A5 Western Transport Corridor Public Inquiry Report New Buildings to Aughnacloy February 2012 — Volume 1 — 2 Table of Contents Volume 1 Page Index of Objectors 4 (Alphabetical) Chapter 1 Introduction 19 Chapter 2 Description Of Scheme 21 Strategic Inquiry Report 23 Chapter 3 The Case For The Department Strategic 25 Chapter 4 Cross Examination Of Departmental 35 Witnesses Strategic Chapter 5 Presentation Of Objections At Strategic Inquiry 37 Chapter 6 Common Issues 201 Volume 2 Chapter 7 Section 1 Inquiry Report 5 Chapter 8 Section 2 Inquiry Report 111 Chapter 9 Section 3 Inquiry Report 175 Chapter 10 Endorsements – Strategic 287 Chapter 11 Conclusions, Recommendations & Acknowledgements 293 Volume 3 Appendix 1 Standard Letters & Objector Listings 5 Appendix 2 Inquiry Appearances Listing 23 Appendix 3 List Of Departmental Documentation 37 Appendix 4 Objector Listing (Numerical) 39 Appendix 5 Inspectors’ Correspondence 57 Appendix 6 Endorsement Listing (Alphabetical) 63 Appendix 7 Statutory Consultee Listing 65 Appendix 8 List Of Abbreviations 67 3 Index of Objectors Surname / Forename / Strategic Local Vol / Page Business Representative Reference Reference A & B Contracts OA-1115 02-071 1/148, 2/165 Acheson Ruth OA-1294 1/192 Adams David & OA-1081 02-004 2/116 Christopher Adams Denise OA-1049 01-079 1/114, 2/44 Adams John Mark OA-1050 01-080 1/115, 188. 2/45 Allen David 03-130 2/229 Allen Elizabeth, James, OA-1164 03-081 1/169, 188. 2/229 David & Mavis Allen John OA-970 1/77 Allen Thomas & Helen OA-1153 03-069 1/166, 188. 2/219 Alternative A5 Represented by OA-982 1/89 Alliance Hoy & Dorman Consulting Engineers An Taisce - Represented by Ian OA-038 1/49 National Trust for Lumley, James Nix Ireland & Attracta Ui Bhroin Anderson Paula OA-1025 1/100 Armstrong Alan OA-1114 02-068 1/148, 2/163 Armstrong David & Lavinia OA-1186 03-139 1/176, 182. 2/185 Armstrong Muriel 03-017 2/185 Armstrong William Thomas OA-1138 03-027 1/159, 182. 2/191 Armstrong William, Margaret & 03-656 2/273 Billie Jo Ash Avenue Represented by 01-003 2/12 Residents Sean Molloy Aughnacloy Represented by Liz OA-1172 03-096 1/171 Development Salter Association Aughnacloy Represented by OA-1142 03-037 1/161, 2/200 Presbyterian Robert Brush Church Baghi Linda & Masoud 01-095 2/67 4 Surname / Forename / Strategic Local Vol / Page Business Representative Reference Reference Baird Mervyn & Olive 01-093 2/63 Ballygawley Represented by OA-1193 03-654 1/179 Development Jim Tallon Association Ballygawley Brian Keown OA-1123 03-006 1/151 Veterinary Practice Ballygawley Represented by OA-1144 03-040 1/162 Traders Isobel Coote & Dillon Morris Barrett Paul & Elaine OA-1160 03-077 1/168, 188. 2/226 Baskin Robert OA-1091 02-026 1/141, 2/130 Beattie James 03-667 2/278 Beggs Leslie OA-1198 03-095 1/182, 2/236 Beggs William Norman OA-1191 03-372 1/178, 188. 2/271 Beggs William Thomas OA-1095 02-031 1/141, 188. 2/136 Bell Mervyn Alexander OA-1162 03-079 1/168, 188. 2/228 Bell Stanley OA-1030 02-084 1/103 2/170 Best Doreen OA-1130 03-015 1/157. 2/184 Bingham Edward 03-117 2/248 Bingham Gladys Emily OA-1192 03-481 1/179 2/272 Bingham Robert Noel 03-128 2/258 Blee Cathal OA-1043 01-063 1/112, 186. 2/27 Blee Pat OA-1238 1/186 Blee Kathleen 01-062 2/27 Boggs Robert 02-015 2/124 Bonner Martin 02-014 2/123 Boyd Norman OA-1242 03-082 1/188 2/230 Boyd Steven OA-1052 01-082 1/115, 188. 2/48 Boyd Trevor OA-1012 1/98 Boyd William OA-1051 01-081 1/115, 188. 2/46 Boyd William Cecil OA-1161 03-078 1/168, 188. 2/227 Boyle Michaela (MLA) 01-094 2/64 Bradley Sean OA-1105 02-053 1/144, 184. 