Arizona Ports of Entry Study Working Paper # 1: Current Conditions Final Paper Volume 1 prepared for Arizona Department of Transportation prepared by Cambridge Systematics, Inc. with Kimley-Horn and Associates and BGM Consulting January 9, 2013 www.camsys.com report Arizona Ports of Entry Study Working Paper # 1: Current Conditions prepared for Arizona Department of Transportation prepared by Cambridge Systematics, Inc. 115 South LaSalle Street, Suite 2200 Chicago, IL 60603 with Kimley-Horn and Associates and BGM Consulting date January 9, 2013 Arizona Ports of Entry Study Table of Contents Executive Summary .................................................................................................... 1 1.0 Overview: State Port of Entry Facilities ....................................................... 1-3 1.1 Introduction and Document Organization ........................................... 1-3 1.2 Summary of Work Performed ................................................................ 1-3 1.3 Summary of Findings Regarding Current Conditions ......................... 1-7 Directional Focus .................................................................................... 1-7 Operating Hours and Status .................................................................. 1-7 Traffic Volumes ....................................................................................... 1-7 Business Activities .................................................................................. 1-8 Physical Condition ................................................................................ 1-12 Technological Limitations .................................................................... 1-13 Staffing ................................................................................................... 1-14 Federal Data .......................................................................................... 1-14 2.0 Primary Port Facilities .................................................................................... 2-1 2.1 Ehrenberg Port of Entry Facility ............................................................ 2-1 2.2 Kingman Port of Entry Facility .............................................................. 2-9 2.3 St. George Port of Entry Facility .......................................................... 2-16 2.4 Sanders Port of Entry Facility .............................................................. 2-23 2.5 San Simon Port of Entry Facility .......................................................... 2-30 2.6 Topock Port of Entry Facility ............................................................... 2-37 2.7 Yuma (I-8) Port of Entry Facility .......................................................... 2-44 3.0 Secondary Port Facilities ................................................................................ 3-2 3.1 Page Port of Entry Facility ...................................................................... 3-2 3.2 Teec Nos Pos Port of Entry Facility ....................................................... 3-9 3.3 Yuma (B-8) Port of Entry Facility ......................................................... 3-16 3.4 Duncan Port of Entry Facility .............................................................. 3-21 3.5 Fredonia Port of Entry Facility ............................................................. 3-27 3.6 Parker Port of Entry Facility ................................................................. 3-33 3.7 Springerville Port of Entry Facility ...................................................... 3-38 Cambridge Systematics, Inc. i 8605-010 Arizona Ports of Entry Study List of Tables Table 1.1 Task 2: Data Sources ............................................................................. 1-4 Table 1.2 Stakeholders Interviewed .................................................................... 1-6 Table 1.3 Port of Entry Facility Operating Hours .............................................. 1-7 Table 1.4 Arizona Domestic Port of Entry Traffic Counts ................................. 1-8 Table 1.5 Arizona Domestic Port of Entry Summary Statistics: Annual Averages 2009-2011 (Inbound and Outbound) ................................ 1-10 Table 1.6 Arizona Domestic Port of Entry Summary Statistics: Average Annual Operating Expenses 2009-2011 ............................................ 1-12 Table 2.1 Ehrenberg Port of Entry Annual Statistics 2009-2011 ........................ 2-7 Table 2.2 Ehrenberg Port of Entry Annual Cost Data 2009-2011 ...................... 2-8 Table 2.3 Kingman Port of Entry Annual Statistics 2009-2011 ........................ 2-14 Table 2.4 Kingman Port of Entry Annual Cost Data 2009-2011 ...................... 