6:13-cv-02471-BHH Date Filed 08/09/18 Entry Number 135 Page 1 of 46 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT OF SOUTH CAROLINA GREENVILLE DIVISION American Humanist Association, | John Doe and Jane Doe, | C.A. No. 6:13-cv-02471-BHH as parents and next friends of their minor | child, Jill Doe, | | PLAINTIFFS’ SUPPLEMENTAL Plaintiffs, | MEMORANDUM ON THE | PRAYER CLAIM v. | | Greenville County School District, | | Defendant. | 6:13-cv-02471-BHH Date Filed 08/09/18 Entry Number 135 Page 2 of 46 INDEX OF EXHIBITS RELEVANT TO PRAYER CLAIM1 Complaint Exhibits (September 11, 2013) Exhibit 2: Mountain View Elementary School Graduation program (Doc. 1 at 16) Exhibit 3: June 10, 2013 AHA Letter to Greenville School District (Doc. 1 at 17-19) Exhibit 4: June 11, 2013 Greenville School District Reply to Monica Miller (Doc. 1 at 20-21) Exhibit 5: AHA Email to General Counsel Douglas Webb dated 6/17/2013 (Doc. 1 at 22) Exhibit 6: GCSD General Counsel Letter to Monica Miller dated June 25, 2013 (Doc. 1 at 23-25) Response to Preliminary Injunction Exhibits (November 15, 2013) Affidavit of Jennifer Gibson (“Gibson Aff.”) (Doc.17-1) Reply re Motion for Preliminary Injunction Exhibits (November 22, 2013) Doe Declarations (Doc. 21-1) • Declaration of John and Jane Doe (Doc. 21-1 at 1-3) • Declaration of Jill Doe (Doc. 21-1 at 4-5) Victor Reynolds Declaration (Doc. 21-2) Post-Remand (Preliminary Injunction) Supplemental Exhibits (June 21, 2014) Exhibit A: MVES Graduation Programs, 2007, 2009, 2011, 2013 from Defendant’s Responses to Does’ Requests for Document Production (Doc. 56-1) Exhibit B-1: Woodmont High School, 2007 Newsletter Printout / Screenshot prayer (Doc. 56-2) Exhibit B-2: Washington Center Screen Shots 2008- 2013 graduation prayers (Doc. 56-3) Exhibit B-4: Hillcrest High School 2013 Graduation Photos, The Patch Screenshots (Doc. 56-5) Exhibit B-5: Wade Hampton High School 2013 Graduation Photos, The Patch Screenshots (Doc. 56-6) Exhibit B-6: Woodmont High School 2005 Newsletter, graduation prayer, download (Doc. 56-7) Exhibit B-7: J.L. Mann Newsletter / Graduation Instructions May 2009, download (Doc. 56-8) Exhibit B-8: Eastside High School 2008 Graduation Reminders, download (Doc. 56-9) 1 The exhibits related to the Chapel Policy, which has now been resolved, are omitted from this list. ii 6:13-cv-02471-BHH Date Filed 08/09/18 Entry Number 135 Page 3 of 46 Exhibit D-1: Hillcrest 2012 Senior Information for Hillcrest High School Graduation, GCSD website (Doc. 59-8) Exhibit D-2: Southside High Class of 2014 Graduation Handout, GCSD website (Doc. 59-9) Exhibit D-3: 2014 Graduation Schedule at Bon Secours (“BiLo Center”), GCSD website (Doc. 59-10) Defendant’s Answers to AHA’s Interrogatories (“D. Ans. AHA Int.”) (Doc. 61-11) Jill Doe Declaration (“Jill Decl.”) (Doc. 61-12) John Doe Declaration (“John Decl.”) (Doc. 61-13) Jane Doe Declaration (“Jane Decl.”) (Doc. 61-14) Plaintiffs’ Motion for Summary Judgment Exhibits (February 4, 2015) Defendant’s Answers to Plaintiffs’ First Requests