4 Steuben 108 0 96 1 0 0 2 2 Suffolk 1599 0 1406 232 0 231 54 57 Sullivan 96 0 102 92 0 12 1 2 Tioga 41 0 198 25 0 2 12 8 Tompkins 72 0 64 66 0 1 1 1 Ulster 229 0 201 197 0 4 7 6 Warren 123 0 107 17 0 11 3 3 Washington 60 0 58 2 0 4 1 1 Wayne 84 0 78 1 0 8 1 1 Westchester 1118 0 3091 19 2 316 54 61 Wyoming 38 0 30 30 0 0 1 1 Yates 23 0 21 2 0 1 0 0 Appendix 1-A NYS Tobacco Retailers Sale to Minor Violation Rate by County 5 Year Summary

County FFY 2010 FFY 2011* SFY 2012 SFY 2013 SFY 2014 FFY 2010 FFY 2011* SFY 2012 SFY 2013 SFY 2014 violations inspections violations inspections violations inspections violations inspections violations inspections Albany 16 473 3 738 4 425 5 384 4 365 3.4% 0.4% 0.9% 1.3% 1.1% Allegany 0 58 0 76 0 43 0 52 3 54 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 5.6% Broome 6 205 4 390 1 219 3 279 1 215 2.9% 1.0% 0.5% 1.1% 0.5% Cattaraugus 0 63 8 106 2 64 2 69 6 70 0.0% 7.5% 3.1% 2.9% 8.6% Cayuga 1 112 1 141 3 85 1 92 4 178 0.9% 0.7% 3.5% 1.1% 2.2% Chautauqua 6 154 3 188 5 131 9 143 1 134 3.9% 1.6% 3.8% 6.3% 0.7% Chemung 0 88 3 138 3 96 8 101 5 105 0.0% 2.2% 3.1% 7.9% 4.8% Chenango 1 47 0 51 4 52 4 79 3 66 2.1% 0.0% 7.7% 5.1% 4.5% Clinton 8 155 9 286 9 135 0 138 0 135 5.2% 3.1% 6.7% 0.0% 0.0% Columbia 3 110 11 329 3 137 8 208 0 164 2.7% 3.3% 2.2% 3.8% 0.0% Cortland 1 53 8 55 7 54 2 59 4 43 1.9% 14.5% 13.0% 3.4% 9.3% Delaware 0 56 0 68 0 62 1 71 0 64 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 1.4% 0.0% Dutchess 26 374 35 553 18 378 29 410 36 391 7.0% 6.3% 4.8% 7.1% 9.2% Erie 20 791 27 1370 27 775 18 721 36 945 2.5% 2.0% 3.5% 2.5% 3.8% Essex 1 78 2 140 0 68 0 72 1 64 1.3% 1.4% 0.0% 0.0% 1.6% Franklin 1 65 0 114 0 57 1 62 0 61 1.5% 0.0% 0.0% 1.6% 0.0% Fulton 1 58 0 82 0 37 1 47 3 58 1.7% 0.0% 0.0% 2.1% 5.2% Genesee 6 62 1 103 3 56 1 59 3 66 9.7% 1.0% 5.4% 1.7% 4.5% Greene 0 60 1 77 2 42 2 61 1 68 0.0% 1.3% 4.8% 3.3% 1.5% Hamilton 1 22 0 40 1 21 3 19 0 15 4.5% 0.0% 4.8% 15.8% 0.0% Herkimer 0 59 2 72 0 46 1 56 4 70 0.0% 2.8% 0.0% 1.8% 5.7% Jefferson 3 82 1 99 0 100 2 121 1 123 3.7% 1.0% 0.0% 1.7% 0.8% Lewis 0 31 0 25 0 22 1 25 0 26 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 4.0% 0.0% Livingston 3 62 2 94 3 61 0 52 0 66 4.8% 2.1% 4.9% 0.0% 0.0% Madison 0 66 1 89 1 48 1 56 0 55 0.0% 1.1% 2.1% 1.8% 0.0% Monroe 35 769 20 1132 27 718 32 757 27 688 4.6% 1.8% 3.8% 4.2% 3.9% Montgomery 1 64 1 80 2 43 0 54 0 64 1.6% 1.3% 4.7% 0.0% 0.0% Nassau 94 2072 86 2271 106 1385 51 1339 63 1329 4.5% 3.8% 7.7% 3.8% 4.7% New York City 941 8434 1222 11723 816 9612 819 9788 715 8713 11.2% 10.4% 8.5% 8.4% 8.2% Niagara 7 202 11 302 5 195 7 213 9 216 3.5% 3.6% 2.6% 3.3% 4.2% Oneida 13 252 8 183 39 159 14 158 13 187 5.2% 4.4% 24.5% 8.9% 7.0% Appendix 1-A NYS Tobacco Retailers Sale to Minor Violation Rate by County 5 Year Summary

County FFY 2010 FFY 2011* SFY 2012 SFY 2013 SFY 2014 FFY 2010 FFY 2011* SFY 2012 SFY 2013 SFY 2014 violations inspections violations inspections violations inspections violations inspections violations inspections Onondaga 4 367 7 593 9 405 8 396 21 400 1.1% 1.2% 2.2% 2.0% 5.3% Ontario 1 87 4 134 0 92 0 103 2 91 1.1% 3.0% 0.0% 0.0% 2.2% Orange 22 529 21 732 19 449 26 468 24 465 4.2% 2.9% 4.2% 5.6% 5.2% Orleans 1 108 7 155 6 102 0 59 1 58 0.9% 4.5% 5.9% 0.0% 1.7% Oswego 4 116 3 222 0 172 0 120 2 116 3.4% 1.4% 0.0% 0.0% 1.7% Otsego 0 70 2 76 2 87 3 72 0 72 0.0% 2.6% 2.3% 4.2% 0.0% Putnam 3 125 3 208 3 110 4 122 6 122 2.4% 1.4% 2.7% 3.3% 4.9% Rensselaer 0 202 0 268 0 189 0 196 13 192 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 6.8% Rockland 24 676 27 1259 3 783 7 849 12 880 3.6% 2.1% 0.4% 0.8% 1.4% Saratoga 5 203 3 397 1 196 1 182 1 185 2.5% 0.8% 0.5% 0.5% 0.5% Schenectady 19 251 20 299 16 357 16 232 8 216 7.6% 6.7% 4.5% 6.9% 3.7% Schoharie 0 35 0 32 2 27 0 33 1 33 0.0% 0.0% 7.4% 0.0% 3.0% Schuyler 0 21 3 31 0 21 0 21 0 19 0.0% 9.7% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% Seneca 1 37 0 57 0 30 0 32 0 29 2.7% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% St. Lawrence 1 139 5 237 2 113 1 125 4 113 0.7% 2.1% 1.8% 0.8% 3.5% Steuben 2 113 2 136 2 104 2 109 2 96 1.8% 1.5% 1.9% 1.8% 2.1% Suffolk 59 1626 109 2526 65 1389 63 1560 54 1406 3.6% 4.3% 4.7% 4.0% 3.8% Sullivan 0 122 0 225 4 118 0 171 1 102 0.0% 0.0% 3.4% 0.0% 1.0% Tioga 0 45 0 69 1 40 1 37 12 198 0.0% 0.0% 2.5% 2.7% 6.1% Tompkins 0 66 2 106 3 58 6 69 1 64 0.0% 1.9% 5.2% 8.7% 1.6% Ulster 21 216 3 316 0 221 0 224 7 201 9.7% 0.9% 0.0% 0.0% 3.5% Warren 3 133 2 200 1 109 2 102 3 107 2.3% 1.0% 0.9% 2.0% 2.8% Washington 3 68 1 118 0 56 0 52 1 58 4.4% 0.8% 0.0% 0.0% 1.7% Wayne 0 66 5 109 0 78 0 84 1 78 0.0% 4.6% 0.0% 0.0% 1.3% Westchester 108 4367 107 6520 32 3016 57 3386 54 3091 2.5% 1.6% 1.1% 1.7% 1.7% Wyoming 0 43 2 51 0 28 0 30 1 30 0.0% 3.9% 0.0% 0.0% 3.3% Yates 0 24 0 28 0 17 0 21 0 21 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%

Totals 1476 25032 1808 36219 1262 23693 1223 24600 1175 23241 5.90% 4.99% 5.33% 4.97% 5.06%

* Information for FFY 2011 is for an 18 month time period Appendix 2

Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid

ALBANY

SMOKE MORE SMOKE MORE COLONIE CENTER WOLF RD ALBANY 12205- Yes SPEEDY MART SPEEDY MART 213 QUAIL STREET ALBANY 12203- Yes SUNOCO SUNOCO 795 BROADWAY ALBANY 12207- Yes SUPER $.99 PLUS SUNY SUPERMARKET 351 ONTARIO STREET ALBANY 12208- Yes ALLEGANY

EAST END MARKET EAST END MARKET 146 E. MAIN STREET ANGELICA 14709- Yes HANSON FARMS HANSON FARMS 10 MAIN STREET FILLMORE 14735- Yes SPEICHER'S GROCERY SPEICHERS GROCERY ROUTE 19 HUME 14745- Yes BRONX

#1 MINI MARKET #1 MINI MARKET 36 WESTCHESTER SQ BRONX 10461- Yes 1 COURT STATIONARY INC 1 COURT STATIONARY INC 90 EAST 161 STREET BRONX 10451- Yes 103 ROYAL DELI FOOD CORP 103 ROYAL DELI FOOD CORP 103 EAST MOUNT EDEN AVE BRONX 10452- Yes 1048 EXPRESS DELI INC 1048 EXPRESS DELI INC 1048 WESTCHESTER AVENUE BRONX 10459- Yes 124 STOP 1 DELI INC 124 STOP 1 DELI INC 124 EAST 183RD STREET BRONX 10453- 1300 CANDY & SNACKS INC 1300 CANDY & SNACKS INC 1300 LAYFATTE AVENUE BRONX 10474- Yes 1300 CANDY & SNACKS INC 1300 CANDY & SNACKS INC 1300 LAYFATTE AVENUE BRONX 10474- Yes 1498 S & R DELI GROCERY CORP 1498 S & R DELI GROCERY CORP. 1498 WESTCHESTER AVE BRONX 10472- Yes 1498 S & R DELI GROCERY CORP 1498 S & R DELI GROCERY CORP. 1498 WESTCHESTER AVE BRONX 10472- Yes 150 AURORA GROCERY CORP 150 AURORA GROCERY CORP 150 E. 174TH STREET BRONX 10457- Yes 156 FOOD MARKET INC 156 FOOD MARKET INC 760 GRAND CONCOURSE BRONX 10451- Yes 1614 BROTHER GROCERY LLC 1614 BROTHER GROCERY LLC 1614 WESTCHESER AVENUE BRONX 10472- Yes 167 J&M GROCERY CORP. 167 J&M GROCERY CORP.. 1210 SHERIDAN AVENUE BRONX 10456- Yes 173 GOURMET DELI INC 173 GOURMET DELI INC 1570 E. 174TH STREET BRONX 10472- Yes 1749 DELI GROCERY CORP 1749 DELI GROCERY CORP 1749 GRAND CONCOURSE BRONX 10453- Yes 180 EXPRESS DELI CORP 180 EXPRESS DELI CORP 906 EAST 180TH STREET BRONX 10460- Yes 180 STREET DELI & GROCERY INC 180 STREET DELI & GROCERY INC 702 EAST 180TH STREET BRONX 10457- Yes 1849 A &C DELI GROCERY CORP 1849 A &C DELI GROCERY CORP 1849 ANTHONY AVE BRONX 10457- Yes 1849 WESTCHESTER GROCERY & CANDY COR 1849 WESTCHESTER AVE BRONX 10472- Yes 1885 WESTCHESTER AVE PETROLEUM INC 1885 WESTCHESTER AVE PETROLEUM INC 1885 WESTCHESTER AVE BRONX 10472- 188TH STREET DELI & GROCERY INC 188TH STREET DELI & GROCERY INC 346 EAST 188TH STREET BRONX 10458- 194 STOP GROCERY CORP 194 STOP GROCERY CORP 341 EAST 194TH STREET BRONX 10458- Yes 20/20 GOURMET DELI INC 20/20 GOURMET DELI INC 788A COURTLANDT AVENUE BRONX 10451- Yes

Page 1 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid 210 CONVIENANCE STORE INC. 210 E. 188 STREET BRONX 10458- Yes 211 D CORP. 211 D CORP.. 2152 CROTONA PARKWAY BRONX 10460- Yes 231 STAR DELI GROCERY CORP. 231 STAR DELI GROCERY CORP. 231 W. 231ST STREET BRONX 10463- Yes 2363 ROSE WOOD GROCERY INC 2363 ROSE WOOD GROCERY INC 3263 WHITE PLAINS RD BRONX 10467- Yes 251 SUNSHINE DELI GROCERY CORP 251 SUNSHINE DELI GROCERY CORP 251 WEST 231ST STREET BRONX 10463- Yes 2741 K AND M DELI GROCERY CORP 2741 K AND M DELI GROCERY CORP 2741 WHITE PLAINS ROAD BRONX 10467- Yes 283 AN GROCERY CORP 283 AN GROCERY CORP 283 E. 161ST STREET BRONX 10451- Yes 305 EAST DELI GROCERY INC 305 EAST DELI GROCERY INC. 305 EAST 181ST STREET BRONX 10457- 3401 DELI & GROCERY CORP 3401 DELI & GROCERY CORP 3401 BOSTON ROAD BRONX 10469- Yes 3437 KLS INC/INACTIVE 3437 KLS INC 3437 JEROME AVENUE BRONX 10467- 3578 JEROME DELI INC 3578 JEROME DELI INC. 3578 JEROME AVENUE BRONX 10467- 3601 BAINBRIDGE GROCERY CORP 3601 BAINBRIDGE GROCERY CORP 3601 BAINBRIDGE AVE BRONX 10467- 368 SUNNY DELI CORP 368 SUNNY DELI CORP 368 E 188TH STREET BRONX 10458- Yes 3773 CARBBEAN DELI GROCERY CORP 3773 CARBBEAN DELI GROCERY CORP 3773 WHITE PLAINS ROAD BRONX 10467- Yes 395 GOURMET AND GROCERY CORP 395 GOURMET AND GROCERY CORP 395 EAST 149TH STREET BRONX 10455- Yes 395 GOURMET AND GROCERY CORP 395 GOURMET AND GROCERY CORP 395 EAST 149TH STREET BRONX 10455- 444 SOUNDVIEW AVE MINI MART INC 444 SOUNDVIEW AVE MINI MART INC. 444 SOUNDVIEW AVENUE BRONX 10473- Yes 469 E P DELI GROCERY CORP 469 E P DELI GROCERY CORP 469 BROOK AVENUE BRONX 10455- Yes 486 BORINQUEN GROCERY CORP 486 BORINQUEN GROCERY CORP 486 EAST 138 STREET BRONX 10454- Yes 50 STAR DELI GROCERY MARKET CORP 50 STAR DELI GROCERY MARKET CORP 928 TINTON AVENUE BRONX 10456- Yes 500 LOS HERMANOS DELI & GROCERY CORP 500 LOS HERMANOS DELI & GROCERY CORP 500 E 165TH STREET BRONX 11236- 545 E 137TH ST GROCERY CORP 545 E 137TH ST GROCERY CORP 545 E 137TH STREET BRONX 10454- Yes 548 GROCERY DELI INC 548 GROCERY DELI INC 548 SOUTHERN BLVD BRONX 10455- 571 EXPRESS DELI GROCERY INC 571 EXPRESS DELI GROCERY INC 571 E 139TH STREET BRONX 10454- Yes 627 GARDEN GOURMET DELI CORP 627 GARDEN GOURMET DELI CORP 627 E. TREMONT AVENUE BRONX 10457- Yes 639-641 GROCERY CORP 639-641 GROCERY CORP 639-641 SOUTHERN BLVD BRONX 10455- Yes 656 FOOD MART INC 656 FOOD MART INC 656 WESTCHESTER AVE BRONX 10455- Yes 69 WEST KINGSBRIDGE GROCERY INC 69 WEST KINGSBRIDGE GROCERY INC 69 W. KINGSBRIDGE RD BRONX 10468- Yes 7 ELEVEN #36803H 7 ELEVEN #36803H. 645 E. TREMONT AVE BRONX 10457- Yes 7 ELEVEN, INC 7 ELEVEN 2192 WHITE PLAINS ROAD BRONX 10462- Yes 7/10 DELI MARKET CORP. 7/10 DELI MARKET CORP. 898 GERARD AVENUE BRONX 10452- Yes 789 EAST 163RD STREET INC 789 EAST 163RD STREET INC 789 EAST 163RD STREET BRONX 10456- Yes 801 HUNTS POINT DELI CORP 801 HUNTS POINT DELI CORP 801-803 HUNTS POINT AVE BRONX 10474- Yes A & G GOURMET DELI GROCERY INC A & G GOURMET DELI GROCERY INC 2132 MOHEGAN AVENUE BRONX 10460- A J H DELI GROCERY CORP A J H DELI GROCERY CORP 942 EAST 179TH STREET BRONX 10460- Yes A&C GOURMET CORP A&C GOURMET CORP 337 EAST 146TH STREET BRONX 10451- Yes A&W GOURMET DELI INC A&W GOURMET DELI INC. 706 EAST TREMONT AVE BRONX 10457- Yes A.J.B DELI GROCERY INC A.J.B DELI GROCERY INC 701 COSTER STREET BRONX 10474- Yes AAA GAS & STORE INC AAA GAS & STORE INC 91 WESTCHESTER SQUARE BRONX 10461- Yes ABDO GROCERY CORP ABDO GROCERY CORP 16B EAST GUN HILL ROAD BRONX 10467- Yes

Page 2 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid AF DELI CORP V/INACTIVE AF DELI CORP V 29 E. KINGSBRIDGE ROAD BRONX 10468- Yes AISHA FOOD MARKET CORP. AISHA FOOD MARKET CORP.. 531 EAST TREMONT AVE BRONX 10457- Yes AL- RAIR GROCERY STORE INC AL- TAIR GROCERY STORE INC 385 EAST 194TH STREET BRONX 10458- Yes ALAAKOORI, AHMED & KASSEM, SAID M CONVENIENCE STORE 1475 WEST AVENUE BRONX 10462- Yes ALAMAL CORP ALAMAL CORP 1418 E. GUN HILL ROAD BRONX 10469- Yes ALBARAKA DELI AND GROCERY CORP ALBARAKA DELI AND GROCERY CORP.. 124 EAST 183RD STREET BRONX 10453- AL-BATHAA DELI GROCERY CORP AL-BATHAA DELI GROCERY CORP 870 PROSPECT AVENUE BRONX 10459- Yes ALKHADASHY, SHAMSAN A ALKHADASHY, SHAMSAN A 804 BURKE AVENUE BRONX 10467- Yes ALLAHABI, WADHAM, M.A. ALLAHABI, WADHAM, M.A. 1759 JEROME AVENUE BRONX 10453- Yes ALNABIL 85 DELI GROCERY CORP ALNABIL 85 DELI GROCERY CORP 971 PROSPECT AVENUE BRONX 10459- ALTAGRACIA GROCERY CORP ALTAGRACIA GROCERY CORP 10 EAST 176TH STREET BRONX 10453- AMEER FOOD GROCERY CORP AMEER FOOD GROCERY CORP 1964 GRAND CONCOURSE BRONX 10457- Yes AMERICAN ALBANIAN GROCERY DELI INC AMERICAN ALBANIAN GROCERY DELI INC 745 ASTOR AVENUE BRONX 10467- Yes AMIGOS GROCERY CORP AMIGOS GROCERY CORP 551 EAST 172ND STREET BRONX 10457- Yes ANEURYS GROCERY CORP ANEURYS GROCERY CORP 1299 FRANKLIN AVENUE BRONX 10456- Yes ANTHONY'S MINI MARKET CORP ANTHONY'S MINI MARKET CORP 740 SAINT ANNS AVENUE BRONX 10455- APPLE GROCERY & PRODUCE INC APPLE GROCERY & PRODUCE INC 2034 EASTCHESTER ROAD BRONX 10461- Yes ARCHER CANDY & GROCERY CORP ARCHER CANDY & GROCERY CORP 1808 ARCHER STREET BRONX 10460- ARCHER CANDY & GROCERY CORP ARCHER CANDY & GROCERY CORP 1808 ARCHER STREET BRONX 10460- ASTOR DELI AND GROCERY INC ASTOR DELI AND GROCERY INC 740 ASTOR AVENUE BRONX 10467- Yes B & J GAS CORP B & J GAS CORP 609 EAST FORDHAM RD BRONX 10458- Yes B & M DELI CORP B & M DELI CORP 16 WEST FORDHAM ROAD BRONX 10468- Yes B & W SMOKE SHOP CORP B & W SMOKE SHOP CORP 106 BURNSIDE AVENUE BRONX 10453- Yes B.C.P PHARMACY INC B.C.P PHARMACY INC 2730 EAST TREMONT AVE BRONX 10461- Yes BAILEY DELI & GROCERY CORP BAILEY DELI & GROCERY CORP 3656 BAILEY AVENUE BRONX 10463- Yes BAKER GROCERY STORE INC BAKER GROCERY STORE INC 818A EAST 149TH STREET BRONX 10455- BARENA CORP BARENA CORP/DORMANT 1335 PROPECT AVENUE BRONX 10459- BARRETO JUAN I BARRETO JUAN I. 24 WEST 183RD STREET BRONX 10453- BARTOW FOOD MART INC BARTOW FOOD MART INC 1945 BARTOW AVENUE BRONX 10469- Yes BAYCHESTER EXPRESS DELI INC BAYCHESTER EXPRESS DELI INC 3929 BAYCHESTER AVENUE BRONX 10466- Yes BETA NEW YORK LLC BETA NEW YORK LLC 1890 EASTCHESTER ROAD BRONX 10461- BIG K GROCERY STORE INC BIG K GROCERY STORE INC 102 EAST 167TH STREET BRONX 10452- Yes BOMBER GOURMET DELI INC BOMBER GOURMET DELI INC 2245 WESTCHESTER AVE BRONX 10462- Yes BRIGGS GOURMET DELI INC BRIGGS GOURMET DELI INC 2650 BRIGGS AVENUE BRONX 10458- Yes BRITO DELI & GROCERY CORP BRITO DELI & GROCERY CORP. 309 CRIMMINS AVENUE BRONX 10454- BRONX 656 FOOD CORP BRONX 656 FOOD CORP. 656 CASTLE HILL AVENUE BRONX 10473- Yes BRONX GOURMET FOOD CORP BRONX GOURMET FOOD CORP 921A EAST 180TH STREET BRONX 10460- Yes BRONX SUPER DELI CORP BRONX SUPER DELI CORP. 754 ASTOR AVENUE BRONX 10467- BRONX TITANIC HABIBI GROCERY INC BRONX TITANIC HABIBI GROCERY INC 1450 E. GUN HILL RD BRONX 10469- BROTHER DELII GROCERY CORP BROTHER DELII GROCERY CORP 699 BRIOTTON STREET BRONX 10467- Yes

Page 3 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid B'S GROCERY CORP B'S GROCERY CORP 2434 CRESTON AVENUE BRONX 10468- Yes BURNSIDE DELI CORP BURNSIDE DELI CORP 126 EAST BURNSIDE AVENUE BRONX 10453- BX METRO SUPERETTE CORP. BX METRO SUPERETTE CORP. 3504 FORT INDEPENDENCE ST BRONX 10463- Yes BX15 DELI GROCERY INC BX15 DELI GROCERY INC 575 EAST 161ST STREET BRONX 10456- Yes BX15 DELI GROCERY INC BX15 DELI GROCERY INC. 575 EAST 161ST STREET BRONX 10456- Yes CACAO DELI GROCERY CORP CACAO DELI GROCERY CORP 918 FAILLE STREET BRONX 10474- Yes CARLOS MINI MARKET CORP CARLOS MINI MARKET CORP. 1940 WEBSTER AVENUE BRONX 10457- CASTLE HILL GRUGS INC. CASTLE HILL GRUGS INC. 674 CASTLE HILL AVENUE BRONX 10473- Yes CHAND SERVICE INC CHAND SERVICE INC.. 3083 WEBSTER AVENUE BRONX 10467- Yes CIRCLE CONVENIENCE CORP CIRCLE CONVENIENCE CORP. 120 HUGH J GRANT CIRCLE BRONX 10472- Yes CIRCLE LINE DELI GROCERY CORP CIRCLE LINE DELI GROCERY CORP 511 EAST 138TH STREET BRONX 10454- CLINTON EXPRESS DELI CORP CLINTON EXPRESS DELI CORP 732 EAST TREMONT AVE BRONX 10457- Yes CROTONA GOURMET DELI CORP CROTONA GOURMET DELI CORP 2291 CROTONA AVENUE BRONX 10458- Yes CROTONA LOTTO PLUS INC. CROTONA LOTTO PLUS INC. 1938 CROTONA AVENUE BRONX 10457- Yes CRUGER EXPRESS DELI GROCERY INC CRUGER EXPRESS DELI GROCERY INC 721 BURKE AVENUE BRONX 10467- Yes CVS/PHARMACAY #2437 CVS/PHARMACAY #2437 732 ALLERTON AVENUE BRONX 10467- Yes CVS/PHARMACAY #2437 CVS/PHARMACAY #2437 732 ALLERTON AVENUE BRONX 10467- Yes CYPRESS STAR DELI CYPRESS STAR DELI. 314 CYPRESS AVENUE BRONX 10454- D BURGOS DELI FOOD CORP D BURGOS DELI FOOD CORP 145 WEST KINGSBRIDGE RD BRONX 10468- DANERYS GROCERY CORP DANERYS GROCERY CORP 765 EAST 175TH STREET BRONX 10460- Yes DANERYS GROCERY CORP DANERYS GROCERY CORP 765 EAST 175TH STREET BRONX 10460- Yes DAY & NIGHT DELI GROCERY CORP DAY & NIGHT DELI GROCERY CORP 1017 LEGGET AVENUE BRONX 10455- Yes DEEGAN AUTOMOTIVE SERVICES CORP DEEGAN AUTOMOTIVE SERVICES CORP. 3031 BAILEY AVENUE BRONX 10463- Yes DELI FARMS CORPORATION DELI FARMS CORPORATION 850 LONGWOOD AVENUE BRONX 10459- Yes DISCOUNT DLEI GROCERY INC DISCOUNT DELI GROCERY INC 710 EAST 187TH STREET BRONX 10458- Yes DON LUIS VIP CIGARS CORP DON LUIS VIP CIGARS CORP 1851 WESTCHESTER AVE BRONX 10472- Yes DORILA FOOD INC. DORILA FOOD INC.. 1681 BRUCKNER BLVD BRONX 10472- Yes EDEN GOURMENT DELI & GROCERY CORP EDEN GOURMENT DELI & GROCERY CORP 1190 CROMWELL AVENUE BRONX 10452- Yes EL BARRIO GROCERY DELI CORP EL BARRIO GROCERY DELI CORP 39 WEST 183RD STREET BRONX 10453- EL BARRIO GROCERY DELI CORP EL BARRIO GROCERY DELI CORP 39 WEST 183RD STREET BRONX 10453- Yes EL BARRIO GROCERY DELI CORP EL BARRIO GROCERY DELI CORP 39 WEST 183RD STREET BRONX 10453- EL BARRIO GROCERY DELI CORP EL BARRIO GROCERY DELI CORP 39 WEST 183RD STREET BRONX 10453- ELYAS LLC ELYAS LLC 1422 WILLIAMSBRIDGE RD BRONX 10461- Yes EMMANUEL DELI CORP EMMANUEL DELI CORP 3019 WEBSTER AVENUE BRONX 10458- Yes EXPRESS DELI EXPRESS DELI 149 E. 149TH STREET BRONX 10451- EXPRESS DELI GROCERY OF RANDALL AVE EXPRESS DELI GROCERY OF RANDALL AVE. 1890 RANDALL AVENUE BRONX 10473- Yes E-Z PASS GOURMET INC E-Z PASS GOURMET INC 688 E. 187TH STREET BRONX 10458- Yes FAISAL M SHAMMAKH FAISAL M SHAMMAKH 3548 BRONX BOULEVARD BRONX 10467- Yes FAM DELI GROCERY FAM DELI GROCERY 1060 SHERMAN AVENUE BRONX 10456- Yes FAMILY DELI FOOD CORP FAMILY DELI FOOD CORP 267 E TREMONT AVENUE BRONX 10457- Yes

