Electrodynamics of correlated electron systems: Based on lectures first given at the 2008 Boulder School for Condensed Matter and Materials P hysics; revised for the 2018 QS3 Summer School @ Cornell University N. P. Armitage Department of Physics and Astronomy, The Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD 21218, USA (Dated: June 14, 2018) Contents on these subjects written down. After the school's con- clusion, I didn't expect them to have much of a life be- I. Preamble 2 yond my own research group although I did post a slightly cleaned up version to the arXiv in 2009. I was then sur- II. Introduction 3 prised and (very!) pleased to find that they've had such a big impact. Many people (from beginning graduate stu- III. Formalism 5 dents to senior faculty) have told me over the years how A. Optical Constants of Solids 5 useful they have found them as an introduction to the B. Classical Treatments: Drude-Lorentz 8 electrodynamic response of materials with quantum coop- C. The Quantum Case 11 erative phenomena. This was very gratifying. In preparation for 2018, it is quite interesting to look IV. Techniques 13 back at what I thought was relevant and important for A. Microwaves 13 \correlated electron systems" in 2008 and what was is ab- B. THz spectroscopy 15 sent. Some of this reflects my own prejudices and some C. Infrared 17 shows how the field has moved on. In the original version, D. Visible and Ultraviolet 18 although I mention the quantum Hall effect, it was only in the context of the plateau transition being a model sys- V. Examples 20 tem for quantum phase transitions (QPT) and the con- sequences of dynamical scaling near a QPT. There is no A. Simple Metals 20 reference to topological insulators or topology in the orig- B. Semiconductors and Band Insulators 21 inal version of these notes. Indeed the landmark paper C. Electron glasses 22 of Hsieh et al.1 had just been published and its signifi- D. Mott insulators 25 cance was lost on me at the time. Needless to say this E. Superconductors and other BCS-like states 25 has become a major topic of inquiry. And although most experimental aspects of the work on topological materi- VI. Advanced Analysis and Techniques 28 als can be understood in terms of free fermions, intel- A. Sum Rules 28 lectually the field has moved in tandem with the field of B. Extended Drude Model 30 strong correlations and so I include some discussion on C. Frequency dependent scaling near quantum these systems in the updated notes. Also, note that in critical points. 36 the 2008 version I left out all mention of nonlinear op- D. Using light to probe broken symmetries 40 tics and nonequilbrium effects. There was little use of the E. Pump-probe spectroscopy and former at the time (with the exception of excellent work non-equilibrium effects 42 on magnetoelectrics and multiferroics2) and I felt that { F. Topological materials and Berry's phase 42 despite some nice work3 { the latter was still too imma- ture to cover explicitly. That has changed for both these VII. Acknowledgments 46 topics. Optics (both linear or nonlinear) has now made important contributions in the detection of subtle broken References 46 symmetry states of matter in cuprates and iridates4{7. arXiv:0908.1126v3 [cond-mat.str-el] 6 Aug 2018 There is also use of non-linear spectroscopies for 2D THz, Note added to 2018 update: These notes are based on which I consider tremendously promising9. And there has lectures I first gave at the Boulder School for Condensed been recent tremendous interest in non-equilbrium phases Matter Physics in 2008. They have been further updated with { most notably { the possibility of driven nonequi- to be distributed at the QS3 summer school at Cornell lbrium room temperature superconductivity in cuprates 10,11 University and Princeton Summer School on Condensed and K3C60 . It is interesting to note that the interest Matter Physics in the summer of 2018. I originally wrote in quantum criticality and scaling phenomena has faded these detailed notes 1) for students at the Boulder school somewhat although their importance is undiminished. and 2) for my own students and postdocs as I found my- What is clear (and has not changed one whit) that is self explaining some of the same material many times and that the field of optical effects of \quantum correlated sys- I thought it would be useful to have some of my thoughts tems" continues to be tremendously active. The compat- 2 ibility of optical probes with many different sample envi- 2. M. Dressel and G. Gr¨uner,\Electrodynamics of ronments and the increased ease of use of ultrafast laser Solids: Optical Properties of Electrons in Matter", systems means that there is a continuing vitality to the (Cambridge University Press, 2002). field. it is clear that optical probes of solids will continue Much newer and modern with many plots of rele- to make essential contributions to the field for years to vant response functions. Good discussion of many come. important techniques13. Beware of typos. 