Public Document Pack Peak District National Park Authority Tel: 01629 816200 E-mail: [email protected] Web: www.peakdistrict.gov.uk Minicom: 01629 816319 Aldern House, Baslow Road, Bakewell, Derbyshire. DE45 1AE Our Ref: A.1142/1674 Date: 26 January 2017 NOTICE OF MEETING Meeting: Planning Committee Date: Friday 3 February 2017 Time: 12.00 pm Venue: Board Room, Aldern House, Baslow Road, Bakewell SARAH FOWLER CHIEF EXECUTIVE AGENDA 1. Apologies for Absence 2. Minutes of previous meeting 09/12/2016 (Pages 1 - 4) 3. Urgent Business 4. Members Declarations of Interest Members are asked to declare any disclosable pecuniary, personal or prejudicial interests they may have in relation to items on the agenda for this meeting. 5. Public Participation To note any questions or to receive any statements, representations, deputations and petitions which relate to the published reports on Part A of the Agenda. 6. Review of Old Mineral Permission Application - Old Moor Quarry (Tunstead), Wormhill, Buxton (NP/HPK/1013/0898, M11781, JEN) (Pages 5 - 42) Annex 1 Site Plan 7. Full Application - Operational Facilities for Brosterfield Camping and Caravan Site to Include Amenity Building, New Access, Manager's Accommodation and Associated Ancillary Facilities at Brosterfield Caravan Site, Foolow (NP/DDD/1016/0972, P.10457, P.11062 AND P.4484, 03/10/2016, 418941 / 376200/AM) (Pages 43 - 78) Appendix A Appendix B Appendix B Plan Appendix C Site Plan Duration of Meeting In the event of not completing its business within 3 hours of the start of the meeting, in accordance with the Authority’s Standing Orders, the Authority will decide whether or not to continue the meeting. If the Authority decides not to continue the meeting it will be adjourned and the remaining business considered at the next scheduled meeting. If the Authority has not completed its business by 1.00pm and decides to continue the meeting the Chair will exercise discretion to adjourn the meeting at a suitable point for a 30 minute lunch break after which the committee will re-convene. ACCESS TO INFORMATION - LOCAL GOVERNMENT ACT 1972 (as amended) Agendas and reports Copies of the Agenda and Part A reports are available for members of the public before and during the meeting. These are also available on the website www.peakdistrict.gov.uk . Background Papers The Local Government Act 1972 requires that the Authority shall list any unpublished Background Papers necessarily used in the preparation of the Reports. The Background Papers referred to in each report, PART A, excluding those papers that contain Exempt or Confidential Information, PART B, can be inspected by appointment at the National Park Office, Bakewell. Contact Democratic Services on 01629 816200, ext 362/382. E-mail address: [email protected]. Public Participation and Other Representations from third parties Anyone wishing to participate at the meeting under the Authority's Public Participation Scheme is required to give notice to the Director of Corporate Strategy and Development to be received not later than 12.00 noon on the Wednesday preceding the Friday meeting. The Scheme is available on the website www.peakdistrict.gov.uk or on request from Democratic Services 01629 816362, email address: [email protected]. Written Representations Other written representations on items on the agenda, except those from formal consultees, will not be reported to the meeting if received after 12noon on the Wednesday preceding the Friday meeting. Recording of Meetings In accordance with the Local Audit and Accountability Act 2014 members of the public may record and report on our open meetings using sound, video, film, photograph or any other means this includes blogging or tweeting, posts on social media sites or publishing on video sharing sites. If you intend to record or report on one of our meetings you are asked to contact the Democratic and Legal Support Team in advance of the meeting so we can make sure it will not disrupt the meeting and is carried out in accordance with any published protocols and guidance. The Authority uses an audio sound system to make it easier to hear public speakers and discussions during the meeting and to make a digital sound recording available after the meeting. The recordings will usually be retained only until the minutes of this meeting have been confirmed. General Information for Members of the Public Attending Meetings Aldern House is situated on the A619 Bakewell to Baslow Road, the entrance to the drive is opposite the Ambulance Station. Car parking is available. Local Bus Services from Bakewell centre and from Chesterfield and Sheffield pick up and set down near Aldern House. Further information on Public transport from surrounding areas can be obtained from Traveline on 0871 200 2233 or on the Traveline website at