Page 4 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF NEW YORK INC FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF NEW YORK INC 1245 EDWARD L GRANT HWY BRONX 10452- Yes FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF NEW YORK, IN FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF NEW YORK, IN. 2500 WHITE PLAINS ROAD BRONX 10467- Yes FAMOUS HERO CITY DELI GROCERY CORP FAMOUS HERO CITY DELI GROCERY CORP 485 JACKSON AVENUE BRONX 10455- Yes FIFTY FIFTY DELI & GROCERY INC FIFTY FIFTY DELI & GROCERY INC 740 MORRIS AVENUE BRONX 10462- FLIPPER DELI & GROCERY STORE FLIPPER DELI & GROCERY STOR. 3967 LACONIA AVENUE BRONX 10466- Yes FORDHAM CONVENIENCE STORE CORP FORDHAM CONVENIENCE STORE CORP 85 W FORDHAM ROAD BRONX 10468- Yes FORDHAM FOOD PLAZA CORPORATION FORDHAM FOOD PLAZA CORPORATION 2487 CRESTON AVENUE BRONX 10468- Yes FORDHAM GOURMET DELI INC FORDHAM GOURMET DELI INC 2542 MARION AVENUE BRONX 10458- Yes G DELI GROCERY CORP G DELI GROCERY CORP 676 CASTLE HILL AVENUE BRONX 10473- Yes GARULITA DELI CORP GARULITA DELI CORP 980 BRONX PARK SOUTH BRONX 10460- Yes GET & GO GROCERY CORP GET & GO GROCERY CORP 1053 OGDEN AVENUE BRONX 10452- Yes GONZALEZ DELI GROCERY CORP GONZALEZ DELI GROCERY CORP 106 EAST 165TH STREET BRONX 10452- GOYITO FOOD CORP GOYITO FOOD CORP 3340 FORT INDENPENCE ST BRONX 10463- Yes GRAND AVENUE GOURMET FOODS INC GRAND AVENUE GOURMET FOODS INC 50A W. BURNSIDE AVE BRONX 10453- Yes GREEN FIELD DELI INC GREEN FIELD DELI INC 132 E. 170TH STREET BRONX 10452- GREEN ZYTHON NEWSTAND INC GREEN ZYTHON NEWSTAND INC 2835 3RD AVENUE BRONX 10455- Yes GUERRERO FAMILY DELI GROCERY CORP GUERRERO FAMILY DELI GROCERY CORP 323 EAST GUNHILL RD BRONX 10467- Yes H & M FOOD CORP I H & M FOOD CORP I 131 EINSTEIN LOOP BRONX 10475- Yes HABIB EXPRESS DELI CORP HABIB EXPRESS DELI CORP. 5223 BROADWAY ST BRONX 10463- Yes HATHEFH DELI GROCERIES CORP HATHEFH DELI GROCERIES CORP 1570 WHITE PLAINS ROAD BRONX 10452- Yes HIGH HOPE DELI INC HIGH HOPE DELI INC 260 E. BURNSIDE AVENUE BRONX 10457- Yes HIGH HOPE DELI INC HIGH HOPE DELI INC 260 E. BURNSIDE AVENUE BRONX 10457- Yes HKM FOOD CORP HKM FOOD CORP 1305 ALLERTON AVENUE BRONX 10469- Yes HMC TOWER INC/INACTIVE HMC TOWER INC 1250 WATERS PLACE BRONX 10461- Yes HOE AVENUE DELI GROCERY CORP HOE AVENUE DELI GROCERY CORP. 914 HOE STREET BRONX 10459- HOLLAND GOURMET DELI CORP. HOLLAND GOURMET DELI CORP. 2460 HOLLAND AVENUE BRONX 10467- Yes HOT GRILL DELI CORP HOT GRILL DELI CORP 1226 E. GUN HILL ROAD BRONX 10469- Yes HUNT'S POINT INC HUNT'S POINT GOURMET INC 770 HUNTS POINT AVE BRONX 10474- Yes ITALCORP, INC. ITALCORP, INC. 947 CASTLE HILL AVENUE BRONX 10473- Yes J & J DELI J & J DELI 1572 WILLIAMSBRIDGE RD BRONX 10461- Yes J & J GOURMET AND DELI INC J & J GOURMET AND DELI INC 1824 ARCHER STREET BRONX 10460- J & J MINI MARKET NO.2 INC J & J MINI MARKET NO.2 INC 3981 LACONIA AVENUE BRONX 10466- Yes JACK SPOT CAFE INC JACK SPOT CAFE INC 3578 JEROME AVENUE BRONX 10467- JENNINGS CANDY & TOBACCO INC JENNINGS CANDY & TOBACCO INC 1461 SOUTHERN BLVD BRONX 10460- Yes JJN CORPORATION JJN CORPORATION 1512 WASHINGTON AVE BRONX 10457- Yes JOSELIN GROCERY CORP. JOSELIN GROCERY CORP. 2238 MORRIS AVENUE BRONX 10453- Yes KEEMO DELI & GROCERY CORP KEEMO DELI & GROCERY CORP 247 EAST 165TH STREET BRONX 10456- Yes KETSIE GROCERY INC KETSIE GROCERY INC 865 EAST 149TH STREET BRONX 10455- Yes KING CONCOURSE DELI 2013 CORP KING CONCOURSE DELI 2013 CORP 1963 GRAND CONCOURSE BRONX 10457- Yes KINGS GRILL & DELI INC KINGS GRILL & DELI INC. 585 SOUTHERN BLVD BRONX 10455- Yes

Page 5 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid KINGS GRILL & GORCERY CORP KINGS GRILL & GORCERY CORP 585 SOUTHERN BLVD BRONX 10455- Yes KINGSBRIDGE SMOKE SHOP & CANDY INC KINGSBRIDGE SMOKE SHOP & CANDY INC 5625 BROADWAY BRONX 10467- Yes KWA FOOD CORP. KWA FOOD CORP. 1798 E. TREMONT AVE BRONX 10460- Yes L & L FOOD CORP L & L FOOD CORP 808 EAST 149TH STREET BRONX 10455- Yes LA CAMPINA DELI GROCERY INC LA CAMPINA DELI GROCERY INC 802 MELROSE AVENUE BRONX 10451- Yes LA ISLA FOOD CORP LA ISLA FOOD CORP 1918 LACOMBE AVENUE BRONX 10473- Yes LACONIA COFFEE & NEWS CORP LACONIA COFFEE & NEWS CORP 4025 LACONIA AVENUE BRONX 10466- LACONIA MARKET, INC LACONIA MARKET, INC 4025 LACONIA AVENUE BRONX 10466- LAS LILAS DELI GROCERY CORP LAS LILAS DELI GROCERY CORP 1544 E 174TH STREET BRONX 10472- Yes LEESA CANDY STORE VIVAS, ELIZABETH 980A JENNINGS STREET BRONX 10459- LISBETH FOOD CORP LISBETH FOOD CORP 1702 WATSON AVENUE BRONX 10472- Yes LISMAR DELI GROCERY CORP LISMAR DELI GROCERY CORP 180 EAST 174TH STREET BRONX 10457- LOS HERMANOS MEAT AND GROCERY INC LOS HERMANOS MEAT AND GROCERY INC 501B JACKSON AVENUE BRONX 10455- Yes LOS TRES HERMANITOS DELI GROCERY LOS TRES HERMANITOS DELI GROCERY 454 MORRIS PARK AVE BRONX 10462- Yes LSD DELI GROCERY CORP LSD DELI GROCERY CORP 1247 WEBSTER AVENUE BRONX 10456- Yes LUCK LELAND LUCK LELAND 1859 ARCHER STREET BRONX 10460- Yes LUCKY 1 STOP GROCERY & DELI INC LUCKY 1 STOP GROCERY & DELI INC 1011A OGDEN AVENUE BRONX 10452- LUCKY 1 STOP GROCERY & DELI INC LUCKY 1 STOP GROCERY & DELI INC 1011A OGDEN AVENUE BRONX 10452- LUCKY STAR GOURMET DELI CORP LUCKY STAR GOURMET DELI CORP 856 EAST 180TH STREET BRONX 10460- Yes M FAMOUS GOURMET DELI INC M FAMOUS GOURMET DELI INC 3506 WHITE PLAINS ROAD BRONX 10467- Yes MAGIC WAY GOURMET DELI INC MAGIC WAY GOURMET DELI INC 643 TINTON AVENUE BRONX 10455- Yes MAJESTIC GOURMET DELI, LLC MAJESTIC GOURMET DELI, LLC 6119 BROADWAY BRONX 10471- Yes MALY 1 EXPRESS DELI CORP MALY 1 EXPRESS DELI CORP. 1132 BOSTON ROAD BRONX 10456- Yes MAMA FRIED CHICKEN CORP MAMA FRIED CHICKEN CORP 297 EAST 170 STREET BRONX 10458- Yes MARCOS JR PENA MARCOS JR PENA/DORMANT 1249 TIMTON AVENUE BRONX 10456- Yes MARIN'S GROCERY & CANDY STORE INC MARIN'S GROCERY & CANDY STORE INC 42 EAST 167TH STREET BRONX 10452- Yes MARTES FOOD CENTER CORP MARTES FOOD CENTER CORP 1055 WALTON AVENUE BRONX 10452- Yes MATANZA DELI GROCERY CORP MATANZA DELI GROCERY CORP 4027 A LACONIA AVENUE BRONX 10466- Yes MELENDEZ GROCERY MELENDEZ GROCERY. 1304 CASTLE HILL AVENUE BRONX 10462- Yes MI TIENDA DELI GROCERY CORP MI TIENDA DELI GROCERY CORP 424 EAST 149TH STREET BRONX 10455- Yes MIKE DELI AND GROCERY CORP MIKE DELI AND GROCERY CORP 202 FORDHAM ROAD BRONX 10468- MOE'S 3 DELI & GROCERY CORP MOE'S 3 DELI & GROCERY CORP 61 EAST BURNSIDE AVE BRONX 10453- MOTOWN DELI AND GROCERY CORP MOTOWN DELI AND GROCERY CORP 1681 BRUCKNER BLVD BRONX 10472- Yes MYKONOS FOOD CORP MYKONOS FOOD CORP 216 E 175TH STREET BRONX 10457- Yes NAGEEB GHALEB NAGEEB GHALEB 1851 ARCHER STREET BRONX 10460- Yes NAGI M SALEH NAGI M SALEH 2306B GRAND CONCOURSE BRONX 10458- NAZ STATIONERY AND NEWSSTAND NAZ STATIONERY AND NEWSSTAND 65 W. KINGSBRIDGE RD BRONX 10468- NEREID CANDY STORE INC. NEREID CANDY STORE INC. 703 NEREID AVENUE BRONX 10466- NEW BEST DELI CORP NEW BEST DELI CORP 73 WESTCHESTER SQUARE BRONX 10461- Yes NEW YEMEN DELI INC NEW YEMEN DELI INC 1348 EDWARD L GRANT HWY BRONX 10452- Yes

Page 6 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid NIN GROCERY CORP NIN GROCERY CORP 555 EAST 169TH STREET BRONX 10456- Yes OGDEN GROCERY AND CANDY CORP OGDEN GROCERY AND CANDY CORP 1373 OGDEN AVENUE BRONX 10452- Yes OJ DELI GROCERY INC OJ DELI GROCERY INC 230 EAST 174TH STREET BRONX 10457- Yes OLINVILLE DELI GROCERY CORP OLINVILLE DELI GROCERY 2218 OLINVILLE AVENUE BRONX 10467- Yes OLINVILLE DELI GROCERY CORP OLINVILLE DELI GROCERY 2218 OLINVILLE AVENUE BRONX 10467- Yes OMALE NEW YORK GROCERY CORP. 2172 CROTONA AVENUE BRONX 10457- Yes OPTIMUM GROCERY STORE INC OPTIMUM GROCERY STORE INC. 2090 BRONXDALE AVENUE BRONX 10462- Yes OSVALDO DELI GROCERY CORP OSVALDO DELI GROCERY CORP. 1882B CROTONA AVENUE BRONX 10457- Yes PAK DISCOUNT & VARIETY INC PAK DISCOUNT & VARIETY INC 631 E. TREMONT AVENUE BRONX 10457- PAK DISCOUNT & VARIETY INC PAK DISCOUNT & VARIETY INC 631 E. TREMONT AVENUE BRONX 10457- Yes PARK VIEW DELI CORP. PARK VIEW DELI CORP. 1402 CLAY AVENUE BRONX 10456- Yes PATHMARK STORES INC PATHMARK STORES INC 2136 BARTOW AVENUE BRONX 10475- Yes PELHAM GARDEN DELI GROCERY INC PELHAM GARDEN DELI GROCERY INC 1512 SCHORR PLACE BRONX 10469- Yes R & B ASSOCIATES GROCERY CORP. R & B ASSOCIATES GROCERY CORP. 554 MORRIS AVENUE BRONX 10451- RAFI GROCERY INC RAFI GROCERY INC. 1205 COLLEGE AVENUE BRONX 10456- Yes RAISHANI DELI CORP RAISHANI DELI CORP 800 EAST 169TH STREET BRONX 10459- RAMS DELI PLUS INC RAMS DELI PLUS INC 574 EAST FORDHAM RD BRONX 10458- Yes RAYAN GROCERY CORP RAYAN GROCERY CORP 4222 WHITE PLAINS ROAD BRONX 10466- REEM'S 2 GOURMET DELI CORP REEM'S 2 GOURMET CORP 412 WILLIS AVENUE BRONX 10454- REEMS DELI 3 INC REEMS DELI 3 INC 1133 MORRIS AVENUE BRONX 10456- Yes RIVERDALE DELI & GROCERY INC RIVERDALE DELI & GROCERY INC 5991 BROADWAY BRONX 10471- Yes ROBERT CABAN GROCERY INC ROBERT CABAN GROCERY INC 1980 GILDERSLEEVE AVE BRONX 10473- Yes ROSARIO DELI GROCERY ROSARIO DELI GROCERY 16 E. 213TH STREET BRONX 10467- Yes ROSEDALE TOBACCO & GROCERY INC ROSEDALE TOBACCO & GROCERY INC 1747A E. 172ND STREET BRONX 10472- Yes RUANE DELI INC RUANE DELI INC 2 CENTER EDGEWATER PARK DR BRONX 10465- Yes S & M GOURMET INC S & M GOURMET INC 670 CASTLE HILL AVENUE BRONX 10473- Yes S N K SONS, INC S N K SONS, INC 2007 WILLIAMSBRIDGE RD BRONX 10461- Yes S&J DELI, LLC S&J DELI, LLC 743 BURKE AVENUE BRONX 10467- S.Y. STRAWBERRY FARMS & GROCERY S.Y. STRAWBERRY FARMS & GROCERY 2403 WESTCHESTER AVENUE BRONX 10461- Yes SABAH CANDY AND GROCERY SABAH CANDY AND GROCERY 1033 MORRIS PARK AVENUE BRONX 10461- Yes SABAH CANDY AND GROCERY SABAH CANDY AND GROCERY 1033 MORRIS PARK AVENUE BRONX 10461- SALLY FOOD CORP SALLY FOOD CORP 126-28 W 228TH STREET BRONX 10463- Yes SAM BEST DELI GROCERY CORP SAM BEST DELI GROCERY CORP 1002 E. TREMONT AVE BRONX 10460- Yes SAM FAST GROCERY INC SAM FAST GROCERY INC 2660 3RD AVENUE BRONX 10454- Yes SAM GOURMET DELI AND GROCERY INC SAM GOURMET DELI AND GROCERY INC. 670 CASTLE HILL AVENUE BRONX 10473- SAMADAN DELI GROCERY INC SAMADAN DELI GROCERY INC 1760 WESTCHESTER AVE BRONX 10472- Yes SAMSEA INC SAMSEA INC 3215 3RD AVENUE BRONX 10451- Yes SANA CONVENIENCE STORE SANA CONVENIENCE STORE 1769 UNIVERSITY AVENUE BRONX 10453- Yes SANA CONVENIENCE STORE SANA CONVENIENCE STORE 1769 UNIVERSITY AVENUE BRONX 10453- Yes SANCHEZ FAMILY DELI GROCERY CORP SANCHEZ FAMILY DELI GROCERY CORP 703 PROSPECT AVENUE BRONX 10455- Yes

Page 7 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid SANTA GROCERY INC SANTA GROCERY INC 2009 CRUGER AVENUE BRONX 10462- Yes SANTA GROCERY INC SANTA GROCERY INC 2009 CRUGER AVENUE BRONX 10462- Yes SAVEMORE DELI GROCERY CORP SAVEMORE DELI GROCERY CORP 1363 WEBSTER AVENUE BRONX 10456- Yes SHAUBI GOURMET DELI CORP SHAUBI GOURMET DELI CORP 24 EAST 167TH STREET BRONX 10452- Yes SHIVALAYA CORPORATION SHIVALAYA CORPORATION 79 WESTCHESTER SQUARE BRONX 10461- Yes SILVER DELI GROCERY CORP. SILVER DELI GROCERY CORP. 1497 WILLIAMSBRIDGE RD BRONX 10461- Yes SKYLINE DELI CORP SKYLINE DELI CORP 171 W. BURNSIDE AVENUE BRONX 10453- Yes SOUTHERN DELI GROCERY SOUTHERN DELI GROCERY 1034 SAINT JOHN AVENUE BRONX 10459- Yes SS ENTERPRISES NY INC SS ENTERPRISES NY INC 557 GRAND CONCOURSE BRONX 10451- Yes STADIUM GOURMET DELI INC STADIUM GOURMET DELI INC 109 EAST 161ST STREET BRONX 10451- Yes STAR 2 DELI GROCERY INC STAR 2 DELI GROCERY INC.. 1033 CASTLE HILL AVENUE BRONX 10472- STEVE DELI & GROCERY STEVE DELI & GROCERY 1524 MAYFLOWER AVE BRONX 10461- Yes STOP & GO DELI GROCERY CORP STOP & GO DELI GROCERY CORP 839C PROSPECT AVENUE BRONX 10459- Yes STUTI INC STUTI INC 1480 WILLIAMSBRIDGE RD BRONX 10461- Yes SUPREME DELI DELUXE CORP SUPREME DELI DELUXE CORP 3399 E TREMONT AVENUE BRONX 10461- Yes SWEET CORNER DELI MARKET CORP. SWEET CORNER DELI MARKET CORP. 3100 PARK AVENUE BRONX 10451- Yes T & A DELI GROCERY INC T & A DELI GROCERY INC. 261 W. KINGSBRIDGE ROAD BRONX 10463- Yes T& T DELI AND GROCERY CORP T&T DELI AND GROCERY CORP 3431B BAYCHESTER AVENUE BRONX 10469- Yes TAYLOR SUPERETTE CORP TAYLOR SUPERETTE CORP. 459 TAYLOR AVENUE BRONX 10473- Yes TE AMO DELI INC TE AMO DELI INC 203 E. 198TH STREET BRONX 10458- Yes THE BEST DELI & GRILL I CORP THE BEST DELI & GRILL I CORP 201 W.T 242ND STREET BRONX 10471- Yes THROGS NECK PHARMACY THROGS NECK PHARMACY INC 4105 E. TREMONT AVENUE BRONX 10465- Yes TOLEDO GROCERY STORE INC TOLEDO GROCERY STORE INC 670 BARRETTO STREET BRONX 10474- Yes TREMONT GOURMET DELI AND GROCERY INC. TREMONT GOURMET DELI AND GROCERY INC 851 EAST TREMONT AVE BRONX 10460- Yes TRIANGLE CANDY & TOBACCO CORP TRIANGLE CANDY & TOBACCO CORP 3404 JEROME AVENUE BRONX 10467- Yes TROPICAL DAIRY FARM CORP TROPICAL DAIRY FARM CORP. 3494 JEROME AVENUE BRONX 10467- Yes TWO BROTHERS GOURMET DELI CORP TWO BROTHERS GOURMET DELI CORP 912 SOUNDVIEW AVENUE BRONX 10473- Yes VANCOURTLANDT PARK DELI INC VANCOURTLANDT PARK DELI INC 240 WEST 238TH STREET BRONX 10463- Yes VIRGINIA DELI GROCERY INC VIRGINIA DELI GROCERY INC 1268A VIRGINIA AVENUE BRONX 10472- Yes WALGREEN EASTERN CO INC WALGREEN EASTERN CO INC 3575 BOSTON ROAD BRONX 10469- Yes WALGREEN EASTERN CO INC #10989 WALGREEN 2431 BOSTON ROAD BRONX 10467- Yes WALGREENS #11745 WALGREENS #11745 2817 3RD AVENUE BRONX 10455- Yes WATSON SOMKE SHOP INC WATSON SOMKE SHOP INC. 1528 WATSON AVENUE BRONX 10472- WAVE EXPRESS FOOD MART INC WAVE EXPRESS FOOD MART INC 1596 WHITE PLAINS ROAD BRONX 10462- Yes WEBSTER GROCERY AND NEWSTAND INC WEBSTER GROCERY AND NEWSTAND INC 2519 WEBSTER AVENUE BRONX 10458- WEST FARMS CONVENIENCE # 1 WEST FARMS 2012 BOSTON ROAD BRONX 10460- Yes WEST FARMS CONVENIENCE # 1 WEST FARMS 2012 BOSTON ROAD BRONX 10460- Yes WESTCHESTER GOURMET DELI CORP 1579B WESTCHESTER AVE BRONX 10472- Yes X-10 CANDY GROCERY INC X-10 CANDY GROCERY INC 562 MORRIS AVENUE BRONX 10451- Yes YOGI 556, LLC YOGI 556, LLC 556 WEST 235TH STREET BRONX 10463- Yes

Page 8 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid YOUNG DELI GOURMET CORP YOUNG DELI GOURMET CORP 480 CONCORD AVENUE BRONX 10455- Yes ZAK DELI AND GROCERY INC. ZAK DELI AND GROCERY INC. 611 EAST 182ND STREET BRONX 10457- Yes ZAK DELI AND GROCERY INC. ZAK DELI AND GROCERY INC. 611 EAST 182ND STREET BRONX 10457- Yes BROOME

FAMILY DOLLAR STORE #3819 FAMILY DOLLAR 1183 VESTAL AVENUE BINGHAMTON 13903- Yes WEIS MARKET #214 WEIS MARKETS 1290 UPPER FRONT STREET BINGHAMTON 13901- Yes WEIS MARKETS #215 WEIS MARKETS 1109 WEST CORNERS PLAZA ENDICOTT 13760- Yes CATTARAUGUS

CROSBY MART CROSBY MART 3511 ROUTE 16 HINSDALE 14743- Yes KLESS BOYS FULL SERVICE KLESS BOYS FULL SERVICE 12248 ROUTE 16 YORKSHIRE 14173- Yes KWIK FILL #M0084 KWIK FILL 428 MAIN STREET OLEAN 14760- Yes RANDOLPH ARROW MART RANDOLPH ARROW MART 92 SOUTH MAIN STREET RANDOLPH 14772- Yes SOUTH DAYTON SUPERMARKET SOUTH DAYTON SUPERMARKET 303 PINE STREET SOUTH DAYTON 14138- Yes SOUTH DAYTON SUPERMARKET SOUTH DAYTON SUPERMARKET 303 PINE STREET SOUTH DAYTON 14138- Yes CAYUGA

MODERN MARKET MODERN MARKET 1 CAYUGA STREET MORAVIA 13118- Yes CHAUTAUQUA

COUNTRY FAIR STORE #15 COUNTRY FAIR STORE # 15 150 LAKE SHORE ROAD DUNKIRK 14048- Yes MACKS HOMETOWN MARKET MACK'S HOMETOWN MARKET 104 CHURCH STREET SHERMAN 14781- MACK'S HOMETOWN MARKET MACK'S HOMETOWN MARKET 104 CHURCH STREET SHERMAN 14781- Yes NOEPLACE STORE NOEPLACE STORE 708 SECOND AVENUE JAMESTOWN 14701- Yes CHEMUNG

EXPRESS MART EXPRESS MART 2150 GRAND CENTRAL AVE HORSEHEADS 14845- Yes EXPRESS MART #337 EXPRESS MART 300 MAPLE AVENUE ELMIRA 14904- Yes GEROW'S DAIRY 2 GEROW'S DAIRY 252 OAKWOOD AVENUE ELMIRA HEIGHTS 14903- Yes HESS MART #32463 HESS MART 2457 CORNING ROAD ELMIRA 14903- Yes KWIK FILL #A0026 KWIK FILL 1997 LAKE STREET ELMIRA 14901- Yes ON THE WAY ON THE WAY 102 MAIN STREET ELMIRA 14904- Yes CHENANGO

NORWICH FOOD AND FUEL NORWICH FOOD AND FUEL INC. NORTH 6120 STATE HIGHWAY 12 NORWICH 13815- Yes VILLAGE MARKETS VILLAGE MARKETS 2536 STATE HIGHWAY 206 COVENTRY 13778- Yes

Page 9 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid

COLUMBIA

BRICK TAVERN RANA & SONS, INC. 812 ROUTE 66 & 9H GHENT 12075- WEST INDIES & NATURAL FOOD WEST INDIES & NATURAL FOOD 302 WARREN STREET HUDSON 12534- Yes CORTLAND

KINNEY DRUGS # 36 KINNEY DRUGS 14 CLINTON STREET CORTLAND 13045- Yes SUNOCO #7256 SUNOCO 3947 NYS ROUTE 281 CORTLAND 13045- Yes VIRGIL COUNTRY MARKET VIRGIL COUNTRY MARKET 1760 NYS ROUTE 392 CORTLAND 13045- Yes DUTCHESS

718 DELI & GROCERY 718 DELI & GROCERY INC. 551 MAIN STREET POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- Yes 7-ELEVEN #25393D 7-ELEVEN 1336 ROUTE 9 WAPPINGERS FALLS 12590- Yes A & M GROCERY STORE A & M GROCERY STORE LLC 15 ACADEMY STREET POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- Yes A & M GROCERY STORE A & M GROCERY STORE LLC 15 ACADEMY STREET POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- Yes ABC GROCERIES ABC GROCERIES 22 DE LAVAL PLACE POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- Yes ADAM DELI & CONVENIENCE AHMED M ELKHATIB 469 MAIN STREET POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- Yes ARLINGTON GETTY MART ARLINGTON GETTY MART INC. 813 MAIN STREET POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- Yes AUTO SHINE CAR WASH AUTO SHINE CAR WASH INC. 2646 SOUTH ROAD POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- Yes B & B MINI MART B & B MINI MART 84 HAMILTON STREET POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- Yes BEACON QUICKMART BEACON MOBIL 361 MAIN STREET BEACON 12508- Yes BEST MART SHAH OIL CO. INC. 7519 NORTH BROADWAY RED HOOK 12571- Yes BUTCHER'S DELI MARKET BUTCHER'S DELI MARKET 81 FALLKILL AVENUE POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- Yes CASABLANCA GROCERY CASABLANCA GROCERY 386 MAIN STREET POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- Yes CHESTNUT MART OF POUGHKEEPSIE CHESTNUT MART OF POUGHKEEPSIE 2605 SOUTH ROAD POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- Yes COPPER ROOF DELI COPPER ROOF DELI LLC 1 FERRY STREET BEACON 12508- Yes CUMBERLAND FARMS #1611 CUMBERLAND FARMS INC. 2447 ROUTE 55 HOPEWELL JUNCTION 12533- Yes CUTTING BOARD CUTTING BOARD 200 MAIN STREET POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- Yes CUTTING BOARD DELI CUTTING BOARD DELI 200 MAIN STREET POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- Yes DOLLAR GENERAL #13147 DOLLAR GENERAL CORP 31 ROUTE 22 PAULING 12564- Yes FAMILY DELI GROCERY NAJI A. RAGEH 32 HARRISON STREET POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- Yes FAMILY DOLLAR #4830 FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF NEW YORK 258 HOOKER AVENUE POUGHKEEPSIE 12603- Yes FAMILY DOLLAR #6104 FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF NY 451 FISHKILL AVENUE SUITE C. BEACON 12508- Yes GIGGLES GIGGLES WORLD CORP. 10 STAGEDOOR ROAD FISHKILL 12524- Yes HOMETOWN DELI AND PIZZA H-TOWN CORP. 812 ROUTE 52 FISHKILL 12524- Yes HOMETOWN DELI AND PIZZA H-TOWN CORP. 812 ROUTE 52 FISHKILL 12524- Yes HY BROTHERS DELI & GROCERY HY BROTHERS DELI & GROCERY 352 MAIN STREET POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- Yes JENNAH DELI & GROCERY JENNAH DELI & GROCERY 285 MAIN STREET POUGHKEEPSIE 12603- K & D DELI K & D DELI INC 200 SALT POINT TURNPIKE POUGHKEEPSIE 12603- Yes

Page 10 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid K&D DELI K & D DELI INC. 200 SALT POINT TURNPIKE POUGHKEEPSIE 12603- Yes KENNEDY FRIED CHICKEN MSS FOOD POUGHKEEPSIE 364 MAIN STREET POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- Yes LILLIAN SMOKE SHOP & DELI 2 LILLIAN SMOKE SHOP & DELI 2 519 MAIN STREET POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- Yes MAIN STREET DELI ROUTE 9 STATION INC. 390 MAIN STREET BEACON 12508- Yes MAIN STREET DELI ROUTE 9 STATION INC. 390 MAIN STREET BEACON 12508- Yes MARIA'S DELI SANGHERA ENTERPRISES INC 117 OSBORNE HILL ROAD FISHKILL 12524- Yes NEW FAMILY MARKET NEW FAMILY MARKET 544 1/2 MAIN STREET POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- Yes NEW FAMILY MARKET NEW FAMILY MARKET 544 1/2 MAIN STREET POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- Yes PK DELI & CONVENIENCE PK DELI & CONVENIENCE 315 MAIN STREET POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- Yes POP'S CIGAR LOUNGE FS W. MAIN REALTY LLC 37 ELM STREET FISHKILL 12525- Yes POUGHKEEPSIE EXPRESS DELI POUGHKEEPSIE EXPRESS DELI 400 MAIN STREET POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- Yes RITA & SONS DELI PRITAM RUPARELIA 25 ACADEMY STREET POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- Yes RITA & SONS DELI PRITAM RUPARELIA 25 ACADEMY STREET POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- Yes RITE STOP GASE & FOOD MART RITE STOP GAS 531 MAIN STREET POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- Yes SHELL MART GKK PETROLEUM INC. 340 VIOLET AVENUE POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- Yes SHELL MART GKK PETROLEUM INC. 340 VIOLET STREET POUGHKEEPSIE 12601- SMOKERS MECCA SMOKER'S MECCA 285 MAIN STREET BEACON 12508- Yes SUNOCO HOPEWELL SUNOCO INC. 2612 ROUTE 52 HOPEWELL JUNCTION 12533- Yes SWARTZ MART SWARTZ MART INC. 893 ROUTE 376 WAPPINGER FALLS 12590- Yes TOBACCO HOUSE TOBACCO HOUSE OF 738, INC 738 ROUTE 9 SUITE C5 FISHKILL 12524- Yes TOBACCO LOUNGE II TOBACCO LOUNGE II 2540 ROUTE 55 POUGHQUAG 12570- Yes ERIE

7-ELEVEN #35138 7-ELEVEN 889 BEACH ROAD CHEEKTOWAGA 14225- Yes 7-ELEVEN #35156 7-ELEVEN 4935 WILLIAM STREET LANCASTER 14086- Yes 7-ELEVEN #35167H 7-ELEVEN 2550 MILLERSPORT HIGHWAY AMHERST 14068- Yes BLASDELL FAMILY MART BLASDELL FAMILY MART 3932 SOUTH PARK AVENUE BLASDELL 14219- Yes BOB'S NY DELI BOB'S NY DELI 1045 DAVIS ROAD AURORA 14170- Yes CITGO BETHFORD AUTO & TIRE 4490 LAKE AVENUE HAMBURG 14219- Yes COUNTRY FAIR STORE #79 COUNTRY FAIR STORE 612 MAIN STREET SPRINGVILLE 14141- Yes CVS #762 CVS PHARMACY 2000 KENSINGTON AVENUE AMHERST 14226- Yes DECADES DECADES 2895 SENECA STREET WEST SENECA 14224- Yes DOLLAR GENERAL #9028 DOLLAR GENERAL 338 KENMORE AVENUE TONAWANDA 14223- Yes DT MINI MART DT MINI MART 613 RIDGE ROAD LACKAWANNA 14218- Yes EAST FERRY CLOVER FARMS EAST FERRY CLOVER FARMS 436 FERRY STREET BUFFALO 14208- Yes EDSON MINI MART EDSON MINI MART 176 EDSON STREET WEST SENECA 14210- Yes EXPRESS MART #375 EXPRESS MART 5115 GENESEE STREET CHEEKTOWAGA 14225- Yes FAMILY DOLLAR #8503 FAMILY DOLLAR 1700 KENMORE AVENUE BUFFALO 14216- Yes GEORGES MOBIL SERVICE GEORGES MOBIL SERVICE 2206 MILLERSPORT HIGHWAY AMHERST 14068- Yes GOLDEN PIPE GOLDEN PIPE 3231 LAKESHORE ROAD BLASDELL 14219- Yes