2-15 Table 2.5 St. George Port of Entry Annual Statistics 2009-2011 ...................... 2-21 Table 2.6 St. George Port of Entry Annual Cost Data 2009-2011 .................... 2-22 Table 2.7 Sanders Port of Entry Annual Statistics 2009-2011 .......................... 2-28 Table 2.8 Sanders Port of Entry Annual Cost Data 2009-2011......................... 2-29 Table 2.9 San Simon Port of Entry Annual Statistics 2009-2011 ...................... 2-35 Table 2.10 San Simon Port of Entry Annual Cost Data 2009-2011 .................... 2-36 Table 2.11 Topock Port of Entry Annual Statistics 2009-2011 ........................... 2-42 Table 2.12 Topock Port of Entry Annual Cost Data 2009-2011 ......................... 2-43 Table 2.13 Yuma I-8 Avenue Port of Entry Annual Statistics 2009-2011 .......... 2-49 Table 2.14 Yuma (I-8 and B-8) Port of Entry Annual Cost Data 2009-2011 ........ 2-1 Table 3.1 Page Port of Entry Annual Statistics 2009-2011 .................................. 3-7 Table 3.2 Page Port of Entry Annual Cost Data 2009-2011 ................................ 3-8 Table 3.3 Teec Nos Pos Port of Entry Annual Statistics 2009-2011 ................. 3-14 Table 3.4 Teec Nos Pos Port of Entry Annual Cost Data 2009-2011 ............... 3-15 Table 3.5 Yuma (B-8) Avenue Port of Entry Annual Statistics 2009-2011 ...... 3-20 Table 3.6 Duncan Port of Entry Annual Statistics 2009-2011 .......................... 3-25 Cambridge Systematics, Inc. iii List of Tables, continued Table 3.7 Duncan Port of Entry Annual Cost Data 2009-2011 ......................... 3-26 Table 3.8 Fredonia Port of Entry Annual Statistics 2009-2011 ......................... 3-31 Table 3.9 Fredonia Port of Entry Annual Cost Data 2009-2011 ...................... 3-32 Table 3.10 Parker Port of Entry Annual Statistics 2009-2011 ............................. 3-36 Table 3.11 Parker Port of Entry Annual Cost Data 2009-2011 ........................... 3-37 Table 3.12 Springerville Port of Entry Annual Statistics 2009-2011 .................. 3-41 Table 3.13 Springerville Port of Entry Annual Cost Data 2009-2011 ................ 3-42 iv Cambridge Systematics, Inc. 8605-010 Arizona Ports of Entry Study List of Figures Figure 2.1 Ehrenberg Port of Entry Facility .......................................................... 2-1 Figure 2.2 Ehrenberg Port of Entry Satellite View ............................................... 2-2 Figure 2.3 Kingman Port of Entry Facility ............................................................ 2-9 Figure 2.4 Kingman Port of Entry Satellite View ............................................... 2-10 Figure 2.5 St. George Port of Entry Facility ........................................................ 2-16 Figure 2.6 St. George Port of Entry Satellite View ............................................. 2-17 Figure 2.7 Sanders Port of Entry Facility ............................................................ 2-23 Figure 2.8 Sanders Port of Entry Satellite View ................................................. 2-24 Figure 2.9 San Simon Port of Entry Facility ....................................................... 2-30 Figure 2.10 San Simon Port of Entry Satellite View ............................................. 2-31 Figure 2.11 Topock Port of Entry Facility ............................................................. 2-37 Figure 2.12 Topock Port of Entry Satellite View .................................................. 2-38 Figure 2.13 Yuma (I-8) Port of Entry Facility ....................................................... 2-44 Figure 2.14 Yuma (I-8) Port of Entry Satellite View ............................................ 2-45 Figure 3.1 Page Port of Entry Facility ................................................................... 3-3 Figure 3.2 Page Port of Entry Satellite View ........................................................ 3-4 Figure 3.3 Teec Nos Pos Port of Entry Facility ..................................................... 3-9 Figure 3.4 Teec Nos Pos Port of Entry Satellite View ........................................ 3-10 Figure 3.5 Yuma (B-8) Port of Entry Facility ...................................................... 3-16 Figure 3.6 Yuma (B-8) Port of Entry Satellite View ........................................... 3-17 Figure 3.7 Duncan Port of Entry Facility ............................................................ 3-21 Figure 3.8 Duncan Port of Entry Satellite View ................................................. 3-22 Figure 3.9 Fredonia Port of Entry Facility .......................................................... 3-27 Figure 3.10 Fredonia Port of Entry Satellite View ............................................... 3-28 Figure 3.11 Parker Port of Entry Facility .............................................................. 3-33 Figure 3.12