2/151 Bratton Tom & Pamela 02-022 2/128 Briggs John OA-1068 01-118 1/125 2/89 5 Surname / Forename / Strategic Local Vol / Page Business Representative Reference Reference Bruce Robin & Jean OA-1064 01-107 1/122 2/76 Brush Samuel (Councillor) OA-1126 03-009 1/153 Brush David OA-1181 03-132 1/174 2/261 Brush Noel OA-1290 03-118 1/180 2/249 Brush Robert OA-003 03-657 1/40 2/273 Brush Victor OA-1182 03-133 1/174 2/261 Bryson Timothy 01-060 2/26 Buchanan Alan OA-1247 02-066 1/190 2/162 Buchanan Alistair OA-1211 1/182 Buchanan Margaret OA-1157 03-074 1/167, 188 2/224 Buchanan John & Sharon OA-1118 03-001 1/149 2/177 Burns Edward & John OA-1063 01-106 1/122 2/74 Busby Raymond & 03-122 2/253 Dorothy Byrne Joe (MLA) 01-094 2/64 Cairns Noel 02-045 2/146 Caldwell Mary 01-109 2/79 Campbell Bryan OA-1218 02-033 1/185 2/138 Campbell Sara OA-1190 03-371 1/178 2/270 Carlin Sean 01-100 2/68 Castlederg Anglers Gary Irvine 02-075 2/168 Club Cauneze Eric OA-1026 1/100 Christie Jane OA-004 1/40 Christie Kathleen OA-338 1/56 2/8 Christie Leslie OA-1000 01-077 1/97, 184. 2/41 Christie Victor OA-981 01-127 1/88 2/96 Clarke Violet Iris 03-121 2/252 Clarke Derek & Andrenna OA-1046 01-075 1/113 2/39 Cleery Liam & Jacqueline 01-097 2/67 Clotworthy Ian OA-009 1/44 Colhoun Derek OA-1103 02-051 1/144, 182. 2/149 Conwell John & Bridget 01-004 2/14 Cooper Alfred 02-072 2/166 6 Surname / Forename / Strategic Local Vol / Page Business Representative Reference Reference Cooper Colin & Suzanne 03-370 2/270 Coote Darren OA-1176 03-107 1/172, 2/242 Coote Eric Samuel OA-1141 03-036 1/161, 2/199 Coote Joy OA-027 1/48 Coote Phillip OA-1174 03-105 1/172, 2/241 Coote Wildridge John OA-1175 03-106 1/172 2/241 Corr Vivien OA-033 1/48 Crosbie James & David OA-1104 02-052 1/144, 2/150 Crosbie Raymond OA-1107 02-055 1/145, 184. 2/153, 202 Crumley Billy & Norman OA-1059 01-090 1/119, 184. 2/59 Crumlish Jude OA-1056 01-087 1/118, 184. 2/55 Cullen Jordan OA-1119 03-002 1/149 Cummings Heather & Robin OA-1206 01-005 1/182, 2/14 Curran Raymond OA-1231 02-034 1/185, 2/138 Daly Leo 03-297 2/270 Darragh Solomon OA-1204 02-049 1/182, 2/148 Davidson Alastair 03-090 2/234 Devine Gerard OA-1108 02-057 1/145, 184. 2/155 Dickson Martha Emily 03-149 2/267 Doherty Alec OA-1045 01-074 1/113, 2/38 Doherty Pat (MLA) 01-003 2/64 Donnell John (Councillor) OA-503 1/60 Donnell Derrick, Sylvia & OA-963 01-086 1/71, 184. 2/53 Hall Donnelly Bill OA-036 1/48 Dooher Patrick OA-1299 01-068 1/192, 2/31 Duddy Family OA-900 1/64 Duff Winston OA-1029 03-658 1/103, 2/274 Dunbar David, William & OA-1097 02-041 1/142, 184. 2/143 Arthur Dunbar John OA-1080 02-003 1/133, 189. 2/115 Dunbar Mary OA-008 1/44 Eisenhart Thomas OA-983 1/93 Elkin David 02-020 2/127 7 Surname / Forename / Strategic Local Vol / Page Business Representative Reference Reference Elliott James & Caroline OA-1071 01-122 1/128, 2/93 Ellis Family 02-047 2/147 Eskra Community Represented by 03-150 2/268 Association Ltd Gerry McCaffrey Evans Glen 03-085 2/232 Farnan Darren RA-043 2/291 Ferguson David 03-664 2/277 Ferguson John 03-665 2/277 Fitzsimmons Ernie & Linda 03-123 2/253 Forbes William 01-008 2/18 Foster James OA-1076 01-137 1/131, 2/100 Friends of the Earth James Orr OA-967 1/75 Fulton Ian OA-502 1/59 Fulton Robert 02-013 2/122 Fulton William & Robin OA-1058 01-089 1/119, 184. 2/57 Fyffe Margaret OA-1212 02-039 1/182, 2/142 Galbraith Mary OA-1041 01-059 1/111, 2/25 Gallagher Joseph OA-1167 03-087 1/170, 2/233 Gallagher Mr & Mrs Joseph OA-1090 02-025 1/141, 188. 2/130 Gallen Eugene 01-099 2/68 Gamble Richard & Sydney OA-1295 01-009 1/192, 2/19 Gamble (22 Robert Samuel OA-1048 01-078 1/114, 188. 2/42 Dunnalong Road) Gamble (37 Robert Samuel OA-006 1/42 Dunnalong Road) Gibson Brian & Jacinta 03-119 2/250 Gibson Oliver 03-088 2/233 Giles Frederick & OA-1154 03-071 1/166, 188. 2/220 Barbara Giles Nigel OA-1195 03-152 1/182, 2/269 Giles Ronald W Charles 03-148 2/267 Giles William Robert 03-113 2/245 Gilheany Declan 02-037 2/141 Gilmore Robert Stanley OA-1137 02-040 1/159, 2/142 Gilmour Ian and Sarah OA-1102 02-050 1/143, 182. 2/149 8 Surname / Forename / Strategic Local Vol / Page Business Representative Reference Reference Givan Robert & Margaret 03-023 2/189 Green Action Represented by OA-973 1/82 John Wright Greer Diane OA-020 1/46 Grimsley William OA-951 1/70 Guthrie Stephen & Sarah OA-1053 01-083 1/116, 2/51 Hackett Eamon OA-1158 03-075 1/168, 188.