Page 11 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid GREEN FROG II GREEN FROG II 3450 UNION ROAD CHEEKTOWAGA 14225- Yes GULF GULF 72 CASCADE DRIVE SPRINVILLE 14141- Yes JIMS TRUCK PLAZA STORE JIMS TRUCK PLAZA STORE 2125 WALDEN AVENUE CHEEKTOWAGA 14225- Yes JOHN'S CORNER STORE JOHN'S CORNER STORE 501 SUNSET DRIVE HAMBURG 14075- K-1 MINI FOOD MARKET K-1 MINI FOOD MARKET 3154 BAILEY AVENUE BUFFALO 14215- Yes KWIK FILL BAUER SERVICES 4298 BUFFALO STREET ORCHARD PARK 14127- Yes MANDELA MARKET MANDELA MARKET 272 FERRY STREET BUFFALO 14208- Yes MOBIL HORVATHS WOODLAWN MOBIL 3326 LAKESHORE ROAD BLASDELL 14219- Yes NIAGARA FALLS DAILY GROCERIES NIAGARA FALLS DAILY GROCERIES 540 NIAGARA FALLS BLVD TONAWANDA 14223- Yes OASIS CONVENIENCE OASIS CONVENIENCE 2437 HARLEM ROAD CHEEKTOWAGA 14225- Yes SINBAD MARKET SINBAD MARKET 2896 DELAWARE AVENUE KENMORE 14217- Yes SPEEDY MARKET SPEEDY MARKET 1799 GENESEE STREET BUFFALO 14211- Yes STADIUM MOBIL FAMILY EXPRESS 3856 SOUTHWESTERN BLVD ORCHARD PARK 14127- Yes SUNOCO #7131 SUNOCO 5215 SHERIDAN DRIVE AMHERST 14221- Yes SWEET HOME FOOD & BEVERAGE SWEET HOME FOOD & BEVERAGE 3030 SWEET HOME ROAD AMHERST 14228- Yes TRADE MART OF BUFFALO TRADE MART OF BUFFALO 169 WILKESBARRE AVENUE LACAWANNA 14218- Yes WALGREEN'S # 03257 WALGREEN'S 1328 ABBOT ROAD LACKAWANNA 14218- Yes WALGREENS #03267 WALGREENS 2043 KENSINGTON AVENUE AMHERST 14226- Yes WALGREENS #03267 WALGREEN'S 15 WILLOW RIDGE DRIVE AMHERST 14226- Yes WALGREEN'S #05592 WALGREEN'S 5275 TRANSIT ROAD CLARENCE 14221- Yes WILLOW RIDGE CONVENIENT WILLOW RIDGE CONVENIENT 15 WILLOW RIDGE DRIVE AMHERST 14228- Yes WOODLAWN DELI WOODLAWN DELI 3306 LAKESHORE ROAD BLASDELL 14219- Yes WOODLAWN TRADING COMP WOODLAWN TRADING COMP 4100 ST. FRANCIS DRIVE HAMBURG 14075- Yes ESSEX

THE BLOOMIN' MARKET THE BLOOMIN' MARKET 1719 NYS ROUTE 3 BLOOMINGDALE 12913- Yes FULTON

CAMPER'S LAST STOP CAMPER'S LAST STOP 318 HOUSEMAN STREET MAYFIELD 12117- Yes CITGO FUEL & FOOD 3006 STATE HIGHWAY 30 GLOVERSVILLE 12078- Yes YOUNG'S VARIETY STORE YOUNG'S VARIETY STORE 37 SOUTH MAIN STREET GLOVERSVILLE 12078- Yes GENESEE

A+ VAPORS & DEALS A+ VAPORS AND DEALS 327 ELLICOTT STREET BATAVIA 14020- Yes LOTUS FARMS LOTUS FARMS 13 LAKE STREET LEROY 14482- Yes WALGREENS WALGREENS 8 WEST MAIN STREET LEROY 14482- Yes GREENE

Page 12 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid BEER WORLD 1 AMOS POST ROAD CATSKILL 12414- Yes CLOTHESPIN LAUNDRETTE CLOTHESPIN LAUNDRETTE 90-6 CATSKILL COMMONS CATSKILL 12414- Yes HERKIMER

PRETTY MART PRETTY MART 4 NORTH ANN STREET LITTLE FALLS 13365- Yes THE 46 SKY LOUNGE DELI SKY LOUNGE/DELI 3062 MAIN STREET OLD FORGE 13420- Yes WAL-MART WAL-MART 103 N. CAROLINE STREET HERKIMER 13350- Yes WAL-MART # 2285 WAL-MART 103 CAROLINE STREET HERKIMER 13350- Yes JEFFERSON

CJ'S CORNER GAS MART CJ'S CORNER GAS MART 16 BRIDGE STREET WEST CARTHAGE 13619- Yes CROSSROADS GROCERY CROSSROADS GROCERY 43691 NYS RT 37 REDWOOD 13679- Yes RHODES GREENHOUSE RHODES GREENHOUSE 7185 NYS ROUTE 3 HENDERSON 13650- Yes KINGS

ESSAM M HAFEED NABEEL M A HUSSEIN 331 CRESCENT STREET BROOKLYN 11208- Yes 1076 BROADWAY DELI CORP 1076 BROADWAY DELI CORP 1076 BROADWAY BROOKLYN 11221- Yes 1090 LIBERTY DELI GROCERY CORP 1090 LIBERTY DELI GROCERY CORP 1090 LIBERTY AVENUE BROOKLYN 11208- 118 FOOD & VARIETY CORP 118 FOOD & VARIETY CORP 118 3RD AVENUE BROOKLYN 11217- Yes 129 DWIGHT ST FOOD CORP 129 DWIGHT ST FOOD CORP 129 DWIGHT STREET BROOKLYN 11231- Yes 132 EXPRESS DELI INC 132 EXPRESS DELI INC 132 GRAHAM AVENUE BROOKLYN 11206- Yes 133 FOOD CORP 133 FOOD CORP 133 LAFAYETTE AVENUE BROOKLYN 11238- Yes 1624 DELI GROCERY 1624 DELI GROCERY 1624 NEWKIRK AVENUE BROOKLYN 11226- Yes 1902 LUCKY DELI & GROCERY CORP. 1902 LUCKY DELI & GROCERY CORP.. 1902 MERMAID AVENUE BROOKLYN 11224- 1920 GROCERY CORP 1920 GROCERY CORP 1920 NOSTRAND AVENUE BROOKLYN 11226- 1925 NOSTRAND DELI CORP 1925 NOSTRAND DELI CORP 1925 NOSTRAND AVENUE BROOKLYN 11226- Yes 2012 DELI AND GRILL CORP 2012 DELI AND GRILL CORP 1891 FULTON STREET BROOKLYN 11233- 2233 FRIENDLY DELI CORP 2233 FRIENDLY DELI CORP 2233 PITKIN AVENUE BROOKLYN 11207- Yes 2233 FRIENDLY DELI CORP 2233 FRIENDLY DELI CORP 2233 PITKIN AVENUE BROOKLYN 11207- Yes 24 EXPRESS SULLIVAN FOOD CORP 24 EXPRESS SULLIVAN FOOD CORP 209 SULLIVAN PLACE BROOKLYN 11225- Yes 277 SUPERMARKET CORP 277 SUPERMARKET CORP 277 SUTTER AVENUE BROOKLYN 11212- Yes 2918 STAR DELI CORP 2918 STAR DELI CORP 2918 BEVERLEY ROAD BROOKLYN 11226- Yes 293 BROADWAY DELI & GROCERY CORP 293 BROADWAY DELI & GROCERY CORP. 293 BROADWAY BROOKLYN 11211- Yes 313 DISCOUNT CANDY & TOBACCO CORP 313 DISCOUNT CANDY & TOBACCO CORP 313 CENTRAL AVENUE BROOKLYN 11221- Yes 317TH STATIONARY CORP 317TH STATIONARY CORP 317TH 7TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11215- 322 DEKALB GROCERY CORP 322 DEKALB GROCERY CORP 322 DEKALB AVENUE BROOKLYN 11205- Yes 359 DELI GROCERY, LTD 359 DELI GROCERY, LTD 359 GRAHAM AVENUE BROOKLYN 11211- Yes 4 SEASONS DELI & GROCERY 4 SEASONS DELI & GROCERY 911 CONEY ISLAND AVENUE BROOKLYN 11230- Yes 415 CROWN DELI AND GROCERY INC 415 CROWN DELI AND GROCERY INC 415 MOTHER GASTON BLVD BROOKLYN 11212- Yes

Page 13 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid 44 NEWSSTAND CORP 44 NEWSSTAND CORP 383 JAY STREET BROOKLYN 11201- Yes 477 NEWS & TOBACCO INC 477 NEWS & TOBACCO INC 477 MYRTLE AVENUE BROOKLYN 11205- Yes 48 N DELI INC 48 N DELI INC 48 NORTH 6TH STREET BROOKLYN 11211- 5 STAR EXPRESS DELI GROCERY INC 5 STAR EXPRESS DELI GROCERY INC 3010 GLENWOOD ROAD BROOKLYN 11210- Yes 525 METROPOLITAN DEI CORP 525 METROPOLITAN DEI CORP 525 METROPOLITAN AVE BROOKLYN 11211- Yes 538 FRIENDSHIP DELI INC 538 FRIENDSHIP DELI INC 538 HEGEMAN AVENUE BROOKLYN 11207- Yes 5TH AVENUE NEWS INC 5TH AVENUE NEWS INC 4724 5TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11220- Yes 7/12 INC 7/12 INC. 170 AVENUE U BROOKLYN 11223- Yes 711 FLUSHING AVENUE FOOD INC 711 FLUSHING AVENUE FOOD INC 711 FLUSHING AVENUE BROOKLYN 11206- Yes 728 EXPRESS DELI INC 728 EXPRESS DELI INC 728 ROGERS AVENUE BROOKLYN 11226- Yes 738 UNITED GOURMET DELI CORP 738 UNITED GOURMET DELI CORP 738 NOSTRAND AVENUE BROOKLYN 11216- 7-ELEVEN 33704A 7-ELEVEN 33704A 1619 M AVENUE BROOKLYN 11230- Yes 7-ELEVEN INC 7-ELEVEN INC. 1523 AVENUE J BROOKLYN 11230- Yes 7-ELEVEN STORE #34051J 7-ELEVEN STORE #34051J.. 520 5TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11231- Yes 7-ELEVEN STORE 36038H 7-ELEVEN STORE 36038H 845 FLATBUSH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11226- Yes 858 FREIENDSHIP DELI CORP 858 FRIENDSHIP DELI CORP. 858 FLUSHING AVENUE BROOKLYN 11206- Yes 860 GOURMET DELI INC 860 GOURMET DELI INC 860 NEW LOTS AVENUE BROOKLYN 11208- Yes 897 PARK AVE DELI INC 897 PARK AVE DELI INC 897 PARK AVENUE BROOKLYN 11206- Yes 9 ST QUICK STOP INC 9 ST QUICK STOP INC 335 7TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11215- Yes 930 BIG BOY DELI INC 930 BIG BOY DELI INC 930 BROADWAY BROOKLYN 11206- Yes 952 FOOD CORP 952 FOOD CORP 952 4TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11232- Yes 960 SPRING DELI CORP. 960 SPRING DELI CORP. 960 DEKALB AVENUE BROOKLYN 11221- Yes A & A DELI FOOD CORP A & A DELI FOOD CORP 1872 FULTON STREET BROOKLYN 11233- Yes A & A DELI GROCERY NY CORP A & A DELI GROCERY NY CORP 588 NOSTRAND AVENUE BROOKLYN 11216- Yes A & J GOURMET DELI INC A & J GOURMET DELI INC 95 KNICKERBOCKER AVE BROOKLYN 11237- Yes A & J POPULR FOOD CORP A & J POPULR FOOD CORP 9102 FLATLANDS AVENUE BROOKLYN 11236- Yes A & W DELI GROCERY A & W DELI GROCERY.. 863 FLATBUSH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11226- Yes A.K.M. DELI GROCERY INC. A.K.M. DELI GROCERY INC. 383-385 X AVENUE BROOKLYN 11223- Yes ABB GROCERY CORP./INACTIVE ABB GROCERY CORP. 1526 MERMAID AVENUE BROOKLYN 11224- Yes ABDO STOP ONE DELI INC ABDO STOP ONE DELI INC 5824 5TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11220- Yes ADEK DELI & GROCERY INC ADEN DELI & GROCERY INC 1649 BEDFORD AVENUE BROOKLYN 11225- Yes AHMED KHALED K. AHMED KHALED K. 167 RALPH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11233- Yes ALABAMA FOOD CENTER CORP ALABAMA FOOD CENTER CORP. 2618 FULTON STREET BROOKLYN 11207- Yes ALAHERI, QAHTAN BEDFORD QUICK STOP 2034 BEDFORD AVENUE BROOKLYN 11226- AL-AMEER DELI & GROCERY CORP AL-AMEER DELI & GROCERY CORP 5716 5TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11220- Yes ALBANY SMOKE SHOP CORP ALBANY SMOKE SHOP CORP 228 ALBANY AVENUE BROOKLYN 11213- Yes ALBOKAIR, MOHAMED M SHAMSADEEN FOOD MARKET. 313 NOSTRAND AVENUE BROOKLYN 11216- Yes ALEX DELI GROCERY ALEX DELI GROCERY 1256 FLATBUSH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11226- Yes ALEX SMOKE SHOP AND CONVENIENCE STORE ALEX SMOKE SHOP AND CONVENIENCE STORE 301 WYCKOFF AVENUE BROOKLYN 11237- Yes ALI MUSED GOURMET DELI & GROCERY COR ALI MUSED GOURMET DELI & GROCERY CORP 825 FLATBUSH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11226- Yes

Page 14 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid ALMAKALEH, WAIS ALMAKALEH, WAIS. 2530 PITKIN AVENUE BROOKLYN 11208- ALNAJAR, N & HOSSEN, A EAST NEW YORK EXPRESS DELI/GROCERY 1540A E NEW YORK AVE BROOKLYN 11212- Yes ALNZAILI, ABDULHAKIM M. CARROLL GARDEN DELI GROCERY II. 245 COLUMBIA STREET BROOKLYN 11231- Yes ALONOFI FOOD MARKET LLC ALONOFI FOOD MARKET LLC 581 ROGERS AVENUE BROOKLYN 11225- Yes ALSAIDI DELI GROCERY INC ALSAIDI DELI GROCERY INC 2929 SURF AVENUE BROOKLYN 11224- Yes ALSARI GROCERY CORP ALSARI GROCERY CORP 1251 SUTTER AVENUE BROOKLYN 11208- Yes AMERADA HESS CORP AMERADA HESS CORP 914 CONEY ISLAND AVENUE BROOKLYN 11230- Yes AMERADA HESS CORPORATION AMERADA HESS CORPORATION. 210 GREENPOINT AVENUE BROOKLYN 11222- Yes AMG GROCERY CORP AMG GROCERY CORP 1395 NOSTRAND AVENUE BROOKLYN 11226- AMG GROCERY CORP AMG GROCERY CORP 1395 NOSTRAND AVENUE BROOKLYN 11226- Yes AML CONVENIENT & DELI GROCERY INC AML CONVENIENT & DELI GROCERY INC. 5916 NEW UTRECHT AVE BROOKLYN 11219- Yes ARENA DELI PLUS CORP ARENA DELI PLUS CORP 77 4TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11217- Yes ARENA DELI PLUS CORP ARENA DELI PLUS CORP 77 4TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11217- Yes ARIANA DELI & GROCERY INC ARIANA DELI & GROCERY INC 1634 EASTERN PARKWAY BROOKLYN 11233- Yes ARTURO'S CANDY STORE ARTURO'S CANDY STORE 47 ROCKAWAY AVENUE BROOKLYN 11233- Yes ASSOCIATES AND GROCERY SUPERMARKET ASSOCIATES AND GROCERY SUPERMARKET IN 7804 20TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11214- Yes ATIN INC ATIN INC 2283 65TH STREET BROOKLYN 11204- Yes AVE. M CONVENIENCE STORE INC AVE. M CONVENIENCE STORE INC 1624 M AVENUE BROOKLYN 11230- Yes AVENUE N GOURMET DELI INC AVENUE N GOURMET DELI INC 6309 AVENUE N BROOKLYN 11234- Yes AZY DELI CORP AZY DELI CORP 53-01 4TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11217- Yes BAGELIT INC BAGELIT INC 7501 13TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11228- Yes BAY PARKWAY DELI GROCERY CORP 2171 BATH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11214- Yes BEACH DELI INC BEACH DELI INC 3204 MERMAID AVENUE BROOKLYN 11224- Yes BERRY GOOD INC BERRY GOOD INC 1123 J AVENUE BROOKLYN 11230- Yes BORGATA DELI CORP. BORGATA DELI CORP. 1977 86TH STREET BROOKLYN 11214- Yes BOYS & GIRLS GROCERY DELI INC BOYS & GIRLS GROCERY DELI INC. 1749 FULTON STREET BROOKLYN 11233- Yes BOYS & GIRLS GROCERY DELI INC BOYS & GIRLS GROCERY DELI INC. 1749 FULTON STREET BROOKLYN 11233- Yes BRITEWAY MINIMART INC BRITEWAY MINIMART INC 668 3RD AVENUE BROOKLYN 11232- Yes BROADWAY GROCERY & NEWS STAND INC BROADWAY GROCERY & NEWS STAND INC 267 BROADWAY BROOKLYN 11211- Yes BROOKLYN'S FINEST DELI I CORP BROOKLYN'S FINEST DELI I CORP 131 TOMPKINS AVENUE BROOKLYN 11206- Yes BROTHER MINI MARKET CORP BROTHER MINI MARKET CORP. 1266 EAST 37TH STREET BROOKLYN 11210- CANDY SHOP 93 INC CANDY SHOP 93 INC 9305 3RD AVENUE BROOKLYN 11209- Yes CARROLL STREET FOOD CORP CARROLL STREET FOOD CORP 350 UTICA AVENUE BROOKLYN 11213- Yes CEPADA GROCERY CEPADA GROCERY 746 WASHINGTON AVENUE BROOKLYN 11238- Yes CHESTER DELI AND GROCERY INC CHESTER DELI AND GROCERY INC. 498 CHESTER STREET BROOKLYN 11212- CHIN'S MINI MART INC CHIN'S MINI MART INC 8306 17TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11214- Yes COLOMBIA GROCERY CORP COLOMBIA GROCERY CORP 439 COLUMBIA STREET BROOKLYN 11231- Yes COMFORT GROCERY INC COMFORT GROCERY INC 533A OCEAN AVENUE BROOKLYN 11226- Yes CROPSEY SUPER MART MSFACHR UNITED LLC. 2813-15 CROPSEY AVENUE BROOKLYN 11214- Yes CVS ALBANY LLC CVS ALBANY LLC. 218 MYRTLE AVENUE BROOKLYN 11201- Yes

Page 15 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid CVS PHARMACY #2436 CVS PHARMACY #2436. 1346 PENNSYLVANIA AVENUE BROOKLYN 11239- Yes CVS/PHARMACY #2498 CVS 341 9TH STREET BROOKLYN 11215- Yes CYPRESS HILL GROCERY CORP CYPRESS HILL GROCERY CORP 567 EUCKID AVENUE BROOKLYN 11208- Yes CYPRESS HILL GROCERY CORP CYPRESS HILL GROCERY CORP 567 EUCKID AVENUE BROOKLYN 11208- D HEIGHTS DELI & GROCERY CORP D HEIGHTS DELI & GROCERY CORP 6902 13TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11228- Yes D S GROCERY D S GROCERY 240 WILSON AVENUE BROOKLYN 11237- Yes D&H JABER FOOD CORP D&H JABER FOOD CORP 421 COLUMBIA STREET BROOKLYN 11231- DAVID GROCERY & FOOD CORP DAVID GROCERY & FOOD CORP 759 PARK AVENUE BROOKLYN 11206- Yes DAVIS DELI CORP DAVIS DELI CORP 1110 PENNSYLVANIA AVENUE BROOKLYN 11207- Yes DAY & NIGHT GOURMET DELI CORP DAY & NIGHT GOURMET DELI CORP 1811 PITKIN AVENUE BROOKLYN 11212- Yes DAY AND NIGHT SMOKE SHOP AND GROCERY 235 CLEVELAND STREET BROOKLYN 11208- DBA RITE AID # 10573 DBA RITE AID # 10573 7501 5TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11209- Yes DEE NEWSTAND AND CANDY CORP DEE NEWSTAND AND CANDY CORP 75 VARET STREET BROOKLYN 11206- DELI & PIZZA LUNCHEONETTE CORP DELI & PIZZA LUNCHEONETTE CORP. 603 Z AVENUE BROOKLYN 11223- Yes DELI EXPRESS DELI EXPRESS 2127 CHURCH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11226- Yes DESHI SUPERMARKET DESHI SUPERMARKET 1322 NEWKIRK AVENUE BROOKLYN 11230- Yes DIAMOND STAR DELI AND GROCERY INC DIAMOND STAR DELI AND GROCERY INC 738 FLATBUSH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11226- DIAMOND STAR DELI AND GROCERY INC DIAMOND STAR DELI AND GROCERY INC 738 FLATBUSH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11226- Yes DITMAS BEST DELI INC DITMAS BEST DELI INC 1218 FLATBUSH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11226- Yes DNJ DELI GROCERY CORP DNJ DELI GROCERY CORP 1789 LINDEN AVENUE BROOKLYN 11207- Yes DUO DUO WANG DELI INC DUO DUO WANG DELI INC 348 ATLANTIC AVENUE BROOKLYN 11217- Yes E 100 GROCERY INC E 100 GROCERY INC. 4023 8TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11232- Yes EARTH'S BASKET INC EARTH'S BASKET INC 599 4TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11232- Yes EAST 36 DELI & GRILL CORP EAST 36 DELI & GRILL CORP.. 1792 FLATBUSH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11210- Yes EAST NY DELI CORP. EAST NY DELI CORP.. 214 TAPSCOTT STREET BROOKLYN 11212- EASTERN PARKWAY CORP EASTERN PARKWAY CORP 1291 EASTERN PARKWAY BROOKLYN 11233- Yes EASTERN PARKWAY CORP EASTERN PARKWAY CORP 1291 EASTERN PARKWAY BROOKLYN 11233- ECOGREEN MARKETS CORP ECOGREEN MARKETS CORP 718 FRANKLIN AVENUE BROOKLYN 11238- ECONOMIC DELI GROCERY, INC ECONOMIC DELI GROCERY, INC 1664 BERGEN STREET BROOKLYN 11213- Yes EL COLMADON CORP I EL COLMADON CORP I. 664 KNICKERBOCKER AVE BROOKLYN 11221- Yes ELIAS DELI GROCERY INC ELIAS DELI GROCERY INC 2311 PITKIN AVENUE BROOKLYN 11207- Yes ELIM LAM GAS STATION CORP ELIM LAM GAS STATION CORP. 1525 MYRTLE AVENUE BROOKLYN 11237- Yes ELLERY ST MARKET CORP ELLERY ST MARKET CORP 499 MARCY AVENUE BROOKLYN 11206- EMAN FOOD CENTER & DISCOUNT MINI MART 1667 FLATBUSH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11210- Yes EMPIRE TOBACCO SHOP CORP EMPIRE TOBACCO SHOP CORP 521 MYRTLE AVENUE BROOKLYN 11205- Yes EVERGREEN MINI MARKET INC EVERGREEN MINI MARKET INC 291 EVERGREEN AVENUE BROOKLYN 11221- Yes EXPRESS 1363 DELI INC EXPRESS 1363 DELI INC. 1363 BROADWAY STREET BROOKLYN 11221- Yes F.J.P. MEAT MARKET, INC. F.J.P. MEAT MARKET, INC. 2823 MERMAID AVENUE BROOKLYN 11224- Yes FADI DELI AND GROCERY FADI DELI AND GROCERY 235 65TH STREET BROOKLYN 11220- Yes FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF NEW YORK INC FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF NEW YORK INC 830 ROCKAWAY AVENUE BROOKLYN 11212- Yes

Page 16 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF NY INC FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF NY INC 895 DEKALB AVENUE BROOKLYN 11221- Yes FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF NY INC FAMILY DOLLAR 2233 NOSTRAND AVENUE BROOKLYN 11210- Yes FAMILY FOOD AT CORTELYOU INC FAMILY FOOD AT CORTELYOU INC 1522 CORTELYOU ROAD BROOKLYN 11226- Yes FAMOUS II GROCERY CORP FAMOUS II GROCERY CORP 783 HICKS STREET BROOKLYN 11231- Yes FARIS M. SHUAIBI & TAWFIQ M. AHMED FARIS M. SHUAIBI & TAWFIQ M. AHMED 185 STARR WAY BROOKLYN 11237- Yes FARMER IN THE DELI & GROCERY CORP FARMER IN THE DELI & GROCERY CORP 357 MYRTLE AVENUE BROOKLYN 11205- Yes FATAWA MIN MARKET INC FATAWA MIN MARKET INC 79 LIVONIA AVENUE BROOKLYN 11212- Yes FATHER & SONS DELI FOOD CORP FATHER & SONS DELI FOOD CORP 1501 CORTELYOU ROAD BROOKLYN 11226- FIRST STOP GROCERY INC FIRST STOP GROCERY #2 643 MARCY AVENUE BROOKLYN 11206- Yes FIVE STAR FIVE INC FIVE STAR FIVE INC 2127 PITKIN AVENUE BROOKLYN 11207- Yes FLATBUSH CONVENIENCE SHOP CORP. FLATBUSH CONVENIENCE SHOP CORP. 1676 FLATBUSH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11210- FLATBUSH DELI CORP FLATBUSH DELI CORP 803 FLATBUSH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11226- Yes FLATBUSH FOOD AMRT CORP FLATBUSH FOOD AMRT CORP 1048 FLATBUSH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11226- Yes FLATBUSH FOOD AMRT CORP FLATBUSH FOOD AMRT CORP 1048 FLATBUSH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11226- Yes FLATBUSH GARDEN FOOD INC FLATBUSH GARDEN FOOD INC. 1938 NOSTRAND AVENUE BROOKLYN 11210- Yes FLUSHING AVE GAS CORP FLUSHING AVE GAS CORP.. 1127 FLUSHING AVENUE BROOKLYN 11237- FLUSHING ISLAND CORP FLUSHING ISLAND CORP 655 FLUSHING AVENUE BROOKLYN 11206- Yes FOOD DELI CORP FOOD DELI CORP 430 MOTHER GASTON BLVD BROOKLYN 11212- Yes FRANCISCO RAFAEL FRANCISCO RAFAEL 209 WILSON AVENUE BROOKLYN 11237- Yes FRESH MINI MARKET INC FRESH MINI MARKET INC 7224 13TH STREET BROOKLYN 11228- FRIENDLEY OPERATING CORP FRIENDLEY OPERATING CORP 1092 ROGERS AVENUE BROOKLYN 11221- Yes FULTON & SARATOGA DELI CORP FULTON & SARATOGA DELI CORP 1961 FULTON STREET BROOKLYN 11233- Yes FULTON 2208 FOOD CORP FULTON 2208 FOOD CORP 2208 FULTON STREET BROOKLYN 11233- FULTON CORNER STORE CORP FULTON CORNER STORE CORP 3441 FULTON STREET BROOKLYN 11208- Yes FULTON DELI GROCERY CORP FULTON DELI GROCERY CORP 2936 FULTON STREET BROOKLYN 11207- FULTON GOURMET AND COFFEE SHOP CORP FULTON GOURMET AND COFFEE SHOP CORP 3336 FULTON STREET BROOKLYN 11208- Yes GALSTYAN, ANNA GALSTYAN, ANNA 8505 4TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11209- Yes GARULITA DELI GROCERY GARULITA DELI GROCERY 114 MARCUS GARVEY BLVD BROOKLYN 11206- Yes GATEWAY TOP SHELF LLC GATEWAY TOP SHELF LLC 739 RIVERDALE AVENUE BROOKLYN 11207- GENUINE DELI AND GROCERY CORP GENUINE DELI AND GROCERY CORP 700 FULTON STREET BROOKLYN 11217- Yes GOHEL, MANISHKUMAR P GOHEL, MANISHKUMAR P S/E/C STATE STREET BROOKLYN 11201- Yes GOLD STAR SUPERMARKET GOLD STAR SUPERMARKET 6005 5TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11220- Yes GOLDEN BELL DELI INC. GOLDEN BELL DELI INC. 247 X AVENUE BROOKLYN 11223- Yes GOLDEN GOURMENT DELI INC GOLDEN GOURMENT DELI INC 1500 PITKIN AVENUE BROOKLYN 11212- Yes GOOD DEAL DELI & GROCERY CORP GOOD DEAL DELI & GROCERY CORP 245 TROY AVENUE BROOKLYN 11213- Yes GOOD LUCK NEWS II INC. NEW MAI STOP N GO 9224 4TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11209- Yes GOOD NEIGHBORHOOD DELI & COFFEE SHOP GOOD NEIGHBORHOOD DELI & COFFEE SHOP. 6724 14TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11219- Yes GOWANA GOURMET CORP GOWANA GOURMET CORP 207 BOND STREET BROOKLYN 11217- Yes GRAHAM SUPER GROCERY INC GRAHAM SUPER GROCERY INC 200 GRAHAM AVENUE BROOKLYN 11206- Yes GRAHAM SUPER GROCERY INC GRAHAM SUPER GROCERY INC 200 GRAHAM AVENUE BROOKLYN 11206- Yes

