EUROPEAN COMMISSION Brussels, 7.3.2012 SWD(2012) 38 final COMMISSION STAFF WORKING PAPER ACCOMPANYING THE REPORT FROM THE COMMISSION TO THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND THE COUNCIL: EUROPEAN UNION SAFA PROGRAMME (Safety Assessment of Foreign Aircraft) Aggregated Information Report (01 January 2010 to 31 December 2010) {COM(2012) 91 final} EN EN COMMISSION STAFF WORKING PAPER ACCOMPANYING THE REPORT FROM THE COMMISSION TO THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND THE COUNCIL: EUROPEAN UNION SAFA PROGRAMME (Safety Assessment of Foreign Aircraft) Aggregated Information Report (01 January 2010 to 31 December 2010) APPENDIX A – DATA COLLECTION BY PARTICIPATING STATES Average no. of inspected No. Member State No. Inspections No. Findings items/inspection EU Member States 1. Austria 463 1048 40.27 2. Belgium 147 171 30.29 3. Bulgaria 117 55 43.90 4. Cyprus 89 45 41.51 5. Czech Republic 181 145 43.73 6. Denmark 69 48 41.87 7. Estonia 41 14 25.98 8. Finland 116 71 36.77 9. France 2691 3326 34.95 10. Germany 1444 991 41.59 11. Greece 420 154 23.63 12. Hungary 22 46 31.64 13. Ireland 70 79 47.41 14. Italy 823 1033 34.91 15. Latvia 54 31 36.69 16. Lithuania 32 7 45.00 17. Luxembourg 58 18 32.45 18. Malta 10 7 39.30 19. Netherlands 258 482 39.66 20. Poland 166 199 40.20 21. Portugal 195 48 40.75 22. Romania 92 33 31.65 23. Slovak Republic 52 101 40.31 24. Slovenia 45 29 38.53 25. Spain 931 1561 39.80 EN 2 EN 26. Sweden 104 54 42.68 27. United Kingdom 1108 322 39.85 Total 9798 10118 37.54 Average no. of inspected No. Member State No. Inspections No. Findings items/inspection Non-EU ECAC SAFA Participating States 1. Albania 14 5 43.29 2. Armenia 39 13 47.44 3. Azerbaijan 11 1 43.82 4. Bosnia and Herzegovina 12 14 38.25 5. Croatia 123 37 33.06 6. Georgia 15 4 32.13 7. Iceland 18 19 38.67 8. Moldova 12 7 34.67 9. Monaco 6 3 46.17 10. Norway 1 3 54.00 11. Serbia 140 91 33.81 12. Switzerland 76 50 40.91 The Former Yugoslav 13. 358 81 37.13 Republic of Macedonia 14. Turkey 1046 528 35.92 15. Ukraine 34 45 48.38 Total 1905 901 36.61 EN 3 EN APPENDIX B - List of States/Territories of Inspected Operators (Listed in alphabetical order) Operator State No. of Inspections Percentage (*) Afghanistan 7 0.06% Albania 32 0.27% Algeria 64 0.55% Angola 61 0.52% Anguilla 8 0.07% Antigua and Barbuda 6 0.05% Argentina 6 0.05% Armenia 32 0.27% Aruba 7 0.06% Australia 21 0.18% Austria 334 2.85% Azerbaijan 44 0.38% Bahrain 23 0.20% Bangladesh 2 0.02% Belarus 74 0.63% Belgium 205 1.75% Bermuda 34 0.29% Bolivia 6 0.05% Bosnia and Herzegovina 21 0.18% Brazil 21 0.18% British Virgin Islands 1 0.01% Brunei Darussalam 1 0.01% Bulgaria 137 1.17% Burkina Faso 15 0.13% Cape Verde 14 0.12% Canada 81 0.69% Cayman Islands 13 0.11% Chad 1 0.01% Chile 11 0.09% China 92 0.79% Colombia 5 0.04% Comoros 29 0.25% Côte d'Ivoire 4 0.03% Croatia 68 0.58% Cuba 12 0.10% Cyprus 