3. G. D. Mahan, \Many-Particle Physics", (Plenum, 2nd ed., 1990). I. PREAMBLE The go-to resource for perturbative treatments of correlations in solids14. Excellent discussion of Physical and chemical systems can be characterized sum rules. by their natural frequency and energy scales. It is hardly 4. Richard D. Mattuck, \A Guide to Feynman Dia- an exaggeration that most of what we know about such grams in the Many-Body Problem", (Dover, 2nd systems, from the acoustics of a violin to the energy lev- ed., 1992). It has been called \Feynman diagrams for dum- els of atoms, comes from their response to perturbations 15 at these natural frequencies. For instance, chemists and mies." Well ... I like it anyways . biologists use infrared spectroscopy absorptions around 5. M. Tinkham, Introduction to Superconductivity, 1650 cm−1 (which corresponds to frequencies of 49 THz, 2nd Ed. , McGraw-Hill, NY, (1996). wavelengths of 6 µm, and energies of 0.2 eV) to identify The classic exposition on superconductivity. Ex- the carbon-carbon double bond in organic compounds. cellent treatment of EM response of superconduc- And it was the observation of light emission from atoms tors (and other BCS-like states) both from the phe- nomenological two-fluid model and the full Matthis- at discrete energies in the electron Volt (eV) range that 16 led to the quantum theory. Bardeen formalism . 6. David Tanner, \Optical effects in solids" Excel- It is of course the same situation in `correlated' elec- lent class lecture notes from one of the pioneers of tron materials. We can learn about the novel effects of of IR spectroscopy on correlated systems. Avail- strong electron-electron interactions and the properties able at of collective states of matter (superconductors, quantum https: // www. phys. ufl. edu/ ~ tanner/ . magnets etc.) by characterizing their response to small notes. pdf 7. D. van der Marel, \Optical signatures of electron amplitude perturbations at their natural frequencies. In correlations in the cuprates", \Strong interactions solids, these natural frequency scales span an impres- in low dimensions, Series: Physics and Chem- sively large frequency range from x-ray down to DC. This istry of Materials with Low-Dimensional Struc- incredibly broad range means that a blizzard of experi- tures" Vol. 25, 237-276 (2004); Also available at mental techniques and analysis methods are required for the characterization of correlated systems with optical http://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/0301506 Excellent treatment of underlying theory, particu- techniques. larly that associated with various sum rules. Many This short review and lecture notes attempt to lay out relevant examples18. a brief summary of the formalism, techniques, and anal- 8. Andrew Millis, \Optical conductivity and corre- ysis used for `optical' spectroscopies of correlated elec- lated electron physics", \Strong interactions in low tron systems. They are idiosyncratic, occasionally opin- dimensions, Series: Physics and Chemistry of Ma- ionated, and - considering the breadth of the subject - terials with Low-Dimensional Structures" Vol. 25, incredibly brief. Unfortunately, there is no single com- 195-235 (2004); Also available at http://phys. plete treatise that presents a complete background for columbia.edu/ millis/july20.pdf these topics in the context of correlated electron materi- ~ Excellent review covering many aspects of the the- als. However, there are a number of excellent resources ory of optical measurements for correlated electron that collectively give a solid background to this field. physics. Particularly good discussion on the use of I recommend: sum rules. Explicit calculations within Kubo for- malism. Many experimental examples with accom- 1. F. Wooten, \Optical Properties of Solids", (Aca- panying theoretical discussion. Unique treatment demic Press, New York, 1972). on the applicability of the conventional descriptions The truly excellent and classic introduction to the of the coupling of EM radiation to solids19 subject of the electrodynamic response of solids (al- 9. D. Basov and T. Timusk, \Electrodynamics of though there is very little in it in the way of elec- high-Tc superconductors", Reviews of Modern tronic correlations). The book that multiple genera- Physics 77, 721 (2005). tions of spectroscopists learned from either directly A thorough review of the use of optical probes in or indirectly. To say that it is full of only basic the cuprate superconductors20. obvious things is akin to complaining that Mac- 10. L. Degiorgi, \The electrodynamic response of beth is full of quotations. Unfortunately it is out heavy-electron compounds", Rev. Mod. Phys. 71, of print....12 3 687 (1999). cal f-electron orbitals, which are relevant in Kondo ma- 11. A. Millis and P.A.