1 2 ETHICS, POLITICS & SOCIETY A JOURNAL IN MORAL AND POLITICAL PHILOSOPHY Number 1- 2018 A Multidimensional View of Misrecognition Douglas Giles Combining Democratic Equality and Luck Egalitarianism Lars Lindblom Norms for the Public Remembrance of Nonhuman Animals Matthew McLennan 8Th Braga Meetings on Ethics And Political Philosophy, With Gustaf Arrhenius Symposium: HAYEK-POLANYI 3 Title Ethics, Politics & Society. A Journal in Moral and Political Philosophy (nº1 2018). Editor-in-chief João Cardoso Rosas. Editors Alexandra Abranches, David Álvarez, João Ribeiro Mendes, Roberto Merrill. Guest editors Alexandra Abranches and Eze Paez for the “8th Braga Meetings on Ethics and Political Philosophy, with Gustaf Arrhenius”; António Batista and Pedro Teixeira for the “Symposium: Hayek-Polanyi”. E-mail [email protected] Editorial board Acílio Estanqueiro Rocha, Alexandra Abranches, Ana Rita Ferreira, António Baião, António Luís Silva Baptista, Bernhard Josef Sylla, Bruno Serra, Catia Faria, Daniele Santoro, David Álvarez, Eze Paez, Giuseppe Ballacci, Hugo Rajão, João Ribeiro Mendes, José Augusto Colen, João Cardoso Rosas, Marco Marian, Pedro Miguel Martins, Roberto Merrill, Sara Bizarro. Scientific Committee Adam Swift, Alan Thomas, Ángel Rivero, Jonathan Wolff, Maria Xosé Agra, Samuel Scheffler, Seyla Benhabib. Edition April 2018. Centre for Ethics, Politics and Society University of Minho, Braga, Portugal. ISSN DOI 2184-2582 https://doi.org/10.21814/eps.1.1 Website http://www.epsjournal.ilch.uminho.pt 4 TABLE OF CONTENTS Introductory Note The Editors ______________________________________ 7 A Multidimensional View of Misrecognition Douglas Giles ____________________________________ 9 Combining Democratic Equality and Luck Egalitarianism Lars Lindblom ___________________________________ 39 Norms for the Public Remembrance of Nonhuman Animals Matthew McLennan _______________________________ 63 8TH BRAGA MEETINGS ON ETHICS AND POLITICAL PHILOSOPHY Introduction Alexandra Abranches, Eze Paez ________________________ 85 The democratic boundary problem reconsidered Gustaf Arrhenius _________________________________ 89 Are moral functionalism’s moral a priori commitments really a priori? Ashley Lane ____________________________________ 123 Gender Identities and Feminism Josh T. U. Cohen _________________________________ 139 Are we post-justification? Stout’s case for self-knowledge, political justification and public philosophy Deven Burks ____________________________________ 175 Hobbes: a voluntarist about the permissibility of state enforcement? Daniel Guillery _________________________________ 203 5 Ethics, Politics & Society Basic Liberties, the Moral Powers and Workplace Democracy Stephen K. McLeod ________________________________ 231 From Natural Law to the Golden Rule: Aquinas Revisited Damiano Simoncelli _______________________________ 261 SYMPOSIUM: HAYEK-POLANYI Hayek and Polanyi for the 21st century – an introduction António Baptista, Pedro A. Teixeira ______________________ 279 O credo liberal e os seus críticos: pauperismo e rede de segurança António Baião, J. A. Colen, Pedro Moreira _________________ 305 The Double Movement in Polanyi and Hayek: Towards the Continuation of Life Filipe Nobre Faria _______________________________ 329 Mito, utopia e democracia em A Grande Transformação de Karl Polanyi Patrícia Fernandes ________________________________ 351 Polanyi’s Economic Embeddedness, Countermovement, and Republican Political Economy Bru Lain _____________________________________ 369 O debate na grande transformação: Ludwig von Mises, Friedrich Hayek e Karl Polanyi sobre capitalismo, socialismo e mercados João Rodrigues _________________________________ 403 6 INTRODUCTORY NOTE Ethics, Politics & Society is a new open access academic journal with double blind peer review dedicated to the publication of high level contributions in the fields of Political Philosophy and Theory, as well as Normative and Applied Ethics. Although it is open to all themes and approaches in these areas of knowledge, the journal focuses on issues related to theories of justice, democracy and recognition, as well as on ethical issues connected to scientific and technological development and their social and environmental impacts. Ethics, Politics & Society accepts the submission of originals both with a direct contemporary approach, or using the History of Moral and Political Philosophy to shed light on relevant problems in our time. This first issue of Ethics, Politics & Society includes an open section and two closed sections that have been nevertheless subject to the same standards of peer- review. The first open section is composed with original articles submitted by Douglas Giles, Lars Lindblom and Matthew McLennan. The section