3. NEW BUSINESS E. 470-498 Sheridan Road (L) – Elliott Dudnik, applicant. Replace existing aluminum framed double hung and fixed storm windows with new aluminum framed double hung and fixed storm windows - Three phase project. Applicable standards: [Alteration] 1-7, 9 and 10. Application for -^ City of Preservation Review of Evanston" Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) APPLICATION FOR WINDOW REPLACEMENT Thank you for submitting your COA application for window replacement. This application is required for exterior work affecting Evanston landmarks and properties within local Evanston historic districts. To process your application, submit one complete electronic copy (PDF) and one hard copy of the application and attachments; not to exceed 11" x 17" paper size by 5pm on the first Tuesday of the month. The electronic copy and hard copy must include the plat of survey showing the location of the existing windows and photos or elevation drawings showing the location of windows. Refer to the Supplemental Information section (page 4) for guidance. Incomplete applications will not be accepted. Applications can be submitted in person or by email (as a PDF) to the Preservation Coordinator, City of Evanston, Community Development Department, Planning & Zoning Division, Lorraine H. Morton Civic Center, 2100 Ridge Avenue, Room 3201, Evanston, Illinois 60201. Completed applications must be submitted at least 10 business days prior to the scheduled meeting date. The Preservation Commission meets on the third Tuesday of the month (check with staff for last minute changes). Applicants are asked to present at the scheduled meeting a brief overview of the project and provide additional information (e.g., photos, letters of support, a sample of the proposed window, samples of proposed materials seeking to replicate existing materials, etc.). For more information call: Carlos Ruiz at (847) 448-8687 or email: [email protected] Section A. Required Information (Print) * Refer fo the Supplemental Information for guidance [page (i) fifth below]. 1) Property Address: FOR STAFF USE ONLY 4~\ - *\^^& *5V-lEte-l D /^*J Application Number: 2) Owner's Name: Address: L,/vfc3=>- •"5V-JO125& cSOWt^^r^) I City: State: Zip: Phone: Email: •e>/AWJwT<5'VJ> IL 6*>ZD2 3) Architect's Name: Address: fel_.L-iOTT "Dt-?1^>O\Vi ^ 1 3 LOts^LJSV City: State: Zip: Phone: Email: B\/Awart7Tc*-> I L 4>O2o2 84"V Sfcfc -^^o Gi>vjix)iVi<aL,t)ui>o\^e6t»«- 4) Contractor's Name: Address: c City: State: Zip: Phone: Email: 5) Landmark: *^q Yes O No * Refer ro the Supplemental Information for guidance [page (i) fifth below]. 6) Within Local Historic District: * fDNo; Q] Yes -> Q Lakeshore Q Ridge £3 Northeast Evanston WCTU ^^ Apartment Thematic Resources Adopted October 19, 2004 Page 1 Section B: Application for Certificate of Appropriateness 1) In addition to the required site plan, elevation drawings, and photos, briefly describe the proposed activity and reason for obtaining a Certificate of Appropriateness. Attach a separate sheet if necessary, and refer to the Supplemental Information for guidance (page 4). For window replacement, state the reason(s) why the existing windows (if original) cannot be restored. Include statement from window restoration contractor to substatiate your claim. , iaepUk4B fc*iSTiwo AUOWMWM 1*BAv*=D t>oum*-wu*$ * ±3tt> STOR^ UO.UQO^ WlTt* "S* A^PUVA W"*** OOUBU6-WMJ6 ^FIXCD -SlbaM U3ITOOWJ - TWBSeFWA-Ste -p^^c^ A* <5WOW>KJ> <2>^> -Stt* pUfiW. 2) Checklist (Check all that apply and attach any additional information) Visible from Public Way (e.g. Streets Type of Exterior Activity Location / Details and Alleys)? G Construction ^Residential G Other: GYes GNo G Demolition n Partial G Total GYes GNo ^JjMteration H Restoration T^ront •gfside S^fRear ^•— "*V • • • jf-> f-^ /-=*** J^Yes QNo G Addition G Landscaping Garage: G Rehabilitation G Front G Side Q Rear GYes GNo O Replacement O New Q Windows J5\Storm Windows G Restoration^E^Replacement G New £&es QNo G Doors O Storm Doors Style/Materials: Roof: Q Restoration Q Re-roof Q New G Front G Side G Rear GYes GNo Style/Material: Solar Panels: Q G Front G Side G Rear GYes GNo * Adhere to Illustrated Guideline (Attached) Fence/Gate: Q Restoration G Front G Side G Rear GYes GNo Q Replacement G New Style/Material: Siding: Q Replacement O New G Front G Side G Rear GYes GNo Style/Material: Exposure in inches: QSign G Awning G Plaque G Restoration G New G Replacement GYes GNo Material: G Air Conditioning Unit G Replacement G New QYes GNo Location: Relocation: G Principal Structure New Address for Relocation: G Secondary Structure Adopted October 19, 2004 Page 2 3) Checklist for Exterior Materials — Check all that apply. a 0) D) c C 33 *•» v> Tn 'x 'x 'x Ul LU LU Fa?ades/Front Porch & Flashing Material Fences Rear Porch Material a Wood Frame n Copper n Wood n Stone Sheet Metal n n Wrought Iron a n Brick n n Other: n D Aluminum a n Stucco n Other: a n Synthetic Stucco Fascias, Soffits, Heiqht: n n Wood Siding Rakeboards, Trim Length: n Aluminum Siding