Page 17 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid GREEN & ORGANICS DELI INC GREEN & ORGANICS DELI INC 446 FRANKLIN AVENUE BROOKLYN 11238- Yes GREENE VALLEY MARKET CORP GREENE VALLEY MARKET CORP 216 GREENE AVENUE BROOKLYN 11238- Yes GREENPOINT FRUITS & DELI MARKET GREENPOINT FRUITS & DELI MARKET 974 MANHATTAN AVENUE BROOKLYN 11222- Yes GROCERY AT 1844 NOSTRAND CORP GROCERY AT 1844 NOSTRAND CORP 1844 NOSTRAND AVE BROOKLYN 11226- Yes GROCERY EMPORIUM, INC. GROCERY EMPORIUM, INC. 1027 BRIGHTON BEACH AVE BROOKLYN 11235- H & H GROCERY & HALAL MEAT INC H & H GROCERY & HALAL MEAT INC 1010 EAST 14TH STREET BROOKLYN 11230- Yes HALSEY GROCERY CORP HALSEY GROCERY CORP 146 RALPH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11233- Yes HAMZA EXPRESS FOOD CORP HAMZA EXPRESS FOOD CORP 559 NEW LOTS AVENUE BROOKLYN 11207- Yes HAMZA EXPRESS FOOD CORP HAMZA EXPRESS FOOD CORP 559 NEW LOTS AVENUE BROOKLYN 11207- Yes HANSON NEWSSTAND AND STATIONER HANSON NEWSSTAND AND STATIONER 37 HANSON PLACE BROOKLYN 11217- Yes HASHALLAH DELI CORP MASHALLAH DELI,CORP 2115 SURF AVENUE BROOKLYN 11224- Yes HEGEMAN GOURMET DELI INC HEGEMAN GOURMET DELI INC. 588 HEGEMAN AVENUE BROOKLYN 11207- Yes HI MANGO NATURAL MARKET V, INC. HI MANGO NATURAL MARKET V, INC. 341 KNICKERBOCKER AVENUE BROOKLYN 11237- Yes HONG CHENG INC HONG CHENG INC 122 S AVENUE BROOKLYN 11223- Yes HONG KAY MARKET INC HONG KAY MARKET INC 7022 18TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11204- Yes HOWARD DELI MART INC. HOWARD DELI MART INC. 199 HOWARD AVENUE BROOKLYN 11233- Yes HOWARD GOURMET AND DELI INC HOWARD GOURMET AND DELI INC. 363 HOWARD AVENUE BROOKLYN 11233- Yes HOYT CONVENIENCE INC HOYT CONVENIENCE INC 186 DEKALB AVENUE BROOKLYN 11205- Yes IN AND OUT DELI CORP IN AND OUT DELI CORP 7223 5TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11209- Yes IRVING GOURMENT DELI INC IRVING GOURMENT DELI INC 350 IRVING AVENUE BROOKLYN 11237- Yes J GROCERY FOOD CORP J GROCERY FOOD CORP 246 AVENUE U BROOKLYN 11223- Yes J&Z DELI & GRILL INC J&Z DELI & GRILL INC 3339 FULTON STREET BROOKLYN 11208- Yes JAE'S DELI GROCERY JAE'S DELI GROCERY 6802 14 AVENUE BROOKLYN 11219- Yes JAMIE DELI INC. JAMIE DELI INC. 2815 AVENUE U BROOKLYN 11229- Yes JAY ST FINEST DELI CORP JAY ST FINEST DELI CORP. 408 JAY STREET BROOKLYN 11201- Yes JAYDELISA DELI GROCERY CORP JAYDELISA DELI GROCERY CORP 711 KNICKERBOCKER AVENUE BROOKLYN 11221- Yes JAYDELISA DELI GROCERY CORP JAYDELISA DELI GROCERY CORP 711 KNICKERBOCKER AVENUE BROOKLYN 11221- Yes JIMMY CANDY STORE JIMMY CANDY STORE CORP 1804 AVENUE M BROOKLYN 11230- Yes JIMY CANDY GROCERY INC JIMY CANDY GROCERY INC 8317 3RD AVENUE BROOKLYN 11209- Yes JORDAN GOURMET DELI & GROCERY CORP JORDAN GOURMET DELI & GROCERY CORP 1129 MYRTLE AVENUE BROOKLYN 11206- Yes JUNCALITO ABAJO MEAT CORP JUNCALITO ABAJO MEAT CORP 1380 PENNSYLVANIA AVE BROOKLYN 11239- Yes JUNIOR 3 SMOKE SHOP & NEWSSTAND INC JUNIOR 3 SMOKE SHOP & NEWSSTAND INC 414 ROCKAWAY AVENUE BROOKLYN 11212- Yes KAHTAN EXPRESS GROCERY CORP KAHTAN EXPRESS GROCERY CORP 618 LIVONIA AVENUE BROOKLYN 11207- Yes KASSIM FAMILY FOOD CENTER INC KASSIM FAMILY FOOD CENTER INC 2226 SURF AVENUE BROOKLYN 11224- Yes KH MINI MART INC KH MINI MART INC 1214 REMSEN AVENUE BROOKLYN 11236- Yes KIMO FOOD CORP I KIMO FOOD CORP I 2582 LINDEN BLVD BROOKLYN 11208- Yes KINGS GOURMENT DELI & GROCERY INC KINGS GOURMENT DELI & GORCERY INC 1702 E 16TH STREET BROOKLYN 11228- Yes KISHETA DELI GROCERY INC KISHETA DELI GROCERY INC. 301 WYCKOFF AVENUE BROOKLYN 11237- Yes KNICKERBOCKER GOURMET AND DELI KNICKERBOCKER GOURMET AND DELI GROCE 309 KNICKERBOCKER AVE BROOKLYN 11237- Yes KY & AM GROCERY INC KY & AM GROCERY INC 5802 4TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11220- Yes

Page 18 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid L & K GREEN GARDEN, INC L & K GREEN GARDEN, INC 6002 5TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11220- Yes L G GOURMET DELI L G GOURMET DELI 301 FRANKLIN AVENUE BROOKLYN 11216- Yes L.G GROCERY AND CANDY CORP L.G GROCERY AND CANDY CORP 459 DEKALB AVENUE BROOKLYN 11205- Yes LA BEBA DELI GROCERY CORP/DORMANT LA BEBA DELI GROCERY CORP 1053 ROGERS AVENUE BROOKLYN 11226- Yes LA BODEGUITA INC LA BODEGUITA INC. 1397 MYRTLE AVENUE BROOKLYN 11237- Yes LA BODEGUITA INC LA BODEGUITA INC. 1397 MYRTLE AVENUE BROOKLYN 11237- Yes LA K PICA GROCERY CORP. LA K PICA GROCERY CORP. 272 JAMAICA AVENUE BROOKLYN 11207- Yes LLITTLE PAPA & SON FOOD CORP LLITTLE PAPA & SON FOOD CORP 853-5-7 CLARKSON AVE BROOKLYN 11203- Yes LORD OF KINGS INC LORD OF KINGS INC 9612 SEAVIEW AVENUE BROOKLYN 11236- Yes LORRAINE CANDY STORE CORP LORRAINE CANDY STORE CORP 52 LORRAINE STREET BROOKLYN 11231- Yes LUCKY 7 GOURMET DELI 2 INC LUCKY 7 GOURMET DELI 2 INC 400 BEDFORD AVENUE BROOKLYN 11211- Yes LUCKY 77 INC LUCKY 77 INC. 8220 13TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11228- Yes LUCKY LOTTO 1 DELI INC. LUCKY LOTTO 1 DELI INC. 1450 NOSTRAND AVENUE BROOKLYN 11226- Yes LUCKY LOTTO DELI CORP LUCKY LOTTO DELI CORP 694 ROCKAWAY AVENUE BROOKLYN 11212- Yes LUCKY LOTTO DELI CORP LUCKY LOTTO DELI CORP 694 ROCKAWAY AVENUE BROOKLYN 11212- Yes LUCKY STARS DELI INC LUCKY STARS DELI INC 1388 BUSHWICK AVENUE BROOKLYN 11207- Yes M & M CONVENIENCE DELI & GROCERY COR 1066 RUTHLAND ROAD BROOKLYN 11212- M & M MEAT AND PRODUCE II CORP M & M MEAT AND PRODUCE II CORP 760 4TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11232- Yes M&D MINI MARKET M&D MINI MARKET. 613 MARCY AVENUE BROOKLYN 11206- Yes MA GROCERY INC MA GROCERY INC 4706 AVENUE N BROOKLYN 11234- Yes MACORIS DELI GROCERY CORP MACORIS DELI GROCERY CORP 165 TOMPKINS AVENUE BROOKLYN 11206- Yes MACORIS DELI GROCERY CORP MACORIS DELI GROCERY CORP 165 TOMPKINS AVENUE BROOKLYN 11206- Yes MADINA FOOD CORP MADINA FOOD CORP MADINA ST JOHNS PLACE BROOKLYN 11213- Yes MALIK DAIRY INC MALIK DAIRY INC.. 379 ELTON STREET BROOKLYN 11208- Yes MARCY CAMERA & ELECTRONICS INC MARCY CAMERA & ELECTRONICS INC 276 BROADWAY STREET BROOKLYN 11211- Yes MARCY DELI CORP MARCY DELI CORP 34 NOSTRAND AVENUE BROOKLYN 11205- MARCY EXPRESS GROCERY CORP MARCY EXPRESS GROCERY CORP 529 MARCY AVENUE BROOKLYN 11206- Yes MARK T INC MARK T INC 4113 AVENUE U BROOKLYN 11234- Yes MART DELI & GRILL CORP MART DELI & GRILL CORP. 894 MYRTLE AVENUE BROOKLYN 11206- Yes MASH GOURMET DELI GROCERY CORP 225 KINGSTON AVENUE BROOKLYN 11213- MASTER OIL CORP MASTER OIL CORP 802 65TH STREET BROOKLYN 11220- Yes MAYAN CONVENIENCE CORP MAYAN CONVENIENCE CORP. 1207 49TH STREET BROOKLYN 11219- Yes MEAL TICKET FOODS INC MEAL TICKET FOODS INC 7402 15 AVENUE BROOKLYN 11228- Yes MEDWAY FOOD MART CORP MEDWAY FOOD MART CORP. 9502 AVENUE L BROOKLYN 11236- Yes METRO DELI OF NORTHSIDE CORP METRO DELI OF NORTHSIDE CORP 78 HAVEMEYER STREET BROOKLYN 11211- Yes MH DELI 2 CORP MH DELI 2 CORP 4502 NEW UTRECHT AVE. BROOKLYN 11219- Yes MH DELI 20 CORP MH DELI 20 CORP 6923 20TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11204- Yes MIKEY DELI & GROCERY INC MIKEY DELI & GROCERY INC 541 MARCY AVENUE BROOKLYN 11206- Yes MIKEY'S SMOKE SHOP MIKEY'S SMOKE SHOP 60 SCHERMERHORN ST BROOKLYN 11201- Yes MILL BASIN SMOKE SHOP INC MILL BASIN SMOKE SHOP INC 5602 AVENUE N BROOKLYN 11234- Yes

Page 19 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid MINI A & E CORP MINI A & E CORP 1229 BEDFORD AVENUE BROOKLYN 11216- Yes MINI MARKET GRAB AND GO INC. MINI MARKET GRAB AND GO INC. 440 MYRTLE AVENUE BROOKLYN 11205- Yes MINI MARKET TENARES CORP. MINI MARKET TENARES CORP. 1468 PROSPECT PLACE BROOKLYN 11213- Yes MOE'S FOOD CORP MOE'S FOOD CORP 3379 FULTON STREET BROOKLYN 11208- Yes MOE'S FOOD CORP MOE'S FOOD CORP 3379 FULTON STREET BROOKLYN 11208- Yes MONYAT DELI AND GROCERY INC MONYAT DELI AND GROCERY INC. 9801 AVENUE L BROOKLYN 11236- Yes MR. JOLLY DELI & GROCERY, INC. MR. JOLLY DELI & GROCERY, INC. 258 DEKALB AVENUE BROOKLYN 11205- Yes MR. SANDWICH 521B INC MR. SANDWICH 521B INC 521B MYRTLE AVENUE BROOKLYN 11205- MUCHO LOCO DELI & GROCERY MUCHO LOCO DELI & GROCERY 441 SUTTER AVENUE BROOKLYN 11212- Yes MUNCHIEZ DELI AND GROCERY INC MUNCHIEZ DELI AND GROCERY INC 167 LENOX ROAD BROOKLYN 11226- Yes MV QUICK STOP CORP. MV QUICK STOP CORP.. 2875 W. 8TH STREET BROOKLYN 11224- Yes MX MART MX MART 10 MALCOLM X BLVD BROOKLYN 11221- MY HABIBI DELI CORP MY HABIBI DELI CORP 296 WILLOUGHBY AVENUE BROOKLYN 11205- Yes N7MARKET, INC. N7MARKET, INC. 183 BEDFORD AVE BROOKLYN 11211- Yes NAGI MANSOOR ALI NAGI MANSOOR ALI. 2059 FULTON STREET BROOKLYN 11233- Yes NAPOLI MINI MARKET CORP NAPOLI MINI MARKET CORP 1536 MYRTLE AVENUE BROOKLYN 11237- Yes NASSER, MOHAMED J. NY GROCERY DELI 3323 CHURCH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11203- Yes NATURAL DELI TABACCO CORP NATURAL DELI TABACCO CORP. 1128 FULTON STREET BROOKLYN 11238- NATURAL DELI TABACCO CORP NATURAL DELI TABACCO CORP 1128 FULTON STREET BROOKLYN 11238- NEPTUNE STATIONERY CORP NEPTUNE STATIONERY CORP 3365 NEPTUNE AVENUE BROOKLYN 11224- Yes NEVINS DELI GROCERY INC NEVINS DELI GROCERY INC 26 NEVINS STREET BROOKLYN 11217- Yes NEW LOTS DELI INC NEW LOTS DELI INC. 41 NEW LOTS AVENUE BROOKLYN 11212- Yes NEW TOWN DELI & GROCERY INC NEW TOWN DELI & GROCERY INC 4323 AVENUE D BROOKLYN 11203- Yes NEW VANDERBILT DELI CORP NEW VANDERBILT DELI CORP 591 VANDERBILT AVENUE BROOKLYN 11238- Yes NEW WAY DELI, INC NEW WAY DELI, INC 721 HENRY STREET BROOKLYN 11231- NIMU GROCERY INC NIMU GROCERY INC 664 WASHINGTON AVE BROOKLYN 11238- NY DELI OF WILLIAMSBURG CORP NY DELI OF WILLIAMSBURG CORP 82 HAVEMEYER STREET BROOKLYN 11211- Yes OCEAN GROCERY & DELI OCEAN GROCERY & DELI. 631 GRAVESEND NECK RD BROOKLYN 11223- Yes ONESIMO S HEREDIA ONESIMO S HEREDIA 108 VAN SICLEN AVENUE BROOKLYN 11207- Yes OPTIMO CANDY & NEWSTAND INC OPTIMO CANDY & NEWSTAND INC. 15 HANSON PLACE BROOKLYN 11217- ORANGE TREE ORGANIC MARKET CORP ORANGE TREE ORGANIC MARKET CORP 121 GRAHAM AVENUE BROOKLYN 11206- Yes ORGANIC GIRL ON 3RD INC ORGANIC GIRL ON 3RD INC 9401 3RD AVENUE BROOKLYN 11209- Yes PARK AVE DISCOUNT CANDY &TOBACCO INC 123 PARK AVENUE BROOKLYN 11205- Yes PARK AVE DISCOUNT CANDY &TOBACCO INC 123 PARK AVENUE BROOKLYN 11205- Yes PARK BEER STORE INC PARK BEER STORE INC 302 9TH STREET BROOKLYN 11215- Yes PEREZ, MARIANO PEREZ, MARIANO 1990 BEDFORD AVENUE BROOKLYN 11225- Yes PITKIN MINI FOOD MART INC PITKIN MINI FOOD MART INC 1625 PITKIN AVENUE BROOKLYN 11212- Yes PLAZA MEAT MARKET CORP. PLAZA MEAT MARKET CORP. 100 COOPER STREET BROOKLYN 11207- Yes PROSPECT DELI AND GROCERY 1 CORP PROSPECT DELI AND GROCERY 1 CORP 492 FLATBUSH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11225- Yes QUDRAT U KHAN QUDRAT U KHAN. 5406 AVENUE N BROOKLYN 11234-

Page 20 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid QUEENS BIJOUX CORP QUEENS BIJOUX CORP 13854 84TH DRIVE BRIARWOOD 11435- Yes RABEAA FOOD CORP RABEAA FOOD CORP 890 ROCKAWAY AVENUE BROOKLYN 11212- Yes RAILNFOREST GROUP, LLC RAILNFOREST GROUP, LLC 7102 NEW UTRECHT AVENUE BROOKLYN 11228- Yes RAJ NEWS CORNER STORE INC RAJ NEWS CORNER STORE INC 1519 U AVENUE BROOKLYN 11229- RAJOURI INC RAJOURI INC 6824 4TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11220- Yes RAMOS GROCERY STORE RAMOS GROCERY STORE 940 UTICA AVENUE BROOKLYN 11203- RAY'S GROCERY RAY'S GROCERY 557 FLATBUSH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11225- Yes RED MOUNTAIN DELI GROCERY RED MOUNTAIN DELI GROCERY 645 SUTTER AVENUE BROOKLYN 11207- Yes REW DELI & GROCERY INC REW DELI & GROCERY INC 4421 NEW UTRECHT AVE BROOKLYN 11219- Yes REYES GROCERY REYES GROCERY 244 HIMROD STREET BROOKLYN 11237- Yes RIGHTWAY GROCERY NASHWAN N. SAID 485 NEW LOTS AVENUE BROOKLYN 11207- Yes RIMPLE INC RIMPLE INC 1940 FLATBUSH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11234- Yes RIO KOSHER LLC RIO KOSHER LLC 3715 14TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11218- RITE AID STORE #3498 RITE AID STORE #3498 1559 FLATBUSH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11210- Yes ROHAN DELI GROCERY CORP ROHAN DELI GROCERY CORP 810 BLAKE AVENUE BROOKLYN 11207- Yes ROSHAN'S DELI & GROCERY LLC ROSHAN'S DELI & GROCERY LLC 726 BROADWAY BROOKLYN 11206- Yes RUPSHA GROCERY RUPSHA GROCERY. 461 CONEY ISLAND AVE BROOKLYN 11218- Yes RUTLAND CANDY STORE CORP I RUTLAND CANDY STORE CORP I 987 RUTLAND ROAD BROOKLYN 11212- Yes S & F GAS LLC S & F GAS LLC 98 3RD AVENUE BROOKLYN 11217- Yes S & T SUPERMARKETS INC S & T SUPERMARKETS INC 424 SUTTER AVENUE BROOKLYN 11212- Yes S&A GROCERY & DELI CORP S&A GROCERY & DELI CORP 8742 25TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11214- Yes S.S.S. SUNFLOWER CORP S.S.S. SUNFLOWER CORP 2409 65 STREET BROOKLYN 11204- Yes SAKAMAN DELI & GRILL CORP SAKAMAN DELI & GRILL CORP 6821 4TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11220- Yes SALEH, YAHYA N SALEH, YAHYA N 806 FRANKLIN AVENUE BROOKLYN 11225- Yes SALIM SMOKE SHOP & LOTTERY CORP SALIM SMOKE SHOP & LOTTERY CORP 488 DEKALB AVENUE BROOKLYN 11205- SAM DELI GROCERY CORP 1 SAM DELI GROCERY CORP 1 1938 NORSTRAND AVENUE BROOKLYN 11210- SAMAH DELI AND GROCERY CORP SAMAH DELI AND GROCERY CORP. 1680 ROCKAWAY PARKWAY BROOKLYN 11236- Yes SAMMY'S DELI & GRILL CORP SAMMY'S DELI & GRILL CORP 1126 WESTCHESTER AVENUE BROOKLYN 10459- Yes SEHAM CANDY AND GROCERY CORP SEHAM CABDY AND GROCERY CORP 241 TROOP AVENUE BROOKLYN 11206- Yes SHAIDE GROCERY INC SHAIDE GROCERY INC 1325 FOSTER AVENUE BROOKLYN 11230- Yes SIMS PHARMA INC SIMS PHARMA INC 1711 PITKIN AVENUE BROOKLYN 11212- Yes SKYLINE DELI CORP. SKYLINE DELI CORP. 297 LEGION STREET BROOKLYN 11212- SKYLINE DELI CORP. SKYLINE DELI CORP. 297 LEGION STREET BROOKLYN 11212- SMART 1 DELI GROCERY CORP SMART 1 DELI GROCERY CORP 3325 SNYDER AVENUE BROOKLYN 11203- SQUARE PARK DELI GROCERY INC SQUARE PARK DELI GROCERY INC 1199 HALSEY STREET BROOKLYN 11207- Yes STAR DELI & GROCERY STAR DELI & GROCERY 943 BROADWAY BROOKLYN 11206- Yes STAR LITE DELI CORP STAR LITE DELI CORP 296 NEW LOTS AVENUE BROOKLYN 11207- STAR LITE DELI CORP STAR LITE DELI CORP 296 NEW LOTS AVENUE BROOKLYN 11207- Yes STARLIGHT SMOKE SHOP AND GROCERY INC STARLIGHT SMOKE SHOP AND GROCERY INC 364 CENTRAL AVENUE BROOKLYN 11221- Yes STAY FRESH DELI & GRILL CORP STAY FRESH DELI & GRILL CORP 1695A BROADWAY BROOKLYN 11207- Yes

Page 21 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid STERLING DELI & TOBACCO CORP STERLING DELI & TOBACCO CORP 216 UTICA AVENUE BROOKLYN 11213- Yes STERLING EXPRESS DELI INC STERLING EXPRESS DELI INC 1367 STERLING PLACE BROOKLYN 11213- Yes STEVE MEXICAN GROCERY INC STEVE MEXICAN GROCERY INC 423 STANHOPE STREET BROOKLYN 11237- Yes STOP ONE FOOD MART INC STOP ONE FOOD MART INC 173 WYCKOFF AVENUE BROOKLYN 11237- Yes SUA MARKET INC SUA MARKET INC 8702/04 5TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11209- Yes SULII FOOD CORP SULII FOOD CORP 301 MOTHER GASTON BLVD BROOKLYN 11212- Yes SUMNER DELI AND GROCERY INC SUMNER DELI AND GROCERY INC 874 BROADWAY BROOKLYN 11206- SUNNY D'S DISCOUNT CORP SUNNY D'S DISCOUNT CORP 211 AVENUE M BROOKLYN 11230- Yes SUNNY ON 18 INC SUNNY ON 18 INC 5818 18TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11204- Yes SUPER ECONOMIC ONE WAY SUPERMARKET C 104-21 GLENWOOD ROAD BROOKLYN 11236- Yes SURF NEIGHBOR GOURMET FOOD INC SURF NEIGHBOR GOURMET FOOD INC 2909 SURF AVENUE BROOKLYN 11224- Yes SUTTER COFFEE NEWS CORP SUTTER COFFEE NEWS CORP. 12A SUTTER AVENUE BROOKLYN 11212- SUTTER COFFEE NEWS CORP SUTTER COFFEE NEWS CORP 12A SUTTER AVENUE BROOKLYN 11212- T.A.G. DELI AND GROCERY INC T.A.G. DELI AND GROCERY INC 2336 BEDFORD AVENUE BROOKLYN 11226- Yes TANG'S AMBER MINI MARKET INC TANG'S AMBER MINI MARKET INC 868 UTICA AVENUE BROOKLYN 11203- Yes THE LATIN BROTHERS FOOD CORP THE LATIN BROTHERS FOOD CORP 1141 FULTON STREET BROOKLYN 11238- Yes THE NEW BROTHERS GROCERY INC THE NEW BROTHERS GROCERY INC 6125 5TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11220- Yes THE NEWS ROOM IN PARK SLOPE INC/DORMAN THE NEWS ROOM IN PARK SLOPE INC 168 7TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11215- Yes THE PLACE DELI & GROCERY INC THE PLACE DELI & GROCERY INC 636 ROGERS AVENUE BROOKLYN 11226- Yes THROOP FOOD MARKET CORP THROOP FOOD MARKET CORP. 664 GREEN AVENUE BROOKLYN 11221- TOP CONVENIENCE INC TOP CONVENIENCE INC 8527 3RD AVENUE BROOKLYN 11209- Yes UNIVERSAL GROCERIES INC. UNIVERSAL GROCERIES INC. 156 U AVENUE BROOKLYN 11223- Yes UNIVERSE ONE STOP SMOKE SHOP 1 INC. UNIVERSE ONE STOP SMOKE SHOP 1 INC 406 B FLATBUSH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11201- US SANDWICH INC US SANDWICH INC 1313 W. 6TH STREET BROOKLYN 11204- Yes UTICA DELI GROCERY CORP UTICA DELI GROCERY CORP 939 UTICA AVENUE BROOKLYN 11203- VAN DYKE DELI & GROCERY INC VAN DYKE DELI & GROCERY INC 361 SUTTER AVENUE BROOKLYN 11212- VICTORIA CONVEINIENT GROCERY INC VICTORIA CONVEINIENT GROCERY INC 300 WYCKOFF AVENUE BROOKLYN 11237- Yes VICTORIA CONVEINIENT GROCERY INC VICTORIA CONVEINIENT GROCERY INC. 300 WYCKOFF AVENUE BROOKLYN 11237- Yes VICTOR'S HALLMARK SHOP INC VICTOR'S HALLMARK SHOP INC 4 METROTECH CENTER BROOKLYN 11201- Yes W & F DELI GROCERY CORP W & F DELI GROCERY CORP, STORE #2 392 NEPTUNE AVENUE BROOKLYN 11235- Yes W & F DELI GROCERY CORP W & F DELI GROCERY CORP, STORE #2 392 NEPTUNE AVENUE BROOKLYN 11235- WALGREEN EASTERN CO INC WALGREEN EASTERN CO INC 1409 J AVENUE BROOKLYN 11230- Yes WALGREENS #04362 WALGREENS #04362 520 ATLANTIC AVENUE BROOKLYN 11217- Yes WALGREENS #11268 WALGREENS #11268 7002 13TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11228- Yes WALGREENS #12080 WALGREENS #12080 285 KINGS HIGHWAY BROOKLYN 11223- Yes WARSAW DELI & GROCERY CORP WARSAW DELI & GROCERY CORP.. 146 A NASSAU AVENUE BROOKLYN 11222- Yes WAVERLY CONVENIENCE CORP WAVERLY CONVENIENCE CORP 349B WAVERLY AVENUE BROOKLYN 11238- Yes WEST DELI INC WEST DELI INC 2902 W. 19TH STREET BROOKLYN 11224- Yes WOLCOTT DELI GROCERY INC WOLCOTT DELI GROCERY INC 51 WOLCOTT STREET BROOKLYN 11231- XING HENG GROCERY INC XING HENG GROCERY INC 4505 8TH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11220- Yes

Page 22 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid XYZ DELI GROCERY CORP XYZ DELI GROCERY CORP 309 SARATOGA AVENUE BROOKLYN 11233- Yes YASSER SALEH JOBAH YASSER SALEH JOBAH. 362 KNICKERBOCKER AVE BROOKLYN 11237- Yes YUN TAI INC YUN TAI INC 4104 AVENUE A BROOKLYN 11203- Yes Z & H GARDEN DELI CORP Z & H GARDEN DELI CORP. 492 FLATBUSH AVENUE BROOKLYN 11225- Yes ZAIDA GROCERY STORE ZAIDA GROCERY STORE 635 WATKINS STREET BROOKLYN 11212- ZAK 89 DELI GROCERY CORP ZAK 89 DELI GROCERY CORP 97 BELMONT AVENUE BROOKLYN 11212- LEWIS

STEWART'S #372 STEWART'S RT 12 & CHERRY LYONS FALLS 13368- Yes MADISON

KINNEY DRUGS #67 KINNEY DRUGS 41 ALBANY STREET CAZENOVIA 13035- Yes MONROE

999 MARKET 999 MARKET 709 CLINTON AVENUE ROCHESTER 14620- Yes CULBERPAK GAS & CONVENIENCE CULVERPAK GAS & CONVENIENCE 645 CULVER ROAD ROCHESTER 14609- Yes EZ IN MARKET EZ-IN MARKET 587 MAPLE STREET ROCHESTER 14611- FINE CITY GROCERY FINE CITY GROCERY 255 JAY STREET ROCHESTER 14608- Yes GATES EXPRESS INC GATES EXPRESS INC. 2206 BUFFALO ROAD ROCHESTER 14624- Yes GLIDE FOOD MARKET GLIDE FOOD MARKET 192 GLIDE STREET ROCHESTER 14611- Yes HESS EXPRESS #32351 HESS EXPRESS 1151 BUFFALO ROAD ROCHESTER 14624- Yes HNU CONVENIENCE HNU CONVENIENCE 1416 CULVER ROAD ROCHESTER 14609- Yes HUDSON NEWS - BAGGAGE AREA HUDSON NEWS 1200 BROOKS AVENUE ROCHESTER 14624- HUDSON NEWS - CONCOURSE A HUDSON NEWS 1200 BROOKS AVENUE ROCHESTER 12624- HUDSON-TITUS SERVICE HUDSON-TITUS SERVICE 2291 HUDSON AVENUE ROCHESTER 14617- Yes JIMS STOP N SHOP JIM'S STOP N SHOP 872 JAY STREET ROCHESTER 14611- Yes KING FOOD MART KING FOOD MART 1144 JOSEPH AVENUE ROCHESTER 14621- Yes KWIK FILL M0078 KWIK FILL 85 STONEWOOD AVENUE ROCHESTER 14612- Yes KWIK FILL M0137 KWIK FILL 82 MAIN STREET BROCKPORT 14420- Yes LIBERTY POLEWAY MARKET LIBERTY POLEWAY MARKET 133 LIBERTY POLE WAY ROCHESTER 14604- Yes LOS PRIMOS DELI LOS PRIMOS DELI 95 CENTRAL PARK ROCHESTER 14605- Yes LYELL AVENUE SMOKE SHOP LYELL AVENUE SMOKE SHOP 455 LYELL AVENUE ROCHESTER 14606- Yes MT. HOPE CONVENIENCE MART MT. HOPE CONVENIENCE MART 404 MOUNT HOPE AVENUE ROCHESTER 14620- Yes NORTH GROCERY STORE NORTH GROCERY STORE 1456 NORTH STREET ROCHESTER 14621- Yes OUTER VAPES OUTER VAPES 3240 CHILI AVENUE ROCHESTER 14624- Yes PERFECTION VAPES PERFECTION VAPES 2032 LYELL AVENUE ROCHESTER 14606- Yes S.D. MINI MART S.D. MINI MART 3910 LAKE AVENUE ROCHESTER 14612- Yes SANTIAGO CIGAR FACTORY SANTIAGO CIGAR FACTORY 335 EAST AVENUE ROCHESTER 14604- Yes SHORT SHOP MINI MART SHORT SHOP MINI MART 216 MAIN STREET ROCHESTER 14604- Yes

