It is not often that a country is faced with the prospect of rebuilding Egypt in innovation Science and from the ground up. Egypt’s recent revolution – notwithstanding the many and inevitable challenges it presents – has ushered in an era of unprecedented hope and expectation. This report assesses the current state of Egypt’s science, technology and innovation (STI) systems, their strengths and weaknesses, as well as the many ideas under consideration and programmes already in place for improving them. It is designed as an accessible guide for anyone interested in Egypt’s future development at this vital time. The research for this report was conducted as part of a multi-partner project entitled The atlas of Islamic-world science and innovation. Bringing together partners from across the Islamic world, Europe and North America, the aims of this project are to explore the changing landscape of science and innovation across a diverse selection of countries with large Muslim populations. Science and ISBN 978-0-85403-952-4 innovation in Egypt Michael Bond, Heba Maram, Asmaa Soliman and Riham Khattab 9 780854 039524 This project was supported by an international consortium, and the report was endorsed by the partners listed below. The views outlined in this report do not necessarily reflect the policy position of these partner organisations. This country report drew significantly on the expertise of in-country partners. Special thanks go to the Academy of Scientific Research and Technology (the National Focal Point) and the Bibliotheca Alexandrina (the National Research Partner). Cover image: Spice market ©Antony McAulay, Fotolia.com Science and innovation in Egypt Researchers Michael Bond, Heba Maram, Asmaa Soliman and Riham Khattab Acknowledgements Special thanks to Dr Mohamed El-Faham, Director of the Bibliotheca Alexandrina’s Center for Special Studies and Programs, for his help in compiling this report. ISBN: 978-0-85403-952-4 NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0 or send a letter to Creative Commons, 171 Second Street, Suite 300, San Francisco, California, 94105, USA. Contents | 5 Foreword from His Excellency Professor Dr Ekmeleddin İhsanoğlu, Secretary-General of the Organisation of the Islamic Cooperation 7 Introduction and summary 9 1 Mapping 12 1.1 The current state of Egyptian innovation 14 1.2 Scraping the barrel for R&D 14 1.3 Egypt’s STI system 17 1.4 The 2007 reforms and the new vision for R&D in Egypt 20 1.5 How successful have the reforms been so far? 24 1.6 Egypt’s key strengths in research and innovation 27 1.7 Resistance to change 30 1.8 The way ahead 30 2 People 33 2.1 South Korea – a model for Egypt? 33 2.2 Bursting at the seams 35 2.3 Quantity over quality 37 2.4 Critical thinking 37 2.5 The state of higher education 39 2.6 Preparing for the real world 44 2.7 Road to recovery 45 2.8 A new university admission system 46 2.9 The road ahead 46 3 Business 49 3.1 Foreign direct investment 51 3.2 The (lack of an) R&D culture in industry 52 3.3 Innovation in pharmaceuticals 53 3.4 Appetite for innovation 54 3.5 Venture capital 54 3.6 Academia and industry 55 3.7 Bridging the gap 57 3.8 Government initiatives to build innovation in industry 59 3.9 Teaching entrepreneurship 60 3.10 How the government can help 62 3.11 Egypt’s IT success story 63 3.12 Nile University – where research and industry meet 66 3.13 Fostering IT entrepreneurship in Egypt 68 4 Places 69 4.1 Who gets the money… 72 4.2 …and who does not 72 4.3 The challenges of the new grant system 73 4.4 Egypt’s Centres Of Excellence 76 6 | Science and innovation in Egypt 5 Culture 84 5.1 A waning appetite for science? 84 5.2 Reviving public interest in innovation 85 5.3 The role of the media 86 5.4 Science and religion 87 5.5 Evolution – where science teachers fear to tread 88 5.6 Egypt’s rigid university system and how it is strangling innovation 90 5.7 The need for more interdisciplinary research 91 5.8 More power to the universities! 92 6 Sustainability 96 6.1 Beyond self-sufficiency 97 6.2 Egypt’s agricultural master plan 98 6.3 Research is the key 98 6.4 Turning desert into farmland 99 6.5 The desert development corridor farmland 100 6.6 Water – will there ever be enough? 