Two Mott Insulator Theory of Superconductivity in K3X (X: picene, .. p-terphenyl, .. C60) G. Baskaran The Institute of Mathematical Sciences, C.I.T. Campus, Chennai 600 113, India & Perimeter Institute for Theoretical Physics, Waterloo, ON N2L 2Y5, Canada We look for unifying aspects behind superconductivity in aromatic hydrocarbon and fullerene family K3X (X: picene, .. p-terphenyl, .. C60). Aromatic hydrocarbon molecules support RVB states. Consequent stability (aromaticity) makes them reluctant electron acceptors. We argue that 2− X accepts only two (not all three) electrons from K3 and creates charged RVB’s in X , and becomes − a (molecular) Cooper pair box. A weak Josephson coupling between X2 molecules creates a Bose 2+ Mott insulator, a potential high Tc superconductor. Remaining lone electron in the complex (K3) − occupies a suitable metal orbital hybrid. They hybridize weakly through X2 molecular bridges, to form a half filled band of renormalized K atom orbitals, a Fermionic Mott insulator. An interplay of RVB physics and charge transfer (mutual doping) or external doping leads to superconductivity in one or both Mott insulators. In our theory there is room for room temperature superconductivity. PACS numbers: I. INTRODUCTION subsystems could become active participants in super- conductivity. In existing theories [12–24] of supercon- 3+ 3− Organic route to high Tc superconductivity is highly ductivity, a nominal charge state (K3) (X) makes 3+ 3− desirable. Ever since a theoretical proposal by Little [1], (K3) effectively an insulating spectator and (X) ef- of organic polymer based high Tc superconductivity, the fectively becomes a (odd electron) molecular conductor search continues. Organic solids such as TTF-TCNQ and (with some hybridization with K orbitals), and supports doped polyacetylene which drew a lot of attention at the superconductivity based on Mott physics. beginning have not become superconducting. However, Firstly, we recognize that polycyclic aromatic hydro- several aromatic hydrocarbon [2] and C60 molecule [3] carbon molecules X are different from molecules with based superconductors have been synthesized [4–6]: K3X saturated bonds. Molecule X supports a correlated many (X: picene, phenanthrene, dibenzo pentacene, coronene, electron state, a p-π pool of neutral singlets (molecular ... C60). Some of them are high Tc superconductors. RVB state). In our theory molecule X accepts only two Other low Tc organic superconductor families, Bechgard valence electrons, accommodates the pair in valence bond salts and ET salts [7], continue to excite physics commu- resonance and becomes a (molecular) Cooper pair box 2 2 nity from the point of view of strong correlation physics. X −. Josephson coupling between X − creates a Boson A recent claim of superconductivity [9, 10] at an el- Mott insulator, a potential high Tc superconductor. Fur- 2− evated temperature of 123 K in K3(p-terphenyl) is re- ther, the molecular matrix X isolates the dication com- 2+ 2+ markable and exciting. (Three benzene rings bridged by plex (K3) . Remaining lone electron in (K3) occupies two C-C bonds along a line forms para (p-) terphenyl [8], a suitable metal atom hybrid state. This hybrid further 2− C18H14). A more recent high resolution photoelectron hybridizes weakly with LUMO of bridging molecules X spectroscopic evidence [11] for pairing gap in p-terphenyl and forms a renormalized metal atom Mott insulator. system upto 60 K adds to the excitement and makes the This fermionic Mott insulator becomes a template for activity worth pursuing. While Meissner signals and a high Tc superconductivity via RVB mechanism [25, 26]. favourable magnetic field dependence of Tc are evidences Mutual charge transfer between two Mott insulators or for superconductivity, other standard and confirmatory external doping can create superconductivity in one or measurements are needed. Are we witnessing birth of a both Mott insulators. new revolution in high Tc superconductivity ? In building our theory we use some key quantum chem- arXiv:1704.08153v1 [cond-mat.supr-con] 26 Apr 2017 Aim of the present article is to suggest an unified model ical and experimental facts: i) polycyclic aromatic hydro- and mechanism of superconductivity in the family of carbon molecules have in general low electron affinities alkali metal doped aromatic hydrocarbon and fullerene [27, 28], due to their extra stability (aromaticity) arising molecular solids K3X. from valence bond resonances. For example, benzene has Briefly, we find that K3X has an unusual nominal negative electron affinity ≈ - 1.5 eV. Consequently elec- 2+ 2− charge state (K3) (X) , rather than usually assumed tron affinities of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (fused 3+ 3− (K3) (X) . A Boson Mott insulator (even electron di- benzene rings) are small in general. They are reluctant cation subsystem X2−) and Fermion Mott insulator (odd electron acceptors in the solid state, ii) an ubiquitous sto- 2+ electron dianion subsystem (K3) ) emerge. Charge ichiometric composition