UNIVERSIDADE DE LISBOA INSTITUTO SUPERIOR TÉCNICO Cosmological and astrophysical applications of modified theories of gravity João Luís de Figueiredo Rosa Supervisor: Professor José Pizarro de Sande e Lemos Co-Supervisors: Doctor Francisco Sabélio Nobrega Lobo Doctor Sante Carloni . Thesis approved in public session to obtain the PhD Degree in Physics Jury final classification: Pass with Distinction and Honour arXiv:1911.08257v1 [gr-qc] 19 Nov 2019 2019 UNIVERSIDADE DE LISBOA INSTITUTO SUPERIOR TÉCNICO Cosmological and astrophysical applications of modified theories of gravity João Luís de Figueiredo Rosa Supervisor: Professor José Pizarro de Sande e Lemos Co-Supervisors: Doctor Francisco Sabélio Nobrega Lobo Doctor Sante Carloni . Thesis approved in public session to obtain the PhD Degree in Physics Jury final classification: Pass with Distinction and Honour Jury Chairperson: Doctor Vítor Manuel dos Santos Cardoso, Instituto Superior Técnico, Universidade de Lisboa Members of the committee: Doctor José Pizarro de Sande e Lemos, Instituto Superior Técnico, Universidade de Lisboa; Doctor Carlos Alberto Ruivo Herdeiro, Universidade de Aveiro; Doctor José Pedro Oliveira Mimoso, Faculdade de Ciências, Universidade de Lisboa; Doctor Gonzalo Olmo Alba, Facultat de Física, Universitat de València, Espanha 2019 To the memory of L´ıria Guerra i ii Acknowledgments In this section I would like to acknowledge a few people, not only for making this thesis possible but also for standing by my side everytime I needed. I want to start by refering the two men that accepted to supervise me, gave me the opportunity to adventure further into the knowledge of gravitation and astrophysics, and successfully guided me for the past 4 years: Prof. Jose´ Sande Lemos and Prof. Francisco Lobo. Also, I want to give a special thanks to Dr. Sante Carloni who was not oficially my supervisor from the beginning but surely was an excellent teacher and coworker with whom I learned a huge variety of topics in physics and mathematics. This thesis would not be possible without him. The research path of a theoretical physicist is regularly stunned by fundamental mathematical prob- lems and my knowledge of geometry and analysis is often unsufficient to proceed further on my own. Fortunately, the Department of Mathematics of IST has always been kindly available to lend me a help- ing hand. I thus want to thank Prof. Jorge D. Silva, Prof. Jose´ Natario,´ and Prof. Pedro M. Girao,˜ for helping me to overcome all mathematical barriers I have faced during the development of this work. The final objective of my academic career is to become a full Professor in a well-known university, and during my research work I was given the opportunity to start teaching classes at IST. For this, I want to thank Prof. Joao˜ Seixas who was the senior lecturer of the first course I taught and who always motivated me to keep teaching and recommended me to the individuals responsible for selecting lecturers for the different courses. I also want to thank all my students for their extremely important feedback on the quality of my classes and for helping me to break the teacher-student barrier by becoming my friends by the end of the semester. Surprisingly and unexpectedly, the paramount moment of my adventure came in the final year of my PhD, when I was accepted for a Fulbright Research Scholarship in the Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore. I want to thank not only my Fulbright host Prof. Emanuele Berti for accepting me in his research group and for the interesting discussions we had during these four and a half months, but also all the friends I made in the USA, specially the ones from the Graduate Representative Organization, the Science Fiction and Fantasy Club, the Men’s Soccer Club, and of course all the members of the Bloomberg Center for Physics and Astronomy. I believe that one can not live a happy life solely based on the success of his career, and thus I want to thank all my friends for every minute they made me happy during the stressful periods of my work. A special thanks to the members of the ”Proletariado Internacional” group, my office mates also known as the Gamiades, my besties Miguel Pinto (Sniper) and Mariana Paeta (Mia), my friends from ”the other offices”, specially Gonc¸alo Quinta, Rui Andre,´ and Miguel Orcinha, my room mate and amazing friend Jose´ Cardoso, my friends from the volunteering program ”Viver Astronomia” specially Joao˜ Retre,ˆ and also Beatriz Bento with whom I shared a lot of adventures. Thank you for every day and night out, for our trips to the beach and to the mountains, for our adventures abroad (specially Morocco and Iceland), for the hikes, for the bike rides, for the studio rehearsals with Inconscientia, and for our group dinners. A huge and special thanks goes to Catarina Bravo, my Taree, for the moments we spent together providing endless fountains of trust and motivation to