for Admissions (“D. Ans. RFA”) (Doc. 84-7) Defendant’s Answers to Plaintiffs’ Revised RFAs (“D. Ans. Rev. RFA”) (Doc. 84-8) Defendant’s Answers to Doe Interrogatories (“D. Ans. Doe Int.”) (Doc. 84-9) Defendant’s Responses to Does’ Requests for Document Production (“DEFS” followed by Bates number) (redacted names of minors) (Doc. 84-10): • East North Street 2014 5th Grade Celebration Program (Doc. 84-10 at 1-4) • Gateway Elementary 2001 5th Grade Awards Day Program (Doc. 84-10 at 5) • Gateway Elementary 2012 Awards Program (Doc. 84-10 at 6) • Gateway Elementary School 2013 Awards Program (Doc. 84-10 at 7) • Gateway Elementary School 2013 Awards Day Teachers Only Program (Doc. 84-10 at 8) • Gateway Elementary School 2014 Awards Program (Doc. 84-10 at 9-10) • Washington Center 2013 Awards Day Program (Doc. 84-10 at 11-12) • Blue Ridge Middle School 2011 8th Grade Awards Program (Doc. 84-10 at 13-14) • Blue Ridge Middle School 8th Grade Awards Teacher Cheat Sheet May 29, 2014 (Doc. 84-10 at 15-18) • Blue Ridge Middle School 8th Grade Awards Day 2014 Program (Doc. 84-10 at 19-20) • Berea High School 2013 Graduation Program (Doc. 84-10 at 21-24) • Blue Ridge High School Senior Scoop April 26, 2012 Edition (Doc. 84-10 at 25-28) iii 6:13-cv-02471-BHH Date Filed 08/09/18 Entry Number 135 Page 4 of 46 • Blue Ridge High School 2012 Graduation Program (Doc. 84-10 at 29) • Blue Ridge High School Senior Scoop April 25, 2013 Edition (Doc. 84-10 at 30-33) • Blue Ridge High School 2013 Graduation Program (Doc. 84-10 at 34) • Blue Ridge High School 2013 Opening Prayer (Doc. 84-10 at 35) • Blue Ridge High School 2013 Closing Prayer (Doc. 84-10 at 36) • Blue Ridge High School 2013 Graduation Program (Doc. 84-10 at 37) • Blue Ridge High School Senior Scoop April 23, 2014 Edition (Doc. 84-10 at 38-41) • Blue Ridge High School 2014 Graduation Program (Doc. 84-10 at 42) • Blue Ridge High School 2014 Graduation Opening (Doc. 84-10 at 43) • Blue Ridge High School 2014 Graduation Closing Prayer (Doc. 84-10 at 44) • Blue Ridge High School 2014 Graduation Practices (Doc. 84-10 at 45-46) • Blue Ridge High School 2014 Graduation Rehearsal Practice (Doc. 84-10 at 47) • Carolina High School & Academy 2013 Graduation Program (Doc. 84-10 at 48-49) • Eastside High School 2013 Graduation Program (Doc. 84-10 at 50-53) • Greenville Senior High School 2013 Graduation Program (Doc. 84-10 at 54-68) • Greer High School 2013 Graduation Program (Doc. 84-10 at 69-70) • Hillcrest High School 2013 Graduation Program (Doc. 84-10 at 71-75) • Hillcrest High School 2014 Graduation Program (Doc. 84-10 at 76-80) • J.L. Mann High School 2013 Graduation Program (Doc. 84-10 at 81-84) • Mauldin High School 2013 Graduation Program (Doc. 84-10 at 85-89) • Riverside High School 2013 Graduation Program (Doc. 84-10 at 90-91) • Southside High School 2013 Graduation Program (Doc. 84-10 at 92-93) • Travelers Rest High School 2013 Graduation Program (Doc. 84-10 at 94-97) • Wade Hampton High School 2013 Graduation Program (Doc. 84-10 at 98) • Wade Hampton High