Sri B Athaulla Khan vs State Of Karnataka on 3 May, 2017 Karnataka High Court Sri B Athaulla Khan vs State Of Karnataka on 3 May, 2017 Author: Aravind Kumar 1 R IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 3RD DAY OF MAY, 2017 BEFORE THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE ARAVIND KUMAR W.P.NOS.49713-49720/2015 C/W W.P.NOS.27986-27990/2012 & 27991-993/2012, 33818- 33822/2015 & 33823-825/2015 & 34039/2015, 33837/2015, 34265-34279/2015, 34522-34533/2015, 34666-34670/2015 & 34672-676/2015, 34728/2015 & 35649/2015, 34831-34835/2015, 35014-35026/2015, 35822-35825/2015, 35869-35871/2015, 36177- 36181/2015 & 36182-184/2015, 36186-36189/2015, 36225/2015, 36226-36227/2015, 36383/2015, 36511- 36515/2015 & 36516/2015, 36528-36533/2015, 36667- 36671/2015 & 36672-676/2015, 36683-36684/2015, 36685-36688/2015, 36770-36774/2015 & 36776- 780/2015, 36793/2015, 36795/2015, 37015- 37019/2015 & 37020-37021/2015, 37026-37035/2015, 37055-37079/2015, 37080-37084/2015 & 37085- 89/2015, 37255-37259/2015 & 37260-261/2015, 37263-37267/2015 & 37268-270/2015, 37419- 37423/2015 & 37424-427/2015 & 37583-592/2015, 37428/2015, 37429/2015, 37431-37436/2015, 2 37440/2015, 37445/2015, 37447/2015, 37451/2015, 37455/2015, 37456/2015, 37551-37552/2015 & 37725/2015, 37577/2015, 37578/2015, 37664/2015, 37711-37713/2015, 37714-37715/2015, 37746/2015, 37747/2015 & 37945/2015, 37931/2015, 37932/2015, 37976/2015, 38042-38044/2015, 38051-38052/2015, 38053/2015, 38054-38057/2015, 38247-38259/2015, 38260-38264/2015 & 38265-269/2015, 38270- 38271/2015, 38272-38273/2015, 38341-38352/2015, 38354/2015, 38360-38362/2015, 38386/2015, 38478- 38502/2015, 38528-38530/2015, 38546-38548/2015, 38790-38808/2015, 38809-38812/2015, 38813- 38815/2015, 38836-38837/2015, 38899/2015 & 38900- 38901/2015 & 38952-38953/2015, 38903/2015, 38904- Indian Kanoon - http://indiankanoon.org/doc/62564772/ 1 Sri B Athaulla Khan vs State Of Karnataka on 3 May, 2017 38923/2015, 38924-38925/2015 38927-38949/2015 & 38950-51/2015 & 42696- 706/2015, 38984-38986/2015, 39131-39142/2015, 39232-39238/2015, 39343-39347/2015 & 39348- 351/2015, 39354-39358/2015 & 39359-363/2015, 39364-39368/2015 & 39369-373/2015, 39639- 39642/2015, 39643/2015, 39842-39843/2015, 39844- 39848/2015, 40107-40123/2015, 40124-40130/2015, 40148-40152/2015 & 40153-154/2015, 40155- 40167/2015, 40213/2015, 40265-40269/2015, 40270- 40274/2015 & 40275-40279/2015, 40281-40339/2015, 40340-40354/2015, 40355-40365/2015 & 40572- 3 40576/2015 & 40577-40581/2015, 40367-40368/2015, 40369-40371/2015, 40417-40431/2015, 40496- 40500/2015, 40904-40918/2015, 40954-40955/2015, 40956-40976/2015, 41016-41017/2015, 41055- 41080/2015, 41082/2015, 41115-41117/2015, 41138- 41139/2015, 41141/2015, 41233/2015, 41330- 41340/2015, 41482-41505/2015, 41523-41524/2015, 41614/2015, 41615-41617/2015, 41856-41860/2015 & 42035-42039/2015 & 42040-42042/2015 & 42043- 42047/2015, 41876-41888/2015, 41893/2015, 41894- 41898/2015, 42398-42399/2015, 42517-42521/2015 & 42522-524/2015, 42625-42629/2015 & 43118- 119/2015 & 43122/2015, 42719-42723/2015 & 42724- 728/2015, 42794-42815/2015, 42901-42902/2015, 42999-43009/2015, 43107-43111/2015 & 43112/2015, 43178-43179/2015, 43219-43223/2015 & 43224/2015, 43467-43469/2015 & 45171/2015, 43607-43608/2015, 43846-43850/2015 & 43851/2015, 43909-43916/2015, 43924-43926/2015, 