devoted to the 8th Braga Meetings on Ethics and Political Philosophy opens with the keynote lecture on “The Democratic Boundary Problem Reconsidered” delivered in Braga by Gustaf Arrhenius. This outstanding contribution is followed by a dossier of selected papers presented at the Meetings by Ashley Lane, Josh T. U. Cohen, Deven Burks, Daniel Guillery, Stephen McLeod, and Damiano Simoncelli. This section has been guest edited by Alexandra Abranches and Eze Paez. The third section consists of a Symposium on Friedrich Hayek and Karl Polanyi. This timely and provocative book discussion that combines readings of The Road to Serfdom and The Great Transformation has been guest edited by António Baptista and Pedro Teixeira, with contributions by António Baião, José Colen and Pedro Moreira, Filipe Nobre Faria, Patrícia Fernandes, Bru Lain, and João Rodrigues. Ethics, Politics & Society encourages prospective authors to submit their manuscripts in English, Portuguese or Spanish through the journal website, together with the statement that the submitted piece has not been published before and elsewhere. All the papers submitted to Ethics, Politics & Society are 7 Ethics, Politics & Society subject to the evaluation of at least two reviewers in the corresponding scientific domain. Papers are sent anonymously to blind referees, who are asked to write a review according to the evaluation form adopted by the journal, which includes the following aspects: adequacy to the journal publication standards; adequacy of the paper subject to the scope of the journal; substantive relevance; originality; relevance of the critical methodology; clarity of presentation; arguments and relationship between initial hypotheses and final results. With the appearance of Ethics, Politics & Society, its editors believe that a clear and urgent lacuna is filled in for an international journal that works as a high-level global forum imprinted with the perspective of Southern Europe. 8 A MULTIDIMENSIONAL VIEW OF MISRECOGNITION UMA VISÃO MULTIDIMENSIONAL DO NÃO-RECONHECIMENTO Douglas Giles* [email protected] Abstract. Following Axel Honneth, I accept that recognition is integral to individuals’ self-realization and to social justice and that instances of misrecognition are injustices that cause moral injuries. The change in approach to misrecognition that I advocate is to replace a macrosocial top-down picture of misrecognition, such as Honneth’s typology, with a fine-grained phenomenological picture of multiple dimensions in misrecognition behaviors that offers greater explanatory power. This paper explains why a multidimensional view of misrecognition is needed and explores the various ways that engagement with pathological norms or disengagement from individuals lead to injustices of misrecognition and how understanding behaviors in terms of these two dimensions—norms and individuals—illuminates causes of injustice. The multidimensional view of misrecognition replaces Honneth’s binary view of misrecognition as the contrary to recognition without replacing Honneth’s conceptions of the value of recognition. Keywords: recognition, injustice, Honneth, social justice, misrecognition. Sumário. Seguindo Axel Honneth, aceito que o reconhecimento é parte integrante da auto-realização dos indivíduos e da justiça e que os casos de não- reconhecimento são injustiças que causam ferimentos. A mudança de abordagem para o não-reconhecimento que eu defendo é substituir uma imagem macrossocial de alto nível de desconhecimento por uma imagem fenomenológica de dimensões múltiplas de comportamentos de reconhecimento misto que oferece maior poder explicativo. Este artigo explica por que é necessária uma visão multidimensional do não-reconhecimento e explora as várias maneiras pelas quais o engajamento com as normas patológicas ou o desengajamento dos indivíduos conduzem a injustiças de não-reconhecimento e a compreensão de comportamentos em termos de duas dimensões - normas e indivíduos - ilumina causas de injustiça. A visão multidimensional do reconhecimento misto substitui a visão binária de Honneth do não-reconhecimento como contrário à noção de reconhecimento, sem substituir as concepções de Honneth sobre o valor do reconhecimento. * Associate Fellow, School of Philosophy and Art History, University of Essex. 9 Ethics, Politics & Society Palavras.chave: reconhecimento, injustiça, Honneth, justiça social, não- reconhecimento. 0. Introduction Following Axel Honneth and others, I accept that recognition is integral to individuals’ self-realization and to social justice and that instances of misrecognition are injustices that cause moral injuries. The change in approach to misrecognition that I advocate is to replace a macrosocial top-down picture of misrecognition,