Page 23 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid THURSTON VILLAGE MARKET THURSTON VILLAGE MARKET 348 THURSTON ROAD ROCHESTER 14619- Yes WESTSIDE SMOKE SHOP #1 WESTSIDE SMOKE SHOP #1 1105 LYELL AVENUE ROCHESTER 14606- Yes NASSAU

7-ELEVEN #11153B 7-ELEVEN 294 GUY LOMBARDO FREEPORT 11520- 7-ELEVEN #11159 7-ELEVEN 80 BROOKLYN AVENUE FREEPORT 11520- 7-ELEVEN #11159 7-ELEVEN 80 BROOKLYN AVENUE FREEPORT 11520- Yes 7-ELEVEN #24568 7-ELEVEN 1571 HEMPSTEAD TURNPIKE ELMONT 11003- 7-ELEVEN #39654A 7-ELEVEN 820 HEMPSTEAD AVENUE WEST HEMPSTEAD 11552- ADAMZ DELI ADAMZ DELI CORP. 369 BABYLON TURNPIKE ROOSEVELT 11572- BEACH BAGEL & DELI A.S.V.P INC. 1090 BEECH STREET LONG BEACH 11561- Yes BELLMORE DAIRY BARN BELLMORE DAIRY BARN 1799 BELLMORE AVENUE NORT BELLMORE 11710- BOUGATFA CONVENIENCE FAMILY GOURMET 292 MAIN STREET FREEPORT 11520- BOUGATFA CONVENIENCE BOUGATFA CORP. 292 MAIN STREET FREEPORT 11520- BP CARMAN DEVELOPMENT CORP. 865 CARMAN AVENUE WESTBURY 11590- BP #2148062 WILLIS AVENUE REPAIR & SERVICE 944 WILLIS AVENUE ALBERTSON 11507-1929 BROTHERS DELI & CATERING SARA MARKET CORP 345 HEMPSTEAD TURNPIKE WEST HEMPSTEAD 11552- Yes CANDYLAND I&M CANDYLAND, INC 1 SUNRISE MALL MASSAPEQUA 11758- Yes CENTRAL AVENUE GOURMET DELI BAGELS & CENTRAL AVENUE GOURMET DELI 514 CENTRAL AVENUE BETHPAGE 11714- CUMBERLAND FARMS #1670 CUMBERLAND FARMS 1610 ROUND SWAMP ROAD PLAINVIEW 11803- CVS PHARMACY #00407 CVS ALBANY INC 598 MERRICK ROAD ROCKVILLE CENTRE 11570- CVS PHARMACY #00510 CVS ALBANY INC. 840 FRANKLIN AVENUE GARDEN CITY 11530- Yes CVS PHARMACY #01229 CVS ALBANY CORP 151 PINE HOLLOW ROAD OYSTER BAY 11771- Yes CVS PHARMACY #01235 CVS ALBANY CORP 1829 GRAND AVENUE BALDWIN 11510- Yes CVS PHARMACY 5368 CVS ALBANY CORP 1220 PENINSULA BLVD HEWLETT 11557- Yes GARDEN CAFÉ 2001 RESTAURANT CORP. 2001 MARCUS AVENUE NEW HYDE PARK 11042- Yes GARDEN CITY GIFT SHOP JVP GARDEN CITY INC. 45 SEVENTH STREET GARDEN CITY 11530- GLOBAL GAS A & G MINI MART INC 530 FRANKLIN AVENUE FRANKLIN SQUARE 11010- GRACEFUL NOTIONS JYOT LLC 260 ROCKAWAY PARKWAY VALLEY STREAM 11580- Yes GULF PLANDOME GULF LLC 546 PLANDOME ROAD MANHASSET 11030- GULF LENTON CORP. 119 POWERHOUSE ROAD ROSLYN HEIGHTS 11577- HESS #32548 HESS MART INC. 4165 HEMPSTEAD TURNPIKE BETHPAGE 11714- HICKSVILLE 5 & 10 HICKSVILLE FIVE & TEN INC, 341 JERUSALEM AVENUE HICKSVILLE 11801- KEVIN & MELODY DISCOUNT KEVIN & MELODY DISCOUNT CORP. 489 MIDDLE NECK ROAD GREAT NECK 11023- LIGHTHOUSE DAIRY MART LIGHTHOUSE DAIRY MART 2257 WANTAGH AVENUE WANTAGH 11793- M & S CARDS & GIFT M & S CARDS & GIFTS INC. 314 CENTRAL AVENUE LAWRENCE 11559- Yes MANOR FRUIT SHACK JDRR CORP 156 COVERT AVENUE STEWART MANOR 11530- Yes MANOR FRUIT SHACK JDRR CORP 156 COVERT AVENUE STEWART MANOR 11530- Yes MARTY'S PARTY MARTYS PARTY INC. 265 PINE HOLLOW ROAD OYSTER BAY 11771- Yes MILK N THINGS VILMA ENTERPRISES INC 1181 WILLIS AVENUE ALBERTSON 11507-1200

Page 24 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid MILK STOP GO BARN INC. 3370 LONG BEACH ROAD OCEANSIDE 11572- MOBIL V.S. GAS STATION 2200 HILLSIDE AVENUE NEW HYDE PARK 11040- Yes MOBIL GARDEN CITY TIRE & AUTOMOTIVE CENTER IN 117 FRANKLIN AVENUE GARDEN CITY 11530- Yes MY NEIGHBORHOOD DELI MY NEIGHBORHOOD DELI 455 ATLANTIC AVENUE EAST ROCKAWAY 11518- NEWSSTAND FREEPORT NEWS PLUS INC. 108 FREEPORT PLAZA EAST FREEPORT 11520- NEWSSTAND IN LIRR STATION TIP TOP NEWSSTAND 66 MAIN STREET PORT WASHINGTON 11502- ONE STOP SMOKE SHOP & CONVENIENCE STOR ONE STOP SMOKE SHOP & CONVENIENCE STOR 985 ATLANTIC AVENUE BALDWIN 11510- Yes OYSTER BAY GENERAL STORE OYSTER BAY GENERAL STORE 30 AUDREY AVENUE OYSTER BAY 11771- PATHMARK #652 PATHMARK STORES INC. 941 CARMANS ROAD MASSAPEQUA 11758- QUICK STOP (SMOKE SHOP) AASHAPURA ENTERPRISES INC. 2741A JERUSALEM AVENUE NORTH BELLMORE 11710- Yes SHELL ROSLYN SHELL INC. 220 MINEOLA AVENUE ROSLYN HEIGHTS 11577- SHELL NSK & SONS INC. 99 SHORE ROAD PORT WASHINGTON 11050- SHELL STATION #417422 NSK & SONS INC. 99 SHORE ROAD PORT WASHINGTON 11050- Yes STOP & SHOP #0569 THE STOP & SHOP STORES INC. 275 PINE HOLLOW ROAD OYSTER BAY 11771- Yes SUNOCO BOLLA OPERATING INC. 274 BROADWAY HICKSVILLE 11801- Yes SUNOCO J & C CANDY INC. 606 WANTAGH AVENUE LEVITTOWN 11756- Yes ULTRA 4030 GAS CORP. 4030 MERRICK ROAD SEAFORD 11783- US PETROLEUM US PETROLEUM 131 MERRICK ROAD FREEPORT 11520- USA QUICK STOP 1587 HEMPSTEAD TURNPIKE ELMONT 11003- WALGREEN'S #04116 WALGREEN'S EASTERN CORP. 4120 HEMPSTEAD TURNPIKE BETHPAGE 11714- WALGREENS #09110 WALGREENS EAST CORP 2474 HEMPSTEAD TPK EAST MEADOW 11554- WALGREENS #10278 WALGREEN EAST CORP. 606 LONG BEACH BLVD LONG BEACH 11561- Yes WALGREENS #15118 WALGREEN'S EASTERN CORP.. 603 UNIONDALE AVENUE UNIONDALE 11553- WAL-MART #2583 WAL-MART 1123 JERUSALEM AVENUE UNIONDALE 11553- WATERVIEW CARDS & GIFTS JMDC STATIONERY 200 OLD COUNTRY ROAD MINEOLA 11501- Yes NEW YORK

101 MORONTA FOOD CORP 101 MORONTA FOOD CORP 101 DYCKMAN STREET NEW YORK 10040- Yes 106 FAMILY DELI & GROCERY INC 106 FAMILY DELI & GROCERY INC 318 EAST 106TH STREET NEW YORK 10029- Yes 111 WEST 45TH ST 111 WEST 45TH ST 109 WEST 45TH STREET NEW YORK 10036- Yes 12 EAST FF CORP 12 EAST FF CORP. 941 8TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10019- Yes 12 ST ONE STOP INC 12 ST ONE STOP INC 101 UNIVERSITY PLACE NEW YORK 10003- Yes 121 CONVENIENCE DELI CORP 121 CONVENIENCE DELI CORP 121 WEST 116TH STREET NEW YORK 10026- Yes 124 DELI GROCERY INC 124 DELI GROCERY INC. 124 EAST BROADWAY NEW YORK 10002- Yes 129 LENOX DELI GROCERY INC 129 LENOX DELI GROCERY INC. 370 LENOX AVENUE NEW YORK 10027- 132 DELI & GROCERY CORP 132 DELI & GROCERY CORP 2240 7TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10027- Yes 1408 GOURMET DELI CORP 1408 GOURMET DELI CORP 1408 SAINT NICHOLAS AVE NEW YORK 10033- Yes 145 CANDY GROCERY CORP 145 CANDY GROCERY CORP 104 WEST 145TH STREET NEW YORK 10039- 145 CANDY GROCERY CORP 145 CANDY GROCERY CORP 104 WEST 145TH STREET NEW YORK 10039- 145 DELI & GROCERY INC 145 DELI & GROCERY INC 1717 AMSTERDAM AVE NEW YORK 10031- Yes

Page 25 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid 149TH FINEST DELI INC 149TH FINEST DELI INC 3620 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10031- Yes 14TH ST FOOD MARKET, INC 14TH ST FOOD MARKET, INC 67 WEST 14TH STREET NEW YORK 10011- Yes 153 FOOD CENTER INC 153 FOOD CENTER INC. 2866 8TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10039- Yes 1663 MADISON AVENUE 1663 MADISON AVENUE 1663 MADISON AVENUE NEW YORK 10029- Yes 17 FOOD MARKET INC 17 FOOD MARKET INC 116 7TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10011- Yes 171 MADISON AVENUE RETAIL INC 171 MADISON AVENUE RETAIL INC 171 MADISON AVENUE NEW YORK 10016- Yes 184 AUDUBON GROCERY INC 184 AUDUBON GROCERY INC 184 AUDUBON AVE NEW YORK 10033- 1944 FIRST AVENUE DELI CO LLC 1944 FIRST AVENUE DELI CO LLC 1944 1ST AVENUE NEW YORK 10029- Yes 2027 TOBACCO AND GROCERY CORP 2027 TOBACCO AND GROCERY CORP 2027 LEXINGTON AVENUE NEW YORK 10035- 202ND ST. DELI GROCERY CORP 202ND ST. DELI GROCERY CORP 3769 10TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10034- Yes 2058 DELI & GROCERY CORP 2058 DELI & GROCERY CORP 2058 LEXINGTON AVENUE NEW YORK 10035- 2058 DELI & GROCERY CORP 2058 DELI & GROCERY CORP 2058 LEXINGTON AVENUE NEW YORK 10035- 2058 DELI & GROCERY CORP 2058 DELI & GROCERY CORP 2058 LEXINGTON AVENUE NEW YORK 10035- 207 INC I 207 INC 4930A BROADWAY NEW YORK 10034- Yes 2082 MADISON FOOD CORP 2082 MADISON FOOD CORP 2082 MADISON AVENUE NEW YORK 10037- Yes 2096 FULTON DELI GROCERY INC 2096 FULTON DELI GROCERY INC. 2096 FULTON STREET NEW YORK 11233- Yes 2137 FRUITS & PRODUCTS INC 2137 FRUITS & PRODUCTS INC. 2137 2ND AVENUE NEW YORK 10029- 216 SAL DELI & GROCERY CORP 216 SAL DELI & GROCERY CORP 216 B AVENUE NEW YORK 10009- Yes 2618 GROCERY CORP 2618 GROCERY CORP 2618 BROADWAY STREET NEW YORK 10025- Yes 2732 CONVENIENCE GROCERY CORP 2732 CONVENIENCE GROCERY CORP 2732 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10025- Yes 282 AMERICAN DELI CORP 282 AMERICAN DELI CORP 282 LENOX AVENUE NEW YORK 10027- Yes 282 AMERICAN DELI CORP 282 AMERICAN DELI CORP 282 LENOX AVENUE NEW YORK 10027- Yes 288 SAMS DELI INC 288 SAMS DELI INC 288 AVENUE U NEW YORK 11223- Yes 28TH SMOKE & ACCESSSORIES LLC 28TH SMOKE & ACCESSSORIES LLC 221 WEST 28 STREET NEW YORK 10001- Yes 327 GOURMET DELI CORP 327 GOURMET DELI CORP 327 1ST AVENUE NEW YORK 10003- Yes 395 THIRD AVENUE RETAIL LLC 395 THIRD AVENUE RETAIL LLC 395 3RD AVENUE NEW YORK 10016- Yes 461 7TH AVE MARKET INC 461 7TH AVE MARKET INC. 461 7TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10001- Yes 466 DELI GROCERY CORP 466 DELI GROCERY CORP 466 WEST 151 STREET NEW YORK 10031- Yes 466 DELI GROCERY CORP 466 DELI GROCERY CORP 466 WEST 151 STREET NEW YORK 10031- Yes 47 PITT GROCERY INC 47 PITT GROCERY INC 47 PITT STREET NEW YORK 10002- Yes 5 BROTHERS 0F 47TH FOOD CORP 5 BROTHERS 0F 47TH FOOD CORP. 689 10TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10035- Yes 510 GROCERY CORP 510 GROCERY CORP 510 WEST 218TH STREET NEW YORK 10034- Yes 527 CONVENIENT STORE INC 527 CONVENIENT STORE INC 527A MALCOLM X BLVD NEW YORK 10037- Yes 528 EAST ELEVEN DELI CORP 528 EAST ELEVEN DELI CORP 528 EAST 11TH STREET NEW YORK 10009- Yes 537 GOURMET DELI INC 537 GOURMET DELI INC. 537 MALCOLM X BLVD NEW YORK 10037- 602 WEST 137 DELI CORP 602 WEST 137 DELI CORP 3377 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10031- Yes 639 USA DELI & GROCERY CORP 639 USA DELI & GROCERY CORP 639 MALCOLM X BLVD NEW YORK 10039- Yes 7 ELEVEN INC 7 ELEVEN INC. 300 EAST 96TH STREET NEW YORK 10128- 7 ELEVEN INC 7 ELEVEN INC. 111 JOHN STREET NEW YORK 10038- Yes 7 ELEVEN STORE 35670H 7 ELEVEN STORE 35670H 1683 1ST AVENUE NEW YORK 10128- Yes

Page 26 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid 710 FRANKLIN AVE CORP 710 FRANKLIN AVE CORP 333 EAST 23RD STREET NEW YORK 10010- Yes 7-ELEVEN INC 7-ELEVEN INC. 302 8TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10001- Yes 7-ELEVEN INC STORE #34917H 7-ELEVEN INC STORE #34917H. 1412 1ST AVENUE NEW YORK 10021- Yes 7-ELEVEN, INC. 7-ELEVEN, INC. 246 WEST 23RD STREET NEW YORK 10011- Yes 80 PINE NEWSSTAND LLC 80 PINE NEWSSTAND LLC 80 PINE STREET NEW YORK 10005- Yes 85 AUBUBON GROCERY STOP I INC 85 AUBUBON GROCERY STOP I INC 85 AUDUBON AVENUE NEW YORK 10032- 94 ST NICHOLAS DELI INC 94 ST NICHOLAS DELI INC 94 ST NICHOLAS PLACE NEW YORK 10032- Yes A H BROADWAY GROCERY CORP A H BROADWAY GROCERY CORP 3770 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10032- Yes A TO Z ON 8TH INC A TO Z ON 8TH INC 711 8TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10036- AA 2100 DELI GROCERY CORP AA 2100 DELI GROCERY CORP 2100 2ND AVENUE NEW YORK 10029- Yes ABG STANDARD OPERATION LLC ABG STANDARD OPERATION LLC. 848 WASHINGTON STREET NEW YORK 10014- Yes AK FAMILY DELI & GROCERY INC AK FAMILY DELI & GROCERY INC 9719 101 ALLEY NEW YORK 11416- Yes AK GOURMET MARKET CORP AK GOURMET MARKET CORP 201 MADISON STREET NEW YORK 10016- AKSHAR 61 INC AKSHAR 61 INC 61 1ST AVENUE NEW YORK 10003- Yes AL MUKHTAR DELI GROCERY CORP AL MUKHTAR DELI GROCERY CORP 2026 LEXINGTON AVENUE MANHATTAN 10035- Yes ALI, YOUSUF S ALI, YOUSUF S 2010 LEXINGTON AVENUE NEW YORK 10035- ALI, YOUSUF S ALI, YOUSUF S. 2010 LEXINGTON AVENUE NEW YORK 10035- ALKA A PATEL ALKA A PATEL N/W/C GREENWICH & BARCLAY ST NEW YORK 10007- Yes ALL FRESH GROCERY & DELI CORP ALL FRESH GROCERY & DELI CORP 334 E 106 STREET NEW YORK 10029- Yes ALYSHIA ALEEM COFFEE SHOP ALYSHIA ALEEM COFFEE SHOP 46 W 21ST STREET NEW YORK 10010- Yes AMERICAN GOURMET AND DELI CORP AMERICAN GOURMET AND DELI CORP 108 E. 126TH STREET NEW YORK 10035- Yes AMERICAN MEAT MARKET AND GROCERY 2051 8 AVENUE NEW YORK 10026- Yes AMIR CONVENIENCE INC AMIR CONVENIENCE INC 2802 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10025- Yes AMSTERDAM CANDY CORP AMSTERDAM CANDY CORP 2038 AMSTERDAM AVENUE NEW YORK 10032- Yes ANAN GOURMET DELI CORP ANAN GOURMET DELI CORP 2391 FREDERICK DOUGLASS BLVD NEW YORK 10027- Yes APOLLO DELI & FRUIT CORP APOLLO DELI & FRUIT CORP 2350 FREDERICK DOUGLASS BLVD NEW YORK 10027- Yes ASHAARY GROCERY CORP ASHAARY GROCERY CORP/DORMANT 132 E. 125TH STREET NEW YORK 10035- Yes ASSOCIATE CONVENIENCE & DELI INC ASSOCIATE CONVENIENCE & DELI INC 108 THAYER STREET NEW YORK 10040- ASSOCIATE CONVENIENCE & DELI INC ASSOCIATE CONVENIENCE & DELI INC. 108 THAYER STREET NEW YORK 10040- AVE D KING DELI CORP AVE D KING DELI CORP 11 AVENUE D NEW YORK 10009- AWDI FOOD CORP AWDI FOOD CORP. 501 W 133 STREET NEW YORK 10027- Yes AZEEZ 2 DELI GROCERY CORP AZEEZ 2 DELI GROCERY CORP 3895 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10032- Yes B&W FOOD MARKET CORP B&W FOOD MARKET CORP. 449 W 206TH STREET NEW YORK 10034- Yes BEN'S DELI BEN'S DELI 32 AVENUE B NEW YORK 10009- Yes BESTWAY DELI GROCERY CORP. BESTWAY DELI GROCERY CORP. 619 LENOX AVENUE NEW YORK 10037- Yes BESTWAY DELI GROCERY CORP. BESTWAY DELI GROCERY CORP. 619 LENOX AVENUE NEW YORK 10037- Yes BHAKTI 838 INC BHAKTI 838 INC 838 LEXINGTON AVENUE NEW YORK 10065- Yes BHUIYA GROCERY CORP. BHUIYA GROCERY CORP.. 179 CHURCH STREET NEW YORK 10007- BHUIYA GROCERY CORP. BHUIYA GROCERY CORP.. 179 CHURCH STREET NEW YORK 10007- Yes BHUIYA, NAZRUL ZAMAN & CO 1568 3RD AVENUE NEW YORK 10128- Yes

Page 27 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid BRIDGES, SHEILA BRIDGES, SHEILA NORTHEAST 1 AVENUE MANHATTAN 10004- Yes BROADVIEW GOURMET DELI INC. BROADVIEW GOURMET DELI INC. 3478 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10031- BURGOS, JUAN R 129 POST GROCERY STORE 129 POST AVENUE NEW YORK 10034- Yes C&B CANDY GROCERY INC C&B CANDY GROCERY INC 248 EAST 14TH STREET NEW YORK 10003- CABRAL, CARLOS NUEVA GENERACION GROCERY. 238 SHERMAN AVENUE NEW YORK 10034- Yes CAMILA FOOD CENTER CORP CAMILA FOOD CENTER CORP 616 WEST 207TH STREET NEW YORK 10034- Yes CAMILA FOOD CENTER CORP CAMILA FOOD CENTER CORP 616 WEST 207TH STREET NEW YORK 10034- Yes CANDY AND GROCERY CORP CANDY AND GROCERY CORP 122 EAST 116TH STREET NEW YORK 10029- CASA BLANCA GOURMET FOODS INC CASA BLANCA GOURMET FOODS INC. 2 WEST 125TH STREET NEW YORK 10027- CHARLIE DELI GROCERY INC CHARLIE DELI GROCERY INC 1795 AMSTERDAM AVE MANHATTAN 10031- CHUBBY HUBBY DELI CORP CHUBBY HUBBY DELI CORP 3350 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10031- Yes CIGARVILLE INC CIGARVILLE INC 51 WEST 14TH STREET NEW YORK 10011- Yes CKK4328 CORP CKK4328 CORP 43 EAST 28TH STREET NEW YORK 10016- Yes CLOISTERS DELI INC CLOISTERS DELI INC 7 HENSHAW STREET NEW YORK 10034- Yes CLORO CIGARS CORP CLORO CIGARS CORP 4028 10TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10034- Yes CROWN GROCERY/ CROWN GROCERY 2215 7TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10024- CVS CVS ALBANY LLC. 338 EAST 23RD STREET NEW YORK 10010- Yes CVS CVS ALBANY LLC. 338 EAST 23RD STREET NEW YORK 10010- Yes CVS #2671 CVS PHARMACY 750 AVENUE OF AMERICA NEW YORK 10010- Yes CVS ALBANY LLC CVS ALBANY LLC 300 PARK AVENUE SOUTH NEW YORK 10010- Yes CVS PHARMACY CVS PHARMACY #2940 500 W 42ND STREET NEW YORK 10036- Yes CVS PHARMACY CVS ALBANY LLC. 420 5TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10118- Yes CVS#2671 CVS PHARMACY 750 AVENUE OF AMERICA NEW YORK 10010- Yes CVS/ #2400 CVS/ #2400 1223 2ND AVENUE NEW YORK 10021- Yes D & A EXPRESS CANDY GROCERY CORP D & A EXPRESS CANDY GROCERY CORP 1633 LEXINGTON AVENUE NEW YORK 10029- D CONVENIENT STORE INC D CONVENIENT STORE INC. 67 AVENUE D NEW YORK 10009- Yes D STOP DELI & GROCERY INC D STOP DELI & GROCERY INC 67 AVENUE D AVENUE MANHATTAN 10009- Yes DAR ALWADI TOBACCO & GROCERY INC DAR ALWADI TOBACCO & GROCERY INC 2027 LEXINGTON AVENUE NEW YORK 10035- DAR ALWADI TOBACCO & GROCERY INC DAR ALWADI TOBACCO & GROCERY INC 2027 LEXINGTON AVENUE NEW YORK 10035- Yes DAS, SUKANTA DAS, SUKANTA 401 WEST 42ND STREET NEW YORK 10036- Yes DAVIDOFF OF GENEVA INC DAVIDOFF OF GENEVA INC. 515 MADISON AVE AVE MANHATTAN 10022- Yes DBA SAAD NEWSSTAND NUR MOHAMMAD ALI S/E/C 8TH AVE & W 30 ST AVE NEW YORK 10001- Yes DELICIOUS GOURMET DELI INC DELICIOUS GOURMET DELI INC 154 E 112TH STREET NEW YORK 10029- Yes DELICIOUS MARKET INC DELICIOUS MARKET INC. 20 EAST 16TH STREET NEW YORK 10003- Yes DESAI, INDUBEN K. DESAI, INDUBEN K. N/W/C HANOVER SQUARE NEW YORK 10005- Yes DIVA DELI GRTOCERY CORP DIVA DELI GRTOCERY CORP 16 EAST 116TH STREET NEW YORK 10029- Yes DOMINGO'S GROCERY DOMINGO'S GROCERY 2591 8TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10030- Yes DUANE READ DUANE READ 4 PARK AVENUE NEW YORK 10016- DUANE READE DUANE READE 585 2ND AVENUE NEW YORK 10016- Yes DUANE READE DUANE READE 1675 3RD AVENUE NEW YORK 10128- Yes

Page 28 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid DUANE READE DUANE READE 1370 6 AVENUE NEW YORK 10019- Yes DUANE READE DUANE READE 769 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10003- Yes DUANE READE DUANE READE 575 LEXINGTON AVENUE NEW YORK 10022- Yes DUANE READE DUANE READE 625 8TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10018- Yes DUANE READE DUANE READE 3387 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10031- Yes DUANE READE DUANE READE 135 EAST 125 STREET NEW YORK 10035- Yes DUANE READE DUANE READE 322 8 AVENUE NEW YORK 10001- DUANE READE DUANE READE 575 LEXINGTON AVENUE NEW YORK 10022- Yes DUANE READE ETAL PTRS DUANE READE ETAL PTRS 46 3RD AVENUE NEW YORK 10003- Yes DUANE READE ETAL PTRS #422 DUANE READE 385 3RD AVENUE NEW YORK 10016- Yes DUANE READE INC DUANE READE INC 305 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10007- Yes DUANE READE INC DUANE READE INC 51 WEST 51ST STREET NEW YORK 10019- Yes DUANE READE PTRS DUANE READE PTRS. 17 JOHN ST. - STORE 2 NEW YORK 10038- Yes DURANE READE ETAL PTRS DURANE READE ETAL PTRS 161 EAST 23RD STREET NEW YORK 10010- Yes DVD PLACE INC DVD PLACE INC 412 8TH AVENUE MANHATTAN 10001- Yes E. HARLEM DELI CORP E. HARLEM DELI CORP 2249 2ND AVENUE NEW YORK 10029- Yes EAST 124 DELI GROCERY INC EAST 124 DELI GROCERY INC. 1933 MADISION AVENUE NEW YORK 10035- Yes EAST N WEST DELI GROCERY CORP EAST N WEST DELI GROCERY CORP 501 W 145TH STREET NEW YORK 10031- Yes EAST VILLAGE FRUIT & VEGETABLE CORP 229 B AVENUE NEW YORK 10009- Yes EAST VILLAGE GROCERY & SMOKE SHOP IN EAST VILLAGE GROCERY & SMOKE SHOP IN 177 1ST AVENUE NEW YORK 10003- EAST WEST GROCERY INC EAST WEST GROCERY INC 532 9TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10018- EASTSIDE GROCERY EASTSIDE GROCERY 1726 1 AVENUE NEW YORK 10128- EIGHT AVE FOOD I CORP EIGHT AVE FOOD I CORP 374 8TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10001- EL AMARILLO DELI GROCERY CORP EL AMARILLO DELI GROCERY CORP 3569 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10031- Yes EMMERSON GOURMET CORP EMMERSON GOURMET CORP 1810 3RD AVENUE NEW YORK 10029- Yes ESAYI CORPORATION ESAYI CORPORATION 2461 ADAM CLAYTON POWELL BLVD NEW YORK 10030- Yes ESSENTIAL PLUS ESSENTIAL PLUS 2259 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10024- Yes EZ CONVENICE MART INC EZ CONVENICE MART INC 109 WEST 27TH STREET NEW YORK 10001- Yes FADAH, A ABDO FADAH, A ABDO 1876 LEXINGTON AVENUE NEW YORK 10035- FADAH, A ABDO FADAH, A ABDO 1876 LEXINGTON AVENUE NEW YORK 10035- FAMILY COMMUNITY DELI & LUNCHEONETTE FAMILY COMMUNITY DELI & LUNCHEONETTE 41 ST NICHOLAS TERRACE MANHATTAN 10027- Yes FIFTH AVENUE DELI INC FIFTH AVENUE DELI INC 554 5TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10036- Yes FIKRI DELI GROCERY CORP FIKRI DELI GROCERY CORP 3787A BROADWAY NEW YORK 10032- Yes FIRST ORGANIC FOOD CENTER CORP FIRST ORGANIC FOOD CENTER CORP 1869 LEXINGTON AVENUE NEW YORK 10029- FIVE WAYS GROCERY CORP. FIVE WAYS GROCERY CORP. 469 W 157TH STREET NEW YORK 10032- Yes FLOYD M LAND FLOYD M LAND N/W/C W. 14TH ST & 6TH AVE NEW YORK 10011- Yes FREEDOM DELI CORP FREEDOM DELI CORP 3475 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10031- Yes FRIST AVE EXPRESS DELI INC FRIST AVE EXPRESS DELI INC 2314 1ST AVENUE NEW YORK 10035- Yes GARDEN GOURMET CORP GARDEN GOURMET CORP 2019 1ST AVENUE NEW YORK 10029- Yes GOLD DELI INC GOLD DELI INC 126 EAST 103RD STREET NEW YORK 10029- Yes