44539-44543/2015 & 44544/2015, 44566-44570/2015, 45088-45092/2015, 45550- 45554/2015 & 45555/2015, 45753/2015, 45902- 45904/2015, 45975-45977/2015, 47006-47009/2015, 47253-47254/2015, 47369-47371/2015, 47464/2015, 47606-47607/2015, 47608/2015, 49463-49464/2015, 49743-49747/2015 & 49748-751/2015, 50170- 50173/2015, 50411/2015, 50457-50458/2015, 50460- 4 50472/2015, 50531/2015, 50534-50535/2015, 51742/2015, 52182-52183/2015, 52787/2015 & 52788-791/2015 & 52792-794/2015, 52922-52924/2015, 53163-53165/2015, 53204- 53207/2015 & 54555-561/2015, 54233/2015, 54756- 54759/2015, 54761-54765/2015 & 54766-54767/2015, 54879-54881/2015, 56055-56059/2015 & 56060- Indian Kanoon - http://indiankanoon.org/doc/62564772/ 2 Sri B Athaulla Khan vs State Of Karnataka on 3 May, 2017 64/2015, 56885/2015, 57343-57347/2015 & 57348- 349/2015, 57481-57491/2015, 57492-57494/2015, 59372/2015, 59773/2015, 119-122/2016, 325- 327/2016, 922-923/2016, 1671-1675/2016 & 1676- 1677/2016, 1916-1917/2016, 2145/2016, 2204/2016 & 2205-08/2016 & 2209/2016, 2211/2016, 3064/2016, 3413/2016, 3629-3633/2016 & 3634-3635/2016, 5302/2016, 6193-6194/2016, 7250-7260/2016, 7435/2016, 7532/2016, 7616-7617/2016, 9047/2016, 9077/2016, 9145/2016, 9254-9255/2016, 9342/2016, 9357-9359/2016, 9943-9947/2016 & 9950-9952/2016, 9969/2016, 9970-9971/2016, 19590-19591/2016, 30412-30448/2016, 33024/2016, 35351/2016, 37273/2016, 30637-30644/2016 & 30647-651/2016, 8606/2017, 117-118/2016, 74-75/2015, 28047/2015, 28807/2015, 28887/2015, 29614-29615/2015, 32417/2015, 32501/2015, 33150/2015, 33151/2015, 33262-33263/2015, 33268-33269/2015, 33270/2015, 33271-33272/2015, 33834-33835/2015, 33836/2015, 5 46698/2015, 52472-52473/2015, 54805-54808/2015, 59047/2015 & 378/2016, 123/2016, 191/2016, 2704- 2705/2016, 2804-2805/2016, 2806-2807/2016, 3807- 3808/2016, 3830-3831/2016, 4210/2016, 4284/2016, 5451-5455/2016, 5516/2016, 5518/2016, 5593- 5594/2016, 6195/2016, 6486/2016, 6765/2016 6766/2016, 6769/2016 & 7341-7342/2016, 6773/2016, 8241-8244/2016, 8415/2016, 8514-8515/2016, 8990/2016, 9231-9235/2016, 9285-9286/2016, 9305- 9308/2016, 9603-9604/2016, 9662-9663/2016, 9727- 9728/2016, 9741/2016, 9912/2016, 10252- 10253/2016, 10254/2016, 10256/2016, 10267/2016, 10429/2016, 10442/2016, 10701/2016, 10813- 10814/2016, 13201/2016, 19432-19435/2016, 22654- 22661/2016, 23186/2016, 24721-24722/2016, 25489/2016, 26615/2016, 28647-28648/2016, 28649- 28653/2016 & 28654-55/2016, 29681/2016, 30450/2016, 58692/2016, 18565-566/2016 WP Nos. 49713-49720/2015 BETWEEN: 1. SRI B ATHAULLA KHAN AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS, N.T.R.ASSOCIATES, NO.13/11 P.M.K ROAD, SHANKARPURA, BENGALURU-560004. 6 Indian Kanoon - http://indiankanoon.org/doc/62564772/ 3 Sri B Athaulla Khan vs State Of Karnataka on 3 May, 2017 2. SRI K P VENUGOPAL S/O.K.C.PUTTVEREGOWDA, AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS, PROP. MAHADESHWARA MOTOR SERVICE, KIRUGAVALU, MALAVALLI TALUK, MANDYA DISTRICT-571424. 3. SRI AYUB KHAN S/O ABDUL SALAM, AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS, KUTHAGAHATHA VILLAGE, SHIVANGANGA POST, NELAMANGALA, BENGLURU RURAL DISTRICT. PIN-562 123. 