101 6.7 The effect of climate change on productivity 106 6.8 The front line of climate change 107 6.9 Adaptation and mitigation 108 6.10 Making the most of the sun and the wind 108 6.11 Public apathy 109 7 Collaboration 111 7.1 University for the national good 111 7.2 Egypt’s landscape of collaboration 112 7.3 Decade of Science 114 7.4 The US-Egypt special relationship 115 7.5 Building partnerships for the future 116 7.6 Progress in figures 116 7.7 Future obstacles 117 8 Summary and recommendations 119 8.1 Strengths 119 8.2 Weaknesses 120 8.3 Recommendations 122 Appendix 1 List of organisations and individuals interviewed 124 Appendix 2 The Bibliotheca Alexandrina 128 Acknowledgements 130 Foreword | 7 Foreword Foreword from His Excellency Professor Dr Ekmeleddin İhsanoğlu, Secretary-General of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation. The research for The atlas of Islamic-world science and innovation report on Egypt was undertaken in collaboration with the various partners including the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC), COMSTECH, ISESCO, the Royal Society, Nature, British Council, the International Development Research Centre of Canada and Qatar Foundation. Apart from various other factors which underpin Egypt’s strategic significance within the OIC as well as on the broader international stage, Egypt stands out as a flag bearer of a civilization known for its scientific and cultural heritage. Contributions by the Egyptian scientists, researchers and thinkers in the fields of astronomy, mathematics, medicine, philosophy and architecture span over centuries, with the pursuit of knowledge receiving further impetus following the advent of Islam in the 8th century. This report includes a survey of Egypt’s current Science, Technology and Innovation landscape, its history, areas of strength, policy framework and institutions relevant to STI, as well as an assessment of the contemporary challenges and opportunities to research and scientific advancement. Despite its various challenges, Egypt continues to show promise in the fields of mathematics, engineering, physics, chemistry, IT, biotechnology and agriculture. Whether it be a Nobel Prize winner in Chemistry or the people behind Alexandria University’s elevation in international rankings, Egypt has succeeded in regularly producing leading scientists in varied disciplines. Egypt ranks prominently amongst the top few OIC Member States in terms of the number of publications whose impact factor has been steadily growing. The reaffirmation of commitment by the Egyptian leadership to the promotion of STI is reassuring for the people of Egypt as well as for many of the regional countries benefiting from Egyptian expertise through scientific cooperation and joint projects. I am hopeful, that the recommendations of this report will receive due consideration and may be taken as a modest contribution of the OIC in the transformation process in the country. I thank all the partners who have contributed in the preparation of this report including the Academy of Scientific Research and Technology of Egypt, the National Focal Point for Egypt and the Library of Alexandria, the Research Partner, for their valuable assistance and support. 8 | Science and innovation in Egypt Introduction and summary | 9 Introduction and summary It is not often that a country is faced with the prospect of rebuilding from the ground up. Egypt’s remarkable revolution – notwithstanding the many and inevitable challenges it presents – has ushered in an era of unprecedented hope and expectation, and the overriding sense that Egyptians have a golden opportunity to overturn three decades of social, economic and political neglect. This is particularly true in the domains of scientific research and education, where there is near-unanimous agreement that decades of under-investment, poor planning of the way research funds are spent, excessive bureaucracy, uninspiring curricula and political meddling have severely weakened a system that once regularly produced scientists who were among the best in the world. Reforms are ongoing and excellence can still be found in many fields, but freedom of enquiry, entrepreneurship and innovation are thin on the ground in both universities and industry. Restoring these crucial pillars will be crucial to development, and will do much to help meet the demand so often heard in Tahrir Square during the revolution for “bread, freedom and social justice”. Egypt has a huge scientific legacy to draw on. Think of the astronomy and optics of Ibn Al-Haitham in the 10th-century, Ibn Al-Nafis’s groundbreaking work on the circulation of the blood in the 13th century and the generations of medical scientists who preceded him, and the thousand-year-old rationalist tradition of Cairo’s Al-Azhar University, the world’s oldest (Mapping, Box 1.1). Reviving the country’s scientific golden days will be a huge challenge, but in the spirit of Tahrir Square anything seems possible. “We believe we are alive now, whereas before we were really dead,” one academic told us. “We saw corruption at every step, then suddenly we had people who were prepared to die for the country. Now everyone wants to contribute to making things better.” He recalled a taxi driver in Cairo in the days after Mubarak’s resignation remarking that “even the air I’m breathing seems cleaner”.