57 0.49% Czech Republic 162 1.38% Denmark 165 1.41% Dominican Republic 3 0.03% Ecuador 3 0.03% Egypt 237 2.03% Estonia 33 0.28% Ethiopia 22 0.19% Finland 122 1.04% EN 4 EN Operator State No. of Inspections Percentage (*) France 231 1.97% Gabon 11 0.09% Georgia 46 0.39% Germany 829 7.08% Ghana 21 0.18% Greece 154 1.32% Hong Kong 27 0.23% Hungary 177 1.51% Iceland 64 0.55% India 31 0.26% Indonesia 4 0.03% Iran 85 0.73% Ireland 397 3.39% Isle of Man 28 0.24% Israel 134 1.15% Italy 269 2.30% Japan 19 0.16% Jordan 73 0.62% Kazakhstan 38 0.32% Kenya 15 0.13% Korea / South Korea 32 0.27% Kuwait 33 0.28% Latvia 110 0.94% Lebanon 53 0.45% Libya 73 0.62% Lithuania 51 0.44% Luxembourg 89 0.76% The former Yugoslav Republic of 15 0.13% Macedonia Madagascar 39 0.33% Malaysia 15 0.13% Mali 4 0.03% Malta 62 0.53% Mauritania 16 0.14% Mauritius 13 0.11% Mexico 21 0.18% Moldova 42 0.36% Monaco 5 0.04% Mongolia 2 0.02% Montenegro 41 0.35% Montserrat 2 0.02% Morocco 174 1.49% Namibia 2 0.02% Netherlands 260 2.22% Netherlands Antilles 14 0.12% New Zealand 11 0.09% Nigeria 6 0.05% EN 5 EN Operator State No. of Inspections Percentage (*) Norway 106 0.91% Oman 8 0.07% Pakistan 46 0.39% Peru 1 0.01% Poland 139 1.19% Portugal 284 2.43% Qatar 59 0.50% Romania 168 1.44% Russian Federation 851 7.27% Saint Vincent / Grenadines 8 0.07% San Marino 1 0.01% Saudi Arabia 37 0.32% Serbia 70 0.60% Seychelles 8 0.07% Singapore 29 0.25% Slovakia 40 0.34% Slovenia 76 0.65% South Africa 16 0.14% Spain 390 3.33% Sri Lanka 14 0.12% Suriname 6 0.05% Sweden 247 2.11% Switzerland 298 2.55% Syrian Arab Republic (Syria) 20 0.17% Tajikistan 4 0.03% Taiwan (Republic of China) 24 0.21% Thailand 24 0.21% Tunisia 191 1.63% Turkey 586 5.01% Turkmenistan 9 0.08% Ukraine 287 2.45% United Arab Emirates 143 1.22% United Kingdom 802 6.85% United States of America 495 4.23% Uruguay 1 0.01% Uzbekistan 26 0.22% Vanuatu 8 0.07% Venezuela 10 0.09% Viet Nam 8 0.07% Yemen 15 0.13% Zimbabwe 14 0.12% (*) = number of inspections in relation to total number of inspections (%) conducted during the time period being considered in this report EN 6 EN – As mentioned earlier there is no discrimination between operators certified in the 44 EU / ECAC States (indicated in bold) and operators certified in the other non-European States. The fact that inspections on ECAC operators account for almost two thirds of the total number of inspections is a direct consequence of the fact that a vast portion of European air traffic is performed by operators from those states. EN 7 EN – APPENDIX C - Aircraft types inspected (by manufacturer) (Listed in alphabetical order) Large airliners (over 100 seats) No. Aircraft Manufacturer 1. AIRBUS 2. ANTONOV 3. BOEING 4. BRITISH AEROSPACE 5. EMBRAER 6. FOKKER 7. ILYUSHIN 8. LOCKHEED 9. MCDONNELL DOUGLAS (now part of the Boeing Company) 10. TUPOLEV 11. YAKOVLEV Regional airliners (19-99 seats) No. Aircraft