Page 29 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid GREATEST 2698 DELI CORP. GREATEST 2698 DELI CORP. 561 W 179TH STREET NEW YORK 10033- Yes GREEN GARDEN DELI INC GREEN GARDEN DELI INC 340 LENOX AVENUE NEW YORK 10027- Yes GREEN OLIVE DELI CORP GREEN OLIVE DELI CORP 161 EAST 116TH STREET NEW YORK 10029- Yes GREENBERG, JOEL GREENBERG, JOEL S/E/C 6TH AVE & 8TH ST NEW YORK 10011- Yes GRUCHY SMOKE SHOP CORP GRUCHY SMOKE SHOP CORP 2409 SECOND AVENUE NEW YORK 10035- Yes GZ CORPORATION GZ CORPORATION 111 1ST AVENUE NEW YORK 10003- Yes H & W DELI GROCERY INC H & W DELI GROCERY INC 4740-44 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10040- Yes HADAR 94 FOOD INC HADAR 94 FOOD INC. 500 E 77TH STREET NEW YORK 10162- Yes HARLEM GOURMET DELI INC HARLEM GOURMET DELI INC 2527 FREDERICK DOUGLAS BLVD NEW YORK 10030- Yes HEADLINE COFFEE BAR, LLC HEADLINE COFFEE BAR, LLC. 250 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10007- Yes HEIGHT CONV STORE ADNAN ISMAIL 4243 BROADWAY MANHATTAN 10033- Yes HEIGHTS LIBERTY GROCERY & DELI INC HEIGHTS LIBERTY GROCERY & DELI INC 3890-3898 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10032- Yes HESS RETAIL OPERATIONS LLC HESS RETAIL OPERATIONS LLC 401 WEST 207TH STREET NEW YORK 10034- Yes HILLSIDE CANDY & GROCERY INC HILLSIDE CANDY & GROCERY INC 4520 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10040- Yes HUMADI DELI CORP HUMADI DELI CORP 354 LENOX AVENUE NEW YORK 10027- Yes HUMADI DELI CORP HUMADI DELI CORP 354 LENOX AVENUE NEW YORK 10027- Yes HWANG 50 857 CORP HWANG 50 857 CORP 857 2ND AVENUE NEW YORK 10017- IN & OUT DELI GROCERY INC IN & OUT DELI GROCERY INC 2176 2ND AVENUE NEW YORK 10029- Yes INFINITY NEWS INC INFINITY NEWS INC 837 LEXINGTON AVENUE NEW YORK 10065- Yes INFINITY NEWS INC INFINITY NEWS INC 837 LEXINGTON AVENUE NEW YORK 10065- Yes INTERNATIONAL NEWS & MAGZINE INC INTERNATIONAL NEWS & MAGZINE INC 302 EAST 86TH STREET NEW YORK 10028- Yes JASANI, MUNIRA JASANI, MUNIRA N/W/C 46TH ST AND 6TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10036- Yes JASON & HARRY FOOD CORP JASON & HARRY FOOD CORP 850 7TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10019- Yes JOE SOUTH SIDE DELI JOE SOUTH SIDE DELI 11577 SUTPHIN BOULEVARD NEW YORK 11434- Yes KAMARAN GROCERY KAMARAN GROCERY 79 AVENUE A NEW YORK 10009- Yes KAMLESH INC KAMLESH INC 2 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10004- Yes KHVP,INC. KHVP,INC.. 265 WEST 37TH STREET NEW YORK 10018- Yes KHVP,INC. KHVP,INC.. 265 WEST 37TH STREET NEW YORK 10018- Yes KINGS 106 DELI GROCERY CORP KINGS 106 DELI GROCERY CORP 2067 2ND AVENUE NEW YORK 10029- Yes KINGS 106 DELI GROCERY CORP KINGS 106 DELI GROCERY CORP 2067 2ND AVENUE NEW YORK 10029- Yes KYS GROCERY INC KYS GROCERY INC. 482 3RD AVENUE NEW YORK 10016- Yes LA BARRACA DELI INC LA BARRACA DELI INC 21 AVENUE B NEW YORK 10009- LAITH GROCERY CORP LAITH GROCERY CORP. 3341 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10031- Yes LAXMI NEWSSTAND LLC GATEWAY NEWSSTAND 237 PARK AVENUE NEW YORK 10017- Yes LE BASKET INC LE BASKET INC 683 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10012- Yes LEE PRODUCE CORP LEE PRODUCE CORP. 1349 2ND AVENUE NEW YORK 10021- Yes LENOX GOURMET DELI & GROCERY CORP 217 MALCOLM BLVD NEW YORK 10027- Yes LEONARD PICARILLO LEONARD PICARILLO N/E/C FULTON STREET NEW YORK 10038- Yes LIBERTY CAFE/DORMANT 513 FOOD CORP. 829 3 AVENUE NEW YORK 10022- LOISAIDA AVE DELI CORP LOISAIDA AVE DELI CORP. 303 EAST 4TH STREET NEW YORK 10009- Yes

Page 30 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid LOISAIDA AVE DELI CORP LOISAIDA AVE DELI CORP 303 EAST 4TH STREET NEW YORK 10009- Yes LONDON GROCERY CORP LONDON GROCERY CORP 252 10TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10001- Yes M & S FOOD CORP M & S FOOD CORP 2482 7TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10030- Yes M & S NEWS & CONVENIENCE INC. M & S NEWS & CONVENIENCE INC. 1154 LEXINGTON AVENUE NEW YORK 10021- Yes MADISON RUTGERS INC. MADISON RUTGERS INC. 197 MADISON STREET NEW YORK 10002- MAHMUD S SAPAN MAHMUD S SAPAN S E CORNER 7TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10019- Yes MANAJ 103 BODHAN INC. MANAJ 103 BODHAN INC. 103 W. 14TH STREET NEW YORK 11101- Yes MANHATTAN EXPRESS DELI GROCERY MANHATTAN EXPRESS DELI GROCERY 91 AVENUE D NEW YORK 10009- Yes MANHATTAN MERCHANTILE LLC MANHATTAN MERCHANTILE LLC 2 EAST 55 SQUARE NEW YORK 10022- Yes MANHATTAN SMOKE SHOP & CANDY CORP MANHATTAN SMOKE SHOP & CANDY CORP 41B MADISON STREET NEW YORK 10038- Yes MARK OPCO LP MARK OPCO LP 25 EAST 77TH STREET NEW YORK 10075- Yes MARTIN'S NEWS AND SUNDRY SHOPS INC MARTIN'S NEWS AND SUNDRY SHOPS INC. 11 MADISON AVENUE NEW YORK 10010- Yes MAX CONVENIENCE INC MAX CONVENIENCE INC 364 WEST 23RD STREET NEW YORK 10011- Yes MAZUMDER, JAHANGIR A MAZUMDER, JAHANGIR A NKA W. 3RD ST & 6TH AVE NEW YORK 10011- Yes ME QUICK STOP GROCERY & CANDY CORP ME QUICK STOP GROCERY & CANDY CORP 4314 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10033- Yes MEGA NEWS INC MEGA NEWS INC 253 EAST 57 STREET NEW YORK 10022- Yes MENTA, KISHOR NEWSSTAND.. S/W/C W 42ND ST & 6TH AVE NEW YORK 10018- Yes MEXICAN DELI INC MEXICAN DELI INC. 2711 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10025- Yes MIDTOWN GIFTS & SOUVENIRS INC MIDTOWN GIFTS & SOUVENIRS INC 541 8TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10018- Yes MIDTOWN NEWS & GROCERY INC MIDTOWN NEWS & GROCERY INC 2578 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10025- Yes MILDRED DELI GROCERY INC MILDRED DELI GROCERY INC 231 EAST 116TH STREET NEW YORK 10029- Yes MINI CART CONVIENCE STORE MINI CART CONVIENCE STORE 159 EAST HOUSTON ST NEW YORK 10002- Yes MIS HIJOS DELI CORP. MIS HIJOS DELI CORP. 2401 2ND AVENUE NEW YORK 10035- Yes MOON'S NEWSSTAND MOON'S NEWSSTAND N/W/C BROADWAY & WAVERLY PL NEW YORK 10003- Yes MUSHEER DELI AND GROCERY CORP MUSHEER DELI AND GROCERY CORP. 1653 ST. NICHOLAS AVENUE NEW YORK 10040- Yes MY WAY CONVENIENCE SMOKE SHOP INC 1594 3RD AVENUE NEW YORK 10128- Yes NABI, CHOUDHURY NAHIN NEWS.. S/E/C BROADWAY & W 58 ST NEW YORK 10019- Yes NAHSHAL, MUSTAFA GREEN VALLEY GROCERY 74 EAST 116TH STREET NEW YORK 10029- Yes NAJM CANDY & GROCERY INC NAJM CANDY & GROCERY INC 1349 NICHOLAL AVENUE NEW YORK 10033- NAMU GREEN MART INC NAMU GREEN MART INC 252 3RD AVENUE NEW YORK 10010- Yes NEIGHBORHOOD DELI Z CORP NEIGHBORHOOD DELI Z CORP 2546 AC POWELL BLVD NEW YORK 10039- NEW DHAKA DELI AND CONVENIENCE INC NEW DHAKA DELI AND CONVENIENCE INC 136 EAST 28TH STREET NEW YORK 10016- Yes NEW FUZHOU SUPERMARKET INC NEW FUZHOU SUPERMARKET INC. 146 HENRY STREET NEW YORK 10002- Yes NIVA MIDTOWN GIFT SHOP INC NIVA MIDTOWN GIFT SHOP INC 440 W 57TH STREET NEW YORK 10019- Yes NIVA NOVOTEL GIFT SHOP INC NIVA NOVOTEL GIFT SHOP INC 226 WEST 52ND STREET NEW YORK 10019- Yes NUCARE PHARMACY WEST LLC NUCARE PHARMACY WEST LLC 250 9TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10001- Yes NYC 88 CONVENIENCE INC NYC 88 CONVENIENCE INC 88A DELANCEY STREET NEW YORK 10002- Yes NYC CANDY STORE SHOP CORP NYC CANDY STORE SHOP CORP 2653 FREDERICK DOUGLASS BLVD NEW YORK 10030- Yes NYC OPTIMO CORP NYC OPTIMO CORP 57 1ST AVENUE NEW YORK 10003- Yes ORGANIC DELI FOOD INC. ORGANIC DELI FOOD INC. 2922 8TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10039- Yes

Page 31 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid P F W TRADING INC. P F W TRADING INC.. 116 UNIVERSITY PLACE NEW YORK 10003- Yes PANDYA, RAJESHWARI PANDYA, RAJESHWARI. N/E/C W 51ST ST & BROADWAY NEW YORK 10019- Yes PANDYA, RAJESHWARI PANDYA, RAJESHWARI N/E/C W 51ST ST & BROADWAY NEW YORK 10019- Yes PARK IRMAT DRUG CORP PARK IRMAT DRUG CORP 2 PARK AVENUE NEW YORK 10016- Yes PATAL ASIA DELI GROCERY LLC PATAL ASIA DELI GROCERY LLC 135 EAST 28TH STREET NEW YORK 10016- Yes PATEL URVISHA PATEL URVISHA S/W/C E 14 TH ST STREET MANHATTAN 10003- Yes PATEL, SURENDRA R PATEL, SURENDRA R 204 WEST 35TH STREET NEW YORK 10123- Yes PERRY & TH STREET CORP PERRY & 11TH STREET CORP 275 W 4TH STREET MANHATTAN 10014- Yes POOKA NEWS INC POOKA NEWS INC 1 PENN PLAZA NEW YORK 10119- Yes PRESBYTERIAN DELI 57 CORP PRESBYTERIAN DELI 57 CORP 57 PITT AVENUE NEW YORK 10002- Yes PRIME ESSENTIALS LLC PRIME ESSENTIALS LLC 88 LEONARD STREET NEW YORK 10013- Yes PSP CONVENIENCE INC PSP CONVENIENCE INC 584 WEST 207TH STREET NEW YORK 10034- Yes RAHUFF HOT SPOT DELI & GROCERY CORP RAHUFF HOT SPOT DELI & GROCERY CORP 1465 AMSTERDAM AVE NEW YORK 10027- Yes RAHUFF HOT SPOT DELI & GROCERY CORP RAHUFF HOT SPOT DELI & GROCERY CORP 1465 AMSTERDAM AVE NEW YORK 10027- RAHUFF HOT SPOT DELI & GROCERY CORP RAHUFF HOT SPOT DELI & GROCERY CORP 1465 AMSTERDAM AVE NEW YORK 10027- RAYIRA GROCERY DELI CORP RAYIRA GROCERY DELI CORP 247 AUDUBON AVENUE NEW YORK 10033- Yes RED APPLE DELI MARKET CORP RED APPLE DELI MARKET CORP 134 HAMILTON PLACE NEW YORK 10031- Yes RX CENTER RX CENTER. 2325 1ST AVENUE MANHATTAN 10035- Yes S & L DELI & GROCERY INC S & L DELI & GROCERY INC 2254 7TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10027- Yes S.M. CONVENIENCE INC S.M. CONVENIENCE INC 86 STANTON STREET NEW YORK 10002- Yes SADAM M SAAD SADAM M SAAD 665 MALCOLM X BLVD NEW YORK 10037- Yes SAIED DELI CORP SAIED DELI CORP 105 EAST 125 STREET NEW YORK 10035- Yes SANTA BARBARA DELI CORP SANTA BARBARA DELI CORP 551 EAST 12TH STREET NEW YORK 10009- Yes SANTIAGO EXPRESS DELI CORP SANTIAGO EXPRESS DELI CORP 3680 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10031- Yes SARAH J OH SARAH J OH N/E/C 40TH ST & 8TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10018- Yes SARASAMIR CORP SARASAMIR CORP 1490 FIRST AVENUE NEW YORK 10075- Yes SARH DELI GROCERY INC SARH DELI GROCERY INC 201 W. 131ST STREET NEW YORK 10027- Yes SHA DELI GROCERY INC SHA DELI GROCERY INC 621 MALCOLM X BLVD NEW YORK 10037- SKY 5TH AVENUE, LLC SKY 5TH AVENUE, LLC. 178 CHURCH STREET NEW YORK 10013- Yes SMZ IMPEX IN SMZ IMPEX INC 146 2 AVENUE NEW YORK 10003- Yes SOHO FOOD LLC SOHO FOOD LLC 545 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10012- Yes SOHO HOUSE NEW YORK LLC SOHO HOUSE NEW YORK LLC 29-35 9TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10014- Yes SPACE 86 CORP SPACE 86 CORP 524 COLUMBUS AVE NEW YORK 10024- Yes SPACE NY 62 CORP SPACE NY 62 CORP 1130 FIRST AVENUE NEW YORK 10065- Yes STEP # 1 DELI GROCERY INC STEP # 1 DELI GROCERY INC 685 LENOX AVENUE NEW YORK 10039- Yes STOP 1 AT DELANCEY INC STOP 1 AT DELANCEY INC 48 DELANCEY STREET NEW YORK 10002- Yes STOP 1 TOBACCO SHOP CORP STOP 1 TOBACCO SHOP CORP 201 CLINTON STREET NEW YORK 10002- STOP AND SHOP II CORP STOP AND SHOP II CORP 3866 10TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10034- Yes STOP AND SHOP II CORP STOP AND SHOP II CORP 3866 10TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10034- Yes STUYESANT DELI & NEWS INC STUYESANT DELI & NEWS INC 375 1ST AVENUE NEW YORK 10010- Yes

Page 32 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid SUHAIL DELI & GROCERY FADHL N SUHAIL 1536 AMSTERDAM AVE NEW YORK 10031- Yes SWEET APPLE DELI A GROCERY CORP SWEET APPLE DELI A GROCERY CORP 4672 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10040- Yes SWEET OLIVE INC SWEET OLIVE INC 345 FIRST AVENUE NEW YORK 10010- Yes TEJ NEWSTAND LLC TEJ NEWSTAND LLC 1350 AVE. OF THE AMERICAS NEW YORK 10019- Yes THE MAGAZINE BAZAR INC THE MAGAZINE BAZAR INC 80 VARICK STREET NEW YORK 10013- Yes THIRD AVENUE GOURMET DELI, INC. THIRD AVENUE GOURMET DELI, INC. 2034 3RD AVENUE NEW YORK 10029- Yes TIEHAMA GROCERY INC TIEHAMA GROCERY INC 195 E. HOUSTON STREET NEW YORK 10002- Yes TILAK INC TILAK INC 1235 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10001- Yes TOBACCO SHOP CORP TOBACCO SHOP CORP 102 CLINTON STREET NEW YORK 10002- TPHG 303 LTD TPHG 303 LTD. 303 5TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10016- Yes ULTIMATE DELI GROCERY CORP ULTIMATE DELI GROCERY CORP. 2017 AMSTERDAM AVE NEW YORK 10032- Yes UNITED GOURMET GROCERY INC UNITED GOURMET GROCERY INC 2366 FREDERICK DOUGLASS BLVD NEW YORK 10027- Yes UPTOWN 2 DELI INC UPTOWN 2 DELI INC 2933 8TH AVENUE NEW YORK 10039- UPTOWN GORMET INC UPTOWN GORMET INC. 3778 BROADWAY NEW YORK 10032- Yes USHA P JOSHI USHA P JOSHI S/E/C 32ND ST & 5TH AVE NEW YORK 10001- Yes W 174 GOURMET DELI & GROCERY CORP W 174 GOURMET DELI & GROCERY CORP 530 W 174TH STREET NEW YORK 10033- Yes WEST 14OBACCO KING INC WEST 14OBACCO KING INC 200 WEST 14 STREET NEW YORK 10011- Yes WEST LOBBY NEWSSTAND INC WEST LOBBY NEWSSTAND INC 555 WEST 57TH STREET NEW YORK 10019- Yes WEST ST GOURMET INC WEST ST GOURMET INC 21 WEST STREET NEW YORK 10004- Yes WESTWAY FRESH FOOD CORP WESTWAY FRESH FOOD CORP. 375 AMSTERDAM AVENUE NEW YORK 10024- YAU MOU CHU YAU MOU CHU 211 EAST BROADWAY NEW YORK 10002- Yes YEMSANALI GROCERY, INC. YEMSANALI GROCERY, INC. 881 10 AVENUE NEW YORK 10019- Yes YSH GREEN CORP YSH GREEN CORP 38 WEST 48TH STREET NEW YORK 10036- Yes YUMMY GOURMET DELI INC YUMMY GOURMET DELI INC. 1773 LEXINGTON AVENUE NEW YORK 10029- Yes Z & S CONVENIENCE STORE INC Z & S CONVENIENCE STORE INC 31 MALCOLM X BLVD NEW YORK 10026- Yes Z & S NEWS STORE Z & S NEWS STORE 224 WEST 35TH STREET NEW YORK 10001- Yes ZARAGOZA MEXICAN DELI & GROCERY INC 215 AVENUE A NEW YORK 10009- Yes ZITOMER PHARMACY INC ZITOMER PHARMACY INC 969 MADISON AVENUE NEW YORK 10021- Yes ZW DELI & GROCERY CORP ZW DELI & GROCERY CORP 2240 2ND AVENUE NEW YORK 10029- NIAGARA

7-ELEVEN #35151 7-ELEVEN 492 OLIVER STREET NORTH TONAWANDA 14120- Yes 7-ELEVEN #35159 7-ELEVEN 95 TRANSIT ROAD LOCKPORT 14094- Yes 7-ELEVEN #35172 7-ELEVEN 9101 NIAGARA FALLS BLVD NIAGARA FALLS 14304- Yes 7-ELEVEN STORE#17163D 7-ELEVEN 6802 BUFFALO AVE NIAGARA FALLS 14304- Yes CENTER COURT MARKET CENTER COURT MARKET 2703 20TH STREET NIAGARA FALLS 14305- Yes CROSBY'S CROSBY'S 7953 ROCHESTER ROAD GASPORT 14067- Yes J & A 138 TRADING INC. J & A 138 TRADING INC. 360 RAINBOW BLVD NIAGARA FALLS 14303- Yes SUNOCO #7619 SUNOCO 502 MAIN STREET NIAGARA FALLS 08131- SUNSET ARROW MART SUNSET ARROW MART 4815 SUNSET DRIVE LOCKPORT 14094- Yes

Page 33 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid THIRD STREET VARIETY THIRD STREET VARIETY 451 THIRD STREET NIAGARA FALLS 14301- ONEIDA

CITGO NORTH UTICA CITGO 385 GENESEE STREET UTICA 13502- FAMILY DOLLAR FAMILY DOLLAR 1112 MOHAWK STREET UTICA 13501- FAMILY DOLLAR FAMILY DOLLAR 1750 BLACK RIVER BLVD ROME 13440- Yes NICE N EASY #5 NICE N EASY 7296 MAIN STREET WESTMORELAND 13490- Yes P & H RUNWAY P & H RUNWAY PETROLEUM CORP 8516 SENECA TURNPIKE NEW HARTFORD 13413- Yes RCJF MANAGEMENT RCJF MANAGEMENT 9827 RIVER ROAD UTICA 13502- Yes SENECA TURNPIKE DRAKE XTRA MART DRAKE XTRA MART 8536 SENECA TURNPIKE NEW HARTFORD 13413- Yes UTICA SUPER SAVER ABE'S UTICA SUPER SAVER 608 SOUTH STREET UTICA 13501- Yes WALGREEN'S WALGREEN'S 1750 GENESEE STREET UTICA 13502- Yes WEST ROME NICE N EASY NICE N EASY 1221 ERIE BLVD ROME 13440- Yes ONONDAGA

7-ELEVEN 7-ELEVEN 1718 GRANT BLVD SYRACUSE 13208- Yes CHOICE ONE CHOICE ONE 1201 BUTTERNUT STREET SYRACUSE 13208- Yes DADDYS PLACE DADDY'S PLACE 339 WOLF STREET SYRACUSE 13208- Yes DIVISION STREET MARKET DIVISION STREET MARKET 318 DIVISION STREET SYRACUSE 13208- Yes DREAM FOOD MARKET DREAM FOOD MARKET 518 WOLF STREET SYRACUSE 13204- Yes FAMILY FOOD MARKET FAMILY FOOD MARKET 814 BUTTERNUT STREET SYRACUSE 13208- Yes FAMLY DREAM FAMLY DREAM 1009 PARK STREET SYRACUSE 13208- Yes GALAXY CONVENIENCE GALAXY CONVENIENCE 303 SOUTH AVENUE SYRACUSE 13204- Yes LOS AMIGOS LOS AMIGOS 204 BRIGHTON AVENUE SYRACUSE 13205- Yes MIAMI DELI MIAMI DELI 700 MIDLAND AVENUE SYRACUSE 13205- Yes OLYMPIC NEWS OLYMPIC NEWS 441 SOUTH SALINA STREET SYRACUSE 13202- Yes PRICE CHOPPER #182 PRICE CHOPPER 3863 ROUTE 31 LIVERPOOL 13090- Yes RITE AID RITE AID 7398 OSWEGO ROAD LIVERPOOL 13090- Yes SAVE MORE MARKET SAVE MORE MARKET 825 TEALL AVENUE SYRACUSE 13206- Yes SMOKERS CHOICE SMOKER'S CHOICE 174 SWAMSEA DRIVE SYRACUSE 13206- Yes SUNOCO GOLY BROS. 800 WOLF STREET SYRACUSE 13208- Yes SUNOCO A-PLUS SUNOCO A-PLUS 971 BRIGHTON AVENUE SYRACUSE 13205- Yes WATSUI MARKET WATSUI MARKET 400 SEYMOUR STREET SYRACUSE 13204- Yes WILSON FARMS WILSON FARMS 2450 JAMES STREET SYRACUSE 13206- Yes ONTARIO

E Z NEWSSTAND E Z NEWSSTAND 672 EASTVIEW MALL VICTOR 14564- Yes THE COMPANY STORE THE COMPANY STORE 4244 ROUTE 21 CANADAIGUA 14424- Yes

Page 34 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid

ORANGE

56 NEIGHBORHOOD DELI 56 NEIGHBORHOOD DELI INC. 56 LANDER STREET NEWBURGH 12550- Yes 9 MAIN STREET GROCERY 9 MAIN STREET GROCERY 9 MAIN STREET OTISVILLE 10963- Yes A&H DELI A&H DELI 32 CULVERT STREET PORT JERVIS 12771- Yes AK'S GROCERY AK'S GROCERY 95 NORTH STREET MIDDLETOWN 10940- ASHLY GROCERY ASHLY GROCERY 44 LIBERTY STREET NEWBURGH 12550- Yes CITGO CHANDER & SONS 45 MAPLE LANE MIDDLETOWN 10940- Yes CITGO QUICK MART CITGO QUICK MART 220 DOLSON AVENUE MIDDLETOWN 10940- Yes CITY CENTER MARKET & DELI CITY CENTER MARKET & DELI 120 BROADWAY NEWBURGH 12550- Yes CUMBERLAND FARMS #1564 CUMBERLAND FARMS 174 MAIN STREET CHESTER 10918- Yes DISCOUNT SMOKE SHOP DISCOUNT SMOKE SHOP 190 S. PLANK ROAD NEWBURGH 12550- Yes DUCKTOWN DELI MARKET DUCKTOWN DELI MARKET 238 WALSH AVENUE NEW WINDSOR 12553- Yes GREEN APPLE DELI MARKET GREEN APPLE DELI MARKET 188 BROADWAY NEWBURGH 12550- Yes HOMETOWN FOOD MARKET HOMETOWN FOOD MARKET 215 ROUTE 17 TUXEDO 10987- Yes HUDSON VALLEY MARKET HUDSON VALLEY MARKET 120 BROADWAY NEWBURGH 12550- Yes HUDSON VALLEY MARKET HUDSON VALLEY MARKET 120 BROADWAY NEWBURGH 12550- Yes K & A DELI K&A DELI 97 FULLERTON AVENUE NEWBURGH 12550- Yes MOBIL MOBIL 124 ROUTE 32 CENTRAL VALLEY 10917- Yes MOBIL MOBIL ON THE RUN 310 BROADWAY NEWBURGH 12550- Yes MOBIL MOBIL 279 BLOOMINGBURGH ROAD MIDDLETOWN 10940- Yes MOUNT HOPE COUNTRY STORE MOUNT HOPE COUNTRY STORE 2269 MOUNT HOPE ROAD MIDDLETOWN 10940- Yes NEWBURGH MARKET NEWBURGH MARKET 271 WASHINGTON STREET NEWBURGH 12550- Yes SALVATO'S FLOWICK DELI SALVATO FLOWICK DELI 581 ROUTE 94 NORTH WARWICK 10990- Yes SMOKE & PUFF SMOKE & PUFF 817 ROUTE 17M MONROE 10950- Yes SMOKER'S CHOICE SMOKER'S CHOICE 125 DOLSON AVENUE MIDDLETOWN 10940- Yes SUNOCO A-PLUS MINI MART 241 ROUTE 32 CENTRAL VALLEY 10917- Yes TOBACCO QUEEN TOBACCO QUEEN 63 BROOKSIDE AVENUE CHESTER 10918- Yes TOBACCO QUEEN TOBACCO QUEEN 69 BROOKSIDE AVENUE CHESTER 10918- Yes WALGREENS #12634 WALGREENS 2084 ROUTE 208 MONTGOMERY 12549- Yes ORLEANS

PURE VAPOR USA PURE VAPOR USA LLP 339 NORTH MAIN STREET MEDINA 14103- Yes OSWEGO

OSWEGO EXPRESS MART OSWEGO EXPRESS MART INC 260 STATE ROUTE 104 EAST OSWEGO 13126- Yes SMOKERS CHOICE WEST SMOKERS CHOICE WEST 255 W SENECA STREET OSWEGO 12126- Yes XTREME UNDERGROUND XTREME UNDERGROUND 27 WEST BRIDGE STREET OSWEGO 13126- Yes

Page 35 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid

PUTNAM

BOYD'S CORNER STORE BOYD'S CORNER STORE 2737 ROUTE 301 CARMEL 10512- Yes CHESTNUT MOBILE CHESTNUT MOBIL RTE 22 & RTE 311 PATTERSON 12563- Yes EAGLE EAGLE GAS 1224 ROUTE 22 BREWSTER 10509- EAGLE GAS EAGLE GAS 1224 ROUTE 22 BREWSTER 10509- PUTNAM VALLEY LIZZIES PUTNAM VALLEY LIZZIES LLC 4 OSCAWANA LAKE ROAD PUTNAM VALLEY 10579- Yes VALUE VILLAGE VALUE VILLAGE 1620 ROUTE 22 BREWSTER 10509- Yes VALUE VILLAGE VALUE VILLAGE 1620 ROUTE 22 BREWSTER 10509- QUEENS

101 QUICK STOP CORP 101 QUICK STOP CORP 10102 NORTHERN BLVD CORONA 11368- Yes 1010 DELI & GRILL CORP 1010 DELI & GRILL CORP 1101 GUY R BREWER BLVD JAMAICA 11433- Yes 107 GUY CANDY GROCERY INC 107 GUY CANDY GROCERY INC 10743 GUY R BREWER BLVD JAMAICA 11433- 109 BROTHER DELI CONVENIENCE INC 109 BROTHER DELI CONVENIENCE INC. 109-14 SUTPHIN BOULEVARD JAMAICA 11435- Yes 109 MERRICK DELI CORP 109 MERRICK DELI CORP 109-14 MERRICK BOULEVARD JAMAICA 11433- Yes 109 MERRICK DELI CORP 109 MERRICK DELI CORP 109-14 MERRICK BOULEVARD JAMAICA 11433- Yes 112 DELI AND GRILL INC 112 DELI AND GRILL INC 112-33 GUY R BREWER BLVD JAMAICA 11433- Yes 131-21 STOP ONE DELI & GROCERY CORP 131-21 STOP ONE DELI & GROCERY CORP 131-21 SPRING FIELD BLVD SPRINGFIELD 11413- Yes 165 STREET NEWS STAND INC 165 STREET NEWS STAND INC 164-17 JAMAICA AVENUE JAMAICA 11432- Yes 168 GOURMET DELI AND GROCERY INC 168 GOURMET DELI AND GROCERY INC. 16834 JAMAICA AVENUE JAMAICA 11432- Yes 179 DELI LTD 179 DELI LTD 179-46 HILLSIDE AVE JAMAICA 11432- Yes 186 GOURMET DELI INC 186 GOURMET DELI INC 18520 HILLSIDE AVENUE QUEENS 11432- 206 DELI INC 206 DELI INC. 206-24 HILLSIDE AVENUE QUEEN 11427- 2ND AVENUE CONVENIENCE INC 2ND AVENUE CONVENIENCE INC 7102 MYRTLE AVENUE GLENDALE 11385- Yes 42-01 GOURMET DELI INC 42-01 GOURMET DELI INC 42-01 30TH AVENUE ASTORIA 11103- Yes 61ST STREET GROCERY INC 61ST STREET GROCERY INC 61-20 MYRTLE AVENUE GLENDALE 11385- 79TH STREET DELI GROCERY 79TH STREET DELI GROCERY 37-71 79TH STREET JACKSON HEIGHTS 11372- 7-ELEVEN STORE 3218C 7-ELEVEN STORE 3218C 146-26 NORTHERN BLVD FLUSHING 11355- Yes 81 STREET DISCOUNT VARIETY STORE INC 81 STREET DISCOUNT VARIETY STORE INC 81-14 NORTHERN BLVD JACKSON HEIGHTS 11372- Yes 89 DELI & GROCERY INC 89 DELI & GROCERY INC 164-03 89TH AVENUE JAMAICA 11432- Yes 89 DELI & GROCERY INC 89 DELI & GROCERY INC 164-03 89TH AVENUE JAMAICA 11432- Yes 94 ST GROCERY CORP 94 ST GROCERY CORP 3562 94TH STREET JACKSON HEIGHTS 11372- Yes 95TH EXPRESS DELI&GROCERY INC 95TH EXPRESS DELI&GROCERY INC 8820 95TH AVENUE OZONE PARK 11416- Yes 97 ADAMS DELI & GROCERY INC 97 ADAMS DELI & GROCERY INC 97-04 ROCKAWAY BLVD OZONE PARK 11417- Yes 97TH STREET MINIMART, INC 97TH STREET MINIMART, INC 97-07/07A 57TH AVENUE CORONA 11368- Yes A & J MARKET INC. A & J MARKET INC. 5959 69TH STREET MASPETH 11378- Yes AAYAN MINI MART, INC AAYAN MINI MART, INC. 8820 95TH AVENUE OZONE PARK 11416- Yes AB SKYDREAM USA INC AB SKYDREAM USA INC 9053 SUTPHIN BOULEVARD JAMAICA 11435- Yes