K3X, (X = p-terphenyl, picene, transfer between two Mott insulators or external dop- dibenzopentancene, coronene, C60, ...) in all known su- ing can create superconductivity in one or both Mott perconductors and absence of superconductivity for stoi- insulators. That is, in our theory both anion and cation chiometry K2 as well as K1, iii) reduced Madelung energy 2 from strong dielectric screening and iv) evidence from X- affinity Ea ≈ 0.5 eV in free space. If we add two elec- 2 ray spectroscopy [29] for a substantial orbital hybridiza- e trons total binding energy becomes ≈−2Ea + R ≈ + 3 tion of valence orbitals of K and molecular orbitals of eV. Here R is the linear dimensions of picene molecule. picene at the fermi energy in K3(picene). Thus two electron binding is not possible in free space; Our theory uses earlier and recent theoretical works i.e., a dianion (picene)2− is not stable in free space, be- and insights: i) recognizing the molecule X as a strongly cause of Coulomb barrier. correlated electron system, capable of supporting charged In the solid state environment various factors could Cooper pair inside molecule X via pair binding and help to overcome a charging energy ∼ 3 eV for transfer- [12, 13] intermolecular Josephson tunnelling [30] ii) a clue ring two electrons to the molecule X: i) electron corre- from a recent theoretical calculations by Naghavi and lation effects in the p-π bonded system, that has been Tosatti [31, 32] and by Chiappe et al. [33], which indi- invoked to give stable molecular charge -2e singlets and cate transfer of two rather than all three electrons to X positive pair binding energy, ii) Madelung energy gain, in K3X for X = picene and phenanthrene,iii) Mott in- iii) electron, lattice, molecular orientational polarization sulating character for the stoichiometry K2, [21, 23], iv) energies, iv) cohesive energy in the Cooper pair Mott a recognition [23] that a Mott insulating reference solid insulating dianion system arising from Josephson tun- K2X could be important for creating superconductivity. nelling. In our estimate these corrections do not add up Our paper is organized as follows. We first discuss, us- to overcome charging energy of 3 eV per formula unit. 2+ ing elementary considerations, why two electron rather Interestingly dication (K3) can help overcome the than three electron transfer is favoured in K3X. Then we large charging energy by contributing to overall cohesion 2− discuss how a charged dianion X effectively becomes a of the solid from: i) energy gain by hybridization of the Cooper pair box. This is followed by discussion of a weak lone electron with K orbitals within the complex K3 and 2− Josephson coupling between X molecules and forma- with empty LUMO orbitals of neighbouring dianions and tion of a Boson Mott insulator, a potential superconduc- ii) metallic cohesion in the correlated metallic state of the tor. A discussion of formation of K atom based Wannier renormalized metal atom band. function and emergence of a Fermion Mott insulator is In our estimate, with help from various cohesion mech- discussed next. A Hubbard model for the renormalized anism one barely manages to have two electron trans- metal atom Mott insulator is presented. Issues of charge fer to the anion. Results from our simple consideration transfer from Boson Mott insulator to Fermion Mott in- is consistent with theoretical calculations of references sulator (mutual doping), self doping or external doping xx. When we consider three electron transfer an en- and estimation of Tc are discussed next. hanced charging energy overwhelms any of the contribu- Before the concluding section we discuss applicability tions above and we do not form a stable solid containing of our ideas to alkali metal doped superconducting ful- transfer of all three valence electrons from K3 to X. lerides, including Mott insulating Cs3C60 that has A15 Similar considerations suggests that K3C60 family we 2− structure. have stable dianions (C60) . Simple fcc and A15 struc- tures in this family makes this estimate more meaningful. Dianion X2− as a Cooper Pair Box. Polycyclic II. BOSON MOTT INSULATOR aromatic hydrocarbon molecules support valence bond resonances. It is a correlated many electron state, a kind 2− Stability of Dianion X in K3X. To substantiate of molecular Mott insulator made of π electrons and well our claim of stability of dianion X2−, rather than trian- described as an RVB state a la’ Pauling. This inbuilt ion X3− we present some basic considerations of charge correlation manifests in several ways: for example, as a transfer in molecular solid K3X. Situation is more com- large ∼ 2 eV splitting between the first excited triplet and plex than in ionic insulator NaCl, where electron affinity singlet states in benzene. One has to go beyond Huckel of Cl, ionization energy of Na and a Madelung sum solely theory to capture this type of interesting effects arising determine energetics. Electron and lattice polarizability from RVB physics in aromatic hydrocarbon molecules. affects are small in NaCl.