School 2014 Graduation Prayer (Doc. 84-10 at 99) • Wade Hampton High School 2014 Graduation Program (Doc. 84-10 at 100-103) Post-Remand Summary Judgment Supplemental Exhibits Filed on October 21, 2016 iv 6:13-cv-02471-BHH Date Filed 08/09/18 Entry Number 135 Page 5 of 46 Roy Speckhardt Declaration (“Speckhardt Decl.”) (Doc. 115-1) • Exhibit A: AHA Membership Summary – GCSD (Doc. 115-1 at 5-9) Jeffrey Lamb Declaration (“Lamb Decl.”) (Doc. 115-2) • Exhibit A: 2015 Wade Hampton High School graduation program (Doc.115-2 at 5-7) • Exhibit B: 2016 Wade Hampton High School graduation program (Doc. 115-2 at 8-10) Michael Bruccoliere Declaration (“Bruccoliere Decl.”) (Doc. 115-3) • Exhibit A: 2013 Greenville High School graduation program (Doc. 115-3 at 3-9) Andrew Irwin Declaration (“Irwin Decl.”) (Doc.115-4) • Exhibit A: 2013 Greenville High School graduation program (Doc.115-4 at 4-8) • Exhibit B: 2016 Greenville High School graduation program (Doc.115-4 at 9-12) Doneta Pernak Declaration (“Pernak Decl.”) (Doc. 115-5) • Exhibit A: 2013 Greer High School graduation program (Doc. 115-5 at 5-7) • Exhibit B: 2016 Greer High School graduation program (Doc. 115-5 at 8-10) • Exhibit C: “Christmas 2012” Concert (Doc.115-5 at 11-13) Elisa Willis Declaration (“Willis Decl.”) (Doc.115-6) • Exhibit A: 2013 – 2015 Mauldin High School graduation programs (Doc.115-6 at 6-12) Arthur Street Declaration (“Street Decl.”) (Doc.115-7) • Exhibit A: Released-Time Christian Education handout (Doc.115-7 at 6-8) James Childress Declaration (“Childress Decl.”) (Doc. 115-8) Teresa Bowen Declaration (“Bowen Decl.”) (Doc. 115-9) Exhibit G: 2014 & 2015 Bell’s Crossing Elementary Fifth Grade Awards Day programs (Doc. 115-10) Exhibit H-1: 2013 Brashier Middle College Charter High School (Doc. 115-11 at 1-5) Exhibit H-2: 2014 Brashier Middle College Charter High School graduation materials (Doc. 115- 11 at 6-10) Exhibit H-3: 2015 Brashier Middle College Charter High School graduation materials (Doc. 115- 11 at 11-17) v 6:13-cv-02471-BHH Date Filed 08/09/18 Entry Number 135 Page 6 of 46 Exhibit I-1: 2014 Berea High graduation program (Doc. 115-12 at 1-3) Exhibit I-2: 2015 Berea High graduation program (Doc. 115-12 at 4-6) Exhibit I-3: 2016 Berea High graduation program (Doc. 115-12 at 7-10) Exhibit J-1: 2015 Blue Ridge High School graduation program (Doc. 115-13 at 1-3) Exhibit J-2: 2016 Blue Ridge High School graduation program (Doc. 115-13 at 4-6) Exhibit K-1: 2014 Carolina High graduation program (Doc. 115-14 at 1-3) Exhibit K-2: 2015 Carolina High graduation program (Doc. 115-14 at 4-6) Exhibit K-3: 2016 Carolina High graduation program (Doc. 115-14 at 7-10) Exhibit L-1: 2014 J.L. Mann High graduation program (Doc. 115-15 at 1-3) Exhibit L-2: 2015 J.L. Mann High graduation program (Doc. 115-15 at 4-6) Exhibit L-3: 2016 J.L. Mann High graduation program (Doc. 115-15 at 7-9) Exhibit M-1: 2014 Travelers Rest High School graduation program (Doc. 115-16 at 1-3) Exhibit M-2: 2015 Travelers Rest High School graduation program (Doc.