Page 36 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid ABDO H M ALAABELI ABDO H M ALAABELI 10220 101ST AVENUE OZONE PARK 11416- Yes ADAM'S BAGELS CORP ADAM'S BAGELS CORP 63-56 WIOODHAVEN BLVD REGO PARK 11374- Yes AK GROCERY INC AK GROCERY INC 180-08 HILLSIDE AVENUE JAMAICA 11432- Yes ALEX OF ASTORIA DELI INC ALEX OF ASTORIA DELI INC 2719 21ST STREET ASTORIA 11102- Yes ALL-SOURCE CORP. ALL-SOURCE CORP.. 91-09 63RD DRIVE REGO PARK 11375- Yes ALSHAWAL SADEO A ALSHAWAL SADEO A 111802 JAMAICA AVENUE JAMAICA 11418- Yes AMBE GROCERY CORP AMBE GROCERY CORP 69-34 MAIN STREET FLUSHING 11367- Yes ARYAN GROCERY STORE INC ARYAN GROCERY STORE INC 79-39 MYRTLE AVENUE GLENDALE 11385- Yes BAISLEY DELI INC BAISLEY DELI INC 117-07 GUY R. BREWER BLVD JAMAICA 11434- Yes BAISLEY SERVICES INC BAISLEY SERVICES INC 122-05 MERRICK BLVD JAMAICA 11434- Yes BATUA LIPIKA BATUA LIPIKA 14713 UNION TURNPIKE FLUSHING 11367- Yes BEST LINDEN DELI INC BEST LINDEN DELI INC 19-38 LINDEN STREET RIDGEWOOD 11385- Yes BRICKTOWN DELI GROCERY INC BRICKTOWN DELI GROCERY INC. 105-15 177TH STREET JAMAICA 11433- Yes C - TOWN C - TOWN 74-39 JAMAICA AVENUE WOODHAVEN 11421- Yes CAMPUS SUPERMARKET INC CAMPUS SUPERMARKET INC. 5904 KISSENA BLVD QUEENS 11355- Yes CANELO & CARMYNE GROCERY CORP CANELO & CARMYNE GROCERY CORP 7269 61ST STREET GLENDALE 11385- Yes CLASSIC DELI GOURMET, INC CLASSIC DELI GOURMET, INC 9619 57TH AVENUE QUEENS 11368- DAD DELI & CAFE INC DAD DELI & CAFE INC 5924 KISSENA BLVD FLUSHING 11355- Yes DESAI CONVENIENCE LLC DESAI CONVENIENCE LLC 3945 43 AVENUE SUNNYSIDE 11104- Yes DITMARS CANDY & GROCERY INC DITMARS CANDY & GROCERY INC 28-05 DITMARS BOULEVARD ASTORIA 11105- Yes D'OSCAR DELI GROCERY INC D'OSCAR DELI GROCERY INC. 11807 SUTPHIN BLVD JAMAICA 11435- Yes DUANE READE DUANE READE 107-14 71ST AVENUE FOREST HILLS 11375- Yes EMPIRE STATE DELI INC EMPIRE STATE DELI INC 42-16 30TH AVENUE ASTORIA 11103- Yes EN-EXPRESS DELI CORP EN-EXPRESS DELI CORP 920 MAIN AVENUE ASTORIA 11102- Yes ESHAAN SUPERMARKET LLC ESHAAN SUPERMARKET LLC 9506 SUTPHIN BLVD JAMAICA 11435- EVERBODYS PLACE OF LIC, INC EVERBODYS PLACE OF LIC, INC. 32-32 QUEENS BLVD QUEENS 11101- Yes FAHMAN FAMOUS DELI INC FAHMAN FAMOUS DELI INC 16310 89TH AVENUE QUEENS 11432- Yes FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF NEW YORK INC FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF NEW YORK INC 13217 14TH AVENUE COLLEGE POINT 11356- Yes FARMERS FANTASTIC DELI FARMERS FANTASTIC DELI 142-01 FARMERS BLVD JAMAICA 11434- Yes FIVE J DELI GORVERY CORP FIVE J DELI GORVERY CORP 14412 LAKEWOOD AVENUE JAMAICA 11435- FLUSHING AVE DELI & GROCERY INC FLUSHING AVE DELI & GROCERY INC 63-22 FLUSHING AVENUE MASPETH 11378- Yes FOREST HOUSE DELI INC FOREST HOUSE DELI INC 41-12 COLLEGE POINT BLVD FLUSHING 11355- Yes FORTUNE USA TRADE INC FORTUNE USA TRADE INC 2405 23RD AVENUE ASTORIA 11105- Yes FOUR STAR FRESH GREEN GROCERY INC FOUR STAR FRESH GREEN GROCERY INC 14613 JAMAICA AVENUE JAMAICA 11435- Yes GEETPAL GROCERY STORE INC. GEETPAL GROCERY STORE INC. 6002 KISSENA BOULEVARD FLUSHING 11355- Yes GOLDEN CHILDREN PLACE INC GOLDEN CHILDREN PLACE INC 4574B KISSENA BLVD QUEENS 11355- Yes GOLDEN DELI NY INC. GOLDEN DELI NY INC. 32-21 LINDEN PLACE QUEENS 11354- Yes GOURMET DELI AND GRILL CORP. GOURMET DELI AND GRILL CORP.. 18520 HILLSIDE AVENUE QUEENS 11432- GRAB AND GO CANDY GROCERY CORP GRAB AND GO CANDY GROCERY CORP 8945 ELMHURST AVENUE ELMHURST 11373- Yes GREEN FARM GREEN FARM 466 ONDERDONK AVE RIDGEWOOD 11385- Yes

Page 37 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid H & A GRILL AND GROCERY INC H & A GRILL AND GROCERY INC. 122-03 SUTPHIN BLVD JAMAICA 11434- H & M CANDY & GROCERY CORP H & M CANDY & GROCERY CORP 30-10 BROADWAY ASTORIA 11106- Yes HABIBI GOURMET DELI INC HABIBI GOURMET DELI INC 13401 ROCKAWAY BLVD S. OZONE PARK 11420- Yes HAPPY FRUITS & VEGETABLES OF NY, INC HAPPY FRUITS & VEGETABLES OF NY, INC. 44-39 KISSENA BLVD FLUSHING 11355- Yes HELEN'S DELI INC HELEN'S DELI INC 715 FAIRVIEW AVENUE RIDGEWOOD 11385- Yes HESS STATION #32513 HESS STATION #32513. 56-01 MAIN STREET FLUSHING 11355- Yes HILL TOP GROCERY OF NY INC HILL TOP GROCERY OF NY INC 87-54 PARSONS BLVD JAMAICA 11432- Yes HILLSIDE #1 DELI CORP HILLSIDE #1 DELI CORP 16401 HILLSIDE AVENUE JAMAICA 11432- Yes HOLLIS WOODS DELI CORP HOLLIS WOODS DELI CORP 19702 HILLSIDE AVENUE HOLLIS 11423- IDI DELI AND GROCERY INC. IDI DELI AND GROCERY INC. 7408 JAMAICA AVENUE WOODHAVEN 11421- Yes IMBABA STATION INC I IMBABA STATION INC I 4925 VAN DAM STREET LONG ISLAND CITY 11101- Yes ISABELA PHOENIX CORP ISABELA PHOENIX CORP 10740 QUEENS BOULEVARD FOREST HILLS 11375- Yes JACKSON GOURMET DELI CORP JACKSON GOURMET DELI CORP 23-02 JACKSON AVENUE LONG ISLAND CITY 11101- Yes JAMAICA QUEENS FOOD CORP JAMAICA QUEENS FOOD CORP 213-01 JAMAICA AVENUE QUEENS VILLAGE 11428- Yes JAMAICA STAR CANDY & GROCERY INC JAMAICA STAR CANDY & GROCERY INC 87-74 168TH STREET JAMAICA 11432- Yes JANAKKUMAR PATEL JANAKKUMAR PATEL. 17102 NORTHERN BLVD QUEENS 11358- Yes JIMMY DELI & GROCERY INC JIMMY DELI & GROCERY INC 86-04 JAMAICA AVENUE WOODHAVEN 11421- Yes JOTI GROCERY INC. JOTI GROCERY INC. 7305 37TH ROAD JACKSON HEIGHTS 11372- KARAM CONVENIENCE STORE CORP KARAM CONVENIENCE STORE CORP 94-10 ROOSEVELT AVENUE JACKSON HEIGHTS 11372- Yes KENNY DELI & GROCERY INC KENNY DELI & GROCERY INC 147-01 GUY R BREWER BLVD JAMAICA 11434- Yes KING OF ROCKAWAY DELI & GROCERY INC. KING OF ROCKAWAY DELI & GROCERY INC. 14221 ROCKAWAY BLVD JAMAICA 11436- Yes KINGS CROSSBAY SUNOCO KINGS CROSSBAY SUNOCO 135-45 CROSSBAY BLVD OZONE PARK 11417- Yes KRISHTI & PAPA INC KRISHTI & PAPA INC 77-05 ROOSEVELT AVE JACKSON HEIGHTS 11372- Yes L&A GOURMENT DELI INC L&A GOURMENT DELI INC 7951 MYRTTE AVENUE GLENDALE 11385- L.I.C. MARKET CORP L.I.C. MARKET CORP 10-07 41ST AVENUE LONG ISLAND CITY 11101- Yes LEONE'S STOP ONE GROCERY LEONE'S STOP ONE GROCERY. 110-26 SUTPHIN BLVD JAMAICA 11435- Yes LINDEN CONVENIENCE CORP LINDEN CONVENIENCE CORP 18907 LINDEN BLVD SAINT ALBANS 11412- Yes LITTLE CASA BLANCA DELI LLC LITTLE CASA BLANCA DELI LLC 10403 101ST AVENUE OZONE PARK 11416- Yes LUCKY 88 GROCERY INC LUCKY 88 GROCERY INC 1421 COLLEGE POINT BLVD COLLEGE POINT 11356- Yes LX FOOD GROCERY INC LX FOOD GROCERY INC 96-14 CORONA AVENUE CORONA 11368- M & D 21 FOOD CORP M & D 21 FOOD CORP. 4465 21ST STREET LONG ISLAND CITY 11101- Yes M & M GROCERY M & M GROCERY 147-07 HILLSIDE AVENUE SAINT ALBANS 11435- Yes M&N DELI GROCERY INC M&N DELI GROCERY INC 9627 ATLANTIC AVENUE QUEENS 11421- Yes MANSOUR GROCERY & DELI INC MANSOUR GROCERY & DELI INC. 122-23 GUY R BREWER BLVD JAMAICA 11434- Yes MARIAS GROCERY MARIAS GROCERY 143-20 101ST AVENUE JAMICA 11435- Yes MEGA DREAM CORP. MEGA DREAM CORP. 75-03 37TH AVENUE JACKSON HEIGHTS 11372- Yes METRO MINI MARKET NY INC METRO MINI MARKET NY INC 6512 METROPOLITAN AVE MIDDLE VILLAGE 11379- Yes MIDDLE EASTERN GROCERY MIDDLE EASTERN GROCERY 2512 STEINWAY STREET LONG ISLAND CITY 11103- Yes MSZ SUPERMARKET INC MSZ SUPERMARKET INC 16010 HILLSIDE AVENUE JAMAICA 11432- Yes MUHARRAM JR. HAITHAM S MUHARRAM JR. HAITHAM S 201 BEACH 116TH STREET ROCKAWAY 11694-

Page 38 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid MUKUL DELI & GROCERY, INC MUKUL DELI & GROCERY, INC 3456 33 STREET QUEENS 11106- Yes N & H GOURMET DELI INC N & H GOURMET DELI INC 7720 101 AVENUE QUEENS 11416- Yes NEW CIBAO GROCERY INC NEW CIBAO GROCERY INC 18602 122ND AVENUE JAMAICA 11413- NEW WONG CORP NEW WONG CORP 75-06 JAMAICA AVENUE WOODHAVEN 11421- Yes NEWS AT 31 INC NEWS AT 31 INC. 2244 31ST STREET ASTORIA 11105- Yes NORAN DELI & GROCERY INC NORAN DELI & GROCERY INC. 13116 MERRICK BOULEVARD JAMAICA 11434- NORAN DELI & GROCERY INC NORAN DELI & GROCERY INC 13116 MERRICK BOULEVARD JAMAICA 11434- NORAN DELI & GROCERY INC NORAN DELI & GROCERY INC 13116 MERRICK BOULEVARD JAMAICA 11434- NORTHERN BLVD DELI & GROCERY CORP NORTHERN BLVD DELI & GROCERY CORP 104-22 NORTHERN BOULEVARD CORONA 11368- Yes NY 588 CORP NY 588 CORP. 136-08 BOOTH MEMORIAL AVE FLUSHING 11355- Yes NY DELI STOP 1 INC NY DELI STOP 1 INC 168-24 HILLSIDE AVENUE JAMAICA 11432- Yes OLD CASTLE FRESH FARM CORP OLD CASTLE FRESH FARM CORP 39-52 QUEENS BOULEVARD SUNNYSIDE 11104- Yes OMAR DELI GROCERY OMAR DELI GROCERY 220-33 JAMAICA AVENUE QUEENS VILLAGE 11428- Yes OZONE PARK OPERATIONS INC OZONE PARK OPERATIONS INC 8814 101ST STREET OZONE PARK 11416- Yes PADMA USA INC PADMA USA INC 14301 HILLSIDE AVENUE JAMAICA 11435- Yes PARKSIDE FOOD MARKET INC PARKSIDE FOOD MARKET INC. 18-59 DITMARS BLVD ASTORIA 11105- Yes PATBRO INC/INACTIVE PATBRO INC 163-10 PIDGEON MEADOW RD FLUSING 11358- Yes PIERRE AND ALBERT INC PIERRE AND ALBERT INC 40-08 30TH AVENUE ASTORIA 11103- Yes PIN DELI & GROCERY CORP PIN DELI & GROCERY CORP 9101 80TH STREET WOODHAVEN 11421- Yes PLAY BALL DELI PLAY BALL DELI 138-17 JAMAICA AVENUE JAMAICA 11435- Yes QUEEN BEE FOOD STORE INC QUEEN BEE FOOD STORE INC 43-82 162ND STREET FLUSHING 11358- Yes QUICK DELI & CANDY CORP QUICK DELI & CANDY CORP 8202 ROOSEVELT AVENUE JACKSON HEIGHTS 11372- Yes QUICK STOP & SHOP DELI GROCERY CORP QUICK STOP & SHOP DELI GROCERY CORP 9202 37TH AVENUE JACKSON HEIGHTS 11372- Yes R & H BROTHERS INC R & H BROTHERS INC 1702 LINDEN STREET RIDGEWOOD 11385- Yes RGA SEVEN DOLLAR DISCOUNT HOUSE INC RGA SEVEN DOLLAR DISCOUNT HOUSE INC 8220B ELIOT AVENUE MIDDLE VILLAGE 11379- Yes ROCA GROCERY CORP ROCA GROCERY CORP. 146-14 ROCKAWAY BLVD JAMAICA 11436- ROCKAWAY PLAZA FOOD, INC ROCKAWAY PLAZA FOOD, INC 15418 ROCKAWAY BLVD JAMAICA 11434- Yes RODEO DELI-GROCERY CORP RODEO DELI-GROCERY CORP. 98-30 CORONA AVENUE CORONA 11368- Yes S & A GROCERY & CANDY S & A GROCERY & CANDY 116-69 SUTPHIN BOULEVARD JAMAICA 11434- SAIFUL DELI GROCERY INC SAIFUL DELI GROCERY INC 12302 METROPOLITAN AVE KEW GARDENS 11415- Yes SAINT BISHOY GROCERY INC SAINT BISHOY GROCERY INC 607 WOODWARD AVENUE RIDGEWOOD 11385- Yes SAINT SHENOUDA INC SAINT SHENOUDA INC 818 WOODWARD AVENUE QUEENS 11385- Yes SATKAIVAL USA INC SATKAIVAL USA INC 7152 YELLOWSTONE BLVD FOREST HILLS 11375- Yes SENECA FALAFEL INC SENECA FALAFEL INC 766 SENECA AVENUE RIDGEWOOD 11385- Yes SENECA FALAFEL INC SENECA FALAFEL INC. 766 SENECA AVENUE RIDGEWOOD 11385- Yes SEVEN DAYS FOOD STORE INC. SEVEN DAYS FOOD STORE INC. 90-83 SUTPHIN BOULEVARD JAMICA 11435- Yes SHEMSON GROCERY SHEMSON GROCERY 87-68A SUTPHIN BLVD JAMAICA 11435- Yes SHIV KAILASH INC SHIV KAILASH INC 4032 162ND STREET FLUSHING 11358- Yes SINBO INC SINBO INC 4024 GREENPOINT AVENUE SUNNYSIDE 11104- Yes SIX STAR DELI & GROCERY INC SIX STAR DELI & GROCERY INC 106-65 160TH STREET JAMAICA 11433-

Page 39 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid SOUTH CORNER DELI GROCERY CORP SOUTH CORNER DELI GROCERY CORP 106-32 SUTPHIN BOULEVARD JAMAICA 11435- Yes SPRING DELI & TOBACCO INC 21915 JAMAICA AVENUE QUEENS VILLAGE 11428- Yes SPRING DELI AND TOBACCO INC 21915 JAMAICA AVENUE QUEENS 11428- Yes STAR BUY INC STAR BUY INC. 9464 CORONA AVENUE ELMHURST 11373- Yes STOP 163 DELI CORP STOP 163 DELI CORP. 163-10 89TH AVENUE JAMAICA 11432- Yes STR NEWS STAND INC STR NEWS STAND INC 4004 QUEENS BOULEVARD SUNNYSIDE 11104- Yes SUTPHIN CORP II SUTPHIN CORP II.. 109-18 SUTPHIN BOULEVARD JAMAICA 11435- SYRENA GROCERY INC SYRENA GROCERY INC 61-01 56TH ROAD MASPETH 11378- Yes T & S SUPER SHELL STATION INC T & S SUPER SHELL STATION INC 74-01 GRAND AVENUE ELMHURST 11373- Yes TAKATY DELI CORP TAKATY DELI CORP 201-15 LINDEN BLVD ALBANS 11412- Yes TAKE & PAY INC TAKE & PAY INC 184-27 JAMAICA AVE HOLLIS 11423- Yes THE CANGRI FOOD CORP THE CANGRI FOOD CORP 1683 MADISON STREET RIDGEWOOD 11385- Yes THE SANDWICH PRINCE INC THE SANDWICH PRINCE INC 11801 SUTPHIN BLVD QUEENS 11434- TULIP DELI & GROCERY CORP TULIP DELI & GROCERY CORP. 15723 ROCKAWAY BLVD JAMAICA 11434- Yes U & H DELI GROCERY INC U & H DELI GROCERY INC 168-19/27 BAISLEY BLVD JAMAICA 11434- Yes US DELI #1 CORP US DELI #1 CORP 8334 PARSONS BLVD JAMAICA 11432- Yes US EXPRESS DELI & GROCERY INC US EXPRESS DELI & GROCERY INC 50-62 69TH STREET WOODSIDE 11377- Yes V&M INTERNATIONAL DELI GROCERY CORP V&M INTERNATIONAL DELI GROCERY CORP 98-20 41ST AVENUE CORONA 11368- Yes WALGREEN EASTERN CO INC WALGREEN EASTERN CO INC 78-11 NORTHEN BLVD JACKSON HEIGHTS 11372- Yes WALGREENS #01487 WALGREENS #01487 104-25- QUEENS BOULEVARD FLUSHING 11375- Yes WHITNEY DELI & GROCERY INC WHITNEY DELI & GROCERY INC 86-24 WHITNEY AVENUE ELMHURST 11373- WHITNEY GROCERY INC WHITNEY GROCERY INC 8525 WHITNEY AVENUE ELMHURST 11373- Yes WINGHING 99 CENTS STORE INC. WINGHING 99 CENTS STORE INC. 9026 43RD AVENUE ELMHURST 11373- Yes XI YANG YANG MARKET INC XI YANG YANG MARKET INC 8220 ROOSEVELT AVENUE JACKSON HEIGHTS 11372- Yes Y & G DELI GROCERY CORP Y & H DELI GROCERY CORP 110-52 FARMERS BLVD SAINT ALBANS 11412- Yes Z & X STORE INC Z & X STORE INC 65-33 AUSTIN STREET REGO PARK 11374- Yes ZHANG, HANG DONG BEN'S 99¢ STORE. 3510 30TH AVENUE ASTORIA 11103- Yes RENSSELAER

4 STAR GROCERY 4 STAR GROCERY 273 4TH STREET TROY 12180- Yes BROADWAY NEWS OF TROY BROADWAY NEWS OF TROY INC. 207 BROADWAY TROY 12180- Yes CONGRESS DELI AND GROCERY CONGRESS DELI AND GROCERY INC. 355 CONGRESS STREET TROY 12180- Yes HOOSICK STREET DISCOUNT BEVERAGE HOOSICK STREET DISCOUNT BEVERAGE 2200 19TH STREET TROY 12180- Yes IBB SMOKE SHOP IBB SMOKE SHOP BORJ TRADING INC 70 CONGRESS STREET TROY 12180- Yes MARPES COUNTRY STORE MARPES COUNTRY STORE 2579 ROUTE 67 JOHNSONVILLE 12094- Yes OLOMPIA GROCERY & DELI OLOMPIA GROCERY & DELI 95 CONGRESS STREET TROY 12180- Yes STAR MINI MARKET MAURICE'S GRILL DELI & GROCERY 88 THRID STREET TROY 12180- Yes STEVEN MART STEVEN MART 47 WASHINGTON AVENUE RENSSELAER 12144- Yes SUNOCO SAIM MART INC. 125 MILL STREET TROY 12180- Yes SUNOCO MART GREENBUSH SUNOCO 447 GREENBUSH ROAD RENSSELAER 12144- Yes

Page 40 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid TROY FOOD MART GAS ELITE 95 HILL STREET TROY 12180- Yes RICHMOND

107 DELI GROCERY CORP 107 DELI GROCERY CORP 107-05 JAMAICA AVENUE RICHMOND 11418- Yes 111-15 JAMAICA FOOD CORP 111-15 JAMAICA FOOD CORP 111-15 JAMAICA AVENUE RICHMOND HILL 11418- 121 DELI INC 121 DELI INC. 12022 101ST AVENUE S. RICHMOND HILL 11419- Yes 49 APPLE GROCERY, INC 49 APPLE GROCERY, INC 49 VICTORY BOULEVARD STATEN ISLAND 10301- Yes 9402 GAS STATION INC 9402 GAS STATION INC 9402 111TH SQUARE S RICHMOND HILL 11419- Yes A & A MINIMARKET II INC A & A MINIMARKET II INC 14319 97TH AVENUE RICHMOND HILL 11435- Yes A & S FOREST FOOD CORP A & S FOREST FOOD CORP 607 FOREST AVENUE STATEN ISLAND 10310- Yes ALKAIFI, SALEH M. ALKAIFI, SALEH M. 1215 CASTLETON AVENUE STATEN ISLAND 10310- Yes ALKHARAF DELI & GROCERY INC ALKHARAF DELI & GROCERY INC 11 TOMPKINS AVENUE STATEN ISLAND 10304- Yes ANTIMO'S FAMILY DELI INC ANTIMO'S FAMILY DELI INC 515 JEWETTE AVENUE STATEN ISLAND 10302- AVS DELI & GROCERY INC AVS DELI & GROCERY INC 400 VICTORY BOULEVARD STATEN ISLAND 10301- Yes B & M BAGELS AND GROCERY INC. B & M BAGELS AND GROCERY INC. 203 GIFFORDS LANE STATEN ISLAND 10308- Yes BROADWAY CORNE DELI & GROCERY CORP BROADWAY CORNE DELI & GROCERY CORP 251 BROADWAY STATEN ISLAND 10310- Yes CASTLETON GROCERY CASTLETON GROCERY 1293 CASTLETON AVENUE STATEN ISLAND 10310- Yes CLASSIC NEWSSTAND INC CLASSIC NEWSSTAND INC 2655 RICHMOND AVENUE STATEN ISLAND 10314- Yes CONVENIENT FOOD MART CONVENIENT FOOD MART 2-6 NEW DORP LANE STATEN ISLAND 10306- Yes CVS PHARMACY #6052 CVS 250 PAGE AVENUE STATEN ISLAND 10307- Yes CVS PHARMACY#6055 CVS PHARMACY#6055.. 5830 AMBOY ROAD STATEN ISLAND 10309- Yes CVS PHARMACY#6055 CVS PHARMACY#6055.. 5830 AMBOY ROAD STATEN ISLAND 10309- Yes DELI-ICIOUS LLC DELI-ICIOUS LLC 1986 HYLAND BOULEVARD STATEN ISLAND 10306- Yes EL BLOQUE DELI CORP EL BLOQUE DELI CORP 13207 JAMAICA AVENUE RICHMOND HILL 11418- Yes ELEGANT GRILL & DELI INC ELEGANT GRILL & DELI INC 35 VICTORY BOULEVARD STATEN ISLAND 10301- Yes FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF NEW YORK INC FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF NEW YORK INC 135 CANAL STREET STATEN ISLAND 10304- Yes FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF NEW YORK INC FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF NEW YORK INC 124 PORT RICHMOND AVENUE STATEN ISLAND 10302- Yes FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF NEW YORK INC FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF NEW YORK INC 135 CANAL STREET STATEN ISLAND 10304- Yes FOOD N GROCERY INC FOOD N GROCERY INC 744 PORT ROCHMOND AVE STATEN ISLAND 10302- Yes H20 AUTO SPA, INC H20 AUTO SPA, INC 2545 HYLAN BLVD STATEN ISLAND 10306- HEARTLAND CONVENIENCE MARKETS, INC. HEARTLAND CONVENIENCE MARKETS, INC.. 645-101 ROSSVILLE AVE STATEN ISLAND 10309- Yes INDORE INC INDORE INC 1404 FOREST AVENUE STATEN ISLAND 10302- Yes ISLAND CONVENIENCE STORE INC ISLAND CONVENIENCE STORE INC 2031 FOREST AVENUE STATEN ISLAND 10303- Yes JMD SERVICE STATION INC JMD SERVICE STATION INC 130-14 HILLSIDE AVENUE RICHMOND HILL 11418- Yes JOHNNY FOOD CORP JOHNNY FOOD CORP 418 JERSEY STREET STATEN ISLAND 10301- Yes JOHNNY FOOD CORP JOHNNY FOOD CORP 418 JERSEY STREET STATEN ISLAND 10301- Yes JUAN DELI GROCERY JUAN DELI GROCERY/INACTIVE 130-02 ATLANTIC AVENUE S. RICHMOND HILL 11419- K & A GROCERY & DELI K & A GROCERY & DELI 196 BAY STREET STATEN ISLAND 10301- Yes MANANA GROCERY CORP MANANA GROCERY CORP 12519 JAMAICA AVENUE RICHMOND HILL 11418- Yes N &N NYC DELI GORCERY INC N &N NYC DELI GORCERY INC 11302 JAMAICA AVENUE RICHMOND HILL 11418- Yes

Page 41 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid NANDO DELI CORP NANDO DELI CORP 102-02 JAMAICA AVENUE RICHMOND HILL 11418- Yes NEW YOU ME CORP NEW YOU ME CORP 2626 HYLAND BOULEVARD STATEN ISLAND 10306- Yes PORT RICHMOND DISCOUNT INC PORT RICHMOND DISCOUNT INC. 203 PORT RICHMOND AVE STATEN ISLAND 10302- PRINCE ALI DELI AND GROCERY INC PRINCE ALI DELI AND GROCERY INC 132-02 LIBERTY AVENUE RICHMOND HILL 11419- Yes Q 10 MINI MART INC Q 10 MINI MART INC 101-05 LEFFERTS BLVD S. RICHMOND HILL 11419- Yes Q10 ENTERPRISES INC Q10 ENTERPRISES INC 118-18 JAMAICA AVENUE RICHMOND HILL 11418- Yes RICHMOND EMPORIUM INC RICHMOND EMPORIUM INC 1307 ARTHUR KILL ROAD STATEN ISLAND 10312- Yes RICHMOND HILL DELI CORP RICHMOND HILL DELI CORP 123-07 JAMAICA AVENUE RICHMOND HILL 11418- Yes RINOM'S DELI AND GROCERY INC RINOM'S DELI AND GROCERY INC 11401 ATLANTIC AVENUE RICHMOND HILL 11418- RITE AID RITE AID # 10538 43-68 AMBOY ROAD STATEN ISLAND 10312- Yes RUBEN CORNER CONVENIENCE CORP RUBEN CORNER CONVENIENCE 2220 FOREST AVENUE STATEN ISLAND 10303- Yes RUP FOOD MART INC RUP FOOD MART INC 4020 AMBOY ROAD STATEN ISLAND 10308- Yes S & T BAGELS & DELI CORP S & T BAGELS & DELI CORP 463 FOREST AVENUE STATEN ISLAND 10301- Yes SEM CITY MIST INC SEM CITY MIST INC 2048 VICTORY BOULEVARD STATEN ISLAND 10314- SOUTH AVE AROUND THE CLOCK INC SOUTH AVE AROUND THE CLOCK INC 171 SOUTH AVENUE STATEN ISLAND 10303- Yes STATEN ISLAND SPORTSCARD INC STATEN ISLAND SPORTSCARD INC. 27 SEGUINE AVENUE STATEN ISLAND 10309- Yes SUAD DELI CORP SUAD DELI CORP 62 RICHMOND TERRACE STATEN ISLAND 10301- Yes THE STOP & SHOP SUPERMARKET CO THE STOP & SHOP SUPERMARKET CO. 2795 RICHMOND AVENUE STATEN ISLAND 10314- Yes VALUE DELI & GRILL INC VALUE DELI & GRILL INC 281 SOUTH AVENUE STATEN ISLAND 10303- Yes WALDBAUM # 813 WALDBAUM 6400 AMBOY ROAD STATEN ISLAND 10309- Yes WALDBAUM #849 WALDBAUM 375 TOMPKINS AVENUE STATEN ISLAND 10305- Yes WALGREENS #11845 WALGREENS #11845. 2191 RICHMOND AVENUE STATEN ISLAND 10314- Yes WATERFRONT GAS & CONVENIENCE STORE WATERFRONT GAS & CONVENIENCE STORE 1125 RICHMOND TERRACE STATEN ISLAND 10310- Yes WELCOME DELI GROCERY CORP WELCOME DELI GROCERY CORP 1616 CASTLETON AVENUE STATEN ISLAND 10302- Yes YOUR TASTE DELI, INC. YOUR TASTE DELI, INC. 2524 FOREST AVENUE STATEN ISLAND 10303- Yes ROCKLAND