4. SMT MARIYAMMA W/O LATE M.S.MARIYAPPA, AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS, MATHA VILLAGE, ATHIMGERE POST, MAGADI TALUK, RAMANAGARA DISTRICT-561201, (REPRESENTING BY M.SIDDRAJEGOWDA) S/O SMT.MARIYAMMA, AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS, POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER. 5. SRI RAMATHULLA KHAN AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS, PROP. RAMATHULLA KHAN ASSOCIATE, NO.13/11, P.M.K.ROAD, SHANKARPURA, BANGALORE-560004. 6. SRI SAYEED AHMED S/O S.NAZEER AHMED, 7 AGED ABOUT 28 YEARS, HAVELI MOHALLA, KOLAR DISTRICT-563101. 7. SRI MADHUSUDANA S/O GOPAL RAO. B.R. AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS, Indian Kanoon - http://indiankanoon.org/doc/62564772/ 4 Sri B Athaulla Khan vs State Of Karnataka on 3 May, 2017 NO.7, BOMMAVARA VILLAGE, UGANAVADI POST, DEVANAHALLI TALUK, BENGALURU RURAL DISTRICT. 8. SRI SRINIVAS MURTHY S/O HANUMADASAPPA, AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS, VISANI ROAD WARD, NO.1, KALYA GATE, MAGADI TOWN, MAGADI TALUK, RAMANAGARA DISTRICT-51201. ... PETITIONERS (BY SRI. SIDDANANJAIAH, ADVOCATE) AND: 1. STATE OF KARNATAKA BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT, TRANSPORT DEPARTMENT, VIDHANA SOUDHA, BANGLAORE-560001. 2. THE ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT, RURAL DEVELOPMENT & PANCHAYATH RAJ (HEARING AUTHORITY), M.S.BUILDING, 8 AMBEDKAR VEEDHI, BEGNALURU-560001. 3. KARNATAKA STAE ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION K.H.ROAD, SHANTHINAGAR, BANGALORE-560027, REP:BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR, 4. REGIONAL TRANSPORT AUTHORITY BANGALURU RURAL BY ITS SECRETARY, BDA COMPOLEX, KORMANGALA, BANGALORE-560034. 5. REGIONAL TRANSPORT Indian Kanoon - http://indiankanoon.org/doc/62564772/ 5 Sri B Athaulla Khan vs State Of Karnataka on 3 May, 2017 AUTHORITY MYSURU BY ITS SECRETARY RTO OFFICE, MYSURU DISTRICT-570005. 6. REGIONAL TRANSPORT AUTHORITY RAMANAGAR BY ITS SECRETARY, RAMANAGAR DISTRICT-56259. 7. REGIONAL TRANSPORT AUTHORITY TUMKUR BY ITS SECRETARY, TUMKUR DISTRICT-572101. 8. REGIONAL TRANSPORT AUTHORITY KOLAR BY ITS SECRETARY, 9 KOLAR DISTRICT-563101. ... RESPONDENTS (BY SRI. ADITYA SONDHI, ADDL.A.G. ALONG WITH SRI E.S. INDIRESH, AGA FOR R1, 2, 4-8; SRI B. PHALAKSHAIAH, ADVOCATE FOR R-3) THESE WRIT PETITIONS ARE FILED UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE ORDER OF R-1 DTD:5.8.2015 AT ANNEXURE-B. WP NOS. 27986-27990/2012 & W.P.NOS.27991- 27993/2012 BETWEEN 1. SRI. P T VENUGOPAL AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS S/O SRI P G THYAGARAJAN NO.12/11, 4TH MAIN MADIWALA NEW EXTENSION BANGALORE . 2. SRI A VENUGOPAL AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS NO.12/11, 4TH MAIN MADIWALA NEW EXTENSION BANGALORE. 3. SMT LAKSHMI DEVI AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS W/O SRI UMAPATHI NO.12/11, 4TH MAIN, MADIWALA NEW EXTENSION BANGALORE. 4. SMT SAROJAMMA AGED ABOUT 32 YEARS W/O LATE SRI RAJASHEKAR NO.230, SECOND CROSS, SECOND STAGE, 7TH BLOCK, NAGARABHAVI BANGALORE. ... PETITIONERS (BY SRI.B R SUNDARARAJA GUPTA, ADVOCATE) AND: 1. THE REGIONAL TRANSPORT AUTHORITY BANGALORE RURAL B D A COMPLEX KORAMANGALA BANGALORE- 560 034 BY ITS SECRETARY Indian Kanoon - http://indiankanoon.org/doc/62564772/ 6 Sri B Athaulla Khan vs State Of Karnataka on 3 May, 2017 2. THE KARNATAKA STATE ROAD TRANSPORT CORPORATION KENGAL HANUMANTHAIAH ROAD BANGALORE -560027 BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR 3.