Angus McEachen’s house: the anatomy of an early 19th-century crofting settlement near Arisaig Ross White*, Chris O’Connell* and Fay Oliver** with a contribution by Sue Anderson* * CFA Archaeology Ltd, Old Engine House, Eskmills Park, Station Road, Musselburgh EH21 7PQ ** Department of History, University of Stirling Scottish Archaeological Internet Report 35, 2009 www.sair.org.uk Published by the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland, www.socantscot.org.uk with Historic Scotland, www.historic-scotland.gov.uk and the Council for British Archaeology, www.britarch.ac.uk Editor Helen Bleck Produced by Archetype Information Technology Ltd, www.archetype-it.com ISBN: 978 0903 90362 2 ISSN: 1773-3803 Requests for permission to reproduce material from a SAIR report should be sent to the Director of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland, as well as to the author, illustrator, photographer or other copyright holder. Copyright in any of the Scottish Archaeological Internet Reports series rests with the SAIR Consortium and the individual authors. The maps are reproduced from Ordnance Survey material with the permission of Ordnance Survey on behalf of The Controller of Her Majesty’s Stationery Office. © Crown copyright 2001. Any unauthorised reproduction infringes Crown copyright and may lead to prosecution or civil proceedings. Historic Scotland Licence No. GD 03032G, 2002. The consent does not extend to copying for general distribution, advertising or promotional purposes, the creation of new collective works or resale. CONTENTS List of Illustrations. iv List of Tables . v 1 Abstract . 1 2 Introduction. 2 2.1 Site history. 2 2.2 Placename evidence . .2 3 The Physical Remains. 5 3.1 Structure A and hard-standing . .5 3.2 Structure B. 7 3.3 Structure C. 7 3.4 The ‘yard’ area . .8 3.5 Other features . .9 3.6 Finds, by Sue Anderson . 9 4 Historical Context . .10 4.1 Introduction . 10 4.2 The broader picture . 10 4.3 The inhabitants of the house at Brunary Burn. 12 5 Discussion. 13 6 Conclusions. 15 7 Acknowledgements. .16 8 Endnotes. .17 9 References. 18 9.1 Cartographic references. 18 9.2 Records held in the General Register Office, Scotland . 18 9.3 Papers and documents held in the National Archives of Scotland. 18 9.4 Parliamentary Papers. 18 9.5 Published works . 18 iii LIST OF Illustrations 1 Site location map. 3 2 Brunary Burn site plan showing trenches, structures and other features . .4 3 Plan of the Brunary Burn structures. 6 4 Structure A from the north-east. 7 5 Detail of wall composition in Structure A. .7 6 Detail of paving within Structure A. .8 iv LIST OF TABLES 1 Value of the Produce of Moidart, Arisaig and South Morar, c 1807–33 . 10 v 1 ABSTRACT This report presents the results of an excavation slate roofing and clay pipe fragments. The project and historical study of an early 19th-century set- provided an opportunity to bring together social tlement at Brunary Burn near Arisaig, Highlands historical research with archaeological evidence for (NGR: NM 6770 8578). CFA Archaeology Ltd carried a somewhat archaeologically under-studied period, out the excavation during October 2005 in advance and also identified the former inhabitants of the of the realignment and upgrading works of the settlement as Angus McEachen and his extended A830 between Fort William and Arisaig. Two rec- family. The buildings appear to have been occupied tangular drystone buildings were excavated, along for perhaps a single generation before the family with a yard area between them. Artefacts recovered was evicted and moved to new accommodation included pottery, iron tools, cauldron fragments, within the area. 1 2 INTRODUCTION This paper presents the combined results of an The site was located 120m to the south of the archaeological excavation and historical research present A830 (NGR: NM 6770 8578; illus 1). It lay undertaken into the social history of a 19th-century at c 50m above OD, in a clearing of trees on rough household at Brunary Burn. The ruinous house is pasture and boggy ground on the west side of the the material embodiment of the life of the occupiers, Brunary Burn. The buildings were previously the McEachens, who are in turn representative of a recorded as part of a survey carried out in 1994 class of people who suffered greatly during a time of (Alexander 1994). The excavation area was heavily economic and social crisis in Scotland’s history. overgrown with bracken and other vegetation. To the The advantages of a combined research strategy south of the main excavation area lay boggy ground are manifold. Archaeological data can produce and to the west lay a large glacial drumlin or knoll. narratives without the support of written documen- CFA Archaeology Ltd carried out an evaluation of tation or oral history. These narratives may span the two partially upstanding buildings at Brunary generations or millennia, or detail a single physical