KEISHA LANCE 55 TRINITY AVENUE, S.W. SUITE 3350 - ATLANTA, GEORGIA 30303-0308 TIM KEANE BOTTOMS 404-330-6145 - FAX: 404-658-7491 Commissioner MAYOR www.atlantaga.gov KEVIN BACON, AIA, AICP Director, Office of Design Proposed Agenda ATLANTA URBAN DESIGN COMMISSION May 12, 2021 Zoom Meeting Registration: https://zoom.us/meeting/register/tJEldu6grjsiGtfHOGy4ybKfZf4IxNvX2c-a Meeting ID: 958 1780 0803 Dial-In: 646-558-8656, access code, 95817800803# 1. Call to Order 2. Approval of Agenda 3. Approval of Minutes 4. Business: Consent Agenda a) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (CA3-21-035) for new construction at 1151 Arlington Ave SW. Property is zoned R-4A / Oakland City Historic District / Beltline. Applicant: Janice M. White 1854 Virginia Avenue, Ste. 2 Deferred on February 10, 2021 Staff Recommendation: Approval with Conditions. Commission Voted: Approved with Conditions. b) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (CA3-21-083) for new construction at 1135 Montreat Ave SW. Property is zoned R-4A / Oakland City Historic District / Beltline. Applicant: Benjamin Middlebrooks PO Box 3275, McDonough Deferred on March 24, 2021 Staff Recommendation: Deferral to the May 26, 2021 public hearing. Commission Voted: Deferred to the May 26, 2021 public hearing. c) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (CA3-21-092) for new construction at 731 Lawton St SW. Property is zoned R-4A / West End Historic District / Beltline. Applicant: Andrew Washington 1635 Old 41 Hwy Deferred on March 10, 2021 Staff Recommendation: Deferral to the May 26, 2021 public hearing. Commission Voted: Deferred to the May 26, 2021 public hearing. Hearing Agenda May 12, 2021 Page 2 of 5 d) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (CA3-21-128) for a variance to reduce the east side yard setback from 14’ (required) to 8’ 10” (proposed); and (CA3-21-129) for a rear addition at 1130 Alta Ave NE. Property is zoned R-5 / Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1) / Beltline. Applicant: Laura Daniel 368 Moreland Avenue Deferred on March 24, 2021 Staff Recommendation: Deferral to the May 26, 2021 public hearing. Commission Voted: Deferred to the May 26, 2021 public hearing. e) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (CA2-21-143) for new signage at 212 Edgewood Ave NE. Property is zoned Martin Luther King, Jr. Landmark District (Subarea 4). Applicant: Gregory Rutledge 45 Inverness Drive Deferred on April 14, 2021 Staff Recommendation: Denial without prejudice. Commission Voted: Denied without prejudice. f) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (CA2-21-170) for alterations at 1181 Arlington Ave SW. Property is zoned R-4 / Oakland City Historic District / Beltline. Applicant: Morgan Tolley 1181 Arlington Avenue Deferred on April 28, 2021 Staff Recommendation: Deferral to the May 26, 2021 public hearing. Commission Voted: Deferred to the May 26, 2021 public hearing. g) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (CA2-21-194) for alterations at 2825 Crescendo Dr NW. Property is zoned R-4 / Collier Heights Historic District. Applicant: Scott Berezo PO Box 2139, Kennesaw Staff Recommendation: Approval with Conditions. Commission Voted: Approved with Conditions. h) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (CA3-21-203) for alterations and side stoop additions at 782 Dixie Ave NE. Property is zoned RG-2 / Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 1). Applicant: Wright Gardner 154 Krog Street NE, Suite 125 Staff Recommendation: Approval. Commission Voted: Approved. i) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (CA3-21-204) for the subdivision of one (1) lot into four (4) lots; and (CA3-21-065) for alterations and an addition at 950 Allene Ave SW. Property is zoned R-4A / Adair Park Historic District (Subarea 1) / Beltline. Applicant: Derrick Harris 1110 Shadybrook Lane Deferred on February 24, 2021 Staff Recommendation: Deferral to the May 26, 2021 public hearing. Commission Voted: Deferred to the May 26, 2021 public hearing. Please submit Historic Preservation staff questions to [email protected] and comments to the Urban Design Commission to [email protected]. Hearing Agenda May 12, 2021 Page 3 of 5 Items Requiring Discussion from the April 28, 2021 Commission meeting not heard due to a loss of quorum j) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (CA3-20-369) for new construction of a single-family home at 186 Powell St SE. Property is zoned Cabbagetown Landmark District (Subarea 3) / Beltline. Applicant: Monica Woods 67 A Boulevard NE Deferred on December 9, 2020 Staff Recommendation: Approval with Conditions. Commission Voted: Approved with revised