TABLE OF CONTENTS Chapter 9: Architectural Historic Resources ......................................................9-1 A. INTRODUCTION..................................................................................................................9-1 B. PRINCIPAL CONCLUSIONS ..............................................................................................9-1 C. METHODOLOGY.................................................................................................................9-2 1. OVERVIEW ..........................................................................................................................9-2 2. AREA OF POTENTIAL EFFECT (APE) ..................................................................................9-3 3. CRITERIA AND REGULATIONS ............................................................................................9-3 D. EXISTING CONDITIONS ....................................................................................................9-4 1. BACKGROUND ....................................................................................................................9-4 2. DESIGNATED AND ELIGIBLE ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES ..............................................9-5 a) Individually Designated, Listed, or Eligible Resources............................................................... 9-9 b) Garment Industry Resources.......................................................................................................9-22 c) Printing Industry Resources........................................................................................................9-32 d) Hell’s Kitchen Residential Resources.........................................................................................9-36 e) Hell’s Kitchen Institutional Resources .......................................................................................9-42 f) Hell’s Kitchen Industrial Resources ...........................................................................................9-47 g) Hell’s Kitchen Commercial Resources.......................................................................................9-49 h) Chelsea Industrial Resources......................................................................................................9-50 i) Commercial Resources Near Penn Station .................................................................................9-53 E. 2010 FUTURE WITHOUT THE PROPOSED ACTION....................................................9-56 F. 2010 FUTURE WITH THE PROPOSED ACTION............................................................9-59 1. DIRECT IMPACTS ..............................................................................................................9-59 a) Proposed Rezoning.....................................................................................................................9-59 b) Open Space.................................................................................................................................9-60 c) No. 7 Subway Extension ............................................................................................................9-60 d) Convention Center, Multi-Use Facility, and Waterfront ............................................................9-62 e) Potential Accommodation for the NYPD Tow Pound and DSNY Facility ................................9-62 2. CONTEXTUAL IMPACTS ....................................................................................................9-62 a) New Development ......................................................................................................................9-63 b) Open Space.................................................................................................................................9-64 c) No. 7 Subway Extension ............................................................................................................9-65 d) Convention Center, Multi-Use Facility, and Waterfront ............................................................9-65 G. 2025 FUTURE WITHOUT THE PROPOSED ACTION....................................................9-65 H. 2025 FUTURE WITH THE PROPOSED ACTION............................................................9-66 1. DIRECT IMPACTS ..............................................................................................................9-66 a) New Development ......................................................................................................................9-66 b) Open Space.................................................................................................................................9-70 2. CONTEXTUAL IMPACTS ....................................................................................................9-71 a) New Development ......................................................................................................................9-71 b) Open Space.................................................................................................................................9-74 I. MITIGATION......................................................................................................................9-74 1. DIRECT IMPACTS ..............................................................................................................9-74 a) Possible Mitigation Measures for Demolition or Alteration of Architectural Resources ...........9-74 b) Possible Mitigation for Accidental Damage from Adjacent Construction .................................9-75 9-i No. 7 Subway Extension—Hudson Yards Rezoning and Development Program FGEIS LIST OF TABLES TABLE 9-1 DESIGNATED AND ELIGIBLE ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES WITHIN THE PROJECT STUDY AREA .. 9-5 LIST OF FIGURES FIGURE 9-1 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: NORTH OF WEST 36TH STREET FIGURE 9-2 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: SOUTH OF WEST 36TH STREET FIGURE 9-3 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-4 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-5 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-6 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-7 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-8 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-9 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-10 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-11 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-12 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-13 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-14 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-15 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-16 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-17 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-18 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-19 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-20 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: THE HIGH LINE FIGURE 9-21 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: THE HIGH LINE FIGURE 9-22 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: THE HIGH LINE FIGURE 9-23 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: THE HIGH LINE FIGURE 9-24 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: THE HIGH LINE FIGURE 9-25 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: GARMENT INDUSTRY RESOURCES FIGURE 9-26 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: GARMENT INDUSTRY RESOURCES FIGURE 9-27 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: GARMENT INDUSTRY RESOURCES FIGURE 9-28 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: GARMENT INDUSTRY RESOURCES FIGURE 9-29 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: GARMENT INDUSTRY RESOURCES FIGURE 9-30 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: GARMENT INDUSTRY RESOURCES FIGURE 9-31 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: GARMENT INDUSTRY RESOURCES FIGURE 9-32 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: GARMENT INDUSTRY RESOURCES FIGURE 9-33 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: GARMENT INDUSTRY RESOURCES FIGURE 9-34 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: GARMENT INDUSTRY RESOURCES FIGURE 9-35 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: GARMENT INDUSTRY RESOURCES FIGURE 9-36 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: GARMENT INDUSTRY RESOURCES FIGURE 9-37 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: GARMENT INDUSTRY RESOURCES FIGURE 9-38 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: GARMENT INDUSTRY RESOURCES FIGURE 9-39 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: PRINTING INDUSTRY RESOURCES FIGURE 9-40 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: PRINTING INDUSTRY RESOURCES FIGURE 9-41 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: PRINTING INDUSTRY RESOURCES FIGURE 9-42 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: PRINTING INDUSTRY RESOURCES FIGURE 9-43 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: PRINTING INDUSTRY RESOURCES FIGURE 9-44 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: HELL’S KITCHEN RESIDENTIAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-45 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: HELL’S KITCHEN RESIDENTIAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-46 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: HELL’S KITCHEN RESIDENTIAL RESOURCES 9-ii Chapter 9: Architectural Historic Resources FIGURE 9-47 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: HELL’S KITCHEN RESIDENTIAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-48 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: HELL’S KITCHEN RESIDENTIAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-49 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: HELL’S KITCHEN RESIDENTIAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-50 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: HELL’S KITCHEN RESIDENTIAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-51 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: HELL’S KITCHEN RESIDENTIAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-52 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: HELL’S KITCHEN RESIDENTIAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-53 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: HELL’S KITCHEN RESIDENTIAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-54 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: HELL’S KITCHEN RESIDENTIAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-55 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: HELL’S KITCHEN RESIDENTIAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-56 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: HELL’S KITCHEN RESIDENTIAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-57 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: HELL’S KITCHEN RESIDENTIAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-58 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: HELL’S KITCHEN RESIDENTIAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-59 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: HELL’S KITCHEN RESIDENTIAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-60 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: HELL’S KITCHEN RESIDENTIAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-61 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: HELL’S KITCHEN RESIDENTIAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-62 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: HELL’S KITCHEN RESIDENTIAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-63 ARCHITECTURAL RESOURCES: HELL’S KITCHEN RESIDENTIAL RESOURCES FIGURE 9-64 ARCHITECTURAL