Manufacturer 1. ANTONOV 2. AVIONS DE TRANSPORT RÉGIONAL (ATR) 3. BOMBARDIER AEROSPACE 4. BRITISH AEROSPACE 5. CONVAIR 6. DORNIER 7. EMBRAER 8. FAIRCHILD 9. FOKKER 10. LET 11. LOCKHEED 12. SAAB 13. YAKOVLEV EN 8 EN Commuter, business and general aviation aeroplanes No. Aircraft Manufacturer 1. BEECH 2. BOMBARDIER AEROSPACE 3. BRITTEN-NORMAN 4. CESSNA 5. CIRRUS AIRCRAFT CORPORATION 6. DASSAULT 7. DIAMOND AIRCRAFT INDUSTRIES 8. DORNIER 9. FAIRCHILD 10. GULFSTREAM 11. ISRAEL AIRCRAFT INDUSTRIES 12. PIAGGIO 13. PILATUS AIRCRAFT 14. PIPER 15. RAYTHEON 16. ROCKWELL 17. SHORT BROTHERS 18. SOCATA Helicopters No. Aircraft Manufacturer 1. AGUSTA 2. AEROSPATIALE 3. BELL HELICOPTER TEXTRON 4. EUROCOPTER 5. KAMOV OKB 6. MIL HELICOPTERS 7. ROBINSON HELICOPTER COMPANY 8. SIKORSKY The distribution of SAFA inspections by aircraft manufacturers is in line with the volume of traffic performed with the respective types. In 2010, inspections covered also general aviation and helicopter operations, but the overall majority concentrated on commercial operations with aeroplanes. EN 9 EN APPENDIX D – Operators Inspected (Listed in alphabetical order) Code Total NAME OPERATOR Operator Name State Operator Inspections 223 FLIGHT UNIT STATE AIRLINE CHD Russian Federation 1 224TH FLIGHT UNIT TTF Russian Federation 5 247 JET LTD TWF United Kingdom 6 2nd SVERDLOVSK AIR ENTERPRISE UKU Russian Federation 1 ABC BEDARFSFLUG GMBH FTY Austria 2 ABELAG AVIATION AAB Belgium 8 ABS JETS ABP Czech Republic 6 AC CHALLENGE AERO LLC CHG Ukraine 2 ACASS CANADA LTD. 6NH Canada 1 ACG AIR CARGO GERMANY ACX Germany 5 ACH HAMBURG GMBH 7AC Germany 3 ACM AIR CHARTER GMBH BVR Germany 5 ACM AVIATION INC. BJT United States of America 1 ACROPOLIS AVIATION LTD CRV United Kingdom 1 ACT HAVAYOLLARI AS RUN Turkey 6 AD ASTRA EXECUTIVE CHARTER SP. ADC Poland 2 ADRIA AIRWAYS ADR Slovenia 46 ADVANCE AIRLUFTFAHRTGESELL. 6HZ Germany 3 ADVANCED AIR MANAGEMENT INC. 6JV United States of America 2 AEGEAN AVIATION AEE Greece 53 AER ARANN TEORANTA REA Ireland 18 AER LINGUS TEORANTA EIN Ireland 69 AERO JET INTERNATIONAL 6ML United States of America 1 AERO RENT, JOINT STOCK COMPANY NRO Russian Federation 2 AERO-CHARTER UKRAINE LTD. UCR Ukraine 10 AERODIENST GMBH, NURNBURG ADN Germany 6 AERODYNAMICS MALAGA, S.L. DNC Spain 8 AEROFLOT - RUSSIAN INT. AIRL. AFL Russian Federation 167 AEROFLOT DON/DONAVIA DNV Russian Federation 27 AEROFLOT-NORD AUL Russian Federation 7 AEROFLOT-PLUS J.S.C. PLS Russian Federation 1 AEROLANE-LINEAS AEREAS NACIONA LNE Ecuador 3 AEROLIMOUSINE LTD. LIN Russian Federation 1 AEROLINE GMBH (SYLT-AIR) AWU Germany 1 AEROLINEAS ARGENTINAS ARG Argentina 6 AEROLOGIC BOX Germany 3 AEROMARINE 7AE Madagascar 3 AERONORTE - TRANSPORTES AEREOS RTE Portugal 2 AERONOVA OVA Spain 21 AEROSTAR UAR Ukraine 8 AEROSUR RSU Bolivia 6 AEROSVIT AIRLINES AEW Ukraine 40 AEROTAXI LOS VALLES VAD Spain 5 AEROVIAS DE MEXICO, S.A.