Conditions. k) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (CA3-21-041) for an addition and site work at 240 North Highland Ave NE. Property is zoned Inman Park Historic District (Subarea 3) / Beltline. Applicant: William Jay George 15 Franklin Street, # 10, Avondale Estates Deferred on February 24, 2021 Staff Recommendation: Approval. Commission Voted: Approved with Conditions. l) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (CA3-21-095) for alterations, an addition, and site work at 1017 Sparks St SW. Property is zoned R-4A / Oakland City Historic District / Beltline. Applicant: Min Kim 3991 Kingsley Park Lane, Peachtree Corners Deferred on March 10, 2021 Staff Recommendation: Approval with Conditions. Commission Voted: Deferred to the May 26, 2021 public hearing due to lack of applicant representation at the public hearing. m) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (CA2-21-096) for alterations at 916 Hill St SE. Property is zoned R-5 / Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1) / Beltine. Applicant: E. Hal Swims 2534 Cedar Canyon Rd SE, Marietta Deferred on March 10, 2021 Staff Recommendation: Approval with Conditions. Commission Voted: Approved with revised Conditions. Items Requiring Discussion n) Application for a Designation (D-21-175) for designation of the 1331 Metropolitan Parkway-Masonic Building to the Landmark Building / Site (LBS) category at 1331 Metropolitan Pkwy SW. Property is zoned NC-9 / Beltline. Applicant: Doug Young 55 Trinity Avenue, SW Deferred on April 28, 2021 Staff Recommendation: Adopt the nomination resolution. Commission Voted: Adopted the nomination resolution. Please submit Historic Preservation staff questions to [email protected] and comments to the Urban Design Commission to [email protected]. Hearing Agenda May 12, 2021 Page 4 of 5 New Applications o) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (CA3-21-201) for alterations, a rear addition, and site work at 727 Bonnie Brae Ave SW. Property is zoned R-4A / Adair Park Historic District (Subarea 1). Applicant: Hillaby Bannister 634 Lester St NW Staff Recommendation: Approval with Conditions. Commission Voted: Approved with Conditions. p) Application for a Review and Comment (RC-21-206) for alterations at 50 Huntington Rd NE. Property is zoned R-4 / Brookwood Hills Conservation District Applicant: Dianne Barfield P.O Box 475, Morrow Staff Recommendation: Send a letter with comments to the Applicant. Commission Voted: The Commission adopted the Staff Report as their comments and will send a copy to the Applicant. q) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (CA2-21-208) for alterations at 1116 Merrill Ave SW. Property is zoned R-4A / Oakland City Historic District Applicant: John E. Swiney 1426 Golf Link Dr, Stone Mountain Staff Recommendation: Approval with Conditions. Commission Voted: Deferred to the May 26, 2021 public hearing. Commission Voted: Deferred to the May 26, 2021 public hearing due to lack of applicant representation at the public hearing. Applications Deferred from Previous Meetings r) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (CA2-20-255) for a revisions to previously approved plans at 389 Hopkins St SW. Property is zoned R-4A / West End Historic District / Beltline. Applicant: Edward Culpepper 302 Lakeside Village Dr. Deferred on September 23, 2020 Staff Recommendation: Deferral to the May 26, 2021 public hearing. Commission Voted: Deferred to the May 26, 2021 public hearing. s) Application for a Type II Certificate of Appropriateness (CA2-21-144) for alterations and site work at 1039 White Oak Ave SW. Property is zoned R-4A/ Oakland City Historic District / Beltline. Applicant: Thomas Dobkin Cooper 3635 Pointer Road, Loganville Deferred on April 14, 2021 Staff Recommendation: Approval with Conditions. Commission Voted: Deferred to the May 26, 2021 public hearing for additional information. Please submit Historic Preservation staff questions to [email protected] and comments to the Urban Design Commission to [email protected]. Hearing Agenda May 12, 2021 Page 5 of 5 t) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (CA3-21-153) for additions and alterations at 2625 Baker Ridge Dr NW. Property is zoned R-4 / Collier Heights Historic District. Applicant: Carlos Eduardo Guzman 2306 Wilkins Cove, Decatur Deferred on April 14, 2021 Staff Recommendation: Deferral to the May 26, 2021 public hearing. Commission Voted: Deferred to the May 26, 2021 public hearing. u) Application for a Type III Certificate of Appropriateness (CA3-21-180) for new single family house at Lot #2 at 776 Mercer St SE. Property is zoned PD-H / Grant Park Historic District (Subarea 1) / Beltline. Applicant: Garrett