7- ELEVEN 7-ELEVEN # 19389C 14 COLLEGE ROAD MONSEY 10952- Yes COLONEL'S DELI 25A OLD ROUTE 202 POMONA 10970- Yes CONVENIENCE PLUS 12 CENTRAL AVENUE PEARL RIVER 10965- Yes CVS CVS PHARMACY # 2205 274 OLD NYACK SPRING VALLEY 10977- Yes MOBIL 275 ROUTE 59 NANUET 10954- Yes ORLANDO'S DELI 20 MYRTLE AVENUE SPRING VALLEY 10977- Yes SHOP RITE 56 RAMPO ROAD GARNERVILLE 10923- Yes ULTIMATE GASOLINE 81 LIBERTY DRIVE STONY POINT 10980- Yes VILLAGE SENSATIONS 111 MAIN STREET NANUET 10954- Yes SARATOGA

GANSEVOORT MINIMART GANSEVOORT MINIMART 1284 STATE ROUTE 9 GANSEVOORT 12831- Yes

Page 42 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid

SCHENECTADY

DABB CITY DABB CITY 125 MOHAWK STREET SCOTIA 12302- Yes FAMILY DOLLAR #2043 FAMILY DOLLAR STORES 1491 STATE STREET SCHENECTADY 12304- Yes HESS SPEEDWAY 1909 CURRY ROAD SCHENECTADY 12306- Yes HIGH CLASS DELI GROCERY HIGH CLASS DELI GROCERY 851 CRANE STREET SCHENECTADY 12303- Yes JOES MOBIL JOE'S MOBIL 1210 ALTAMONT AVENUE ROTTERDAM 12303- Yes JOES MOBIL JOE'S MOBIL 1210 ALTAMONT AVENUE ROTTEDAM 12303- Yes MAHA PETROLEUM MAHA PETROLEUM INC. 591 BROADWAY SCHENECTADY 12305- Yes RAIZADA MART RAIZADA MART 1747 UNION STREET SCHENECTADY 12309- Yes STATE STREET CONVENIENCE STATE STREET CONVENIENCE 1339 STATE STREET SCHENECTADY 12304- Yes ZAID DISCOUNT ZAID DISCOUNT 808 ALBANY STREET SCHENECTADY 12307- SCHOHARIE

E&P DEV INC. JIYA CORP. 1363 STATE ROUTE 10 JEFFERSON 12093- Yes ST LAWRENCE

HELENA GENERAL STORE HELENA GENERAL STORE 28 MAIN STREET HELENA 13649- Yes LAMPHERE'S MARKET LAMPHERE'S MARKET 2798 STATE HIGHWAY 11B POTSDAM 13676- Yes NICE N EASY #2308 NICE N EASY 301 CHAMPLAIN STREET OGDENSBURG 13669- Yes ON-A-ROLL DELI ON-A-ROLL DELI 50 NORTH MAIN ROAD MASSENA 13660- Yes STEUBEN

ACORN MARKET #11 ACORN MARKET 121 FRONT STREET ADDISON 14801- Yes SUBGARDI'S W & W SUBGARDI'S W & W 6161 ROUTE 417 ADDISON 14801- Yes SUFFOLK

7-11 7-ELEVEN 128 CARLETON AVENUE ISLIP TERRACE 11752- Yes 7-11 #16440D 7-11 MAIN ROAD CUTCHOGUE 11935- Yes 7-11 #25520B 7-ELEVEN 1999 NEW YORK AVENUE HUNTINGTON STATION 11746- Yes 7-ELEVEN 7-ELEVEN 6230 JERICHO TURNPIKE COMMACK 11725- 7-ELEVEN #34034A 7-ELEVEN 1000 WELLWOOD AVE WEST BABYLON 11704- Yes A & K STATIONARY A & K STATIONARY 863 LONG ISLAND AVENUE DEER PARK 11729- AROMA SMOKE SHOP AROMA SMOKE SHOP 6 E. MAIN STREET SMITHTOWN 11787- Yes BABYLON BEVERAGE BABYLON BEVERAGE 345 LITTLE EAST NECK RD WEST BABYLON 11704- Yes BESIM'S FINE CIGARS BESIMS FINE CIGARS 99 JOBS LANE SOUTHAMPTON 11968- Yes BING'S SMOKE SHOP & GROCERY BING'S SMOKE SHOP & GROCERY 1002 MONTAUK HWY COPIAGUE 11726- Yes CARDS SMART CARDS SMART 18 VETERAN'S HWY COMMACK 11725- Yes

Page 43 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid CARDS SMART CARDS SMART 18 VETERAN'S HWY COMMACK 11725- CIRCLE M BEVERAGE BARN CIRCLE M BEVERAGE BARN 160 MONTAUK HWY WESTHAMPTON 11978- Yes CITGO CITGO 1905 E. JERHICO TPKE & ELLWOOD RD HUNTINGTON 11743- Yes COLLADO HOOKAH COLLADO HOOKAH 80 G MONTAUK HIGHWAY SUITE E COPIAGUE 11726- Yes CVS PHARMACY CVS PHARMACY 355A BROADWAY AMITYVILLE 11701- Yes CVS PHARMACY CVS PHARMACY 341 COMMACK ROAD COMMACK 11725- Yes DEV CARDS & GIFTS DEV CARDS & GIFTS 460 COUNTY ROAD 111 MANORVILLE 11949- Yes EXIT 42 DELI EXIT 42 DELI 270 SPUR DRIVE SOUTH BAY SHORE 11702- Yes GOLD COAST CIGARS GOLD COAST CIGARS 246 LARKFIELD ROAD EAST NORTHPORT 11731- Yes GOODFELLAS CIGARS & TOBACCO GOODFELLAS CIGARS & TOBACCO 2215 MEDFORD AVENUE MEDFORD 11763- Yes GREAT RIVER DELI GREAT RIVER DELI 58 RIVER ROAD GREAT RIVER 11739- GREAT RIVER DELI GREAT RIVER DELI 58 RIVER ROAD GREAT RIVER 11739- Yes GULF GULF 253 BROADWAY HUNTINGTON 11743- Yes HAMPTON MARKET PLACE HAMPTON MARKET PLACE 36 RACE LANE EAST HAMPTON 11937- Yes HANDY PANTRY HANDY PANTRY 876 CHURCH STREET BOHEMIA 11716- Yes HANDY PANTRY HANDY PANTRY 12250 MAIN ROAD MATTITUCK 11952- Yes HESS #32343 HESS 4800 DEER PARK & GRAND AVE DEER PARK 11729- Yes HESS MART HESS MART 2012 RT 112 MEDFORD 11763- Yes J & C GIFT, CANDLE & LOTTO J & C GIFT, CANDLE & LOTTO 600-12 PORTION ROAD RONKONKOMA 11779- Yes LISA'S CARDS & GIFTS LISA'S CARDS & GIFTS 700-30 PATCHOGUE-YAPHANK RD MEDFORD 11763- Yes MARCOS BROOK DELI MARCOS BROOK DELI 87 BROOK STREET BAY SHORE 11706- Yes MERMAID MARKET MERMAID MARKET 780-A BAY WALK OCEAN BEACH 11770- Yes MILK N'THINGS MILK N'THINGS 1287 A DEER PARK AVENUE NORTH BABYLON 11703- Yes MOBIL BOLLA MARKET 5477 ROUTE 347 MOUNT SINAI 11766- Yes MR. ROBERTS GENERAL STORE GMS GROCERY 300 FRONT STREET GREENPORT 11944- Yes MR. TOBACCO MR. TOBACCO 17 SINGER LANE SMITHTOWN 11787- NANITOS DELI NANITOS DELI 1036 LITTLE EAST NECK ROAD WEST BABYLON 11704- Yes PATHMARK PATHMARK 800 MONTAUK HWY. SHIRLEY 11967- Yes R.M. GROCERY R.M. GROCERY 40 E. SUFFOLK AVENUE CENTRAL ISLIP 11722- Yes RITE AID RITE AID 836 SUNRIS HWY BAY SHORE 11706- Yes RITE AID #5665 RITE AID 2799 ROUTE 112 MEDFORD 11763- Yes RODRIGUEZ DELI ENTERPRISE RODRIGUEZ DELI ENTERPRISE 99 MIDDLE COUNTRY ROAD CORAM 11727- Yes SHELL SHELL 9 LAKE AVENUE RIVERHEAD 11901- Yes SHOP RITE SHOP RITE 64 ROUTE 109 WEST BABYLON 11704- Yes SMART MART EXPRESS SMART MART EXPRESS 731 MIDDLE COUNTRY ROAD ST JAMES 11780- Yes SOUTH FORK DELI SOUTH FORK DELI 863 COUNTY ROAD 39 SOUTHAMPTON 11968- Yes SUNOCO SUNOCO 669 OLD TOWN ROAD PORT JEFFERSON STATIO 11776- Yes SUNRISE SUPERMARKET SUNRISE SUPERMARKET 49 E SUNRISE HWY LINDENJURST 11757- Yes THE BARN THE BARN 370 HAWKINS AVENUE RONKONKOMA 11779- Yes THERESAS COFFEE CABOOSE THERESA'S COFFEE CABOOSE 82 B SURREY CIRCLE SHIRLEY 11967- Yes

Page 44 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid TROPICAL MARKET TROPICAL MARKET 155 SUNRISE HWY & STRAIGHT PATH LINDENHURST 11757- Yes US1 GAS US1 GAS 607 STATION ROAD BELLPORT 11713- Yes VALERO VALERO 620 MONTAUK HWY EAST MORICHES 11940- Yes WALGREENS WALGREENS 102 NORTH MAIN STREET SAYVILLE 11782- Yes WAL-MART WAL-MART 85 CROOKED HILL ROAD COMMACK 11725- Yes WAVE WAVE 4740 SUNRISE HWY BOHEMIA 11716- Yes XTRA XTRA WILLIAM FLOYD PARKWAY SHIRLEY 11967- Yes SULLIVAN

CATSKILL GROCERS CATSKILL GROCERS INC. 41 STEWART AVENUE ROSCOE 12776- Yes GOOD FELLOWS MARKET GOOD FELLOWS MARKET INC. 5239 MAIN STREET SOUTH FALLSBURG 12779- Yes TIOGA

DANDY MINI MART DANDY MINI MART 2 OWEGO ROAD CANDOR 13743- EXPRESS MART #349 EXPRESS MART 1081 ROUTE 17C OWEGO 13827- Yes FAMILY DOLLAR STORE #4365 FAMILY DOLLAR 42 WEST MAIN STREET OWEGO 13827- Yes OWEGO E-Z MART QUICKWAY MAIN WEST MAIN STREET OWEGO 13827- QUICKWAY FOOD STORE QUICKWAY FOOD STORE 23 MAIN STREET NEWARK VALLEY 13811- Yes RED APPLE FOOD MART RED APPLE FOOD MART 8894 STATE ROUTE 434 APALACHIN 13732- RITE AID RITE AID PHARMACY MAIN STREET OWEGO 13827- SUNOCO XTRA MART 186 OWEGO STREET CANDOR 13743- Yes SUNOCO MINI MART DAY & NIGHT 112 NORTH AVENUE OWEGO 13827- Yes SWEENY'S MARKET SWEENY'S MARKET 6518 STATE ROUTE 434 APALACHIN 13732- Yes TIOGA DOWNS TIOGA DOWNS RACETRACK LLC 2384 RIVER ROAD NICHOLS 13812- Yes TOMPKINS

CLARK'S SHUR FINE CLARK'S SHUR FINE 33 NORTH STREET DRYDEN 13053- ULSTER

EXXON VERONA OIL CO. MAIN & NEWTON STREETS PHOENICIA 12464- Yes KENNEDY FRIED CHICKEN MSS FOOD CORP 592 BROADWAY KINGSTON 12401- Yes PX EXPRESS PIONEER EXCHANGE EXPRESS 6117 ROUTE 209 KERHONSON 12446- Yes SUNOCO 209 EXPRESS MART SOUTH ROUTE 209 KERHONKSON 12446- Yes TILLSON GENERAL STORE TILLSON GENERAL STORE 735 SPRINGTOWN ROAD TILLSON 12486- TOBACCO ROLL 1 LLC TOBACCO ROLL 1 LLC 900 ULSTER AVENUE KINGSTON 12401- Yes VALERO BIG BELLY DELI 3981 ROUTE 32 SAUGERTIES 12477- Yes WARREN

Page 45 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid CLEVERDALE COUNTRY STORE CLEVERDALE COUNTRY STORE 2660 ROUTE 9L QUEENSBURY 12804- Yes POT BELLY DELI & COUNTRY STORE POT BELLY DELI & COUNTRY STORE 3711 LAKE SHORE DRIVE DIAMOND POINT 12845- Yes WATER'S EDGE MARINA WATER'S EDGE MARINA 47 SAGAMORE ROAD BOLTON LANDING 12814- Yes WASHINGTON

CUMBERLAND FARMS #1530 CUMBERLAND FARMS 75 MAIN STREET HUDSON FALLS 12839- Yes WAYNE

HARRY'S ENERGY INC. HARRY'S ENERGY INC. 3885 STATE ROUTE 104 WILLIAMSON 14589- Yes WESTCHESTER

76 STATION - VILLAGE PANTRY PALISADES FUEL INC. 1 BROADWAY PLEASANTVILLE 10570- Yes 7-ELEVEN #25680C KWANGWOO KIM 488 BEDFORD ROAD PLEASANTVILLE 10570- Yes 7-ELEVEN #34351A 7-ELEVEN 167 MARTINE AVENUE WHITE PLAINS 10601- Yes A & P #32-194 GREAT ATLANTIC AND PACIFIC TEA COMPANY 20 WELCHER AVENUE PEEKSKILL 10566- Yes ANGELO'S DELI VAN CORTLAND PARK DELICATESSEN INC. 54 VAN CORTLANDT PARK AVE YONKERS 10701- Yes BN'S VARIETY STORE VK VARIETY INC. 25 GRAND STREET MOUNT VERNON 10550- Yes BP E. POST ROAD GASMART INC 34 POST ROAD WHITE PLAINS 10606- Yes CIGAR WAREHOUSE SHAWAL INC. 119 CENTRAL PARK AVENUE SCARSDALE 10583- Yes CITGO 124 LEXINGOTN AVE INC 124 LEXINGTON AVENUE WHITE PLAINS 10601- Yes CVS #4745 CVS PHARMACY INC. 26 MAMARONECK AVENUE WHITE PLAINS 10601- Yes CVS PHARMACY #0530 CVS ALBANY LLC 309 MAIN STREET NEW ROCHELLE 10801- Yes CVS PHARMACY #1770 CVS ALBANY LLC 325 MAMARONECK AVENUE WHITE PLAINS 10605- Yes CVS PHARMACY #1940 CVS ALBANY LLC 585 YONKERS AVENUE YONKERS 10704- Yes CVS PHARMACY #4539 CVS ALBANY LLC 25-43 PROSPECT STREET YONKERS 10701- Yes DAISY'S CARD & GIFT SHOP DAISY'S CARD & GIFT SHOP 8 BROADWAY YONKERS 10701- Yes DOM'S DELI & GRILLE HOUSE DOM'S DELI & GRILLE HOUSE 284 SAW MILL RIVER ROAD ELMSFORD 10523- Yes DY GROCERY & DELI DY GROCERY & DELI 271 FIRST STREET MOUNTY VERNON 10550- GETTY JIZMO MINI MART 681 LINCOLN AVENUE MOUNT VERNON 10550- Yes GROCERY CENTRO AMERICA GROCERY CENTRO AMERICA INC 199 1/2 IRVING AVENUE PORT CHESTER 10573- Yes J & D BODEGA GROCERY J & D BODEGA GROCERY CORP 68 HERRIOT STREET YONKERS 10705- Yes J & J LUNCHEONETTE ANA ANTONIO 1581 CENTRAL PARK AVENUE YONKERS 10710- Yes LA CABANA BAR & RESTAURANT LA CABANA BAR & RESTAURANT 206 ASHBURTON AVENUE YONKERS 10701- Yes LA ESQUINA LATINA LA ESQUINA LATINA 95 COLLEGE AVENUE SLEEPY HOLLOW 10591- Yes LUCIO'S DELI LOBATO & LUNA INC. 57 GRAMATAN AVENUE MOUNT VERNON 10550- Yes LUKOIL EMIS AUTO CENTER INC. 268 TARRYTOWN ROAD WHITE PLAINS 10607- LUKOIL M & S GASMART INC 185 HIGHLAND AVENUE OSSINING 10562- MANA FOOD MANA FOOD CENTER CORP. 120-126 SPRING STREET OSSINING 10562- Yes MANOR AUTO SERVICE CENTER MANOR AUTO SERVICE CENTER INC. 135 SHORE ROAD PELHAM 10803- Yes

Page 46 of 47 Penalized Tobacco Retailers and Vendors 04/01/2014 - 03/31/2015 COUNTY Zip Code Vending Fine Facility Name Legal Name Street Address City Machine Paid MI NEGRO DELI GROCERY MI NEGRO DELI GROCERY CORP. 197 VAN CORTLANDT PARK AVE YONKERS 10705- Yes MOBIL YONKERS GAS & CONVENIENCE INC. 1230 NEPPERHAN AVENUE YONKERS 10703- Yes MOBIL KDA INCORPORATED 1770 MAIN STREET MOHEGAN LAKE 10547- Yes MOBIL GUNKS HOLDING COMPANY 891 SAW MILL RIVER ROAD ARDSLEY 10502- Yes MOBIL CHESTNUT MARTS INC 215 BROADWAY SLEEPY HOLLOW 10591- Yes MOBIL CHESTNUT MARTS INC 30 LINCOLN AVENUE PELHAM 10803- NEW ROCHELLE DELI WESTCHESTER FOUR STAR DELI INC. 476 MAIN STREET NEW ROCHELLE 10801- Yes NEW STOP DELI & GROCERY NEW STOP DELI & GROCERY 563-573 BROADWAY YONKERS 10705- ONE STOP SHOP ONE STOP SHOP GROCERY CORP. 108 ELM STREET YONKERS 10701- Yes PEEKSKILL GAS & FOOD PEEKSKILL GAS & FOOD INC. 800 DIVISION STREET PEEKSKILL 10566- Yes R&W DOLLAR WORLD R&W DOLLAR WORLD INC. 20 WELCHER AVENUE PEEKSKILL 10566- Yes REPUBLICA CIGAR LOUNGE REPUBLICA CIGARS INC. 550 GRAMATAN AVENUE MT VERNON 10550- Yes ROYAL SCARLET DELI ROYAL SCARLET DELI 99 POST ROAD WHITE PLAINS 10601- Yes SHELL FARROWS AUTO SERVICE INC 332 MANVILLE ROAD PLEASANTVILLE 10570- Yes SHELL CROSS RIVER DEMON SHELL SERVICE INC. 870 RT 35 CROSS RIVER 10518- Yes SHELL POST ROAD SHELL INC. 115 POST ROAD WHITE PLAINS 10606- Yes SHELL CENTRAL PARK FOOD CORP 731 CENTRAL PARK AVENUE YONKERS 10710- Yes SHELL J & E AUTO CARE INC 1821 COMMERCE STREET YORKTOWN HEIGHTS 10598- Yes SHELL EXECUTIVE CENTRAL SERVICE CORP 1 ENTERPRISE BLVD YONKERS 10701- Yes STATION SHOP H & D PLACE 211 HALSTEAD AVENUE MAMARONECK 10543- STOP & SHOP #500 STOP & SHOP SUPERMARKET CO. HARRISON STREET NEW ROCHELLE 10801- Yes THE FAMILY FOOD CENTER THE FAMILY FOOD CENTER LLC 100 LINDEN STREET YONKERS 10701- Yes TJ DELI TJ DELI 93 POST ROAD WHITE PLAINS 10601- VALENTINE'S GOURMET DELI RIVERDALE & VALENTINE DELI & GROCERY 466 RIVERDALE AVENUE YONKERS 10705- VALENTINE'S GOURMET DELI RIVERDALE & VALENTINE DELI & GROCERY 466 RIVERDALE AVENUE YONKERS 10705- VALLE DELI & GROCERY VALLE DELI & GROCERY 326 WALNUT STREET YONKERS 10701- Yes VINNY'S DISCOUNT CIGARETTES B&V TOBACCO CO. LLC 4408 BOSTON POST ROAD PELHAM MANOR 10803- Yes VINNY'S DISCOUNT CIGARETTES B&V TOBACCO CO. LLC 4408 BOSTON POST ROAD PELHAM MANOR 10803- Yes VRS CORP. VRS CORP 30 BROADWAY YONKERS 10701- Yes WAHDAN THREED DS DELI INC 503 SECOND AVENUE MOUNT VERNON 10550- Yes WALGREENS #11291 WALGREENS PHARMACY 11 ASHFORD AVENUE DOBBS FERRY 10522- Yes WYOMING

7-ELEVEN 7-ELEVEN 64 MAIN STREET WARSAW 14569- Yes

Page 47 of 47 Appendix 3 Youth Risk Behavior Survey (YRBS) Comparison New York State Results for 2013, 2011, 2009, and 2007

Tobacco Use

New York State 2013 New York State 2011 New York State 2009 New York State 2007

Total % of Total % of Total % of Total % of Male Female Grade 9 Grade 10 Grade 11 Grade 12 Male Female Grade 9 Grade 10 Grade 11 Grade 12 Male Female Grade 9 Grade 10 Grade 11 Grade 12 Male Female Grade 9 Grade 10 Grade 11 Grade 12 Behavioral Category Students Students Students Students

Tried cigarette smoking, even 30.9 31.7 30.9 24.1 26.7 33.2 40.4 33.5 34.3 32.7 26.4 30.9 36.9 39.9 37.2 39 35 29 35.3 39.3 46.8 45.4 45 45.7 35.1 44.8 49.3 54.5 one or two puffs

Under 13 when smoked whole NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA 8.2 9.6 6.7 10.3 7.5 7.5 7.2 11.1 12 10.1 10.9 11.9 9.3 10.7 first cigarette first time

Currently used tobacco (current cigarette use, current smokeless 16.4 20 12.6 11.8 13.6 19.1 21.8 NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA tobacco use or current cigar use)

Smoked cigarettes on one or 10.6 11.7 9.5 7.4 9.4 11.5 14.6 12.5 13.2 11.8 9.3 10.8 13.2 16.2 14.8 16.2 12.7 11.4 12.8 15.9 19.3 13.8 12.9 14.7 8.4 12.8 15 20.2 more days (past 30 days)

Smoked cigarettes on 20 or more NA NA NA NA NA NA NA 5.5 6.7 4.3 3.3 4 6.5 7.3 5.8 6.7 4.3 4.4 5 6.2 7.3 6 5.7 6.4 2.7 5.3 7.4 9.1 of the past 30 days

Smoked 10 or more cigarettes per day on days smoked (past 15.7 18.8 11.8 21.1 8.8 15.4 14.6 16.3 18.9 13.3 17.3 8.5 13 19.2 13.3 16.4 6.9 23.9 7.2 9 14.3 12.4 18.4 7.1 13.4 11 11.5 10.1 30 days) Smoked cigarettes on school property on one or more days NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA 6.5 7.2 5.3 5.9 5.4 7.4 7.2 5 5.2 4.7 3.3 5.2 4.6 5.9 (past 30 days) Ever smoked regularly, one or more cigarettes per day for 30 7.9 8.9 6.8 4.5 6 9.4 11.7 NA NA NA NA NA NA NA 9 9.7 7.6 6.8 7.4 10.5 11.3 10.5 9.9 11 7.4 9.6 10.3 14.7 days Current smokers who tried to quit smoking during the last 12 NA NA NA NA NA NA NA 7.9 8.5 7.4 5.1 8.4 8.8 10.1 38.8 35.8 43.2 46.8 36.9 39 35.9 57.3 54 60.4 68.4 60.4 56.2 51.4 months Used chewing tobacco or snuff on one or more days (past 30 7 11.2 2.4 6.8 5.5 7 7.9 7.3 1.1 3.4 7.3 6.5 5.2 8.1 7.5 12.2 2.2 6.3 6.2 8.4 8.4 5.1 8 2.1 4.1 4.2 4.7 5.9 days) Smoked cigars, cigarillos or little cigars, one or more days 12.2 16 8.1 9.1 9 13.5 17.1 NA NA NA NA NA NA NA 12.7 18.4 6.5 10.7 9.5 11.4 19.6 9 12.9 4.9 6.5 8.2 10.3 10.3 (past 30 days) Appendix 4

2014 New York State Youth Tobacco Survey New York State Middle and High School Students – Ever and Current Use of Tobacco Products

Cigarettes Cigars Smokeless Tobacco ENDS Hookah

% ±C.I.* % ±C.I.* % ±C.I.* % ±C.I.* % ±C.I.* Middle School

Ever Use 5.4 1.5 2.1 0.6 2.3 0.8 6.9 (5.2-8.6) 4.4 1.5

Current Use 1.1 0.5 0.7 0.3 0.9 0.5 3.2 (2.2-4.2) 2.1 0.9 High School

Ever Use 22.9 4.3 13.0 2.0 9.2 2.6 21.6 (19.0-24.1) 15.3 1.8 Current Use 7.3 1.8 5.5 0.8 3.6 1.2 10.5 (8.7-12.3) 6.2 1.2

Note: * 95% Confidence Interval

ENDS (Electronic Nicotine Delivery System) also called electronic cigarettes are battery‐powered devices that heat a solution of liquid nicotine and other chemicals creating an emission which is inhaled by the user.

Hookah - a single or multi-stemmed water pipe for smoking. Appendix 5 Allocation of Tobacco Enforcement Program Funding April 1, 2014 - March 31, 2015

COUNTY GRANT Bronx Albany $90,887 Kings Allegany $30,265 New York City New York $2,019,162 Broome $58,155 Queens Cattaraugus $31,427 Richmond Cayuga $32,202 District Offices $617,031 Chautauqua $44,210 Canton St. Lawrence Chemung $37,625 Geneva Ontario Clinton $41,692 Wayne Columbia $37,044 Yates Cortland $29,297 Glens Falls Saratoga Dutchess $83,721 Warren Erie $196,248 Washington Genesee $31,233 Herkimer Chenango Livingston $33,945 Fulton Madison $29,684 Herkimer Monroe $150,346 Montgomery Nassau $298,317 Hornell Schuyler Niagara $56,218 Steuben Oneida $62,803 Monticello Sullivan Onondaga $102,895 Oneonta Delaware Orange $95,148 Greene Orleans $26,585 Otsego Oswego $41,498 Saranac Lake Essex Putnam $40,917 Franklin Rensselaer $53,700 Hamilton Rockland $70,163 Watertown Jefferson Schenectady $57,961 Lewis Schoharie $25,229 Total $5,266,981 Seneca $27,166 Suffolk $328,144 Tioga $28,328 Tompkins $32,395 Ulster $62,222 Westchester $235,565 Wyoming $27,553 Subtotal $2,630,788 Appendix 6 New York Fire Reporting System Tobacco-Related Fire Statistics January 1, 2014 - December 31, 2014

Number of Number of Number of Number of Population Number of County Civilian Civilian Firefighter Firefighter (2010) Fires Injuries Deaths Injuries Deaths Statewide Totals 19,378,102 884 20 20 4 0

Albany 304,204 13 Allegany 48,946 2 Broome 200,600 10 Cattaraugus 80,317 11 Cayuga 80,026 2 Chautauqua 134,905 4 Chemung 88,830 3 Chenango 50,477 1 Clinton 82,128 10 Columbia 63,096 6 1 Cortland 49,336 4 1 Delaware 47,980 1 Dutchess 297,488 12 1 Erie 919,040 23 1 Essex 39,370 1 Franklin 51,599 2 Fulton 55,531 2 Genesee 60,079 3 Greene 49,221 2 Hamilton 4,836 0 Herkimer 64,519 2 Jefferson 116,229 7 1 Lewis 27,087 1 Livingston 65,393 7 Madison 73,442 2 Monroe 744,344 49 4 3 Montgomery 50,219 4 Nassau 1,339,532 17 New York City 8,175,133 228 7 13 Niagara 216,469 13 Oneida 234,878 11 1 1 Onondaga 467,026 31 1 Ontario 107,931 8 1 1 Orange 372,813 159 Orleans 42,883 3 Oswego 122,109 8 Appendix 6 New York Fire Reporting System Tobacco-Related Fire Statistics January 1, 2014 - December 31, 2014

Number of Number of Number of Number of Population Number of County Civilian Civilian Firefighter Firefighter (2010) Fires Injuries Deaths Injuries Deaths Statewide Totals 19,378,102 884 20 20 4 0 Otsego 62,259 1 Putnam 99,710 3 Rensselaer 159,429 10 Rockland 311,687 57 1 St Lawrence 111,944 0 Saratoga 219,607 10 Schenectady 154,727 13 Schoharie 32,749 3 Schuyler 18,343 0 Seneca 35,251 0 Steuben 98,990 5 Suffolk 1,493,350 24 1 Sullivan 77,547 6 Tioga 51,125 3 Tompkins 101,564 2 Ulster 182,493 18 1 Warren 65,707 10 Washington 63,216 2 Wayne 93,772 8 Westchester 949,113 44 1 3 Wyoming 42,155 2 Yates 25,348 1 State of New York Andrew M. Cuomo, Governor

Department of Health Howard A. Zucker, M.D., J.D., Commissioner of Health