QUeensland Alcohol-related violence and Night Time Economy Monitoring (QUANTEM) APPENDICES (April 2019) Prof Peter Miller Dr Richelle Mayshak Dr Kerri Coomber Dr Renee Zahnow A/Prof Jason Ferris Prof Robin Room Ms Michele Burn Dr Debbie Scott Ms Thea Vakidis Ms Steffi Cook Dr Michael Livingston Mr Simon Towle Dr Nic Droste Mr Scott Regan Mr Nic Taylor Dr Lachlan Goold Dr Cheneal Puljević Dr David Mount Dr Dominique de Andrade Ms Lillian Rangiah Dr Ashlee Curtis Ms Lauren Boubouras Ms Kristy Grant Mr Bowman Nixon Dr Foruhar Moayeri Ms Brooke Vayne Dr Nicholas Carah Mr Ryan Baldwin Dr Jason Jiang Prof Jake Najman Ms Barbara Wood TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. Appendix 1: Differences between ID scanner data Sources ............................................................................................ 1 2. Appendix 2: Patron Interviews – West End Comparison Site ........................................................................................ 2 2.1. Patron Demographics ............................................................................................................................................. 2 2.2. Levels of Intoxication (BAC Reading and BAC Estimate) .................................................................................... 4 2.3. Pre-drinking Behaviour .......................................................................................................................................... 7 2.4. Drug Consumption Patterns.................................................................................................................................. 10 2.4.1. Drug Swabs ..................................................................................................................................................... 12 2.5. Experiences of Aggression and Harm .................................................................................................................. 13 3. Appendix 3: Patron Interviews – Planned and Past Movements .................................................................................. 15 3.1. Cairns ................................................................................................................................................................... 15 3.2. Fortitude Valley .................................................................................................................................................... 17 3.3. Surfers Paradise .................................................................................................................................................... 19 4. Appendix 4: Patron Interviews – Signs of Intoxication ................................................................................................. 22 4.1. Cairns ................................................................................................................................................................... 22 4.2. Fortitude Valley .................................................................................................................................................... 23 4.3. Surfers Paradise .................................................................................................................................................... 25 5. Appendix 5: List of Signs of Intoxication ....................................................................................................................... 28 6. Appendix 6: Patron Interviews - Perceived effect of Government Policy .................................................................... 29 Cairns .................................................................................................................................................................................. 29 Fortitude Valley .................................................................................................................................................................. 30 6.1.1. West End Comparison ..................................................................................................................................... 31 Surfers Paradise .................................................................................................................................................................. 32 7. Appendix 7: Patron Interviews – Perceived Safety Rating ........................................................................................... 34 7.1. Cairns ................................................................................................................................................................... 34 7.2. Fortitude Valley .................................................................................................................................................... 35 7.2.1. West End Comparison ..................................................................................................................................... 35 7.3. Surfers Paradise .................................................................................................................................................... 36 Appendix 8: Venue observations data .................................................................................................................................. 37 Appendix 9: Precinct mapping ............................................................................................................................................... 1 7.4. Fortitude Valley ...................................................................................................................................................... 1 7.5. West End ................................................................................................................................................................ 4 7.6. Surfers Paradise ...................................................................................................................................................... 8 7.7. Cairns ..................................................................................................................................................................... 9 7.8. Townsville ............................................................................................................................................................ 11 7.9. Toowoomba .......................................................................................................................................................... 13 Appendix 10: Maps showing the temporal and spatial change of live music Performances in Fortitude Valley for the 2001-2018 financial years ................................................................................................................................................. 15 Appendix 11: Maps showing the temporal and spatial change of live music performances in Brisbane for the 2001- 2018 financial years .......................................................................................................................................................... 33 Appendix 12: Maps showing the temporal and spatial change of live music performances in Cairns for the 2001-2018 financial years ................................................................................................................................................................... 51 Appendix 13: Maps showing the temporal and spatial change of live music performances in Surfers Paradise for the 2001-2018 financial years ................................................................................................................................................. 69 Appendix 14. Communication from QGSO regarding Queensland Preventative Health Survey ................................... 87 Appendix 15. Economic evaluation survey results and Detailed calculation method of cost per incident ..................... 90 7.10. Impact on the licensed premises ........................................................................................................................... 90 7.11. Costs of serious assaults in the criminal justice system in Queensland ................................................................ 91 7.12. Costs of hospital admissions and emergency department services in Queensland ............................................... 92 7.13. Costs of ambulance call-outs in Queensland ........................................................................................................ 92 7.14. Costs of traffic crashes in Queensland .................................................................................................................. 92 Appendix 16: Evaluation Framework .................................................................................................................................. 94 Appendix 17: Two Independent Reviews of QUANTEM Evaluation Report ................................................................... 97 7.15. Reviewer number 1 .............................................................................................................................................. 97 7.16. Reviewer number 2 ............................................................................................................................................ 109 i TABLES TABLE 1 PARTICIPANTS’ SEX AND AGE IN WEST END BY INTERVIEW TYPE (BRIEF/FULL) ............................................................... 2 TABLE 2 BAC READING AND ESTIMATES AMONG PARTICIPANTS IN