www.travelineeastmidlands.co.uk. Please note that there is no catering provision for members of the public during meal breaks. However, there are cafes, pubs and shops in Bakewell town centre, approximately 15 minutes walk away. To: Members of Planning Committee: Chair: Mr P Ancell Vice Chair: Cllr D Birkinshaw Cllr P Brady Cllr C Carr Cllr D Chapman Cllr A Hart Mr R Helliwell Cllr Mrs C Howe Cllr H Laws Ms S McGuire Cllr J Macrae Cllr Mrs K Potter Cllr Mrs L C Roberts Cllr Mrs J A Twigg Cllr D Williams Other invited Members: (May speak but not vote) Cllr A McCloy Cllr F J Walton Constituent Authorities Secretary of State for the Environment Natural England This page is intentionally left blank Agenda Item 2. Peak District National Park Authority Tel: 01629 816200 E-mail: [email protected] Web: www.peakdistrict.gov.uk Minicom: 01629 816319 Aldern House, Baslow Road, Bakewell, Derbyshire. DE45 1AE MINUTES Meeting: Planning Committee Date: Friday 9 December 2016 at 10.00 am Venue: Board Room, Aldern House, Baslow Road, Bakewell Chair: Mr P Ancell Present: Cllr D Birkinshaw, Cllr P Brady, Cllr C Carr, Cllr D Chapman, Cllr A Hart, Mr R Helliwell, Cllr Mrs C Howe, Cllr H Laws, Ms S McGuire, Cllr J Macrae, Cllr Mrs K Potter, Cllr Mrs L C Roberts, Cllr Mrs J A Twigg and Cllr D Williams Apologies for absence: Cllr A McCloy and Cllr F J Walton. 159/16 CHAIRS ANNOUNCEMENTS The Chair of the Committee reported that item 6 on the agenda relating to the application for operational facilities at Brosterfield Camping and Caravanning site had been withdrawn and will now be heard at the Planning Committee on 13 January 2017. 160/16 MINUTES OF PREVIOUS MEETING The minutes of the last meeting of the Planning Committee held on 11 November 2016 were approved subject to the amendments below, as a correct record. Minute 144/16 relating to the application for the temporary use of land for a Horticultural Show at Chatsworth House was amended to show that the RHS will set up the Liaison Committee. The minute 150/16 was amended to show that the building had intrinsic merit related to water management and treatment in the area. 161/16 MEMBERS DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST Item 7 Cllr Andrew Hart and Cllr Kath Potter had each received correspondence regarding the application. Item 8 Mr Robert Helliwell declared a personal interest as he knew the applicant Mr Corbridge. Item 9 Page 1 Planning Committee Meeting Minutes Page 2 Friday 9 December 2016 Cllr Kath Potter declared a personal interest as she had asked that the Planning Committee Site Visit on 8 December drive past the site. 162/16 PUBLIC PARTICIPATION Two members of the public were present to make representations to the Committee. 163/16 FULL APPLICATION - ERECTION OF WOODEN PODS FOR CAMPING AT NETTLEBEDS FARM, TOP HOUSE LANE, WINCLE Members had visited the site on the previous day. The following spoke under the Public Participation at Meetings Scheme: Mr John Cartledge for Applicant The application had been deferred from the last Planning Committee to enable a site visit to take place. Members had noted on the site visit the severity of the steepness of the site and the distance from the farm yard to the pods as this had been the suggested parking place for those using the camping pods. An alternative site closer to the main farm buildings and on flatter ground would be more appropriate . The applicant had already discounted the farm yard as a parking location, following submission of the application, due to the health and safety risks and a new site for parking also needed to be identified. It was noted by Members that the size of the pods was due to the fact that there was not an amenity building on site so all washing and toilet facilities were self contained in the pods. The Officer recommendation to refuse the application was moved, seconded, put to the vote and carried. Members requested that the applicant work with Officers to identify an alternative site. RESOLVED: That the application be REFUSED for the following reasons: 1. By virtue of the siting, size and layout of the proposed camping pods and the engineering works required to facilitate the development on this sloping site, the proposed development would appear unduly intrusive, having an unacceptable adverse visual impact on the character of the surrounding landscape and consequently harming the valued characteristics of the National Park. The development would therefore be contrary to Core Strategy policies GSP1, GSP3, L1 and RT3, saved Local Plan policies LC4 and LR3 and to policies in the National Planning Policy Framework, including the provisions of Paragraph 115 relating to development in National Parks. 164/16 FULL APPLICATION - ERECTION OF LOCAL NEEDS AFFORDABLE DWELLING AT SHUTTS FARM, SHUTTS LANE, BAKEWELL Members had visited the site on the previous day.