THE POETRY OF MARGARET ATWOOD John Wilson Foster LARGARET ATWOOD'S current popularity stems in part from the fact that her poetry explores certain fashionable minority psychologies. With its cultivation of barely controlled hysteria, for instance, her verse is that of a psychic individual at sea in a materialist society. This hysteria, however, assumes specifically feminine forms and lends Atwood's work certain affinities (of which current popularity is the least important) with that of Virginia Woolf and Sylvia Plath. For like these two predecessors, Atwood confronts her own sexuality and the contemporary roles laid down by men for her to play. A minority psychology similar to that which informs her identity as a woman informs her national identity, for Atwood is a contemporary Canadian aware of belonging to a minority culture on the North American continent and in reaction recollect- ing and re-enacting her pioneer ancestors' encounter with the wilderness and with the native people. Appropriately, the Canadian ancestral experience — repository of the spiritual identity of a people — happens to be best commemo- rated in the journals and memoirs of some remarkable women, including Catha- rine Parr Traill, Susanna Moodie and Anna Jameson. Charges of opportunism could easily be levelled against a poet so deeply involved with the minority psyche. But they are answerable by our exhibiting, as I hope to do here, the essential coherence of Atwood's poetic themes. Her poetry succeeds not by masterly technique or style but by a peculiar force of content, by exciting transformations of experience that appear only to the superficial reader as mere opportunities. Among the experiences of being an individual, a woman and a Canadian, Atwood intuits an underlying connection deeper than minority membership. These experiences flesh out in multiple guise the root formula of her poetry. Like a mathematical expression, that formula sustains a wealth of individual existences — of image, motif, subject and dramatic situation. Stated briefly, Atwood's poetry in the six volumes to date1 concerns itself with the self's inhabitation of spaces and forms and the metamorphoses entailed therein. All that is thematically important derives from this: invasion, displacement, evolu- MARGARET ATWOOD tion and reversion, as well as those notions significant enough to warrant book titles — survival, ingestion (cf. The Edible Woman, a novel), and surfacing. The message of Atwood's poetry is that extinction and obsolescence are illusory, that life is a constant process of re-formation. The self is eternally divided in its atti- tude to the forms and spaces it inhabits, simultaneously needing, fearing, desiring and despising them. Because the scenario of inhabitation takes place through space and time (spaces in time become forms and forms become spaces), we can see its perti- nence to the contemporary Canadian's encounter not only with the landscape and its inhabitants but also with the past preserved in part by that landscape — that is, with his pioneer ancestors (whose journey itself enacted the scenario), with the native people and with his own primordiality. Also, since roles are spaces and forms, we can see its pertinence to the current re-definition of femininity. And behind the feminine and Canadian, the individual. If the self's identity as woman and as Canadian is threatened by the variety of the Canadian past and present, its identity as human being is threatened by the fact that self apparently cannot exist outside forms and spaces. At best, self is merely reflected off the surfaces of others' forms of self. This is the frightening phenomenology of Atwood's world superimposed, skin-like, upon the illusory solidity of its rocks, animals, artifacts and people. kTWOOD's SPACES are rooms, houses and even the human body, but in the beginning they are the spaces fashioned by her pioneer ancestors — the cabin and the clearing. How these spaces were created, inhabited, defended and sometimes abandoned is recorded in the journals and letters of the pioneers and early visitors themselves, which thus provide an illuminating background to the poetry. Always they concern a journey : the journal and guide are the arche- typal Canadian literary forms which function in the Canadian literary imagina- tion as does the novel in the English, something Atwood has recognized in subtitling her critical work A Thematic Guide to Canadian Literature and in "re-writing" the journals of Susanna Moodie. There was to begin with the ocean voyage and after, more important, the journey across the land. Ireland, Seamus Heaney has noted, has "no prairies/Το slice a big sun at evening," and he adds: Our pioneers keep striking Inwards and downwards. New world pioneers on the other hand encountered such prairies and much else that Ireland lacles : towering mountains and awesome gorges, deserts, icefields and inland seas. The long journey from landfall to backwoods is an overland move- MARGARET ATWOOD ment ("surfacing," one might call it) that even today the Canadian can re-enact, as Atwood does in "Migration: C.P.R." which chronicles a journey from "the misty east" through "the inner lakes," prairies, mountains and "faulted gorges" to the forest by the western ocean. The pioneer's "long day's journey in the woods," as Mrs. Traill describes it in The Backwoods of Canada (1836), ended not with welcome but with the hostility of wilderness, wild animal and settler. In "Paths and Thingscape," Atwood's Mrs. Moodie complains : I am watched like an invader who knows hostility but not where All are begrudging and "unforgivingly previous" to her. Rarely in The Journals of Susanna Moodie or in Roughing It in the Bush (1852), or in the journals of Mrs. Jameson and Mrs. Traill is the red man anything but benign towards the white man, but behind the annoyance of the Indian asked in "First Neighbours" about the toad-like object on the stick lies the real hostility between the races.2 In fact, the white man desired the removal of the red man "back from the extending limits of civilisation," as Mrs. Jameson noted, "even like these forests, which fall before us, and vanish from the earth, leaving for a while some decaying stumps and roots over which the plough goes in time, and no vestige remains to say that here they have been."3 It is upon the "malignant face" of the forest, that most formidable prior occupant of the clearing, that Atwood's Mrs. Moodie, like all pioneers, vents her greatest wrath. "A Canadian settler hates a tree," adds Mrs. Jameson, "regards it as his natural enemy, as something to be destroyed, eradicated, annihilated by all and any means" (I, p. 96). Settlement could not take place but by the penetration and destruction of the forest. The old was obliterated by the new. But the new is at first mere negation. Disembarking at Quebec, Atwood's Mrs. Moodie is "a word/in a foreign language," but later in the bush her husband is not even that, but is merely "an X, a concept/defined against a blank" ("The Wereman"). The clearing represents the settler's negative and unintelligible signature upon the wilderness, the displacement of its prior occupants. But soon it signifies a new phase in the scenario of inhabitation: the immigrant upon landing who became a pioneer upon striking for the backwoods has upon clear- ing become a settler. The pioneer has become a new person as the clearing is a new feature of the landscape. A new flora appears which the settler begins to name as though it had just been created.4 The landscape is culturally virgin with no associations.5 It is also, and in this notably different from Mrs. Jameson's native Ireland, too new for ghosts.6 For forest and pioneer, settlement is oblitera- tion and a fresh beginning. MARGARET ATWOOD The cabin, erected immediately after the first minimally necessary felling, is a space within a space. Like the clearing it is at first blank, a mere negation of the bush. Soon both cabin and clearing are havens (concentric areas of withdrawal) against the forces of the old that return to deny the new. In "Dream 3 : Night Bear Which Frightened Cattle," the "lighted cabin" is the last refuge from the bear which invades the clearing like "an echo" of the previous inhabitants. The settler's life is a nightly siege, terrified as he is of being ambushed outside by nightfall. Indeed, cabin and clearing create for the first time in the wilderness the vital dialectic of inside and outside.7 "Survival" means the successful maintenance of the inside against the outside constituted by annoying settlers, "trespassing" Indians, wolves and bears, the oppressive summer and "relentless iron winter" (Jameson), the bush and the darkness. The clearing, inside relative to the bush, is outside relative to the cabin, a dialectic Atwood exploits in "Two Fires" when the clearing is mercifully inside the burning forest, but mercifully outside the burning Moodie cabin. (each refuge fails us; each danger becomes a haven) Here, as in other poems, Atwood represents the enclosed spaces of her locales by parentheses. Even when positive, the cabin and clearing remain precarious. Mrs. Jameson sees the clearing as a man-made island resisting "a boundless sea of forest." In The Circle Game, in such poems as "After the Flood, We," "Descent Through the Carpet" and "Winter Sleepers," Atwood also sees the landscape paradoxi- cally as aquatic. The image of a re-forming sea conveys the idea that the forces displaced by the cabin and the clearing are not really obliterated after all but are, by an Archimedean principle, merely re-located. Nothing is destroyed in Atwood's universe: it simply assumes another space, another form.