Burn (NMRS No NM68NE 42) in June and July event such as making a clay pot. It is usually more 2005 (Suddaby 2005). During this work, the building difficult to reconstruct short-term events over a day interiors were investigated by trial trenching and or a generation, as they may leave no archaeologi- a series of test pits investigated the area between cal signature. Historical research on the other hand, the houses. A programme of excavation subse- with its myriad oral and documentary evidence, quently took place focusing on the buildings and can elucidate past events, and the people involved, area between the houses, as well as the recording within many different timeframes. But, with its of ancillary features, in September and October focus on written evidence, this form of research can 2005. The excavations were required as the site also be prey to bias and mis-representation within would be covered by the construction of an embank- the evidential documents, and can fail to supply ment on the approach to the new bridge over the detail relating to the physical aspects of life for the Brunary Burn as part of the A830 upgrading. A subjects. Archaeological research, however, is well watching brief was later conducted during topsoil placed, and has a long and practised methodology, stripping associated with the road construction in for understanding material evidence. The combina- the summer of 2007, to monitor the removal of the tion of both these lines of research, archaeological buildings and the stripping to natural subsoil by and historical, can be a powerful analytical research mechanical excavator; no further archaeological tool. remains were discovered. The archaeological work was commissioned by Historic Scotland on behalf of Transport Scotland, an agency of the Scottish 2.1 Site history Executive. Several other archaeological sites, recorded in Brunary Burn lies in the district of Arisaig in the the National Monuments Register for Scotland Western Highlands. Together with neighbouring (NMRS), in the vicinity of Brunary Burn, were of districts of Ardnamurchan, Moidart, Morar and particular relevance to this study (illus 2). They Knoydart, this general area is often referred to as were a drystone building with associated rig and the ‘Rough Bounds’. Bounded to the north by Loch furrow (NM68NE 41); field banks and quarries at Hourn and to the South by Loch Suinart, with Druim an Darich (NM68SE 19); field banks at Torr mountains, innumerable sea- and freshwater lochs, an t-Sagairt (NM68NE 40); a drystone rectangu- and a dramatic coastline, the area is almost arche- lar building (NM68NE 35); a township comprising typically Highland in its natural beauty. The Rough eight buildings (NM68NE 35); and a rectangular Bounds, however, also refers historically to the turf structure (NGR: NM 6583 8835) difficulty of the terrain, the almost impenetrable nature of much of the landscape, and the isolation of the population. This remoteness only came to 2.2 Placename evidence an end relatively recently; the West Highland rail line was opened at the end of the 19th century with It has been suggested that some of the placenames the extension to Mallaig completed in March 1901 in the immediate area of Brunary Burn contain (Thomas 1979, 11), a regular steam ship service evidence for a religious settlement of early date: began earlier (Durie 2003, 47–55), and, prior to this, Torr an t-Sagairt (mound of the priest), Lochan Torr the road from Fort William was completed in 1812 na Nighinn (little loch of the mound of the sisters (Rixson 2002; though, at the time of writing, there (or nuns)) and Lochan a Chléirich (little loch of the are still some single-track sections near Arisaig). cleric) (R McCullagh, pers comm). Torr an t-Sagairt 2 Illus 1 Site location map could be explained by the fact that the Statistical point. The excavations at Brunary Burn recovered Accounts mention preachers travelling to the Kinloch- no supporting evidence for an early religious site, moidart area to preach to their flocks; if this were to however, it is doubtful that the activities of peripa- be done in the open air, then the preacher may have tetic preachers would leave much physical evidence used the drumlin as a natural dais and vantage of their presence. 3 Structure B Structure A Tr 2 Structure C Tr 3 4 Tr 4 Mound of stones Tr 1 n r u B y r a n Alignments of possible rig and furrow u r B 0 1 2 10m scale 1:200 Illus 2 IBrunaryllus 2 - Site Burnplan sh siteowin gplantrenc hshowinges, structu rtrenches,es and othe rstructuresfeatures, and andlocat iotheron of t rfeaturesenches. 3 THE PHYsical REMAINS A mitigation strategy was agreed with Historic maximum height of 1.5m. They were of drystone Scotland prior to construction work commencing construction and consisted of three elements: an on site and following the evaluation work (Suddaby outer face of roughly dressed, very large boulder- 2005).