n n Wood Terraces, Patios, Decks D Vinyl Siding n n Metal n n Wood n Shinqle, Material: n Synthetic Material, Type: n n Stone n n Brick Pavers n Other: n n Other: Concrete Pavers d Roofing Material Poured Concrete n Wood Shingles Door Material n Other: Propose n n Wood Shakes n n Wood Slate n Metal Driveway Material a n Clay Tile n Clad Asphalt a Asphalt Shingles n Other: Poured Concrete n n Metal Sheet Style: Brick Pavers Other: Window Type n Concrete Pavers n X Double Hung n n Crushed Stone Chimney Material n Casement n Other: Brick n X Other: 1*l*El^> d Stone Add Other Materials/Alterations/ Stucco Window Material a n Fixtures/Not Listed Here (Explain Other: Wood Propose n n n n and Attach Information As Aluminum Needed): Gutters/Downspouts Steel Copper n Other: Q Q Air Conditioning Unit Aluminum n 0 Solar Panels a n Galvanized Sheet Muntins D D a n Other: n Not existing n n n True divided lights n n n n Sim/Jlated divided lights n n Date: d 4) App icant's Signature: ^^A/\ J Print Name: ^CL^/crr-r; £ "DOt>M\ Proceed to Section C if you are requesting a zoning or fence variation and/or s special use. Refer to the Propose Supplemental Information for guidance [page (i) below]. For Planned Development refer to Supplemental Information [page (i) below]. Adopted October 19, 2004 Page3 LAKESHORE CONDOMINIUMS LAKESHORE CONDOMINIUMS 4. PUBLIC HEARING – Application for Rescission of Landmark Designation A. 2623 Lincoln Street (L) – David and Rebecca Kimbell, applicants. Application for Rescission of landmark designation of 2623 Lincoln Street. Memorandum To: Chair and Members of the Evanston Preservation Commission From: Mark Muenzer, Director of Community Development Damir Latinovic, Planning and Zoning Administrator Carlos D. Ruiz, Senior Planner/Preservation Coordinator Subject: 2623 Lincoln Street – Application for Rescission of Landmark Designation Date: June 17, 2016 BACKGROUND David and Rebecca Kimbell, owners, submitted the application for Rescission of Landmark Designation by Ordinance on February 1, 2016 (Attachment A). 2623 Lincoln Street was designated an Evanston Landmark in 1978 per Ordinance 57-O-78 (Attachment B). The 2015 Inventory attributes Joseph H. Bristle as the architect. The house was landmarked under criteria A5: Exemplify the work of a nationally or internationally known architect, or major local architect or master builder; A7: Exemplify an architectural style, construction technique or building type once common in the City; and A9: Be selected for inclusion on the 1972 Illinois Historic Structures Survey. (Attachment C). The 2015 Inventory includes the following information on 2623 Lincoln Street: Integrity: Excellent; Architectutal Classification: Tudor Rival; Roof Material: Slate; Foundation: Stone; Porch: Portico; Details: Arched entry portico, half timbering, stonework; Window Material: Vinyl window replacement (2013); Construction Year: 1929; Window Type: Casement (some double hungs); Window Configuration: Multi Light; Wall Material: Stone; Wall Material 2: Stucco; Plan: T Shape; Historic Features: Arched Portico, prominent chimney, half timbered gables; No. of Stories: 2; Roof Type: Cross-Gabled; and Alterations: Replacement windows. PROCESS FOR RESCISSION OF HISTORIC LANDMARK DESIGNATION In accordance with the City Code, Title 2, Subsection 2-8-6. - AMENDMENT AND RESCISSION OF DESIGNATION, a public hearing has been scheduled with the Evanston Preservation Commission on Tuesday, June 21, 2016. Page 1 The step by step procedure for a public hearing is outlined in Article 4. Application Hearings of the Evanston Preservation Commission Rules and Procedures. The public hearing process is summarized below: 1. Applicant will present testimony followed by questions from the Commission 2. Any member of the public wishing to testify will be afforded an opportunity to ask questions of the applicant. 3. Any member of the public wishing to testify will be afforded an opportunity to provide any public comment 4. The applicant will be afforded an opportunity for rebuttal of any evidence/testimony given by the public 5. The Chair may summarize evidence presented 6. The Commission shall thereafter proceed to discussion of the proposal with respect to the applicable standards 7. Based upon Findings of Fact, the Commission shall then vote to either recommend approval, recommend approval subject to conditions, defer for further information or recommend denial. As required by the City Code, within 35 days following the close of the public hearing, the Commission shall consider whether the landmark or district no longer meets the criteria for designation (Section 2-8-4 below), and make a recommendation to the Council, including a report concerning whether the landmark does or does not continue to retain significance and integrity (Attachment D). In accordance to Sub-Section 2-8-6 (B), the Council shall rescind (or amend) a designation only upon a finding that the designated landmark or district no longer meets the criteria for designation (Section 2-8-4 below).