each other, for always being there to listen every- iii time I needed to let off some steam from inside, and for always being ready to help me with my problems even when the solutions were out of her knowledge. We understand each other more than anyone else, and that is a huge reason for me to feel happy and confortable. I only know I made it home when I drown in your ghost light. An overwhelmingly important acknowledge belongs to my family, my parents and my sister, who have always been supportive and whose sacrifices are the main reason for me to be where I am today. Thank you for teaching me that with hard work and the pleasure to live for the reason we love most are the main ingredients for a life of success and happiness. A special thanks to my grandmother who passed away a few months before I started this work and whose dream was to watch me becoming a successful scientist. To finalize, I would like to acknowledge the financial support of FCT-IDPASC through the grant number PD/BD/114072/2015, to LIP for the finantial support to attend the IDPASC schools in 2016 and 2019 and the IDPASC students workshops from 2016 to 2019, and also Fulbright Comission Portugal for my Fulbright Research Scholarship in the Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, MD. iv Resumo Neste projecto, estudamos aplicac¸oes˜ cosmologicas´ e astrof´ısicas da teoria de gravidade h´ıbrida metrica-´ Palatini generalizada recentemente proposta, que combina aspectos de ambos os formalismos metrico´ e de Palatini do metodo´ variacional em gravidade f (R). Esta teoria nasce como uma generalizac¸ao˜ natural da teoria de gravidade h´ıbrida metrica-Palatini´ que provou ser a primeira teoria a unificar a expansao˜ cosmologica´ acelerada com os constrangimentos do sistema solar, sem recorrer ao efeito camaleao.˜ Do ponto de vista cosmologico,´ mostramos usando metodos´ de reconstruc¸ao˜ que os factores de escala com comportamentos da forma de potenciasˆ e exponenciais em universos FLRW existem para varias´ distribuic¸oes˜ de materia´ diferentes, assim como soluc¸oes˜ para universos colapsantes. Usando o formalismo de sistemas dinamicos,ˆ mostramos tambem´ que nao˜ existem atractores globais no espac¸o de fases cosmologico´ e que universos estaveis´ podem ser descritos por factores de escala que divergem em tempo finito ou tendem assimptoticamente para valores constantes. Estudamos ainda o espac¸o de fases cosmologico´ de teorias de gravidade com termos de sexta e oitava ordem nas derivadas da metrica´ e concluimos que os termos de ordem superior nao˜ sao˜ negligenciaveis.´ Na area´ de astrof´ısica, mostramos que usando as condic¸oes˜ de junc¸ao˜ da teoria e´ poss´ıvel obter soluc¸oes˜ para objectos compactos suportados por cascas finas, tais como cascas auto-gravitantes com e sem fluidos perfeitos no exterior e ainda soluc¸oes˜ para wormholes transitaveis´ que satisfazem a condic¸ao˜ de energia nula em todo o espac¸o-tempo, nao necessitando portanto do suporte de materia´ exotica.´ Mostramos tambem´ que existem formas espec´ıficas da acc¸ao˜ para as quais o grau de liberdade escalar massivo da teoria e´ estavel´ no ambitoˆ de buracos negros em rotac¸ao˜ descritos pela metrica´ de Kerr. Palavras-chave: gravidade modificada, cosmologia, sistema dinamico,ˆ cascas finas, worm- hole, buraco negro v vi Abstract In this work, we study cosmological and astrophysical applications of the recently proposed generalized hybrid metric-Palatini gravity theory, which combines features of both the metric and the Palatini ap- proaches to the variational method in f (R) gravity. This theory arises as a natural generalization of the hybrid metric-Palatini gravity which has been proven to be the first theory to unify the cosmic acceleration with the solar system constraints, without resource to the chameleon mechanism. In the cosmological point of view, we show using reconstruction methods that the usual power-law and exponential scale factor behaviors in FLRW universes exist for various different distributions of matter, along with solutions for collapsing universes. Using the dynamical system approach, we also show that no global attractors can exist in the cosmological phase space and that stable universes can either be described by scale factors that diverge in finite time or asymptotically approach constant values. Furthermore, we also study the cosmological phase space of theories of gravity with terms of order six and eight in the derivatives of the metric and we conclude that the higher-order terms are not neglectable. In the area of astrophysics, we show that using the junction conditions of the theory it is possible to obtain solutions for compact objects supported by thin-shells, such as self-gravitating shells with and without perfect fluids on their exteriors, and also traversable wormhole solutions which satisfy the null energy condition for the whole spacetime, thus not needing the support of exotic matter.